I just want to mention one thing. when I recommend that she doesn’t use a tinted moisturiser because she has oily skin, I’m talking about how long wearing the Product will be on her skin type. I’m not talking about skincare. This isnt a skincare reaction video. Also the Tinted moisturiser she uses, is oil free, I say that I wish she had mentioned what kind of tinted moisturiser she is using for her skin type. Tinted moisturiser (despite the name) isn’t skincare and should not be used in place of skincare. However, it will add moisture to the skin makeing it too excessive for acne prone and oily skin. I’m very oily myself, and use oils and heavy moisturisers on my own skin. People with oily skin and acne prone skin should still moisturise.

I get a massive 'not like other girls' vibe from her.

“I love it when people say they have a breakout and it’s like one spot...” I DIED.

I love how Robert literally never laughs at anyone trying to be funny. His face just says, “get on with it!” 😆

“So I don’t really know who she is...” ok so we’re already dragging her by the scalp before the review even starts 😂

If you think blowing on her brush is bad you should see her skincare routine 😂

“It’s powder so it won’t crease” “..no.” Lol loved that part

People keep saying "I didn't know James had a brother!" I didn't know Robert had a brother. I've never seen James' videos before.

She seems like the type of person who would wear converse to prom and say, "Its just who I am!"

When people say they are breaking out and have one pimple.. 🥵 my acne could never

So one’s a skincare guru and and the other is a makeup guru. Their mom is a lucky women.

She try’s so hard to be “laid back”

As soon as she blew on the brush, I knew you were gonna pause it lmao

I want Robert to look at my face and tell me how to do my makeup based on my face shape

She tries too hard to be a stoner chick. She just irritates me.

It's kind of annoying how she speaks on the tutorial. She looks and sounds like she's dope, And acts like she pretends to didn't care about herself when she does. Like lack of selfcare was something "cool" . It's cringey

Oh my Jesus Christ this video was to respectful like he was so nice about all his advice. He just seems like the most likeable person.

“Seems like she has a good understanding of her skin and what products to use” Guys I don’t think he’s seen the skincare routine video yet 😣

I love it when my bacteria gives birth 💙 Shout out to bacteria, love you betch

That chick tries too hard to act like a “bruh”

Bella: it will keep my eyeshadow from creasing because it is a powder Robert: no❤

my stupid ass clicked on thinking I was watching James Welsh..but noticed his demeanor is a bit different, then realised it's the other brother😊😊

She’s like one of those early 2000s tumblr girl who thinks self deprecating is a personality type...

stop dragging Bella in the comments im tired of liking them all

She’s “I’m not like other girls” personified

Imagine having english as your second language and trying to understand her mumbling

For some reason I think she tries to lower her voice

I’m literally at 4 minutes 35, and the ‘No’ I just heard from Robert just gave me life. ‘But it will keep my eyes from creasing because it’s a powder’. NO. Honestly, one word, but the sass attached??? I need it as my ring tone! 😂

i know im here really late but i have learned more tips on how to do my makeup in this video than i have watching "beauty gurus"

KZfaq wtf....all the garbage Ive been recommended you neglected to mention that James brother has a channel before today?

Why do people feel the need to drag others down? I think this whole video is great, you didn't tear her down like most would.

The fact that this is a routine meant for acne prone skin when she has one (1) pimple and she "hasn’t had one in a minute" is personally insulting

"I'm gonna get my phone and I'm gonna stick this cotton pad to it, using this cotton pad" hahahahahahaa

Its very cringy to watch her talk

Robert is the one person who actually paid attention in class & took all of the information given- forward with him. ♥️

“Just look at it, no judging” Cue face in thumbnail: 👁 👄👁 😂😂

You look like...a very beautiful jafaar? You’re eyebrows are so gorgeous!

The cotton pads on his phone killed me 😂

She is doing her makeup very minimal, that’s what I loved about it, people just don’t understand that less makeup is better for everyday life and extreme makeup is mostly for camera, going out and stuff....

Thank you for bringing the theory of makeup application back into focus. As a makeup artist, I’m bloody sick of the “KZfaq drama” and pointless backstabbing. You’re a breath of much needed air! Xo

It seems to me like she’s trying too hard to appear as though she’s not trying too hard... like she’s trying too hard to be relatable and cool. Also, I can’t stand it when people act like experts in fields where they are clearly only entry level. She knows nothing about skincare or makeup and acts like a pro in both areas.

Wait so james welsh and robert welsh are 2 different people. And robert is not a fictional character that james made up for fun so he could create different contents ??? Some body please help me Edit: oh yeah they are twins my bad

Your reaction video was unusually frank yet respectful. Please never stop making videos that don’t intend to just cater to what people generally want to see (exaggerated dislike or like)! Really really enjoyable and informative

"Its like sticking paper to paper, using paper" LMAO! I loved this video

My guy you look like CGI how's your skin that smooth

I'm not sure Bella Thorne has ever done anything that allows her to speak this authoritatively about makeup. Certainly not her horrifying skin routine...

I almost died when she said she was using powder as a base on her eyelids to stop her eyeshadow from creasing because I KNEW you were going to have something to say about that. And I love the analogy you used to explain it. "It's like sticking paper to paper using paper" 😆🤣

"She's not the brightest" kinda vibes

I just feel so...like, comforted? By this classy and informative yet devastating dissection. ☕️ 😌

“She’s really really pretty but she’s a celebrity she kinda has to be” 😂😂😂

"I don't really know what she does" neither do I lol

I wish she wouldn’t try so hard.

"No judging.." Bruh that's literally the reason I click on these types of videos.

The eye roll had me laughing here at 2 am 😂🙌🏻

I’ve been watching makeup vids for some 8 years now, on and off? And Robert is the first person to explain effectively what eyeshadow primer does. Thank you!

These videos are really helpful, and I love them, thank you! I do like watching other people do makeup, but it's super helpful to know how to adapt their tutorials to myself, or to ensure my methods will actually pay off, and in real life. You're the best!

I sat here for like 10 minutes thinking James looks different

Hi my names B-thorn and I'm like, so not like other girls

Glad you showed up in my recommended. You explain things in a way that's easy to understand, you have a calm way about you, and a nice voice. Also, your skin is heaven. Thanks for the videos!

Idk how I found you but I've literally binged your videos straight for 24 hours and I love you! So refreshing to see a pro MUA give us tips and the real on makeup

Have you seen the new video she did for harper’s bazaar? It’s a horror show.

Wat? We got a king in skincare and in makeup?? Love the Welsh brothers!

I discovered you last night & i’ve been binge watching your videos all day. you’re incredible and i’m so happy you have a channel. thank you for teaching makeup theory and being analytical about makeup without being judgmental or catty i’m here for it

what I love most about your videos is how professional and respectful you are. Its all constractive. Great advice as always 👌

"she was on a show on nickelodeon" 🤔😂😂

Ok but can we talk about his skin?? Wtf?? Is that makeup or just natural glow?? I’m so jealous

The fact this girl own a makeup brand...

I felt your pain when she blew on her brush, and so many people does that!

Um does she not have the Sephora app or a store near her??? Super Orgasm is ALWAYS in stock

I have legit been wondering why people thought that eyeshadow was a "base" for eyeshadow for years. Concealer, eye primer, foundation, even CREAM shadow, sure! That tracks. But powder eyeshadow AS THE BASE ITSELF, I have been wondering how that works for AGES. Spoiler alert: it doesn't work for me.

I REALLY love the way you make these response videos without roasting the subject! Just giving the educational comments. Great! Love U man!!

I've been a makeup artist for years and every video I watch from you I still learn something new!

I think this was great. I love that you were honest and funny (the eye roll, I think we did it at the same time lol). Some other videos I’ve seen (ok just one) they’re so polite, like they don’t want to offend. It’s not about offending it’s about an honest critique. That’s what we want! Keep up the good work. I always enjoy your videos!

I rewound to that eye roll so many times 😂

I was supposed to be doing my own makeup and just wanted something I could glance at past my makeup mirror... here I am 4 of your videos later with only brows done🤣 I'm developing an addiction.

I watch you and your brother all the time and I really love the energy and vibes you guys give. Keep it up and remember, that beauty is in everyone

Bacteria giving birth! Lol!

oh my god I feel like I'm on some kind of parallel universe 😭

Am I the only one who loves it, when Robert demonstrates how not to do things with random utensils 😂 he really wants to show us what not to do. 😂 I love him for that

Wowie her makeup routine is the exact opposite of her skincare routine Decently well researched She knows whats gonna work best for her skin She isnt absolutely destroying her skin in the process Just. So much less agonizing than her skincare routine

I love that James does skincare and Robert does makeup so we have awesome info about both subjects.

Her lip injections weren’t done right 😓

4:36 Living for the not so subtle shade :D That "no" left me screaming ^^

This was actually super informational, there are little things I do that I never realized I did!

Was that an eye roll at 3:56 😂

I love this guy... His laugh is so shady I LOVE IT

I just discovered this channel and omg I need more of these reaction videos!! I could watch them all night! Great channel Robert!!

What I LOVE about this video is you're a professional who is informing her viewers of the truth of her application. You're not "dragging" her... I've learned A LOT from you in this video. It really makes me wonder... why would they choose her for vogue? Odd.

You’re actually so on point with your comments. Found your channel recently and you are actually one of the realest youtubers when it comes to skin care. Great advice and good quality products. Thank you 😊🤗

Since she didnt add more eyeshadow, I think she just meant she was putting that one color to keep her eyelids from getting oily/creasing, not to keep other eyeshadow from creasing. That's how I took it anyway 🙃 Great video!!

Oh how I have missed technical tutorials and critiques of makeup on KZfaq. It has been so many years. I’m so happy I found your channel

I love how Roberts talks it’s super cute and contagious.... The way he laughs when he talks and he try to be so polite and be a gentleman with every video so adorable I wish I could meet Robert #1 fan.. 💎💎💎Robert💎💎💎 Such a diamond

he was dead inside by the time he turned on this camera cause he knows he finna get disappointed

I thought you were James but stayed because you're Robert, here we love Robert a lot❤

I needed this. I mean, all of your reaction videos. THANK YOU for brining expertise back.

I died when you hit your elbow

Plot twist they’re the same person fooling us all

You have such a beautiful smile. Those teeth are dazzling. Take a look at her going to bed routine. She puts lemon juice on her skin because it is natural. She is clueless on how to take care of her skin. Right now she is young, but unless she changes her skin care routine soon she will be a wrinkled mess by 40. She also uses no sunscreen!!!

Such helpful tips! I'm 41 with dry skin, I look about 35ish though! I exfoliate once a week, spf all year round, I use serums, and hydrate and moisturize and I love Korean sheet masks! I will be binge watching you all day, so HELLO! YOU ARE LOVELY!! 💕🌸

I didn't think that the video would be so educative but it was educative and informative. Nice work robert welsh.