Doesn't matter if the song was good or bad, when Judy sang, it was brilliant!!!

It’s not just her voice it’s her presentation! Such an incredible artist.

Saw the incredible Judy in concert in San Francisco, right after her Carnegie Hall triumph. From the moment she stepped on stage, she had the packed Civic Auditorium on their feet, cheering...and we never sat down. Hers was an incredible talent.

I wish she could have been as happy as she made others feel.

Kids, it just doesn't get any better than this. A star, a mega talent...a legend - Judy Garland.

Garland improvised this whole scene (my uncle worked on the set.) The song is not a great one but she makes it seem great. The footage captures her as she was in thousands of concerts, She is basically playing herself here. I saw her in live concerts. I can't describe the effect she had on her audiences. Not one gimmick. Just a great artist giving 200%. At her best, no one could touch her. She always moved the audience.

Her total body response at 3:50 should have put an Academy Award in her hands.

Four dislikes. Who are you people? Do you prefer voices generated by computers? This is talent at its finest. 100% real. Shame on you for disliking. You lot must like the Kardashians and Kayne West.

No one could grab and hold an audience like Judy.

Judy knocked the ending of this song right out of the ballpark! She poured her talent out through every syllable of this song to an incredibly climactic ending! We will never see anyone come close to her talent or dedication again.

Maybe the greatest singing/performer of all time. Just never bored with her. First singer to fill football stadiums and still leave people outside.

Even when her voice cracks on occasion she is still a mesmerizing presence and soooo much better than anyone else! Forget technical singing she rises above this with sheer PRESENCE and a magical stage management with no peer. She was definitely something ethereal and I am a non- believer.

No singer can touch Judy Garland: past or present!! What a voice!! She was a very good actress and good dancer as well. What do we have these days. Madonna, Beyoncé, Lady G a Ga ( every time I hear her sing I GA GA) etc.

I am so grateful to read these wonderful comments. To know that so many appreciate and love Judy Garland so much, especially so many young people. Just to know that this younger generation is not missing the magic of the Judy Experience . I do listen to Judy everyday but I also watch her movies pretty much every day and have seen every movie she has made and all of her appearances and TV shows. I read everything on KZfaq and have pictures of her on my walls. I even ask God in my daily prayers to give her my love and let her know or remind her how much so many love her and appreciate her and will never forget what a legend she is. Thank you again for continuing praise. It is important to the world and to the new generations.

There are no words to describe her...oh wait, just one...LEGEND

The BEST singer, actress, dancer of all time!! No one even come close to her. Her movments and acting choices are so organic so perfect. I LOVE the ending "With My Heart on the Wings of a Song". All her gestures are so real. She's always fresh no matter how many times you've seen her. Judy touches your soul. Not even Streisand can do that.( I'm not sure she has a soul! ) I love you Judy!!

This is another performance that added to her title as "one take Judy". So magical.

It seems incredible today that Judy wasn't nominated at least for a Golden Globe for this one!

Not really top drawer Arlen & Harburg but Judy transforms it to pure gold. Absolute magic

I literally have "no words" to describe this beautiful human being. I listen to her all day every day and its depressing when I have to listen to the garbage on the radio. I honor Judy in my little way by listening to her records on my old record player. I love and will always love Judy Garland!!!

At the end, at 5:53 she looks up at the audience, it's only for a second or two, but the expression on her face is heartbreaking.

Judy Garland was born to be a singer. Despite her tragic private life, her career as a singer always glittered. Lots of her fans, including me, still love her. She was just like an angel, who sacrificed herself to bring joy and happiness to her fans.

Never seen this before. BUT WHAT A TALENT. She could sell a song like nobody else.

This woman was one of the greats of her time,god blessed her with a magical voice that could make you smile.

Let me say that Garland's voice and talent have been a friend to me since I heard the first few cords of the beginning of "Judy at Carnegie Hall". Garland's voice and talent continue on through all of her film and recorded work. Thank you JUDY, I'll be listening for you. KOR-

when you watch a performance like that you don't say anything you just enjoy the moment, and that you have witnessed something that words cannot describe, amazing lady and an amazing talent.

Judy was so good she could take crap lyrics like these and make it sound like you want to listen to it a couple million times.

she is other-worldly.....never before or since has someone captivated me the way she does...... every. single. time.

At the time I viewed this video, there were 2 dislikes. Wonder if these 2 think people like Beyonce or perhaps Madonna etc., are great talents. SO sad if it is true. Todays youth, and even going back say 10 20 30 years, have not been exposed to true talent like Judy. Or for that matter, Pavarotti,Chalplin, Mozart, Gershwin, Kelly and Astaire, Arnstrong, you get the idea. It should be mandatory that all kids watch Graland.

The greatest female entertainer no one has ever come close to . Its sad music artists to day cannot get anywhere near this lady for over all talent .

Garland was a genius! Thanks for letting us share this.

This woman gave her all when performing. Judy Garland will long be remembered way after other PERFORMERS have long gone. Her voice so distinctive that you did not even have to here her name before she sang a song. Way above the top entertainers and yes I believe that she was robbed of the Oscar for a star is born . However Judy will always be remembered while whoever won is probably long forgotten.

Just love that song after all these years I still can’t get enough of Ulysses Garland What a phenomenal performer

People who have never seen Judy Garland in person can never understand the persona behind this singer.... so emotional, so talented, such and ability to convey to the audience like none other.... well there will never be another!

Thanks for posting a clip from this undeservedly often overlooked British film. The character she played resonated strongly with her own life experience and there are some well written scenes and songs.

This is a very good movie. Did you notice her kids Lorna and Joey Luft in the scene on the ferry boat?Proof Judy loved her kids and took them with her.

Judy's singing reminds me of a breaking heart begging you to love it back to together again.

Soulful Garland performance show the magic of Judy Garland and her amazing character, by this time in front of audiences for decades she had it all down to perfection, then there is that amazing voice...wish she would have gone on singing longer, nobody compares.

My God.....no words, only tears fall! There has never been another

Judy is simply the best at what she does

No other singer has ever come close to the power, charisma, emotional range, etc. - as Judy Garland. NO ONE!

Staggering talent. Brings me to tears of joy.

There was no one like her...not even close!!!

There's NO ONE BETTER! LOVE IT!

Two thumbs up! What an elegant performance! She looks gorgeous. Absolutely stunning.

Wonderful.Sometimes you're lost for words....

Only she could do that! Noone else....

This song expresses my passion for singing.....and I love singing it, too!!! Thank you for sharing!!! I love Judy in this movie!!!

her voice is so calming to me

God I love you and miss you Judy Garland, may you rest in peace

she was magic on stage! she had so much energy and talent. thanks for posting! (:

Dear LORD! I am brought to tears every time I listen to this woman sing! athey dont make em lime that anymore do they!

An American Genius.

Thanks for posting. Wish Judy was still with us.

Such an ENORMOUS talent, the saddest story in show business!

I always thought of this as a sad song here is a wonderful lady who was just taken advantage of. Listen to her first movies then her later ones and then this one, she looks and sounds like a completely different women however that last lyric is so true, no matter what she just kept on singing.

Love the quality! This is one of my favourite Judy songs, and accurately describes my love for singing!

This song was written by Harold Arlen and EY Harburg. The two also wrote Over The Rainbow, Judy Garland’s signature song.

Such a legend and will always be my favourite thank you for sharing this 💖

thank you again for the re-master!

Happy Birthday to Judy Garland & her legacy!

One of my Favorites!!

Perfection..thank youx

Oh if only I could talk to her today and tell her that she is just so good and that I will walk with her and not leave her.

Such a talent!

Great job! Unrecognized for her dramatic talent, Judy pulls out everything she has in her bag of tricks to put over a rather mediocre song. If this had been an "A" picture, she certainly would have gotten an Oscar nod, if not win. I've read that "Go On Singing" tanked at the BO and that's a shame. Someone with Judy's undeniable magic: how would YOU like it if someone woke you up at 6am and said "We've got to get this scene now, so....Sparkle! ....NOW!!" I can tell you what I would have said to them and it wouldn't have made it past that "production code".

Perfection ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Happy birthday Judy love u!!!

Beautiful

From 1:26 the Treatment Room scene runs unbroken for almost six minutes. Bogarde said Judy asked him to rewrite it at the last minute and they rehearsed it for six hours, but many reviewers thought it was improvised. All Neame did was to move the camera slowly into a tighter two-shot: Dirk selflessly keeps his face turned away and the lighting somehow transforms Jenny from a grumpy, sullen frump into a pretty little thing. Unfortunately the former persona would predominate in her last six years.

my favorite by her!!!

Such an amazing and iconic talent but yet I find myself so Melancholy when I watch her

Amazing

Oh she's wonderful

She was magic!!!!!!!!

Magic.

Judy could sing the telephone book and whom would be bored? Love you Judy ❤🎉🎉🎉

Queen❤👑

Such a tragedy, in this film you get the impression the whole way through it is not acting, it is simply Judy. And reading her biography and what went on behind the scenes, you understand that is true.

LA INMORTAL JUDY ! 🌹❤️🌹

Nothing like it ever again....

Exelent picture

EPIC

Her entrance exchange with the audience is pretty much how she was in real life on stage.

yo pienso.esta mujer...........era de lo mas de lo mas..............en todos los sentidos............y su hija.......tres cuarto de lo mismo...............las cantantes mas completas.....................en todos los sentidos.............pues el mundo en ese momento era para ellas...todo su ser.y dieron el cien por cien..........y el gran disfrute de la vida....desde ellas mismas..........con todas sus miserias......que eran superadas todas por su propio canto.......movimiento.expresiones.................y desenvoltura total....llena de amor intenso..y tal vez ...de reivindicacion....

I just love this. I can't stop thinking about, what if she just stopped with the pills, and never went back to MGM or Warner Bro's, or why didn't she just stay with Vincente Minnelli. R.I.P Judy Garland

Does anyone know which key Judy is singing this? I have the sheet music for this song, but it's in a different key, and I want to have it transposed.

The LP has been released on CD, and I took the track from that.

Oh. A couple of years ago a good friend asked me to convert a bunch of LP|vinyls & a huge box of cassette tapes -- his favorite "oldtimie religious music" collection -- to CD's. He had a good converter to digitize LP|vinyl & cassette tapes & gave it to me to use. The problem is, of course, home converters have no way to sense "end ot track" positions. All must be done manually by rote listening to the tracks & on|off with the digitizer -- boring after a while but nice listening to good music!!

Does anyone know which key Judy sang this in? The original key was Bb major, but it's probably a 2nd or 3rd lower.

The stereo track comes from the LP, which was released in full stereo. Nothing was enhanced, Dr. Isaacs.

Very interesting story behind the shoot... not a great song but great performance of it

And she did

where is mort ?

I must presume -- barring exhumation of her vocal chords -- that the "stereo" dual and variant sound tracks were FX added to make two separately discerned audio signals. But, with the "borrowed" and FX enhanced extra tracks, did anyone ever call ASCAP even for simple notice? Well, don't blame me, I would have had I known!! Judy as always sound perfect regardless!! From: Dr. Elyas Fraenkel Isaacs, PhD, DPH, DDiv.

This was her LAST MOVIE she MADE

The last two words... "singing day"... WTF does that mean?

I see. But your comment brings up a good question for the technologically minded. From your words, I presume, the DVD was poorly produced & so the lousy mono audio. You say the "stereo track comes ... LP" &, again, I presume you mean you extracted the digital image of the "analog" audio from the LP vinyl album. I know there are many LP|vinyl to computer[digitized signal] converters. Some need a lot of direct sound engineering overview per each song track. Which did you use -- interesting!!

I could see her as a comedian

ok