I think the coolest thing about BMTH is you could ask 10 different fans to make their own list and they would all be completely different.

Finn: “I’m a purest. The heaviest or the poppiest” Also Finn: “this will be their best album because it’s the perfect combination of heavy and poppy”

Finn: “I want an album to be fully committed to being either pop or metal, I don’t want it to be half and half” Also Finn: “The new unreleased album is my favorite because it is a blend of their entire catalog”

There Is A Hell / Heaven at the very bottom 😂!?! Easily their best work in my book and such an underrated album. By default still quite heavy and Metalcore based, but the now signature electronic production was properly introduced, and it also started showing their ability to switch up the sickest single string riffs, for the most ambient and tranquil clean electric guitar, leaning into more balladry territory.

That's the Spirit and Post Human are my favorites. Great band overall. Edit: the balls on this man--not putting Sempiternal at #1.

My favorite band yo! Always an event when they drop new material

I really enjoyed Sepiternal, it was so different to me when it came out. I think i agree that they just dont make bad music.

My personal ranking: 1. Sempiternal 2. That's The Spirit 3. Survival Horror 4. There Is A Hell... 5. Suicide Season 6. amo 7. Count Your Blessings. All really solid albums, I have to say amo grew on me a lot even though I still have it low on the list. Also I haven't listen to Music to Go To etc. And for their Debut EP I think its fine but I'd rather just listen to Count Your Blessings instead. Also I respect your opinion on There Is A Hell, it is a growing pain album, but I think it is easily there most underrated and I wish bring me would play some of these songs more often. Lee's guitar work on There Is A Hell as well as Sempiternal is God tier stuff, especially his clean parts.

Sempiternal is in my top 3 albums of all time, It was incredible when it was released 10 years ago and still holds strong today. But yeah there isnt much "bad" stuff in their entire discography

Post Human is my favourite record from them, and now it really feels like they are putting out their best music. Some sort of mix of influences between core and linkin park and whatever else electronic that goes, always really fun to listen to.

Man, honestly, your second channel became my main one to watch, thank you for all the work you're doing!

Your metalhead incel impressions are always so spot on. God tier talent.

Count your blessings will always have a very special place in my heart. I genuinely enjoy the album but it’s also tied securely to very fun memories of my teen years.

I understand Finn's point about wanting music to be one way or another. Either really heavy or really pop. What's funny is that I tend to like the in between stuff.

I've never been that much into their music after Sempiternal, but I have huge respect for them as artists. It's not easy to be making music for 20 years and still have a fresh new sound every couple years.

I really enjoyed That’s the Spirit. I went through a very hard time personally when it was released and it was a good form of escapism at the time, so I look back on it very fondly.

Couldn't agree more on the no 1 pick. Amen, Darkside, Lost, Code Mistake, Strangers, Die For You, and Bad Life (Assuming they all will make it into the album). Just those few songs are enough to justify how good the album is going to be.

There is a Hell is best album, will not argue

My list is in near reverse order. I really like There is a hell..., Suicide Season, and Sempiternal the most. Easily my top 3 BMTH albums. I think all their music is good for what it is. I just can't help but be a little dissapointed when they release different stuff. Like I'll listen to it, and I might even like it but I never really return to it. I hear their newer stuff regularly on spotify and I don't skip it when it comes on but it does make me want to put on some of the metalcore era stuff after hearing it.

Sempiternal coming out a decade ago does make me feel old. Came out when at the end of my junior year of high school and it absolutely swept all of us metalcore kids

Finn can you make more videos about nu metal please? we need atleast 6 more nu metal videos this month!

Also Ollie is prob the best looking dude of the whole scene era. He wins the beauty contest hands down. I remember a vaguely alt stripper talking about how hot he was constantly.

as someone who was a bit too young for the scene era and now just getting into their discography they’re incredible, lee malia is the most underrated guitar player i’ve ever seen honestly the whole band, oli has his moments tho but fantastic front man

Ive been listening to BMTH since 2008 😊 Still listen to them. It's just one of those bands that can't do you wrong.

How can you place at nº1 an album that’s not even out yet? Am I missing something?

Here's my list: 1: count your blessings 2: count your blessings 3: count your blessings You get the idea

BRING ME DA 'ORIZON! Those dudes nail every sub-genre of rock. Them alongside Bad Omens and Falling in Reverse are the best in the game right now.

Hard for me between post human + amo but there is a hell was always my fave for years … what a great band! Shadow Moses … hats off chaps. Smashed it!

My fav albums from them are: 1.) Sempiternal 2.) Suicide Season 3.) There Is a Hell 4.) Count Your Blessings 5.) Post Human Survival Horror 6.) This Is What The Edge Of Your Seat Was Made For EP 7.) Thats The Spirit 8.) Amo 9.) Music To Listen To Who agrees with me? Drop a comment 👇

Finally some ranking that there is NOT Sempiternal on first place.

You should do this with A Day To Remember or Hatebreed. I know you're big fans of those bands and they both have a lot of albums that are really good

Sitting there and listening to death core going "it's so catchy and I love the shit production" is such a meme

bold move of you to put their upcming album in first place but I think you're actually onto something. ppl will not stfu about how long it's taking but I can wait & I think it'll be worth the wait too.

My (metalcore-kid) list (worst to best): -Music to listen to... (just not my type of music - count your blessings (too much riff salad) -amo - thats the spirit (thrown and drown were just amazing singles) -post-human I - suicide season - Sempiternal -there is a hell

Everyone always forgets the chillout sessions :( one of my favs

When I heard AMO, I immediately thought they should do an album with Trent from NIN

me when someone rates anything but count your blessings as the best 😤😡 Edit: lmao I was meming but I wasn’t actually expecting it to be #2 for you. It’s a classic album in the genre IMO, your analysis of it was spot on.

So glad you included Music to listen to... It's such a cool record and doesn't ever get any attention. It's definitely not for everyone but I love it!

I saw this video on my recomended, freaked out, listened to it, heard he was going to talk about music to listen to, my fav album of all time. "Like seeing spiders running riot on your lover's grave hit's so hard."

Calls Sempiternal the definitive modern metalcore album: doesn’t even make top 3. Says Song to Listen to is an album he wouldn’t choose to listen to: doesn’t get last place. Finn is clearly a genius.

Remember discovering this band by ordering some album on CD and when it arrived they accidentally shipped me the there is a hell album and band tee as well.

It never ends got my attention back in 2010 but first time I heard Shadow Moses in 2013 was almost like a spiritual moment for me 🥲 there hasn't been any other band for me since then (altho Bad Omens is slowy getting there)

Nothing makes me happier than to see them still killing it. The only album i didn't like a lot was the one with the long title.

there is a hell is my favorite album by them, but ive come to the realization that it was the first album i listened to back when i was 14 so

Sepiternal was my favorite when it came out. They have live album out with a choir and orchestra and thats amazing too.

"There is a Hell" and "Sempiternal" are personally my favorites

Awesome. BMTH is my favorite band, so I can't wait to dig into this video. Edit: Sempiternal that low is a crime, but I get that it is hard when they have soooooo many bangers.

My spotify wrapped up had Post Human as my most listened to album/band so I guess I like that album lol. Lost was my most listened to song though. I actually disliked them back when they did Deathcore so hadn't given them a listen to until last year but rapidly became one of my favourite bands. Oli knows how to make absolutely catchy and banging choruses and you can tell he vibes really well with Jordan when they're coming up with lyrics for a song.

Met them here at home, Milwaukee WI. They were here for "suicide season" @ the rave. They did a small meet and greet before the concert. I got to shake all their hands and two autographed posters, which I lost. Wished Ollie a good show. Remember that night forever.

The Disrespect for “There is hell…” is unbelievable. The dichotomy of heavy instrumentation and harsh vocals, and cleaner softer sections that are heavy emotionally. How can you not like songs like Crucify me, It Never Ends, F*ck, Alligator blood, Visions, Don’t go, or Blessed with a curse? I get your a purist, but there’s more nuance to music than being a one trick pony.

Not gonna lie, I thought Oli was able to get so swole because he was so short..

When I started being a fan literally everybody hated them… I really don’t know when exactly that changed

DUDE I'm back again - fuck yes, you put count your blessings at the top. I knew our tastes would eventually align Finn! Shout out to all of your content though man. Appreciate you!

Thank you for this. I get goosebumps everytime I hear count your blessings or suicide season, such important albums for me in my youth, and the scene at that time. Being a die hard BMTH fan, you got me to look at this subjectivity, and I agree with all of your picks.

I got into BMTH pretty late, like “That’s The Spirit” late but I’d went back and listened to their previous projects. Nonetheless, my favorite 3 are That’s The Spirit, Post Human and Amo.

I remember, I went to JB hi-fi and picked up that EP, this is what the edge of your seat was made for, only because they had an interesting name. Still can’t figure out what the idea of each song was, but I still think it slapped.

People forget that screaming can hurt your your vocals didn’t he have to get surgery on his vocal cords

havent listened to every bmth album but here is my ranking 1)sempiternal 2)there is a hell 3)sucide seasons 4)count your blessings 5)post human survival 6)amo

I like how this vid just turns into Fin confessing how attracted he is to Oli Sykes 😂

It wasn’t that long ago I was thinking Napalm death has been around forever, heck

Hey wait a minute. I'm the same age as the band and I ain't a junior in college. I'm not that old...

as a long time fan since count your blessings or even who wants flowers when there dead the EP I think this is a solid positioning and love how they have progressed. Bonus points they got some heavy shit recently so I'm personally happy to hear that but overall not disappointed with anything they have put out. Solid ranking my friend!

I'm with you on Count Your Blessings. It sounds oddly good even though the guitars are super fizzy, drums are clicky, vocals are a bit muffled. But the organised chaos somehow makes it a real addictive sound. Really cool 'At The Gates' style riffs. Their metal influence really came through and it sounded way different to anybody else you're right. I think being British made them stand out slightly too because it would've been a completely different hardcore scene over there. Nostalgic album though, got me hooked because it sounded filthy but it had really cool metal riffs and solos that I was searching for.

Lee’s amp was broken for This is What the Edge of Your Seat was Made For

Can we all agree that at this point, it’s basically “Amen” and then everything else?

For me it goes Suicide Szn, Count Your Blessings, Post Human, and the direction of the new stuff

“ maybe it will be out by the time you watch this”. It’s delayed till summer now :(

Really like your ranking ! I wouldn't have done the same but it makes sens. This band is the perfect band to get anyone into heavy music. Starting with the pop stuff, then going rock and end with metalcore/deathcore ! 😁

if i join patreon will you review my thesis or is it just music related things lol

I’m going to give this video a like just for the fact that you mentioned them bring in Nordstrom for Suicide Season. Almost nobody ever mentions that fact when discussing how ahead of the curve bring me was early on.

From least liked to most liked- that’s the spirit, edge of your seat, suicide season cut up, there is a hell, music to, sempiternal, amo, count your blessings, suicide season, post human 1

Wow, i thought for sure you were going to discredit count your blessings and just put it last with not much commentary about it, But you've made me proud Finn. It's number 1 for me, but you putting it number 2 totally blew my mind! Well done man!

Do ADTR next

BMTH pretty much has a song for every "vibe", and that's what I love about them

I haven’t even started the video but I’m already outraged and you’re wrong

"I don't like the mix of pop and heavy, I want one or the other, no in the middle." *puts Post Human at number 3*

I interviewed Oli in 2019 and asked him to rank their records from worst to best. Here’s his list back then: 6. Count Your Blessings 5. There Is a Hell… 4. Suicide Season 3. Sempiternal 2. That’s the spirit 1. Amo

lmao when you said 2004 as being a date people remember i was like ahhh the year i was born!

Interesting ranking 😅. Post Human: Next Gen is definitely gonna be great judging by the songs we have now.

2:35 “man Oli was skinny back then” yeah, its called ketamine💀

I thought you gonna put the first ep in the number one slot😂

you gotta have major balls to not put Sempiternal or That's the Spirit or at least Post Human at number one

Hell yes this is one of the best tier lists by Finn. Count your blessings and suicide season are the goats of metalcore, those 2 got me into metal as a while

Bold choices made respect. Sleep with one eye open is unrecognized proto-djent before Meshuggah worship took over.

there is a hell is THE masterpiece by them

Ice nine kills is a band that is near 20 years old and getting bigger and bigger

Ok but... "There is a Hell" is undoubtedly their peak for me. I put that album up there with The Beatles, Alanis Morissette's "Jagged Little Pill" etc. for top 10 albums of all time. Sempiternal honestly is just "There is a Hell" pt. II in the way that Green Day's "21st Century Breakdown" is the followup to "American Idiot." It's good, but doesn't capture that epic and groundbreaking feeling that the first does. I love BMTH's pop side too, but "There is a Hell" captured the moment in a completely unexpected way. Oli's introduction to clean vocals, HUGE guitar sounds, unreal songs - through and through. They were leaving their deathcore roots but discovered a bombastic and cinematic sound along the way.

Just curious, where would you place the EP "This is What the Edge of Your Seat Was Made For"?

Best to worst, the only right way. - Suicide Season - Count Your Blessings - There is a Hell... - That's the Spirit - Sempiternal - Amo - Post Human: Survival Horror

Where was "This what the edge of your seat was made for"?

Literally last night I was thinking, "I want Finn to rank BMTH" and I wake up get on my computer and see this. All you atheists out there, this is proof that there is a God.

I’d be more forgiving of Sempiternal not being #1 if Amo wasn’t #2.

This is what the edge of your seat was made for.

Random fact: Scorpions started in 1960s but didn’t really become popular until 1985 and then dropped another huge album in 2006

I’m almost 40 ffs 😂😂😂😂

This is possibly the most out there, against the norm, ranking ive ever come across 😅

I like it pure 10 min later My fav album is the one where they combine everything they ever did

Dude you missed Womb 2 Da Tomb rap side project 😂

Maybe its because I've outgrown that older metal sound, but these days you won't see me listening to any of their older music at all. Every now and then I'll put on Sempiternal from start to finish, but I honestly like their newer music more. And this is coming from someone who was listening to them back in the Myspace Era. My personal top 3 are That's The Spirit, Amo and Post Human.

That's the Spirit is the album that made them MASSIVE.