LA Show Tickets! hub.seetickets.com/us/event/10-20-pm-city-of-sound/molly-malone-s/2814521 My band: open.spotify.com/artist/19ErqV3IIZFacXLQF0mqgs?si=ENYQpUy6QW2l5jy5qLUt6w STGE: stgeapp.com/

Imagine being 10 years into your career with thousands of LIVE performances, doing them sick and with sound issues, and insane schedules behind you, and all of your mistakes can only add up to 3 minutes?? They were raking the internet for any and all bts mistakes and this is all they could find, if anything this just proves how good bts are :D

I think it's weird how people who can't sing critique others. Every singer has off days, period. The in ears, being sick, warm ups, etc. You can't judge singers based off of the ending stage of these broadcast. They aren't trying hard lol. People are so judgemental...and just trying to put them down because they don't like the group. Everyone needs to stop being hateful to others. People need to build others up. Thanks for your reaction and understanding of the guys.

kpop stans learned the word "strain" and fuckin ran with it dude

For context, if I'm not mistaken, "jin didn't sing properly" with the drums, it was the encore after they won the awards show. It's not performance, their actual performance was amazing. They only sing for their fans before go home, many idols only sing for fun and playfully, not just BTS. People often talk harshly about this encore, let them have fun ffs 😂

As someone who also sings, I always sigh really hard when people talk about "strain" or being "out of tune" as a sort of blanket criticism without knowing how to actually describe what their ears are hearing. They hear something "imperfect" and immediately dive to "bad technique" without context. And the amount of saying "strain" for Jimin particularly in response to the natural 'cry' at the end of his notes always makes me facepalm. It's not strain!! Nothing like strain. The one clip where you mentioned they sounded rushed/not warmed up is the encore of a music show in Korea. They are announced as winners and must IMMEDIATELY sing their song. They may have warmed up, but elapsed time is hard to tell -- they would have been waiting on stage before the announcement. They have no back track, their equipment seemed not to work, they were trying to mess with their props, etc. It's a lot going on! Thank you so much for pointing out fog, the mix, etc. Fans who aren't in the industry really do need more education about the realities of live singing.

I literally had vocal lessons last week and our voice teacher used jimin as an example of someone who has a gifted unique voice. She emphasized how hard to carry jimin's unique tone esp that most of his parts sit at the highest registers. She said that even if his voice isnt the most stable, jimin actually gives most bts songs the flavor and the uniqueness to it. He makes some bts songs unsingable for some because of the uniqueness and the level of difficulty he brings to the song because of his voice. This is an objective opinion. I'm a mamamoo, rose and ailee stan and i love jm's voice.

I saw a documentary where Jimin was in tears backstage in the middle of a performance because he was in pain and could barely say a word due to a non-stop schedule. He felt so bad for giving a poor performance for his team and the Army. It wasn't just Jimin; there was a time when they could only sleep 2-3 hours a day for weeks because they had too many performances and a jam-packed schedule. I'm not trying to excuse their poor performances, specifically these ones. But I felt sad and gained more respect watching them give their best for every performance, no matter their condition. I appreciate your reaction! Hope to see more! ;)

Love your reactions.... first, for the first clip with poor Jimin, that was a performance where the production crew had the WRONG guide in their ears and it was throwing them off and the show apologized profusely afterwards when ARMY fussed at them for doing such a bad job of setting the system incorrectly. I felt so bad for him cause you know the haters used every chance they could to attack. The 2nd clip was them goofing around after the show so Tae was probably just tired and not really pushing, it was at the part of the show when they are usually doing something fun or silly after as the credits are about to roll, and often times their in-ears aren't on right. . So yeah, you're right on point. plus these clips that she was saying "still not improving" actually went back in time to an older performance so her editing is misleading as well. I gave up on giving her the benefit of the doubt after that 3rd clip LOL EDIT: Also on the Love Yourself tour, Jimin was sick during part of it and got so bad at one point that even though he came out and performed amazingly he couldn't literally sing most of his parts on this song and he teared up and apologized to ARMY for not being able to do as well as he wanted, but he still did amazing and I challenge anyone who is sick, especially with the throat, to even talk let alone sing. SIGH. I saw him live the last show before he got sick and it was beyond amazing. His voice and all of their voices were golden and it was freaking cold. I was so worried about them but they rocked it.

I am not a vocalist...but I've never even thought about the fog! I wish more people who critize or think they know what they hear would listen to this! I'll be using the link to watch!! CANT WAIT!!!!❤

In my experience if a person says ‘I’m an army too’; it usually means ‘I’m not an ARMY, I’m a kpoppie but I don’t want to be attacked by ARMYs for being a hater.’ After 10 years of live singing, if this is what they manage to come up with I’m proud of my boys. While other idols are lip syncing and perform on total backing vocals, my kings have been singing live for a decade whether rain or shine……😏

Thank you for standing up for Jimin. He gets the most hate from antis and solo stans, it’s so sad. I’d also like to say that it’s easy to go through their 100’s and 100’s of performances and find one that is not the best example and pick it to death. As mentioned by others, there is video of Jimin right before they performed The Truth Untold complaining about how his throat hurt so bad that it hurt to breathe. Bad sound in their in-ears, too much fog, (thanks for the lesson about that), illness, these are all things that make for a less than perfect sound on a single occasion. Honestly, this person had to have gone through a LOT of videos to find these examples. Thank you for standing up for our guys!

Man I loved this video. It's nice to have and educated person giving their intake. Jimin is always hated, no matter if he hits the highest notes, adds so much emotion or elevates the song

It’s nice to hear a critique about vocals from someone who actually sings! Thank you for your insight💜 It’s easy to find a handful of bad moments for any singer and make it look like they can’t sing, when you don’t include context to anything. To not find one moment of JK struggling is telling. As amazing as he is, he’s still human. I’m sure there’s one this solo Stan could’ve included to mask their bias😂 imo a true army wouldn’t seek these moments out to share like this. I’ve seen Reddit threads with similar arguments that use this same handful of moments. I keep RM’s voice in my head reminding me to move on and not argue, it’s their loss anyway.

First, let me applaud you for your restraint. 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 Your faces and memes were priceless. Secondly, thank you for your knowledge! I had no idea fog could do this. I, personally, am sensitive to fog at shows. It dries my eyes out and makes me cough. I thought it was just me! Every time I see it flowing across the stage I’m like…sigh… *cough* Great reaction!

20:29 for that concert, Jimin was actually sick and asked JK to support him in the back half of the song

I agree 1000% about the dangers of fog. I am a retired circus performer and fog was my enemy. You can’t breathe! If you take a full breath in, it makes you choke and cough. I don’t know how singers can sing at all!

Thank you for the reaction, I’ve been waiting for this one! People are so hard on Jimin. It feels like they were just picking on him here. He has a beautiful unique tone and people just love to tear him down.

Thank you for your informed commentary based on your expertise. I feel like the maker of the video is NOT an expert and their opinion is based upon erroneous assumptions. I love your BTS reaction videos, I look forward to more of them. Best of luck with your endeavors with your band, you guys are great! And dude, you're freakin' adorable ;)

Jimin is my bias and I love him more than anything. He has said in interviews that he didn’t get vocal lessons pre-debut like the other vocalists because initially BH wanted him to rap. Crazy huh! He would listen in on the lessons and then practice what he heard in his own spare time. Suga finally told BH that Jimin should be a vocalist. Jimin was not a born singer but rather had to teach himself and he has talked about how he made up his own techniques. Jimin is just amazing and to think he hit all those high notes from the beginning because of his sheer passion to excel. His determination and drive to succeed are unmatched. I hope he knows how much his vocals have been loved by millions of fans worldwide. Thank you for your input, most people knew nothing about the fog issue! Good to know!

I loved this breakdown. Spot on and real as always. The ON performance the content provider used in the beginning (around min 9) was the closing of an award show where traditionally they have the group or individual perform an "encore" after winning the Music Show grand prize. Their vocals had cooled by then. It's usually a poor set up behind it all, in ears not functioning properly, etc. Typically it is half hearted and goofy, sometimes changing parts with each other, etc.

Really appreciate your perspective as a vocalist, I’ve never even considered the effect fog would have on their vocals but it makes so much sense, especially in jimins case. I swear there’s been an agenda against him their entire career, downplaying his talent and criticising his live singing abilities. Judging just by the channel name of the person who made this video, plus their “criticism” and the cherry-picked clips they used, I would say this definitely comes from a solo and not an army

I missed the live of this, but this is why I like your reactions. This is not Milli Vanilli, ffs, it's BTS. No band has 10+ years of "perfect every time" performances. Thank you & Good luck with the show!!! Unless life gets in the way, I'll be watching!!!

To add to my first comment about how crazy it is that all bts mistakes add up to ONLY 3 mins, ALL of these mistakes were under bad circumstances too. The first one their in-ears were f*cked up and none of the members could hear sht, the second video they had NO in-ears and it wasn't a performance but a "celebration" after they won an award (basically just for fun), third performance he was sick, fourth performance vocals were edited and backing track lowered, fifth performance Jimin was so sick that he couldn't talk before and even started crying because of it at the end of the performance. Like isn't that insane? They really chose only clips where there were external issues going on to "prove" that bts can't sing?? (also this was made by a blackpink Stan and jungkook akgae, aka only stans jungkook and hates the other members, so the part about them "liking" bts was a bold-faced lie)

“The Truth Untold “ performance was in Brazil I think, and there is a BTS documentary of this tour and Jimin was sick and was losing in voice. No one here disagrees with your comments. Good luck on your show. I downloaded the app and hope to see you live from my living room in Ohio. 🫶🏻

I love how you took the time to explain the technicality behind things to help people better understand what is actually going on. I love Jimin and his voice and it breaks my heart to see how frustrated and down on himself he gets when his performance isn’t perfect. Jimin needs to see this video too, then maybe he won’t blame himself when something happens that is beyond his control. 💜

Also, major Jungkook solo stan vibes of course. It's like it's supposed to prove he is so much better an everyone else.

Im a singing teacher University level you are right on every point and explanations. i used to do big stages here in Quebec Canada and fog is a killer and cause big damages to vocal cords its over drying and stiffing the vibration to help you eat half of teaspoon of Vaseline then its not attaking your cordes.

Ok I finished the video and seriously, I f*cking love you!! Everything you said was professional and perfect! You know what you are talking about and it is clear!! Thank you 🙏 💜

Hooray for actual reactions by actual singers! The second cliip starting with V is them singing the winner's encore for one of the weekly kpop music shows. Groups often act silly and do playful stuff during these, but also often struggle because they can't hear the track properly and exactly as you said, have not had a chance to warm up properly. Every time someone uses one of these encores to trash a Kpop vocalist I cringe. They are flat because they can't hear and in-ears are failing them, not because of strain or not being able to sing. Ugh!

Looks like the person who made the video is strongly Jungkook biased. Nothing against Jk's voice of course. But hyper criticism on the other vocalists seems really unfair. There are lots of people out there who call themselves 'Army' but they are solo stans in reality... so sad. You are right from a technical point of view; I also take singing lessons, and I am scared by dry throat more than by a sore throat...

I don't even know what haters trying to prove. All I see is at least they still sing live. And this is just a compilation of when they didn't sound their best. Which is not a big deal because I have seen countless live flawless performances from them.

Seriously J, you did this with class and were so careful to be technical about your criticism. Well done. The rest of the guys are about to head off to Military Service soon so keep up the reactions. It'll do our hearts good while we miss them. (I just made myself cry, ARMY wtf. 😭

Thank you for the objective reaction. Truly love your input

This why I enjoy reactions by vocalist and people in the music industry. It really helps to understand why certain things may sound off. If I wanted 100% perfect, I would just listen to the recorded versions of the songs. Live most bands, especially BTS sounds better, yep, occasionally someone misses a lyric or is a little flat on a note, but the energy Live is everything.Ironically BTS gets accused of lip-syncing because they sound so good live. I have seen them skip a word so you can hear the backtrack is much lower or even sing another member's short part to show they aren't. thanks for reacting; I think I tried to watch the original video a while ago and got mad part way through and stopped.

I really love your reaction since you know what you are talking about because you are a vocalist yourself. I hate people who complains and claimed that Jimin cannot sing just because they simply do not like Jimin because of stupid toxic solo stans and toxic shippers . They are just plain haters and do not know what they are talking about.

One other thing, Jimin was the last member picked, he had the shortest training period before they debuted, he would watch the other member's lesson and practice on his own after their regular training, often training until 2 am and getting up for school at 6 am. So for years, he felt less than. He wrote the song Promise (with Slow Rabbit and RM) as a promise to not be so hard on his-self;, you should react to it.💜

Thank you so much for reacting to this video. Good luck with your shows! I've downloaded the stage app and everything. 💜

honestly love your bts live reactions hope you checkout more of their songs ❤

i've grown up in a very musically inclined family and i cannot express the amount of frustration i feel when i see random people on the internet speak about things they CLEARLY don't understand, especially about singers. there's so much that goes into a performance that people don't realize, so many factors to take into consideration, and you can absolutely tell when the folks who criticize like this have no clue wtf they're talking about lmao 😅 edit: i wanted to add that, yes, context is SO important and this person is leaving out every bit of it, which is doubly annoying. and pitting the members against each other is so???????? ugh.

Thank you for your reaction and for clarifying some things. When I first saw this video I was surprised, but then not, bc I immediately felt that BTS were rushed and not prepared. You can see in the end like they were just told to sing the song since they won an award. And it just sounded like the sound crew for that award show didn’t have it together. Thank you again for enlightening us from your professional perspective. Take care. 🫰🏼💜

This was so helpful to hear your explanations. It makes so much sense. Thank you. 💜. Off to listen now…

When someone who can sing well doesn't sound as good as usual, something is wrong. I appreciate that you're bringing in the context. People yell about "vocal strain" a lot, mostly with Jimin, and it's always nonsense. They don't understand vocal technique but they've picked up this "strain" idea and throw it around to sound smart. There's a concern troll sort of thing happening where they're like "I just don't want him to hurt his voice" and it's so obnoxious. No one is perfect all the time - even Jungkook! - and that's the point of live performance: it's live. You get what they have to give on that day in that moment. Good luck at your show!

1st, Andromeda is my fav 🎉 👏 Good luck on your concert! 🙏 2nd, Thank you for sharing your experience as real performer, especially interm of fog. Years ago, I trainned my vocal for choir, hence I know a little bit of singing technique, hence when Jimin was cracked, I tought he must been struggle of something on stage, but never thought, due the fog. Thank you for acknowledge me. 👏 In live performance which involve many things, can give Mariah Carrey off tune while she is a timeless world diva.

This video you reacted to threw up a red flag from the jump, since it's by someone named, "JK Shining Solo," i.e. one of those people who thinks they're lifting up their favourite member by tearing down the rest. Then, the first clip started playing & I recognized it from a notorious performance in which their in-ears weren't working properly. I thought, "hmm... is that the game, "JK Shining Solo," is going to play? I don't know if I wanna waste my energy on that." So, I jumped ahead to the next example in the video and - shock! surprise! - it's footage of a music show encore. No mention of how many Idols don't sing at all for encores - because they don't necessarily have working in-ears for encores. It just demonstrates that most people have little understanding of either vocal technique or of modern production methods.

I really enjoyed your reaction! I think the whole band is amazing, but there are bound to be mistakes when in a lot of ways, they were learning as they went. They never claimed to debut as experts, and they're so self- critical that I hate when less flattering moments are cut and put together. I also think it's unfair to use Jungkook as a comparison, because he's part of the band and he wouldn't want to be used to make anyone else feel bad. He's a huge fan of all the other members! Thanks for the insights, I never thought about fog at concerts, but I will now!

thanks for making this video, so much of what you have said makes a lot of sense. I see how hard this group of seven work, and I struggle with comments being made without supporting ‘evidence’, having an objective view was appreciated.

"I'm not gonna take this personal" video bashes Jimin ... "I'm about to ruin this man's whole career"

Thanks for adding context to these clips. I have acted on stages that have fog on them and it's horrible. I hadn't thought about how that must affect a person as a singer. It must make it really difficult because of the sheer amount of breathing you are doing. Also, I popped over to listen to some of your songs on Spotify, I see what you mean about the amount of air in your voice. I really liked Andromeda. :)

Jimin was sick that day

Thank you so much for your insights. My parents were musicians, and you remind me of the musicians I grew up around. (I wish my dad was still around to see them as he would love BTS for the professionalism they bring to everything they do.) Thank you so much for bringing this perspective. 💗

Just came across this video because someone linked it up on Twitter. I am an ARMY and a Jimin stan at that. And it always hurts me whenever I see these unncessary "constructive criticisms" when in reality, they're only masked like that because they are indeed throwing hate on him. I always watch vocal coaches/singers reacting to these singing videos from BTS but I think you are the first person to actually put it in a much insightful context. I've never thought of "fog" and how it can vastly contribute to how it can affect a vocalist's performance. I've always seen it as something used for decorative purposes and it's frequent because concerts and performances like these typically use these "fog" to create a more dramatic experience for the audience. So, thank you to you. I learned something new today. I will always bring this new-found knowledge with me and try to be more understanding of performers in general. You earned another subscriber to your channel. I hope you get more recognition from your insightful videos. 😊

0:46 done and done 💜 you have great music 💜

Thank you for this, it was really informative. As someone who can’t sing, I would never even attempt to criticize what I have no experience with, and have nothing but respect for those who put themselves out there on stage and perform. I am glad to hear your take on this, as I feel like the person who made the video may not be a good judge of what is going on. No hate to that person, just my opinion. Anyone who follows BTS knows how hard they work and how upset they get when they feel like they didn’t sing perfectly. But to me, the fact is that they care so much means more to me than perfect vocals all of the time. Oh and I am really looking forward to watching your performance on the 2nd. I am super excited to see the band perform and also watch the cameraman struggle to find you when you go into the crowd.😂

Thank you so much for your input and informative information. I had no idea all of these things. I have seen videos of where Jimin did seem to be off, but I knew that regardless, he can sing. So it helps knowing context. Thank you!! You’ve given us all information we can hopefully pass on to others. I’ll reference this video. 🫶🏽 💜

Thanks to react to this video. The video creator maybe is a Jimin hater. And he/she is not an Army. We do not need these kind of person in our community. We love them and we protect OT7 like we do with our kids. Thanks God you gave a good perspective of what is going on stage as you are a professional too. 🙏

I really hate when people dont know anything about the topics they discuss. First of all i wanna say this here out and proud, i bet this person (who made the video) isn't an ARMY. Cuz, i double that bet on this, any ARMY from debut will clearly say that BTS has one of the best vocalists in the industry without a doubt. They have distinctive voices which made their songs rich in sound acpects. Around 4:12 it showed their Fake Love stage performance with Charlie Puth on the key. That performance was not the best and they had in-ear issues expect Jungkook cuz he already performed Attention by Charlie Puth with Charlie Puth on stage. Guess what? He had in-ear problems at that stage too. 4:26 that performace from their 2019 encore stage which when idols do after recieving awards (i think its just for daesang). Guess what? If it's not BTS nobody cares if idols do or do not perfect encore performance. Encores isnt about perfection. It is for fun. 16:31 Jimis had have already a sore-throat issue at that time cuz he was sick. After performancing bunch of songs like IDOL and Fake Love and Mic Drop how he could sing perfectly with sore throat and all those fogs around? I want this person to sing to a karaoke mic (i want the song to be The Truth Untold btw - if they are ARMY since debut, they have to know/memorize TTU by heart), record it and see if it give them to perfect vocals. Cuz why not right?

Yessssss i just watched your video saying you would react to this!!! Im so excited for your reactionnnn

wow your insights about the fog are so valuable. as a fellow Jimin Defender i knew that there was a reason behind some of his so called "strain" but obviously without any musical technical skill i didn't know what it was exactly. The sheer amount of jimin vocals i've consumed I know for a fact he's an amazing singer with a very unique, light and airy tone. Great video

Thank you for your reaction😊. I was so mad when haters said that Jimin can not sing😮, after 10 years singging and dancing they said he can not sing, what a crap is that 🤨🤨🤨.

i understand providing feedback and criticisms, but making a whole ass video and titling it specifically how “BTS Can’t sing” is absolutely wild to me. Every artist has their off days, they could’ve been sick, etc we don’t even know. But discrediting their efforts and saying they “can’t sing”.. how are they even an army. Also that one ON live near the beginning was an encore. It’s not even a rehearsed performance, and choosing to point out their vocals there tells me how much they had to grasp at straws to prove their point. I’ll just completely ignore the fact that theyre likely not a vocalist themselves with their lack of technical judgement.. since the video itself was kinda pointless

You're so much fun to watch. I love your genuine affection for the boys and actually learn a thing or two about singing techniques from you. Man, if I could watch your concert in LA, I would, but sadly I live hundreds and thousands of kilometers away. Still wishing you the best of luck though! You're gonna smash it.

Whatever you were saying regarding the fog is true... I was performing on stage and that was not even singing and it was dancing... Fog machines were aimed at the stage and by the end of 5 mins powerful dance performance I had dry throat and was unable to speak and was about to pass out.... That fog hurts like shit...BTS are never singing bad unless there is some issues with technical stuff... If they are bad singers then listen to their Acapella versions...💜💜💜

These critique videos frustrate me and you are a trooper for reacting to this and educating on what’s really happening. The creator most likely does not know about singing and just wants to hate. Also like the first clip, that’s an encore and not an official performance. The haters love to use those as evidence that the idols can’t sing and it’s a weak argument. Same goes for using a SNL performance as an examples as well. All bad and unfair.

I'm a trained vocalist. I stopped performing after college because I didn't have the passion anymore. However, the fog thing is so real. I would often get bronchitis and completely lose my voice by the end of Christmas Spec (a super big Christmas show my university did that has multiple showings). The fog was the reason. Almost all of us, 100 singers and 50 orchestra members would be sick by the end. It sucks.

For SNL they purposely sang off beat, dropped out lines and changed their mics throughout the performance (watch Suga) to prove to haters that they do actually sing live. You'll see it when you watch the full set. For untold truth .. jimin was getting progressively worse throughout this tour because he was so sick but still went out every night. You can tell by his body language he knows its off. Jin shared in 2017 they only got a day and a half off a month. They were absolutely exhausted. Tell me any other band that works like that and still put their fans first. As RM said they are aware their fans may only get 1 night with them so they give it everything

although you were obviously pissed, man, you are still very articulate. this is great reaction :) thanks!!! 💜💜💜

it's actually so interesting I've never thought about fog but if I'm not wrong later in their tour bts stopped using as much if not at all especially in their stadium tour and it definitely helped bc theirs vocals were amazing

Hey did you see Jimin won Best Male Artist at the MAMA2023, they keep bashing his talent but he keeps proving them wrong.. we love Jimin and we love BTS.. thank you for your reaction

Thank you Sir for trying to educate the uneducated! I can't get it why this people who not even professional singers try to slander somebody when they can't even themselves can hold a note! Unbelievable!

It seems it's a solo fan who did that sh*t. Those whose bias is JK and "ship" Taekook spread a lot of hate for Jimin. She took bad mixes and situations where Jimin was sick. And... what's the problem with bits of cracking voice? He even corrects the problem rapidly AND most of time they are perfect. I'm sure she had to work hard trying to find those pieces of "bad" performances. She called herself Army? She's a liar!

This is giving undercover hater wolf in sheep clothing. Let's be clear no fan makes a whole video like this of a group they claim to like without showing a fair balance of hits and misses. Saying your a fans while trying to point out how bad they are is true hater stuff because if they can't sing then why are you a fan of them? Bet if you do a deep dive you'd find they actually are a real fan of another group.

i really can’t take seriously kpopers’ opinions on singing bc most of them aren’t singers themselves (or know about music in general) or bc they only know about kpop music, they really have minimal understanding and knowledge of the industry and artistry, and i’ve already watched so many videos of artists reacting to them and praising their voices, even in the moment where kpopers pointed as “strain” voice lmao… once again, another amazing reaction + analysis, i love your videos so much and thank you for your support to bts 😢💜

Thank you, thank you for the valuable feedback and for putting everything into perspective. It's great hearing all this from someone that actually knows what they are talking about. I ppreciate you taking the time to do this. ❤

The part where they have drums is not a performance. Their performance was finished they already won the music show. The members usually plays or have fun during an encore. Its not a serious performance. The creator chose that on purpose.

oh my god this is off topic, i really like your single "but one ghost" i keep playing it✨❤️‍

You have got to be one of the best reactors out there and the insight you provide is awesome! Jimin was sick during TU and I can’t believe how many people hold on to these clips. Anyways, have a great performance on the weekend

You are the best omg! The way I loved this reaction, truly, THANK YOU! Not only did I learn about fog but the way you brought it just made me smile all the way through 💜

Thank you so much for your reaction. It is nice to see a realistic reaction from someone who knows what they are talking about - rather than self-proclaimed "experts". I'm no expert when it comes to singing, but my reactions when I first saw this video (and there are, unfortunately, a few videos out there like this) was much like yours. They clearly had little knowledge of what they were talking about, and some comments just made me think "What the...?' The way they praised Jungkook's vocals (which, admittedly, are praiseworthy) while attempting to tear down Jimin and Jin's vocals, just had the feel of a solo stan. So objectivity could be an issue. Plus, as so many others have pointed out, these clips were shown entirely out of context. And context is so important. Several of these clips were at the end of music shows - where no one really does their best, and they often just goof around. It's far from representative of their abilities. Or clips where, it is well known Jimin was sick, or there were technical issues, indicates they were there to confirm a narrative. Plus, chronologically, they were all over the place. Thank you for the information about Fog. I admit I never considered it's effect on a singers voice. But it makes sense, and I'll take notice of that in future. But I know so many things can affect a singers voice; weather, humidity levels, altitude, heat and cold, sickness, exhaustion, and so many other things. As others have pointed out, the fact that they are not 100% all the time, just proves that they sing live; which is nothing to be ashamed of.

Thanks! Your professional exclamations are very much appreciated 💜

The fact that some of these are actually EDITED by the haters js to make it seem like BTS can't sing is insane. BTS are truly amazing singers.

I appreciate your comments, and based on my son's experiences as a lead singer, your points were valid. People don't realize what it takes to be a singer - a real, professional singer. Just singing in the shower is NOT the same as singing live professionally. And how many western artists today sing live anyway? I don't care if the creator is ARMY; don't criticize if you don't have the knowledge to criticize. Having an opinion is fine, but this wasn't that. I am so glad you did this. And I know how hard your songs are to sing - I've listened to them! You're very good and the insights you brought shed a nicer light on these examples. Thank you so much and good luck on Saturday - wish I could be there.

Also I remember one of their performances of Truth Untold Jimin openly admitted he was sick and his throat was not in a good condition that's why he had JK help him with the higher notes and to sing together with him in certain parts of the song. Also I think he puts that extra trill in his voice at the end of a word to convey emotion and vulnerability like when someone crying and speaking at the same time. It also reminds me of MJ singing he did the high squeaks as well and he was an amazing singer that's why he is known as the king of pop, but no one says his technique is off. Lastly Jimin never got voice lessons to begin with. I think it took him 3 or 4 years before the company allowed him to get lessons that's why he was so hard on himself when they were rookies.

just in case it wasn’t obvious already the person who made this video is clearly not an army and most likely a solo

As a singer myself, I get so annoyed when they bitch that Jin and Jimin are “straining”. 🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄😤😤😤😏😏😏 So many people with no knowledge about singing out here making shit up. Thank you for speaking the truth. 💜💜💜

LOVE THIS!! Literally appreciate this context, although I already understood it. 💜

Ohhhh i so much loved your pro imput !!!!! The context !!!! Thank you thank you 💖 You made it all clear seriously 💜💜💜

You can’t take solo stans seriously, they just wanna put the other members down for their bias to shine. All BTS are great singers on their own. Btw love your videos💜

I love this „Ya‘ll are kinda beautiful savages sometimes.“ 😂 But a reminder to please stay nice is always appreciated! Thanks for your breakdown!

I truly love jimin’s voice it’s different & very unique.

For a bit more context, the ON stage where the person criticized them so much was an encore stage after a music show where they won first place. It wasn't a serious performance and the members frequently goof around during those. This isn't the performance during the actual show. This is also literally the first time they ever performed without an audience. It was their first performance after Covid started impacting everything and the first time there was no audience permitted to attend. I couldn't say about warming up or not, but they were emotionally heavily impacted by having to sing with no audience. Especially for an encore stage that's rarely treated seriously to begin with.

Hell yeah!!!! Been waiting for this just to see the rage that comes from the core of the heart (as a singer) when people try to put the 'Can't sing' label onto literal professional singers with many many years of their careers......

I hate it when people say "jimin can't sing" when he clearly can. They always pick 2-3 performances that were his offdays or encores that are always rushed to criticize him when we have 10 years worth of amazing performances that is automatically ignored to justify their "criticisms". The BTS hate train is so forced sometimes.

Dang this was super informative - would love to see more videos like this! We know BTS has the talent but as a non singer it’s cool to know more about why

At 7:30, it wasn't even a performance so to speak, I think it was after the show and they were just casually singing to their song and playing around with Army. They always do this, it shows how funny they are and how much they love Army, that they stick around even after the show is officially over. You can see all the other Idols leaving. Thank you for standing up for them, especially Jimin. His voice is angelic, like you said before and I get goosebumps whenever I see him dance, he is literally floating.

I live in a very dry climate, and it definitely affects my singing.

since youre new and havent really dove into the technicalities of what kpop idols do the venues they perform and who runs the venues the award shows and music shows etc you wont get the context but you are clearly seeing a pattern even without knowing. so in korea music shows and award shows are literally RUN by the big labels aka the big 3. the big 3 have a hatred for bts so a lot of performance mistakes that the venues staff is supposed to take care of like in ears, fog, mics etc are purposely sabotaged to make the public lose faith in bts abilities. it may sound like a conspiracy but i swear its true. it has been exposed that awards were withheld from bts and given to groups from the big 3 labels, its been exposed that venues and staff would purposely not do their jobs only when bts perform to the point bts knew it and you can see them get pissed off multiple times at multiple different performances through the years. and prior to bts being too big to ignore these same shows and networks would cut their performances or not film properly like filming the ceiling or zooming in and out to where you cant even see the performance. this is why for a while bts stopped doing music shows and it has since been revealed a lot of artist mistreatment happens by the staff to artists from smaller labels like forcing them to buy staff meals even though the groups dont have much money for themselves. staff being rude abusing the power dynamics. so much i can say but seriously now that you gave context about fog and venues being involved in a lot more things to help the performances run smoothly it makes even more sense how much power they have over bts performances and why they always have issues only in these places and not really in anywhere else. like suga himself called out the corruption last year or the year before and it came out in news a few weeks ago that bts label is pushing for change for artists to get better treatment at these shows prior no one else had the power to do so and with korean culture you have to respect those in power. artists have the least power compared to staff and higher ups etc especially where age is involved or how many years someone has been working there. say youre 24 and someone whos been working there for 4 years is 20 you have to respect the 20 year old cause they have work seniority over you. and then the power of age dynamics is even stricter like if someone in their 20s disrespects someone in their 50s it causes a lot of issues you HAVE to respect elders even when theyre wrong.

This was very educational. Thanks.

As a jimin fan I’m so glad people recognise how breathtaking his voice is! People seem to be critical for one slightly of(even though they’re all amazing to me all the time) performance and ignore the hundreds of other amazing performances they do. Like they can have a tough day at work!

You can tell that person is an algae because she would bash all the members except JK.