Hey Liz, thank you :-D I actually came by your channel when researching for this video so it's cool to have you visit and comment. Hope you're well!

@@thegroovygenes2772 you wasted your genes on him, congrats.

bulgarian is one of serbian dialects

@@gfdfgaadfgadfg2309 1885? Should we do that again or you had enough of it?

@@HeroManNick132 1885 what?do you think when the Serbian army came to Vidin and almost to Sofia? While you were wandering around Slivnica....

Have you watched her N Macedonian video? It's extremely obvious she hasn't got any experience with language learning.

@@tazzz1783 ? what do you mean? I don't think there's anything to be understood here.

Ma čoveče on je našao izuzetno glupa devojka da pogađa . Da bi razumeo srpski ili makedonski moraš malo da uključiš mozak , evo naprimer kad kaže " Polako ali sigurno " i ona gleda ko ovca i kaže neznam a onda je pita kako bi to bilo na bugarskom a onda odgovara " Bavno no sigurno " , u stvari Polako na bugarskom je Poleka a isto se može reči i Bavno ali kao što sam reko izuzetno glupa , verovano čak ni Bugarski nezna . Evo mene naučio sam Srpski bez ikakvu pomoč bilo od koga , samo sam slušao muziku i gledao filmove , tako da nije ni malo teško da naučiš a kamoli da pogodiš obične reči koje itekako postoje u Bugarskom jezikom samo malo treba da uključiš mozak . Što me mene nisu izabrali da pogađam 😃 . Pozdrav iz Bugarskoj

@@naskok007 Slažem se sa tobom. I ja sam naučio bugarski vrlo lako tako što sam prvo naučio osnovne bugarske reči koje se razlikuju od srpskih, naprimer nie (mi), sega (sad), koga (kad), gi (ih), bavno (sporo), hubavo (lepo), nameri (nađi), pak (opet). A onda sam gledao bugarske filmove i čitao bugarske tekstove bez ikakvih problema

@@user-or9ix2ls4q upravo na to sam mislio , to su jezici koji su do pre 300-400 godina bili skoro isti , do pre 100 godina bugarski je isto imao 7 padeža kao i ostali slovenski jezici , do tada su srpski i bugarski bili jako identični a plus to do tada u srpskom ni je bilo toliko reči iz engleskog a u bugarskog nije bilo toliko ruske reči

@@naskok007 имаш право, това момиче требва малко въображение да вкара за да се сети за някои думи. То повечето тя дето се чуди си ги имаме и в българския език ама не може да зацепи за какво става на въпрос…Аз например не мога да кажа че знам сръбски ама особено като го чета например като твоя коментар тука разбирам на 100% всичко

I (Zhen) agree with you. Another plus of listening to another language first hand is that you can also read their lips and of course ask them to repeat certain words which in our experiment wasn't an option 😅

WE also say BASH in Bulgarian, idk why she couldn't get that. We can say "Tuka e bash prijatno" makes perfect sense in Bulgarian.

@@dayanbalevski4446 Така е! Ако кажеш: "Баш ми е драго", се разбира, че ти е особено/много приятно. Но го използваме често и със значение на "точно" : "Баш там няма да ида" = "Точно там няма да отида", "Баш беше решил" = "Тъкмо беше решил".

In some western dialects we can say ''Овде е баш приятно.'' The biggest difference is Bulgarian is the only Slavic language that lacks of JE sounds with Macedonian (despite Macedonian kept it to some degree). Some dialects still kept this but the Standard form almost completely removed the ''JE'' sound except in some words like ''йерархия, фойерверки'' that uses ''Й'' instead of ''Ь'' that has been limited just to O.

Never knew you spoke Russian!? So you going to come in the channel and do a Czech???

Yeah and if u are interested, explore where do these languages come from truly (who spread) , bg are trying to steal, like they steal everything, the macedonians who made a language for the Slavs, translated books, bibles, they they were spreading from Solun(tesaloniki) to Moravia and beyond, they shread Macedonia in 1912 and they still are trying to destroy the country that gave them literacy, religion and... It's shame, the victors write the history

@@mitedupev7956 абе глупаак, иди питай баба ти и дедо ти да научиш нещо истинско, а не сърбо комунистическите измислици

There is nothing wow about it, Slavic languages divided last in Europe, in 10th century all spoke old Slavic, so languages are quite close

That's true. A long time ago, two girls and I watched American movie with subtitles in Serbian on the Yugoslav television. One of the girls was from Burgas - from Eastern Bulgaria, and the other was from Vratza - a town in Western Bulgaria. The girl from Burgas said she didn't understand a bit of the subtitles, and the girl from Vratza said she understood everything. The problem is, that back then they used the Latin sript in Yugoslavia, and we use Cyrillic alphabet in Bulgaria.

В Белград ли?

@@HeroManNick132 Не, пътували сме през цяла Сърбия, почти навсякъде сме се разбирали, ако някой не говори английски.

Oleta!! It's soon time for us to all meet in a park and have Bulgarian conversation between the 4 of us me thinks!! Definitely one for the channel haha

@@thegroovygenes2772 Hey Jenia & Phil! Yes that sounds great would be so cool to see you guys!!

Македонският е посърбен български диалект.

@@HeroManNick132 is it? Sure grammar is more similar to Bulgarian then to Serbian, and words are influenced by Serbian a lot, but don’t forget that it used to be Serbia before Turka arrived, it is not like Bulgarians say recently influenced. Torlak dialects in western Bukgaria, south eastern Serbia and parts of Macedonia are mix of Serbian and Bulgarian

@@macakucizmama831 Вардарска Македония беше част от Сърбия, след Първото българско царство, когато цяла Сърбия бе част от това царство. Сръбският е просто архаична версия на българския език с падежи и нарочно сте изменили някои от значенията на думите като например ''разлог'' (reason) и ''разлог'' (hollow) на български. Разбира се вие нямате също (исто) така ''в/във/во,'' а само ''у,'' което го използваме само за място или нещо, скрито навътре. Сега като го прочетох твоето име по-внимателно, разбрах (разумях), че при нас би се превело като ''Котаракът в чизми'' и граматиката е леко разменена. ''Мачак,'' която е диалектна дума у нас, е в именителен падеж, докато на български ''чизми'' e в именителен падеж, а ''чизмама'' е в творителен падеж, който е архаичен вече за нас, макар че няколко думи са останали от него: пътьом настоящем денем нощем утром пешком бегом пълзешком лазешком даром ходом родом и т.н. Можем и да кажем ''Мачакът в чизми,'' макар че нестандартно ще звучи, а пък ''Мачакът у чизми'' - още по-нестандартно. Характерно още за вашият диалект, е смяната на ''е/ъ'' в ''а'' чуден - чудан тъмен - таман (таман на български е синоним на ''тъкмо'') Милен - Милан и т.н. Или замяната на ''я, ъ, е'' в ''е, jе'' нямам - немам (макар, че в западните диалекти го имаме ''немам'' също.) него - него/њeго добър - добар и т.н.

@@HeroManNick132 both languages are Slavic, hence similarities, but no, Serbian is not Bulgarian, Bulgarian is language developed from a 7 Slavic tribes living in a present Bulgaria and Macedonia, also Bukgarian was influenced by Greek and Russian later, these Slavic tribes in Bukgaria were Antes, totally different tribe of Serb tribe that were Sclaveni, Serbian was developed from porto Slavic, and Serbs are not native in most of modern Serbia, early Serbs lived around Adriatic sea, modern Serbia was colonized during Serbian kingdom in middle agaes, how can you even claim such nonesense? Serbs came to the Balkans from modern Germany, Poland and Czech Republic, while Slavs came to Bulgaria from the east .

@@HeroManNick132 also Serbian in southwestern Slavic language, whike Bulgarian is southeastern, give me a break how Serbian is Bukgarian, Serbs spoke with old Slavic when they came to Balkan later they developed Serbian , Serbian also use a lot of French, German and Italian words

''Ovde'' exists in Bulgarian too but as a dialect word used mostly in Western Bulgaria and not in the Standard language. In Standard form we only use ''tuk'' or ''tuka'' (like Macedonian only has ''tuka''). We have ''tu'' in Bulgarian but it has different purpose like ''ту черен, ту бял''

Thanks for this, now that you say it it makes sense! I have to admit though, something that doesn't make ass much sense and is slightly more intriguing... What inspired you to choose that name? :-D

In russian we actually say in a similar way. Спасибо! (Thank you!) - Не за что (меня благодарить)! (the phrase literally means 'There is nothing you have to thank me for, it's easy for me'). More proper one which corresponds with 'You are welcome!' is 'пожалуйста!'

@@thegroovygenes2772 haha, I came up with this a long time ago when I was trying to come up with an outrageous name, and was somewhat inspired by the name of the death metal band Dying Fetus

@@user-nh6op5rq4y Greets to our Russian ,best greets from Serbia .

In Bulgarian exists similar phrase: Няма защо. It's very commonly used.

Ти от Източна България ли си?

@@HeroManNick132 ot Ruse sym.

@@eugenymalo8704 Познах! Обикновено българите от Източна България по-трудно разбират западните диалекти. Руският е също много близък, макар и да звучи много архаично!

Listen to Macedonian. It is almost the same

Same meaning.

If you had a little bit of exposure to serbians you would have understood more.

I agree :)

Good idea, thanks Edward 🖒

You could say for the every language family. Well, English diverged so much because of the Romanization period of the Frenches but still there are words that are almost the same as other Germanic languages like how ''water'' is the same in Dutch too but pronounced slightly differently.

I would understand both of these Stormrage! I guess you are right, if we speak slowly so I can also make sure I am hearing the words separately and not just like one sentence is one long word, then we will probably have a descent conversation! I wish I had a friend like this when I was back home and to be honest for the last 10 years that I`ve lived in the UK, I don`t remember meeting 1 Serbian person - even at uni where the mixture is usually from all over the place. It`s interesting you say this about your grandmother. Mine uses some Turkish words even though as far as we know we have no Turkish relatives but I guess in our region of Bulgaria there were enough Turskish people in the past to make some of their words stick (like with you unofficially of course).

@@thegroovygenes2772 I guess we all picked up some Turkish words. It is a normal thing when you live for 500 years under them. There are lots of them in Serbian, but so are Greek or French and more recent English. We use "dvoriste" more often then "avlija", second one is Turkish word. I wonder if you can understand either. I live in Belgrade and we speak standard Serbian here but my grandmother never lost her dialect so I learned some interesting phrases from that region from her. But dialect thing is dying off now. Younger people over there use more standardized words and only thing remaining is an accent.

Yes, true they influence is present and actually in certain parts of Bulgaria they are still present too. I think there are some villages where the population is predominantly Turskish people. I assume it's the same in Serbia?! I don't understand the Turkush word but the Serbian one sounds like our word for garden/land in our house premises which is 'dvor' (двор). Is it the same? Same in Bulgaria, dialects are dying off too and many young people make their way to the capital more and more so yes the language is being standardised there, too.

@@thegroovygenes2772 In Serbia not Turkish, just Muslim (Bosniak). But they are not using Turkish language but their culture is more influenced by Turks. And still it is minority living in south west around town of Novi Pazar. Yes, it is house yard. But dvor have slightly different meaning in Serbian, it means more like royal palace when you say it but roots must be same, house. For house we say kuca or dom (second must be from Latin, Domus).

@@thegroovygenes2772 speaking of dvor we use thing liek "dvoriti" that means to serve someone, you know to treat them as VIP.

Interesting experience SerbAtheirst :) I guess it is like a bit of a challenge in this situation. It would always be tempting to try to speak to someone in your own language (if they are similar in any way) to see how far you can get to in the conversation but also have the option of reverting back to English.

However ''енглески'' is called ''английски'' (англиjски)

@@HeroManNick132 važi

Seems Serbs taught you to say ''bugar'' and not ''bulgarin?'' 😂

From where she is from? If she is from Eastern part of the country, she would struggle more but if she is more from Western part of the country she would understand them better.

In Bulgarian we have ''voz'' as train but it's old-fashioned and we used ''vlak'' like Croatian. The Croatian ''mrkva'' is closer to the Bulgarian ''morkov'' I'm pretty sure ''Šargarepa'' is a Hungarian loan so that's why it's the difference. But I didn't know that ''kotlon, burkan'' are also from Hungarian origin that made into Bulgarian.

@@HeroManNick132 Interesting, on croatian Islands people often say "Mrkav" instead of "Mrkva" 🥕 also Interesting thing that alot of last names end with "Ov" like Petrov,Tomasov,Vlahov... Like in Bulgaria for example, even if most common ending in Croatia is "Ić" like Modrić for example.

@@stipe3124 In Bulgaria we have many variants but most commonly is ''OV/EV'' for man and ''OVA/EVA'' for women. We have on ''SKI'' for man and ''SKA'' for women like the ''Macedonians'' Even mixed ones like ''OVSKI/EVSKI'' and ''OVSKA/EVSKA'' Sometimes on ''ŠKI/ŠKA.'' The rarest ones are on ''IN/INA'' or ''SKIJ/SKAJA'' We even have some from Armenian origin like that ends on ''JAN'' But most common are on OV/EV and EV/EVA. Macedonians have a bonus on ''IḰ'' which are based of the Serbo-Croatian ''IĆ''

@@HeroManNick132 We have also many variants but there is no "Eva" for girls so it is Eva Petrov even if it is girl, it's not Petrova. We have alot German and Italian last names like Rossini, Rosi,Rošini or Schindelfeld.

@@stipe3124 And also forgot to mention that some people are like half Serbians or have a Serbian origin we write ''IĆ'' will the the same as the Slovenians ''IČ'' Macedonians replace it with ''IḰ'' because ''Ḱ'' is based of ''Ć'' while in Bulgarian there is no difference between ''Č'' and ''Ć'' we write the hard one because similar like Russian with ''Ž, Š, C'' never get soften we never soft ''Ž, Š, Č'' Usually ''Ć/Ḱ'' in Bulgarian are replaced with regular ''Č, K'' but most commonly ''ŠT'' Best example is the word ''house'' or ''I will'' BG - MK - RS kăšta - kuḱa - kuća šte/ke - ḱe - će Vučič - Vučiḱ - Vučić And so on.

''Овде'' is a dialect word here and not everyone knows it.

''Приятно е овде'' го има в някои диалекти също (исто). Но по-близко до българско ''Приятно е тук(а).'' - ''Приjатно jе ту.''

Смешно е как: аз моля - jа молим ние/ний молим - ми молимо

Интересно е как сте изменили ''молим,'' както на словенски: аз моля - jа молим (в някои диалекти имаме и ''я,'' но в стандартната форма е винаги ''аз'') ние/ний молим - ми молимо

@@HeroManNick132 Az is not Slavic though, Az is Bulgar, aka turkish. Ja is Slavic. But some old Serbian documents from middle ages use Az , probably dur to influence of Chrich Slavonic which was upper class language

@@macakucizmama831 Contrawise! In Proto Slavic it was ''(j)azъ'' so it's Slavic! Then why in Slovenian is ''jaz'' and in Macedonian is ''jas?'' Bulgarian is the only one who kept this form. Also can you stop with your propaganda? Seriously, this is why I hate the Serbs because of that and being chauvinistic about the North Macedonia dispute because you backstabbed us in front of your preference of Greece and Russia over us! We could have been the closest but you chose Greece and Russia instead, so yeah...

@@macakucizmama831 Also I in Turkish is ''ben'' I don't get it what do you mean that ''az'' and ''ben'' are the same thing? Seriously, just stop with the Turkic BS that teach you at school, then you'll ask why we can't get along! It's because of that! Bulgars have Persian roots, it's because Asian languages get mixed up. Like some people say that Tajik is a Turkic language, when it's actually Indo-European, Iranic! The irony is that Serbian uses more Ottoman Turkic words than Bulgarian which are from Arabic and Persian. Like for example we say ''час'' but you use ''сат'' which is not a Slavic word. We also have ''сахат/саат'' but these words are barely used nowadays for ''hour'' while you use it as common literature word. Also for spoon you use ''кашик'' which is another Ottoman Turkish word, while we use ''лъжица'' which is a Slavic word like how the Croats use ''жлица'' We have that word ''кашика'' but it's archaic. This is what I mean that your language is basically archaic version of Bulgarian.

@@HeroManNick132 well it wasn’t like that always, Russia was also working against Serbia by making big Bulgaria, after 2nd Balkan war Russia and Serbia become very close, which cost Serbs to lose half of modern Albania due to influence of a western powers. About Greeks, you were in both world wars on a bad side, Serbs lost 1/3 of a male Poland in ww1, Greeks helped us, Serbs were on recovery in Greece. Serbia did attacked Bulgaria in 1885. but it was Austrian interest, and king Miland had to attack to prevent oppression of Serbs north of Danube and Sava inside Austria.

you also can say in serbian tu je bash prijatno ovde or tu have the same meaning

''Овде'' го имаме и ние в някои западни диалекти.

@@TIMENIJATEBI ''Ovde'' is used in Western dialects mostly, while in Standard language we use ''tuk/tuka.'' ''Tu'' in Bulgarian has a different meaning and it's more likely a different usage like for comparing stuff like - ту черно, ту бяло.

''Ща'' и ние го имаме, както сърбите.

@@HeroManNick132 е да, ама при нас "ща" е по-скоро съкращение от "ще те". Оригиналната Славянска дума със значение какво "що" се е запазила във "защо", но накратко казваме " 'що" за защо. По-ни е интересно да знаем какъв, каква, какво е нещо, от колкото що е то. ;)

@@nikolayordanov3115 И разбира се ''защо'' е при тях абсолютно същото като нашето, но написано с ''шт," защото те нямат ''Щ.'' Даже то е по-близко от македонското ''зошто.'' ''Ща'' е по-скоро като ''искам,'' което за сърбите е архаична дума, както с тяхното им ''иштем.''

@@HeroManNick132 хмм, интересно. Те не казват ли "хтем" за искам? Имат и волим и жалим за искам. Но изглежда ти по-го разбираш сръбския.

@@nikolayordanov3115 Да имат, но от сърби бях чул, че имат ''искам/иштем,'' ала в днешно време са ги заменили с ''хоћу/хтем.'' ''Хоћу'' се произнася по същия начин като руското/украинското ''хочу'' (почти). СР - РУ - УК хочю - хачю - хочу ''Желим'' е точно като нашето ''желая.'' Интересно е как в почти всичките бивши югославски езици (освен македонския език) за първо лице, единствено число е някак си като нашето за първо лице, множествено число. Като например: летя - летим моля - молим летим - летимо молим - молимо В повечето славянски езици, даже в руския ''искаю'' означава ''търся,'' както при нас оттам е произходът на корената ''искам,'' която в по-остарелия си смисъл може да означава и това. ''Волим'' е по-скоро като ''сакам,'' което идва от италиански и се използва повече като ''обичам'' или както македонците използват ''сакам'' за искам и обичам.

I guess this girl is not a constant inhabitant of Bulgaria...Her language culture and vocabulary is poor.

С "полако" разбрах какво имат предвид, но не съм сигурна дали по пътя на логиката или съвпадение, заради близко звучене. Реших, че "полако" е като "плахо" = неуверено, боязливо, със страх. Когато изпитваш несигурност, вървиш бавно. Та оттам реших, че е нещо като "вървя с плахи/малки стъпки" = вървя бавно. Но това, което ти даде за пример има повече смисъл, отколкото откъдето аз изходих.

Имаме го ''ово'' също в някои западни диалекти, както и ''овде.'' По-близката дума до ''али'' е ''ала.'' Макар, че и ние имаме ''али/ал'' като диалектно за ''или.'' ''Када'' също го имаме в западните ни диалекти - тя е от санскрит.

I think it would be plaho i sigurno in bulgarian.

Ха, но тогава защо гледаме на сръбски с превод, както на руски, но не и на македонски?

​​​@@HeroManNick132you just sad, no why do we watch serbian translate, like in russian, but not like in maccedonian I got here and there in general I could guess and assume what you said and mean 😃😃😃

@@kname1882 Ти си отроден българин.

He might be Albanian. One never knows.

@@rightwingreactionary no he seems like a native serbski

Нямаш разлики между диктаторът Слободан Милошевич. Да не кажа как изкривихте думата ''свобода'' със ''слобода.''

More like Macedonian can be called strictly a Bulgarian dialect

@@jonathanivanov7070 Bulgarian is a dialect of Serbian, and Serbian is a dialect of Montenegrin.

@@mihanich How much Putin paid you?

@@HeroManNick132this comment costed Putin 2 lunches at McDonald's

@@mihanich You mean ''Вкусно и точка?'' I haven't heard of McDonalds before being in Russia. 😂

Funny how bulgaria is on the balkans before serbia but ok

Haha in your dreams

nije bas tako brate oni nemaju samo padeze i nas jezik je bio slican njihvom pre vukove reforme

@@janakolasinac1686 I understand that you are a Serbian chauvinist. 1. Turks and Mongols are different racially and linguistically. 2. The proto-Bulgarian language, probably from the Turkic group, disappeared more than 1000 years ago. 3. All Slavic languages derive from the common proto-Slavic language. 4. South Slavic languages are divided into two groups: Western (Serbo-Croatian) and Eastern (Bulgarian-Macedonian). The difference is mainly in the lack of grammatical case and the determinant in the eastern group. I see no reason to declare a language from the eastern group a dialect of a language from the western group. Croats, Montenegrins and Bosniaks (even in Serbia itself) from the Western group (almost identical to Serbian) do not consider their languages to be Serbian dialects.

When did these old Serbs convert to Bulgarians? Do you have evidence of ever expressing the Serbian ethnic sanity of the population on the territory of today's Bulgaria?

Unless if you count Albanian and Armenian which are isolated too.

@@HeroManNick132 Υes of course and not only those. There are other isolates too. Like the Basque language which unlike Greek, Albanian and Armenian, is not even indo-european in origin but it seems to be totally unrelated to any lingual family.

@@theo9952 We are talking about Indo-European languages not Non Indo-European ones.