Fields 2018 Ohio State team was 9th in the nation in total defense. Caleb’s 2023 USC team was 116th in the nation in total defense. In college Caleb was always on a worse team than Fields, yet his stats still smoke Fields. Caleb Williams: 37 games = 93 TD / 14 Int / 10,082 Yards / 169 Rating + Rushing: 966 Yards / 27 TD Justin Fields = 34 games = 67 TD / 9 Int / 5,701 Yards / 178 Rating + Rushing: 1,133 Yards / 19 TD Caleb Williams also played well against ranked teams: 12 games / 3,602 Pass Yds (300 per game) / 27 Pass TD / 8 INT / 66.7 completion pct / 9 Rush TD / 3 fumbles lost. Most of those losses came from the defense not knowing how to tackle or cover routes. Caleb can’t play offense AND defense. There is a reason why people have been comparing Caleb to Mahomes. I have watched all of Caleb’s USC games except for about 4, and it is easy to see why. They have seen him make all those crazy Mahomes throws. We can watch them right here on KZfaq. We don’t need to watch full games because they have already been documented on video. Caleb’s ability to make accurate, off platform throws - combined with his ability to escape tackles - is what makes him fun to watch. Draft him or don’t draft him - just don’t let the Patriots get him. Don’t let the Patriots back in the playoffs.

It's funny we they say dynamic running game when the QB led the team in rushing

never thought i'd hear greeny say "that good good" it's not even 9 am and my day is already made LOL

Somebody other than Fields

Key thing for me that was Riddick said that stuck out is Williams struggled behind a bad line not being able to throw in rhythm....as a Bears fan guess what we watched Fields running for his life behind a bad line

Greeny has been on point on several fronts. Mahomes was a 3-star coming out of HS. He literally didn't get a reputable scholarship offer outside of Texas, so he signed with T-Tech. Nobody scouted Mahomes for the draft. The Chiefs GM found him and guess who Mahomes talked to first...Matt Nagy😂 Yeah the coach the Bears fired but kept Flus. Go check out that Mahomes vs Baker game...Oklahoma vs Texas Tech. Baker was a BALLER with a cannon of an arm. Awesome game. Fact is regardless of who they draft, nobody knows. Mahomes would NOT be 3x SB champion on the Bears because they aren't the Chiefs. He sat behind a back-to-back Pro Bowl QB in Alex Smith. Fields was thrown to the wolves because Nagy was forced to play him early. Bears fans are neurotic. But for Fields sake, I hope they trade him to the Steelers or Falcons where the coaches and city have seen him, want and love him. And fyi, Burrow has only lost to Mahomes once. Both Fields and Caleb will do well but Mahomes is 1 of 1. Stop being clowns.

Keep fields draft marv jr.

NFL scouts drool over QBs so much to the point where we see a “once in a lifetime talent” every year at the draft in that position… the NFL, its fans, scouts, etc has this unhealthy obsession and impatience of the QB, and this is detrimental to the league and developing players… if the Bears a team I loved since I was a child give up on Fields and decide to draft Williams, I’m a say this… it shows a level of arrogance by the front office thinking he’s not good enough, when in all actuality they threw him under the bus (like Riddick said at the 3:40 mark), when the front office failed to not only surround him with a good line, not only failed to provide him with viable coaching on the offensive side… I see players like Mayfield (Swagu said it best at the 5:00 mark about Baker) and Geno Smith doing well in their situations this season shows me that situation is everything and if I’m an outsider looking in, like what makes me think that trading Fields and getting Williams the same s**t isn’t going to happen with Williams?! Fields never had a real shot and he’s been accountable, he’s been improving, he increased his QBR by 11 points after his injury, they don’t have the #1 pick because this team absolutely sucked, they have it because of Carolina’s arrogance thinking they’ll be better and was willing to trade for a QB with a shitty infrastructure… and the Bears with their record without Carolina’s pick were a seven win team that could’ve very well been a ten win team if they didn’t blow games against Denver, their first game against Detroit and maybe either the first Minnesota game or New Orleans The only reason you let go of Fields is because of Money, plain and simple… that’s the only reason… which if Caleb is good (which is a possibility but I Don’t TRUST IT), you’re going to have to pay him 55-60 million a year with the way contracts are looking to be by the time the 2027-2028 seasons pass… in hindsight, Fields’ contract would be cheaper long term… Also… there’s something that Mike Lombardi said, the essential element of team building starts with an O-Line and D-Line cause that provides security… what were the common core of our recent conference champions heading into the Super Bowl?!? Continuity on both lines… Chicago could fix the interiors for both lines, actually get Fields one more piece for a WR2, maybe a second tight end, and get a Middle Linebacker… If Chicago does the same thing with Williams, it will screw him up… and this front office arrogance is showing right now at its worst

On that Good good 😂😂😂

On that good good 🤣 I love when these old guys gotta talk about gas

4:10 😂😂😂😂😂😂greeny said that "good good"

Where was all these draft gurus when Mahomes was in college? Nobody was drooling over him but everybody is so sure about Caleb 😂🥱

so if Justin wasn't setup to succeed if we do draft CW instead of building the team we're doing the same thing to him (this is literally the definition of insanity - repeating the same process and expecting a different result)! This entire situation would be idiotic if the bears drafted CW!

Keep Fields , better and competent coaching, real play scheme around JF and the rest of players on this team. A real offensive play book. Keep building more talent on this Chicago Bears team Nobody plays hard like Justin and took in stride the bad coaching and less talent on this team for 3 years. Justin is talented and a tough dude to face the pressures of failing seasons.

Ppl keep acting like Mahomes isn’t special when they say Caleb can do things like him in the NFL.

Bears should sign Flacco or Tannehil to 1-2 year deal! Draft Caleb, trade fields for a 2nd or 3rd. Build OL and skill positions through draft an free agency. After a year or two start Caleb when he is ready and team is built up

Bears should just get a wr first stack up the offence so nobody can give fields an excuse then if you get rid of Justin fields you’ll already have the weapons to make the transition easier if you get a vet

Wizards GM Troy Weaver, former Asst. GM to Sam Presti in OKC, was asked about their draft process after looking back at the all the MVPs that the Thunder picked. He said, "pick the person; not the player. If they're a hard worker, team-oriented, competitive, and focused on the field, that's the guy you want - even over someone you think is more talented." Trade Williams for a historic haul, Ryan... the red flags here are crimson

It won’t be the same situation tho , u have a number 1 wide out and top 5 te and a top 5 defense with a lot of cap space to add to the team with a qb on a rookie contract not the same

As a bears fan I want Justin fields as QB1 next season. Even if Caleb is as good as advertised, I still believe in the talent of Justin fields. Fields also has the support from the locker room, understands our division rivals and he plays good in cold weather.

How many times do you except the Bears to constantly change QBs and expect and think they're going to become a better team? What's to stop the Bears from doing this same thing to Caleb Williams 3 years from now if he doesn't pan out? They may reset on the QB again on Caleb. Well, if the Bears do draft him, they better win at least 10 games, no less than 8, or they would have taking another step back, again.

😂😂😂 espn is so savage now. I love it

What Happened to Malik Willis and all those QB's from last year's NFL Draft?

That’s the best point made. Since the bears hold an extra pick, why not reset the clock on the financial side and build with your original 9th pick. Actually invest in your qb by his third seasons meaning trading draft capital, spending money in free agency. If that’s the way you would like to build your team. I wouldn’t.

Bear are sick of the flack from not taking Mahomes, they won't repeat that same mistake with Caleb

We appreciate Greeny STOMPIN" for Justin Fields! Greeny made some interesting points about when Justin & OSU played against Clemson & about Justin being a Throwing QB @ OSU. I kinda want The Bears to keep him & be smart & build around Justin. BUT if they do the stupid thing & trade Justin, I hope he lands in Atlanta or Pittsburg & wins a Super Bowl in 2 years.

It’s funny because Ryan has never hinted on anything except for he wants to see Justin as part of the future and he said at the end that but we have to do our due diligence and at least consider that I thought because that’s what you’re supposed to do as a GM. But that’s it. He never once said you know just needs to be this if you blah blah blah. And I don’t think Justin is going anywhere because he’s not talking about anything, he’s not packing his bags. And again, it makes no sense to put two years of developing Justin, two years of drafting players to put around him, talking about the right type of offensive lineman that can move, our athletic, guys who can keep up with zone runs and Justin Fields tendency to takeoff and run. If you watch Josh Allen, sure he looks pretty good running but a bit stiff. Lamar Jackson, sure he’s very fluid he moves well but he also has some awkwardness to his step he’s not graceful and he will more than often get injured every year. And although his talent as a passer is definitely better and he’s making much better decisions, I don’t know if he’s ever going to win a Super Bowl I think he’s hit his ceiling but who knows you never know. Is that because he doesn’t have enough guys around him? possibly. But I don’t think he’s done trying. Jared Goff has resurrected his career, he’s gotten to play in the Super Bowl twice… Not bad for six year? Player a guy who was not supposed to start again on another team, another throw away and yet now he’s the main man in Detroit and is really great. So people need to understand that even guys with the lower ceiling, you know not athletic, but has the right size, tall more like Tom Brady. Those guys succeeded in the NFL because they have a great blocking upfront. He’s in a good situation and he could probably get to a Super Bowl that’s not impossible. But because it is where the ability to your legs are so important, and guys are just fields are going to be more prevalent in the next three years or so. I still think guys like Justin and other quarterbacks like Anthony Richardson, that could be the next wave because Patrick Mahomes has that ability, he’s much like Aaron Rodgers except a bit better. And Justin Fields is probably one of the best if not the best runner with the ball if you wanna talk about a player/quarterback who has a little bit of everything in his running game and doesn’t make you cringe when he wants to lower his shoulder and attack. I love that. He’s tough as nails. And I don’t think she’s going to be so easily to injure plus he’s taking less direct hits. But every now and then I don’t have a problem with that I think that’s awesome. Josh Allen constantly does that he’s not injured more often than Lamar Jackson so I don’t know, it’s just size and build. What about Caleb? How often is he going to be injured? He could be exactly like Griffin RG three was a very similar player talent, is a little taller but all the same qualities mobility athleticism can throw the ball anywhere.but he’s got to be careful so perhaps he’s going to be more like him than Justin Fields… The guy he is compared to.

As a packers fan I’m praying that the bears keep fields. It’s been 3 years now. His best games came against some historically bad defenses. And his team wasn’t bad. The defense was awesome for a lot of the season, the o line actually was middle of the pack and performed better with Bagent at QB, and you can do much much worse than DJ Moore, Cole Kmet, Darnell Mooney (who btw has a bad rap because anytime he’s targeted Fields airmails him), Khalil Herbert, and Roshon Johnson. Kyler Murray was in a worse situation all around and looked better coming off an ACL.

Go look at the last three qb draft classes and tell me why Chicago should take Caleb. Definitely a great talent but Chicago has enough capital and cap space to make an environment that is much better for Fields to perform. Then if that doesn’t work out, at least they have a better team because of the picks

Draft Caleb Trade JF1 and the 9th pick to the Patriots or Washington for their pick Draft MHJr

Ah SH*T. If Louis Riddick says Justin Fields will be traded usually means Justin Fields will remain a Chicago Bear. And I wanted to see the Bears draft Caleb Williams. #confidentlywrong

They might do that, San Diego chargers did it with drew Bree’s and Phillip rivers, until drew hurt his arm and eventual was traded to the saints

How is this even a question ?. Lamar, Burrow, Herbert, Allen and Lawrence are all better QB’s and none of them have been able to get past Mahomes to get to a SB. Burrow is currently the only QB who can beat him and even he hasn’t been able to win it all. Why would you keep Fields who isn’t even half as good as the guys I listed when you can take a dude at one who is a much better prospect and will be in his first year of a rookie contract

fields is the dynamic running game

I wonder if these people even watched Caleb and not just highlights, he consistently holds on to the ball for approx 5 seconds

What kind of package would the Falcons or the Steelers offer for Fields.

Dak doesn’t show up in big moments. Dallas should draft a viable replacement to sit the bench and learn the game for a season or two.

i would only argue that thru 1 season at oklahoma people said similar things about spencer rattler before he lost the job to caleb. I think some of the success is because of the coach.

I’m old enough to remember my Jets wanted to “restart the qb clock” by drafting Wilson instead of flipping that pick to the niners. It didn’t turn out so good. Keep fields, get a haul for the draft pick… they’ll always be another “generational QB” in next years draft.

Let Fields play and trade the pick for a multiple 1st rd picks. Use their own pick and trade it to SF for Aiyuk you get a wr1 without risk drafting a bust at wr

At the end of the day I’m happy either way. Draft Caleb and pray coaching can help develop him into the stud he looks like. Or Trade to 2 get a haul for the hometown kid. Draft MHJ acquire as many picks as possible maybe even trading back to 3 if possible. Fields was always QB 2 in that draft hasn’t been able to take the year 3 jump everyone expected, but if he’ll be cheap money in the future, we’ll have cap money and a chance to draft 3-5 starters every year for the next 2-3 years. So what I’m saying as a Bears fan. We’ll trade to 2, take Maye and keep fields

You know the sports media pisses me off a lot but I gotta say I appreciate them talking up Caleb and JF1 both a lot. Bears won't be able to go wrong with this draft. Both will have high value if these teams listen to the media at all lol

That good good 😂

What funny is nobody is going to give Chicago a high draft pick for fields because they know if they want Caleb they got no choice but to get rid of Fields and if Bears let him go it want be for nothing higher then a 3rd. I bet any amount of money on it.

Chicago has been debating this move all season. That alone tells you where the real problem is.

I’m praying fields get up out of there at this point stop playing with that man career Chicago And boosting these college dudes and haven’t played in the big leagues is wild 😂

That why u get extra draft picks and build the team the right way one player can not win a super bowl this kid is caleb not pat Mahomes so stop with the comparisons

I'd keep Fields and build around him. Williams is really good....but the NFL is faster and will keep him contained..and limit his use to just his arm in windy Chicago. He'd be a great fit in Vegas...for his talent and personaiity.

Russell Wilson don’t have a Raider bone in his body we’re good 🏴‍☠️

That “dynamic running game” will be average without Fields.

To me, the cowboys are in the sam situation as the ravens They have no choice but to pay their QB. Because they give them the best chance in the regular season. But come playoffs. Hold your breath everyone, these boys have major anxiety breakdowns and can't complete throws or run for first downs. They need the best defense in the league that can take the ball from the opposing offense and score the touchdowns.

Bears need to keep Fields period point blank. Build around him and Bears are instantly in the running. Williams is still a wildcard, we know what Fields is.

The only people I have ever heard mention"resetting the clock" have been TV commentators. Teams don't worry about resetting the financial clock if they believe they have the right guy in place. They've already tried resetting the clock twice and are in the same position. So doing the same thing and expecting something different is never successful. What has been proven successful in building championship level teams is getting multiple highly talented players on your roster. Getting multiple first and second rounds picks would be the best way to obtain that knid of talent.

I could be wrong. BUT I dont like the reset the clock argument. Caleb Williams will cost more than JF1. CW will make close to 4yrs 40 mil with a 5th year option between 30-40 mil (5yrs 80mil) JF1 is on a 4yr 18mil contract w 22 mil 5th year option (5yrs 40mil). CW second contract WILL be 60 mil per year. Josh allen got 43 mil in 2021, J Burrow got 55 mil last year. Dak, J LOVE, Tua, are all going to want 50 mil per year. By the time CW enters his second contract 60 mil will be the going rate. I think you can get JF1 4-5yr around 40-45mil, so all in all, JF1 10 yrs 260 mil. CW(10yrs 380 mil)

Bears passed up on CJ Stroud in 2023 draft. Let’s see if they pass on Caleb Williams in 2024 draft.

Justin is in the right place now.

The Bears hold all the marbles. They can keep Fields and Draft Calib Williams and if Fields ends up a better pro then the Bears have Calib Williams to trade also. It doesn't necessarily mean Fields is holding anything down for Calib if Fields is better than Calib then Calib will be the one traded or even released if he doesn't adopt to the NFL.

Reset for the bears is outrageous

Caleb aint MJ, but this is like Portland debating to draft MJ, since they already had Drexler.... if you make the wrong move you'll never stop hearing the What ifs?

The Bears are in a great position this offseason There is no question that Caleb is replacing Fields And having another Top 10 pick, they can grab him on of the the best LT in the draft Plus they have all the cap space in the world

"On that good good" Greeny is my favorite white guy 💯😂😂☠️☠️

Keep Fields Build around him! DJ and Kmet and coaching staff and the Fans believe in him!

Dear My Steelers, give the bears what they want and get Fields

Chicago should work on that o-line before they add another great QB. Just my opinion.

Every other team in the division is getting better and moving forward while the Bears continue to stay less than mediocre and dwell in the NFC North cellar. He better come in and DOMINATE FROM DAY ONE! If not, all of this hype would have been for nothing. I don't want to hear that he needs "development" and he needs to "catch with the NFL speed" because with all of the type, he must be NFL ready already.

I hate how in the modern NFL these analysts get so enamored by “an athlete who can play qb” which is just another way of saying a black qb who can run. I’d rather take “a qb who can be athletic”. The fact of the matter is to be a long term success in the nfl I want a guy who can make a throw over a guy who primarily relies on his legs. That’s what running backs are for.

Greeny is right

Watch Poles trade down and extend JF this year to a team friendly deal. 3 year $50-60m

Keep Justin and Draft Bo Nix or Rattler if you want to go that route. I agree that Caleb needs to sit 1 year. Actually I think all of the QB’s in this draft need to sit and learn and it would benefit all of them the most. There is a reason that GB still does it and it works. Jordan Love is proof. He isn’t even that great but you put him in th oven for 3 years and BAM playoff QB

Lou said you didn’t see enough out of Caleb because of bad O-line which Justin didn’t also have, Caleb is a deadly fast runner out the pocket, justin is deadly out the pocket in league not college ✋🏽 STOP THIS they are both similar I’ve seen this for two years the media wants to control Justin’s narrative where he should go and make contract an issue they will pay him

i had to stop taking the segment seriously when Riddick talked about Caleb getting out of the pocket and "destroying pursuit angles" Caleb is nowhere near as strong or fast as Field, let alone the fastest guy on the field. he gets tracked down every play whether he scores or not, and these are college kids. in the league everybody can run you down. the college stats are comparable. and let's not all forget Fields played the COVID year and only had half a season.

Hopefully they don't BEARS this up and pass on a QB again. Time to move on from Justin Williams is a clear upgrade

trade back twice.. get Brock Bowers.. Watching tape, he looks like he has a chance on being the best TE ever.. trade ones with cardinals for they no.2 let them take MHJ cuz we dont need a Diva no1 we have More so Rome should be there at 9 and is NIIIIICE!! Use on of the 2's for Jackson Powers the Center.. AND.. Tell me if I am crazy, but did anyone see the plays with Velus coming out of the Backfield??? I thought I was watching Pacheinko from KC!! Move him to a rotational RB and our offense would be TOP NOTCH!! dont judge me on the name spelling..lol

The worst Caleb Williams can be is another Justin Fields. Even if he’s mid tier I bet he throws more in one season than Justin has. And at Best he can beat the guy that just won the Super Bowl.

Comparing him to Mahomes is just stupid. Mahomes has a stable coach with Andy Reid. The last stable coach the Bears had was Mike Ditka, which makes since. The Bears are stuck trying to recreate 85. If the Bears let Fields go, that would be one of the WORST moves they every made.

No Marcus, we DO HAVE TO JUDGE HIM by his playoff performances... he's saying as if playoff doesnt mean anything to the team LOL

BY YEAR 3 .. CALEB WILLIAMS WILL BE A SUPERSTAR/FRANCHISE/MVP CALIBER QB ..

Imo I would draft marvin Harrison give fields dj Moore and marvin Harrison 2 weapons if it don't work then draft a qb next year

JF1 to ATL PLEASE!! 🙏🏾 🙏🏾

draft Marv Jr and Brock Bowers...Improve around Fields

Bears can trade back 1 spot and get a haul, keep fields and still draft Marvin. You basically can revamp your entire team instead of hoping williams will be a star.

Justin Fields is the best quarterback in the entire NFL.

If Justin Fields and Caleb Williams were in this same draft together as prospects who would you take Bears fans? Leave your delusions the pick is CW13

I agree with Jeff Saturday. Caleb Williams is Listed at 6-1, which means 5-11&1/2, which is short in the NFL. He has daddy issues, a red flag. Also, there seems to be other behavioral issues lurking in the background. Stay away, stay far away, and let another team make the sucker move. Keep Fields, get the picks, and if Fields doesn't work out, you can trade him next year for more picks. Quarterback hype this time of year is deafening. Stop the noise, take the picks, and guess what, there is always another one next year.

Fields WILL be the starting QB for the Bears in 2024.

Caleb Williams had 83 sacks and he HATES Chicago, so why draft a player who does not want to play for you because #2 is his hometown team with his former coach from USC on board. Swap spots with Washington for 3 First round draft picks. They can swap again for more draft picks and get Marvin Jr. and some more protection for Justin Fields.

This could be like drew brees Philip rivers/ Eli manning

Jeff Saturday is annoying, Ryan Poles and Kevin Warren have nothing to do with drafting Trubisky or Fields, they have a right to draft their QB.

Caleb wants to play for DC, why is the media pushing for him to goto Chicago?

Both are talented. Caleb has arm talent, Justin has a different kind of arm talent. I think the intangibles will matter. The organization seems to really like Justin, his teammates too. Not the same, but Watson tanked the Brown’s culture. If the Bears trust Caleb’s leadership then I can live with that. But making the decision on all factors, I’d stay.

fileds gets so much leeway its unreal on to the next 2.5k yards season XD

They making this video just for bears not drafting Caleb 😂😂

College speed isn’t nfl speed

Being the Alex smith to Patrick Mahomes.

I hope they trade Fields and he goes and gets to the play offs while the bears will get another top5 pick for another 3 years straight haha

Keep Fields and draft Marvin Harrison jr

I can’t wait for the bears to draft the next greatest QB in 5 years.

Bears fans are failing to realize BOTH choices are good. Keep fields and trade back for a haul, GOOD. Take Caleb, GOOD. Great time to be a bears fan man sit back and let poles cook. 🐻⬇️

Justin Fields has 40 TDs and 30 INTs in 3 years, has never reached 3,000 passing yards in a season, never thrown 20 TDs in a season, never had a completion % rating over 62%. Who's highest QBR in a season was 56.3... what is there to hold onto? Blame the coaches, players and front office all you want, those numbers do not lie. Nobody knows if Caleb Williams will be better, or Maye or Daniels depending where Chicago goes at QB, but Fields is out of Chicago. Make no mistake, Fields ability to run with the football exaggerates how people evaluate his game, as he's spectacular running with the football. But as a QB his lack of arm talent and inability to execute in the passing game is factually below average. What the Bears must consider is whether they think Fields is worth $35 million per year or even more.

Williams should go to the Commanders how many chances do the bears need 🤦🏽‍♂️