Can China Beat America? the crisis of the U.S. Navy

Рет қаралды 31,919

7 ай бұрын

It was produced as a battle video by referring to the CSIS war game results published in the media.
This is the first of the four videos.
CSIS War Game Scenario PART 1
This video was produced using ARMA 3, DCS WORLD, and COLD WATERS.

Пікірлер: 26

@travismcneese9867 6 ай бұрын

Nope, the US Navy has way to many Carrier Strike Groups, Nuclear Submarines & Aircraft to over come. Plus not to mention all its Allies would be assisting them. It wouldn't be in China's favor, as the US Navy is very very very well experienced. While China's Military experience is only practiced to attack a non threat. Not a actual very well experienced Navy. As all of US, NATO & Allies have been in War for decades & real world experience & are experts. US, NATO & all its Allies have military bases all over the entire World. It would actually be a lost cause to even try. Lets all just NOT have a World War. For the rest of the Planet sake. Its better for everyone to just be friends & work together to make this Workd a better place for everybody ❤️💯%

@stuartemmanuel3735 Ай бұрын

This belongs in a modern day fiction novel, but reality is cruel every empire falls and the US is not the exception

@josue123454 3 сағат бұрын

And. The Japan all the fleet in pear harbor all is possible

@maxlin3442 7 ай бұрын

Taiwan has 1000+ shore based supersonic and subsonic AntiShip Missiles, and its fleet would not likely going to be going head to head with the chinese navy anyways

@milsimk 7 ай бұрын

In CSIS's Wargame, Taiwan's navy is initially wiped out, and Taiwanese missiles damage about two to three of the Chinese ships. And Taiwan's submarines destroyed some of the Chinese ships.

@user-xm9do4vl2j 7 ай бұрын

🔥🔥🔥 just finding your page deff got a new sub!! Keep killing it man!!... Bs. What software are you using to make these videos??? Lol always wanted to try n make video like this but never new the software needed

@user-kn2jm2wt5n 7 ай бұрын

Cool!

@1947_gout_key_d_lai 7 ай бұрын

Great video! The dialogues accurately convey the meaning, but the phrasing is different from native speech. If you need more material for creating videos on the topic of the Taiwan-China conflict, here's a little secret that everyone in Taiwan knows but no one wants to talk about. In the event of an invasion, half of Taiwan's troops are likely to betray the island, as many officers are not de facto Taiwanese. Their families fled to Taiwan with their tails between their legs in 1949 when the Nationalist Chinese were losing the civil war to the Communist Chinese. Over time, these Chinese refugees no longer see their former foes as enemies but as allies, the allies who can help them maintain their position in Taiwan's ruling class. Before the influx of Chinese refugees into Taiwan, they sent troops to massacre Taiwanese in 1947, an event followed by decades of the so-called White Terror. From then on, the Chinese became the ruling class on the island. However, after a Taiwanese individual accidentally became the President, they began seeking help from their old foes, the Communist Chinese. They are now very pro-China. When I was serving in the military, I noticed that most of the officers were Chinese. Like many colonial regimes throughout history, the majority of the military personnel are the invaders. The U.S. government is obviously aware of this situation, so they have never sold us top-tier weapons like the F-35. The best we can get is the F-16. While not top-tier, these weapons are sufficient to sink Chinese ships. No one in the world understands Chinese methods better than Taiwanese. Believe me, the Chinese are only good at bluffing and manufacturing counterfeit products. They will undoubtedly be defeated, but only if Taiwan's troops don't betray their paymasters. Xi Jinping considers Taiwan an easy target due to the low loyalty of Taiwan's troops.

@milsimk 7 ай бұрын

Oh my god! I also knew some of the fact that Taiwanese officers act like Chinese spies. But I read your article and it seems more serious than I thought. In my previous video, the same situation as you said is described. Attach the link below. Please write down your thoughts after watching the video. kzfaq.info/get/bejne/lb6moNZhla_RpKs.html

@1947_gout_key_d_lai 6 ай бұрын

@@milsimk In the video they defect when they see Chinese winning, but more likely that they will defect at the beginning of the invasion, and the number will be far more bigger than just an officer. When I was in compulsory service, the Chinese officers didn't even try to hide their intention. They are too lazy to do their jobs. They spend all day talking bad about President Lee and President Chen, both of whom are Taiwanese. They said they would surrender to their commie cousins in the second when the war began. It's like a sport to them, competing to betray Taiwan. They are not shy about expressing their intentions publicly. My unit had more senior officers than the field troops had. The higher their rank, the more likely they are Chinese and have zero loyalty to Taiwan. To them, joining the army is just a job. It's a bit like a family business. Their parents asked them to go to military schools and engage in military jobs after graduation. Because they are the ruling class, they make these jobs pay higher than others, considering they don't have any skills. In contrast, Taiwanese generally don't want our children to join the military because serving in this corrupt system means being worthless. We used to look down on military personnel, but this atmosphere is changing. The Chinese are taking their advantage of the mainstream media to praise the military, creating the illusion that those traitor-wanna-be cowards are as great as the US military. Yes, the Chinese on our island are stealing the image of the US military, despite of the fact that the US troops have been protecting Americans and ROC troops had been massacring Taiwanese. They even boasted that their families were the protectors who prevented Taiwan from becoming a communist country, even though they were unable to protect themselves and had to flee to Taiwan. It is the Taiwan Straits and the US government that protect Taiwan. Most comments like this one would be deleted if I was writing in Mandarin on Taiwanese websites. We are not allowed to talk about racial conflict in Taiwan. If you do this, the mainstream media will catch you and ruin your life. A few years ago, a female netizen made a video saying that the Chinese who fled to Taiwan were "refugees". Although it's truth, it caused an uproar. The mainstream media viciously attacked her and harassed her families, colleagues and neighbors. The poor woman had to move to a remote village and change her name. In Taiwan, Chinese refugees call themselves "honorary citizen", a title under which they enjoy better social welfare than Taiwanese. They basically don't have to work. Although we're not allowed to talk openly about ethnic conflicts, I have seen many times on the Internet recently that people said that as soon as the war started, they would first eliminate those pro-China traitors. Chinese refugees amount for about 12% of Taiwan's population. They are the ruling class. Many important companies, such as TSMC, are under their control. However, the workers, engineers in various fields are Taiwanese, including low rank soldiers. When we have to put everything on the table, we don't know who is going to win.

@marvinsamson7376 7 ай бұрын

No america have many allies

@captabhimanyubhat Ай бұрын

Asians do not believe in the term as allies we in the establishment and government thinks US is our enemy very equal to China because US has that infiltration that China does not have you provide huge money to the radical Islamic group within India

@soemoethu-tk4mp Ай бұрын

definitely

@johnusher2331 5 ай бұрын

Can china beat usa no they have no nuclear aircraft carrier can they defend yes but an attack on usa land is out of question

@shaun469 Ай бұрын

Do they want to attack us land?

@christophersteele4902 2 ай бұрын

China has all these "awesome weapons and ships", yet they have less experience than Russia and look where that cluster screw is currently at. the first week might be theirs, but landing on Taiwan will mot be easy/ A whole bunch of China's ships. planes, sailors and soldiers will be at the bottom of the Taiwan strait. After the Straits of Malacca are closed to Chinese Shipping and trade the advantage reverts completely to the USA.

@MiG-31893 7 ай бұрын

🇯🇵🇯🇵🎌🎌

@user-fu9vj9ix3g 5 ай бұрын

This fits my theory on what a Chinese attack on Taiwan would look like. China is not yet the equal of the US navy, but they don't need to be. They only need to be first to strike Taiwan and then dare the US and Japan to intervene - while aiming missiles at Japan's shipping infrastructure and bases, along with aiming at Guam and Okinawa. CHina also holds the chain that prevents N.korea from attacking S. Korea. Also, even though the US has 11 carriers, there are only seven or eight at sea at any given time. The others are in re-fitting and repair. The US navy does not possess enough surface combat ships to sortie 11 carrier battle groups at a time. Some of those are also in for re-fit. If the US sends a fleet, it would at most be just one carrier battle group, with another sent from the Indian Ocean - five days away. It is possible there is one off Korea, but that group would be frozen in place with the Chinese threat of releasing N.Korea. IMO, the US will be pressured by Japan and S. Korea to stand down, letting Taiwan go - rather than see the two most important economc allies of the US get destroyed. IF the US does not stand down, and launches missiles, there is the very real possibilty that the US could lose that one carrier group, and Japan could also lose it's new navy. China would also suffer huge naval loses as well as damage to its land defense. Howver, China is well prepared to manufacture munitions whereas the US is not. In the initial three days of the conflict, the US would run out of munitions and have to re-supply by sea - while fighting off air attacks and attempting to avoid submarines. China can return to shore to resupply, and has thousands of high quality missile sights thatwould survive American long range attacks. And, Guam and Okinawa would be smoking ruins. China might even hit Thailand to take out US air assets there. Poeple forget that the US does not concentrate air defense at thier bases in great numbers - preferring to deply those assets forward-on ships. AFTERMATH; If the US stands down: Taiwan becomes part of China. Japan and S.Korea come under tremendous pressure to become client states of China, since China now controls all trade routes in the Near Pacific/Malacca Straits. Australias and Philipines are forced to declare neutrality. Vietnam now lives in mortal fear. The entire world balance of trade will shift to Chinas advantage. Japan and S.Korea ask the US to leave their countries, and the US retreats to Guam and Pearl Harbor, and will no longer sail l its ships past the Inner Island Chain. In order to get to the Suez, it will have to sail south of Indonesia. India will become more defensive of China and will begin to invest in more weapons - especially nukes. If the US does not stand down: War will destroy Japan and S.Korea - and Taiwan. Possibly at least one American carrier group will be sunk or nuetralized - unable to re-arm fast enough at sea. The second carrier group will not arrive in time. All other above scenarios apply. There is no computer modeling that shows a clear US victory in a battle for Taiwan. China can take the losses better than the US. Short supply lines, many more facilities for logistics, and a short strike distance to gain enough of a foot hold to cause a surrender of Taiwan before America has enough power in the area to make it worth the fight to take Taiwan back. The best thing Taiwan can do is move all those microchip workers and engineers to the US and as much machinery and production equipment as they can with them while there's still time. Destroy the rest on the way out. Just an opinion, but one that has a lot of think tank support.

@Triggatra4258 5 ай бұрын

Oh you're part of a global think tank?? Ok we'll all trust your every word and fear China. SIKE IT'S USA BITXHHHHH 🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲

@itzyaboimemez2074 2 ай бұрын

I kinda agree on your statement. However, one problem is that the US can easily mobilize and counter any Chinese attack fron any angle. We already know the US knows because of the intel leak months (a year?) ago. Also, China would also suffer more because of both incompetency and inexperience as well as the questionable effectiveness of their equipment. I can still see China invading Taiwan but they will suffer more casualties than what the CSIS can think off. However, that's just what I can go off of with how China takes its operations and how they respond vs how the US can respond and do their operations. In the international scene, I can see South Korea doing it but Japan would be supporting the US, especially how large of a percentage the Japanese population does support the US. In the air defense, the US defends their bases with a few Patriot SAMs and CRAMs, maybe even a few MANPADs. Adding to the defense are powerful ground-based radsr systems that the US use for base defense. Also adding to that are AWACS and C&C aircraft. But, again, both the CSIS and basically everyone are still in the dark when it comes to US equipment capabilities. We only saw a small portion in Ukraine. So, in my opinion, we should look at what the CSIS produces with a grain of salt and keep on speculating as the CSIS, from what I can see from their war simulations, do not expect any unpredictability of any side doing unpredictable moves.