I think this whole scene would've been a bit better if they failed crucio the first couple of times because they didn't want to hurt each other.

I was so heartbroken that Sebastian didn't even argue over using the spell on us. And then he just moves on quickly without even making sure that we're totally fine? Yep. Heartbroken.

"Never let them know your next move" *casts it on ominus*

Writhing in agony on the floor. Sebastian 👁👄👁 aRe YoU aLrIgHt?

somehow "You're my friend and I don't want to torture you, I can take the pain cast it on me. Oh, but I'd still love to learn how to torture people for my own use" feels like a much darker choice than just casting it on Sebastien.

Bruh why is Ominis the only one who sounds appropriately concerned in this scene? Sebastian and MC are both just kinda blase about the whole thing, when either of them cast it they look worried for like five seconds and then get over it. It's a bit disappointing, especially considering Seb is supposed to be our best friend or something, I mean he's the one we do the most quests with. I guess this is just another reason why Ominis was always my favorite from the start, lol.

To think, the beginning of this quest literally made you believe you were going into the chamber of secrets

I feel really bad for Ominus throughout the game. It just feels like, Sebastian and Ominus were such good friends, but when the MC walks into the picture, Sebastian is pretty ready and willing to betray his old friend and tell all his secrets to gain the confidence of someone who he sees as being a more useful ally. Seriously though, Sebastian is willing to keep Ominus’ secrets until it benefits himself. Would it have hurt him to have asked permission of Ominus before telling them about the undercroft? And Ominus isn’t stupid, like he says here, of course Sebastian had told the MC about his very personal very painful experience with his family and the curse. What a betrayal of friendship. I really don’t blame him for being hurt by it all. And if Sebastian is so willing to betray Ominus for his own benefit, at what point would he be willing to betray the MC to benefit himself?

Interesting how Sebastian will ask if you're okay after casting it on you, but when you do it, you don't even ask if he's okay ahahaha (and Ominus, a sweetheart checks on the inflicted regardless on who it was)

Sebastian is writhing and grunting on the floor a LOT longer than the MC, lol. Our boy fully got laid out. I thought it'd be a lot worse, honestly. our elbows didn't even hit the ground. MC took it like a CHAMP. Fell to our knees for 13 seconds then pushed right back up off the ground, looking like I just got punched during a period cramp. Not great but given this curse is _unforgivable,_ I'd be expecting worse. I'll take it as Sebastian not really wanting to hurt us all that much, and MC's being a little more intense because they've slain SO MANY ENEMIES by this point, _the bloodthirst shall not be quenched._ (My bloodthirst is nothing compaired to my BF playing this. I just hear him saying "Knee High, Gotta Die!" and the screams of Ranrok's forces.)

the fucking joy and happy expression of the MC while learning the unforgivable curses. awh man how I wish they did more details and put more effort into writing such serious topics

I don't want to hurt my sweet boyfriend so I choose him to hurt me.

I tried both. Honestly his reaction when you get hit by the curse comes off as uncaring lol. He was quite happy to have the curse done on him so we could all leave, so I stuck with that one.

the scene would have been so much more impactfull for me if the screams would have been more agonizing. Like the scream from Hermione when Bellatrix tortured her. For being under the literall torture curse, Sebastian/MC sounded relativly relaxed 😂

I love the smug expression on your character´s face when you just casually walk away from Sebastian, who is still in pain 😏

I love this game for scenes like this. It’s so dark and covers adult themes well even hits you with morally difficult decisions that have no morally right answer. God this game is so damn good

I had the curse be put on me. If I'm to inflict curcio on others it's only fair that I know what kind of spell I'm putting on others. Plus a Slytherin trait is leadership and I feel a leader needs some bad experiences to help them make future decisions.

I had to take the hit for my man seb

I use Crucio on Sebastian for his own good. I didn't want him to use dark magic and get used to it. Bec I thought that if he will do this for once he'll become bad - but if he knew how crucio felt then he think twice before using it.

I love that no matter choice you made Ominus would still ask them if their all right after the Crucio spell.

Please the way you don’t even ask if he’s alright after casting it on him 😂 idk why that’s sending me

Hitting sebastian with it and him going "I would have done anything to make [the pain] stop" I feel like that was him lowkey trying to tell Ominis to stop blaming himself ; n;

I used it on him because Ominis said "if you cast it you'll regret it forever" and i didn't want either of them to feel bad 😭 A few sec of intense pain >> emotional damage

Sebastian didn't really argue or rush to us apologising when he did the curse. He didn't ask if we were sure or insist he teach us so he'd be the one to be cursed. When it's his option to speak to Ominis, he doesnt GO to his friend like we do, he just stands staring at the door as they talk. Out of the two, Ominis sounded so much more concerned for us than Sebastian. Am I alright?? What do you think, I'm on the floor in agony! Then again, we don't do much more than look really troubled when we see Seb in pain either. It's a hard scene to watch either way...

The Protagonist: *falling on their knees due to so much pain and agony, feeling as if nails are being hammered into their body and feeling as if they’re going to die* Sebastian: are you alright? 😮

this scene could have had so much more impact depending on the choices you made, its one of the many scenes they missed the mark on i feel, its like in the books and movies and even in what ominis says about it the cruciatus curse is this big ominous spell that leaves the caster regretting their decisions and the recipient left in agonising pain and feeling traumatised even perhaps going insane from it and yet all that happens in this scene is one of the two characters cast the spell, the other wriggles on the ground for a bit and then gets up like nothing happened. personally i still wouldnt wanna cast it on sebastian cause i as the player from an omnipotent stand point have an emotional attachment to the character and i actually feel guilt and regret for my actions in the game regardless of the fact that they have no real consequences, and thats another thing, due to the fact that there are no real or even emotional consequences in the game, the player can do as they please and it doesnt matter because 9 times out of 10 the choices dont matter anyway. i would say the only part of the story that has any real emotinal consequences depending on your choices is the ending with fig but even then that does change much, *spoiler alert* but if you pick to keep the magic sealed you get to see him again before he dies and if you choose to open it to the world you dont get to see him again, either way he still dies, the lack of change and consequence makes the story somewhat boring when it could have been better. dont get me wrong, this is still a great game to play, but the lack of change in the choices and the lack of consequences plus the overall plot holes really take the game down a notch for me. again dont get me wrong, i love it but its got so much more potential and the creators have really not let it reach its full potential because of these little details. again this is just my opinion, you dont have to agree but if you dont theres really no need for slander or to be rude. this is a happy and safe community and we should all treat eachother kindly and with respect.

I spent the whole scene asking if I could cast it on him yet when the decision came I was weakened by my complete inability to choose the mean dialogue options and got it cast on myself

Ominis: ARE YOU ALRIGHT!? Sebastian: you good fam? Cool

I had Sebastian cast it on me, but now i realize the right answer is to cast it on him. He's ambition needs to be tempered a bit, it leads to many Slytherins turning into dark Wizard. Him seeing how Ominis felt would've been a powerful lesson.

I took the hit, I would never cast it on a friend.

Reading the comment section, it seems I was one of the few to use it on Sebastian rather than take one for the team. I just didn’t wanna waste my wiggenweld potions, lmao. I understand why im a Slytherin lol

I just kinda considered what Ominus(?) was saying about how casting the curse changed him and I didn't want that to happen to Sebastian. I'm afraid he's the type of person to take it lightly and continue to use it

While in excruciating pain - Revelio!

This whole questline needed so many more options. The way it played out felt like the “bad” ending if there were bad and good endings to it

Hufflepuffs: *nooo you're my friend, cast it on me!* Slytherin mfs: 😈

The boy characters scream to me was more in pain.

I love this quest. The writing of sebastions questline is so good and i love the darker feeling to it

I wanted to learn it to use on people who deserve it (dark wizards and poachers. Enemies.) and I like to be powerful haha but I had him cast it on me because I'd never do that to a friend or innocent person. I'd feel terrible about it, so OFC taking the hit is the only option.

"She had no one to cast the curse on" There is actually... Just find any living being, there are spider webs so there are definitely spiders around + if there isn't, just cast it on herself.

TWO POINTS HERE WITH MAJOR SPOILERS - - - - 1. Very interesting that Ominis points out in both situations that for Unforgetable “you have to mean it”. This proves that our darling Sebastian did want to kill his uncle and makes his story much much darker imho cause it can’t be “the fury of the moment” or anything like that. 2. Are we gonna talk about the fact that MC / Sebastian get tortured and are back on their feet right away, whereas Natsai gets tortured just a bit longer and needs recovery in a wheelchair ? Quite incoherent if you ask me, but hey, the game is too good to focus on this ; )

[SPOILER] Regarding the issue that you have to mean it... Compare our/Sebastian's reaction to the curse to what happens to Natsai in the end. Same curse, but a totally different level of pain. At least that is what made me think about this scene again.

I mean, we could Crucio on someone else other than the 2 of us, at least he wouldn't see what's coming... I'm going to hell

Am i the only one that never got that “crucio” writing on the floor in my play through?

and as a surprise, they made the slytherin evil again.

I let him cast it on me, but now that I think about it, I feel like he should've insisted on the MC casting it on him. He's the one that got everyone into this mess in the first place!

I took it but the way he says crucio sounds like a certain road man word

Sebastian was a homie I had him do the curse on me couldn’t do him dirty like that

I am concerned by how high Sebastian's pain tolerance is. Why is it so high. He took the Crucio heck of a lot better than MC. And no yelling, no screaming, only grunts. This is not normal. Seriously, what is his pain tolerance. Sebastian, baby, are you okay?

Where was the option for a « harder daddy » 😮?

ofc i took one for the team no questions asked

The spell: Cripplyio

Least there’s 2 ways of learning that curse. I did it the safe way and cast it in Sebastian.

It's almost cruel that the Cruciatus Curse hurts Sebastian more than us. Here we are, simply brought to our knees; while Seb is half sprawled out on the ground. It's not fair.

Poor Ominis Gaunt, I understand how he feels

I know the player is screaming in pain and such but Sebastian's "are you alright?" While we're still yelling will never not make me laugh 😭

I get the feeling we get more expressive when casting Crucio on him than he does 😭

"I thought you knew me better!" My god, that hurt.

Definitely agree with a post saying that our character is a sociopath 💀💀💀

I love your character

Couldn't Ominis's aunt just cast Crucio on herself?

I cast it on myself cuz i dont want to hurt my tool. He still very usefull

Sebastian's second true step on the road to darkness... the first being the moment he found "magick moste evile" in the restricted section. I'm pretty sure he actually learned the three unforgivables with that damn book. Why the heck would something like that be in a school is beyond me

I learned it and him cast it on me. Wanted my character to know what it felt like, while having fun using it on poachers and goblins.

Why did I let him cast it on me despite having him teach me? Maybe it was as thanks for his generosity. Or maybe its because knowing firsthand the pain it inflicts will allow me to use it more effectively

I honestly thought this would be much more emotional. Too easy and too little screaming.

Anyone notice that the logo for cruico is a hand with nails in it?

Even though I was going for most evil Hufflepuff, I just couldn't bring myself to torture ma boy Sebastian

What level do you have to be for this quest?

Should have been more frightening. It is so telling that Sebastian was willing to torture you if it meant getting a little closer to helping cure Anne, but the torment really didn't seem that extreme. And I laughed when Sebastian said, "Are you alright?" Like, bitch?

Its the are you alright right after he did that. Like you see mc in pain.

I was so scared we were gonna have to use this on Ominis. :(

I screwed up and now I cast cast it lol is there another chance to squire it in the game??

bro my character looks the same tf

after what ominis said sebastian saying “i think i can cast it if i have to” made me think he agreed casting it was worse than being the target so i casted it on him but now i realize he just hadnt known the spell too well opps

3:41 "It was excruciating". That's probably why it's called Crucio.

Tourched faces on the stone and crucio etched on the floor, my guess if we have to cast it on one of us. Of course that’s what it means what else could it be. Everyone gets icecream?

my playthrough I couldn't see crucio etched in the ground. My brother was slytherin and he saw it written crucio like this video.

That reaction to the Cruciatus curse is a fucking disappointment. According to Harry, who had experienced this curse a few times, the effect of the curse was worse than that of “one thousand white-hot knives boring into the skin”. It's supposed to be the torture curse, yet she acted like she got hit in the gut! I mean sure, even if he didn't mean to really cause her Voldemort crucio levels of pain, his crucio, even if only 1/1,000 as painful as Voldemort's, then it should have been at least as painful as being stabbed by a white-hot knife. But not, it was like 1/100,000 as weak. Pathetic.

is it just me who hates the dark ominous spell music hits BEFORE the player /character utters the incantation

poor Seb. he had already suffered too much for Anne, I decided to let him use the spell on md

Seb: not sure if I can cast crusio but I’ll try Also Seb: cast imperio and avada kedavra without hesitation and knows about them enough to teach us Oh how I love you Sebby boi

Ah Sabastian, The Garry Of Hogwarts

I'm playing this game on my PS4 and I absolutely adore using the Cruciatus Curse😈

I took the hit

The magic of chadness makes you resistant to unforgivable curses, hmmm. If MC gets hit with 'Avada Kadavra', take a wigglywhatever potion and you're right as rain.

Him: *casts it on me the first time around* Me: *literally makes a new character the same as the first one and casts it on him*

SPOILERS: Okay, but the difference between this moment, and when Natty takes a crucio hit for us. I always thought that was very interesting.

I'd do it on my MC instead 😂

THAT IS LEGIT MY VOICE IN THE GAME- (I made him do the curse on me. wasn't bad honestly. BUT AFTER WHEN OMINIS SAID "are you okay!?")

This looked like less than kick in the balls

Damn, look at them just getting up and carrying on, can you believe Natty was a wheelchair afterwards? Weak.

I didnt want to hurt my pookie so i told him to cast it on me instead. But i wanted to watch this to see what he would look like while under the curse and its kindaaa 🤭

Is this a slytherin only quest?

It was so watered down.

See this is why I let him cast it on me I like Sabastian

Weird…your character looks like mine 😅😂

Not gonna lie this is probably the lamest portrayal of an unforgivable curse I’ve ever seen. Looks no different than any other spell meant to cause harm and doesn’t even sound like it’s pain greater than anything.

Crucios is meant to be unforgivable curse that tortures the user. Id expect the reaction to the pain be a little bit more than stubbing a toe 😐. Atleast sebastian looks like he got punched in the gut hut that still is underwhelming

3:20

I let him use the spell on me but I didn’t learn it I will never use or learn dark magic