I love that Watson will have a special place in your pet cemetery. You are so caring and devoted.

Such a sweet family! Focus on the positive.I look forward to Apple and Sherlock running around in the backyard one day together. Peppoli will visit for sure.

This has been a bitter-sweet story of Apple’s first litter.

Thank you for the update. You're right in that little Sherlock looks a bit lonely all by himself now. So glad Watson has been memorialized with his own headstone. His time was brief, but he impacted not only your family, but the rest of your followers as well. He was a gallant little boy & will be missed. On a lighter note, I burst out laughing when just as you said "Apple will start soon to push him to walk/move" she started to lick and vigorously roll little Sherlock over and over - little legs sprawling every which way!! Looking forward to further updates....

Charlie the fact that you have brought Watson home and will be memorializing him with his own headstone speaks volumes. So fitting for “family”. The love that you and yours have shown is a testament to the devotion you have as a breeder and as exceptional human beings. Bless you all! 🐶♥️

Sherlock looked so lonely lying there until Apple came to join her little boy. She seems to be a good mummy.

Sweet Sherlock is going to be a fine puppy. It’s comforting to know that Watson is home again. You are wonderful people. Bless you! ❤

We just love watching Apple take care of Sherlock!

Aww so sweet to memorize Watson. We get attached too!

I’m happy to hear that Watson will be memorialized , I was going to mention that when I found out he went to Rainbow Bridge but felt it wasn’t appropriate so I’m delighted ❤️🙏 I’m praying for Sherlock to strengthen his bones with lots of Love ❤️ and Blessings from the Devine and all the Angels 😇🐶❤️🙏

Hi Charlie, Thanks as always for the videos. We love the fact that you are memorializing Watson. and great to see how well Sherlock is doing. Apple as well. Mandy wanted me to tell you something about your joke about the mother licking the dog back there. She said 144% Ewwwwwwww.. She said that you being a mathematician, you would get that joke. LOL. Thanks again. Keep up the great work and have a great weekend...

Charlie, the devotion that you and Katie have shown over the years to your Cavaliers speaks volumes.on strength of character. Thank you for your videos which continually teach me how to take good care of my Cav pup.

Very interesting about the eggcrate foam. Pneumonia! That was a surprise to me! Poor Apple, losing her pups. I often wonder what they think.

Good morning! Thank you for update on Sherlock and Apple a great mum. So sorry for your loss Apple. Rest in peace Watson .

Sorry about the loss of Watson!!

Thanks for the update, Charlie. Your videos about this litter have been so educational 👩‍🎓! I have a theory about Watson: Maybe his purpose in this life was simply to cuddle his brother, thereby helping Sherlock to get off to a great start... ? If that's the case, he did a STELLAR job 🤩! Sherlock is a stunning puppy and will no doubt be a champion in the ring as well as a treasured companion. Take care and stay well.

Sherlock looks very comfortable in his crated bed. Apple is tenderly taking good care of her baby...great mama ❤

You were a math teacher too? That’s impressive. Glad that Sherlock is doing well and his little paws are doing well too. It’s really special to keep Watson’s memory. He was a loved little puppy. Sherlock is loved too.❤

Thank you for your updates. I look forward to them each day. Blessings to you.

Sweet Apple has had quite the time with her first litter. But she is such a good mother! Sherlock is going to get all her attention so he is going to be a great puppy! ❤

Clearly Sherlock does not feel uncomfortable with his new bedding since he relaxes while sleeping. Sweet puppy, stay healthy! Your fans love you.

What wonderful care these darlings have

Sherlock does seem quite comfortable! I love the way Apple takes such good care of him. Thanks for another update Charlie!!!

Sherlock is such a sweetheart … I think he is going to be just like his mom Apple . Especially with all the love surrounding him 🐾🐾❤

Good Morning🥰. Sherlock looks so comfortable in his new bedding! Such a sweetheart! 🥰. Mornin to my friend Apple! Good mama, Love you!🥰🐾

You: he's sleeping peacefully Apple: roll over and let me lick you, come on, move 😂 She's a great little mommy.

-Very sorry to hear about Watson. Poor little thing.

At some point, I'd be interested in your thoughts about Apple's ability to have a successful pregnancy and feeding in the future. Not sure if this issue is unique or might be considered chronic.

Charlie , te iba a preguntar si el colchón era incómodo para Sherlock ,pero ya has resuelto mis dudas .Me gusta hacerte preguntas , desde la curiosidad , porque evidentemente tú eres el que tiene muchísima experiencia y el que resuelve todas mis dudas . GRACIAS. 😘😘

Thats great to hear that ur having the stone of watson. Please show us when u get it. Looks like the egg foam is doing a fantastic job with sherlock. R u still doing the sock too?

hahahah awwww that APPLE is such a good momma. And i know from cats and kittens it must not dont taste good because i saw a momma cat gag or make the stink face when she was cleaning her kitten. do dogs make a stink face like cats and other animals do? i only had farm dogs and they were never inside. i dont know much about dogs.that is why i love you channel so much .i learn alot from you.

Does Sherlock have any understanding that his brother is gone and if so, how is he doing with that aspect?