Cheap (Factory Made) Vs. Expensive (Hand Made) Steel Tongue Drum Comparison

  Рет қаралды 50,512

Dylan Ferno

Dylan Ferno

Күн бұрын

Hopefully this steel tongue drum comparison helps you decide what kind of steel tongue drum to buy. While the factory made steel tongue drums are decent instruments, it might be worth it to invest in the better instrument in the long run. This video compares a 12” inch 13 note steel tongue drum from Amazon vs. A 12” inch Kosmosky steel tongue drum. Keep in mind that not all handmade drums are double sided which is a huge advantage to the Kosmosky drums in my opinion.
0:00 Overview and some Pros/cons
0:57 More Pros/Cons
2:15 Sound Comparison
4:04 Tuning Comparison
5:11 Design Comparison
5:45 Conclusion
#Kosmosky #steeltonguedrum #tankdrum

Пікірлер: 87
@JonathanNeumann
@JonathanNeumann 2 жыл бұрын
I totally agree with your final thoughts. It wouldn´t be smart to invest a lot of money into an instrument you probably don´t like and that can happen regardless of build or sound quality. If there´s no other way of testing this instrument, a cheap tongue drum can be a place to start. If you then conclude that a tongue drum is for you, you can still upgrade to a high quality drum :)
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno 2 жыл бұрын
Thanks for watching! Yea of course I started with the cheaper drum too before making the jump aha. I guess that goes for beginning any instrument such as guitar, keyboard etc. that it makes sense to get an 'entry level' one to see if it is something that really speaks to you in the first place
@ThatOneGuyWeAllKnow
@ThatOneGuyWeAllKnow 8 ай бұрын
I did not expect that drastic of a difference it’s crazy
@yvonneschlame8657
@yvonneschlame8657 4 ай бұрын
À few years back (around 6) I bought a handmade one in a little esoteric shop in Brittany, France. They are made of old Gas bottles by someone from the area. I paid around 120€. In size it compares with the ones in this video. Handmade doesn't have to be out of reach. If you're in that part of the World, check out "Chemin d'éveil" in La Roche Bernard. Everything about that place (the village and that little boutique) is quite fascinating. ❤
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno 4 ай бұрын
Cool! Sounds like a really nice store and place 👍
@misou8300
@misou8300 8 ай бұрын
I had bought a tank drum ( factory made) from a generic music shop and am loving it, as someone with little to no instrumental experience I find the factory made one to be more than enough for a test in the waters since it's super fun to mix and match all the notes and learning simple songs can be rewarding. If you're debating on which one to chose you'd need to consider how much you're willing to invest into the tank drum in terms of time. If you're sure you're going to use it then I see no issues in getting the expensive one but if you're looking for a new hobby or to just fart about with them then the factory one is a perfect fit
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno 8 ай бұрын
I 100% agree with this comment
@barak_ahtha
@barak_ahtha 2 жыл бұрын
Kosmosky clearly has the better tone! I'd consider it an investment in one's spiritual health & wellbeing! Thank you for the demonstration!
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno 2 жыл бұрын
Thanks! I like that idea of an 'investment.' I wish you all the best
@Pixel_dust1211
@Pixel_dust1211 2 жыл бұрын
Thank you. I just purchased one from amazon as I have been going back and forth on it for a while. I am excited to learn. The other one is absolutely stunning and viewed their webpage and vowed to myself if I can actually stick with it, then I will purchase one. I love the sound and those are gorgeous. Thank you for your review.
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno 2 жыл бұрын
Awesome! I definitely started with thr Amazon first too! thanks for watching
@sonicalstudios
@sonicalstudios 3 ай бұрын
Great video, was going to buy one for the studio. Might get a hand made one, Tuning is important and the high notes had a slight distortion to them with the cheap one.
@thathandpanlady4510
@thathandpanlady4510 2 жыл бұрын
I loooooove KosmoSky drums! Ive got 4 of them - 3 of which are two sided, so 7 scales. Beautiful look … beautiful sound! GREAT for sound therapy which is what I do …. 👍🏼 Good review!! ☺️🛸🎶🦋
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno 2 жыл бұрын
Thanks! subbed your channel. Nice stuff
@thathandpanlady4510
@thathandpanlady4510 Жыл бұрын
@@DylanFerno …Awwww thanks … so very much appreciated!! And just fyi, my music pages are also on FaceBook, Instagram and TikTok … all under the same name ….That Handpan Lady … 🤗🛸🎶🦋
@ccturner8224
@ccturner8224 5 ай бұрын
I wish you would review every product for sale for everything! You get to the point, you are articulate and knowledgeable and you made perfect sense! I watched your video after the fact of placing my order to Kosmisky for the ine you showed here (mountain river i think its called) and also Celtic Tree: one for home and one for my massage/sound healing studio. But your video made me happy with my purchase....a little buyers remorse 😊
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno 5 ай бұрын
I really appreciate that feedback! Good luck with your studio!
@artnow2
@artnow2 2 жыл бұрын
Good review except one should add this. I have one of each in the same key. The reason I had to buy the cheaper amazon drum was because it has a chromatic scale. This allows you to play well known songs. Most tank drums leave out half notes (like a pentatonic scale) to make them sound more harmonious. This way one person can play the melody and the other can play an accompaniment with a cool interlude. I think Kosmosky may be working on drum with a chromatic scale.
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno 2 жыл бұрын
Yea that's all true as well. Thanks for pointing it out. I believe Kosmosky does make some chromatic drums also but definitely not all of them
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno 2 жыл бұрын
@@jamesmichael20910 I agree. Thanks for adding this.
@sillyjellyfish2421
@sillyjellyfish2421 2 жыл бұрын
Yeah, drums that are of a certain scale resonate better as a default then again with a chromatic one you can play anything at all since it has all the notes in its range. So it's a tradeof
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno Жыл бұрын
Actually it seems like no tongue drums have a chromatic scale because they can only play in one key per side. So they may have a natural scale if all 7 notes of the key are included. A chromatic instrument would mean that all 12 possible pitches are available to play as in a piano or guitar. Kosmosky's new wave drums do offer a full natural scale however
@CaseyChromaticArts
@CaseyChromaticArts 2 жыл бұрын
Nice, thanks for the review, you have a really calming voice
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno 2 жыл бұрын
Thanks! glad you enjoyed
@miarritzekosurfari
@miarritzekosurfari 2 жыл бұрын
Kosmosky has a brillant sound, more in high tones. They are just incredible! Thanks for the vid'
@maryfield6920
@maryfield6920 Жыл бұрын
Great review. I want the Kosmosky. ❤️
@Specialkfree
@Specialkfree Жыл бұрын
I debated for so long and ended up getting the double sided KosmoSky drum in the pattern Gem, which fits the name. It’s spectacular and I haven’t even gotten it yet. The sound and aesthetics was unparalleled to any other drum. I considered the Vibe drum, from AZ but it wasn’t pretty enough. I am beyond thrilled to get my drum!! PS yours is gorgeous!
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno Жыл бұрын
Good choice! and thank you
@jacobbockover1628
@jacobbockover1628 Жыл бұрын
Even through youtube i can really hear the difference. This is giving me thoughts of a net stand for those
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno Жыл бұрын
Yea big difference. I've been using a singing bowl cushion as a playing stand that works well.
@DeepAscension
@DeepAscension Жыл бұрын
Hi thank you so much for this comparison! I thought I'd bring up an interesting thing that I noticed. The cheaper tongue drum has the same paint finishing as smaller, mini, and pocket Meinl brand tongue drums!!! I suspect that they are all made in the same factory in China and that yours has dissent tongue leafs design but possibly the same quality as Meinl. I myself have 2 small, 2 minis, and the pocket Meinl for diversity of scales. They are excellent products for what they are. I also own a Rav Vast in Celtic D Minor and have owned, sold it, a Guda Freezbee in Arcane scale. Rav Vast is king hands down. I'm going to get a Kosmosky of the same design you have! Thanks for the video. Lastly I think there is something to the quality of tongue drums at larger dimensions 9" and above that is a deal breaker. If you can play it with your fingers then it is a sign of good quality steel /construction. I prefer and primarily play with my hands and this it is a necessity. Thus I will be purchasing a Kosmosky as my second tongue drum as it appears better than a Guda Freezbee.
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno Жыл бұрын
Yea the mass produced ones are definitely all from pretty much the same factory and just branded differently. I definitely agree that they need to be bigger than about 9" to get the deep ethereal tones. I find the smaller ones kinda more like cool looking xylophones
@samuellund1377
@samuellund1377 2 жыл бұрын
Thank you, good info, straight to the point. I'll probably go cheap for now since I have little to no experience and want to try it out. The other one is gorgeous though. One day perhaps...
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno 2 жыл бұрын
Glad it was helpful! you can't go wrong with a cheaper one. As long as they are at least 10 inches in diameter they will sound great in my opinion
@nymenris2821
@nymenris2821 3 ай бұрын
there is no comparison, the sound quality on the more expensive one sounds SOOOO much nicer
@VicTheFigGuy
@VicTheFigGuy 4 ай бұрын
Thank you for the reciew. I just bought a cheaper one off Amazon with 15 notes that I ak excited for. If I can stick with it then maybe I will invest in a more expensive one!
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno 4 ай бұрын
That's the way to do it! I started with the Amazon one too
@stephenstokes3831
@stephenstokes3831 2 жыл бұрын
Thank you for this video. I've just started trying to figure out what to get for the first time and learn about these wonderful instruments. Out of curiosity, what scale(s) is your Kosmosky drum in?
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno 2 жыл бұрын
You're welcome! The drum is B minor on one side and E mixolydian on the other side
@00Regista
@00Regista 2 жыл бұрын
Perfect video
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno 2 жыл бұрын
Thanks! Glad it was useful
@sarahnguyen91
@sarahnguyen91 3 ай бұрын
Thank you very much . May I know the app you use to check the tone .
@unknownscientist1530
@unknownscientist1530 Жыл бұрын
I bought kind of a mid grade one off of Amazon, and I love hitting away at it and free styling it, but I feel like it just does not have that tone I want. It's good, I definitely like it, but I'm seriously thinking of getting a nice hand made one. I'm no musician, I bought this as sort of a psuedo fidget toy and a stress reliever, but even despite that I feel like I crave more out of this 100-ish dollar one I got.
@royalewithcheese12
@royalewithcheese12 2 жыл бұрын
Thanks for the comparison. Is the Kosmosky drum easier to play with your hands when compared to the factory drum?
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno 2 жыл бұрын
They are both suitable for handplaying. The layout of the notes is a bit more intuitive on the factory drum (the adjacent notes are 2 whole tones apart) but you can get used to the Kosmosky drum layout easily
@WW-ik4ot
@WW-ik4ot Жыл бұрын
Thanks for the video! What's the name of the cheap one?
@sheldonnorton9035
@sheldonnorton9035 8 ай бұрын
Fascinating! The Hand made one has bell overtones While the factory one is more dull and almost electronic. It would seem totally subjective (short of the tuning issue). For my purposes I would go factory. I had a factory one arrive from Amazon today but it was a different colour from that I ordered. Another one will arrive tomorrow. Don’t know why I included that boring detail. Anyways. Ha
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno 8 ай бұрын
I agree that it is mostly subjective. They sound different and can be used in different contexts, but if they were the same price, I think the 2-sided one is better. The factory one is definitely worth it though and still a great instrument 👌
@wttw4942
@wttw4942 2 ай бұрын
Thanks. How do you replace the strings of it and can we use nylon strings instead of metalic? Do they make electric versions of it? Great video! The hand made produces more harmonics than the factory made.
@FREEZER4000
@FREEZER4000 Жыл бұрын
Hi , I've had a Kosmosky for a few months , I really LOVE ! It's just a beautiful sounding instrument. There is on tongue on the bottom which does not have the full resonance as the others others .. its still beautiful sounding however I was wondering if you might have run in to this and if there is anything to be done about it . - Thanks - oh - btw , replacement rubber vacuum cleaner bands (that make the sweeper turn ) are excellent for placing the Kosmosky drum on for playing on table
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno Жыл бұрын
Hey most tongue drums I've played have had 1 or 2 tongue that don't resonant as much. It's normal. You can using small magnets under the tongues to see if that helps
@FREEZER4000
@FREEZER4000 Жыл бұрын
@@DylanFerno Thanks , I thought that as well I will try magnets . There is something I did I'd like to share with you .I ran some heavy nylon twine through the small holes on the drums outer edge . In this way the drum hung freely ,sort of like a marching band drum it was all jury rigged hanging from a boom mic stand . Hanging it this way I was able to play both sides. Quite the sound experience ,and all tongues resonated beautifully . I haven't done it yet , but I plan to build something better to to hold it this way . As you might imagine , it was a little risky trying this , but it does work - billy
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno Жыл бұрын
@billy freeze That's a really cool idea thank you would love to hear a sound demo of that
@FREEZER4000
@FREEZER4000 Жыл бұрын
@@DylanFerno sure - working on a proper stand for it .
@Jestunes
@Jestunes Жыл бұрын
Is it the way you're playing it that makes some of the notes sound like 2 notes playing simultaneously or do the notes just have one sound? Not sure if you know what I'm saying but some of the notes you hit had a clanking sound along with the actual note. Is that with all these steel drums? I'm speaking as a professional musician for over 50 years. I try to play musically and not just spiritually and thinking of buying a steel hand drum in my retirement. Thanks for sharing...
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno Жыл бұрын
Im not 100% sure I understand the question. There is only one note per tongue. When you hit the tongue there is an initial striking sound before the note rings out. The resonance inside of the drum may cause some other notes to ring slightly as well.
@DeepAscension
@DeepAscension Жыл бұрын
I thought I'd add some two cents in what you're asking and maybe some more guidance in your decisions. 1 the loudness and resonances which emit from the tongue drums really need a good quality mic and setup for proper recording. Check out World Drum channel on KZfaq and you can understand what that guy is discussing when he plays a Kosmosky drum. 2. I have a Rav Vast, had a Guda Freezebee FYI the ones on Amazon are ripoffs from the top Guda from Dmitry, I also have a multitude of Meinl pocket, mini, and small tongue drums. A. The Rav Vast is hands down the boss! Forget a handpan as they can easily be out of tune. The Rav, if you can afford it, will provide you the sound and the crowd pleasing that you will and should want. I'm not a musician with knowing notes and what not. But I can intuitively play these better than what most you tubers put out there. B. The guda was good but different than the Rav as it has a more plucky sound from the initial strike and much less resonance, flat? This is good in its own way I should note that the Quality you want and are looking for is found in one someone thing can you play it with your fingers. If yes it's a great start. If you must use mallets then I would not purchase. Lastly, the guda for best quality get the real ones from the Dmitry website. C. The Meinl, given its an instrument company, I blind bought the " 2 small, 2mini & 1 pocket" tongue drum found with in their "sonic energy" line/series. I think this was excellent to break into After the Rav Vast looking f hour my NEXT amazing tongue drum. Reason being the Rav is second to none. Do I get a larger Meinl Tank Drum or Meinl Octave Sonic Energy? Well the meinl small, and the mini are definitely helpful in that I can experience a multitude of scales in person for future choice. Also it reveals quality of the meinl brand. I will comment this to this videos main section, but included here is this as well the small, mini and pocket meinl are great quality cheap and excellent product! They are by no means close to larger tongue drums.when you look at the finish of the cheaper tongue drum in this video it is the SAME exact paint finish as the meinl products. I suspect they are made by our in the same factory in China and these are unbranded and slightly different cut. Thus the cheaper one can be on the similar level of quality. Maybe that helps you make a decision. As for me I will be purchasing a similar design of the Kosmosky and am currently researching by video, again the recording of the scales is hit or miss to really know what you're listening to. However,.... Finally........after all of this....... It boils down to this can you play it with your fingers? The answer, for me, is that for some reason the resonating capabilities of the tongue drum reveal best quality IF it is able to be played by BOTH mallets but I prefer and primarily play with your fingers/thumb knuckle. Thus the decision for a second larger drum becomes simple. The Meinls are great but I found are almost impossible to play with your finger. That kicks out the Meinl Sound Energy "Tank Drum" and "Octave" choices. The only, again to me, 2 choices that exist are another Expensive! And large/heavy takes up space Rav Vast or......... A beautiful design with 2 individual scales Kosmosky. Both are playable with fingers as far as I can tell in videos. There is a lot in personal preference, scale color size price. Keep it simple you have enough money for a Rav Vast get the one you want and most enjoy for the scale and sound. If you want more affordable and possibly 2 scales! Then get the Kosmosky. You can always purchase, like I did a few of the smaller Meinl tongue drums to in person experience the scales and then make your decisive choice. Celtic D minor Rav Vast is amazing. I'm going to get a kosmosky that allows for a brighter elation feeling and something maybe with akebono? MAYBE our something like pygmy. There is an idiopan in 12 size and you can tune it with little magnets however you like. For me I like to be able to pick it up and exoect and know what I will hear. All the best! Hope to know what you end up choosing
@sherei9530
@sherei9530 Жыл бұрын
What do you think of the Balmy drum?
@tony8354586
@tony8354586 Жыл бұрын
Should have played some tunes!
@themachobrochacho1987
@themachobrochacho1987 23 күн бұрын
WHOA....
@annecyle
@annecyle 6 ай бұрын
Which scale would you recommend for a beginner but someone who has some music experience.
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno 6 ай бұрын
Whichever one sounds the best to you!
@ELisa-qf2mw
@ELisa-qf2mw 5 ай бұрын
I was about to buy a handmade drum, but then I bought an Amazon one... I feel a bit guilty, but it has more notes and case included for half the price... And I'm not good at music, I only bought it to accompany my psychodrama sessions and to play around with my family and friends, not to make serious music... I feel that one of the 13 tongues doesn't sound great, but I've read that it can be fixed by sticking some small magnets on the inside, is it true?
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno 5 ай бұрын
Magnets can help tune the tongues better, but if it is just a bit 'dead' sounding it can't really help with that unfortunately. Good luck with your practice!
@jimbeau8519
@jimbeau8519 Жыл бұрын
what brand is the cheaper drum?Thanks
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno Жыл бұрын
I wouldn't really be too concerned about brands on the cheaper drums from Amazon and Aliexpress. They all come from the same or similar Chinese factories so the products are essentially the same across brands, just with different stickers slapped on them. Go for one with a size, design, and price that you like 👍
@tonyfendall
@tonyfendall 25 күн бұрын
My £50 Amazon drum was perfectly in tune using my guitar strobe tuner.
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno 25 күн бұрын
Nice! Some are probably better than others. But it seems like most notes being slightly out of tune is the norm
@tonyfendall
@tonyfendall 22 күн бұрын
@@DylanFerno I realise I may have been lucky.
@Riin_Rio
@Riin_Rio Ай бұрын
What are the price differences?
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno Ай бұрын
about $80 USD for the amazon one and about $350 USD for the hand made one
@Riin_Rio
@Riin_Rio Ай бұрын
@@DylanFerno That’s the kind of thing that’ll last you at least 30 years. So amortizing it comes to about 3 cents a day. AND should be worth a lot more at the end of the 30 years, leaving you with a half a lifetime of exquisite sounds and a profit ! I’ll take it !
@clausbader9537
@clausbader9537 6 ай бұрын
When you make comparisons please use identical keys and number of tones. Don't compare an apartment with a house.
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno 2 ай бұрын
I agree but of course I don't have every kind of drum in every scale 😊
@welc0mechange738
@welc0mechange738 Ай бұрын
If youre going to get a cheaper Amazon one, fine they are good but get atleast a 10 inch
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno Ай бұрын
I agree
@youravantgarde
@youravantgarde 4 ай бұрын
The hand made one sounds sooooo much better
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno 4 ай бұрын
100%
@tangleslong499
@tangleslong499 Ай бұрын
Although Kosmosky drums sounded nice, it takes a long time for the sound of a note to stop. Too much reverberation which can be a nuisance if you want to play a music.
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno Ай бұрын
yea good point. I think this is mostly a pro of the drum for ambient music. But when playing with other instruments you can mute its reverbation by holding your hand or mallet on the notes after striking them
@lordfyita2096
@lordfyita2096 8 күн бұрын
The hand made sounds a little bit whack.
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno 7 күн бұрын
aha really? I mean they do sound different so it comes down to preference at the end of the day
@a.bloke2.0alwayslearning.23
@a.bloke2.0alwayslearning.23 2 ай бұрын
Sorry, but for Tome and Resonance the Cheap Drum IS the better From. A Musical Instrument is for PLAYING, for it's SOUND!, so if you want something to LOOK at, get a Painting. .
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno 2 ай бұрын
Sure. I have different preferences but I respect both of those opinions.
@a.bloke2.0alwayslearning.23
@a.bloke2.0alwayslearning.23 2 ай бұрын
@@DylanFerno It's good to have an open mind Does the Fancy One have a picture hook attachments for wall hanging ? Does it have those 3 little rubber feet that allows it to sit stable on floor, desk, chair or stand ??? Those Under Tongues still mess up the Top Tones, harmonically overlap resonating, and shorten it resonating time. If you want to damp a Tone, you only have to put your Hand on it. If the Tone ain't there, you can't extend it. Altogether a WONDERFUL Instrument that is Brand New to me (at 72 and for 5 Years Studio set up Groups, Big Bands and ENTIRE Symphonic Orchestras complete with PRRCUSSION SECTIONS !!!), I don't know how I missed The Tongue Drum. It's most ASTONISHING Features:- It breaks ALL the Drum Percussion Rules offering the Full Scale + 2 from, (not counting the feet), ONE SINGLE COMPONENT and needing no other parts to work effectively. Is this a NEW Invention ? My Female Percussionist would have KILLED yo get one. Take Care. DDDOOO000ooonnG !!!!!!!
@DylanFerno
@DylanFerno 2 ай бұрын
@a.bloke2.0alwayslearning.23 Hey so it doesn't have any attachments for wall hanging. I made my own hook to hang it up. It has 3 tiny rubber feet that fell off. I use a singing bowl cushion underneath it for maximum resonance. It's very cool that you have such a history with music. I think the instrument was created around 2007 or so, so it is a relatively new instrument but yea it's really cool and can easily be hooked up to speakers directly with a magnetic contact microphone
20 HANDPANS 😱 | Handpan Choir & Malte Marten
2:53
Malte Marten Method
Рет қаралды 714 М.
Sprinting with More and More Money
00:29
MrBeast
Рет қаралды 24 МЛН
1 класс vs 11 класс (неаккуратность)
01:00
БЕРТ
Рет қаралды 4,4 МЛН
Indian sharing by Secret Vlog #shorts
00:13
Secret Vlog
Рет қаралды 50 МЛН
What is ? Tongue Drum Tank Drum Tongue Pan - which and what to buy.
20:07
Making a Tongue Drum From a Propane Tank!  Steel Tank Drum DIY
11:09
Understanding Steel Tongue Drum Tuning
13:24
Musical Miscellany
Рет қаралды 48 М.
6 Ways To Use Your Tongue Drum
4:49
Root Rhythm
Рет қаралды 70 М.
How To Play (and Find Music For) the Steel Tongue Drum
8:51
Musical Molly Khan
Рет қаралды 215 М.
Body
2:38
Asik - Topic
Рет қаралды 307 М.
Қайрат Нұртас - Қоймайсың бей 2024
2:22
RAKHMONOV ENTERTAINMENT
Рет қаралды 1,3 МЛН
Alisher Konysbaev - Ol Aru (Official Music Video)
2:40
Alisher Konysbaev
Рет қаралды 7 МЛН
Asik - Body (Lyrics Video)
2:42
Rukh Music
Рет қаралды 673 М.
Kalifarniya - Hello [official MV]
2:54
Kalifarniya
Рет қаралды 3,6 МЛН
ИРИНА КАЙРАТОВНА - ПАЦАН (MV)
6:08
ГОСТ ENTERTAINMENT
Рет қаралды 753 М.