It depends on the people Like if all the strong vocals come together, then maybe But the fact is that all the strong vocals never came together in one group to perform So yeah The strong vocals in chuang 2020 is Curley gao Chen zhuo xuan Ma si hui Wang Yi jin Yao hui Wang ke And more of course
@jaime1916 Жыл бұрын
@@nira66李紫停也好利害,101大部分實力都比較高,豆子跳舞表情很到位
@valonganiza4 ай бұрын
2024 and still remains a masterpiece amongst all
@alexpang53374 жыл бұрын
虽然我不懂音乐,可是听了很多遍两个版本的,真的觉得陈芳语的和音很漂亮啊……这组简直就是完美了……
@smvringo3 жыл бұрын
2021回來為了聽陳芳語的部份,穏定的中音配搭聽得好舒服
@X10_ele4 жыл бұрын
这组。。。好像已经出道很久的明星一样。。。我的天啊。。。
@X10_ele4 жыл бұрын
@MS4E12-HO Adrian [s] 我知道啊。。。。
@user-wh7sy4yl3f3 жыл бұрын
頂上去
@wahafung93743 жыл бұрын
難得一見的組合
@samchiu52364 жыл бұрын
101的實力唱將在这组
@Doraemonhandle3 жыл бұрын
如果換許靖韻來,真不知道怎麼分配
@Nance_tianhua7 ай бұрын
Here I am in Dec 2023 and I will still continue to rewatch this 🥹 this song is too good
I’ve watched so many survival shows, and hands down, this is one of the best performances i’ve seen. Their performance gives me goosebumps whenever i watch it, these girls are so talented af, kinda sad that Kimberly got robbed 😔😔
@jjon56062 жыл бұрын
Kimberly said in an interview that she wanted to get eliminated. Did not like all the shady things mgmt did or allowed to be done to the girls. If she hadn't been so good, probably have gotten her wish much earlier.
@summertwinkle7492 жыл бұрын
I think the song is very good too. It's funny because Stephanie Sun was very popular even with my friends but I never ever listen to her songs. But now that I hear her songs covered by other singers so many years later, I found out that she really does have good songs. I finally concluded maybe her voice and singing style are just not my cup of tea, but vocals totally affected how I judge the song!
@nurulhikmah8862 Жыл бұрын
What is the song name?
@NaDee-mh2po2 ай бұрын
IDK where these girls are now but damn I still come back to this performance for it's magical vibes
@BrownSkingirl256Ай бұрын
They were the best ,❤
@bentin3752 жыл бұрын
總覺得 陳芳語就想大姐姐一樣 照顧著mimi李紫婷 最出色的part都給她唱 自己在旁還支持著她
@Lynt_4 жыл бұрын
3A were so legendary!
@howlhakuashitaka76163 жыл бұрын
The best team!! The leader divided the lines so smartly!! I love the way their voices support each other's! Have listened to this version almost 20 times but still get goosebumps
Lucia wu and Kimberly seriously got robbed, I still can’t believe that level of talent didn’t debut
@ztaoexolisaguanlin56754 жыл бұрын
To be fair Cnetz all acknowledge Lucia, Kimberly & Angela's vocal prowess which is why they atleast had Lucia & Angela reach the finale (Kimberly did not because of attitude problem issues Cnetz have w/ her) but they just don't fit a girlgroup. Cnetz knew they fit solo more than a dance girlgroup. They're vocals also are more on powerhouse side which isn't what the girlgroup are aiming for. Zining, Ziting, Sunnee & Aojuan vocals are better suited for a girlgroup. Even Fujing, Meiqi, & Xuanyo's vocal who might be weaker but suit a girlgroup more. Can you even imagine a girlgroup with Adele, Beyonce, Celine Dion etc. All great vocalist but don't fit together as dancing girlgroup. In a girlgroup someone needs to be a main vocals and someone needs to be sub-vocals for support. Then there are the dancers, rappers, visual or actress of the group, variety persona etc. An idol girlgroup is NOT a VOCAL CHOIR!!
@mimi-oz7wr4 жыл бұрын
⭐️ GUANLIN / EXO / ZTAO ⭐️ I’m just saying they’re talented no need for an essay hahaha
@sieghart78894 жыл бұрын
@@ztaoexolisaguanlin5675 yes i can imagine a girl group with Beyonce and its called "Destiny's Child". Oh wait, it's not just my imagination. Even S.H.E remade their song in Lian Ren Wei Man (original - Brown Eyes). these girls were too good for stupid rocket girls.
@ztaoexolisaguanlin56754 жыл бұрын
@@sieghart7889 You did not get what i mean. I know Beyonce is in Destiny's child. What I meant is that can you imagine ADELE, BEYONCE & CELINE DION aka ALL 3 of them in one DANCING GIRL GROUP?! That's ridiculous! Also Tencent made it clear from the start that they want a DANCING POP GIRLGROUP not a powerhouse vocals. P.S. If you really want to support this girls and please buy their music because I do. I buy Lucia's songs. I even stream her Like You cover that she did just last week. Instead of calling Rocket Girls stupid just go actually stream these girls songs so they can be successful too like RG.
@ztaoexolisaguanlin56754 жыл бұрын
@@mimi-oz7wr No you said they were robbed and I explain why they are not. I don't get why people now a days use 'writing an essay' as insult. Well to be able to fully express and make a point come across you do have to explain things in further details but i guess people just hate reading now because most are close minded to it. That sucks. I hate short cut & would rather explain things in details than be misinderstood but i guess people still cannot comprehend.
@hinhger4 жыл бұрын
Just only word that I want to say is "Perfect".
@dean43682 жыл бұрын
Come here for 陳芳語。玻璃心讓我認識了她。
@aswpch88954 жыл бұрын
经典的表演 现在回来看还是一样喜欢 真的很难超越这个表演
@joyyyce4 жыл бұрын
有沒有看完青你舞台回來的😂不會只有我吧?😂(btw青你2破風舞台c位許kiki大推❤️🌚
@siqicai19454 жыл бұрын
ꀭꆂꐟꏸꍟ 我也是
@dingyinghui95584 жыл бұрын
这里
@grizroudvv4 жыл бұрын
我Ki必须C位出道!必须的必!
@joyyyce4 жыл бұрын
@@grizroudvv 一齊努力打投衝一保二😤😤😤
@X10_ele4 жыл бұрын
我我我 我很喜欢许佳琪
@yjw38513 жыл бұрын
2021还在听的 👇
@doasisay7623 жыл бұрын
+1 (fr. Thailand)
@benjamin-o7h2 жыл бұрын
Mimi and Kimberly had the best high pitch in the harmony
@natdcoconut29824 жыл бұрын
From the first evaluation 'Problem' till now 3A always slayed and deliver the best performance among any other stages!!
My favorite stage of all 3 ss. They had equal lines, costumes and airtime! Their voices matched well and quality even though the other two girls (non-3A) were from lower class. I always comeback for watching this performance
I miss 5A. They are the best vocal in Chuang forever.
@sharr11537 ай бұрын
After the years that have passed, this performance still remains a masterpiece.
@pavpaver5142 жыл бұрын
Original Artist: Stefanie Sun Song: 逆光 也许我一直害怕有答案 也许爱轻轻在风里打转 离开释怀 很短暂又重来 有时候自问自答 ye xu wo yi zhi hai pa you da an ye xu ai qing jin zai feng li da zhuan li kai shi huai hen duan zan you chong lai you shi hou zi wen zi da บางที ฉันอาจกลัวคำตอนนั้นมาโดยตลอด บางทีความรักก็ผันแปรเปลี่ยนอย่างเงียบ ๆ ในสายลม พรากจากไป ปล่อยไป รวดเร็ว แต่ถึงอย่างนั้นก็ยังเกิดขึ้นอย่างซ้ำ ๆ บางครั้ง ฉันก็ถามตัวเอง เพียงเพื่ออยากจะหาคำตอบให้กับตัวเอง 我不要困难把我们击散 我责备自己那么不勇敢 遗憾没有到达 拥抱过还是害怕 用力推开你我依然留下 wo bu yao kun nan ba wo men ji san wo ze bei zi ji na me bu yong gan yi han mei you dao da yong bao guo hai shi hai pa yong li tui kai ni wo yi ren liu xia ฉันไม่ต้องการให้เราถูกแยกจากกัน เพียงเพราะการถอยหลัง ฉันกล่าวโทษตัวเองอยู่อย่างนั้น เพียงเพราะไม่มีความกล้ามากพอ รู้สึกเสียดาย ที่ไม่เอื้อมไป ตอนนี้แม้เราจะยังโอบกอดกันไว้ ฉันยังกลัว เพราะอย่างนั้น ฉันจึงได้ผลักไสเธอออกไป ในขณะที่ฉันยังคงอยู่ 有一束光 那瞬间 是什么痛得刺眼 你的视线 是谅解 为什么舍不得熄灭 我逆着光却看见 you yi shu guang na shun jian shi shen me tong de ci yan ni de shi xian shi liang jie wei shen me she bu de xi mie wo ni zhe guang qu kan jian ในชั่วขณะนั้น แสงที่พาดผ่าน เข้ามาทิ่มแทงดวงตาของฉัน สายตาของคุณนั้น ราวกับเข้าใจ ทำไม คุณถึงไม่หันกลับมา ฉันยืนอยู่ หันหน้าเข้าหาแสง และที่แห่งนั้นฉันเห็น 那是泪光 那力量 我不想再去抵挡 面对希望 逆着光 感觉爱存在的地方 一直就在我身旁 na shi lei guang na li liang wo bu xiang zai qu di dang mian dui xi wang ni zhe guang gan jue ai cun zai de di fang yi zhi jiu zai wo shen pang แสงระยิบนะยับที่มาจากน้ำตาของคุณ ฉันไม่ต้องการที่จะต่อต้านพลังนั้นอีกต่อไป สุดท้ายแล้ว ฉันมาเผชิญหน้ากับคุณด้วยความหวัง และ หันหน้าเข้าหาแสง ตอนนี้ ฉันรู้สึกถึงสถานที่ที่ความรักคงอยู่ ที่นั้นคือข้าง ๆ ฉันเอง 我以为我能后退 反复证明 这份爱有多不对 背对着你如此漆黑 忍住疲惫 睁开眼 打开窗 才发现你就是光芒 wo yi wei wu lu hou tui fan fu zheng ming zhe fen ai you duo bu dui bei dui zhe ni ru ci qi hei ren zhu pi bei zheng kai yan da kai chuang cai fa xian ni jiu shi guang mang ฉันนึกว่า ฉันสามารถถอนตัวออกจากก้าวย่างนี้ได้ พิสูจน์ครั้งแล้วครั้งเล่า ว่าความรักของเราเคยผิดพลาดไปตรงไหน เมื่อฉันหันหลังให้กับคุณ ทุกอย่างกลับมืดมนไปหมด โอบกอดแผ่นหลังที่เหนื่อยล้าของตัวเอง ฉันมองลอดผ่านหน้าต่างที่ถูกเปิด สิ่งเดียวที่ฉันนึกขึ้นได้ คุณคือแสงสว่าง 有一束光 那瞬间 是什么痛得刺眼 你的视线 是谅解 为什么舍不得熄灭 我逆着光却看见 you yi shu guang na shun jian shi shen me tong de ci yan ni de shi xian shi liang jie wei shen me she bu de xi mie wo ni zhe guang qu kan jian ในชั่วขณะนั้น แสงที่พาดผ่าน เข้ามาทิ่มแทงดวงตาของฉัน สายตาของคุณนั้น ราวกับเข้าใจ ทำไม คุณถึงไม่หันกลับมา ฉันยืนอยู่ หันหน้าเข้าหาแสง และที่แห่งนั้นฉันเห็น 那是泪光那力量 我不想再去抵挡 面对希望 逆着光 感觉爱存在的地方 一直就在我身旁 na shi lei guang na li liang wo bu xiang zai qu di dang mian dui xi wang ni zhe guang gan jue ai cun zai de di fang yi zhi jiu zai wo shen pang แสงระยิบนะยับที่มาจากน้ำตาของคุณ ฉันไม่ต้องการที่จะต่อต้านพลังนั้นอีกต่อไปแล้ว สุดท้ายนี้ ฉันมาเผชิญหน้ากับคุณด้วยความหวัง และ หันหน้าเข้าหาแสง ตอนนี้ ฉันรู้สึกถึงสถานที่ที่ความรักคงอยู่ ที่แห่งนั้นคือข้าง ๆ ฉันเอง 光芒 你是光芒 guang mang ni shi guang mang แสงสว่าง คุณคือแสงสว่าง
@blinkherehylt23164 жыл бұрын
I misss thisss!! This is the best produce 101 China part and performance!!
@prinzparamio20264 жыл бұрын
Sorry not sorry but out of all vocal performances I've seen in survival shows, this was the best LIKE LITERALLY THE BEEEST in my opinion.
rewatching this, i wish chuang let their top vocals to perform in one group [in the show itself] cause we got our top 4 vocals debuting but stilll i wish we can have the really2 good vocal ones to perform
@pollyzhou47064 жыл бұрын
还是觉得创造101最经典,很多歌都好听,学员也有很多有实力的
@rmbaby94822 жыл бұрын
天呐 每次听到芳语唱的那段就会起鸡皮疙瘩
@polyrize66214 жыл бұрын
<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="87">1:27</a> the winning part
@yamy86354 жыл бұрын
創一我心目中的神舞台之一!! 好聽到雞皮疙瘩!! 《逆光》《逆風》《木蘭說》也是我最愛的經典舞台
@jingchau3 жыл бұрын
這麼多個版本,這個和聲真的最好聽
@nicnic20994 жыл бұрын
the best performance in this show indeed!!!
@Kimmy-mu6lb3 жыл бұрын
This is such a gem. One of the best performances to date.
OMG, it's amazing how beautiful their voices are!! I am so in love with the way they sing.. they are all very talented!! This presentation is one of my favorites without a doubt. 💅
@pammy67736 ай бұрын
Their vocals are all insane!
@lynnl20332 жыл бұрын
这个版本是合唱里和声最棒的 非常喜欢
@phoebe95702 жыл бұрын
Kimberly is so considerate that she chose the flat part and made it a good piece
@ngocanhnguyenthi9460 Жыл бұрын
LYRICS: Zuo ci liao ying ru zuo qu li wei Ye xu wo yi zhi hai pa you da an Ye xu ai jing jing zai feng li da zhuan Li kai shi huai Hen duan zan you zhong lai You shi hou zi wen zi da Wo bu yao kun nan ba wo men ji san Wo ze bei zi ji na me bu yong gan Yi han mei you dao da Yong bao guo huan shi hai pa Yong li tui kai ni Wo yi ran liu xia You yi shu guang na shun jian Shi shi me tong de ci yan Ni de shi xian shi liang jie Wei shi me she bu de xi mien Wo ni zhuo guang que kan jian Na shi lei guang na li liang Wo bu xiang zai qu di dang Mian dui xi wang ni zhuo guang Gan jue ai cun zai de di fang Yi zhi jiu zai wo shen pang Wo yi wei wo neng hou tui Fan fu zheng ming Zhe fen ai you duo bu dui Bei dui zhuo ni ru ci qi hei Ren zhu pi bei Zheng kai yan da kai chuang Cai fa xian Ni jiu shi guang mang Guang mang Ni shi guang mang
@dithrolungat60143 жыл бұрын
Will always be most Legendary Performance in the history of CHUANG. The best vocal team in CHUANG history. ❤
@awasetsu3 жыл бұрын
One of the best performances of all PD seasons ever
@ruili48564 жыл бұрын
相比青你2的vocal组,还是觉得这组唱得好,和声也好听
@tcytcy68634 жыл бұрын
Rui LI 這是創造101的
@kc5744 жыл бұрын
ChungYan Tse 她説相比
@Lee-jb4us4 жыл бұрын
跟易燃易爆炸有得比吧
@windycloud91644 жыл бұрын
lee tieong seng 沒有得比! 差太遠!
@windycloud91644 жыл бұрын
其實,青2 也有不少 能唱,但節目打壓太過!
@la64553 жыл бұрын
The another amazing thing in this group is the best vocals in the same group here.
For real, I'm in love with this stage! They made me cry... The feeling, the vocals, the talent, they are AMAZING!
@royalmajesty245110 ай бұрын
This is the first time I've watch this. They're all amazing vocalist! I wish I discovered this kind of survival show earlier (The first 2 survival shows I've watched are chuang 2020 & ywy2)