The books always mention elders telling stories to kits, but we never get to hear any of them. So I always imagined that they were telling the stories in this book. Timeline weirdness aside

I wish Raincloud showed up again - I found the ending to her story kind of haunting when I was young, and with TBC questioning the "a leader's word is law" rule and eventually changing it entirely, it would've been a good time to bring her back. It's funny how both of the stories dedicated to that code seem to explore why it's a bad idea.

Badgerfang's story hits hard when you first read it, and it sticks with you. When I finally thought I was over it, they showed it all over again in Blackstar's novella and broke my heart all over again :'D As for when each code comes into law, maybe the timeline isn't in chronological order? As in, maybe the first code was not the first code created? It's simply just a set of rules for them to follow

crying over badgerfang once again at my big age😭😭😭😭may starclan light his path 😭😭😭😭😭😭

poppydawns story with longtail and darkstripe always stuck with me

This book introduced us to Flowerstar, Smallstar, Ripplestar, Mossfire, Daisytail, Badgerfang, and Redscar. I love these guys so much!

"Cats shouldn't kill each other during fights" *looks at the Wind Clan cat that murdered Badgerfang.*

I REAAAALLY hope they mention the part where leaders were picked upon bloodline in any new DOTC books. That’s super interesting and I forgot entirely. I could see Skystar doing that for sure

i liked Daisytail's story, and i liked Longtail's story, i started to care for him more because of that. These stories may not be as true, but they are still fun to read

I loved Code of the Clans for all the hidden information shown. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe that before this time, the only way to see the Warrior code was to read it on the very shifty-back-then Warriors website. As well as some background characters being fleshed out, and I especially liked the chapter where Longtail eats prey and Poppydawn dies, and Longtail believes if he didn't eat prey she would've survived. What was your favourite story in the book?

I dunno why I was fixated on a small mistake, but you said Splashtail on code 3 and I did a double take. I thought they just reused the name Splashtail on accident, like how there are three Milkfurs, all related. But Splashtail in code of the clans is supposed to be Splashheart, not Splashtail. It's alright, mistakes like that happen as the prefix "Splash" matches a major character from the newest arc, so I can see where the confusion comes up. I always get Moth Flight and Mothwing mixed up.

I wish we got to see more of the clans' shared folklore, legends, etc. I'm fascinated by the idea of events from the past being distorted and exaggerated to tell a better story, the way legends are. It's an aspect of clan culture that doesn't get the attention I think it deserves.

I love so many characters in the field guides

The art for this video is SO CUTE 😭 I love how you can understand the dynamics and personality of each character

I wonder if they're ever going to update the Code of the Clans for The Broken Code and onwards?

Its crazy to me that only the makn series books are about 30. Once i counted all of the books in total and ended up near 80, and that was still years ago lol

Aww I love the art, Sunny!

You know, by the time I got to Sandstorm's passage, I realized something. Before Firestar joined the clans, before all these rules were put in place, the clans still had a long way to go from escaping the savagery and violence they had in the beginning before Starclan was invented. This wasn't just a book about clan history. It was essentially telling the story of the warrior clans' progress, how through signs and circumstances, Starclan eventually them to become the noble cats they are today who live by honor and stability. And Firestar, being the chosen one, was the culmination of all that the warrior code stood for and brought it front in center before all of the clans. Just think, without Firestar, the clans may not have learned to truly appreciate what the warrior code means. They might not have come together to stop Bloodclan, find their new territory, or even face the Dark Forest. And Code 16, which hadn't been part of the code at this time, would ultimately cement this change.

Mossfoot and Jumpfire though But I used to strive to believe these stories don't go in a chronical order... Aside from that they're pretty nice.

New Video!

i like this channle

I think what we have in this book is simply a response to the mini contradictions with in the main series and all this supplementary stuff. Victoria Holmes never struck me, as being all that bright, I saw her in an interview and honestly she was special. So given that she put a very modern cat to tell these tales of how the cold came to be is an after effect. And I do believe that they did not go back and read the prophecies, began, or any of the other books for that matter before they wrote this particular guide. So in at times, it does seem like it doesn’t make sense, I think they’re going with a collection rather than an actual fact Depiction of history and how the code became generationally locked into these cats mines.

Omg I’m so early

First