Comparing the New Castles of Burgundy Special Edition to the 20th Anniversary Edition

Рет қаралды 3,490

Күн бұрын

So today I took out my older version of Castles of Burgundy to compare the components with the new Special Edition that I just received this week! I just decided to jump right in pulling pieces out without any preparation and without even having gotten to play the new edition yet and I'm also still getting used to this new overhead camera I'm using so I apologize for the places where the focus gets pretty wonky.. I actually have some better shots in my unboxing video for the Special Edition pieces so check that out if you're interested in seeing those a little more clearly. I'm really looking forward to getting a playthrough of this with Sean later this week so keep an eye out for that as well! I hope you find at least some of this helpful if you're deciding on a version and as always thank you so much for watching!
Also check out Sean Peck's videos with and without myself over at his own channel‪@PecktecGames‬ !
Timestamps:
00:00 - Intro
03:49 - Cardboard Hexes
09:54 - Game Box Size Difference
10:59 - Rulebooks
12:14 - Game Boards
14:10 - Expansion Player Boards
15:49 - New Dual Layer Boards vs Old Player Boards
17:47 - New Acrylic Hexes
19:31 - Player Aids
23:20 - Shields
24:31 - Area Completion Bonus Tokens
25:14 - 100/200 Point Tracking Tokens
25:45 - Turn Order Trackers
27:15 - Dice
27:37 - Trade Goods Crates
29:23 - Coins
29:59 - Workers
31:24 - Trade Route Expansion
32:00 - Automa "Chateauma" Cards
32:45 - Alternate Portrait Point Trackers
33:10 - Point Tracker Miniature Busts
33:57 - Border Post Expansion Tokens
34:40 - New Vineyard Expansion Components
39:41 - New Castle Hex Miniatures
41:20 - Wrap-up/Outtro

Пікірлер: 35

@Socksrule3032 2 ай бұрын

Thank you for this video. It was great to see the comparsion before I buy the KS reprint!

@organiccardboard Ай бұрын

You're welcome, I'm glad you found it useful! Thank you for watching!

@otakuofmine 2 ай бұрын

if you still havent found out (or just for people here, i had to check it too), an "automa" is essentially another term for a boardgame AI, simulating an enemy. I guess so u can play for 2 players "solo".

@organiccardboard 2 ай бұрын

Yep, automa is a term that was sorta "coined" by Stonemeier games when they made the first solo opponent that was called the "Automa" for their game Viticulture. They chose the word automa because it's Italian for automaton and since their game was set in Italy they wanted to go with the Italian word.

@otakuofmine 2 ай бұрын

@@organiccardboard I see, funny how those words catch on. Love to hear details about such things! thx for the response

@organiccardboard 2 ай бұрын

@otakuofmine You're welcome and thank you for commenting! And for watching!

@wyatth2992 11 ай бұрын

When you're describing the feel of the acrylic hexes, they remind me of the Project L pieces. If that helps anyone.

@organiccardboard 11 ай бұрын

Nice! I haven't had the chance to play that one yet..

@Copterman 2 ай бұрын

I am considering backing this, but I don't know if I should go for acrylic tokens or no. Do you use the acrylic or the cardboard? Recommendation?

@organiccardboard 2 ай бұрын

I would definitely go for the acrylic tokens as well as the hexes. I only grabbed the acrylic hexes last time and kicked myself afterwards when I saw my buddy from Pecktec Games' copy that had the rest of the tokens in acrylic as well. I jumped back on the latest KS just to order those. They're totally not necessary, just as the hexes aren't, but they're so nice that I would definitely recommend them. I still think the miniatures though are a little overkill for me so I'm not planning for those. The main box is already freakin' huge, lol!

@Copterman 2 ай бұрын

@@organiccardboard yeah miniatures don't appeal at all. what about the play mat?

@organiccardboard 2 ай бұрын

I'm not really a playmat guy unless it fits in the box like it does in Flamecraft for example.. In general, I hate storing game components outside of the main box. I'm already short on room and for me personally they really don't add to my enjoyment anymore than any generic neoprene surface on the play area does. Pecktec picked it up too but I'd prefer to just play without it on a neoprene covered table. If I remember right there may have been issues with either dark colors or blurring too which is common with playmats. I might be wrong about that though.. 🤔

@rogerhobbs9674 3 ай бұрын

Does the acrylic set come with castle tiles (or does that exist in a separate set) for those who don't prefer the 3D castles in gameplay?

@organiccardboard 3 ай бұрын

Yes they come with the acrylic set. The special edition comes with cardboard castle tiles as well. The minis are just something you switch out on your board when you place them into your duchy so they are always optional but they come standard with the Special Edition so you'd have to buy an older set if you didn't want them at all.

@rogerhobbs9674 3 ай бұрын

@@organiccardboard Awesome - thanks for the great video. I'm hoping the reprint campaign will launch soon because the acrylic tiles are nowhere to be found. 😞 The holy grail for my new favorite board game. Thanks again!

@organiccardboard 3 ай бұрын

@rogerhobbs9674 Oh yeah, it's a fantastic game! I'm actually looking forward to picking up the extra acrylic pieces myself for the workers and other bits as I passed those up the first round. Thanks for the nice comments and thanks again for watching!

@ninjac8866 Ай бұрын

Thank you for this great comparison video. I saw it after I'd backed the reprint. I think my aging eyes will definitely cope better with the larger tiles and less busy board! I'm also glad I went for the acrylic tiles as I'm also hoping it will reduce wear and tear on the components.

@organiccardboard Ай бұрын

@ninjac8866 I think it's well worth getting all of the acrylic bits! The game is huge so be ready for that 😅 I ended up giving the small box to my LFGS's public collection though because even considering size, I know I'll never not want to play the big one, haha. I'm glad this was helpful for you and thank you for watching!

@Scamander 10 ай бұрын

Still waiting for mine, lol (*crying in European*). The cardboard victory point tokens are there, because the classic pledge doesn't include the busts. :)

@organiccardboard 10 ай бұрын

Oh no! I hope it arrives soon! Good to know, I didn't realize that the regular set didn't include the busts.

@chantal256 9 ай бұрын

Hi is this the retail version? Or the kickstarter? 😊😊

@organiccardboard 9 ай бұрын

This is the Kickstarted version but honestly I'm not sure what would be different between the Kickstarter and the retail version of the Special Edition.

@batac667 3 ай бұрын

Does the new dutchy boards and game board fit in the box from 20th anniversary?

@organiccardboard 3 ай бұрын

Hmm I don't think so.. I actually gave away my older copy so I can't check for certain.. Are you just asking for travel purposes?

@batac667 3 ай бұрын

@@organiccardboard yes, I would just put everything cardboard from special edition into this box + few duchy boards (not dual layered, just a tile board with plastic insert) so that I have this for traveling

@organiccardboard 3 ай бұрын

I think it'd still be hard to expect it to fit but maybe? I wonder if anyone has any good travel option ideas in the bgg forums. I don't think the tiles would fit so you might be able to just throw all of those tile bags into another bag.

@batac667 3 ай бұрын

@@organiccardboard ill try my best to fit it, fingers crossed. Will leave a comment here after my new edition arrives..Can't wait for reprint on gamefound, such a gem of a game :) do you maybe know some info about shipping? Campaign is in Q2 of this year, but I dont see any info about shipping date

@organiccardboard 3 ай бұрын

I hope it works! Worse case scenario you could probably get a smaller tote box and just put the essentials in there to take places. The vineyard expansion is going to add to that space a lot though but it's my favorite expansion so worth getting there wherever you're going. I don't know about shipping though.. I actually wasn't aware of the reprint since I got in on the first one.

@Lucky_Red_Fish 11 ай бұрын

Even the old version is not the old 2011 version, they are all newer versions!

@organiccardboard 11 ай бұрын

Yes you are correct! I think I mentioned that somewhere but it was easier to just say new and old rather than Special Edition and 20th Anniversary Edition, haha.

@PMMagro 5 ай бұрын

I think the oldest version has less off an ADHD colour-scheme. The big Special edition has nicer art though. The Anniversary edition has many nice player mats etc though, like many extra expansions to the base game. I will not change my orginal edition for Anniversay but whould never buy the old (the Anniversary has many expansion included). For me as the game is so good extra replayability is king.