I died at “WHO ARE YOU!?!?” 😂😂😂

It's always fun to see someone discover Haley for the first time. A lot of songs she does are better than the originals.

When she started to scat, your face went from transfixed to a kid on Christmas morning. You were as awestruck as I was when I first saw this.

Haley Reinhart - Cant help falling in love. (Happy Tears WARNING)

I have loved her since she was on American idol she should’ve won honestly. Her tone and breath control and clean vocals and growling low notes just send shivers up the spine. She is so underrated it’s criminal

A big nod to Scott Bradlee's arrangements and flawless piano playing...

You should see her rendition of Seven Nation Army that she did with Post Modern Jukebox! UNFFFF!

Maybe my 10th viewing of this reaction over the last several months, but what a rare treat this is indeed. How often in all recorded history do we as human beings get to witness one human falling in love with another in the span of 8 minutes? What a wonderful miracle to witness. (even if I hoplessly fell in love with her first, lol) I bow to the supirior paring of Do Legacy Dee and the uber talented Haley, may you both live happily ever after!

This reaction. This felt as if I were watching her for the first time. Jaw dropped. Incomprehensible. What the f$%% did she just do? Yes. Exactly. Great video.

Honey, you've just scratched the surface of Haley's immense talent! She slays ballads, rock, blues, jazz, and a few country. Treat yourself to an evening of listening to her music: the kind you can feel and not just hear.

Four years later, this is still one of my favorite reactions on KZfaq!!!

Postmodern Jukebox ft Haley Reinhart is my jam. I love t he way do a different take on new songs with an old big bad flare.

Haley uses no auto tune btw, non of the postmodern jukebox singers use autotune. It's amazing because their live performances sound better than their official video. You need to react to the rest of her covers. I would suggest "Mad World" and "Opps I did it again"

I love seeing your face change everytime Hayley pulls out a tool that you had no idea she had.

You can’t react to any other version of creep now. This cover CANCELLED all of the others.

Well this is definitely my favourite reaction to Haley's Creep.

Everything from PMJ is just magic.

Haley and Postmodern Jukebox also do a cover of Seven Nation Army that is outstanding. Great reaction.

each different facial expression you made in this video gave me some extra 2 years of life

to quote Steven Tyler .."Girl..you sing sexy!"

So just watched this reaction for like the millionth time and it never gets old. Haley is probably my new favorite female vocalist at this point and Dee your smile just lights up a room every time. Love, love, love your reactions. Keep being the beautiful human being you are on a daily basis.

Not only does she NOT use any auto-tune, this song was recorded in a single take after recording 2 other songs!!

Dee Omar: I'm done Haley: No you ain't As somebody who's loved Creep and performed it myself for years, I also had a big dumb grin on my face when I saw this for the first time, you can't not

Love your honest reaction :) Haley sings like a dirty angel :D

just love the expression on her face when she was in like 5 seconds for hearing haley the very first time, she'd be like wut da flying fook... ^^

I agree with you. I cried the first time I heard Haley sing this song.

They are amazing!! Their cover of 7 Nation Army with Haley is just astonishing! You should definitely check it out

You have to check out her American Idol performances, particularly House of the Rising Sun.

When you can DO IT ONE TAKE AND THAT'S A WRAP...NOTHING MORE TO SAY

She nailed the 1940s torch singer vibe to the wall and made a trophy of it to take home. Outstanding!

The piano player, Scott Bradly, runs a youtube channel called Post Modern Jukebox. Haley is singing his arrangement. PMJ is a rabbit hole you will ABSOLUTELY enjoy.

Been following Haley since American Idol. She's fantastic.

I've seen and heard many reactions to Haley's rendition, Dee, yours is still the best.

Haley Reinhart and Jessie J are my two queens. Keep outdoing themselves every time I watch them.

Haley Reinhart's amazing - she was on American Idol, and she's since been touring with Postmodern Jukebox and Casey Abrams (another American Idol alum). you should definitely react to more Postmodern Jukebox. they literally take modern hits and make them sound vintage. their arrangements are incredible. they've also worked with Mario Jose.

I have only discovered this version last week and I am in LOVE with it! Thanks for the react!

I love you're reaction, it was real and amazing and right. Nobody can top this and radiohead thank you for this song, but my god you must have to bow to this woman your selves.

At the end when you said this is your favorite version: Yeah, we know. Ours too. In fact, we knew it would be your favorite before you did.

Daaaamn 😆 Dee I freaking LOOOVE your reactions 👏👌👏

It's like we are trying to describe seeing Jesus, Elvis and an alien encounter at a McDonald's in Fresno California after watching Haley sing 'Creep.'

this is one of my favorite reactions of ALL TIME.... you rock! you made me laugh out loud at least 5 times, and I was smiling the entire time watching you enjoy the video... very nice!

This is the best creep version period ------Hi Dee

I love Haley so much. She brought me here, and now I love you! Thank you for your energy and the love you've shown to this amazing woman.

I love your passion. You were blown away and shared that with us. Well done.

I was hoping to find a video of you reacting to this song and you didn't disappoint, watching your face was a thing of beauty, that was 8 mins of my life I will gladly give you x

Your reaction is priceless and it's a Christmas gift I was not expecting God bless you and your family going forward

Your reaction videos are so well done, so professional and at the same time so sincere and warm, keep doing your thing.

this reaction gives me life like omf this was so me when i first heard her voice its so bloody captivating love love love Reinharts voice so is such a queen

Loved your performance Dee it's great to see your appreciation of Haley, she's a joy to my ears too😊

This is my favorite reaction chanel on youtube thank you for your content and enormous positive energy that your spread through it.

Your reaction is the best I’ve seen so far! You are so fun and funny! Love you 😘

I love this girl's reaction to creep😂

So glad you finally got to watch Haley’s version! She’s incredible!

I heard that was Haley's first "take" on that recording! She's my all time fave singer, love-at-first-song when I heard her on American Idol. This last year I've seen a HUGE transition and growth in her singing presence. UGH She's coming into her own for sure and I'm going to follow her forever 💛👏 You are so cool btw... love your reactions rotfl

Love seeing people fall for Haley! Great reaction.

As far as I’ve been told this was recorded live and in one take.... boom

Your facial expressions are top notch!! Her voice is beyond spoken words. This is one of my favorite versions of creep. Brian justin crum is also at the top!

This reaction must encapsulate the inner thoughts of so many people who discover this cover lol

Hailey placed 3rd on the 10th season of American Idol - that’s how her career started! She’s done many songs with Post Morten Jukebox. You should check them out!

Yesssss Queen! Served it on a silver platter

Saw her in concert even better in person. She filmed this video in one take.

She is one of my favorite artists. Her voice is EVERYTHING 😍

This is your favorite version of Creep? Well, this is my favorite Creep reaction! Your little squeal at 2:51 totally messed me up!

That was a great reaction.. you were awesome. This is my first time seeing your channel. I love the creepy version lol..

I loved your reaction it was real and then funny and then when she was getting more intense you were like dayumm girl when are you gonna stop raising the bar lmao

The fantastic job reacting to the song! probably one of the best covers in modern history. Haley and the band together in the song war fantastic! Your reaction is absolutely priceless. I love it and I love you!

Two things: 1. I really love Radiohead. I grew up on them, I love them. 2. I very, very rarely consider a cover to be better than the original. This is better that the original by far. It’s a beautiful song, but it belongs to her now. I doubt anyone could ever sing this song better than she did. That’s it, go home, no point in even trying. That she isn’t a household name is a tragedy. Yes, I’m perhaps a little biased because blues and jazz is what I sing, but I don’t care, she’s that good, she should be super famous and getting all the awards.

I know you did this six years ago. If you haven't found it already, there is an audition video of a 15 year old Caroline Baran doing Creep. I believe the story goes that she was originally tapped to do this. She also kills it.

You should check out her version of Can't help Falling In Love I believe its the best cover of it, amazing song

There is so mu'h going on with Haley's vocal control and intensity that just blows everybody away. She came up out of an amazing struggle on American Idol. She is so amazing and wins hearts like CRUSH Baby!!! Loved your reaction. I've seen several reactions to this video and each are are stunned with awe by Haley's rendition of this song. The thing is...she has got tons to explore and so much to give. 😍🎶🔥♥️🔥🎶😍

Normally i require at least 3 videos i like to sub..... this is officially the exception

The more I watch your KZfaq, the more I feel like listening to my favorite YTB videos. Love ya

REALLY LOVED your reaction (so I hit the SUBSCIRBE button). I love a self-confident woman who isn't intimidated by another woman, and actually CHEERS her on! SO much fun to watch you reacting to this video, Dee.

LOVED LOVED LOVED the reaction! SUBBED!🤗 Two YOUNG girls did it on The Voice somewhere. It was GREAT! 😎😁 Look forward to more!⚘✌

She is Hysterical...I had to subscribe..Great reaction!

She got my attention years ago on American Idol and she should have won. What a marvelous singer and performer! Loved your reaction.

I just ran across this and I wanted to say thank you. Just a real person enjoying and appreciating a real artist. Your face says it all. Again thank you. By the way thank you for being a strong beautiful woman. Need more of you.

Haley set a new bar for this song!!

Lmao I love your reactions

Best reaction to HR yet. When the aliens come I will show them YOUR vid as an example of how emotion can shift from one person to another. Both your reaction and her performance define what it is to be human. Kudos.

MA'AM YOUR REACTIONS ARE SOOOO FABULOUS!

I think that vids now on about 85 million views. Haley rocks!

There are no more creepy Creep versions that you have not already seen. Glad you like Haley (and PMJ!). Catch their tour next time they come through. Much fun!

Love this reaction. I do not be think anyone will ever top this, Haley is incredible 💕

She loaded that song with everything.

I love postmodern jukebox. Idk what it is but almost everything is just amazing. The voices the different years and styles..... it’s just amazing

This was recorded 100% live, and, she did that in one take.

In the pictuary under the word GOBSMACKED IS A PICTURE OF DEE OMAR . SHE GOT YOU BABE.

Haley is great..but you, girl, are so special and funny! GREAT VIDEO!

Man!...Loved that reaction!

My favorite reaction video. Ever. God I love that version of that song.

If you've seen the Extra Gum Commercial, she's the one singing Can't Help Falling In Love.

She's fucking amazing! I love hearing other people's reactions. Great job with yours!! My favorite too!!

I subscribed to you just because of this reaction! Soooo great!🤣🤣🤣❤❤❤

You should also check her out singing White Rabbit. She kills it.

You need to see Haley and Puddles Pity Party just ripping up "Mad World". One of the most disturbingly beautiful things I have ever seen.

If you want another woman performing Creep, check out Daniela Andrade. Very understated, but goosebump-worthy :)

Your smile at 4:44 at the scatting was magical to me.

I agree Dee. This has to be one of my fav versions of all time.

Stone cold epic reaction! Please keep up the good work and react to more genres! As a hardcore subscriber may I say I adore what you do, and I apologise right now for taking the liberty to say you are beautiful! XxX