Somewhere Robbie Daymond is dressed as Boromir...

That Geralt costume is still INSANELY GOOD.

I love how people react to Matt's costumes like "WTF?!" Man is a cosplayer not just a voice actor.

29:14 it’s been years since I’ve seen Lotr but Ashley’s impression of when pippin gets attacked while holding the palantir is so spot on it had me rolling😂

Gotta love the public shaming to Amazon for failing at their one job.

The fact that the bit has come full circle from Matt saying Ashley looked like a young Billy Boyd to her dressing up as his character on the episode is just (chef's kiss).

Marisha as Taliesin looks like David Tenant in Good Omens

Travis with long hair......I feel......conflicted.

Honestly, Laura KILLED it as Robbie XD I loved it XD

Gandalf the Grey with bright purple fingernails, absolutely gorgeous.

Laura and Travis as the Briarwoods is so good

I think the soldier B bit is one of my favorite CR bits.

2023: Ashley literally just looks like she's in Growing Pains again.

Would have been hilarious if the real Merry or Pippin actors guested for this year’s Halloween episode.

Why does Marisha look so good as Legolas

22:10 you can hear Taliesin take pyschic damage in the background

The Fellowship this year was amazing, but I will never get over Laura as The Gentleman.

Matt being all humble casual, but even a layman like me can tell some of his costumes must have taken forever to make.

Laura and Travis as the Briarwoods is giving SUCH 'What We Do In the Shadows' vibes and now I have a MIGHTY NEED to see them as Nadja and Lazlo XD 18:17 well now I need Liam to rock a smokey eye look ALL the time, good lord sir 🥵 I need to go back and rewatch the 2021 halloween episode, Laura as Robbie is absolutely on point!

“Watch it again bro”

Ashley 's Emma Frost was beautiful!

"Get a theater degree kids. It's not totally useless." fucking killed me 😂😂😂😂😂😂

They joked that Marisha's Legolas looked like Tilda Swinton. But I was seeing Draco Malfoy.

i love that this is a throwback to that one sam shirt of small ashley where everyone said she looked like billy boyd.

cannot wait for the bells hells edition of 2016 and 2020, the npc's and villains from this campaign deserve their halloween spotlight

Laura kills it as The Gentleman

I love that Ashley was Pippin, given that shirt Sam wore of her young and everyone said she looked like Billy Boyd.

I completely forgot the episode where they dressed as themselves, and i fell in love with it a second time xD Also, Sam as Mr. Fantastic in the X-Men is stil legendary.

I can't express how much I love halloween episodes Having to wait for new eps makes me sad, so I'm currently in the middle of ep. 74 of C3, but did I tune in yesterday just to watch the beginning of the live and oh boy I'm glad I did. New animated intro on top of costumes was such a treat

At the very least Sam chose the right comic universe with mr fantastic even if not xmen 😅

people dont talk about how gorgeous ashley looked as emma frost nearly enough

Watching them go from one table, to pandemic distanced, and back to a table was healing

I never knew I needed Marisha to cosplay legolas until now!!! HOT DAMN SHE LOOKS FIRE 🔥

Am i the only one thinking that short hair look good on Laura?

Ashley dressed as herself from Growing Pains. 😍 So cute 🥰

I saw a live comment that Sam​break tradition of wearing cheap costume/break the theme of the table, this time.

She really does look like Billy Boyd

God, I remember watching the first Halloween episode. Matt’s costume blew it outta the water. I shouldn’t be surprised given his cosplay background, but it kinda floored me.

13:38 Travis says as I, a Drama major, sit watching this video in my dorm room, avoiding my homework for my Drama class.

also matt being spot on with gandalfs voice. a part of me was like 'oh wow nice impress- heyyyyy wait a minute'

"You're the only one alive here" "Cheers" Oh liam.

Ashley in The Rings of Power would fit RIGHT in!! WoW! What a perfect Hobbit! 🥰

I think Matt's Gandalf costume was a LOT more XPToLevel3 than he was hoping.. xD

Rest in piece soldier B

😂 I *just* watched the OG compilation before the 2023 was added this morning too - amazinggg ❤️

God i love Matt's gambit!

Thank you for this Up-to-Date compilation! Critters are The BEST! 😍

Gotta love gandalf with pretty purple nails

27:00 marisha was hawt AF as dark phoenix

travis that long hair looks so good on you!

Ashley being Pippin while remembering how in love she was with being called to look like young Billy Boyd truly makes my day

“I hear vampires burn get the diesel”. I lost it laughing.

This video just kept getting better and better!! XD SO GOOD!!!

Quick correction for Travis for those who were as confused as me: Richard Moll (Bull from Night Court) played Two Face in Batman the Animated Series. Travis played Two Face in Batman: The Telltale Series.

Dear god it's almost been a decade

Was lucky enough to be live for 2016. It was amazing.

4:47 does anyone else get big Milo from Atlantis vibes off of this character?

Matt: I have a problem Me: I wish I had a problem like that

Thank you!

6:00 Lord Briarwood may be dead, but he is the life of the party! To make a call way back, do a Justifiers costume party.

My first ever episode of CR was that Halloween episode back in 2015. I wanted to know why that handsome man was dressed as a barmaid and if my wife would be mad at me for making that my next costume. The laughter and joy was charismatic and I've been hooked ever since. MAN that's a lot of hours to be a critter. Best chore-buddies ever. Thanks for reminding me of my roots with the show/fandom.

Damn. I remember the first ones cuz I googled rat queens. Never knew how big crit role would get.

I love them so much

I cannot believe that it's been nearly 10 years of CR!! Each one of these felt SOOO long ago but also like last week. I literally had to pause the video when I realized it's been years since Robbie began playing as Dorian.

These people are good people

it was so smart to have all the hobbits on one side, it really sells the sizes.

C3e2 was my 2nd ever episode and I was so confused haha

Laura's Robbie impression sounds like Serana from Skyrim

This is my second time watching the 2022 intro and I just realized that Travis went "Ja" and not "Da" ...

Marisha and Ashely look AMAZING!

There’s just something so chaotic about this year’s Halloween special and them as the Fellowship of the Ring😂😂😂

Ey, Sam finally understood the assignment in 2023!

Laura Bailey ❤❤❤❤

why is travis doing a german accent for "peter rasputin" lol

i started watching them 2021 in C3 after my girlfriend broke up with me. then i stopped, finished my studies, getting my life back and back here i am too starting with C2 from 2018. even then this video made me realize its the 3rd Halloween since the breakup. time just rushed away with a snap of a finger. idk if this is a good thing or a bad thing. i still miss my ex girlfriend, but those friends here give me good vibes everytime i watch an episode. for me its thursday everyday

Has Liam done a Nightcrawler cosplay since?!

It is fascinating how a round of absolute nerds like this have a guy who doesn't know some of the most iconic quotes in Fantasy.

Laura and Marisha as Rat Queens...the way I screamed was unholy

Man i didnt know xp to lvl3 was in lotr!

It would be amazing if they were given creative control of LoTR related adaptations going forward! Also, I would love for them to play a Star Trek RPG for a one-shot and to be given their own animated Star Trek series by Paramount+.

These are great! Where do we watch the full episodes?? They looked like such fun times!

please someone confirm that there was a microsoft sound at like 9:57, this is the second video tonight thats had a sound like that randomly and im going insane

Next year he will dress up as the characters from Baldur's Gate 3

I wish Travis dressed up as Roy Mustang instead of Two Face

I was hoping that Matt would be showing up as Vincent

Ashley is basically indistinguishable from Billy Boyd, and it's hilarious

Anyone else sad that when they did the characters they voiced, that Liam didn't do warden from for honor?

Liam actually looks like the Merry actor from the movie, so Liam should have been playing Merry and Ashley play Frodo. Plus the Frodo actor has a childish face that fits cute Ashley better.

I don’t know if it’s needed, but **Campaign 3 spoilers**!! 4:58 So, this is how I learned that Planerider Ryn wasn’t the only one who lost an arm while turned to stone. Lmao.

i thought 2020 Ashley was mr Susan for a second

I will never be able to look at hobbits the same way.

to this day 2016 Laura and Travis as the Briarwoods have the official right to murder me for their own pleasure.....

11:47 Laura not dressing up as Jaina Proudmoore is a travesty!!! If Ashley was there I wondered if she would've dressed up as Gretchen Grundler from Recess

Lord of the rings Costumes Is surprising

18:56

why didn't Sam dress up as Sam from lotr??? missed opportunity

Nobody correcting sam on the "He's Bilbos grandson" is concerning

In every single LOTR picture, I think Sam looks photoshopped in. Even when I’ve seen the video and know he is actually right there, he still looks like he’s been copy/pasted in to me.

2023: It's a pity they didn't use character names from Bored of the Rings...like Legoland and Borrowmoney...😊

you didnt voice 2face.... it was Richard Moll. but nice try lol