I’d argue that Mephiles killing Sonic should rank higher since 1. Sonic was technically resurrected rather than a Miracle Max moment so Mephiles actually did kill Sonic 2. Mephiles took this route to cap off his reign of terror across the timeline. 3. This leads to Solaris nearly destroying the entire multiverse

5:24 to 6:11 Sonic's Werehog Transformation AKA The best opening cutscene in Sonic's gaming history.

I've always enjoyed the dark moment in the final story of SA2.

The movie design joke was funny

Sonic The Hedgehog Fan Theories: B. S. To Truth Bomb

According to the Sonic Twitter takeover 2 Station Square was Rebuilt after the Chaos Incident

Fun fact: that creepy theme from Sonic CD's sound test is the boss theme in US version of this game

I agree with this list, only I would've put Mephiles killing Sonic at the darkest end! But why? Because he killed Sonic in a very cowardly fashion then laughed manically when Elise started crying, which resulted in him finally being able to merge with Iblis to become Solaris and destroy time and space leaving nothing but darkness. His permanent defeat resulted in a time reset where he no longer exists and this made Elise really upset as her encounter with Sonic never happened but she accepted it anyway.

If Sonic being kissed by Elise isn't on here this list is inaccurate. 3:00 FIND THE COMPUTER ROOM! 7:12 Fun Fact: Mephiles was originally gonna be the villain in Sonic Forces, which in my opinion, is a better option than Infinite due to Mephiles being such an interesting villain. In my opinion, Mephiles destroying the multiverse is the darkest moment due to killing pretty much everything.

Sonic the Hedgehog Villains: Evil to Most Evil

The worst thing to happen is when a character that didn't do anything wrong gets killed. : ( It is also terrible when characters that wanted to do good later turn evil. By the way, I hate the evil personal eye for an eye cliche.

Mephiles the dark Should be the most terrifying villain in the franchise

Delturune characters: good to evil

Final Mova from the series finale in Sonic X. Looking at that abomination gives me the shivers......😰😬😣😩

I think "Chaos destroying station square" should be 1st considering how many Homan dies due to the flood

I've honestly seen the werehog transformation so many times that it does register as dark to me

I’m surprised that Elise (almost forgot her name) kissing Sonic, Dark Gia’s transformation into Perfect Dark Gia and Eggman “pissing on the moon” isn’t in this list…

Super Mario Odyssey Characters : Good to Evil Good : Mario and Cappy Neutral : Pauline Evil : Bowser

In a Sonic Twitter Takeover, they were asked about Station Square's status, which they answered to it being rebuilt after Chaos destroyed everything.

Do Metal Gear Solid Moments: Grim to Darkest!

Ratchet & Clank Characters: Good to Evil.

I love how the werehog used to make me shit my pants, but now I think he's cooler than Shadow. I've come a long way from 2010

Gears Of War Characters Good To Evil

I was watching this, and all of these scenes are terrifying (they better not have Shadow killing everyone with a gun in Sonic 3 😅). Can you Mario moments darkest next?

Pokemon Fan Theorys: from bull to Truthbombs.

Personally, I feel like you did an ok job at arranging this list. One that probably should have been added is the Sonic 2 Bad Ending. But not the Genisis version. That one was pretty lighthearted, but the Gamegear version wasn't as lighthearted. In the good ending, we see Sonic and Tails just running alongside each other, just being friends. But the bad ending shows Sonic running alone. The story of the game is that Tails is kidnapped, and Sonic has to go and save the kid from Robotnik. But in the bad ending, it's presumed that Tails wasn't able to be saved and was maybe killed by Eggman. Not only was Sonic running alone, but once he's finished running, he looks up into the sky and sees a constellation that's in the shape of Tails. While I wouldn't say it goes above Maria, it could probably tie with Gerald, maybe go over his death as Tails was a lot more innocent at that time. It also isn't confirmed that Tails dies, but the evidence (Sonic running alone only in the bad ending, the constellation in the shape of Tails, what the main goal of the story is) really makes you think he's dead. Which is why I say this should've probably been on the list.

Please do Super Mario Series moments: Grim to Darkest.

Imprisonment in a badnik is like Imprisonment in the matrix films without being in the simulation world. Fleetway Robotnik tried to use people to power a computer and if it had been successful the people would be trapped permanently as part of the computer because there wouldn't be any way to save them other than death. Thankfully Super Sonic stopped it by accidently creating an EMP blast while escaping his prison so he could kill Sonic and everyone on the planet after toying with them a bit, since Super Sonic is a Sadist and likes hurt people before he kills them.

Us: *Comment about good ideas.* Wickedbinge: Yeah I’m going to do the hell I want and you guys will shut up. Your choices are trash. Me: The people won’t stand for this! Wickedbinge: People? What people?

probably my opinion only, but the echidna tribe disappearing because of Chaos, and the cause about it being their self-interest it's actually a good reason and it's better than Chaos doing such thing for any other reason. The reason is very real and we can see something alike in our reality, how being greedy about an objective can screw up much people's lives, also shows that intents can resonate to the master emerald, just like what happens to the chaos emeralds (when used with good intent, their form disappear, when used with bad intent, their colours disappear) welp, it's just my point about it, where it is on the list fits perfectly! and talking about it, i would put the death of Sonic in 06 a bit higher, like in 4th place, and the reasons a lot of people are saying, so I'm not gonna repeat everyone else's comment. thank you for the attention, and take care!

Too bad they didn’t include Emerl’s Death from Sonic Battle or sonics in tire dimension briefly getting wiped out by the formation of Solaris.

I think the bestiality scene from 2006 should be near the top here. The implications of that are pretty disturbing

I would possibly like to have seen a few 'suggested' dark moments on this list. These would be things that we either know happened, but we're not sure about the details. The exact circumstances on Maria's death would've been one of these, only in that Shadow's game revealed that it was clearly not an accident. Head Cannon: the government suddenly changed its mind about Project Shadow because of a turnover election. If that were to be the case, then Maria was literally murdered by politics and the arguing of political parties and the rulers of the people she loved so much. Another possibly dark moment, though it's probably more of a mystery than outright dark, is Sonic's origin story. Yeah he's the fastest thing alive, but how? Why? Where are his parents? Sonic is usually portrayed as having a pretty tragic if not violent backstory, when he has a back story at all. In the games, there is none... but there may be a hint. At the end of SA2, Shadow literally asks Sonic "What are you?" and Sonic's reply is simple but nothing to inspire confidence. "What you see is what you get... just a guy who loves adventure." This line could mean a few things, and sadly we are never given any answers. 1. The comment is literal in that Sonic doesn't even know. He doesn't have a backstory: he doesn't know why he's so fast and powerful, etc. 2. This comment is a lie. Sonic knows very well where and what he came from, but not necessarily why. This is what we'd expect to hear from a dude who has a secret identity that only his parents and family members know who might not even realize that he's Sonic (Niki the Hedgehog), or an orphan who just so happens to be gifted (cinematic universe), or anything in between. Finally, 3. Sonic is literally an escaped science experiment, possibly another scientist's attempted continuation of Project Shadow or even the next generation prototype. He has all of Shadow's abilities, even Chaos Control! And no matter how far ahead Shadow starts in SA2 and beyond, Sonic always somehow manages to catch up to him. If this theory were true, I would find it hard to believe that Sonic knows the truth based on the thoughts he was having in that exploding space capsule. Also if this is the case, it would leave a question as to who created him. It can't be Eggman, because if it were then it would stand to reason that Eggman would have some way to control him, and the evidence suggesting that Eggman is toying with Sonic's lie of a life is very slim. Eggman has attempted to kill Sonic multiple times over the years, and while I would love to explore this theory further, there are other matters that more urgently require my attention. Thank you for reading. ♥

That sonic CD one is not supposed to be creepy but funny in Japan.

Super Mario odyssey characters: good to evil

Can you do Kirby moments dark to darkest? Include the soul bosses as well the latest soul boss, Chaos Elfilis' 2nd form

Please Do StarFox characters: good to evil including Wolf O'Donnell, Katt Monroe, Krystal, Fara Phoenix, Fay Spaniel and Miyu Lynx

COD Zombies Villains : Evil to Most Evil

2 things: 1. Make a video titled "Classic Sonic Bosses: Easiest to Hardest" and 2. The Final Boss of Sonic Mania should be here. In the fight, Eggman proves he will do ANYTHING to kill Sonic, even if it means risking his own life.

scourge had some dark moments in the sonic archie comics

I believe that all of project shadow and it’s aftermath should be one ranking

Do Sonic Heroes Good to Most Good and Sonic Villians Evil to Most Evil

Nah! The darkest moment in Sonic is when Shadow called Infinite weak which started his villain arc. Truly a sad moment.😂😂😂

We need Dan the man characters: good to evil

Do Sonic villains evil to most evil

Did you know that the creepy music from the secret sound test screen is actually the boss theme?

What about Dark Gaïa and Black Doom's appearance it looks scary and probably Dark specially when Dark Gaïa stole sonic's werehog power he suffered the same pain he had before when he transformed into a werehog like you said

Dead rising; bad to most evil

Gta hd universe good to evil.

Awesome and cool! ^_^

Can you do Sonic the Hedgehog villains evil to most evil

Hm, how very interesting. Say, i would really like to see you do Touhou Project at some point.

You should’ve put the threats by the deadly six. Like Zazz telling you that he will skin you alive and you’re going home in a box. How about Zor and his depression and he asks himself why he’s still alive.

What's criminal was that Sonic and the Secret Rings and Black Knight weren't included on the list.

Emeral deserves to be on here.

Sonic 06 imo is the darkest Sonic fate.

Plz do Kirby final bosses easiest to hardest

Epic mickey good to evil

I found out the GUN soldier who killed Maria on shadow the hedgehog was actually known as Heavy Dog. Also the next video I want to see is resident evil heroes good to most good.

The Shadow game like a child who tries too hard to convince people they're mature when in reality, though, the kid is just immature and silly. Which I think describes the game perfectly. As it can come ascross as untentionally funny at times.

Yikes, there are so many dark moments in the Sonic the Hedgehog Franchise whether that Mephiles stabbed Sonic in Sonic 2006 or the fact we know how gruesome Maria's death is. These dark moments will either make you shiver in fear or simply cry.😬💦

Sonic gon too far

Do the video about "which Undertale characters would win the squid game" plssssss

The Quarry characters good to evil please

How a sequel video of this with dark non game moments from the sonic series.

Mayby you should go for the splatoon Series next.

You missed eggman pulling out a gun on Amy in sonic adventure

Shouldn't the part where Solaris almost destroyed all of time and space count, or, does the fact that it was averted keep it from counting? Or does it count with Mephiles killing Sonic?

Could you do bully weak to powerful and do a bully good to evil for my birthday please

Only thing that sonic is tortured in forces was cutted because that will be not a kids game

Freedom Planet Characters Good-to-Evil, pretty please?

Mario + rabbits characters good to evil Put in donkey Kong as well

Please do a Squid Games for My Hero Academia

Making the sound test Easter egg even worse, the text was for a while thought to translate to something along the lines of Demon. Don't worry. It's just the name of a dev that is awfully close to Demon.

do tom nook deeds good to evil

Sonic satam characters good to evil

Music in the beginning?

Mephiles Is The Only Sonic Villain To Kill Sonic Infinite On The Other Hand Only Beats Up Sonic In The Cutscenes

Dead rising gruesome to most gruesome

Did you know in style sonic unleashes transform sonic was originally going to be a electricity’s and shoe he skeleton

Shadow the hedgehog the whole game is the darkest considering sonic games supposed to be a kids game ya saga is putting some serious moments for the adults who plays sonic

One I’m thinking is a Sonic X episode where people die by tree maybe? Something like that

The sonic with a human like face is called majin sonic or in English demon sonic Edit: they use to use a death animation where sonic would lose his eyes and then at the death screen he would fall into spikes and bleed but later that was found to grusome

1. SONIC CD'S GAME OVER MUSIC. 2. SECRET SOUND TEST SCREEN. 3. SEMI HERO: HERO ENDING. 4. EGGMAN CAPTURING ANIMALS + ALIENS FOR POWER SOURCES. 5. BEGINNING OF SONIC FORCES. 6. SONIC TURNING INTO A WEREHOG. 7. MEPHILES BREIFLY MURDERS SONIC. 8. THE WHOLE SHADOW GAME. 9. CHAOS KILLING NEARLY EVERY ECHIDNA. 10. E-102 GAMMA'S SACRIFICE. 11. DESTRUCTION OF STATION SQUARE BY CHAOS. 12. PROFESSOR GERALD'S EXECUTION. 13. THE MURDER OF MARIA ROBOTNIK.

Ahh...

What does the words mean in the secret sound test

I am very, VERY tired of asking. I didn't ask last video because I thought I was annoying you and you would make them if I didn't. But no. So PLEASE let this be the last time I ask you. PLEASE DO Nintendo heroes: Good to most good and Nintendo villains: Dumb to brilliant. I am really starting to lose faith in you guys.

Gta HD univers good to evil plsssss

Possessed Amy from Sonic X. Thanks KZfaq thumbnails from around 2009.

Why no tv shows, anime, comics, movies or side games?

Minecraft structures worst to best

I finc the japonês meseg in the second racing translates to infonit

what about the end of the world

mario rabbids kingdom battle good: beep-o grey: spawny evil: megabug weakest: beep-o average power: phantom strongest: the heroes dumb: rabbid yoshi average smart: bowser jr smartest: beep-o

BNA Brand New Animal good to evil Naruto good to evil

sonic die 2006

Younger Sonic fans back then: 😳WTF. NOW😫