Рет қаралды 12,826
What's the big deal with jokes premised on rhetoric that further marginalizes trans people? Good question, check these out:
- Experiences and Factors Associated with Transphobic Hate Crimes Among Transgender Women in the San Francisco Bay Area: Comparisons Across Race. Gyamerah, A.O., Baguso, G., Santiago-Rodriguez, E. et al. (2021). BMC Public Health 21, 1053. bmcpublichealth.biomedcentral...
- “Passing” and the Politics of Deception: Transgender Bodies, Cisgender Aesthetics, and the Policing of Inconspicuous Marginal Identities. Billard, T.J. (2019). In: Docan-Morgan, T. (eds) The Palgrave Handbook of Deceptive Communication . Palgrave Macmillan, Cham. www.researchgate.net/publicat...
- Transgender Polyvictimization in the U.S. Transgender Survey. Messinger AM, Guadalupe-Diaz XL, Kurdyla V. Journal of Interpersonal Violence. August 2021. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34463...
- Effects of Humor and Bystander Gender on Responses to Antigay Harassment. Katz J., Federici, D. & Brown, D. (2022). Journal of Homosexuality, 69:6, 947-966, www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/1...
- Fatal Violence Against the Transgender and Gender Non-conforming Community in 2021. Human Rights Campaign. Retrieved June 17, 2022, from www.hrc.org/resources/fatal-v...
"But," you say. "You didn't even prove with facts and logic that Dave Chappelle is a bad person, why don't you like him?"
⬋ ⬋ ⬋
This isn't about whether I like or dislike a person. I don't care whether Dave fits the category of 'bad' or 'bigoted' or 'transphobic' because that's not important. If you clicked this 29 second video expecting a detailed discussion of the issues that are raised by Dave's work, that was a bit of a misstep. But I can help you out and direct you to Jessie Gender's 'The Complex Transphobia of Dave Chappelle' • The Complex Transphobi... and Kat Blaque's 'Watching Dave Chappelle's Full Special, Before Criticizing it...' • Watching Dave Chappell... . You can listen to people give extremely detailed explanations about why comedy is not immune from other speech in furthering bigoted ideologies, and you can learn and read about the extremely real pain and suffering inflicted every day on people because of these ideologies. It's really not that complicated and I invite commenters to open themselves up to the blatant logic of criticizing Dave's recent lazy work.
And let me add, to the several people commenting that "punching down" implies the targeted group is "down" and "lower", and these commenters are just ever so egalitarian in their perspective, so they would never view a group as "down"! Nice logic trick people but I am not convinced/fooled. The argument against punching down obviously doesn't involve claiming trans people are "worse" or "lower" in any way, other than in terms of sociopolitical power in the status quo of most societies nowadays. Dave was punching down because he was speaking (lies and misrepresentations, actually, if you look into it) about a trans fan of his ending their life, and he blamed it on harassment Dave alleges (falsely and without evidence) that this person received from the trans community. He blamed a trans person's death on trans people with no evidence, when this person was suffering for so many other reasons that could have been cited. ( • Dave Chappelle Narrate... ) One might argue that Dave was wrong to even be discussing it, because it's not his place. This is not me limiting his free speech, it's me expressing mine, and saying he was morally wrong to say many of the things he said. You also need to understand that whether you found all his other jokes about trans people's genitals funny or not, currently trans identities are under siege from the state like you have hopefully never experienced with any aspect of your identity, person reading this. (archive.is/ymrmb) I hope you never have to experience anything like this, but that's not an excuse to remain ignorant and passive in the face of the widespread targeted use of power against a minority group.
Oh, and his 'Space Jews' joke conflated Jews with Zionists. It was blatant unless you don't understand anything about Judaism and Zionism. It is a profoundly antisemitic trope to conflate Jews with Zionists. The bit was unfunny, but more importantly its antisemitic premise was clear. And again, for people who struggle to grasp this concept: I'm not calling Dave Chappelle antisemitic, because I don't care whether he is. The joke was. And that's what he's sending out into the world that actually influences others' ideologies and behavior.