Sharing your knowledge with us is a pleasure to listen to and learn. Thank you! Dimash is a force that's not fitting into any categories and I love him for it! While pleasing our ears and nourishing our souls he's thriving and changing music history in an unprecedented way. For this and for the human he is, we already won in millions of hearts from all over the world. Without big labels of the music industry Dimash is being who he is and changing the 🌍🌎!!! Much love to you 🫶🌹🫶🌹🫶

Люблю читать отзывы и радуюсь всем пожеланиям и любовью. Димаш есть Димаш и никто его не сможет повторить. Принимаю его таким каким он есть с душой и сердцем.

Димаш потому и Димаш , что он один такой и нет ему подобных , не то , что опредение жанра его трудно , но до сих пор никто не может дать определение его голоса , многие считают котртенором , но это не так , Димаш -- это голос будущего , которое еще не изучено нами ,' но которое так будоражит мир , Димаш опередил мир на целое столетие , многие не понимают этого и пытаются точно прикрепить его к определенному жанру ,' не будет этого , он такой , какой есть и понадобятся еще годы , годы воспитания целой плеяды артистов , чтобы хоть как-то приблизить их к нему , возможно в далеком будущем такие , как он станут обыденными , но сейчас он один такой на всбю планету и в этом его уникальность и неповторимость и не надо пытаться навешивать на него ярлык одного жанра , он новатор ,' он бунтарь и, в музыкальном училище ему запрещали многое , но он упорствовал и стал тем ,' кем хотел , он может стать великим оперным , тем более , что еще с 2013 года ему предрекали блистательную оперную карьеру , его , буквально , толкали в нее , но это не его , годами корпеть над звучанием одной ноты - это не его , он кроссовер , он изобрел совершенно новое направление музыкального жанра , которое не воспринимается многими , вот учили их так , значит , так и должно быть , но это , повторяю,' не его ,' никто не сможет повторить особого Димашевского звучание , чистого , хрустального , как горный родник , сами Высшие силы благословляют его светлую душу и не надо загонять ее в рамки допустимого. , в противном случае , мы можем потерять это уникальное звучание., голос самой первозданной природы .

There is no category for Dimash. He is in a class of his own. I think he has realised this a long time ago and this is why he will never be classed as 'pop' or 'opera' because that is what he is not. Dimash is one of a kind and for those who try to pigeon hole him can never do so. I honestly as glad that he is not like everyone else, he has enriched the music industry with his wonderful voice, so please sit back and enjoy this wonder of the modern world.

МЫ ЛЮБИМ ДИМАША КАКОЙ ОН ЕСТЬ И БУДЕМ ЛЮБИТЬ НЕ ВЗАВИСИМОСТИ КАК ДИМАШ БУДЕ ПЕТЬ И НАСЛОЖДАТЬСЯ СПАСИБО ВАМ ЗА ВАШИ ИСКРЕННИИ ПОЖЕЛАНИ И ЛЮБОВЬ МИРУ

Какие виды музыки нам известны? Классическая, эстрадная, народная. Та что же, куда отнести голос Димаша? К классике, классической эстраде? Точнее о себе он сам сказал: "Кроссовер, или неоклассика". И в этом он совершенный новатор, хотя и до него пели, но так, чтобы свободно и плавно перемещаться из регистра в регистр, из жанра в жанр, и все это супер отработанно, логично, смыслово, гармонично и безупречно красиво, что его музыка - для слушателей на любой вкус, только, конечно, но хороший музыкальный вкус. Она есть настоящее искусство. Но самое главное, что через голос Димаша мы чувствуем его доброе сердце, чистую душу, понимаем, что он хочет нам сказать. А качество его исполнения и есть любовь, уважение к публике. Статики в музыке нет, также, как и в любом виде искусства. Мы же сегодня не читаем, например, стихи С. Есенина (при всем уважении к нему) нараспев, как он когда-то читал? Как музыкант, знаю, о чем говорю и вижу, как стремительно растет талант Димаша, как он трудолюбив и самокритичен, как верен тому, что музыка не создается в угоду низкому вкусу или на коленках... Вопрос интерпретации, импровизации для настоящих Художников в искусстве - всегда открыт, может, это и есть творчество и развитие личности. Хотите понять и почувствовать Димаша? Тогда послушайте именно его композиции, созданные этим светлым и добросердечным человеком, Он гениален и немножко опережает наше время...

Dimash je Umetnik duse, ne treba mu kategorizacija. da je zeleo siroku popularnost, preusmerio bi svoj put na komercijalu i potpisao ugovor sa producentskim kucama. ovako je izabrao svoj put i ostao dosledan sebi. mislim da je u muzici neko ko menja standarde, poput Elvisa, Bitlsa, Majkl Jeksona, ljudi koji su ostavili svoj pecat

Здравствуйте. Мне 72 года. Историю становления Димаша, как певца, я сравниваю со своим сыном. Ему 40 лет он кандидат наук по математике, программист. С детства мой сын увлекался многими науками, биологией, литературой, математикой астрономией, музыкой, иностранными языками. Самостоятельно изучил игру на гитаре, на пионине. Все говорили, что он вундеркинд. В итоге матиматик. Ему 40, и до сих пор он не уверен правильный он сделал выбор. Может он лучше пошёл бы по музыке или биологии и т. д. До сих пор в дисконфорте. Но собрать в одно целое все знания очень сложно. Я советовалась с психологом, когда он был ещё в младших классах. Мне объяснили, рождаются такие люди, им трудно сделать выбор, какое из направлений им больше интересны. И посмотрев историю жизни Димаша, я его понимаю. абсолютно, с детства он интересовался, многими направлениями музыки. . Кассеты с оперными певцами, которые он слушал и Майкл Джексон и многие другие направления. А как выбрать, если он может петь все. Голос позволяет, но кругом рамки, шаг в сторону уже не опера, уже не джаз, уже не поп музыка. И появилась музыка - Димаш. Он осуществил мечту. Он в одной песне включает разные направления. И он это делает настолько корректно, гармонично, деликатно, безумная оранжеровка, музыкальное сопровождение и главное его голос, слов нет. Но не это главное. Каждая песня это ода, это реквием. Если заметили, во время концерта, он поёт всем своим существом, на разрыв аорты. Его тело, лцо, руки работают в унисон с песней. Впечатление, что он смотрит в глаза каждого зрителя и говорит,не обращайте внимание на мой голос. Причём тут мой голос? Вы слышите мои слова, вы слышите о чем я пою? Это про любовь , про мир, про семью, про детей. Все песни со смыслом. Такое впечатление, что у него какая-то миссия. Он молодой человек,, ещё совсем юноша.И мне кажется для него это важнее чем его голос. Голос это инструмент, данный ему богом и трудом. И это возможность эмоционально передать смыслы его песен. И знаете, все его поклонники, как раз, это поняли. А поёт ли он оперными голосом или каким-то еще другим, для них уже не важно. Димаш вошёл в их сердца, в их души. И как я вижу, сторонников его таланта становится все больше. И не просто так, великий Пласидо Доминго поставил Димаша рядом с собой, осуществить мечту молодого певца, даже не оперного.. как вы оценили. Не это ли признание оперного сообщества, талантом молодого Димаша. Дай Бог ему здоровья,и дальнейших творческих успехов!!! Спасибо вам!!!

Да, Уильям! В мире есть тысячи певцов, мастерски поющих оперу. В мире есть тысячи отлично поющих в поп-жанре. В мире есть тысячи певцов захватывающе поющие джаз. И только один единственный в мире Димаш поющий как никто другой. За это мы его и любим, ценим его мастерство.

Hello Willian, I agree with your considerations about Dimash's musical style not falling within the two genres mentioned by you. He considers himself a crossover, a neo-classic, in fact he doesn't even fit into that world. He is a game changer, there are those who love him and those who hate him but he will never go unnoticed. The important thing is that above the fame, the success as an artist that he has already achieved at least in Asian countries, his biggest concern is with peace in the world, full protection for children, respect and loyalty to his family and his fans. That's why we love him without restrictions with the pure surrender of our heart permeated with love, loyalty to his principles. Dimash is an avatar, ethical, precious, beautiful and generous, a gentleman recognized by us as an icon of the new race of humans. Hug from Brazil.

Димаш настолько запал в сердца " дорогих",что нам не важно в каком стиле он поет!- главное -слушать,видеть и наслаждаться его разнообразным творчеством! Спасибо за Ваше уважение к искусству Димаша!

Thanks for not being offended by the emotional reactions of fans who often lack the musical training to do analysis. Thanks also for trying to draw reasonable and logical conclusions from these reactions. In recent years, worldwide, we have seen huge voices from various countries that amaze us with their quality and level of training. A large part of them do not close themselves in one genre or style of singing. In my opinion, even opera fans are now accepting a wider range of singers. It is more difficult for pop fans because they are usually not musically prepared. But now they also need more meaningful music that goes beyond entertainment. I am glad that Dimash is not a world pop or opera star, because he, both as a singer and as a person, carries messages that should not be diluted in the general mass. In this version, it is more audible because it is different. Hopefully.

Yes, Dimash got his wish. He wanted to sing all genres and he does them all superbly. What a tragedy it would have been for the world if he had accepted that position as an operatic tenor and spent the rest of his life doing that! Now hundreds of thousands have experienced his artistry, the beauty of his voice, and the purity of his heart and soul that are so filled with love for all people and the earth. ❤

To me I love Dimash's versatility of singing as I don't classify him in any genre of music. His uniqueness in utilizing his voice just makes me happy when listening to him.❤ Greetings from Bangkok,Thailand.x

Спасибо Уильям. Для меня Димаш -- идеальный голос и идеальный артистизм. Я слышу, что он звучит не совсем так, как классические оперные певцы, и мне это нравится! Если честно, в исполнении Димаша я готова слушать всё -- от оперных арий до рэпа. Димаш любой жанр делает ""своим" и исполняет не совсем так, как "полагается" и это тоже нравится мне. Димаш не идёт протоптанными путями, а создаёт свой собственный, уникальный путь -- огромный труд для вокалиста. Лично я не считаю замечание о том, что в этом дуэте Димаш не во всём соответствует канонам оперного вокала критикой. Это -- констатация. Обидно ли это -- нет. Он сам не захотел строить карьеру в опере, мне кажется ему было бы тесно в жёстких классических рамках. Оперный стиль -- одна из красок в огромной палитре его голоса. Этот дуэт с Пласидо Доминго Димаш спел так, как счёл нужным. Получилось великолепно, мне понравилось.

Hello Mr.William, I really enjoy your reactions to my beloved Dimash. i think you are right on your comments specially when you said that Dimash can't be placed in a particular musical genre.Allow me to give some details about his performance with Placido Domingo,He treated il maestro Placido with the utmost respect ,he didn't try to show overshadow his idol even though we all know his prowess besides Dimash was sick that day in spite of that he was able to give us a beautiful performance. For me, on the other hand I just enjoy the feelings he gives me every time with is unique voice. You can tell that I am a Dear but I respect your knowledge and your hard work.Everybody can tell that Dimash performance wasn't completely operatic , it was Dimash style and I loved it.! I have already booked a ticket for his concert in Budapest .I live in Italy so this will be my second Dimash concert. I belong to an Italian fan club and there will be more than 100 fans just from our fan club that will be there. One of the things about being a Dimash fan is that you get into a family that share the same feelings ,we are very helpful to each other and we are well organized . Greetings from Italy

Why don't we just call it the Dimash genre. A unique genre that nobody can do at the moment. He is in a class of his own and I don't see any difficulty for him to attract admirers. In fact we are so mesmerized by him that I, for one, do not listen to any other singers now (except when they are singing with Dimash!!!). I saw a video where someone asked Dimash what kind of genre he considered himself to be in, Igor Krutoy answered for him - he is Dimash. ❤

Agradeço os seus comentários, sempre se aprende mais. Continue, eu aprecio o seu trabalho. Eu penso que Dimash criou um novo "conceito musical", o dele - Dimash! Assim, ele é único. Não?! Uma coisa é certa, Dimash tocou, sensibiliza e agrada a todas idades e géneros. Eu adoro Dimash e vou a Budapeste só para o ouvir, ver e sentir! (67 anos) Obrigada. (pt)

WE KNOW THAT!!! We know everything about Dimash. Dimash is not willing to sell his soul by signing a contract with a record label company. He didn’t with Igor Krutoy either. He wants do his own thing and has gained popularity on his own terms. Slow and steady wins the race or not. I don’t think he cares. Yes we are dedicated to Dimash because he has magic in his voice and all his Fans will agree. Those who don’t like him can find music elsewhere. Of course he would like to covet the biggest prize in music but not at the expense of his convictions. If you don’t know that, then you don’t know Dimash. Thank you!!❤️🇨🇦

Yes, Dimash is in a category all by himself, dont think he will ever be mainstream. I'm sure he could have gained more fame, had he chosen to sighn with a big label, but he has chosen to be independant for a reason. It will take him longer to become widely known, but he seems to be in no hurry. I dont remember, if you listened/reacted to "Omir" (his gift for his Dears on his last birthsday) .. that song will tell you a lot about, what is important to him. Greatings from an old Danish Dear and Angel 🌷🇩🇰❤️

Dimash is Dimash ! ❤

Уильямс, вы уникальный, а Димаш непревзойденный гений, без изъянов и упрёков. Галактика в мкзыке❤

Here is an excerpt from a commentary by Murat Ren, a professional musician and philosopher. "... Of those who have already commented on this performance, no one has noticed that the surprising thing about this interpretation was that Dimash, singing the tenor part, sang it in a baritone manner, while Domingo sang the baritone part in a tenor manner. This is the joke our artists gave us, they switched the characters, and as a result this music sounded fresh and unusual! A performer's genius always manifests itself in the most unexpected ways, and it is this quality that distinguishes them from other artists. The vision of geniuses cannot be predicted, they open new worlds, new perspectives, they are able to breathe fresh wind into established canons and create the highest standard of new compositions. We can only thank God for giving us the opportunity to enjoy the fusion in absolute beauty of two voices of unsurpassed artists! Bravo Domingo, bravo Dimash!..... I put him on a pedestal, show and tell everyone, tell my professional colleagues that we should strive for such dedication of an artist as Dimash has! We all, and I among others, should be equal to him, because with his art he, above all, brings love ... "

Dimash es Dimash, hace lo que le gusta y lo disfruta, lo importante es eso, es auténtico, mágico, único, inigualable, incomparable, magnético, adictivo, te llena de sentimientos bellos aún con temas de absoluta crueldad, te transporta a su mundo, así que dejemos que siga siendo simple y nada menos que DIMASH, EL MEJOR ARTISTA DEL MUNDO CON SUS SOLO 29 años, gracias , saludos 🇦🇷

I have to repeat again: Dimash voice should classified Unesco Cultural Heritage!!! Hugs

You are right that Dimash does not fit into any one category. He and Igor Krutoy in an interview with Russian TV, I believe, and Dimash was asked "What are you? A bass, baritone, tenor?" and Igor answered "He is Dimash". I believe that is also a good answer if he is ever asked what genre he fits in. He is Dimash, a genre of his own. I believe he understands the challenges of breaking into western music scene. He will not ever change his standards and he will sing only what comes from his heart. But, if you noticed, his 3 most recent releases were more in a jazz/blues style. "Dudarai" kzfaq.info/get/bejne/Y9OPotOSq5--mp8.html and the 2 premiers in his Hong Kong concert: "Smoke" kzfaq.info/get/bejne/lbpjq8uA29HOqnk.html and "When I've Got You" kzfaq.info/get/bejne/q5OWbLGSt7m7ooE.html The official videos have not yet been released for the HK premiers, but we hope to see them soon. We Dears are very proud of him and hope all his dreams come true. We will be there to support him on his journey.

Димаш работает в жанре crossover, это и есть его стиль и его "стул". Он никуда не упадет, он сидит на этом стуле, как на троне!

Hello, William! Thank you for your musings! I appreciate your time! Dimash knows he chose a difficult path. As his fan, I absolutely adore his rebel spirit and continued search of new expressions/experimentations. I love that he doesn’t want to be boxed into a specific genre. In fact, that’s what makes him unique. ❤

I appreciate your statement and know it’s true - and this is the wonder of Dimash. He fits nowhere, but he makes any sort of genre so beautiful - everybody want to hear him. This IMO will make Dimash to the most impressive and important singer in history because he doesn’t fit in, because he has no boundaries and he makes music with no category - „only“ makes the whole music world wondering how extraordinary beautiful music can be. It seems a lot more of other singers are experimenting and now knowing you has to have a strong and perfect basic and an unbelievable time of hard working to gain such beauty. A little bit like Mozart - there were many who didn’t like him (specially the established music world) in fact he was revolutionary in his time and also didn’t really fit in 😂 If Dimash fits in or not is obsolet. It is a fact he sings not the traditional exact way of opera, rock, pop or others and it is also fact it’s not necessary. There is no room for being offended. If somebody likes him is as always taste. And I think it’s time for new things - we have to be happy to be able to listen to him and always waiting of „SOON“ 😅 Love from Austria 🇦🇹

A single fan of Dimash is equivalent to a thousand fans of the western pop singers. I have never seen a fandom whose love for the singer is so intent. Many, if not all of the Dears, including myself, are willing to give their lives to Dimash. They have this unexplainable passionate love for him.

DIMASH IS NOT AN OPERA SINGER.DIMASH IS UNIQUE WITH AN EXTRAORDINARY VOICE.❤❤❤❤

Esto dijo un importante músico italiano después de estudiar profundamente a Dimash. Es la definición más acertada a la que tarde o temprano nos terminaremos todo el mundo por aceptar: “Conozco el Bel canto desde que nací. Dejemos una cosa clara: Para ser claro, su voz es como lo que en biología se llama una Célula Todopotente. En este sentido es una “Voz Madre.” A partir de esta célula se puede generar cualquier tipo de tejido, lo que comúnmente se llaman Géneros Musicales. Sus transiciones son tales que la transición ya no existe. Dimash no canta los diferentes géneros(ópera, pop, rock, también rap, etc.) Dimash ya tiene desde el principio todos los géneros. En su caso los géneros musicales no son más que una coloratura, una inflexión, una declinación de su voz general. Lo mismo se aplica, por supuesto, a todos sus registros de voz. Esto también conduce al hecho de que canta fácilmente en varios idiomas. Las diferentes lenguas nacionales no son más que determinaciones sub-especies de su sonoridad general. Permítanme darles un ejemplo que también es una confirmación: Dimash fue cuestionado y criticado por no haberse dedicado exclusivamente a la ópera. Fue el propio Dimash quien declinó la invitación a especializarse en cantó operístico, y esto es perfectamente consistente en su batuta valor. Dimash no sólo es un cantante operístico ni sólo rock, ni sólo pop, ni nada especificado y específico, simplemente porque es un cantante “Holístico” tanto en el sentido filosófico como científico del término. Dimash es un “Sistema de canto” que no es más que la suma de sus propias partes. Canta con todo su cuerpo. Este hecho no sólo se refiere a consideraciones técnicas relacionadas con la postura a tomar en diferentes momentos y modos de canto. Es ante todo que, como he dicho, en Dimash cantar es equivalente a todo el organismo. Supongo que tarde o temprano esto debería haber pasado en alguien y sí, sucedió en este chico kazajo. En resumen: los otros cantantes, todos los demás cantantes, interpretan una canción. Dimash se ejecuta a sí mismo.

Dimash impress me just because of his own style of voice. and a humble young artist is hard to find these days, that make me become his dear, I always like your reaction, must watch when I see you, thanks and please continue to do Dimash reaction, see you again.

Димаш может спеть в чисто оперном жанре. Просто был всего день репетиции и с больным горлом. Тем более оперные певцы поют только оперу и одну и ту же арию исполняют много много раз. Тем более петь на другом языке и ещё на старинном французском и один день репетиции. Димаш чудесно и гениально справился.

Dimash has said in interview that the neoclassical or crossover genre will make it hard for him going forward but it is what interests him, And with all his thousands of fans , worldwide, we are accepting the crossover music with absolute awe and wonder. And I for on, love it when he surprises us with rap, or blues, or jazz or pop.etc, whatever mood I’m in, I can pick a Dimash song that will entertain me.

Димаш не ищет легких путей .И подстраивается он в одном случае,когда нужно выразить уважительное отношение в пении с кем то дуэтом,или с несколькими исполнителями. Мы ценим его благородную скромность,с его то возможностями он может забить своим голосом любого. Он не помещается в рамки того же шоубиза,который не очень жалует. И это замечательно.Большому кораблю свое плавание.А насчет сложностей в карьерной жизни,он большой и умный мальчик,разберется.

Dimash knew what he is into and what he is in for... He said it himself that it is a difficult road that he has taken...🩵🩵🩵DQ

Рахмет Уильям! Димаш ол ДИМАШ!!! В Казахстане некоторые жюри конкурсов тоже говорили: зачем всё в одну песню (т.е. все жанры) "впихивать"... в начале карьеры... как бы Димаш ни пел: дай бог ему здоровья, личного счастья и благополучия!!! Ақ жол болсын!!!

Ich bin der Meinung,dass Dimash nicht seine volle Stimme eingesetzt hat.Erstens war er etwas krank und hatte Husten und zweitens allein von seiner Menschlickeit und Respekt vor dem großen Plácido Domingo der mit seinen 82 Jahren neben ihn steht,wollte Dimash mit Sicherheit nicht glänzen.Es war sehr klug von Dimash..Danke für deine Reaktion.Ich bin gerne bei dir🙂💕Vielleicht haben wir noch nicht alles von Dimash gehört

Как правильно вы всё объяснили! Полностью согласна. Поклонники Димаша любят и поддерживают его не только за вокальное мастерство, но и за дар переживания, душевность, теплоту и простоту.

You are right, Dimash is not yet a household name, incredible though that may seem to a fan like myself. The algorithm still feeds me reactions by other vocal coaches who claim that this is their first time hearing him. I am finding that increasingly hard to believe. Dimash doesn't fit into any musical genre, not even into a voice type, as you correctly point out. He is such a great entertainer as well as being an extremely skilled singer. I hope he continues to sing for a long time and that he takes good care to avoid injury to his extraordinary vocal apparatus.

Hello sir. Happy 2024. Your personality and music knowledge are amazing. Thank ypu for taking of you precious time to explain some facts about great artists such as our Dimash. I think he is in a league of his own. He connot be compared to anyone and that's wonderful. I like opera and pop, so Dimash's style satisfies both worlds expectations. He is so complete and wholsome to me! Moreover, his charm consists of being able to flowlessly perform in different genres. I reckon it's not something about belonging or not to a specific genre, but people's' likes. I love Dimash's music and what he does on stage. Maybe he"not listened on the radio cause there is an industry supporting mediocre artists that without the help of technology wouldn't be able to sing. Dimash is already famous besides of not being promoted on conventional media and that's incredible. God bless you! I love your reactions. Hugs from Dominican Republic.

Great thoughts, William! Dimash knows he’s picked a tough row to hoe but that’s why, I think, a lot of we Dears love him! 👍🤗♥️

Los genios se salen del común porque crean nuevas cosas, dan frescura y renovación a lo anquilosado, de otra forma la humanidad no evolucionaría, pero a la gente se le dificulta aceptar lo nuevo y cuando llega alguien que mueve lo ya establecido, es rechazado, incomprendido y a veces ridiculizado por ser diferente de los demás. Dimash llegó a innovar estilos musicales, como dice usted maestro, él está en una posición muy difícil… pero Dimash es genuino, persistente y seguro de lo que quiere… Así son los genios. Desafortunadamente la mayoría de las veces los reconocen y valoran cuando ya no están.

At least Dimash excels in his own style. I love the fact that the divider between opera and pop does not exist when I listen to his songs. Simply stated, not opera, not pop, simply excellent.

Asombroso Dimash 💯💯🇨🇷❤️

Обожаю Вас и Ваши комментарии! И полностью с Вами согласна! Димаш уникален!

You are very respectful and I understand you very well. We are all a little bit biased when it comes to Dimash. It was the first time I listened to opera and so I came to know more about opera. So it opens new musical worlds. Dimash makes art through music so it is original and comes from inspiration, not from planning a career as a superstar. I love the way he looks at his life and music.

Hello William, first of all, Dimash is not a follower but an innovator. In addition, it is unlikely that an independent artist from Kazakhstan will be a household name in the West without a record label and heavy advertising. Dimash is aware of this and chose that path. Slowly but surely 💪👍😃

William, I am personally so glad we have Dimash in our world. Because of him and then reactors like you with musical knowledge we simpletons are learning a lot from your comments and analysis about music and singing. That is far more important and helpful than trying to put Dimash in a category. It is all a helluva lot of fun too!

Спасибо Уильям . Не оправдыайтесь, я всё равно люблю Ваши реакции на Димаша и уважаю Ваше мнение. Вы всегда корректно, интересно и с любовью отзывается о творчестве Димаша. Димаш - сын степей. 😂. Широкой душой и размахом крыльев. Он молод и ему все интересно. Он может и пусть пробует то, что ему интересно данный момент. Всем он не может нравится. Кто его любит, тот всегда его поймёт и примет то что делает наш Димаш. Спасибо Вам ещё раз. С уважением из России ❤

Thank you William. Wonderful conversation about Dimash! Some of Dimash's fans should take a breath before becoming defensive. They are not doing Dimash any good by not accepting a healthy, intelligent, and informed conversation and the sharing of thoughts and observations. Dimash does not live in a bubble. He would not appreciate fans trying to protect him by closing their ears to information and observations about music, and the differences between singers and types of delivery. Dimash calls his singing style 'Neoclassical' and it is a perfect word for it. Yes, Dimash does not fit into categories already established. He is forging his own way with training, quality, musical knowledge, and a desire to know everything that there is to know about music. Then he shares it with us. Dimash's 'Dears' need to grow and learn without fear that if someone compares (in an informed way) Dimash to other serious singers, that it is o.k. It does not hurt Dimash. Blindly defending him without knowledge or information, does him no good and just makes Dimash's fans look... (excuse me for saying this)... ridiculous. Dimash's 'Dears' need to up their game! Dimash is all about appreciating music, and would have no problem with what you said William, and Dimash's fans also should not have difficulty with it either. You are knowledgeable, you are informed, you are an incredible listener, you are intelligent, you have a true appreciation for Dimash's amazing abilities, and you are experienced. Dimash has continued his quest for musical knowledge and experience and I believe that Dimash's fans should do the same. This is how we all will grow and how the world will find and appreciate Dimash.

Yo creo que encaja perfectamente en cualquier categoría, solo es mi opinion❤❤Dimash🤗

Thank you for your time to explain this , for me personally I am so glad that Dimash declined the opera house offer other wise I never will discover him , I dont like opera singing at all only this time I listened to opera when Dimash sang it the way he sang it was way way pleasant to the ear and if you notice he doesn’t want to be overpowered on Domingo, I hope with all my heart Dimash not take the opera as a path , and the way he mixes the genre is very unique, BTW he has songs are pure POP but you didn’t heard yet , شكرا جزيلا لك على وقتك مره اخرى ، طالما هنالك ديماش نحن (dears will always be there)

Димаш - эпоха нашего времени. У Димаша два оперных образования и его приглашали в престижный театр, но он отказался. Он уже пел дуэтом с оперным певцом Сундет Байгожин "Notre-Dame de Paris", пел с оперной певицей Аидой Гарифулиной, с Зариной Алтынбаевой.

Dimash is in his own category, and therefore neither the opera world nor the pop world accepts him too much.First of all, Dimash is a man of art, and music, not divided into genres, flows through him, leaving a completely new mark in history.

Dimash sabe que no encaja en perfil específico. Está absolutamente conciente de que canta para una minoría. Qué le vamos a hacer? Escogió el camino más difícil. No es por eso que lo amamos? Escogió no oscurecer más la voz en esa interpretación porque es fiel a sí mismo, no busca aprobación. Y por favor, no necesita que nadie lo esté defendiendo . Nunca he visto que esté en busca de abogados 🙄. Hace lo que quiere, como él quiere. Por eso no tiene contratos con managers ni disqueras. Muchos se amargan por cualquier crítica, mientras que a él no le importa!!! Es feliz haciendo las cosas a su estilo y punto ❤❤❤

Dear William, I know you are a real dear like us. And you are sharing your worries with us. I like that. Dimash has a lot of opportunities and interests and dreams and the world of music is open for him because of his skills. So perhaps it`s not easy to decide, which way to go. But I think, he does everything on purpose: Breaking walls down between genres, styles, traditions, and countries, with using traditional instruments, lot of different languages, integrating eastern style into western pop music, and so on. But you are right, he has that operativ tone in his voice and not everybody is able to love that or can even appreciate what he is capable of. But it is Dimash`s best part of his character, not to leave his path. He can`t get disturbed from what he wants. So I`m trusting him. He knows what he does. And fame is not the most important thing to him.

I have noticed a lot of Reactors on KZfaq will ask this question of Dimash and Avi Kaplan. "What genera is this?" They are trying to categorize the sound. When they ask about Avi, I just say, "the category is Avi Kaplan." While Avi is classically trained Basso Profundo, and was offered a bass position with the L.A. Opera House in his early 20's, that was not what he wanted to do. The next day, he was offered a bass position with the newly forming A Capella group Pentatonix. He took it, made his millions in 6 years and left from horrible fatigue. As he wrote his own music and released, his fans knew he was finding his place in music. Not a huge fan base like he had with PTX, but still his place. Now, Dimash has a much larger fan base, and generally, they accept whatever genera he has placed himself in. I am surprised some did not like his strictly operatic sound. I find his vast range of abilities to be quite wonderful.

Здесь простая истина. Пласидо после знакомства с Димашем по интернету, это его внук показал Димаша, Пласиду Доминго конечно же захотелось воочию увидеть Димаша и конечно же спеть с ним, услышать живой голос Димаша, поэтому и было предложение, что обязательно надо спеть дуэтом. Только и всего. Задачи не стояло спеть прямо оперным голосом, почему такое внимание оперной теме. Димаш бы если захотел пел в опере, но он отказался. Зачем такие скрупулезные подходы, тем более Димаш может все петь. Говорите о Димаше то, что он поет в данный момент, делайте реакции, но не надо лезть в дебри. Всем добра и адекватности во всем❤

Thank you for your reactions to Dimash. Yes, he is truly unique and special. He can’t be categorized or compared. He is on a league of his own. I’m a nurse, I only listen to music for pleasure. After I discovered Dimash, I started to really love music. I’ve learned a lot about different genres and techniques thanks to him. I’m not a fan of Opera but Dimash introduced me to it. Now I’m open to listen to some opera too. It’s amazing how he has changed me in a couple of years. The feelings and emotions that I experience when I listen to Dimash are great. And the fact that you can’t even imagine what’s he’s going to do next it’s so exciting. I’ve seen Dimash singing with opera singers before: Kazakh singers, Sundet Baigozhin and Zarina Altynbayeva. I’ll leave you the link. Anyways I don’t think he was doing opera here but he was amazing as always. Thank you, again, I’ve learned a lot thanks to you, too. kzfaq.info/get/bejne/ps53jMuhmJ7HZ6c.htmlsi=SoLkKRxHViKi9hPD kzfaq.info/get/bejne/Zqlzm7CcnrXNZI0.htmlsi=YNV21zzuTd1Aszsu

I think you're right about Dimash not fitting either the opera or pop "world". In fact, it seems to me that that is exactly the way he wants it. He had the opportunity to join the opera world where, with his dedication to perfecting his craft, he would no doubt have risen as far as possible. He could also easily join the pop world if he just left out all of the colours that come from his classical training and was content to write and sing mostly songs with suggestive lyrics and a limited range. Instead, he chose to blend the two worlds (along with folk singing). Sort of like an artist who isn't a painter and isn't a sculptor but is a multi-media artist. Just as this may cause a few purists to dislike his work, I think it is also what draws his fans TO his music. I like the beautiful tunes in his songs. I like the fact that although he sings in many languages, I don't have to worry that I may be singing something rude if I try to sing along. I like the way he sings about important concepts (like time passing, the need to stop war and fighting with love and acceptance, etc.)I like the way he uses so many tones and styles in one song to express emotion. I love the way he sings with his entire body and especially the way he uses his hands to pluck notes out of the air and move them into the range he wants them in. Truthfully, I think with the range and skills he has, his ability and beauty would have been lost if he had limited himself to just opera or just pop.I think he has chosen correctly for who he is and that he will draw the audience that is right for him also. Thanks for your thoughts in the video. It's fun to have this back and forth exchange of ideas!

Dimash es uníco su voz nos ha conquistado ❤️🙏🤗🇵🇪

Thank you William, spot on as always. He doesn't fit in anywhere, and that can be extremely difficult for an artist, you say. I think Dimash is fully aware of it and he has grown from the sunny, smiling boy he was into this serious, I would say introverted young man that we see today. There is even a slight sadness in his eyes. People who love his art are also puzzled why not everyone is smitten with his voice the moment they hear him. The world is more divided today than it was in 1990 when Pavarotti, Bocelli and Zuccero recorded Miserere. Some of the great musical art has been lost in the last 30-40 years. The link between generations was lost, if not severed, and with it continuity.

Hello Wiliam I always like your reactions to Dimash, its obvious that you understand him. I "got" your reaction the first time, I said almost the same thing to a Fan, on a different reactors site. Its shame that some of them take offense at every little thing, when they make up some statements by themselves, that are not verified. I see from the numerous comments that the Dears are a very intelligent and educated group AND know everything about Dimash. I read all of them, and agree with most. Some very insightful remarks here. I hope that he continues on his chosen path, he is an extremely intelligent man and knows what he wants to do, and does it, Spectacularly!!! Go Dimash.😊😊😊 Cheers

I agree with what you say, he doesn't fit in any category, and I'm sure Dimash knows it. He said in an interview that he likes and listens to many types of music, so logically he likes to sing many different genres ... because he can. I find very interesting, original and brave his musical evolution, at the moment just tasting different styles and genres. He is doing what he wants in the way he wants, and he is very successful, not as much as others, but probably enough for him.

Hello William! Yes, I think you are correct in your assessment! I was also thinking about that, and I wonder if it is better this way? The price of becoming a huge household name is very steep. You get tremendous pressure on yourself, everyone wants something from you, pushes you, your freedom shrinks into non-existence. What Dimash has now is already spectacular, and probably a heavy burden too, but it still allows for some of the normal life, people do not jump on him when he walks on the street in US and many other places. I hope he will have enough creative freedom and he will find inspiration to figure out what he wanna do next and enjoy his life, and create something beautiful that we Dears will appreciate immensely 😍

MERCI BEAUCOUP POUR TOUTES VOS EXPLICATIONS ....NOUS AIMONS DIMASH.....NOUS AIMONS SON TRAVAIL ET SON ACHARNEMENT À SE DONNER À FOND À TOUT CE QU IL FAIT AVEC BEAUCOUP DE PASSION ....❤❤❤❤

William, thank you for your interesting point of wiev. I think you are onto something. I agree that Dimash does not fit into any"standard boxes", because they are too small for him. For this very reason he declined the offer to sing in Astana opera. May be Dimash just need to start his own category. History will settle this.❤✌️

Well, I think Dimash is really a special form. He goes his own way. I don't know whether it will ever become so popular around the world that it will be featured in the media. I don't even know if I should want that. Fact one is, he hasn't yet surrendered himself to any official opportunities in the music business, which he would have to do in order to be supported by them. But if he wants to remain so unique, he can't do that either, because then they would have control over him and we would lose him as he is. Fact two is that he cannot be categorized, and that makes it difficult to appear in the media. For example, in Germany, radio stations are often divided into categories. Classical, pop or other classifications. Where would Dimash fit in? Which station should you play it on? On all of them? Depending on which song of his fits in here or there? He is unique and we are so lucky to know him. KZfaq is a blessing for artists like him. It fits well into this new world that is happening online. Who knows what else will happen. Part of me wishes he would become even more known worldwide, including in the media. But just as the special thing that he is.

Thank you, William, for this explanation. For many years, my friend and I had season tickets to the Kennedy Center Opera House and enjoyed expanding our musical appreciation. I'm still a total newbie about opera though! When I listened to Dimash with Placido Domingo, and thought about "opera" from my limited experience, Dimash's voice seemed, I don't know, the word that came to me was "brighter" and I thought that perhaps he needed more weight (literally!) behind him. I loved his voice nevertheless (I've been a Dear since The Singer. I love Dimash's passion about HIS music and how he won't be categorized. When I think about sharing his music, I have to stop and think "who would enjoy this particular song?" instead of just sending it out to everyone. You are always my first go-to reactor when it comes to Dimash. Thank you for taking the time to post this. ~ a Dear from Maryland, USA

And what would have been the importance in Dimash's life if he had chosen to be a traditional opera singer? In my opinion, none, he would just be part of a category of operatic singers. Dimash, an extremely intelligent young man, was able to use this to his advantage with all his talent and hard work to spread his message.

Dear William, thank you for your clarification though I felt that you made your points very clear in your earlier video. Dimash is not an opera singer, though he was trained in operatic techniques early in his schooling. I admit that I found Dimash’s version more pleasing but also realized that it was not necessarily traditional. I actually liked the comparison. Thanks for all you do. Please continue to share your experience and opinions with us; I enjoy your videos very much!

I believe Dimash is very mature and already realized an artist do not need to pursue main stream. He just needs to find all his public and he will be able to live from his art. Once they try to fit in a particular type of formula they may get super famous but get stuck in an art they do not believe in, or don’t excite them enough. David Bowie went there and he hate it. He was much better going back to experimental art. Dimash is similar in that way. He is bigger than one style, or one language. He likes to explore and he is collecting his public doing what he loves. Not bending to mainstream formulas and contracts.

Hi William! I've been over my head the past few weeks and it was hard to find time to watch anything. So I had not watched yet your "comparison" video when I came across this one and naturally it got me intrigued! So I watched that too, right after. Let me say that I'm so grateful you are around! I find all of your input fascinating, extremely interesting and educative as well as utterly entertaining in the way you put it through! Thanks so much for sharing your knowledge with us 🙏❤ I have immense appreciation and respect for opera singers and a very clear idea of how hard it is to train your voice that way. But I'm one of those who are not accustomed to that style, it sounds too "heavy and annoying" in my ears, BUT... to be honest I should also admit that I've never given opera any chance to grow on me... I also totally get all that you say about Dimash. The reason his voice speaks to me so deeply is firstly related to his natural tone, his unique, personal timbre, which - to me - is truly the most pleasant male voice I've ever heard. Skills aside. A totally subjective opinion of course. And secondly, it's not his range but the artistry and the emotional depth with which he is using all his skills. Those are the Dimash hooks for me. Consequently, regarding pure opera singers, I can add one more factor "why" they often come across as non-natural to many people. It's their faces!! What they're doing with their voices is so hard and demands so much focus and often such extreme vowel formations, that their expressions lose the natural feel of a story teller and all I can see is a distorted face creepily dissolved into a pair of epically wide eyeballs & mouth! There's no room for the emotions to come through. The effort and the technique overshadow all story telling in my eyes. While Dimash's face, being non restricted to the specific rules of strict opera voice style, is always mirroring the story and hence conveying all the emotions of the song. I don't mean any disrespect to Kaufmann & Hvorostovky, this is just a sincere attempt to explain "why" they can't move me. It's not just about the voice style, it's the strong impact form the audio-visual combo that throws me off. Although I should also admit that there were parts in their duet which - singled out - sounded divine even to my ears 😊 As for your basic question about Dimash's versatility, I have a lot to say but unfortunately not much time, so I'll have to go. But I want to close this comment by saying that I always love the way you react to over-protective Dears! Just laying pure facts objectively, logically with neither bitterness nor guilt and... with tons of subtle yet witty humor! 😅❤👏

I had a good friend when I lived in NY. She was a of Evolutionary Biology professor at Colombia, . When I was visiting her one day I asked if humans were still evolving? She answered that yes, we were; however, it is estimated that formamide transitions take up to 20,000 years. That conversation from all those years ago now has me having hours-long chats about this with my friends and how it seems to be the only logical thing we may be seeing. Dimash is the dawn of not only a new genre, but also the fingerprint of evolution before our very eyes. One day when the young today is very old will say that they remembered hearing him sing when he was alive and they feel blessed to have been so.

Dimash is our trailblazer! He is one of a kind and so is his "category". For those who are stuck in the mud about trying to decide into which category or voice range Dimash belongs, I say, too bad for them. We Dears have been watching Dimash for YEARS and he still surprises us with each new song. I attribute these surprises to his variety of vocal, instrumental and cinematic talents and how he combines them. My personal opinion is that by placing an artist into a "genre", we can unwittingly limit the creativity of someone who supersedes the norms. Thank you, William, for recognizing Dimash as the treasure he is.

Thank you William for your collective analysis of Dimash's singing genra.

I love you both your both unique in your own ways. Sending love from Michigan USA 💌💖💌

Pues creo que eso es parte de lo que lo hace único, que no pueda encasillársele!... difícil camino el que ha elegido, y ello hace que valore mucho más todo su trabajo creativo. Espero que más temprano que tarde, se le dé el valor que se merece. Gracias William, mi cariño desde Chile 🫶🏻🇨🇱

Hi William, he said it himself on a trip he made to India. He said that the kind of music he makes is neo-classical or crossover, and that it's very difficult to get an audience , but In spite of this, he has managed to have a lot of fans around the world who like the kind of music he creates. And I am one of them of course 😊 I am so happy to have the privilege of hearing the wonderful voice of Dimash, for us, his dears he is unique as a singer, as a composer and as human being. Thank you William, I appreciate your reactions and statements about Dimash. 🌹

Completamente de acuerdo Dimash es excepcional y no hay comparación, ni clasificación es único en todos sus extremos. Cuando me lo encontré en KZfaq en pandemia, èl pasó adelante y me dijo: " con permiso aquí me quedó" y hasta el momento no lo he dejado ir. Me produce tantas emociones increíbles al escucharlo y verlo cantar; eso es lo que a él le importa y le interesa, provocar que su voz , sus interpretaciones nos lleguen al alma y nos hagan vibrar.❤❤❤

I really liked your comparison. And he himself said he's trying for a neoclassical style of singing. Mixing genres in songs. But also Dimash does have true pop songs too. Give me your love, Be with me, Zhalyn, Fly Away, Neverland, My Beauty, just to name a few.

Hola desde Argentina..Creo qué ahí recide su magia,no e caja en ningún estilo y es capaz de cantar todos y fusionarlos,una voz maravillosa,trabajo duro y una creación y mentalidad sin límites!! ES UN GENIO!!!

Спасибо дорогой Уильям что вы есть такой какой есть . Здоровья и процветания вам.

It's funny I was thinking about how my opera singing and coaching friends would struggle with this performance. For the most part they were merciless in criticizing this same duet when Domingo performed it with Andrea Bocelli. One other reactor (Wordsmith) was great in poining out that there are many sorts of tenors and this perfomance was mostly in the lyrical category and many have pointed out that Dimash made an effort to "match" his partner, Domingo, in a duet where neither should dominate the other. He managed it with nuance and respect. It has been pointed out that Dimash has a number of times demonstrated more drama, darkness and volume in his baritone (and bass), and brightness in his tenor, particularly in El Amor En Ti. And he has been known to "drop the mike" and sing unamplified filling his performance space. I have longed for Dimash to gift us with a purely operatic performance of an aria and this may be the closest we get to it since he refuses to be locked into any one genre. Our beloved reactor Ceci Dover was overcome with emotion like so many of us, including you, with this extraordinary perfomance. And that, in the end, is what performance is about. Not so much about the appreciation of excellence in technique as touching universal emotional responses as the highest form of artistic acheivent.

Thanks William I totally understand what you were trying to illustrate. I heard an interview with Dimash where he readily identified his genre as neo-classical and agreed with the interviewer when she said it was going to be a challenge, in terms of popularity. But it seems that’s what keeps him motivated, and, certainly for his fans, that diversity is what keeps our interest. You never know what is coming next! Exciting! Truly he is a genius! So are you! Always love to hear your well considered and professional thoughts about Dimash whom I know you also greatly admire 🙏💕✌️

Williams es un excelente profesional y admira el trabajo maravilloso del maestro Dimash simplemente gracias Williams por tener en tu canal al mejor cantante del mundo 🌎...sería interesante que reaccionaras a Passione en el Aniversario de Kaznua por favor gracias 😊

Thanks so much William ❤

Дуже рада кожному вашому коментарію чи реакції на Дімаша. Ваші думки цікаві. Від вас не треба захищати Дімаша, бо ви відноситесь до нього з великою симпатією і справедливі до його таланту! Дякую, завжди чекаю на ваші реакції.❤

Dimash is not very popular in the West only because he does not sign contracts with large production companies, so there is no large investment in advertising, Dimash wants to be free in his creativity

I'm a great admirer of our Dimash's gigantic talent, but I don't see any problem with people who have in-depth knowledge of singing techniques making constructive considerations about his imperfections. We know that although he is extraordinary, he can and will improve his singing techniques even further, because that is how he is, he seeks perfection to deliver the best possible to his fans, and we thank him for this honor.

I agree with everthing you say.💚

Thank you very much for this analysis. I always appreciate your postings and have recommended them to others. ❤

Exactly, thank you.

Great job of describing your reasoning. I think there's some Dimash Dears who simply like to compete on who is the most addicted, adoring and enDEARing of the Dears. By the count of your playlist of just Dimash performances, I would say you're up there in the most addicted category to his voice and performances. Just saying, that no one really can complain or criticized about your love and endearment to the GOAT. I am still amazed at how long your playlist is of Dimash.😮

I loved both duets, and explored further after your comparison. Thank you for that! ❤❤❤

Hola William, a mi me gustó mucho su canto ,con Plácido Domingo y también sus otros estilos, quizás para alguien como yo que es un mortal común ,no note las imperfecciones del canto operístico, pero Dimash a hecho que lo escuche y para mi ya es un gran paso en la educación de mi oreja, creo que nunca me habría interesado si no fuera por Dimash ,👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

I agree! It’s also what makes him unique.❤

Ciao william sai che dimash e/un professore di bel canto che ha un master in jazz e molto altro ❤