Is There Meaning In "Subverting" Shounen Tropes?

  Рет қаралды 396,796

Trixie the Golden Witch

Trixie the Golden Witch

7 жыл бұрын

The Golden Witch writes on Substack: goldenwitch.substack.com
And is also supported on Patreon: / goldenwitchfire
Golden Witch on Instagram: / goldenwitchfire
Golden Witch on Twitter: / goldenwitchfire
Edited by Davoo: / thedavoo
Under the Scope on Deconstruction: • What Actually Is A Dec...
Shouts out to Jaxblade and Best Guy Ever for their consultation on collecting clips for this video:
Jaxblade: / jaxblade07
Best Guy Ever: / @bestguyever
Text version: myswordisunbelievablydull.wor...

Пікірлер: 2 100
@twilftw
@twilftw 7 жыл бұрын
Well actual digi hunter x hunter is a deconstruction of shonen Jump because the magazine is called weekly shonen jump and hunter x hunter dosnt come out weekly.
@123rtXd
@123rtXd 5 жыл бұрын
togashi with the 1000000 trillion iq play
@turtleboy1188
@turtleboy1188 5 жыл бұрын
This
@Jun-bm8ly
@Jun-bm8ly 5 жыл бұрын
what did togashi mean by this??!
@fusionxtras
@fusionxtras 5 жыл бұрын
FUUUUUCK
@Snetzelsnetzalsnetzul
@Snetzelsnetzalsnetzul 5 жыл бұрын
Genius
@Kohdok
@Kohdok 6 жыл бұрын
tl;dr - People are mistaking competent writing for being subversive.
@TheRachaelLefler
@TheRachaelLefler 5 жыл бұрын
It's not unique to anime either. If I had a dime for every time I browsed new books and found a crappy 'subversive' or 'dark' version of a classic fairy tale.... :/ Please stop making these. Your feminist grimdark take on Little Red Riding Hood is not a new or original idea.
@tiagodarkpeasant
@tiagodarkpeasant 5 жыл бұрын
hxh is good not because it is subversive, but it is subversive, every arc defy expectations first arc has the inverse tournment where the strongest fight only one time, meaning no increasing stakes second arc has the dansel in destress simply walk out, while the heroes are getting their powerups third arc they never get to the top of the arena, at least gon achieve to give the number back to hisoka, but doesn't defeat him in a "surprising" development mid battle fourth arc is the meeting between the heroes and the main villains, they never fight because they are too weak, the semi main character gets his vegeance, but it is useless greed island is the less subversive,they have a full trining arc, gon actually wins the game, get the prize and use it to get closer to his objective them we have chimera ant the most analyzed arc current arc is jojo battle royale
@TheRachaelLefler
@TheRachaelLefler 5 жыл бұрын
It's good when an anime is subversive but when it's trying to be subversive for no other reason than to be cool, that's crap. Same with grimdark writing.
@ineednochannelyoutube5384
@ineednochannelyoutube5384 5 жыл бұрын
The expectation is shit writing. Competent writing subverts the expectation.
@HigurashiMerlin
@HigurashiMerlin 5 жыл бұрын
@@tiagodarkpeasant That kind of subersivion is just called good story telling. In terms of a shounen it is just calling attention to the flaw story telling of the most mainstream shounen stories.
@DisProveMeWrong
@DisProveMeWrong 7 жыл бұрын
I dont even care if things are subversive or main stream. I just like good stories.
@CidGuerreiro1234
@CidGuerreiro1234 7 жыл бұрын
Same here. No point in being different or subversive if it's also boring as shit.
@thugishere6629
@thugishere6629 7 жыл бұрын
CidGuerreiro1234 yeah you're right but how the fuck is jojo subversive
@oldmanlogan9616
@oldmanlogan9616 5 жыл бұрын
You said it all.
@dereenaldoambun9158
@dereenaldoambun9158 5 жыл бұрын
@@CidGuerreiro1234 Totally agree.
@shadowman6110
@shadowman6110 3 жыл бұрын
Here here
@psychronia
@psychronia 7 жыл бұрын
So in summation, good Shounen aren't good because they avoid old tropes, they're good because they use them well in one way or another.
@matt0044
@matt0044 7 жыл бұрын
It's not the tools, it's how you utilize them.
@marlonyo
@marlonyo 7 жыл бұрын
going to give you 3 likes for that comment
@popopop984
@popopop984 4 жыл бұрын
Genius man
@ss6truks
@ss6truks 4 жыл бұрын
Bingo. This is why I like My Hero
@ggwp638BC
@ggwp638BC 7 жыл бұрын
If subvertion is the mainstream, doesn't that mean that, to actually subvert the tropes, you need to follow the suposed mainstream to default, in order to contrast with the actual mainstream of trying to subvert it?
@Puntosmx
@Puntosmx 7 жыл бұрын
GGWP Your deconstruction of deconstructivist mainstream is making my head hurt x_x
@Lyoshi157
@Lyoshi157 7 жыл бұрын
Really makes you think huh
@dohickey7184
@dohickey7184 7 жыл бұрын
GGWP subception
@iamalittleboat
@iamalittleboat 7 жыл бұрын
so everything that isn't subversive _is_ subversive of the subversive. which means that in essence everything is subversive, - but if that's the case then we might as well say nothing is.
@Narlaw1199
@Narlaw1199 7 жыл бұрын
I think you found the secret to the success of fairy tail.
@DxBlack
@DxBlack 7 жыл бұрын
...totally jumped over the fact that Saitama wasn't trying at the end of S1 and his opponent pointed it out as he was dying.
@sebsthexeno9460
@sebsthexeno9460 7 жыл бұрын
DxBlack Well regardless, the fight didn't end with one punch.
@psychoflashdrive4564
@psychoflashdrive4564 7 жыл бұрын
That wasn't his point. His point was that it just turned into a normal shonen fight.
@FeanixFlamage
@FeanixFlamage 7 жыл бұрын
i wouldn't really call it a normal shonen fight. saitama was more or less just taking the hits like they were nothing for most of the fight. most finale battles in anime have both characters pulling out all the stops, throwing down as many big and flashy powerful attacks at their disposal, neither one giving an inch as they struggle back and forth. saitama more or less just humors his opponent at the very end after he uses a "serious" move, if only so he wasn't entirely disappointed in the outcome of the fight when he realized how utterly and hopelessly powerless against saitama. even if the fight didn't end with one punch, it was still what, three punches? (not counting his consecutive punches which might as well have been overkill)
@G34RImmenseTriickZ
@G34RImmenseTriickZ 7 жыл бұрын
FeanixFlamage although you point is valid, what if saitama was actually being serious, and instead was bummed out at the end, thinking that the fight he just had was the best he was ever going to find. Just a thought. I'm not the most knowledgable and would not mind if you replied on this matter.
@AnimeOverdose1
@AnimeOverdose1 7 жыл бұрын
It's not about that. The point is that the show doesn't stay true to its core 'joke' and depicts an epic fight as it just wants to show cool fighting scenes as any other shounen. Saitama could've easily ended a fight after seeing that Boros could take his normal punch and Saitama doesn't do this just because he feels pity for Boros as he totally understands his situation as noone else and let him go all out just before he kills him, that's why Saitama uses 'serious punch' only when Boros makes his final move. A justified scene but that's not the point that is made here.
@Puntosmx
@Puntosmx 7 жыл бұрын
My stancd is simple: There are so many tropes that trying to "subvert" one makes you fall into another. Also, sticking to ia trope and subverting is not the point. The point is telling a compelling story.
@Puntosmx
@Puntosmx 7 жыл бұрын
Yes, I agree. Tropes are narrative archetypes that allow us to understand stories with ease. Subverting them is a narrative tool to tell compelling stories. In the end, tropes and subversion are just tools to tell stories ^_^
@tiagodarkpeasant
@tiagodarkpeasant 5 жыл бұрын
that is the thing, subversion is a tool, not the objective, you can be subversive and fail, if it leads to a worse story, like sao never fighting the fucking boss, just a maniac with hacks
@JaxBlade
@JaxBlade 7 жыл бұрын
Phenomenal video my friend, you covered all my favs haha and thank you for the shout out haha im honored and happy to have Helped ^_^
@LioMei3
@LioMei3 7 жыл бұрын
How can I get a JoJo body though?
@Ronin11111111
@Ronin11111111 7 жыл бұрын
8 hours of training every day for 20 years.
@enzantakeshita8838
@enzantakeshita8838 7 жыл бұрын
Depends on what part you're after!
@LioMei3
@LioMei3 7 жыл бұрын
I'm after *the body* part of a body.
@enzantakeshita8838
@enzantakeshita8838 7 жыл бұрын
Lio Mei I meant story parts like Stardust Crusaders or Vento Aureo... O___O
@owlid3890
@owlid3890 7 жыл бұрын
"Gintoki has ended major dramatic arcs while screaming 'domestic violience' and hitting people over the head with the wooden sword" This just convinced me to start watching gintama
@FirstFallSnow
@FirstFallSnow 7 жыл бұрын
Why can't a good show just be a good show? Why does everything have to be revolutionary? Media over-saturation maybe?
@matt0044
@matt0044 5 жыл бұрын
We just crave something new.
@captaincap4931
@captaincap4931 4 жыл бұрын
@@matt0044 that crave is a fatal flaw
@cavendish2925
@cavendish2925 4 жыл бұрын
Some people like to feel "smart/intellectual." I should know the feeling firsthand; been there, done that.
@dranoradragonqueen1494
@dranoradragonqueen1494 4 жыл бұрын
probaby
@wallstreetzoomer
@wallstreetzoomer 3 жыл бұрын
@@cavendish2925 its a phase, Im over it and went back to the Narutard that I was as a kid.
@jiIIua
@jiIIua 7 жыл бұрын
None of those things make Hunter x Hunter a deconstruction of the shonen genre, but these things do: Gon's unfailing optimism, a staple of the shonen protagonist, is the reason he can't accept Kite's death and insists he's alive even when it's clear to everyone else that he's gone. Killua's unyielding devotion to his friend, another staple of shonen manga, tears him apart and weighs on him so heavily that he breaks down under the expectations. It takes shonen tropes and examines them realistically, and it's not just the chimera ant arc that addresses those subversions: it's slowly built upon for the entire series. The violence and darkness aren't what makes it a deconstruction (or maybe not a full deconstruction, just.. deconstructive?) But that's definitely not the only thing that makes it great.
@KinglyRed
@KinglyRed 7 жыл бұрын
jillleigh99 Yeah the one thing I would use to label HxH as a deconstruction is Gon's character. The story presents him in a certain way early on and you're lead to believe he's just another happy-go-lucky Luffy or Goku kind of hero. Then as things go on you slowly discover that what defines him as a "classic" shonen protagonist are also the things that make him violently unstable and a danger to himself and his friends. The moment when a mass-murdering bomb maniac calls HIM crazy says it all, really
@Shadic6098
@Shadic6098 7 жыл бұрын
jillleigh99 ...I don't feel like you even hit the mark on what he was trying to accomplish with the video. He wasn't claiming that certain elements from HxH made it a deconstruction, rather that these elements don't make it subversive. Digi is saying the elements are only just good storytelling and nothing more.
@jiIIua
@jiIIua 7 жыл бұрын
Shadic6098 I feel as if the purpose of the video was to point out the elements that people often cite to argue that a show is a deconstruction,& showing that those points don't necessarily make a show subversive. With my comment I was trying to address some of the elements that I think do make it deconstructive & subversive, in a sense, because he didn't address them & because I'm always ready to sing the praises of hxh lol
@buckwade3874
@buckwade3874 7 жыл бұрын
+jilleigh99 That...sounds genuinely mature, and interesting.
@animewatcher102
@animewatcher102 7 жыл бұрын
Someone was going to mention it eventually but One Punch Man has its own Hercule. Great video by the way.
@OniLinkBrazil1993
@OniLinkBrazil1993 7 жыл бұрын
King?
@huonglevan2276
@huonglevan2276 7 жыл бұрын
+OniLink that's a spoiler
@sirbruno95
@sirbruno95 7 жыл бұрын
Hưởng Lê Văn Man. I wasn't patient enough and read ahead in the manga. After reading that part, that scene in episode 11 made so much sense. It was glorious.
@wolfpackgaming2492
@wolfpackgaming2492 7 жыл бұрын
AnonEars mumem rider?
@swolechic
@swolechic 7 жыл бұрын
Naw, Mumen rider is perfectly aware of how he compares to other heroes, and he actually is still badass for doing his best.
@mindlessfury
@mindlessfury 7 жыл бұрын
It's called a counterculture, it's a well documented reaction to the over-use of specific themes or styles in usually artistic fields. Read up on it sometime because it's extremely well explored and theres hundreds of cases of it throughout history. Once a saturation reaches a certain point only two things can happen, the new generation can embrace it and take a step further with it, or they can shun it, and in that case the media that they create will be a counter culture, and it'll usually be as drastically a fuck you to the media that can before it as they can possibly manage. This is the start of that counter culture, artists/writers seeing "well hey im sick as shit as this, I wonder if the market is too"
@tumbke
@tumbke 7 жыл бұрын
Once the counterculture is embraced, it becomes mainstream. After that, we just do it again and again, possibly taking inspiration from previous eras to create the "new" counterculture. It's pretty much the history of art, where the "new" culture is just a reaction to the previous one.
@EternallApprentace
@EternallApprentace 7 жыл бұрын
While I want to agree with you, I think humbly of how I am only 27. Started anime at age 3 or 4, and it could barely walk compared to the speed at which it's dosed out these days, all technology and such considered. So perhaps it has just started after all, but we're in a time where the attention span left over is diluted and diminishing with all that keeps flying to the screens. In other words, our time to care gets smaller and smaller as inflation of crap rises lol...but objective time wise, perhaps we could still consider this trend "new"?
@mindlessfury
@mindlessfury 7 жыл бұрын
Sounds like a personal problem. Don't imprint your personal problems with the medium and think it's the general feel of the world.
@NuclearCherries
@NuclearCherries 7 жыл бұрын
I'd ask you to do a video on how Fairy Tail fails as a Shounen action series, but that would mean that you'd have to watch Fairy Tail, and no one would have to suffer doing that.
@Trixiethegoldenwitch
@Trixiethegoldenwitch 7 жыл бұрын
Luckily, this guy did kzfaq.info/get/bejne/qN2igcyL1qzFcZ8.html
@Dragonborn-jw6yl
@Dragonborn-jw6yl 7 жыл бұрын
yeah, just watched his, but his doesn't go in as much depth as i'd like it to like yours :/
@skerllyfulgencio4036
@skerllyfulgencio4036 7 жыл бұрын
As you were talking about shonen series being different, you should talk about World Trigger, another Shonen Jump series(and unfortunately an underrated one) that avoids most of the common cliches with the genre(letting the protagonist alone to save the world, use power ups, etc) Read it or watch it, but please talk about it man
@skerllyfulgencio4036
@skerllyfulgencio4036 7 жыл бұрын
+Digibro As you were talking about shonen series being different, you should talk about World Trigger, another Shonen Jump series(and unfortunately an underrated one) that avoids most of the common cliches with the genre(letting the protagonist alone to save the world, use power ups, etc) Read it or watch it, but please talk about it man
@skerllyfulgencio4036
@skerllyfulgencio4036 7 жыл бұрын
As you were talking about shonen series being different, you should talk about World Trigger, another Shonen Jump series(and unfortunately an underrated one) that avoids most of the common cliches with the genre(letting the protagonist alone to save the world, use power ups, etc) Read it or watch it, but please talk about it man
@for56seven60
@for56seven60 2 жыл бұрын
OK this video hit the nail on the head as to why it annoys me when people say hunter x hunter is good because it goes against the grain or whatever the fuck. DONT boil good narritives down soley to the fact that it goes against something, if it were that simple to create a story on the scale and quality of HxH then any dumbass with a pen and paper could make a story just as good. I never understood why people saying those things annoyed me so much until I watched this vid and now I'm almost more annoyed lol cause I can see more clearly how I'd argue they're almost objectively incorrect.
@rexgeorgerodriguez7620
@rexgeorgerodriguez7620 Жыл бұрын
Really? Hunter x Hunter sure have those common anime tropes and storyline but I don't think someone could simply come up of how the story is structured and executed well like Togashi does. For example, the main four characters are not even always together in every arc and somehow Togashi manage to tell a story without feeling it out of place. If you read the manga further to the current arc, you will know what I mean. Not every mangaka do the story where the big main character like Gon completely out of the next arc without it being out of place but it manages to pull out naturally because Gon's journey to find his father ended. Many mangakas subverts expectations but done it poorly same for common or cliché storyline in anime, even though its repetitive as long as its done great its a good anime.
@tutumazibuko2510
@tutumazibuko2510 5 ай бұрын
@@rexgeorgerodriguez7620 plenty of writers can and have, read more instead of sucking off Togashi so much
@daone1008
@daone1008 7 жыл бұрын
I think that having subversive elements in a story is not the same as building a whole series on a subversive foundation. One Punch Man is truly unique in the way that none of the dramatic tension hinges on whether Saitama will win or not. This alone changes the entire dynamic of the story, as it is no longer about the main character overcoming obstacles. But instead about meaningful interactions aside from doing battle, and existential problems a godlike human can provoke in people who are already very strong. Same goes with HunterXHunter. It subverses the convention that shounen protagonists are important people who affect important changes. Instead, it spends a ton of time fleshing out the antagonists, effectively making it an ensemble story, which is exceedingly rare in the shounen genre.
@s3studios597
@s3studios597 3 жыл бұрын
That first part is basically just Superman.
@KL-gh8we
@KL-gh8we 2 жыл бұрын
Subversion in HxH is to tell you card game mechanics with over 100 cards, then painfully in detail tell about abilities of some of them, use like 4 of them, then lately the mentioned cards render useless. I have never been trolled so much before
@fortniteballs57
@fortniteballs57 Жыл бұрын
The HxH thing you did is not that subversive. One Piece, for example, was already playing with it in a shy way before, untill it became a strong point for characters like Hody Jones, Doflamingo, Señor Pink... And Jojo did that too before in Part 4.
@RemixExtender
@RemixExtender 7 жыл бұрын
11:28 "And all this time, *_I haven't even mentioned Jojo's Bizarre Adventure!_* Holy shit, do I even have to talk about it? Is there anything that it _hasn't done?_ Can anything else be said to 'play around with the genre in a big way' when part of the genre is this generation-spanning epic that's also rife with obscene violence, scatological humor, and plotting that's nothing but a maze of subversion?" tfw digi didn't talk about Jojo because _he didn't need to_
@ShinachiHChan
@ShinachiHChan 6 жыл бұрын
He lost a bit of credibility by not mentioning Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood.
@DeepDiveDevin
@DeepDiveDevin 6 жыл бұрын
FMA wasn't published in Shonen Jump.
@ShinachiHChan
@ShinachiHChan 6 жыл бұрын
@Shaddy - He's not just talking about Shounen Jump though.. He specifically mentioned "Shounen Tropes", which includes other popular Non-Jump Shounens like Fairy Tail, Detective Conan, FullMetal Alchemist, etc.
@marcomeme4875
@marcomeme4875 6 жыл бұрын
ShinachiHChan it wasn't necessary to bring up FMA. So to say "he lost credibility" is sort of ridicolous
@ShinachiHChan
@ShinachiHChan 6 жыл бұрын
Riley Jones - Actually FMA was/is very relevant when discussing the execution of shounen tropes. And anybody with credible knowledge on the genre should always consider it, in regards to the genre. Also, i specifically pointed out "*A bit* of credibility"- implied as little to none.
@Wespa64
@Wespa64 7 жыл бұрын
jojo is love jojo is life
@android19willpwn
@android19willpwn 7 жыл бұрын
*chew*
@RDV333
@RDV333 7 жыл бұрын
What I got from this video: 1) People don't actually know what subversion and deconstruction means; 2) Jojo is the tits.
@vandagylon2885
@vandagylon2885 7 жыл бұрын
Miselus subversion appently means to shake-up the system of something
@brunnokamei9623
@brunnokamei9623 6 жыл бұрын
Wespa64 Love and live, I agree. Subversive, I don't think so.
@fedeshaw2343
@fedeshaw2343 6 жыл бұрын
Android 19 DUWANG
@ude4225
@ude4225 7 жыл бұрын
The great thing I've found about One Punch Man is not that it's subversive or nothing about its meta-jokes about different manga genres, rather I feel that the great point One Punch Man tries to make is the dedramatization of fiction. Everyone in One Punch Man is a typical shonen character and the story arcs are typical shonen story arcs, but Saitama it's introduced in the world of One Punch Man to make fun of the drama fiction normally carries. That's what it's Saitama, OPM's narrative makes Saitama the only real person in a world filled by characters. Aside from his powers. By introducing the blunt, normal, unintersting real life in a fictional world we see how stupid and intense and dramatic everything is in our fictions. That's why Saitama has all this dialogue about how strange/intense/over the top everyone is acting, to depict that gap between reality and fiction. He's doing nothing new, for sure, this narrative that tries to talk about fiction through the introduction of reality in a fictional world was made centuries ago in Don Quijote de la Mancha, for example. But I feel that OPM doesn't want to particularly make fun of shonen rather talk about the difference between real life and fiction and how they interact between each other. I think OPM uses shonen because it's the most "established" structure in the culture of the author and thus it's easier for the author to make his point. Good video btw! Sorry for the long text
@Supermateo97
@Supermateo97 6 жыл бұрын
I agree with your point and you actually made me think about OPM in a new light a bit, but interestingly enough, I didn't like OPM BECAUSE of it's de-dramatization. Seeing drama and emotions are what get us attached to characters, but Saitama's non-dramatic personality means we'll never see him "really" struggle with anything and that's what (IMO) made OPM forgettable.
@RoyalFusilier
@RoyalFusilier 6 жыл бұрын
Same here. I struggled with OPM. I struggled with wanting to like it, hearing from everyone it was so good, and then just.. not being able to. There's this pervasive atmosphere of nihilism and flatness from the non-dramatic tone it tries to strike as a blow against 'fiction drama', the way mass destruction happens seemingly at random and for no reason, the powerlessness of almost everyone in this world, that all combines perhaps in ways the author didn't quite intend. The show communicated very clearly that Saitama mattered, and literally that's it, so I hope you don't care about anyone else. Even Genos is never going to win or succeed, so while he's likable, why bother caring about him? All the other good guys are worse for the same reason; either they're jerks, or while they may be likable, they're all complete jobbers. Either I'm not supposed to take them seriously and they're jokes, in which case why am I getting multiple whole episodes of their courageous (yet entirely futile) struggle, and if I am supposed to take them seriously, why don't they matter narratively and all that? Same with villains. If they're all one-note 'I'm going to kill humans literally just because' then why is so much time and effort spent on them, and if they're not, why don't most of them have any depth? The villains in a parody superhero show are really a chance, and so far in season one, it's just, nothing.
@joshbetraveling4eva
@joshbetraveling4eva 7 жыл бұрын
Digi interpreted the Boros fight all wrong. It's not that Saitama does defeat everyone with one punch, it's that he can defeat anyone with one punch. And he ignored/missed the end which reveals that Saitama did not fight anywhere near his full potential (though that much was obvious during the fight), and shows the emotions he has after not finding a worthy opponent once again even though Boros was by far the most promising candidate. When the series DOESN'T parody these tropes in this way and plays these tropes straight, such as in the current arc, it does so to let us better examine the personal issues of the characters involved (the heroes, in essence, and their raison d'etre ) and tests the ideals of heroism, among other recurring themes that pop up throughout the story. The Garou arc is a perfect example of this, but people on't understand until they either read the webcomic, wait until Murata catches up, or wait for season 2
@gabeng60
@gabeng60 7 жыл бұрын
All ive gotta say is: ORAORAORAORAORAORAORAORA
@yepyep86
@yepyep86 7 жыл бұрын
Christian Choo muda muda
@WickedAnimeTroll
@WickedAnimeTroll 7 жыл бұрын
MUDAMUDAMUDAMUDA
@gabeng60
@gabeng60 7 жыл бұрын
OP Man meh i still love the shouting of those beautiful oras, mudas and doras
@gabeng60
@gabeng60 7 жыл бұрын
Isaac Argesmith it lives up to the "bizzare" in its name
@lordhighlordofthehalfgays2456
@lordhighlordofthehalfgays2456 7 жыл бұрын
Christian Choo Arrivederci!
@kutaoizumi4189
@kutaoizumi4189 7 жыл бұрын
ur argument about OPM is invalid cause Tornado is best grill so yah take dat digimon!
@AndreasNicklasson
@AndreasNicklasson 7 жыл бұрын
Blizzard is pretty sweet too. Dem curves...
@Redd2D
@Redd2D 7 жыл бұрын
ur al rong asuna breast gill
@kutaoizumi4189
@kutaoizumi4189 7 жыл бұрын
U all have shit taste in waifs im sorry guys
@iwanttoputkamuistoesinmymo5938
@iwanttoputkamuistoesinmymo5938 7 жыл бұрын
Kutao Izumi you spelled mosquito girl wrong
@nara070690
@nara070690 7 жыл бұрын
You are all wrong, Genos best Waifu
@Natboy129
@Natboy129 7 жыл бұрын
Its fun to see people criticize shows like Dragon Ball, Naruto, Bleach and One Piece for being standard and base line, without realizing that back in their day they were the revolutionary series for the genre, just like One Punch Man, Mob Psycho and I guess Hunter X Hunter is now.
@Natboy129
@Natboy129 7 жыл бұрын
Yeah, evolutionary is an exaggeration, but they all made a pretty big impact. Heck re-reading Naruto shocked me because I forgot how good it used to be.
@Tzumaoable
@Tzumaoable 7 жыл бұрын
You do realize that the Hunter x Hunter manga started running before Bleach and Naruto proper and just a bit later than OP, right? Even if we're talking anime only, the HxH and OP adaptations started at the exact same time too.
@martinvadakara7759
@martinvadakara7759 7 жыл бұрын
Everybody uses HXH to compare to naruto but the problem is that they are still both different series. One is about hunters and one is about ninjas.
@jjrobledo
@jjrobledo 7 жыл бұрын
but they became repetitive and just recycles the formula
@Nightman221k
@Nightman221k 7 жыл бұрын
It's fun at first before it gets obnoxious with pretentious fans of more "subversive" series saying shonen like it's an insult.
@FranK-tg7ou
@FranK-tg7ou 7 жыл бұрын
Basically different doesn't mean subversive
@FranK-tg7ou
@FranK-tg7ou 7 жыл бұрын
Also thanks for talking about opm I really liked this segment And thanks for giving jojo that praise
@JCOdrjones
@JCOdrjones 7 жыл бұрын
"I don't like typical shonen" >only shonen they think they've watched is DBZ English dub >>also has watched/read other shonens without knowing or denying they're reading shonen A true cultured anime fan. Good video btw Digi.
@Jepze158
@Jepze158 7 жыл бұрын
But only shounen i ever truly liked is Yu Yu Hakusho
@JCOdrjones
@JCOdrjones 7 жыл бұрын
ew275x Said stigma is slightly below "real anime"
@Yal_Rathol
@Yal_Rathol 6 жыл бұрын
luckily, we now have a solution, and that solution is my hero academia.
@DeepDiveDevin
@DeepDiveDevin 6 жыл бұрын
The _original_ DBZ dub at that. Kai's dub is way more faithful with it's twists and turns.
@TheRedHaze3
@TheRedHaze3 6 жыл бұрын
I see what you're getting at but there is such a thing as "typical shounen". Sure there's outliers like Death Note, but they're just exceptions that prove the rule. Most are like inferior versions of Yu Yu Hakusho, DBZ and My Hero Academia.
@s3studios597
@s3studios597 11 ай бұрын
I feel like a lot of people take for granted how old and influential Dragon Ball is. I wasn't alive for most of it's manga run, but I've seen people who were talk about how it was pretty subversive for its time and how Toriyama likes subverting expectations. Nowadays, Dragon Ball and its tropes are so ingrained in culture and have been copied so many times, that people just don't think about that. It's become the standard.
@rosiepark9607
@rosiepark9607 2 жыл бұрын
It’s the same objections that horror movie fans have when people call Hereditary or Babadook “subversive and thoughtful” horror. It implies that the genre itself is inherently low brow and cannot contain thoughtful storytelling.
@heavymetalfan1167
@heavymetalfan1167 2 жыл бұрын
Nowadays it is
@TheRainSnake
@TheRainSnake 7 жыл бұрын
But even in the Boros fight, it's revealed at the end that Saitama could have just taken him out with one punch by hitting him a little harder. He was just humoring the guy for the whole fight. Also, I think you brought this up yourself but OPM is more than just the One Punch gag. It's the overblown backstories, the heroes/villains/monsters who are simultaneously cool and completely mundane, having nowhere to go after you've reached all the potential you will ever have, and the adult lifestyle Saitama has. I think saying a series isn't subversive because it has the elements of the series it's subverting doesn't make sense. Unless I'm mistaken, you need those elements in order to subvert them. In OPM, it just happens to take those elements and bounce them off of Saitama being a really bored grown up, who values sale days, paying bills, noise complaints, and broken ceilings over dramatic entrances and drawn out fights.
@TheRedHaze3
@TheRedHaze3 6 жыл бұрын
I think his point is that any good Shounen series is subversive in it's own right, even the ones we think are setting the standard, like DBZ. Thus, OPM - or any other anime - being subversive, is nothing new.
@tetsuoyugen3702
@tetsuoyugen3702 6 жыл бұрын
TheRainSnake pretty sure in one punch man he fought boros because Saitama know what it feels like to be so bored and itching for a fight. Even in the end Saitama said it was tough to beat boros just so he could feel content for fighting Saitama. Saitama's compassion is something really amazing bout him
@jonsnor4313
@jonsnor4313 6 жыл бұрын
And Boros is mad at him for holding back, because he has the same dilemma as saitama, he deastroyed dozens of enemies for a worthy enemy, and saitama holds back. Hunter x hunter is smart and creative. that is why it is good. That and the author is a troll who loves keeping the audience on its toes, to subvert the expetations while still making logical sense. And he likes traps like alluka who has no specified gender.
@ivanbackfromthecardshop8093
@ivanbackfromthecardshop8093 4 жыл бұрын
No he never had the ability to kill Boros. Boros was only going to die after he used up his energy to stop regening. Boros never stood a chance but saitama didn't have an out until Boros used all his energy for a single attack
@TheRedHaze3
@TheRedHaze3 3 жыл бұрын
@The Fantom Convoy Yes, it is. It's in Shounen Jump. That makes it Shounen.
@richt6314
@richt6314 7 жыл бұрын
Is there really any meaning in anything aside from that which we ourselves ascribe meaning to?
@Syogren
@Syogren 7 жыл бұрын
Not really, no.
@richt6314
@richt6314 7 жыл бұрын
#nihilisticthoughtswithRichTits
@raksh6872
@raksh6872 7 жыл бұрын
function /= meaning also we cant be sure to perceive them the way they really are so no, not even that
@richt6314
@richt6314 7 жыл бұрын
Simple means of differentiating meaning v. function. Consider a $20 bill: -function (purpose/role): serves as a medium for exchange transaction -meaning (in context of question; value/worth/significance): the numerical buying power associated with the value 20.00 we attribute to it
@richt6314
@richt6314 7 жыл бұрын
+unsigned int Without getting into a debate of semantics, in retrospect, the inclusion of purpose was in poor taste in elucidating my point as I haphazardly included it as being synonymous despite the fact that purpose has intention behind it whereas a function can be an inherent property. In the money example, until we attribute value to it, it cannot serve it's intended functionality; its functionality is predicated on its value. Ultimately, this is very much an argument of whether or not existence precedes essence. The main point I’m trying to elucidate, as +IDKMJTOANIHITII noted, is that despite having a function that doesn’t necessitate any notion of value without us being the ones to ascribe value to it. Despite the role of fundamental particles, energy, forces, and the like, if one doesn’t attribute value to the constructs brought about by the amalgamation of them then it would follow that they have no relative value to that individual. Even iff these fundamental forces were objective depictions of reality, that wouldn’t constitute any reason for their being aside from the mere fact that “they are what they are.”
@HxH2011DRA
@HxH2011DRA 7 жыл бұрын
Simply put, Hunter x Hunter 2011 is the greatest anime of all time. Thanks so much for this video digi it's truly appreciated!
@ShadowWolfRising
@ShadowWolfRising 7 жыл бұрын
no, that's The Nutshack.
@zinekaizerzen-pokemonunite1390
@zinekaizerzen-pokemonunite1390 7 жыл бұрын
your name is hilarious XD
@wldeagle827
@wldeagle827 7 жыл бұрын
One Piece is better.
@TalesOfNerdiaChris
@TalesOfNerdiaChris 7 жыл бұрын
If HxH2011DRA says it, you know it is true. Hey buddy :)
@HxH2011DRA
@HxH2011DRA 7 жыл бұрын
TalesOfNerdia You know it! Good to see ya man ;)
@Ronin11111111
@Ronin11111111 7 жыл бұрын
This is my new all time favourite video of yours, probably because I love this genre.
@Cernunnnos
@Cernunnnos 7 жыл бұрын
You only get the appreciation of subversion when there's too many by the numbers shows flooding the market, which there is a lot of. You ma be able to draw parallels between a subversive show and a less self aware show, but it's really more about how it's presented than simply what is presented. What's interesting about Saitama isn't just that he's more powerful than anyone else and can stomp them with ease, which is how the gag is played. It's how it's effected his drive as the hero he set out to become. When it starts, he's frustrated with his power. He feels he's lost the very thing that he was living for. The drive to become the best, which is the raison d'être of most Shonen protagonists. They all keep moving forward because they want to be the most powerful, the most respected the most whatever in their particular universes. And they all come up against insurmountable odds to test their resolve. That all happened to Saitama before the show starts. Now he's reached the top and that's what's bothering him, (oh shoobedy do). The show doesn't dissolve into the standard shonen fair of training harder than ever before and pulling out all of the stops to surpass a looming threat. It becomes about how he can come to terms with being insurmountable and where his place in the world is. He goes from being a 'hero for fun' to simply being a 'hero'. He's no longer doing it for his own desires or to prove himself, he's doing it because no one else can. That's much more in-line with the complex motivations found in some Sienen. He routinely sacrifices his own reputation and desire to be credited to make sure that the heroes out there that are still on the journey he completed don't get disheartened or have the fickle public turn on them. That's what the shows about, one characters acceptance of a life without the thrills he initially desired and the pity he takes on the others who haven't realised that their goal is hollow. That's he reason the Boros fight goes on for so long. Aside from it being a beautiful piece of animation that they obviously wanted to spend some time on. It's because Saitama see's himself in Boros. And gives him the fight he wishes he could have. That's why there's so many parallels to Saitamas dreamt moleman fight, like the heart beat representing the rekindling of passion.
@Kriss_ch.
@Kriss_ch. 7 жыл бұрын
Good video! The Dragonball to Hunter x Hunter comparisons are undermined by how every good character in Dragonball either gets resurrected after every arc, or end up in a sort of afterlife where they are clearly still "alive" in a sense and can come back to Earth as long as they get permission. Ponzu getting shot in the face in Hunter x Hunter and Yamcha getting stabbed through the chest just doesn't carry the same impact because Yamcha is totally fine just one or two chapters later. One Piece completely limits its deaths to flashbacks and off-screen nameless marines... Except for poor Mr. 10. I completely agree that One Punch Man and Hunter X Hunter are good shonens, not just subversions. But they aren't the same as all the others either. One Punch Man's strong point is how Saitama is depressed that every fight is a curb stomp, and that's not the same as other characters beating mooks in one punch to show how much stronger they've become. I'd say what makes Hunter X Hunter stand out is that it establishes the rules for their abilities so thoroughly, and has all the makings of a regular action shonen, but cares so much more about trickery. Gon has defeated what, a single "boss" of the enemies? And even then it was through someone else's plan, with tricks outside his own abilities, and a literal trap. But because of Gon's personality, you still got an actual fight before the trap ended it instantly. At another point, a huge villain and a good guy has a massive fight, which the villain wins, but then succumbs to poisoning from a weapon completely outside of any abilities. It's a show that gives you enough of what you expect from the genre, but then upends it afterwards. It is also a subversion, not just a good shonen, and the other shonens having some humor on behalf of themselves or being comedy shows don't diminish that.
@prnklinfierc
@prnklinfierc 3 жыл бұрын
The fact that I take issue with you saying "good guy and bad guy" supports your point further
@sage3892
@sage3892 7 жыл бұрын
toriko is rad, dude. it also makes me stupidly hungry
@BuddMcAwesome
@BuddMcAwesome 7 жыл бұрын
which is why i dropped it at ep 1. i can't afford the amount of food it makes me crave
@sage3892
@sage3892 7 жыл бұрын
MrAwesome45 the manga is worse. sooo much detail in the first 3 pages jfc
@BuddMcAwesome
@BuddMcAwesome 7 жыл бұрын
ya i saw the first chapter's few first pages and i got hungry that day i didn't eat for 20 hours so you can imagine how that fucked me up
@longrua1231
@longrua1231 7 жыл бұрын
I think what really made me like the manga is its absolutely autistic passion for world building, even the tea leaf that made the tea that the characters are drinking come from a tree with a specific way of harvesting its leaf in its own specific ecosystem oh and the animals there look like it come from Australia serial killer cousin.
@sage3892
@sage3892 7 жыл бұрын
Long Rùa and the jelly that changed flavors while eating it~ Welp, time to read toriko some more. Wish me luck
@Molcrid
@Molcrid 7 жыл бұрын
Is nice to see that you are bringing up those videos, i really hope to see more references like that in the other anime related channels and spread the knowledge
@seqka711
@seqka711 7 жыл бұрын
THANK YOU You have no idea how much I love this video for saying everything I've been thinking.
@ThePreciseClimber
@ThePreciseClimber 7 жыл бұрын
Dragon Ball > Dragon Ball Z So there!
@Ash_Wen-li
@Ash_Wen-li 7 жыл бұрын
Of course.
@WickedAnimeTroll
@WickedAnimeTroll 7 жыл бұрын
fact
@YukiGibson
@YukiGibson 7 жыл бұрын
You don't even discuss that
@kasparkannel3108
@kasparkannel3108 7 жыл бұрын
What are you talking about? there is only Dragon Ball
@shaffand.7375
@shaffand.7375 7 жыл бұрын
dbz is much better. Comedy and goofy characters
@Just_Some_Guy_with_a_Mustache
@Just_Some_Guy_with_a_Mustache 7 жыл бұрын
Now you've done it. Now I want to hear your thoughts on the Shounen Protagonist archetype.
@juwanbantug5465
@juwanbantug5465 4 жыл бұрын
Just Some Guy with a Mustache Now that you've mentioned it... I've always wanted to see an idealistic shonen protagonist that wants to become a hero encounter so much horrible and disfiguring shit to where by the end of the series, the idealism of said protagonist is gone and he even becomes suicidal due to the actions he made in order for his dream to become a hero come true. I want a character that starts out mischievious, playful and idealistic. But at the end, he's more mature, reserved, and shy; something along the lines of Jaden Yuki's character development from YGO GX. The only trait that stays constant about the protagonist is his 'determinator' nature, and even then that aspect of him goes from endearing to downright disturbing as the series progresses.
@Eccentrick218
@Eccentrick218 7 жыл бұрын
Great video, love seeing all of your analysis!
@jeromefournier9667
@jeromefournier9667 7 жыл бұрын
This was very informative, thanks for doing it. much props.
@WorthlessWinner
@WorthlessWinner 7 жыл бұрын
10:00 Fist of the North Star did 1 punch man when Dragon ball was new
@ilyasbasuki3207
@ilyasbasuki3207 7 жыл бұрын
*One Touch Man
@mistergremm735
@mistergremm735 7 жыл бұрын
unassumption no, but i would say they have same concept, The first 15-20 were Ken is just Saving People from Warlords who talk shit and Then Ken Ends them anti-climactic with 100+ Fist, not until maybe 25 as remember when story gets super serious, Also unlike OPM, Fist was Meant To be taken Serious from start
@psychocrysis2
@psychocrysis2 7 жыл бұрын
Except Kenshiro actually struggled in some fights and was defeated by Souther once.
@TheBlackDustx
@TheBlackDustx 7 жыл бұрын
As much as I usually agree with your points this argument was rather poorly put together with what seemed to be a bad understanding of the scenes in both HxH and OPM.
@TheBlackDustx
@TheBlackDustx 7 жыл бұрын
TheDavoo He had correct examples but it's how he correlates amount killed with how dark a story is rather than how it was carried out.
@Yoseqlo1
@Yoseqlo1 7 жыл бұрын
Good analysis. And the channels you recommend seems pretty cool, thanks.
@ArcenyHax
@ArcenyHax 7 жыл бұрын
I was just thinking about this topic and remembered you had a video. thnx digi ;)
@Rasheedgames
@Rasheedgames 7 жыл бұрын
Basically, a show being different isn't necessarily subversion, it's just good storytelling?
@ebbandfloatzel
@ebbandfloatzel 5 жыл бұрын
Well to subvert something, you have to specifically make your audience believe you're doing something, but then not. If a show was trying to subvert the idea of getting a new power up, just never having your character learn anything new isn't subversion. You have to have your character be given something that at first sounds like a power up/new move... But it turns out to have been fake or the opposite.
@terracannon876
@terracannon876 5 жыл бұрын
The feeling I get from others saying an anime is "subversive" is that they have incredibly low expectations of anime. For all that they like anime, the majority of anime is not good, and when asked, they (more like, my friend) will say that anime is trash. That I should celebrate X or Y for being "subversive and that's why it's good" when it's just normal, good characterization.
@semvision
@semvision 6 жыл бұрын
Can't we just accept a shonen for being fun and enjoyable when it is fun and enjoyable?
@juwanbantug5465
@juwanbantug5465 3 жыл бұрын
This isn't feasible when a lot of shonen anime is predictable nowadays. For something to be fun and enjoyable, it has to do something relatively different from the norm, and a lot of modern shonen anime can't really do that when the roots of the genre (Naruto, DBZ, etc.) have been established. The closest thing we have to this is FSN (most especially Heaven's Feel), and that movie trilogy/route in the VN plays out as less of a shonen anime and more of a psychological horror within the perspective of a supposed (emphasis on supposed) shonen protagonist like Shirou Emiya.
@lobstertail
@lobstertail 7 жыл бұрын
B-but OPM does it all ironically
@YukiGibson
@YukiGibson 7 жыл бұрын
Somehow it doesn't add anything new, I'll have to disagree
@YukiGibson
@YukiGibson 7 жыл бұрын
More importantly, is a seinen
@isaacargesmith8217
@isaacargesmith8217 7 жыл бұрын
The Sea King was in no way ironic.
@lobstertail
@lobstertail 7 жыл бұрын
My comment was in all ways ironic. I even stuttered, c'mon bois...
@isaacargesmith8217
@isaacargesmith8217 7 жыл бұрын
***** What's irony
@caiopatric
@caiopatric 7 жыл бұрын
Thn again, there's no point in just showing that these things can happen in other shows. its the sum of it's parts that makes an anime like hunterxhunter what it is. and the WAY it does said things. i don't think there's anyone out there saying HxH is only good because it's subversive. but i do think most people appreciate the show a lot because it's CONSTANTLY doing such subversive things. and that's something that not many others are doing. that's why it grabbed the attention of so many people.
@rexgeorgerodriguez7620
@rexgeorgerodriguez7620 Жыл бұрын
I actually like HxH not just because its subversive but it does surbversion in a logical way. It doesn't feel out of place because its fits to the characters decisions and actions. Many shows tried this but it feel force because it doesn't fit the story and character decisions and actions.
@LuckyBastard12345
@LuckyBastard12345 7 жыл бұрын
Who cares about Yamcha
@InquisitorThomas
@InquisitorThomas 7 жыл бұрын
Your Mom that one cat that's name I forgot
@arselcrusader5600
@arselcrusader5600 7 жыл бұрын
Who cares about that cat whose name we've forgotten?
@InquisitorThomas
@InquisitorThomas 7 жыл бұрын
Arsel Crusader Yamcha...?
@arselcrusader5600
@arselcrusader5600 7 жыл бұрын
Good point.............
@henryt3301
@henryt3301 7 жыл бұрын
Oh, I don't know, the people who has watched the original Dragon Ball since the beginning, or the fact a character being killed a second time DOESN'T come back from the dead?
@MusicalBloodDrop
@MusicalBloodDrop 7 жыл бұрын
Awesome video~! I feel like I learned a good bit about story structure :3
@ryoga316
@ryoga316 7 жыл бұрын
You fail to mention that one of the common tropes in Shonen Anime is the Power-Up Trope, in which a character gains a transformation or a new power that would allow the character to defeat the opponent. In Dragon Ball, this is exemplified with the Super Saiyan form. One Punch Man subverts this trope by making Saitama the most powerful character ever, but the fact that he is that powerful and is seeking a real challenge to make him unleash his full power, opts him to fight his opponents at the minimum level. Saitama's battle with Boros, and later with Garou in the manga/webscomic, indicates that Saitama was fighting most of his opponents at the minimum level of power, only opting to raise it when he meets opponents that show to have more potential. Going back again to Dragon Ball for comparison, Goku defeating most of the minor villains was due mainly to his incredible strength, but by no means did he fight them at full power and is reserved mainly for the major villains. And even then, there would be some points it was not enough, so Goku needed either a new technique, or a new way to increase his strength via training or whatnot to finally gain the advantage. So the comparison here is that Goku gets stronger through training, whereas Saitama has reached his maximum power (if there even is one), and is intentionally nerfing himself for the sake of a more challenging fight. When you look at it, One Punch Man's subversions are from series like Dragon Ball and similar, but not other Shonen Anime like Death Note and even that of Rurouni Kenshin.
@user-vh8bm9mu4u
@user-vh8bm9mu4u 7 жыл бұрын
Powerups are not as common as you'd think. In One Piece the characters had to train for two years off screen and still did not gain much but some power level boost. (not counting Luffy's Gears). In Fullmetal Alchemist, any "powerup" is really just the characters learning a hidden secret about alchemy and exploiting that new found knowledge. Also you still misunderstood what Subversion means. Saitama is no different from Luffy or Goku, One Punch Man just makes a joke out of it while the other two series has the super character distracted by something else.... One punch man does that too actually.
@ryoga316
@ryoga316 7 жыл бұрын
Saint Seiya, Heavenly Sphere Shurato, Demon Prince Zenki, Sakigake! Otokojuku, Ninku, Hell Teacher Nube, & Flame of Recca are among the many Shonen anime that follows the Power-Up Trope. Other Shonen titles like Hikaru no Go and Rurouni Kenshin do not use those tropes for the simple reason that it does not apply to the theme and style of anime they are. These are the types of Shonen anime in which One Punch Man subverts, or parody, if you will.
@user-vh8bm9mu4u
@user-vh8bm9mu4u 7 жыл бұрын
ryoga316 I have not heard of a single anime you mentioned, so yeah...
@user-vh8bm9mu4u
@user-vh8bm9mu4u 7 жыл бұрын
***** Lol I said not counting gears, havent got that far yet,
@ryoga316
@ryoga316 7 жыл бұрын
***** I'm not surprised, considering many Anime fans today only know the usual series like One Piece and Naruto, but never heard of others that came before and during, such as Flame of Recca. Others like Samurai Troopers (Ronin Warriors) tend to be popular only during their time, but is often left unknown by today's fans except those who have seen it when it was still new.
@garrettcarter2959
@garrettcarter2959 7 жыл бұрын
Are you kidding me? Everyone knows that nobody dies in One Piece. You know, unless you absolutely have to. And sometime you still survive
@carefree4all1
@carefree4all1 7 жыл бұрын
Garrett Carter People in One Piece do die. Lots of them. One Piece has a optimistic tone, but it's set in a world where people with power constantly fight for more power. Didn't Digibro show you a video of that happening.
@adityav8475
@adityav8475 7 жыл бұрын
Garrett Carter One piece has many dying in flashback and in a cruel way too. I just dont want someone to die and come back later, thats just bull shit(Dbz did that constantly) And Some times one piece gets too dark(like zeff eats his own leg to survive, law travels under corpses to get out of town after his family being massacred)
@Mathwiz97X
@Mathwiz97X 7 жыл бұрын
(Apologies for the long comment, but Hunter x Hunter is too good for me to not talk about it extensively, so bear with me). Hunter x Hunter is an amazing series not because it is a deconstruction of the shonen genre (which it isn't), but because it is a well-written celebration of the shonen genre. You can play around with the tropes of a genre and still be a part of that genre, and Hunter x Hunter, at its core, is a shonen action series - not an anti-shonen. One of the most common examples of this supposed "subversion" of expectations that I always see used is the Chimera Ant arc. In the Chimera Ant arc *(SPOILERS, of course - go watch Hunter x Hunter if you haven't already, and then come back),* a seemingly important character is killed off, there is an apparent tone shift, and the concept of a heroic power-up/transformation is flipped on its head. In regards to the first two, like you said in the video, these aren't examples of subverting Shonen tropes, but rather they are perhaps subversions of the reader's/viewer's expectations, and most good stories must possess the ability to do that. Personally, I was shocked when Kite died, but this isn't the first time that a seemingly important character has died in a Shonen story. Jiraiya's death during the Pain arc in Naruto or Krillin's death in the beginning of the Piccolo Daimo arc are both pre-existing examples of this concept. In fact, the entire Piccolo Daimo arc is similar to the Chimera Ant arc in that the tone of the show shifts, a major character dies to emphasize the sheer power of the foes that our heroes are confronted with, and our protagonist is completely overcome with rage. Dragon Ball may not have gotten to that extreme power-up transformation stage like it later would with the Super Saiyan, but it does use the idea of vengeance/redemption to progress the development of the protagonist much like the Chimera Ant arc does with Gon. The Chimera Ant arc may be incredible in how it presents itself, and it is strengthened more so by how innocent the first few episodes of the show seemed to be, but I think it's safe to say that almost if not every shonen action series does this. When you strip away the artistic flair of the Chimera Ant arc and boil it down to its basic elements, what you are left with is an action-oriented, "save the world" tale with elements of redemption and vengeance thrown into the mix. Even Gon's "reverse Super Saiyan" transformation at the end of the arc has been done before. In Naruto, the whole idea of the Nine-Tailed Fox transformation and its many variations is that Naruto's rage is overwhelming him and turning him into an uncontrollable monster. Heck, Dragon Ball even manages to pull a "reverse Super Saiyan" transformation at the peak of the Cell arc when Gohan ascends to a Super Saiyan 2. His emotions and his newfound power overwhelm him much like they do with Naruto and Gon. What makes Gon's transformation stand out above these other characters, however, is that the buildup to this transformation is so masterfully handled. In the case of Naruto, we know that he is a kind and playfully mischievous boy at heart, but he isn't exactly innocent in the way that Gon is portrayed at the start of Hunter x Hunter. Gohan shares this sense of innocence, but he has several moments where his rage hints at his hidden potential for destruction, and while Hunter x Hunter definitely hints at Gon's hidden power, there is never a moment before the Chimera Ant arc where Gon completely loses his mind. He displays his vast wealth of hidden strength on several occasions, but during these moments, he is always in control of himself and his powers. When Gon finally reaches Pitou, however, he has far surpassed his breaking point. We have had plenty of time to empathize with Gon up to this point, but in the case of Gohan and Naruto, we can't really sympathize with their opponents because, at this point, we only know of them as being treacherous villains. Sure, Pain eventually turns a new leaf, but we as an audience are only shown this after Naruto has already overcome his inner demons. In the case of Hunter x Hunter, we have come to hate Pitou throughout the massive buildup to the final battle, but when Pitou suddenly begins acting in a way that we can sympathize with, we start doubting whether Gon's convictions are entirely justifiable in the grand scheme of things, and this reflects in the way that Gon is framed during these final moments. He doesn't know how to react to these new developments, and neither do we, which is why his transformation hits all the more powerfully when we don't know who we should be siding with. To compare it to the Yorknew arc, Gon and Killua didn't want Kurapika to have to kill anyone, so when Gon inevitably kills Pitou in such a brutal manner, it seems like a complete betrayal to his own character. None of this depth can be expressed by the idea that "Hunter x Hunter is a deconstruction." From this, I want to touch on the tournament at the end of the Hunter Exam arc. This tournament is not a subversion of the shonen tournament arc as a whole, but it is, instead, a subversion of the typical tournament in general. A standard tournament is a single-elimination series of matches where the winner advances and the loser is eliminated, but in the Hunter Exam, the loser advances and the winner earns their Hunter License. This idea may be interesting in its own right, but the way that this concept is integrated into the narrative is what makes it work. Anyone could use this "anti-tournament" concept, but that doesn't inherently make the use of it good or interesting. What makes this concept so effective is that Togashi uses it to give Character B a fighting chance against a Character A who otherwise would have mopped the floor with Character B. Physical strength does not define a fight in this tournament: mental strength does, and Togashi executes that idea brilliantly through Gon's fight against Hanzo. I could talk for weeks about Hunter x Hunter, but I'm not here to write a novel about it. Hopefully this gets my point across, lol. (P.S. That cat is adorable, Digi, although I doubt that you made it this far in the comment if you've even seen it at all.)
@Rhino1004
@Rhino1004 7 жыл бұрын
Add newlines and create a new paragraph whenever you enter a different object to discuss. By doing that you make it so that people actually decide to read your stuff.
@xDarkomantis
@xDarkomantis 6 жыл бұрын
(Apologies for the long comment, but Hunter x Hunter is too good for me to not talk about it extensively, so bear with me). Hunter x Hunter is an amazing series not because it is a deconstruction of the shonen genre (which it isn't), but because it is a well-written celebration of the shonen genre. You can play around with the tropes of a genre and still be a part of that genre, and Hunter x Hunter, at its core, is a shonen action series - not an anti-shonen. One of the most common examples of this supposed "subversion" of expectations that I always see used is the Chimera Ant arc. In the Chimera Ant arc (SPOILERS, of course - go watch Hunter x Hunter if you haven't already, and then come back), a seemingly important character is killed off, there is an apparent tone shift, and the concept of a heroic power-up/transformation is flipped on its head. In regards to the first two, like you said in the video, these aren't examples of subverting Shonen tropes, but rather they are perhaps subversions of the reader's/viewer's expectations, and most good stories must possess the ability to do that. Personally, I was shocked when Kite died, but this isn't the first time that a seemingly important character has died in a Shonen story. Jiraiya's death during the Pain arc in Naruto or Krillin's death in the beginning of the Piccolo Daimo arc are both pre-existing examples of this concept. In fact, the entire Piccolo Daimo arc is similar to the Chimera Ant arc in that the tone of the show shifts, a major character dies to emphasize the sheer power of the foes that our heroes are confronted with, and our protagonist is completely overcome with rage. Dragon Ball may not have gotten to that extreme power-up transformation stage like it later would with the Super Saiyan, but it does use the idea of vengeance/redemption to progress the development of the protagonist much like the Chimera Ant arc does with Gon. The Chimera Ant arc may be incredible in how it presents itself, and it is strengthened more so by how innocent the first few episodes of the show seemed to be, but I think it's safe to say that almost if not every shonen action series does this. When you strip away the artistic flair of the Chimera Ant arc and boil it down to its basic elements, what you are left with is an action-oriented, "save the world" tale with elements of redemption and vengeance thrown into the mix. Even Gon's "reverse Super Saiyan" transformation at the end of the arc has been done before. In Naruto, the whole idea of the Nine-Tailed Fox transformation and its many variations is that Naruto's rage is overwhelming him and turning him into an uncontrollable monster. Heck, Dragon Ball even manages to pull a "reverse Super Saiyan" transformation at the peak of the Cell arc when Gohan ascends to a Super Saiyan 2. His emotions and his newfound power overwhelm him much like they do with Naruto and Gon. What makes Gon's transformation stand out above these other characters, however, is that the buildup to this transformation is so masterfully handled. In the case of Naruto, we know that he is a kind and playfully mischievous boy at heart, but he isn't exactly innocent in the way that Gon is portrayed at the start of Hunter x Hunter. Gohan shares this sense of innocence, but he has several moments where his rage hints at his hidden potential for destruction. And while Hunter x Hunter definitely hints at Gon's hidden power, there is never a moment before the Chimera Ant arc where Gon completely loses his mind. He displays his vast wealth of hidden strength on several occasions, but during these moments, he is always in control of himself and his powers. When Gon finally reaches Pitou, however, he has far surpassed his breaking point. We have had plenty of time to empathize with Gon up to this point, but in the case of Gohan and Naruto, we can't really sympathize with their opponents because, at this point, we only know of them as being treacherous villains. Sure, Pain eventually turns a new leaf, but we as an audience are only shown this after Naruto has already overcome his inner demons. In the case of Hunter x Hunter, we have come to hate Pitou throughout the massive buildup to the final battle, but when Pitou suddenly begins acting in a way that we can sympathize with, we start doubting whether Gon's convictions are entirely justifiable in the grand scheme of things, and this reflects in the way that Gon is framed during these final moments. He doesn't know how to react to these new developments, and neither do we, which is why his transformation hits all the more powerfully when we don't know who we should be siding with. To compare it to the Yorknew arc, Gon and Killua didn't want Kurapika to have to kill anyone, so when Gon inevitably kills Pitou in such a brutal manner, it seems like a complete betrayal to his own character. None of this depth can be expressed by the idea that "Hunter x Hunter is a deconstruction." From this, I want to touch on the tournament at the end of the Hunter Exam arc. This tournament is not a subversion of the shonen tournament arc as a whole, but it is, instead, a subversion of the typical tournament in general. A standard tournament is a single-elimination series of matches where the winner advances and the loser is eliminated, but in the Hunter Exam, the loser advances and the winner earns their Hunter License. This idea may be interesting in its own right, but the way that this concept is integrated into the narrative is what makes it work. Anyone could use this "anti-tournament" concept, but that doesn't inherently make the use of it good or interesting. What makes this concept so effective is that Togashi uses it to give Character B a fighting chance against a Character A who otherwise would have mopped the floor with Character B. Physical strength does not define a fight in this tournament: mental strength does, and Togashi executes that idea brilliantly through Gon's fight against Hanzo. I could talk for weeks about Hunter x Hunter, but I'm not here to write a novel about it. Hopefully this gets my point across, lol. (P.S. That cat is adorable, Digi, although I doubt that you made it this far in the comment if you've even seen it at all.)
@Edamori
@Edamori 6 жыл бұрын
xDarkomantis Just make the video already. Jeez. You clearly already have a script. Just voice it, put appropriate background footage, and you've got a bangin' video.
@jonsnor4313
@jonsnor4313 6 жыл бұрын
It has the same tone as yoyo hashiko the authors earlier manga with some heroes having the same moralities, in this case because they are demons.
@cernanwinterfox85
@cernanwinterfox85 5 жыл бұрын
I think what makes Gon's transformation so different and compelling is that he is aware and accepting of it. He goes from an innocent child to a point where he more or less straight up tells a guy that right and wrong are irrelevent since he's stronger and therefore decides the rules.
@aquaswords22
@aquaswords22 7 жыл бұрын
I am so glad someone made this video.
@justicedunn5502
@justicedunn5502 7 жыл бұрын
You analyze OPM based on it's fights when it's less about the fights and more about Saitama's struggle with being broke, bald, overshadowed, and not receiving the recognition he deserves. So yes, OPM does fall into SOME standard shounen tropes if you only look at the fights. We already know how all the fights are going to end. That's why the appeal of the show is deeper than that. Judging OPM on it's fights is like judging Madoka Magica on the girl's costumes and saying it's a standard magical girl anime. Sure, that's one of the major reasons it's classified into that genre, but you would be overlooking everything that makes the show different.
@jonsnor4313
@jonsnor4313 6 жыл бұрын
The interestin thing is saitama longs for a good fight, because he loves the excitement, but is doomed to never have is and because of that he is bored constantly.
@MBkratos11
@MBkratos11 4 жыл бұрын
He’s just using the elements of the stories that fits his argument, this video is pretty bad actually
@KL-gh8we
@KL-gh8we 2 жыл бұрын
To add to what you said, the fights are just visuals and the different mechanics/techniques are not explained explicitly and it can be whatever the author comes up with. If you watch OPM to seriously debate about character fighting ability, then you dont get the idea of anime at all 😂😂
@psychopathsnope_9039
@psychopathsnope_9039 2 жыл бұрын
Okay, so I wanna be clear that I personally think someone taking what is considered cliche and wrote and doing it well enough to stand above the reast is just as, if not more commendable then taking a story in a new and unexpected direction. However, implying that the tone of two shows can be well represented by simply showing parallels in the literal characters and events isn't really a fair argument. Stories kill of hundreds if not thousands of people consistently, it's kind of a thing escalation in media does habitually. Entire worlds get destroyed as an afterthought once fights get too big. However how said destruction is portrayed, and how seriously the media takes said action is what sets the tone. To give a grossly exaggerated example to demonstrate my point, MC is fighting an unstoppably evil unquestionably bad guy. MC chases bad guy into castle defended by bad guys knights and fights his way to the throne room, where he finally corners the bad guy and ends his tyranny. Take situation two, as MC rushes after bad guy towards the castle, we get flashes of an innocent young girl playing with her mother in the castle yard, hugging her dad knight. We see the alarms go out about the approaching MC and the lil girl hides in a barrel. Same fight ensues, but this time the dad knight is among the soldiers, MC kills him as easily as the rest, and we get a scene of his head rolling dawn a stairwell and his lifeless eyes starring into space, as we flash to the daughter so is quickly crying and telling herself that her big strong dad will protect them. What the MC did in both cases was the same, his actions no different. Knights commonly had families and people who relied on them. and obviously when they die they leave those people behind. My example though likely flawed and low quality doesn't come anywhere close to world destruction, but they could both be easily portrayed as 'the main character wipes out an entire castle of guards in his quest to kill bad guy' Personally, I think the largest difference is when a story is aware that it's depicting tragedy. and I think media being aware of what it's actually portraying is what people want, and most people default to considering deconstructions to be the only way to get that. A perspective I disagree with personally. but that's a comment for a future inordinately length comment, I'm already only tangentially related.
@mikeoxmaul9870
@mikeoxmaul9870 2 жыл бұрын
Underrated comment. In some other anime planets are being destroyed and wiped out in seconds but in attack on Titan the rumbling which is basically almost the end of the world is causing fights between fans whether it was the right thing to do or not and you can really understand both sides
@fortniteballs57
@fortniteballs57 Жыл бұрын
that's the entire point of the video
@benlink202forever
@benlink202forever 7 жыл бұрын
You talk about all of these shows, but no Inuyasha. I'm hurt.
@Trixiethegoldenwitch
@Trixiethegoldenwitch 7 жыл бұрын
It wasn't in Jump.
@LeReVaQ
@LeReVaQ 7 жыл бұрын
Ben Link rekt
@mhx47
@mhx47 7 жыл бұрын
+Digibro But didn't you say that was the case also for One punch man? 11:20
@benlink202forever
@benlink202forever 7 жыл бұрын
Digibro Yeah, but it feels very Shounen to me. Oh well, maybe you could make a video on it in the near future?
@hongu1634
@hongu1634 7 жыл бұрын
Shounen doesnt automatically equal Shounen Jump
@peterbrooke7146
@peterbrooke7146 7 жыл бұрын
awesome vid digi :D awesome you mentioned jojo definetly my fav manga and anime ever
@julianseipp2708
@julianseipp2708 7 жыл бұрын
really like that you gave a shoutout to jax he is awesome
@SUPERRRSAIYANNNNN
@SUPERRRSAIYANNNNN 7 жыл бұрын
Thanks for mentioning Goatama.
@Art0fKuma
@Art0fKuma 7 жыл бұрын
One Piece episode 767 With the minks is the best example of an old shounen subverting expectations.
@Arlesmon
@Arlesmon 7 жыл бұрын
I don't know if I want to watch the entire anime to see that part, since if you didn't watch one piece back when it had few episodes it might get hard to get into. But that depends if the show still gets your attention for that long
@charliecrome207
@charliecrome207 7 жыл бұрын
I'm really glad you mentioned jaxblade he deserves so much more more attention
@MetaZoop
@MetaZoop 7 жыл бұрын
No matter how many times I see it, everytime The Best Guy Ever breaks out the power drills I die in a happy giggly fit, I love it so much!
@WhackashitCollaborations
@WhackashitCollaborations 7 жыл бұрын
Long story short, watch Hunter X Hunter 2011. LOL
@pillarmenn1936
@pillarmenn1936 7 жыл бұрын
One little nitpick though about the part with Boros. It's not that Saitama does defeat everyone with one punch, it's that he can defeat anyone with one punch. And you ignored/missed the end which reveals that Saitama did not fight anywhere near his full potential (though that much was obvious during the fight), and shows the emotions he has after not finding a worthy opponent once again even though Boros was by far the most promising candidate.
@vandagylon2885
@vandagylon2885 7 жыл бұрын
John Marco Reyes no, he just beats people in one punch because he is stronger than them..
@ZeroComics
@ZeroComics 7 жыл бұрын
If you realise One punch man biggest subversion is its ending(And isn't it a subversion on super heroes?)
@sethpalmer9955
@sethpalmer9955 7 жыл бұрын
best video in a while digi I loved it
@MidoriNatsume
@MidoriNatsume 7 жыл бұрын
And then there is me, who loves repetitive troopes clichés
@cocoa18_
@cocoa18_ 7 жыл бұрын
Midori Natsume "Not that there's anything wrong with that!"
@minhkhangtran6948
@minhkhangtran6948 7 жыл бұрын
Yeah, it's like rice: Some people like it, some people don't, some people eat it their entire life and still love it done.
@carefree4all1
@carefree4all1 7 жыл бұрын
Midori Natsume I doubt that. There maybe tropes that you like that you can watch for years and years, but I doubt that anyone likes repetitive tropes if they don't like it.
@ZygfrydJelenieRogi
@ZygfrydJelenieRogi 7 жыл бұрын
BestGuyEver isn't underappreciated. It's just that, despite his talent and passion, he never uploads anything
@marlonyo
@marlonyo 7 жыл бұрын
i have never thought of the lovecraftian implication of Dragonball Z powerlevels
@ChristopheN108
@ChristopheN108 7 жыл бұрын
Excellent video !
@GaryJojo
@GaryJojo 7 жыл бұрын
I love this video so much.
@LuckyBastard12345
@LuckyBastard12345 7 жыл бұрын
Also Pitou is best girl
@pictureofacat9525
@pictureofacat9525 7 жыл бұрын
Your Mom It's funny, because Pitou is a boy
@MrSomebody54
@MrSomebody54 7 жыл бұрын
In the wiki it said that Pitou was gender neutral, unless Togashi stated otherwise in an interview.
@animewatcher102
@animewatcher102 7 жыл бұрын
I distinctly remember Neferpitou mentioned to be male while reading the manga before the anime came out. But the anime goes out of its way to give Pitou a more feminine figure.
@FierceCast
@FierceCast 7 жыл бұрын
U gay
@MrSomebody54
@MrSomebody54 7 жыл бұрын
AnonEars That's fair since I only read the manga after the Chimera Ant and Election arcs. Androgynous characters aren't anything new in anime/manga and I'm not interested enough in this debacle to look it up so I'll just take your word for it.
@ellie4534
@ellie4534 7 жыл бұрын
As expected, this also applies to "subversive" shows within other genres. I constantly hear people praise Madoka for being subversive, but most people don't realize that it's just about as dark as Sailor Moon or Cardcaptor Sakura. And considering that Madoka is my favorite anime, it kinda feels like people are missing the whole point of why it's so great.
@twopintsofmilk
@twopintsofmilk 7 жыл бұрын
I thought I was already subscribed to under the scope. Thanks Digi :)
@demonsawakening
@demonsawakening 7 жыл бұрын
outstanding video as ever
@Arexion5293
@Arexion5293 7 жыл бұрын
Isn't Neon Genesis Evangelion considered to be deconstruction? Just asking, not making any points.
@sebsthexeno9460
@sebsthexeno9460 7 жыл бұрын
There's more to Evangelion than just being a deconstruction. The point of this video, I believe, is to say that a brilliant show is more than just it's subtext.
@tjarsun
@tjarsun 7 жыл бұрын
I think Evangelion is not just a mere deconstruction because the "mecha-genre like fights" are the least important thing about it. I mean they are great, filled with amazing animations and art, and every time they fight they are risking the whole world, but they are just a plot device.
@Arexion5293
@Arexion5293 7 жыл бұрын
theMoporter It is according to the video Digi linked at the start of this one, since it actually has something to say about the subject matter it tackles. It does also point out that something being deconstruction is just a start of the conversation, not the end of it.
@tatharion9508
@tatharion9508 7 жыл бұрын
it is, and it was.
@deadstockparadise5898
@deadstockparadise5898 7 жыл бұрын
Eva is NOT a deconstruction of mecha, but more of a return to form to classic anime that had darker themes - the ending was above all else a reference to Devilman's apocalyptic, depressing finale. It subverts some shitty cliches from what Anno found to be "autistic" (his wording, not mine - his use sounds similar to the 4chan one) 90s otaku anime cliches. The claims of Eva being a deconstruction of mecha come from judging the mecha genre based on shitty babified 70s versions of Go Nagai properties - not the original manga versions (Getter Robo in particular was always very dark and bizarre) and while ignoring Gundam, which did moral shades of grey and "what if a teenager REALLY had to pilot a mecha" in freaking 1979. Anno didn't hate anime & manga in the 90s. He just hated modern anime & manga.
@t850terminator
@t850terminator 7 жыл бұрын
Who needs to subvert tropes when you can just steamroll thru them with pure fabulousness and constant posing?
@itseman2
@itseman2 7 жыл бұрын
Evey video DigiBro creates, makes me wanna think on some deep hypothetical sh*t! Stellar video as always...people need to see more of your content man!
@IamMonvi
@IamMonvi 6 жыл бұрын
Holy Squapagoli!!! You are my absolute favorite anime based KZfaqr of all time. I'm sad that I didn't subscribe to this channel sooner, considering one of your videos is the only reason I decided to stick with Hunder X Hunter in the first place! I'm absolutely in love with how complete your understanding of storytelling and directing is, and how well you articulate yourself.
@ChangedMyNameFinally69
@ChangedMyNameFinally69 7 жыл бұрын
You know what makes HxH subversive? It's actually good.
@PaperPatriot
@PaperPatriot 7 жыл бұрын
hahahahaha
@andrewrogers6197
@andrewrogers6197 7 жыл бұрын
LJK401 WHY THE FUCK ARE YOU HERE?!
@ChangedMyNameFinally69
@ChangedMyNameFinally69 7 жыл бұрын
Andrew Rogers Hello fellow RWBY HATR.
@ChangedMyNameFinally69
@ChangedMyNameFinally69 7 жыл бұрын
Andrew Rogers Not the hugest fan of Digi at times, but when he makes a good video, he makes a good video.
@andrewrogers6197
@andrewrogers6197 7 жыл бұрын
LJK401 Huh, you did call him cancer at one point.
@fallenasleep7247
@fallenasleep7247 7 жыл бұрын
There's an interview of the guy who wrote infinite jest, in which he talks about how postmodernism has a bad tendency to merely critique, without offering anything new.
@rodney2x48
@rodney2x48 7 жыл бұрын
The subverting or deconstructing tropes in anime has become a trope in itself, especially in light novels and their adaptations.
@theo6525
@theo6525 6 жыл бұрын
I waited so long for you to mention JJBA, and got unhealthily happy when you did.
@Shangori
@Shangori 7 жыл бұрын
I think the 'difference' in these anime/manga are more because of something else. Character relatability. As someone who has tried to look into xianxia at some point in time, I was blown away, absolutely blown away, by the stereotype of the 'evil character'. It was almost always someone who was jealous or thought himself to be high and mighty, to then be crushed or humiliated. A hurdle for the protagonist to overcome and nothing more. Think back to the difference between goku in db and goku in dbz. In db he was this little naive kid that wanted to experience the world. It was fun because you could relate to his naive side, his childish side and have his strength play off this childish side. In dbz he was a musclebrain that punched things and become more powerful. If only he died when he should have and let gohan take over, having a coming of age thing without his father to look after him. That would have been a much more interesting show to watch. I think people are too focused on the tropes. Tropes are ideas that work. Its why they turned into tropes. A shonen story will not suddenly become a slice of life. The fighting will still happen, the progression of the character's strength will still happen. If you can create a new 'trope', a new template to work from, great! But I think the characters should be the main focus
@tama3162
@tama3162 7 жыл бұрын
So satire on shounen doesn't equal subversion? Got it. Now I wonder how Digi feels about this whole fad about making "dark" and "edgy" Magical Girl shows.
@TheRachaelLefler
@TheRachaelLefler 5 жыл бұрын
I am so sick of those and I want them to die... People are just trying to replicate the success of KLK and PMMM without any of the effort that made those shows so phenomenal. Also Princess Tutu, Pretear, and Revolutionary Girl Utena were darker, more sophisticated shoujo shows so it's not even true to say that the genre by itself is saccharine. So that means that simply making the one darker doesn't make something a deconstruction. I'm not sure if it's Digi or some other KZfaqr who pointed this out in a video about how PMMM is not really a deconstruction so much as it's a straight magical girl show with a tragic tone, which had been done before. It still has a happy ending, after all.
@ineednochannelyoutube5384
@ineednochannelyoutube5384 5 жыл бұрын
Sailor moon had the world end after one season, and had basically the same eventual conclusion as pmmm. Not to mention Revolutionary girl utena. Magical girl shows were always gritty shit.
@CidGuerreiro1234
@CidGuerreiro1234 7 жыл бұрын
I barely watch anime anymore but, as a writer myself, I find your lectures/rants very entertaining and enlightening.
@vazak11
@vazak11 Жыл бұрын
Solid video!
@dj-d2030
@dj-d2030 7 жыл бұрын
They need to bring back Shaman King
@Entropic_Alloy
@Entropic_Alloy 7 жыл бұрын
DJ - D20 After Shaman King Flowers, I'd rather it stay dead and buried.
@anotherKyle
@anotherKyle 7 жыл бұрын
flowers was pretty much the same as shaman king only a generation later and not at all finished how did that make you not like shaman king?
@Entropic_Alloy
@Entropic_Alloy 7 жыл бұрын
King is fine. Flowers started going down a path that was not interesting in the least. Oh now we have the unknown from the entire series branch family coming and wanting to cause problems for the new protagonist? It was not strong in the slightest. Yeah it isn't done in terms of translations, but it finished in Japan in Oct. 2014, and the fact that we don't see any translations is typically indicative of the lack of interest from translators.
@HenriqueErzinger
@HenriqueErzinger 6 жыл бұрын
Flowers is not finished in the same sense that the original Shaman King was not finished: it got axed and rushed. The author got the opportunity to go back and redo the ending of the original one, but flowers wasn't really successful at all, so it just ended like that. I don't know about Flowers, since it really wasn't all that interesting at all, but I'd be happy with a SK remake that expanded into the Kang Zeng Bang ending added later.
@ATypicalPlague
@ATypicalPlague 6 жыл бұрын
I feel like this video picked an absolute strawman to argue whether HxH is an example of subversion of tropes. The reason HxH is considered a subversion of tropes/deconstruction of shounen is not because it's dark. What makes it a subversion is that it handles common tropes of the shounen genre in a way that goes completely against how they're typically used. Gon transforming to fight Pitou is not a moment of triumph, as compared to Goku turning into a Super Saiyan, but rather a moment of exceptional weakness for the character. The tournament being interrupted is not a subversion of the tournament arc trope, but rather the fact that the tournament itself had nothing to do with characters being stronger than one another and was structurally different to any other tournament arc. Major story arc villains are presented as obstacles to be overcome in dramatic battles only for these to almost never occur (Chrollo is captured and his nen is sealed without him doing anything, and Meruem is defeated by an atomic bomb). These are subversions of the trope of major villains being defeated in climactic battles with the hero. Have we ever seen a One Piece story arc villain being defeated in any way besides a punch from Luffy? This is where 'subversion' comes from.
@Kaimon3500
@Kaimon3500 6 жыл бұрын
ρlague In the last arc Jack was taken out without even fighting Luffy
@jonsnor4313
@jonsnor4313 6 жыл бұрын
The end of the elecion arc was subversive, and the end of meruem. Hunter x hunter has lots of subversive parts.
@slifer875
@slifer875 5 жыл бұрын
goku's super saiyan transformation wasn't a triumph either, goku changes into a completely different person, enjoying the suffering of his oponent and telling his own son he is going to kill him if he doesn't leave to get revenge on frezzer, lets not forget goku doesn't get a happy ending at the end of that arc, namek explodes and goku aparently dies being a tragic ending where goku lose himself in hatred. if your going to tell me "oh well that totally doesn't matter because goku escapes" then i can say that momment doesn't matter because gon is heal up by a deus ex machina in the next arc. Gon transformation is NOT the anti-supersaiyan momment, on the contrary, is the closest recreation to what happened to goku.
@prnklinfierc
@prnklinfierc 3 жыл бұрын
@@slifer875 I could be wrong since I've never seen DBZ, but was that too out of character? Wasn't he always brutal, and I know at least one of those characters were an awful husband and father. So maybe the contrast is that Gon is so bright eyed and goes onto hurt the person he loves most (Killua) and completely lose himself, to compare to Goku who as far as I know, was always brutal and looking to pummel someone. Also, it doesnt matter that Alluka brings Gon back, because the subversion is not that they'd kill the character off, but that he had the ability to be so cruel and mutilate his enemy's body even after their death when we had seen him be so innocent before. (That doesn't mean the progression wasn't natural or even lightly foreshadowed). Please correct me if I'm wrong, but this is just my thoughts on the situation
@slifer875
@slifer875 3 жыл бұрын
@@prnklinfierc don't believe the memes, goku wasn't a terrible father, quite the opposite he loves his family. He is a martial artist but he doesn't want to kill his oponents and doesn't take pleasure on inflicting pain or humiliating someone, goku went a head and broke frieza both physically and mentally out of pure anger, the english dub censors and changes many things in the dialogue, in the japanese version he wants frieza to live only to suffer in shame for the rest of his sad existence. The only other time goku got that angry was when a picoloo minion murdered krillin and goku went on a shorth rampage...
@KA1N3R
@KA1N3R 7 жыл бұрын
Excellent video.
@germsspices
@germsspices 7 жыл бұрын
This is why I like GIntama, they just make small stories of very old tales, even using historical references to a certain extent. It's genre is unheard of in the anime industry but in every aspect it repeats the most classic tropes, perfecting their pace, enhancing their messages, to draw out the essences of fiction. Remember Gomene, Jerry?
@RexVergstrong
@RexVergstrong 7 жыл бұрын
>People die in One Piece Sure, Digi.
@itsallfunky4591
@itsallfunky4591 7 жыл бұрын
I mean, exept for the important pirates they do die.
@RexVergstrong
@RexVergstrong 7 жыл бұрын
+That1Weirdo No one dies. Even the worst injuries are shrugged off. Cases like Brownbeard are really stupid.
@itsallfunky4591
@itsallfunky4591 7 жыл бұрын
RexVergstrong Monet would like to have a word with you. So would Vergo. Every single dude touched by Magellan's superpoison. etc.
@Granetdud
@Granetdud 7 жыл бұрын
Oh my god, I forgot about Magellan. What a terrifying villain (when he wasn't on the toilet).
@psychronia
@psychronia 7 жыл бұрын
Granetdud Dude, what are you saying? I'd say toilet form is the one most people who knew him would dread to be around almost as much as battle form.
@raulalvarez5021
@raulalvarez5021 7 жыл бұрын
I think lots of people feel that HxH is subversive simply because it subverts their expectation of "All Shonen Anime is bad", simply because they dont like most shounen anime and yet somehow ended up loving HxH. I know because, for the most part, this is my case. Except I dont think "All shonen anime is bad", but more like "Im aware that most shonen anime just doesnt appeal to me".
@murrox7117
@murrox7117 7 жыл бұрын
I appreciated One Punch man because, although I haven't seen to many shonen anime or read much manga on it, the show admits that Saitama will win right from the get-go. It doesn't needlessly ask the question of "Oh, will our hero be able to save the day?!?" because the answer to that is pretty much always yes. You do have a good point though, that it's not all that different. Loved your perspective on that
@kagitsune
@kagitsune 7 жыл бұрын
You're awesome, all you dudes are awesome. I just discovered JacksBlade after finishing OPM. I loved this video... It carries a lesson far beyond anime narrative... "Mastering the fundamentals" can apply to any form of popular art or narrative building. :D
@zero1188
@zero1188 7 жыл бұрын
its pretty simple. any anime that not pertaining to friendship would be consider subverting the genre. mainly because its breath of fresh air to see an anime creator try something new. dont really blame people for thinking that way. people dont like redundancy. there no really such thing as being original but if creators at least made an attempt animes would be a whole lot better
@savajho5468
@savajho5468 7 жыл бұрын
Wow. I should have guessed it before, but this video is a spoiler sausagefest
@Sasu123456789x1
@Sasu123456789x1 7 жыл бұрын
Epic video!!!
@Rulerof2006
@Rulerof2006 7 жыл бұрын
I never thought of Hunter X Hunter 2011 as anything other than a Shounen show that was done really really well. The Chimera Ant arc was fucking beautiful.
We Have Accepted Mediocrity
26:04
Trixie the Golden Witch
Рет қаралды 1,1 МЛН
Aesthetic IS Narrative
19:10
Trixie the Golden Witch
Рет қаралды 305 М.
ROCK PAPER SCISSOR! (55 MLN SUBS!) feat @PANDAGIRLOFFICIAL #shorts
00:31
Always be more smart #shorts
00:32
Jin and Hattie
Рет қаралды 39 МЛН
⬅️🤔➡️
00:31
Celine Dept
Рет қаралды 51 МЛН
How to Recognize a Terrible Anime (in just one episode)
31:14
Trixie the Golden Witch
Рет қаралды 5 МЛН
You're Gonna Carry That Weight
12:07
Trixie the Golden Witch
Рет қаралды 1 МЛН
"Turn Your Brain Off"
9:29
Trixie the Golden Witch
Рет қаралды 931 М.
Why You Should Watch/ Read One Piece
32:05
Super Eyepatch Wolf
Рет қаралды 2,2 МЛН
Uh, Rowling Why Does Slytherin Still Exist?
42:55
Quinn Curio
Рет қаралды 4,6 МЛН
How To Subvert Shonen's Greatest Trope
12:21
We Heart Giant Robots
Рет қаралды 3,7 М.
K-On! - The Ultimate Adaptation
17:00
Trixie the Golden Witch
Рет қаралды 287 М.
Oda Just Dropped a Joyboy BOMBSHELL! (1119+)
15:40
GrandLineReview
Рет қаралды 175 М.
The Difficulties of Being Right About Anime
8:59
Trixie the Golden Witch
Рет қаралды 160 М.
Гиены и их жесткий матриархат!
0:48
Fact Fusion
Рет қаралды 1,9 МЛН
37.First Day as a Zombie💀
0:32
Limekey0
Рет қаралды 25 МЛН
How the hell is this done#joker #shorts
0:14
Untitled Joker
Рет қаралды 2,5 МЛН