@David Roberts Need to exist? None of the mentioned villains need hero to exist, they are just opposites from them; To show what a hero could be if they cross established lines.

@David Roberts Joker existed way before Batman in Dark knight:/ And that's really it, closest thing to what you described. Nowhere near enough to prove your statement right.

@David Roberts ...Sure, my angry friend from the glasshouse:/

I don't think its that as all the Doctor Whos who didn't regenerate inside the TARDIS were inside a set/room. Non were on the street lol

It's just a convention that has grown up in New Who. With the change in style of regenerations to the big pyrotechnic display we now get I suppose it is handy to have a standing set to rig rather than blowing apart some random location. In Classic Who regenerations were much more low key affairs basing featuring the Doctor passing out, some random visual effect and then the new Doctor stands up. The 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 7th and 8th regeneration all happened outside the Tardis. Only in the first regeneration is it implied that the Tardis takes an active part in the process--and at that point it wasn't even referred to as regeneration but rather 'renewal'. Secrecy doesn't seem a likely reason; not only is the Tardis set is no more or less secure than any other studio setting but the actors taking the role are trailed far ahead of the regeneration. In the case of Tennant, he was announced by the BBC only about 3 weeks into Ecclestone's run

@@MrPaulMorris Yes the regen were more low key, but only in comparison to the god like nature given the the new Doctor Whos.

8 to lets say 9

@David Roberts I don't know why you'd think he'd thought that. Cammy just answered the question, nothing more.

@@theunfamousone2818 Spoilers...

2 to 3 aswel, sort of?

Also 'Scream of the Shalka'

How is that a spoiler? It’s something someone says in the episode.

It's an odd phrase and at the time I wondered if it was a reference, for some reason, to the Beatles 'Lucy in the Sky With Diamonds'.

@David Roberts agreed!

I think I would say 'was' or 'had been' rather than 'is', given their long history of conflict.

God is funny!

The2Coolest2 stole it probably

Nah, it happened a few times in Classic Who.

No, but the TARDIS does help in the process.

Nah dawg. How could you be a whovian if you think regeneration HAS to happen in the tardis lmao

Renee Vejbirk well don’t tell him that

Which, one, the old man Master or the regenerated young man Master?

Jacobi duh lol

@@iain9757 Fair enough. However you might so but he/she not, which I think would be nuts. Jacobi is obviously the best in the modern era and his appearance was way too short in my opinion.

but most watching would know plus they did it with the daleks and cybermen so

Meghan Perkins But it’s a reaction video.....your supposed to see his reaction

22dallas1, i can’t tell if this is literal or sarcasm, so I’ll respond as if I’m meant to take this response literally. I’m aware it’s a Reaction Video, and you’re not clever for stating the obvious, a child can do that. To the point I was making, other Reactors will pause the show when they wish to comment about it. If you read my entire comment, you’d see I recommended he do that. We’d still get his reaction, he’d avoid missing important expositions, and stop irritating members of his audience.