We feed both for our pup. We do the smartblend with salmon oil when we’re in a pinch and we do the proplan when we have coupons also with salmon oil. Our puppy LOVES it!

I really like this video. I seem to keep coming back to it as I decide which foods to feed my multiple dogs.

Dr. Rea thanks for the entertaining, unfiltered and down to earth review of these two products. It has been many years since having to research dog food and there is certainly a lot of brands and information out there in the wild. Frankly I feel like I have been down a rabbit hole and back weighing and considering all the products. This review is really helpful because you asked the question and provided some insight to Purina One and Pro Plan. Of the three levels of dog food, Chow, One and Pro Plan I think Purina One is a safe bet. It is certainly more affordable than ProPlan and Purina One has a lamb and rice puppy, Puppy Chow does not. Our breeder uses Puppy Chow and recommends Purina. So Purina One it is!

Hello, Thanks for the information that was so wonderful. I will watch all your videos and keep supporting

Hi yesterday I discovered your channel and it is excellent. I would love to hear your opinion about grain-free foods in relation to foods with grains, Taste of the Wild and Pro Life

Seems most dog foods even lamb and rice have some chicken meal. I contacted Purina to see if they had a completely chicken/chicken meal free product. I got a direct answer from Purina. Good news they make a Salmon and Rice product in the Pro Plan product line. Pro Plan Salmon and Rice is apparently free of chicken and chicken meal. This would seem to support the notion that ProPlan offers more specific and specialized ingredients.

The large bag of pro plan runs about $54. My dogs love the adult pro plan. One is three (used to be on Purina 1) and the other is 10 (used to be on a grain free diet until my vet advised studies found it's not good for their heart and liver) They love it dry and I've even found them trying to get into the bag for snack between meal times. They're both doing great! No tummy problems and they always have well formed solid poops that are honestly about half as much compared to when I had them on previous brands/ types. One note about the older dog pro plan formulas - Petco person said the elderly formula is lighter in calories to assist with maintaining healthy weight and added glucosamine for joint health. Petco advised that you can always give your dog glucosamine /vitamin E / cognitive (DHA and Omega-3) supplements. The same kind we take. No need to buy a dog specific supplement because they cost about twice as much and you can just mix the vities into their food.

Your videos are very educational. Can you compare purima pro plan vs purina one puppy food large breed. Can you also compare the winner of that with your blue diamond. I liked your review of the blues but I am wondering if it is the same quality for puppy food. Thank you!!

Thanks for all the great content.

Hey doc, just watched your video and enjoyed it. Finally someone who knows what they are talking about! I have just started watching these utube videos on pet food and it is tragic people who know very little are influencing people. I just retired from 34 years as a veterinary rep for Hills. Btw, I have asked Purina reps at conferences the differences of their diets. They will only answer it’s just different channels, grocery etc. even if you ask if cost was no issue, which food is the best, they will never answer you. Looking forward to watching more of your videos and hopefully agreeing with you!

Bringing home a golden retriever puppy soon. Can you make a recommendation of a puppy food you would recommend?

What purina formula do you recommend for an adult french bulldog? Thanks

I have 2 poodles and 1 golden doodle. Pro plan salmon a good choice? We currently feeding Nutri source chicken n rice

Hi I was wondering if you can do a review on puppy dry food. What's better between purina one and pro plan puppy. Thank you

Hey I know it’s an old video but I have feed my yeasty golden hills and RC for most of her life but prices have been to high for us. Switched over to the pro plan salmon and rice which is adult life stage 😂 hope it works for her

Great honesty review thanks

I love your videos! I want to know what type of food would you recommend for a German shepherd puppy my boy is almost 8 months old and has been eating Purina one smart blend large breed puppy formula. I want to switch him to something better.

Hi! Thank you for these videos. I have been feeding PPP sensitive skin and stomach for almost three years. first the puppy formula now adult. we discovered early on my dog has a poultry sensitivity and I can’t afford the prescription option. however, i recently fell into the marketing traps and switched to Open Farm. After seeing your recent video I don’t think they are the best option either :(. What concerns me is when trying to read the label and compare to your chart for the PPP, they only show min/max and I cant find the dry matter basis chart anywhere. Any idea where I can get that? Also, some things on your chart of nutrients aren’t listed on the guaranteed analysis at all (such as sodium or chloride) does that mean it’s bad? I’m truly at a loss 😭😭😭😭

Do a video on Walmart premium brand Pure Balance and Aldi Being Pure

How do you feel about the Purina Beyond line. It’s seems to have probiotics in it, whereas Purina ONE does not….🤔

My golden doodles have been on PPro Plan for 3 years. since they were 8 weeks. But they LOVE Purina One (I purchase POne at the dollar store if auto delivery is a couple days late) and they tear it up!! Now I feel like they don't really enjoy their Pro Plan. Idk what to do!!

Rachel Fusaro 420k plus subs says she's a nutritionist, says Purina pro plan is garbage, Yet you gave it a good review as does our Vet who made a list of quality dog food brands. Trying to research dog food is kind of useless but I have faith in your reviews.

My cavapoo has senstive stomach cant decide between purnia one plus digetive or purnia pro plan

Wouldnt it be cheaper to get a vitamin E supplements to go along with the one plan than go with the pro plan

Which food should I give one year’s huskies dogs

Cool

What is the difference between Purina Pro Plan and Pro Plan Veterinary diets

Thank you for you video. I have a 9 month old weimaraner and 14 week old pitbull. I was originally feeding blue buffalo and it was making my weimaraner gassy loose stool and many GI upsets. I switched to purina pro plan puppy and they are doing great. I'm having a difficult time convincing my boyfriend to switch his 7 month old weimaraner off of blue buffalo he thinks it's a great quality food.

My rat terrier was sick with diarreah and vomiting with kibbles and bits food I switched him to purina one and my vet says that purina one chicken and rice is a great choice and to keep him on it

Whrr can I get tha cheapest,,, or gt credit for it….

What if a same brand has two foods one says ‘all life stages’ and ‘adult’ but the ‘all life stages’ has fewer calories ? What would be your suggestion for that ? For a dog that is prone to weight gain? Would the one that is basically puppy food still be better since it’s fewer calories than the stated ‘adult food’?

I never got a clear answer to my question: difference between puppy chow, Purina one and pro plan. I did get coupons however.

Is it good

What brand of food do you feed your personal pets?

Costwise Purina One Chicken and rice is more reasonable I believe

I always look for corn content

Purina pro plan small bites beef is the only food ur toothless 4lb yorkie eats. Something about the dried beef chunks he just can’t resist.

I'm gonna start my dog on the pro plan complete essentials chicken and rice and see how he does cause he doesn't like the food my vet reccommended he doesn't like the science diet vet reccommended

There is a difference when your dog has sensitive skin issues and bones that vitamin E is important my dogs use the Pro plan and they seem to like it much better !

Tried an “all life stages” product....too rich for my puppy.

Some of the stuff they make is pure garbage but, the Purina pro plan that is very expensive I did not see any bad ingredients in it.

The pro plan cognitive is for senior dogs that seem to have cognitive issues due to their age.

Purina one has corn, Pro plan does not

The cognitive plan is for.senior dogs

Hi!!!!! Im very confused why promoting Purina which has synthetics galore and you put Carna4 basically as a no to dog food?? Your a Vet. We have a vet in the family she says your promoting these foods cuz they pay you too??? Heath for pets does not include sythetic vitamins added to fooods no???

Very misleading info and opinion. Very disappointing you didn't even know which foods to choose for the comparison. You are comparing two totally different foods and you have no clue what you are reviewing and going by just info from a package. You didn't even know what arginine is and what it is for, yet people are looking at this video and can actually choose the wrong food based on your advise. Food for cognitive function is very specific for dogs that are above a certain age and it's designed to stimulate brain activities and better oxygen distribution to the brain, hence the food is targeting a specific types of dogs. Where Purina One is mainly a daily balance food, not targeting a specific dog condition. PLEASE, learn more about a type of food and what it actually does, before you make a review which can have serious implications for a pet.

Please employ editing of your videos so that we don’t have to sit through unrelated parts such as Pioneer Woman treats, phone dialing, phone messages, phone on hold, chat typing, etc. Super irritating video.