Her version is always my favorite. Revisiting this after a year, and it's still great.

Respect on everyone likes what they like - personally, I like the reimagining of the song as New Orleans Jazz...but also love the original, but I can see how hearing something iconic in a different tempo and key can throw a person. As an aside, I'm curious as to what you think about her improvs/scats, I think it's one thing that sets her apart (aside from the throaty growls, of course hah)

I so love an honest reaction. Respect what deserves respect, love what you love. Awesome.

I love this one! I appreciate your honesty and COMPLETELY get you😁

It's hard to create a new path in your brain for a song that you love. This version was the first time I heard Seven Nation Army, I only heard the original version later. So. This version is my brain path for this song. Great respect for another opinion. That's part of what makes art so dynamic.

Thanks for reacting to this. Interestingly enough, I had never heard the original, therefore it worked for me as it was something new to me personally. Thanks again 🙂

I appreciate the honesty. For me the instrumentation is good, even if too repetitive. But the vocals are just great! For me. Keep up the good work. Another thumbs up on this video.

After hearing Haley go retro I need a cigarette, a drink and just kick back immersed in the afterglow.

I love the White Stripes but when Hailey covers a song, her version is my favorite, sorry.

Think of it as musical archaeology. They uncover the original musical roots of the song from before the rise of rock.

Justin Johnson: Malanguena 😲 Wow. Flawless!

Ahh, Haley! :) Btw, I have a photographic memory too. Well sometimes I can remember where I put my photographs.

This was way better than the original .

Postmodern jukebox all about that Bass you have to listen to it

Don’t kid yourself... you know you loved it

Thank you for your honest reaction!

I love PMJ, and I love this particular arrangement, but there are a few of their arrangements that, while I can see where they were going with it and I can appreciate the technical brilliance, they just don't quite work for me. So I get where you're coming from...

In this video, they were only a few levels away from unlocking the trombone player.

love it, i listen to this least once a month for years now. thanks for reaction.

Her voice is very jazzy.

I'd like to see a reaction to PMJ's cover of Gnarls Barkley's - Crazy. Gives me chills every time I hear it.

WOW!!! Fantastic!!

Fair analysis, thanks for reacting. Haley is a beast and should be more mainstream IMHO. PMJ does their thing and it is always done well. I respect your personal opinion based on the original.

Funny, I heard this version first and like it better. You get something in the head and like to keep it that way.

This is what PMJ does. It takes established songs and stands them on its ear. It Haley also does a take on "Black Hole Sun" that might get an interesting reaction.

If at all possible could you do another cover of this song? 2cellos "Seven Nation Army" official video. Have never heard this cover before, they did a great job. WOW! Thank you for doing this one!

Hahaha, tastes obviously differ - and that's cool cause it would be terribly boring if we all liked the same thing. Personally, for me, the original White Stripes version sounds like a badly practiced garage band unfamiliar with their instruments and suffering from a horrendous hangover ;-)

Finally a reactor who says when he's not a big fan of a performance❣

I concur with all the above! Thanks

No, Haley's Britney Spear's cover as Marylin Monroe is her 2nd best performance in my opinion. I recommend Pentatonix - Cracked, Scott Hoying - Tell Your Momma On You, or Scott Hoying and Kevin Olusola - The A-Team.

Personally I think when anyone hears one the the best performance by any artist and then listens to other performances, it can become a slight letdown because you know what they are capable of and human nature wants more. But you're still trying to be objective. I can almost say 90% if anyone hears this performance 1st and then moves on to "All That Bass" (which you haven't heard by PMJ yet with Haley and Morgan) and then go to "Creep" each performance would have been appreciated more and more without any reservations due to expectations. In your case your expectations were also knowing this song you like a certain way prior and that you probably loved, which gave a preconceived perception. For me Creep is the best performance Haley does and she so damn sexy doing it. It's the whole package. After listening to "Creep" it's hard to find a better performance. But that's just how I feel, No one may feel the same. That's the beauty of music.

I know this comment is late, regardless if you aren't into Dirty NO Jazz, you have to admit that Tbone solo was fire. Glad you were able to grind through and find bits and pieces to groove to even if the performance as a whole isn't your thing.

I just stumbled onto your channel today because of PMJ and am thoroughly entertained by your facial reactions throughout the song. That being said, I can totally respect your opinion on this rendition as a whole. I loved the rendition and look forward to seeing more of your videos.

Okay, I'm always a day late and a dollar short it seems. But nonetheless, you've heard Haley sing jazz on a couple of tunes. So here's a new rock song she wrote off of her recent "Lo-Fi Soul" album called "Don't Know How to Love You". I pretty sure you will like it cause it's a very soulful rock song in which she sings to perfection. kzfaq.info/get/bejne/kLqKi66nqbHJgok.html

Subscribed because of the intro and, PMJ needs more reacts.

How about checking out their cover of 'Old Town Road' - real blues style sung by Miche Braden. She owns that song!

Do their version of Oops I did it again!

I agree this match of song and genre isn't my favorite. But, for what it was, it was well done. I appreciated the shoutout on the first PMJ reaction. The one I am really "holding out for" though is PMJ and Morgan James' covers of 'Maps' and Aerosmith's 'Dream on'. Also there is a cove of Megan Trainor's 'All about the Bass' that feature her and Haley that is fun.

The dress alone was worth the view.

I'd love to hear your take on "Operator" by The Manhattan Transfer. Older, but amazing...

I agree with everything you said. :)

I would like to recommend (PMJ): Take me to church-Morgan James, Ain't no rest for the wicked-Joey Cook; Every breath you take-Vonzell Solomon and Staight up-Ashely Stroud. They have so many good songs though. Sorry to request so many at once

Hey I love you guys reactions when Creep by Haley Reinhart yeah that's right some of us white people have soul as you can see. like the shirt so you part of THE GREAT AWAKENING FAMILY LOVE ALL MY AMERICAN BROTHERS AND SISTERS #WEAREFREEDOM. CAJUN. ALASKAN QANON. PATRIOT

Agree! I like parts of the song but not my fav. Can you react to Rozzi- Lose Us ft Scott Hoying from PTX😁

Okay, so if you haven't done it yet, you need to see PMJ's cover of Gnarls Barkley's "Crazy." Gives me chills every time!!! (Just like Creep!)

I love the white stripes version as well. This version is an amazing rendition that stands on it's own, not as better though. IMHO

Oh, and if you do like good scat/jazz improv, let me recommend Jaya and KZ Tandingan cover of 'Feeling Good'

Haley Reinhart performs black hole Sun, and the dress she is wearing is amazing. she also performs habits. she's so adorable. I love the lighting they had for her on the stage in this video, it was perfect. her personality truly comes out when she is doing the vocals for that song. but if you want to see her be real. check out Haley Reinhart's Song BETTER. MY GOD THAT VIDEO. Better is the song of her album. Yes, the video is amazing. there are several of them on her album that is amazing. I'm the video that she does with puddles pity party the clown is amazing because of the height difference between her and puddles. And if you don't know who puddles pity party is check out his rendition of the song I who adore you

And your poison for this evening sir? Bourbon, scotch or martini?

Im sorry this didn't work for you.... but oh man does it work for me!

I understand getting one version so ingrained in them that it's hard to do any other version. There were some that did that with Disturbed's Sound of Silence (which I saw your reaction). If everybody loved everything that everyone did, we would have no variety and interestingness :) Keep doing your thing.

Please react to Chris Cornell’s remake of Michael Jackson’s Billie Jean..the best version on KZfaq is the acoustic live version and it’s a black and white picture of Chris Cornell looking straight forward..that is an amazing remake that gets stripped down and made me realize I didn’t even really pay attention to the lyrics much for the original lol it’s amazing

you really NEED to react to Africa by Leo Moracchioli

Haley -> Monroe + Jazz + Circe !!!

have to admit I like the performance but here I must say somehow I have missed the original so I have nothing to compare it to. So now I go find the original and the 2 Cellos cover and have a wonderful exploration of music today.

Try IronHorse byt Mean Mary, step out of your confortzone!

REQUEST: Something old, something new, something you might do-- Guitar virtuoso Frank Marino's "Voodoo Chile Montreal 2001" kzfaq.info/get/bejne/fraFnbp6sKe9pok.html Haley performing one of her songs "Check Please" Naperville RibFest 2018 kzfaq.info/get/bejne/aL1ld66cxp-ZaWw.html

Since it's soon is Christmas, I'd like to see you react to Ann-Sophie von Otter singing "Holy night". It's based on a swedish song written in the style of swedish folkusic. It's a great Christmas song and almost none have heard it. Here's the link kzfaq.info/get/bejne/j62Eh7Z9mNeRomg.html

I don't have a photographic memory but I do have a pornographic memory.

I agree with you. Love her voice but not better than the original this time

Please react to Inside Looking Out by Grand Funk Railroad.

Damn! Just.... beautiful! Shit man, love this channel and your stank face! 👍

Its definitely not as good as the original, but for me....for what they were going for I think they did great, and Haley is amazing!!!

Brother great channel.... Haley's kooL but this sux Vs original TIP OF DAY# ROSCOE BY MIDLAKE.... WIZARDS SLEEVE REMIX THIS WOULD BE A FIRST REACTION VIDEO EVER OF A SONG THAT HAS HUGE CULT FOLLOWING....

You're not going to like 'em, or at least prefer 'em, all.

Please react to Haley to "Creep" ! ♥♥

I have a new video you and your viewers are going to love ...........PINK FLOYD , comfortbly numb........LIVE at EARLS COURT 1994.............i swear this will blow your minds

Its a New Orleans Dirge style

But does it work?

I agree with you.. The Brass was too much. I coulda done fine with Haley, the bass and piano.

Please react to Yebba!!!

Fair enough. Being honest is better than being fake....... 1 last try for PMJ...... no rest for the wicked featuring Joey cook.... I think the song lends better to the jazzy arragement.

Your mission DramaSydETV, should you choose/decide to accept it, ... As always, should you or any of your REACTION Force be caught or killed, the Secretary will disavow any knowledge of your actions. Your reaction could self destruct. Your mission is to React to punk rock We could go back in time and start you with David Bowie and ashes to ashes but let's bring it a little bit forward. start with a band called she wants revenge. Their song: tear you apart. Next up. Band. Wolf mother. Song: joker & the thief. And try your best to contain your emotions when you listen to the song by The band. blue October. The song: hate me to day Then seek Out your absolution by attending the church of the band GHOST and their song, ritual Good luck on your mission reactor 5.4 3.2 1

Do Rammstein Deutschland

Subscribed! 😁 I've enjoyed the few of your reactions I've seen, and I like your commentary, and that you are real about what you like and don't like. I really like this version (and the original song), but I don't think that my preferences should dictate what everybody else likes, as seems to be with many viewers (negative, or even not overflowingly positive responses in reaction videos tend to attract dislikes). Anyway, you want suggestions? Here's one: Asaf Avidan has been criminally un-reacted-to! Very few reactions to him out there, and he's pretty exceptional. He's a singer-songwrighter and multi-instrumentalist. I suggest reacting to his "Her Lies", specifically this version: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/fNVdpLGryt6oh3k.html

you dont know what good music is my freind

I AGREE with your analysis in all counts. I love Haley and hate this strip tease version of the song. That’s all folks

Yea, I love PMJ and Haley Reinhart, but this cover really just doesn't work for me, either.

Did you say pornographic memory? You got a thumbs down from me this time. You were all over "Creep' But didn't "get" this?

the harmonica ruined it for me. without that i feel it was amazing

the harmonica ruined it for me. without that i feel it was amazing