my book vs movie for DUNE PART TWO is up! link in this description!

I just started reading Sabers of Paradise by Leslie Blanch, which inspired Dune. It's a nonfiction book about Imam Shamyl, a Daghestani leader who led a war against the Russian empire in the 19th century. I didn't realize how much Herbert pulled from this book. E.g. The secret hunting language, the crysknife (called a kindjal and they used to say to their opponent "may thy kindjal rust" similar to "may thy knife chip and shatter"), the part about the women fighting as well as the men and throwing their babies at the enemy (and this is just in the first couple of chapters).

In trailer for Part Two, I enjoy seeing Princess Irualan doing some narration like in the novel

Excellent commentary on the novel versus Denis' movie, and I certainly agree with 95% of what you mention. I'm quite amazed at how wonderfully you handled this. On a side note: I don't think I've ever heard anyone talk about a small sentence early in the novel and an early Irulan writing at a header that Paul never had any childhood playmates or friends! Wow, what does that do to a child? Anyway, I'll be interested in your comparison of Dune Part 2 and the novel.

Such a great breakdown, Laura! Seriously, it’s a big plot with a ton of moving parts, not an easy one to make a concise video about. I’m so excited that you’re also covering Dune, gives me an excuse to revisit part one 🪱 Part Two soon!

Fantastic detailed summary/comparison!

I LOVE Dune!! Excitedly awaiting part 2, but I admit, you explained some things about Dune 1, that I didn't know or couldn't understand. Thank you.

I just watched Dune Part 2 yesterday and I can't wait for your review of it versus the book. You will have a LOT to talk about!

I think Part 1 was missing out on a lot of context because it didn't have enough screen time (I wish we could get an extended cut). I also feel that the Jamis battle lacked any emotional weight. It just kinda came out of nowhere. Honestly that was the only part of the movie I kinda disliked.

You should give the scifi miniseries a go, whilst it isnt very high production it is more faithful to the novel than any other adaptation.

20:35 I would add that the Atreides are the most moral of the noble houses but they aren't kind just because of their noble heart, they have a strong "PR department" so to speak. Many good gestures are calculated (but then again, they could get away not doing things that they do anyway). Of course, in any case, always better than the alternatives.

Wow! You knocked this video “out of the park.”

Awesome video! I reccomend you keep going after the first 3 books. One of my favorited is god emperor of dune the fourth book!

You didn't mention the dinner party. It's one of my favorite scene in the books. It just explains so much stuff that are going on about arrakis and the characters. But I get why they cut it, because it's probably the hardest thing to adapt in the book.

Just finished reading part one of the book after having seen both of the movies. I personally like the book more so far. I like information-gathering and complex theories and stories, so the book hits the spot. The movies in comparison literally feel like I'm dreaming the book. The atmosphere, the music, the mystical visions, and the sparse dialogue, the details and events being a little bit out of order, etc. I honestly wonder if that is what the director was going for when adapting the book to film--dreaming the books.

Dune is my absolute favorite book! I enjoyed the Sci-Fi channel's Dune movies, but I haven't checked out the new ones . . .

I cant figure out which book to read.... I keep seeing several different versions and i cant find a list of the books, in order.

Love you videos

I’ve watched part one & two multiple times this year & I absolutely love it. I’m halfway through the Dune book & lol shocker I love it too.

17:10 I think it's interesting. In the film, Yueh says to the Baron that he wants to release her from her agony and he could join her. That to me read like he resigned to die as long as he knew that this meant she was also dead. Very specific wording for how it was shown to us that the Baron likes to do monkey paw deals. I was really bummed about the Thufir Hawat stuff because I love that actor and would've loved to see him spar with Jessica lol.

I love Dune! I rarely re-read books, but I always come back to Dune every year or so! I enjoyed the film, but there's so much in the book that I wish was in the film. But I know not everything could be included without it being 10 hours long... 😅 Also, The David Lynch Dune gets too much hate! It's not as bad as people make out, but it is also very, very clear when they ran out of money. 😂

Bless the Maker and His water. Bless the coming and going of Him. May His passage cleanse the world. May He keep the world for His people. I still get the chills when Kynes mutters the prayer. Great essay, I love your observations. If I tried to do something like this video I would be all over the place.

Nice review, Laura. I enjoyed the Dune film adaptation for the cast, world -building, and the epic Hans Zimmer score. I will probably read Dune after I watch Dune Part 2. Take care and have a nice day.

Great review! One of these days, it would be so interesting for you to share how us mere mortals can keep up with these books with massive plots and countless characters like you do. It must be a process that you can get a patent on!

Frank Herbert was not very happy about starwars and the many coincidences between the two.

Had to play the video in the background, those eyes were piercing into my soul and i was getting lost. But awesome video, hope you let us know your thoughts on part 2

Did seeing the movie first help you get through the book? I tried reading Dune a few years ago, and the writing was too dense-world-building fantasy/sci-fi for me. I'm still interested though.

Great video, also, nice hair and shirt btw. Something you made me think of when talking about Jamis challenging Jessica and Paul, i think Jamis was such a religious zealot that he could see through the BS and see how they didnt quite fit the prophecy. Which is ironic because his beliefs were planted by the bene gesserit and should be serving Jessica. I might be misremembering this.

Very Impressive breakdown of both movie and book. 44:00 I thought you were hit by a Hunter / Seeker!

So, Frank Herbert was incredibly upset with Lucas ripping of Dune and was planning to sue him. He eventually changed his mind after Tim O'Reilly convinced him not to sue.

Good analysis, it is not easy to remember all the book details, there is so much to remember. I liked the first film, knowing the story took away some of the awe. I expect small changes in both, I just hope we do not lose some important themes. I expect some aspects of the book will not be expanded on until the third film. If you like the first book, you will absolutely love the next two. The four book is not really suitable for a film but is a major in depth explanation of the overall goal for mankind controlled by Paul and his son The 5th and 6th book pick up the results of the first 4 books in the far future. The son of Hebert wrote two books to complete the original series but I think he went off at a tangent that his father would not have done, but they suit all the prequel books the son has written, so I understand his motive.

question- why does paul keep having dreams about specifically chani?

Ah so that title, does it imply that you will ONLY discuss/spoil things that happened thus far in the movie and will not touch on anything that will take place later on/in the second & third movie? If that's the case, I can watch this video, but wanna make sure before I do, as I really look forward to seeing part 2 without having been spoiled before. 😊

Visceral, soft c, like viscera

Take a sip every time they say Lisan Al'Gaib

Bene Gesserit aren't really witches as that would imply the use of supernatural powers which isn't what they do. Every Bene Gesserit ability is peak human skills, having learned to control their bodies down to the thinniest atom, to perceive and "read" people, to change the chimical composition of poisons in their body, and to project pinpoint voice commands that instill ideas in another's person mind, etc. Just like Mentats are also peak human skills in information gathering and retention. This is all a result of the Butlerian Jihad, and subsequent ban of all artificial intelligence. It was determined that the human body needed to be taken to its absolute limits, to achieve complete mastery over it, in order to essentially become the ultimate "thinking machine", to make up for forbidden AI technologies. That philosophy birthed the Bene Gesserit, the Mentat and the Navigators.

Excellent job. I am a big fan of the Frank Herbert Dune novels and was hella excited when it was announced that they were doing another Dune movie. Like you I agree that the 2021-2024 movies are visually stunning and follow the book pretty closely. However, one thing I do appreciate about the David Lynch movie, is that a lot more exposition was done around the economics of spice. Lynch never lets the audience forget that the entire motivation driving the political intrigue in this world is the Spice Melange as the oil that keeps the wheels of this fictional universe turning. In the 2021 film, there is barely a vague mention by the Emperor’s envoy and the Baron. The other aspect of the Lynne film that was vitally important is his exposition around the importance of the Guild as a major manipulative force diving the dangerous politics in this world, along with the bene gesserit sisterhood. I was massively disappointed that the role of the guild was virtually omitted from the Denis Villeneuve film. To me the Guild and its navigators, are one of the most captivating players in this universe. I hope we see them featured more in the next film. Does anyone else out there have any thoughts about this, if so I would love to know what you think. I would also hope that the Thufir Hawat storyline is included. Having said all of this. Dune Two might be the most visually spectacular sequel to a film I have ever seen. Thanks for your content, I really enjoyed it!

I love both but one of the criticisms is that Frank H. renders the villains in a rather simplistic way common to 1960s sci-fi. True, but I think they serve a purpose and illustrate how this strata of humanity has evolved to be so unfeeling and ruthless. Dune is, after all, about a vision of mankind at extremes.

Dune movie part one and part two are not the same as book and i say it failed , the movie failed.

Maybe because it's Valentine's Day and I'm alone and bitter but I had to stop watching after three minutes. Like you I'm not into fantasy but I take it to another level. I despise fantasy. I did like this video because you deserve One Million subscribers. Gotta go....my table for one is waiting for me. Reserved under "Bitter". 🤡