How is Germany’s school system different from the one where you live? 🤓📝 #berlin #germany #cultureshock #germanschool #livingabroad #livingingermany #shorts
Пікірлер: 292
@hape386210 ай бұрын
It should be mentioned that these paths can be easily changed. This way, no one gets stuck in the wrong school/career forever. The idea behind this is not to burden practically gifted/interested children with too much dry academic material and, conversely, not to bore intelligent children with an unchallenging curriculum.
@marsin640610 ай бұрын
Theoretically true, but not practically
@thecrazycrazycatlady253210 ай бұрын
Agreed! I was at Gymnasium first, then switched to Realschule and after i was finished with that, i finished the Gymnasium as well and got my Abitur. My sister went to Hauptschule first, switched to Realschule after a year and started a Formation. She then went to evening school to get her Abitur as well. There are so many ways.
@Blazzzerr10 ай бұрын
Nobody can say if you are 12 years old if you will make it to q uni or not
@GrizzlyonFire10 ай бұрын
@@marsin6406 actually it is very common to visit higher schools after finishing the starting one. I started with Realschule und then continued with Berufskolleg (something between Gymnasium and Realschule). Then Fachhochschule (Bachelor) and University(Master). Many of my old friends had better grades and continued with the Gymnasium after finishing Realschule. One of my best Friends finished his job training, became master in his Job and then went to university and is currently making his Doctor in Physics. So I Think it’s very easy in Germany to get to the highest academic degrees step by step.
@tomendruweit938610 ай бұрын
i know dozens that changed levels midway through or went from haupt to real or real to abi. its not really hard at all and very easy to do@Elaisen2
@DeadCat-4210 ай бұрын
I was in the short bus, learning disabilities classes until eighth grade, then moved to advanced placement. I'm now an electrical engineer.
@erika821410 ай бұрын
I have learning disabilities too and my parents decided not to enroll me in the German Schools because as the gentleman described they thought I would have a very difficult time. I don’t know if the German Schools recognize learning disabilities. So, I stayed enrolled within the American Schools through the Department of Defense. I graduated and went on to college. My German friend was recommended to go to trade school and her sister was recommended to go to college.
@brandcack411710 ай бұрын
Same but now I’m a clinical psychologist
@thecosmos72910 ай бұрын
That's awesome!
@laerramarie262010 ай бұрын
@@erika8214You sound like you never lived in Germany
@oscarmike34829 ай бұрын
My brother was the same, now he's a chartered accountant. Funny how things work out 😂
@EmilySC2310 ай бұрын
Quick side note, because you mention law and medical school: The uni system is different than the US and rather than grad school you directly apply for law, etc when you start university without doing an undergrad first. Just wanted to mention that since it confuses a lot of people.
@hkgehts90619 ай бұрын
he's not from the US. why is everyone comparing to the US and when did he mention law or medicine?
@EmilySC239 ай бұрын
@@hkgehts9061 I guess because it’s the most well-known amongst English speaking people and therefore the easiest to compare/the one others get compared to?
@EmilySC239 ай бұрын
@@hkgehts9061 He mentions the Gymnasium path to university could open the door to law or medical school
@marquisdehoto163810 ай бұрын
You can also continue school after your first degree and can get from hauptschule to gymnasium and then study. And I like this flexibility
@xSoulhunterDKx10 ай бұрын
Well obviously. You will also get a higher level of education when you finish your apprenticeship (Ausbildung)
@marquisdehoto163810 ай бұрын
@@xSoulhunterDKx I meant something like BOS/FOS and you can make every degree after you left school. Even if you leave without any. At least in bayria🙈 why is the system in germany so complicated? 😅
@xSoulhunterDKx10 ай бұрын
@@marquisdehoto1638 ahh, thanks for letting me now what exactly you meant. German education isn’t really complicated. More like underfunded 😂
@marquisdehoto163810 ай бұрын
@@xSoulhunterDKx maybe. I mean in some states primary school is 4 in other 5 or 6 years. Some apparently stay in the same class only difference is and leave after 9, 10 or 12(?) Years.
@stephjovis34699 ай бұрын
Thanks I was wondering. I was in Hauptschule but in Austria. Went on to Handelsakademie and eventually to uni. You can learn a job after or go to another school
@fermintenava591110 ай бұрын
That's like it feels... a little bit. I did pretty well in primary school, except for Physical Education and Crafting Lessons ("Werkunterricht"), but my teachers were convinced that I should be good in all subjects and that I wouldn't be able to keep up with pressure in Gymnasium. So I went to Realschule, with a lot of people that I didn't get along with, while the few friends I had moved on to Gymnasium... so the stress in Realschule did not come from school work, but mostly from my classmates. And yet, when I eventually took advanced schooling on a Gymnasial level to get to university, I found that not only school work was doable, but my classmates were much chiller and more mature (I mean... they were over 18, but still!), and it was a more healthy environment to grow up. So what do I take from this? ... I'm not sure. I was an anxious child, and maybe pressure would have gotten to me either way. But I don't think physical grades were a good enough justification to keep me below my level, and some early counseling might have done better adapting to the challenges.
@wl6bbyd9 ай бұрын
Fun fact: many Gymnasium graduates actually end up doing an apprenticeship after all :)
@sushikissa777710 ай бұрын
In Finland we choose our school at the age of 16. And after that it's still easy to change. But everybody can go to a special class already at the age of 9. Special classes are thing like music or art
@enemybmp9 ай бұрын
You're also able to go to gymnasium when you're on the hauptschule. What is he talking about? Of course you have to do something for that, learning inluded.
@FrickPlstnFrickPride8 ай бұрын
I know right, he's so delusional. This is not at all how German schools work. That's just what Germany wants others to think.
@hkgehts90617 ай бұрын
@@FrickPlstnFrickPride that is how they work. You go from the Hauptschule to Realschule for one year and from Realschule to gymnasium, usually repeating a grade.
@ringoinah9 ай бұрын
In the Netherlands we get sorted at age 12. It’s also very difficult to switch paths.
@vermas465410 ай бұрын
Gesamtschule is definitely the best one
@SeanORaigh9 ай бұрын
This would've given primary school me intense anxiety. I didn't even have my future planned out when I graduated high school, let alone primary.
@SchennyoOoO9 ай бұрын
you don't really make a decision. School gives a recommendation depending on your grades and how you do in school. And then your parents will do whatever they like haha and you can always continue studying to get to the highest academically highschool level
@minlea0310 ай бұрын
Its actually not. After fourth grade the teachers check on how quick you are with learning new things. Since every child develops different not every child woud be able to learn as quickly as you are supposed to in the Gymnasium. That means kids who have trouble to learn that fast can go to a school first that is not so stressful for them to slowly reach the level of the Gymnasium. You can finish after 9th or 10th grade or you finish 10th grade and go to a Gymnasium afterwards to finish at 12th or 13th grade. It is made to make it easier for kids who don't understand or develop that quickly and even if you finished with 9th or 10th grade you have an opportunity to study in University.
@lisal.111410 ай бұрын
Also in some states we have primary school till grade 7 and change after the 6th grade😅
@lifeasrini10 ай бұрын
Here in Australia it was a bit like that when I was young in the 80s/90s. We were placed in "levels" in high school and encouraged to move to trades at 15 if we were in the lower levels. Some states had separate high schools for trade and university levels, but mine did it the first way. But they made it pretty easy to find other paths if you found yourself on the wrong one. I know it's changed a lot now, they encourage all kids to stay through high school but I'm unsure how it works within the schools itself ✌️
@thectrqueenmedina9210 ай бұрын
We have this at my high school. The “pathways” as we call them are easily interchanged if your desired career path changes
@lonelygovernment454410 ай бұрын
well that's the oversimplification of the century
@jungschon400310 ай бұрын
Em, no it's not.
@ericsoul60410 ай бұрын
@@jungschon4003Are you german or have attended german school?
@sarazverinova40510 ай бұрын
Do you want me to explain what a YT short is?
@jungschon400310 ай бұрын
@@ericsoul604 yes and yes. And I have a university degree. But I know that the German system is neighter just or efficiant.
@arnodobler109610 ай бұрын
@@jungschon4003Berufsfachschulen, Fachhochschulen, Berufsschule, ... um nur einige zu nennen
@gengis7379 ай бұрын
The great think in Germany is that, whenever in your life, you can go back to school / uni and improve your diploma. Usually with your employer's agreement and being paid partly by the state, partly by the employer. So initial orientation can harm, but is not for life.
@jackrabbit454510 ай бұрын
Where I live you can be in university and still not have a career path till 2ed year, and if you already have your career path you’re forced to take 30-40 hours of classes unrelated to your path
@lifeasrini10 ай бұрын
The first way makes it sound pretty cool, time to figure it out, but if you're stuck doing things you know you can't use later, that would be annoying.. worse if you have to pay for those useless units 😭
@tf36559 ай бұрын
In Germany you decide with enrollment what subjects you want to study and will only have the classes relevant for said subject (or what certain people thought would be relevant). So a law student and a med student will have no overlap classes (other than something like general soft skills). You can change the subject but will likely have to start from 0.
@ChungusTheLarge10 ай бұрын
In my country everybody is trained to be a factory worker, but we closed all of our factories
@Roll_dude10 ай бұрын
So USA
@Deridus10 ай бұрын
Sounds like Amerika...
@mirjanamiksic680910 ай бұрын
😅😅like with us,but we have "import" produkt,we only shoping,and work in shop
@Deridus10 ай бұрын
@@mmking9517 Fair enough. De-industrialization is widely blown out of proportion, but what did happen certainly didn't do their countries any good. Most American textiles, for example, aren't made there anymore. Dingolfing is still a major automotive site in Deutschland, and Sveriga still has the best foundries in the world, but even so, your point still stands.
@Deridus10 ай бұрын
@@mmking9517 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@Stolens8710 ай бұрын
This separation is actually pretty shitty... Gesamtschule was not available where I live but that sounds alright. I've been in Realschule and there was always judgements between other schools. Today everybody's child is the smartest and has to go to the Gymnasium since it seems to offer the best chances... But you (or your parents) have to decide that if you are 10 or so. I really don't like it
@naomiallen85379 ай бұрын
I’m from the Netherlands and it nearly the same but we get an advies so VWO is gymnasium,HAVO is like the middle ones but we have a lot more then three so you are sure to have on that fits like MAVO,KADER PRAKTIJK but also can choose later so you can have HAVO/VWO wich means later on you can choose if your able to go to VWO or HAVO
@TeaIngyer9 ай бұрын
Friendly reminder that "Sorting Hat" style education has been proven to reduce positive education outcomes. Even when you can change levels/paths, telling students what you think they should be causes social pressure to conform.
@nolanwilson565210 ай бұрын
That fourth option sounds quite beneficial. I know a ton of people from FSU who switched their majors 3 times, its not common for someone to stay in the same job field at a young age.
@tf36559 ай бұрын
That is not a switch of majors, more like levels of difficulty.
@martalis74529 ай бұрын
I can just felt it was like they asked you what you were gonna do and you just have to figure it out
@angrypirate109410 ай бұрын
Up to 9th grade is the same for everyone, at most you'll see math and english being taught at a higher level to the more gifted kids, then 2-3 years of trade, nerd, standard or finance school to prepare you for higher education. The state also offers remedial courses for those that took the wrong path after 9th grade but want to pursue a career that their path did not prepare them for.
@SchennyoOoO9 ай бұрын
My sister got sorted into the Hauptschule, then after a year or so she switched to Realschule, after she finished that she went on to the Gymnasium and then to university. Then she quit that and did an apprenticeship. So there is really a lot of options and you are not stuck with one thing after you get sorted into one type of school
@andreasarnoalthofsobottka29289 ай бұрын
Not to mention that you can go to evening school (Abendgymnasium) and take your A- levels any time as an adult, become a Meister in any trade and go to university studying in your field.
@midnightmusings81449 ай бұрын
It's the same in other countries. After primary school you either go to a general highschool or to a trade school. After the general highschool there are still a few options.
@robertnett97939 ай бұрын
As the video is short and the system quite intricate: There are secondary lanes for higher education. For one, you can add a 10th year to trade school to get the intermediate degree. With this you can go specialised 'Oberschulen' (upper or above schools) where you can get the gymnasiums degree and the prequisits to attend university. You also can have your regular trade school, do an apprenticeship and go to a 'Trade Upper School' after that getting your gymnasium degree that way. Then there's a path from an artisan mastery (which is NOT a masters degree, but a title you can earn after apprenticeship and 3 years of practice) to a career specialised university. So there are a few straight forward roads for most people. elementary school - trade school - apprenticeship - job (- mastery) or elementary school - gymnasium - university or elementary school - real school (middle school) - and from there either a career or Oberschule - university...
@jesussalvador84959 ай бұрын
This should be implemented here for New York City schools
@NoahErikkson9 ай бұрын
This is a really cool aspect of German culture that America needs
@saraleigh53369 ай бұрын
Why? America should be more classist?
@brettk93169 ай бұрын
I like freedom 🇺🇸
@letmebecharlie10 ай бұрын
haha i love that i immediately recognized the location where they shot this video
@Silvercrypto-xk4zy9 ай бұрын
That’s drastically different than the one size fits all mandated 12 years (13 if you went to preschool) in america. We don’t even have the option of school related work experience until our last year unless you get your own job at 16 but then you’re expected to do both the homework plus working and the restrictions on work are numerous
@mattryangomez361810 ай бұрын
Yeah so um My school just doubled the amount police One of which walked up to me with their hand on their holster because my hall pass wasn't visible I also found out in my school district tomato ketchup is considered a vegetable My 83 yr pre cal teacher is coughing her lungs up while at the same time multiple students have tested positive for covid Im in my senior year of highschool True red white and blue merican 👍🙂👍
@RFMvids7010 ай бұрын
It's that way in most of Europe.
@Leon_Portier9 ай бұрын
Our school system with the division into Haupt- Realschule and Gymnasium is extremly flawed.
@thegoodspear179 ай бұрын
People should be able to pick what they want to do.
@starlinguk9 ай бұрын
I'm Dutch. Similar school system. He started at a lower level and ended up at gymnasium. He's got a degree in engineering.
@meganjones25809 ай бұрын
So where I live at the moment, in Italy, they choose to go to a classical school, scientific school or like a school more focused on technical subjects and then you study a set curriculum. But the country I am from, Wales (not sure if it’s the same across the whole of the UK), we all stay in the same school but choose the subjects we want to study for our GCSE’s with some compulsory subjects like maths, science, English and Welsh.
@dweuromaxx9 ай бұрын
Thanks for your comment, Megan.
@wotthemic779110 ай бұрын
The US School system did nothing for me. Didn't help me find a career path, didn't help me look for higher education or opportunities, and some of my teachers outright said that they thought I should just drop out.
@arstotzkianarmedforces10578 ай бұрын
It’s not all about you, it’s a really free country where you have to decide your own opportunities. They aren’t just gonna hand it down to you, and if they are telling you to drop out, is it really surprising that nothing could be recommended?
@JimAllen-Persona9 ай бұрын
In older days, I disagreed with this system. However, seeing how many students want to coast through our educational system with minimal effort and really don’t want to be in a mandatory class like Algebra, maybe it’s worth investigating. I’m glad there’s a shift in US culture towards not looking down on the trades. In Europe, it’s not a big deal… some people go to college, others into vocational apprenticeships. I think it’s great.
@carolinemorgan9410 ай бұрын
Well for a start if we had that Merry-Go-Round contraption at my school parents would have been threatening the school board left and right to sue if they did not get rid of that thing. But I wish we did have that in the states cuz that looks like a lot of fun
@haresmahmood9 ай бұрын
It's similar in the Netherlands and I hope they change it
@user-mc5ry1rg7l9 ай бұрын
Similar in Slovakia and Czechia - but dobe in 9th grade ať the age of 14/15
@renatamuehleisen42449 ай бұрын
This is a great system! Should be implemented all over the world! Miss my home country!
@Camille-Couture9 ай бұрын
It’s quite similar in Poland
@himaliamit86989 ай бұрын
The word gazemsula vibes
@TheLofren10 ай бұрын
Remember that they are not obligatory nd a student can choose to take another path
@Heathers_ECE_Consultation10 ай бұрын
Question how is it teaching in Germany? Pay? Ability to do your job? Expectations? Sick leave?
@keroki93210 ай бұрын
Sick leave is unlimited and mandatory for every job in Germany. Other than that the teachers suffer just as much as teachers from other countries
@hape386210 ай бұрын
Teacher is quite a good job in Germany. School ends at 1 pm. Afternoon is free. Holidays are plenty: 6 weeks in summer, 1 week around Halloween, 2 weeks around Christmas, 1 week around Mardi Grass, 2 weeks around Easter and 2 weeks around Pentecost. Salary is very good, as you are a civil servant. Teachers are in high demand at the moment. I don't understand your question "Ability to do your job?" Do you mean if anyone interferes with your teaching? Generally no. (Especially not parents!) But sometimes (randomly every few years) the school director together with a school supervisor from the ministry of culture might sit in one of your classes to evaluate the quality of your teaching. The Expectations are that you teach the official curriculum (as defined by the ministry of culture of the federal state you are teaching in) according to the best practices you've learned at University, during your referendar time (2 years) and continued teacher trainings. There is no such thing as "sick leave" in Germany (and the whole EU for that matter), not for teachers or any other profession. If you are sick, you are sick. Period. Sick days are unlimited and do - of course! - not count on your holidays. And - of course! - you can't be fired for being sick.
@Heathers_ECE_Consultation10 ай бұрын
@@keroki932 I was wondering because it's common to not have enough subs in the US and having other teachers teach multiple classes. I've even heard of multiple reports of teachers having to pay for their own subs out of pocket.
@Ittoswetboosay10 ай бұрын
@@hape3862afternoon/ weekend isn’t “free”. teachers are paid to do 40 hour weeks and therefore the time after 1pm is supposed to be used for preparing classes, grading tests and responding to questions
@hape386210 ай бұрын
@@Ittoswetboosay True. But we both know that teachers in reality don't spend another 3-4 hours a day for preparation, grading and certainly not responding to questions …
@ellid31349 ай бұрын
It’s not Hauptschule anymore. Now it’s called Mittelschule
@thorodinson2929 ай бұрын
War mal auf der Hauptschule. Hab jetzt ein abi und mach ne IT Ausbildung. Nicht aufgeben!
@julianmrgl95689 ай бұрын
He was my teacher. HI MR. DENNIS!!!!!!
@That_Stranger9 ай бұрын
In the uk we …. You guessed it primary, secondary, college and university …..WOWZA
@sobiaasghar67569 ай бұрын
What kind of school for medicine and business studies?
@sidthompson95389 ай бұрын
What song is playing in the background?
@plumjet0910 ай бұрын
I just noticed the school you’re standing in front of has the same name as the ICAO code for Los Angeles International Airport
@bobSeigar9 ай бұрын
How many do you sort into Painting? Ive heard thats pretty dangerous.
@gggggg-hs2tk10 ай бұрын
Not really different but very different at the same time because in Italy they tried to do something similar when I was in middle school, except that my Italian teacher hated my guts and fought with all the other teachers and the principal about their advice to send me to university oriented high schools, like madam calm down it's just a suggestion and you don't have any power over my parents who already hate you anyways💀 basically we still have the same kinds of paths but we get to choose them, also it really depends on the family and how much the parents listen to the teachers (my parents didn't listen to the Italian teacher, they listened to the others and me so I got sent to the school I loved and did very well! I'm still studying linguistics at uni), I don't even know if they still write high school recommendations on the middle school reports anymore honestly. Oh and also you can change paths in high school really easily, you're not stuck from the first year, you have at least three years to change before you start falling behind
@minafrog10 ай бұрын
Everyone who went to a gymasium back in primary are total dropouts lmaoooo
@daevidfan58289 ай бұрын
He forgot the "Sekundarschule"
@fuzzyfrogs736210 ай бұрын
Not at all since I live in Germany 😂
@millionmiler9 ай бұрын
You forgot Wirtschaft Schule
@robertbernard-gx5oo10 ай бұрын
lol they reconsider and revoke me from ever llearing
@MeatboyYeee9 ай бұрын
Naja dass die Berufslaufbahn durch den Abschluss mehr oder weniger vorhergesehen wird ist vielleicht vor 20 Jahren so gewesen aber es hat sich geändert
@ernomarcelstravels10 ай бұрын
In NL🇳🇱 it's even more complicated.
@lisal.111410 ай бұрын
He simplified it a lot, in Germany the schooltypes mentioned in the video r the most commen, but every State does things differently... and from what I have heard some people do have different kinds of Realschule ( in my State u were able to aply for your A Level ( what u need for university) with your Realschulabschluss, in others aparently its similar to Hauptschule and does not offer that oportunity. Some states have schools for people with a Realschulabschluss to do their A Level for 3 years or to do something below that for 2 and some aparently only have Gymnasium. Problem a Gymnasium is mostly age restricted ohh and u can also get your A Level at an evening school. Its also possible for people with a Realschulabschluss to take on an aprenticeship and to study at a college in their respectable field. U can always level up. We just have restrictions on how often u r allowed to study the same degree and the Quality of your education really shows as soon as u have a university experience. Also the support that your family can provide u emotionally, financially and in terms of education can really influence stuff. 🐞🌹🌬🦋
@Fernando3161110 ай бұрын
Your future is not "decided"... you can switch schools or take extra courses/years to change paths. This is extrimely misinformant.
@goatman089 ай бұрын
Starting to feel like MAYBE just maybe germany might be ahead of the game with how certain things ahod be done
@dodopoopinpoop9 ай бұрын
Sad how in America it's not about what skill sets you have but if you have money do your career.
@osen318210 ай бұрын
⚡⚡🤝
@JerryCuberton2 ай бұрын
K-8 is primary school 9-12 is high school Welcome to Ontario
@carolwilliams533710 ай бұрын
It sounds like they really care about the kids and pay attention to their strengths
@einfachmarvin87939 ай бұрын
Not really
@brianarbenz132910 ай бұрын
In the U.S. we have an unwritten system of determining students’ academic future. To begin with, in the poorer families children don’t get nearly as much prenatal and pediatric health care, or nutrition. Our terrible health care system, abject economic inequality and racial red lining make a mockery of the notion of equitable educational opportunities.
@sigsauer_firearms10 ай бұрын
lol ok buddy keep telling yourself that victim minded nonsense
@brianarbenz132910 ай бұрын
Sausage firearms, or whatever that name was, I’m not the victim here. I mean my education was good enough to have included punctuation! 😃😃😃
@Deridus10 ай бұрын
Could it be that, and stay with me for a moment... You're both grossly oversimplifying the problem with American schools?
@Chrisp707-10 ай бұрын
@@DeridusI mean he oversimplified it but he’s not wrong. It’s much much worse than what he described
@Deridus10 ай бұрын
@@Chrisp707- Oh how well I know. I started off in a private school. Ended up having to go to a public school. I always wanted to home school my own children but that's not in the cards. Everything is so bureaucratic. Unnatural. It's simply depressing that I am not allowed to raise my own child.
@texaswunderkind9 ай бұрын
Seems overly complicated. But I do think American school systems should get back to promoting skilled trades, rather than acting like all students should attend college. In the old days my school district had a "Tech" high school where they taught plumbing, electrician, welding, auto repair, etc. like a trade school. Students graduated with marketable job skills. They were also a football power, since 75% of the students were male.
@broppiovinegar296410 ай бұрын
School choice for the win
@mattimuller889410 ай бұрын
And forgot the Berufsschule
@ChampionSeif9 ай бұрын
You forgot IGS
@thomthom34209 ай бұрын
You have misunderstood the system totally.
@JustGrizzzz10 ай бұрын
I’ve always agreed with this style of learning.. in America I learned about math that was only used in cameras aka Imaginary units (-i, i^2). if I’m not a going into civil engineering why do I need to learn about math in cameras.. sure it teaches problem solving skills but why not teach me about the problems I’m realistically gonna solve?? Even as a college student I’m still learn general ed that I’m never gonna utilize?!?
@lonewolf280710 ай бұрын
In america were prisoners that are forced to learn how to be a good obedient puppy oh and also the entire government is corrupt welcome to America☺️♥️
@tragicallymistaken10 ай бұрын
Oh my gosh, this sounds like a dream compared to schools here in the US. I’m not quite sure what they teach you in all of those schools, but I know that starting 6th grade (idk what year it is for Europeans) you have to have a math, science, English, and history class and none of it you retain. Stuff you learn in 7th grade you won’t talk about again until 10th grade or the teacher skips most of the lessons. All the class rooms are gray and boring. I’d compare it to a prison . Nothing we learn in our schools with benefit us in the future. If I know I want to be a doctor, I don’t really care about US history.
@sTas073-i1e9 ай бұрын
The system most countries use including germany and the us is the Prussian schooping system
@valife68969 ай бұрын
Sounds like this German guy from long time ago got his way
@pavlemackic381110 ай бұрын
Barbarick
@TheSniperStriker10 ай бұрын
Thats wrong....we have sooooo many schools after that to get every degree you need
@StrongKickMan9 ай бұрын
The best people come from Gesamtschulen!
@jvox457110 ай бұрын
Go PAULA CAROLINA!!.. ummm, the background music...
@spaceguygames88762 ай бұрын
It's not a difference because I live in Germany
@pokeray119610 ай бұрын
the differnce is that germany's systrm is useful unlike the gun loveing usa
@elliotbest551610 ай бұрын
Your missing Sonderschule
@TSimo11310 ай бұрын
Germany has SOOO much freedom
@einfachmarvin87939 ай бұрын
Found an American
@dallysinghson55699 ай бұрын
This sounds kinda scary as kids do change and fixing them in place at primary school is tetchy...
@RorchaksRevenge10 ай бұрын
I have to pay for it
@pudermcgavin446210 ай бұрын
I wish to the us would do this but nope we removed all of these classes cuz funding
@pudermcgavin446210 ай бұрын
Also they are killing the trades! Kids kids kids trade school is good believe me!
@brandcack411710 ай бұрын
@@pudermcgavin4462here in St. Louis we have one of the best trade schools in the country called Ranken and I got a lot of friends who go there, I wouldn’t say trade is dying
@moony308010 ай бұрын
It's called Mittelschule, not Hauptschule. They changed The Name many years before you Made this Video!
@amanbirbthe4th96710 ай бұрын
No idea where you're from, but it's still called hauptschule where i live
@facts_people-n9 ай бұрын
Difference is.....theirs works
@a1aprospects47010 ай бұрын
Why would we want teachers... who got the EASIEST college degree with the lowest standards... determining what fields kids should focus on? Most of the advice I got from teachers as a student, and that my 3 children got, was off-base and often laughably wrong.
@ih8myfriends10 ай бұрын
In America you go to college or jail. And which one is largely determined by how rich your family is.
@yourmo3549 ай бұрын
Diese Kommentarsektion ist nun Eigentum der Bundesrepublik Deutschland
@Akii-Lamb9 ай бұрын
| go too Gymnasium
@JoeCampbell0610 ай бұрын
The way you explained it reminds me heavily of The Giver's system. I hope it isn't like that cause that is terrifying.
@JoeCampbell069 ай бұрын
@@Hippidippimahm No, though I was very tired. It was explained very simply and knowing Germany it is most likely a great system. It just reminds me of the system in the book. (Just the education part, nothing else.)
@tf36559 ай бұрын
@@JoeCampbell06the choosing career paths is highly misleading. It sorts in academic abilities and not career paths.
@JoeCampbell069 ай бұрын
@@tf3655 that makes a lot more sense. Thanks.
@jayvee03119 ай бұрын
Germany is kinda socialist kinda draconian but still free-ish.
@fredrika279 ай бұрын
You're forgetting to tell the audience what a NEGATIVE influence this has on 9 and 10 year olds mental health when they are told they must go to Hauptschule! Over the last three decades, there has been an extreme uptick in Hauptschule pupils failing school while parents force many unqualified students into Gymnasium, hence why Gesamtschule has been so popular among both parents and students. What's worse: immigrants, generationally poor Germans, racial minorities, and the working class have little economic mobility because the system has relied on keeping these groups under educated in order to have a cheap workforce for low paid jobs. The government now sees how racist and classist this is, but produced the teachers that discriminates by making sure these teachers come from the upper classes instead of supporting working class mobility. Immigrants and racial minorities are four times likely to take the longer path to university than their German counterparts. Once graduated, they still don't have the same opportunities as Germans because names are used to discriminate in hiring practices. This came to light when Deutsche Bank had not one board member who was of color while women were also rare. So much for a fair education system!