How impressive , This is deep . He has worked thru a lot in his years, but to come full circle shows the amazing heart & strength Marshall has . I can only imagine the weight lifted off his Mama .

I'm 67 and this is not the kind of music that I listen to. That being said I recognize what wonderful artists Miley and Eminem are. I do enjoy them and fully the support the work that they do.

This song hits deep down and just definitely reminds me of my own upbringing. He found the courage to use every painful memory he had to write such creative music. This collaboration between Em and Miley was amazing.

Eminem looking a little handsome as he gets older. Better with age.

Who knew a Em song could bring so many tears to my eyes 🥺

I been listening to eminem since 1999 and I'm 34 now. I love this man, he was my childhood and he's still getting me through, he's such pure talent

I'm almost 30 and have listened to Em since I was in the 5th grade. This isn't a song I can listen to every day because I can relate way too much and I don't need to be crying everyday. 😅 🤦‍♀️

To whoever is listening to this song now, wherever you are.... Sending you love, peace, healing and all good wishes. May your life be good❤❤

I’m 57 years old 5 kids that are doing good in life. My mom single parent mom worked 2 3 jobs my whole child hood. But dude this song hits me in my heart. Thank you.

I almost didnt watch this vid, but thankful I did. My mom had confessed that she did things differently when me and my siblings were growing up. Not staying in a shitty marriage. She tells me dont waste your life being miserable no matter how mich ot sets you back. We grew up okay but when my mom left my dad we lived in the worst apartments. It was tough on my mom and I wish I had more compassion for how hard it was for her. She is my everything ever since.

Eminem and Miley Cyrus are both very talented and versatile artists in the music industry. Their collaboration could bring a unique and interesting combination of styles and sounds. Eminem’s powerful lyrics could complement Miley Cyrus’s energy and vibrant voice, creating a captivating and memorable song.❤❤🔥🔥

Its a fan made mix, incase anyone is looking for the original song its called 'headlights by eminen ft nate reus'..idk about the miley cyrus song

We all see life different when we get older.

probably the only rapper that has overwhelming emotion in his lyrics that you can FEEL

Just really feeling this song had to send it to my brother and my mom, dont realize how much u can't have someone in your life but still thank them for trying cause they did love you maybe just didn't know how, nobodys perfect but I thank my mom for not giving up no matter how fucked up she was cause my dad never was around shes getting older and I dont know but I want her to know i did appreciate her for what she did do. I wish things were better but this is our life and im thankful for what part of her i did have and hope for her a better life in the next one. I love u mom.

Eminem please never leave the mic. Gosh!!!

This song hits me on the level of a mother and sacrifices we make and being judged by our children. Beautiful song. I have no addictions, but I am raising my kids alone. Tough being the father and the mother.

That song is fkn deep!! My mom battled addiction. She didn't get clean until I was 22. Sober 2 years and then died. My brother wouldn't speak to her. He missed out on the 2 years she was sober. But I get it. It's hard. I miss her so much. She was around and a good mom when I was little. And then just snapped one day. Just gone. Not sure whats worse knowing what having a good mom feels like and having it ripped away or just not knowing at all. When she was sober 2 years I had my mom back!! 😢 I was angry at God like why! Then I realized one day that I had 2 years with her that I wouldnt have had if she would have died before she was clean. God gave me that breif gift. So many things I wanted to say and didn't and can't now. Thanks for this song. I listened to it atleast 6 times back to back. ❤ mad respect for you making this song for your mom man. Your music fans can honestly say you have helped us realize we are not alone. Dont ever feel like you dont have genuine fans out here ❤❤ because you really do. ❤

If this song doesn’t accurately describe how you feel about your parents from childhood to adulthood… idk what does…not understanding why they are the way they are but as an adult you understand cuz you been through shit in life. I have never cried listening to a song the first time and this put me to tears. This song hit different for me. Couldn’t relate more. 😢Eminem is back👌🏻

Em, it’s been a true honor watching you evolve through the last few decades,right before my very eyes, in real time. You are genuinely magnificent. Xxxooo

This song is great. I lost my mother and my grandmother in 2020 and I think of them all the time Even though my mom wasn't around I still love her and miss them both

This song had me ugly crying! My mom struggled with addiction. She died young at the age of 49 with the flu but I know her body was just tired.😢

MM sobriety has given you Health on all levels. Your insight has intensified, your compassion grows and you’re relatability deepens. I love your energy and sweet face. The pain I used to see in your young eyes has turned into hope. Your anger mitigated. I have much respect for you ‘Em.

You know it’s crazy. It’s like Eminem literally raps my life

I didn’t grow up with my mom and Just made peace with her last weekend sharing coffee at my house trading stories. This one hits right on the button. Needless to say she is going to finally meet her grandkids.

Mom is the 1 and only... Mom is my heaven... i love you Mom... ❤

Oh my goodness.... I can't tell you guys how much I relate to this. Such a real, emotional, and long overdue apology to someone you loved and but still resented so much for having weakness - only to grow up a bit and realize years later that it was illness. And while it may not change what happened, it at least puts a candle in place for healing through a new understanding of how things went..... Great song!

Lotsa people hurting out there we all should start treating each other with respect and love

To my only son. There’s nothing you could ever do that I wouldn’t forgive you for. I will love you forever.

You we're there to help us cope as kids and now you're back to help as adult kids heal once again. My mom and I are like you and your mom E. Thanks for showing us humility and that how we heal as kids is not so different than how we heal as adults.

I'm 45.. I realised that the pain never goes away.we can put it on the side for sometimes , but the pain never goes away....

Please all, life is too short to hate on your loved ones. Some of us might have a chance to apologize or forgive, but others won’t. If you’re lucky enough to, do it now before it is too late. Let love lead ❤❤

Actually balling 😭 So proud of him as a person fuck an artist. I've always loved him and what he's stood for. I hope one day to be as strong. 💚

For those of us who truly know how much he bashed on his mom & now him forgiving her publicly... it hits different

I'm happy he did this - it shows he's grown up and matured, his writing is more refined as well.

This song was so impactful.. I showed my sons. I named my youngest, Marshall, after you. We've had a tough life - but we stay close. I didn't want things to be like they are with my parents.. When you're real in these songs - you're real to all of us. Thanks for this music, Marshall and Miley. You're beautiful.

I love Eminem so much he is amazing and deserves everything that's good

Eminem has sang with some awesome artist in his life. Keep it up Eminem

EM, YOUR STARTING TO (TRY) TO FORGIVE, BUT FUCK ITS HARD , I FEEL YOU.

Miss u mom, see u soon, love u, R.I.P

You keep me alive. No joke. You're my god. This song is amazing cry😢

Wow This guy STILL has the ability to amaze a 47 y/o man who has always loved, understood and is thankful for Marshall. Nuff said. 😊

Whoever put this together actually did pretty good.

As a tear hits hard on my tablet, I say RIP momma...so many of us probably had that same tear. I hope this song will heal my broken heart of being the youngest, carrying the load on my shoulders getting beat down, thinking it was my fault. Wow Mathers thank you from the deepest part of my broken heart and my scarred soul

I had so many walls...so much rage... Impenetrable defences...all necessary...and my mom deserved them all... No weapon on this earth would have ever broken through them... Then came nem...no ax in hand... Just airing his own laundry and bareing his own heart...and wouldn't you know it as everything i needed (as usual with Nem)...and without raising a finger... He found his way in... Everything is melted...all the rage formed from pain...we are BOTH (me and my fortress) living in peace and unity FINALLY...as nothing but a puddle on the floor. THANK YOU Nem, thank you for ever, from every last piece of my shattered (but now FINALLY mendable) heart 💕

Been listening since 8 miles was released, I am 55 in may love him

Wow. Eminem has found God. What a beautiful repentance. His mother’s prayers have been answered. God bless you Em and Em’s mom. This made me cry.

It's good to hear Em having a healthy relationship with himself😢😮😊

Quand tu fais un son avec Eminem, t'as tout gagné dans ta carrière...

This was my life ..the original runs through me cold...this one hits hard it's just slower 😫 I miss my mom she's still sick but I pray one day...maybe ❤

Ele é perfeito em qualquer época.....❤❤❤❤ Ela sem comentários ☺️🍀🍀🍀

I loved the song. i just don't know why miley was in the video the way she was? This was about his mom, not about Miley being all sexy!! Just MY opinion. Just a thought 🌹⚘️🌹⚘️🌹⚘️🌹 i hope his mom does hear this song!

This song is so bittersweet and so beautiful. This artist has grown sooooo much.

I pray that he and his mom reconcile before she passes away and they have an opportunity to create new memories…It’s never too late to forgive, to be forgiven and to start again! Such a beautiful, heartfelt song. 🙏🏻

Thankyou marshall. for healing your mother issues.

My dad was physically and verbally abusive. I couldn't have any proper friends bcoz he let me lived his wishes and I quietly find my own world on substances and when he passed away on my 17th birthday I was already a full blown addict. Ever sence addiction disease has got me and seems to never leave me or I didn't really wished to quit idk....been cleaned and relapsed over and over again for decades but I still insist on getting out and be healed, find peace and make amends for my every wrong deeds and actions. I just couldn't forgive myself for having to do it at the first place and especially how I couldn't quit after knowing what it did to me and this hurts me more than anything else. Anyone out there struggling I wish you all the best in every steps. The sun shines still and hope still linger somewhere deep inside...so never give up upon yourself even if everyone does.

Im in tears. I have 3 boys who don't care if Im alive

After 2Pac, Em no doubt is the best rapper. Another master piece. 👍👍

God I felt this one forgiveness is essential love always wins

This song made me realize how beautiful Miley voice is.

Thank you, Marshall! I'm a sgl Mom from Southwest Detroit of an only Son, Sean...an up n coming Rapper in Detroit who got murdered in LasVegas, NV cut he wouldn't sell Asian china white. I didn't do dope, I did 60 hrs/wk work and took him to Vegas to get him outta of dope...we also left poverty. He played Beautiful for Mr, before he was murdered...thank you, Marshall...This Mom needed to hear you, Son! I love you and so did Sean!

This song is honest and beautiful. Honestly you make honest music that makes honest emotions. 💯🎶💪

This song is literally my life gives me chills down my spine I can’t stop crying I miss my grandmother so much and the love of my life and my family were all so broken rn I lost my daughter my sister possibly got raped by someone who took advantage of me and punched me in my face and I lost everything and made a beautiful blessing with a dead man

After all these years, he still is the artist who moves us on the deepest level. Brilliant and beautiful - - and - - I so appreciate his truthfulness.

Honestly the comments or the lack thereof are a reflection that we miss the old Em.

I've always loved Marshall!! I respect his history and his lyrics since day one!!

Miley so beautiful ❤

Awesome!! Just when u think......There you Are!!!; So proud of you Em?!! Keep being real !! You are very blessed my man!!! Word.. prayers and much love ❤❤

My non birth mom was never there. I grew up in a bad place. My children grew up loved and with roots to the community.

❤ Eminem you that I love this song. You and Miley Cyrus singing it. It's a great song. Keep up the good work you're doing and God bless you

Im sorry you and nathan were scared growing up. I can relate, I didnt have a father and my mother didnt like me since birth. Maybe try talking to her more because even from another side she probably still comes around you and Nathan. I dont know anything about your mom but Id bet she is sad seeing you 2 hurting and would make up for it if she could. I hope you keep healing.

Just lost my mom last October RIP mom 😢 I miss you so fuckin much 💙💚💙💚💙💚😎

Kocham Eminema za ten jego głos za to ile w tym emocji i wrażeń ❤ serducho od małego po dzis ❤

Love this big air hug to anyone been or going thru it i can honestly say just keep moving and be the best you! ❤

LYRICS OF THAT MASTERPIECE Eminem: I went in headfirst, never thinkin' about who, what I said hurt In what verse, my mom probably got it the worst The brunt of it, but as stubborn as we are, did I take it too far? "Cleanin' Out My Closet" and all them other songs But regardless, I don't hate you 'cause, Ma You're still beautiful to me, 'cause you're my Ma Though far be it from you to be calm Our house was Vietnam, Desert Storm And both of us put together could form an atomic bomb Equivalent to chemical warfare And forever we could drag this on and on But agree to disagree, that gift for me Up under the Christmas tree don't mean shit to me You're kickin' me out? It's 15 degrees And it's Christmas Eve, "Little prick, just leave" Ma, let me grab my fucking coat Anything to have each other's goats Why we always at each other's throats? Especially when Dad, he fucked us both We're in the same fuckin' boat You'd think that'd make us close (nope) Further away it drove us, but together, headlights shine And a car full of belongings, still got a ways to go Back to grandma's house, it's straight up the road And I was the man of the house, the oldest So my shoulders carried the weight of the load Then Nate got taken away by the state at eight years old And that's when I realized you were sick And it wasn't fixable or changeable And to this day we remain estranged, and I hate it though, but Miley: Pictures of you scattered on the floor I know you can't be here anymore But maybe if I keep your memories Than I might feel like you're still next to me Eminem: 'Cause to this day we remain estranged, and I hate it though 'Cause you ain't even get to witness your grandbabies grow But I'm sorry, momma, for "Cleanin' Out My Closet" At the time I was angry, rightfully? Maybe so Never meant that far to take it though 'Cause now I know it's not your fault, and I'm not makin' jokes That song I no longer play at shows And I cringe every time it's on the radio And I think of Nathan being placed in a home And all the medicine you fed us and How I just wanted you to taste your own But now the medication's takin' over And your mental state's deterioratin' slow And I'm way too old to cry, the shit is painful though But, Ma, I forgive you, so does Nathan, yo All you did, all you said, you did your best to raise us both Foster care, that cross you bear, few may be as heavy as yours But I love you, Debbie Mathers Oh, what a tangled web we have 'cause One thing I never asked was Where the fuck my deadbeat dad was Fuck it, I guess he had trouble keepin' up with every address Eminem: But I'da flipped every mattress, every rock and desert cactus Owned a collection of maps And followed my kids to the edge of the atlas If someone ever moved 'em from me That you coulda bet your asses If I had to come down the chimney, dressed as Santa, kidnap 'em And although one has only met their grandma once You pulled up in our drive one night As we were leavin' to get some hamburgers Me, her and Nate, we introduced you, hugged you And as you left I had this overwhelming sadness Come over me as we pulled off to go our separate paths and I saw your headlights as I looked back And I'm mad I didn't get the chance to Thank you for being my mom and my dad So, mom, please accept this as a Tribute, I wrote this on the jet, I guess I had to Get this off my chest, I hope I get the chance to Lay it 'fore I'm dead, the stewardess said to fasten My seatbelt, I guess we're crashin' So, if I'm not dreamin', I hope you get this message that I will always love you from afar, 'cause you're my mom Miley: Pictures of you scattered on the floor I know you can't be here anymore But maybe if I keep your memories Than I might feel like you're still next to me

I had tears with this one

They need to collab for real!!

Both of my favorite artist growing up in one song love it ! ❤️

So glad your mom got clean & you had those years with her . Everyone is battling some sort of addiction & depression these days. God works in mysterious ways. Stay Strong you have those memories to remember ❤

"...how I just wanted you to taste your own...!" Whoa! Those lyrics pierced me!

You never know how much you ❤them till there gone. Glad u gave her this even after it all was broken. My mom fought addiction to alcohol. My grandfather would get me outta bed 2 go bar 2 bar 2 find her bc I was only 1 she listen to .. weird right but she’s never judged me for my wrongs em ik ur story different but glad u had some healing ❤

If only these 2 🤩

Alot of female singers pairing up now with males its great I love hearing there songs done different with an added female tone to it or vice versa !!! He singing so angry and hers is so calm and soothing how odd together! I realize there is a story its just so odd to hear him so angry and then she comes on so calm and sultry like night and day

It's both sad and cathartic just how many people with whom this song resonates very personally. Not a Miley fan but her talent is undeniable.

The TRUTH is absolutely beautiful. In so many ways. Everyone can connect to the truth. The Lord has a purpose for every single thing and every single second of our lives. Bless these artists for sharing such a story.

Big name in the game 💪👌

This is so powerful emotional painful soft hearted love. I don’t know why I’m crying. Must be so hard for the people who relate 😔😢🫶🏼as I’m moved by this song

I'll be the first to say I was one of those problem child's and I thank my mother every day for it I've done everything known to man but she still believes in me. #momsarestrong

Oh this is really good. Their voices definitely compliment the overall sound of the song. I’ve gotten old enough to see Eminem mature. I hope they work things out while they have the time. Some songs just sound like the heart fell out onto the page- this is one of those songs.

Can't stop smiling while listening to this. Pure musical bliss!

Touches my soul

Hard to give love to someone not emotionally capable of returning it. Love them anyway!

Love conquers everything I believe, and I hope that is the case in each one of us...

I can totally relate to this relationship-I still hold on to troubled feelings even though she is gone. Issues never resolved

He has grown so much it's been interesting to watch from the 90s to now

Here we are! 25 years later! 🎉❤

Найкращі❤.Це щось неймовірне дає сенс до життя і вірити в краще.❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

To forgive is devine ❤ beautiful song, wouldn't have expected anything less from the Combination of the two... beautiful song 💝

Both incredible artists ❤

Это моя любимая песня навсегда!