I can't support Aria. I don't want to see non-Korean people in Kpop. A Kpop idol is an ethnically, racially Korean artist and performer who breaks into the music scene. Non-Korean people can't be Kpop idols. They are Pop singers who call themselves "Kpop idols" to profit from the Hallyu wave Someone like Rose, Wendy, Yongbok (Felix), Chan, Bae Jun Yung (Jacob), Moon Hyung Seo (Kevin), Son Young Jae (Eric), etc with a Korean ancestry who acquired non-Korean citizenship or nationality would still be ethnically, racially Korean and qualified for the Kpop idol position. Half Korean people like Huening Kai and Ju Hak Nyeon would be as qualified. According to my definition of Kpop, Black Pink, Black Swan, Exo, Enhypen, X:IN, GOT7, SEVENTEEN, NCT, TWICE, CLC, etc are Pop falsely labelled as Kpop to flow more swiftly across national boundaries, increase global competition and make more money in non-Korean countries People ask, "are you Korean?" If I said that I'm an Asian person of Korean ancestry, you would agree with me? They say, "non-black people can rap, non-Korean people can be Kpop idols" Non-black people appreciating rap, R&B, hip hop, jazz, etc, is different from non-Korean people breaking down Korea’s cultural traditions. The black people of today didn't "create" any music genres. Their ancestors did. They don't own their ancestors' "creations," and it's theft to pass them off as their own A moderate amount of music appreciation preserves the distinct cultures of the past. But the surge in the number of non-Korean people crossing into the Korean entertainment industry above traditional, moderate levels is transforming "Kpop" into something Korea won't quite recognize as its own. It's not a great thing My suggestion is to safeguard Korea's resources for ethnically Korean people. The present Korean entertainment industry should preserve for the talented people of Korean ancestry resources necessary for their growth Talented ethnically Korean people are finding it difficult to get a job and apply their skills to segments of their entertainment world. It's distressing to see non-Korean people stealing their jobs. Even more distressing is Korean agencies refusing to recruit, train, and retain available and willing talented ethnically Korean people. They have become blinded by money, favorably inclined toward gratuitous "globalization," and reliant on the less compliant, more high-maintenance non-Korean people I'm not saying that non-Korean people can't be "idols." Idols are celebrities. Anyone can be a celebrity anywhere. I'm saying that they can't be "Kpop" idols. They can't have the "K" in Kpop This is a massive deviation from the popular opinion, isn't it? I would welcome non-Korean people to the Korean entertainment industry within sustainable parameters. Homogeneity of the Korean ethnicity would be maintained for 99% of the groups. Most idols would be Korean, and few would be non-Korean. The non-Korean idols wouldn't call themselves "Kpop" idols. They would call themselves idols, celebrities, singers or performers. Then, Korean agencies would have incentives to work out alternative arrangements not so reliant upon non-Korean people They ask, "why should we international fans enjoy Kpop, even more importantly, pay for its performances?" Why not? Non-Korean people can support Kpop, and leave ethnically Korean people to sing and perform on stage. They can be involved partially, and not fully. Think of a fancy Asian restaurant that doesn't hire non-Asians. You would be welcome to visit and book a table. You wouldn't be welcome to get involved in the kitchen. You don't have to be a staff member (an idol) fully involved with food preparation (production and performance) to have a unique and enriching gastronomic experience (listen to Korean music)

I'd like to add that non-Korean people invading and dominating the Kpop industry raises concerns about authenticity and representation. It limits opportunities for Korean people to represent their culture and experiences on the global stage. The presence of non-Korean singers in Kpop dilutes the authenticity of the genre, making it less representative of the unique experiences and perspectives of Korean people. Pop music genres should remain true to their ethnic, cultural origins to maintain their authenticity It also raises the question of the role of the Kpop industry in promoting Korean culture and values. Invaded and dominated by non-Korean people, it's incapable of reflecting the unique cultural and artistic traditions of Korea. It's more focused on profit and commercial success than on promoting Korean cultural values. That's a problem Kpop is not just a musical genre, but a vibrant cultural phenomenon that transcends linguistic boundaries. A Kpop/Korean song can be primarily in another language (English, Japanese, etc) and still be a true embodiment of Kpop's spirit and essence, as long as it embraces Korean ethnicity/race

@@realistnightshade6300 yes i too belive korea is for Koreans not outsiders Like how my country is for my people

Aliya please mujhe bhi South koriya lekar chalo mujhe BTS se milta hai black pics milta hai tumse bhi mil gaya hai please please Mera jagah ka naam bol dete Hain rampurhat Bangali main girls hun lekar chalo yah Mera Vada hai Sapna Bangali mein bol sakti ho aur video only English

Kpop Idol don't try to " be cute" bruh dumba$$

Yes

Wdym? Trying to be cute? Korean idols are cute, indians are not

@@choco2753 facts

​@@MyB4llsHurt more like FAX

Yes ❤️

Согласна, она как глоток свежего воздуха

No one's hating on her stop spreading rumors.

@@syedarizvi89 huh u should stop if you don't know anything. I am active fanpage of her i know that. You should stop spreading false rumours.💀

@@Universe_is_calling haha you're childish

💀😭

She is super white broski

ikrr

Koreans doesn't know really what is india

​@@sunilkumarpsunilkumarp3724 really..... But how can u pls explain me 😊

2000 % 🗿✔️

Infinity ♾️

Yea true ❤

And she really love her mom❤😊

❤❤❤

@ariakpop2003 🤗🥰

she's good and everything but i felt like her rap was crap completely

@@pranjlisrivastava4872 how good are you in rapping?..

Me✋🏽❤❤❤

ЯЯЯ

I like aria and xin

I hope .. i work so hard to be a idol .. if i be a kpop idol ofcourse i will meet aria

Me ❤

Make a friendship

Me

Согли

Meh 🤢🤮

@@irneaa 👁️👄👁️ girl what meh🤢🤮 what does that mean

@@sarada_uchiha123 It's her way to say that she is pregnant in her jealousy and also mentally sick from Aria's success 🥱

also i think people were saying she doesnt look indian is fooled by her makeup which is very korean esque. but when she turns her face, her side profile gives away her "indian features" even if the front of her face may seem tweaked by her makeup

Mallu...❤‍🔥💜

Romanjamss😍

Malayali😍💜

@@priyadarshinipriya5317 💜💜mallu armies.... 🥰🥰

Evde poyalm oru Malayalee indaavmm

Caps

@@K-44BlackBumblebee u r not even from india.the people from kashmir is different from the people of tamil nadu.the people of punjab is different from the people of nagaland

That's why l said we have diversities. I am from the Northeast Indian state of Meghalaya. From the Garo tribe. Google it and you'll find that information atleast.

@@Aarushi261 Glad you do...

Very much Agree , in my opinion our ne brother sister has east Asians features they can debute in k-idol or pop too with more success rate potential. Btw 💕😘 from Siliguri ✌️🌟

Mostly people think dark tone Africans

They think all indians are either tamilians or Punjabis

@@coconut_cool how could Africans could be from asia U need good IQ

They are just jealous

thats why she doesnt fit to be a kpop-idol

I was thinking the same, hope it will happen soon 🤞

@@tejar1539 Hope so 🤞

Priyanka is not an kpop idol

@@sukanyadas8991 No she wasn't before...she was obviously a zpop idol...But now she is going to debut as a kpop soloist soon.

​@@manishasamal3874 Really? Congratulations to her then! I can't wait to see her debut ❤🥰

"She is SOO talented 😭😊" meanwhile her "tAlEnT" : 0

​​@@K-44BlackBumblebee every idols is considered as so called " TaLeNt" uk 😂

@@Aquaspirit247 Guess your "every Idols" translates to that indian girl because it's called so-called talent 😂

Girl she's not talented at all.

​​@@K-44BlackBumblebee For your kind information she is very talented. Before she did not get any lines to sing because she did not know Korean but now she gets so many lines because she speaks Korean well. She has improved a lot since her debut. Her stage presence, rap and dance has improved. Go and see her performance in her recent songs.

@@maxrockatansky5657 nobody cares. Old Bollywood is emotion.

​@@maxrockatansky5657 Then you are surely missing out a lot

@@epistolarydream_ I agreed about the old times.

@@maxrockatansky5657 okay, ur wish

@@maxrockatansky5657 you are missing real movies 👍😶

I think when ppl move to another country they try to adapt to the "look" there. Like makeup style, clothes, hair, manners. And the makeup that they do for the idol tends to highlight features that makes u more korean looking i guess.

I was just saying this to another viewer who was being critical of Indians looks. Indian civilians are beautiful. Love their features and various beautiful skin tones. ❤

файтин

She fits the korean beauty standard. She’s gorg

She is in korea for begging

keep on being a delulu

Да!❤

me to

She is a pure Southindian beauty. She is a Malayali like me

​@@smrithiparameshwaram6732 do you look like her?

@@smrithiparameshwaram6732 in the end she is from india.

Sab kuch sikhaaya hua hota hain bhai....yeh screen ki duniya kabhi bharosha nahi karna chahiye...

i havent seen a single hate comment

May be not here but if you see insta comments our indians are the one who actually hate her by saying she did plastic surgery and also some other groups fandoms too

Beautiful ? yes kind ? Not sure! All that glitters is not gold. Even the most rude people act humble in interviews no one in their sane mind would be rude during interviews so dont judge people based on their interviews that's the most fake process

@@saloni2244 being skeptical, may I ask you a silly question, do you believe in god? Because if you are truely a skeptical person, you shouldn't believe in anything you see or hear, not even in your memories,your decisions and your choices in your life, that's how you can be truely be the ideal skeptical person..

The problem with the world it counts only tamilians and Punjabis as Indians

Even her skin tone is kind of average skin tone for Indians. Some people are darker some lighter but on an average this tone is pretty common.

@@pikachuthunderbolt3919 bro what are you talking about? 👄 world only knows bollywood, curry and hindi if they're thinking about India. And Tamil community is well known cause Tamils are not only Indians yk?

Commented about how diverse we are and Yet u said Namaste at last💀

@@thehawkseye3412 It's average skin tone if there is bleaching cream on the counter....a heinous and toxic taboo.

She is from Kerala. My state.

Indian male k pop idol I coming

​@@PewdiepiefanUpdates oh really

When

Its character building

Malayali.

What's 'minyo' and 'salpurichum' Just curious 🤔

@@jenxxkxm9424 민요 is a style of folk singing that has slight differences of singing techniques from different regions in Korea and 살풀이춤 is a style of folk dancing that involves a long white piece of fabric.

not really without Aria their group is nothing.they are nobody and nothing in Korea.only hype around this group is being created by Indians and other South Asians.

Have you seen Chanty? Even she looks pretty. Even Aria is.

​@@Luvhee127 we never actually see her speaks English so maybe she doesn't speak English

​@@Luvhee127 she doesn't know English. She might know a few words not more than that.

I think that's coz her skin tone, figure etc. Matched with other members, who are foreigners. Edit:I'm not saying that her features are not common in India but brown is the most common color in India. Majority are different shades of brown, which looks typically Indian.

@@Pihu523 nah many Indians have same skintone like aria even me and my frnds have it and same figures they just doubting bc they are judging through their little knowledge.

The fact that you refer to people of color as "dusky" is what propelled this entire debate....and it saddens me.

@@gwynmcc I am not making them inferior by saying dusky. My own skin tone is dusky and I have zero problem with that. It's just general idea what people of other countries have that all Indians are dusky. I am just talking about them who categorise Indians by their skin colour.

@@gwynmcc I think it’s just Indian vocabulary.. do you think we Indian will call each other “people of colour”? I mean aren’t we all just poc😅.. so it’s like a shade card of beige and brown.. dusky, wheatish, fair are like vocabs that aunties use (trying to be polite but you know what they mean)

That’s also a stereotype. She is from south of India. Both north and south indians are similar

​@@NoRiceToEat she is from south India but she isn't a dravin blood she is an Aryan with her skin color u can tell

Everybody can tell she's indian too obvious.nobody doubt about it.

@@inyourdreams3816 It is basically the amount of melanin, UV exposure and genetics. Not uncommon to find dark skin tone in Northern parts of India too and lighter skin tone in Southern parts of India. Within an Indian community you will find range of skin tone variation.

​@@inyourdreams3816 lol who is aryan . No honey she is pure South Indian 😂 many Dravidian has lighter skin tone 😂

Sriya has already debuted. Blackswan will have their comeback on the 19th! Her teaser dropped yesterday. The MV was filmed in Odisha ❤

@@goldyd144 sorry and thanku i didn't know 🙃🙃

​@@goldyd144 wait where? I don't see it!? Can you give the link?

@@Pihu523 yeah I just saw em! Can't wait!

​@@goldyd144sriya is north Indian and this girl is from South. South is rarely represented save for Aishwarya Rai, Deepika podukone and padma laxmi who are from south

Yeah 💗😊

She already was a child actress.

@@Repeuh why not in india?