Irrespective of what views engineer sahib holds about Iqbal, my disappointment is on his soft presentation of socialist ideas. Iqbal was a public figure and not above criticism. But it takes people like me months to explain that Socialism/Communism is not compatible with Islam. Engineer sahib's soft comments about them contaminate the uninitiated minds. That he must stop! Lastly, I would again request to keep the disagreement within the bounds of decency.

قیصر بھائی نے آج ثابت کر دیا کہ انجینئر صاحب کی ہر بات پے آنکھیں بند کر کے عمل نہیں کرنا

واہ قیصر بھائی واقعی آپ اسلام کے بارڈر کے سپاہی ہے ❤❤❤❤❤❤

ہر مشہور آدمی علم والا نہیں ہوتا۔۔ انجنیئر اسکی اعلی ترین مثال ہے۔ جہلا میں سب سے مشہور عالم

قیصر بھائی انجینیئر صاحب تو بیٹھے ہی انہی کو سپورٹ کرنے کے لیے جن کے خلاف اپ نے علم جہاد بلند کیا ہوا ہے جزاك الله

تمام باتیں بہترین انداز میں دلیل کے ساتھ کہی گئی ہیں ۔ اللہ آپکی توفیق میں اضافہ فرمائے

There is such a huge gap we need to fix and this man is doing such a great job. Unless you know your enemy you'll never know how and when they'll strike.

اقبال کی باتوں کو سمجھنے کے لیے بندے کو پہلے ادب اور دوسرا علم میں گہرائی ہونی چاہیے وہ مرزا صاحب کے پاس ہے نہیں 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔

Please create a series on explaining all forms of "isms". It would be highly beneficial for everyone.

نہ وہ علمی نہ وہ کتابی وہ ہے بس پکا فسادی😮

Engineer’s understanding of philosophy, poetry in general and Iqbal in particular is so superficial and flawed he should just stop embarrassing himself at this point now. Years back when he made a video discussing Rumi and regarding his allegorical stories as facts completely exposed his understanding of poetry, literature and art.

Ulema, Scholars of modern sociology and Real educated people, all are going against Mirza. Its only because he has no real knowledge of anything, but half baked knowledge of things he thinks he is an expert of.

Qaisar Sahab you are one of the most eloquent speakers I listen to these days. I am totally inspired by how you deliver your ideas and present your case against this swarm of athiesm, lgbtq, and secularism agenda. I have been learning alot from you. May Allah give you Jaza e Khair and allow us to learn from you even more.

Still engineer sahab's students are pretending to avoide these flaws😁.

Allah subhan tala qaiser bhai ki zindgi mein barkat karay Ameen

I love the Ali bhai the way he explain Islam to us but disappoint him in secularism... qaiser bhaii is right and Ali bhai have to take backstep..

You are very knowledgeable and respectable qaiser sir. I wish people like you exist more in Pakistan. The dream of making Pakistan a developed country all over can be fulfilled when people like you come forward and inspire people from their views and ideas. Your brother from India 🇮🇳

The problem with Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza is that he pass judgement and interfere on fields outside of his own...His field is Sectarianism and he is good at it which benefits Muslims but he is causing issue interfering in the field of Political Sciences and Philosophy by passing irresponsible and problematic judgement. He should realise he hasn't undergone formal training in this field to develope enough understanding and critical thinking ability to pass judgement on Islamic basis!

One line to say" Not everyone is completely right or false"

We need more Personalities like QAR ❤

One man army May Allah bless you SIR❤

I have come to conclusion that it's a waste of time to explain engineer sahab and his followers.. when we point out at the danger engineer sahab is doing thier ego is being hurt

Salam Qaisar bhai ... yar you are doing a great job masha Allah. i'd say 95% of our public are not fully aware of these "isms" that you're intellectually refuting, hence, i'd suggest if you can start a youtube series on these "isms" i.e. introduction of these ideologies for "dummies". This can go in parallel with the debates that you're having but i think educational content will be more useful and impactful for the general public to be able to fully get the context of your debates and ability to connect the dots. Pls look into it. Thanks

Engineer has an habit to speak whatever comes to his mouth and he spends many days then to prove him right! He's a joker!

انجینیر کو ویسے ہی شوق ہے ہر معملے میں ٹانگ اٹکانے کا، حالانکہ علم سے اکثر محروم ہی پایا گیا ہے۔ پتا نہیں لوگ متاثر کس بات سے ہو جاتے جب کہ قیسر راجا بھائی کی دلیل میں دم ہوتا ہے۔ مرزا ان کے سامنے جواب سےعاری دکھائی دیا

اصل دکھ تو اِس بات کا ہے کہ انجینئر انتہائی قطعیت ،نخوت اور اعتماد کے ساتھ اِقبال کے اشعار کو اسلام کے خلاف قرار دیتا ہے کہ جیسے اُس سے سمجھنے میں کوئی غلطی ہو ہی نہیں سکتی ۔ انجینئر معذرت کے ساتھ ایک مغرور آدمی ہے ۔

All those people commenting on his posts and admiring him. I want to clear one thing. I’ve seen all that podcast and the later review video Mr. Qaiser did to show his disagreements for Engineer Mirza Ali. The thing is, He’s just defaming him for the sake of his disappointments and disagreements. Our Islam also not teaches us to stick to just one point and create a fuss over it. In the podcast, Sir Qaiser said that he had just some disagreements while in majority of his POVs align with him (Eng Ali). So, in the behalf of some points, he’s starting a controversies. What else he doing rather than making the argument longer? In my opinion, everyone has right to hold disagreements and their opinions to themselves and not to make a conflict just for it. And as per the Title of the video suggests, its all about the socialism and Allama Iqbal. I don’t think that’s a more valuable topic in which his perception should be align with yours. Because our Islam has no relation with Iqbal’s perspective. Yes, he’s a great philosopher. We should just take him as that rank not more than that. So please, Its better to just keep this issue within you and him (privately) and not make us think that you’re doing this for popularity or something else. I respect your opinions too, I’m not a supporter of Ali Mirza but as per a Human and Muslim, I don’t appreciate this way of making videos on someone with whom you have contradictions. Thanks!

Assalamoalaikum. This is the first time i have seen any of your videos. Wonderfully spoken Qaiser sahab.. آپ کے 'ممدوح' کو شعر اور شاعری سے بھی اتنا ہی علاقہ ہے جتنا کہ سوشلزم لبرل ازم اور دیگر مغربی فلسفوں سے۔۔ والسلام ، ڈاکٹر عفان اکرم

Dua to Fix all your family issues: رَبَّنَا هَبْ لَنَا مِنْ اَزْوَاجِنَا وَذُرِّيّٰتِنَا قُرَّةَ أَعْيُنٍ وََّاجْعَلْنَا لِلْمُتَّقِينَ إِمَامًا اے ہمارے رب !تو ہمیں ہماری بیویوں اور اولادوں سے آنکھوں کی ٹھنڈک عطا فرما اور ہمیں پرہیزگا روں کا امام بنا۔ Our Lord! Grant us from among our wives and offspring, comfort to our eyes and make us an example for the righteousness. (Al-Furqan:74)

I am a scholar of political philosophy from Kashmir, India. To establish Islamic law in any nation-state in Muslim country first sects have to go away otherwise secularism is the only option to survive. If Ali Mirza is of this opinion, he speaks sense rather common sense.

The way you clarify the things is just admirable😊😊

Mashallah well needed clip keep on spreading dawah

I must appreciate the way Mr. Qaiser talks,... and his research work is also commendable...keep that up

My God! this my first video of Qaiser bhai and I'm truly impressed. In fact, this is very first Pakistani/Urdu video I saw on yt that's like those English videos of our muslim brothers in the west doing dawah work. now, why does this channel has only 60k subscribers? this is bad, are we only using youtube for buck bhai n t-series??

Great.....Qaiser Ahmad.great.. Jo bnda IQBAL ko smjhtta hai wo ... Ap ki tarah intelligent or sahebe farasat hi hotta hai.... جب عشق سکھاتا ہے آداب خود آگاہی ۔ کھلتے ہیں غلاموں پر اسرار شہنشاہی ۔ اقبال ۔ 💯♥️

Sir your way of talking and arguing is very well but Engineer sahab will never leave his arrogance and popular way of just doing disagreement without any logic and facts.

You are agreeing in the video that Karl Marx was against capitalism. The point he was emphasising was that karl max ideology brought revolution and iqbal was impressed by that. Iqbal or any person can be wrong in certain ideologies.

Coming here after watching review of Mufti Rashid Mehmood on your Podcast !!

This is my first ever comment on any video, I just want to share few points jo mjhe mirza se related bohat bother krte hain, yet he has a great fan following, but still he really don't even know how to talk, ye banda har cheez may apne apko oper lanay ki koshish krta hy k mjhe sb kch pta hy or baki sb log jahalat ki zindagi guzar rahay hain, is k lehje may bohat sakhti or gharoor ki jhalak mehsoos hoti hy isi liye kabhi may sochta hu k iske followers b shayad aese he hain jo facts and figures ki basis pay koe baat nae kr skte, any ways qaiser bhai i really appreciate the work you're doing, I really wish k Allah pak mjh nacheez se b apne deen ka koe kaam lay lay, or jo bhatak rahay hain unhe hidayat de, ameen

Engineer wo bacha hai jo logo ke gharo ki bell baja kar bhag Jaya karte hai

Qaiser bhai Essi tarah videos banaya karain jis mai socialist, liberals, Atheist logon ki quotation reference show ker kay jawab dain.

Mashallah ,qaiser bhai ko pta hai kaise ikhtelaaf krte kisee baat pe jb koi ki glti ho to ,na uspe kufr fatwa,aur uske baaki islam quran sunnat liye kam ko support !!bs jispe ikhtelaf us baat pe oppose krte ❤ This is the true way ,every other firqaparast have to learn from qaiser bhai 💖

"In the country of the blind, the one-eyed mirza is king"

Bohot Zabardast qaiser bhai ❤

Qaiser bhai maine ap ko aj 2sri baar suna haa ap MashAlllaHhh bohat acha bolty Hein Andaaz ur adab k daairy ma reh kr Baat krnaa ap ka passand Ayaa Alllah qabol Farmyaa...

Dear QAR You are doing absolute work against Fitna may Allah give you reward for all your efforts I also want to contribute through videos. I am going to make videos too you inspired me.

Qaisar Bhai har insaan har field me master nahi hota aur Ali bhai jaise agar kahi galti kare to mashallah aap jaise schooler bhi maojood hai usko sahi karne ke liye qaiser Bhai Allah aapki hifazat kare AAP bahoth achcha kaam kar rahe hai

He has to be unique, so he has to diagree on every topic.... I swear by Allah, being a college student, i never mind mirza sb because according to me he has that little knowledge which makes him to noise louder.....

Qaisar Bhai i watch your content a lot , but dont you think that you also did a podcast review and after that Engineer made video but in this video you are claming that after podcast people will decide and Engineer made a video again but actually it was you and your team did the video with some nasty comments on him , so definately he will respond like you make this respond video to his response video

اللہ پاک سے دعا ہے کہ اللہ پاک ہمیں"پلمبر مِرزا، جاوید غامدی اور ساحل عدیم" کے فتنے سے تمام مسلمانوں کو محفوظ فرمائے، آمین اللہ پاک اِن فتنوں کو چُن چُن کر ہلاک فرمائے آمین

This happens when some ignorant plamber tries to intervene in world of poetry and litrature 😂

Allah App ko Lambi Lambi Umer AAta Fermaaye

Mashallah qaiser bhai ❤

Engineer sahab ko sunte huye aik arsaa ho chuka hai..... Aur abb main iss nateejay per pohncha hon k Engineer sahab ko urtaa teer lene ka shok hai!😊

Jo haalat aaj Qaiser bhai ki ho rhi, same yei halat hmari b hoti when it comes to religious issues... Mirzay ka jo dil krta wo bolta, jesay dil krta ahaadith mein garbar krta, or aam bnda smjhta k wao kya deen ki aalaa baat kr d hei... Allaah isko wo dey jo yeh deserve krta hei, or Allaah is fitnay sey hmari jaan churaaey... Jesi understanding iski in topics pr hei, us sey b zyad gai guzri deeni topics pr hei...

Evil eyes off. Raja sahab ap ki bht zberdst contribution ha islam ko save kerny ma. ❤ bht duayn hain apky liye. Allah apki bht hogai at keryn.

brother mujhe honestly aaj tak mirza ka purpose samajh nhi aya, what is he trying to do, ummah ka time and khud ka time waste karne ke alawa kya kaam kar rahe hain??? he seems to be beating about thw bush with no specific purpose

Sir ji. U R great . I m 💯 Agreed with you..

Engine Mirza is one of the latest fitna today and qaiser Ahmad raja is a wise man and true ashiq e Rasool

video link not available in card for ex socialist

Mashallah a very good response from u. It seems that Engineer sahab feels like he has to give his opinions on matters that he doesn‘t fully understand and the sad part is that once he gives his opinion he won‘t allow himself to be corrected because he thinks that retracting some false opinions is a sign of weakness

जिन logo ये भी नहीं पता की ये मसला क्या है wo jahil log bhi engineer के खिलाफ bhok रहे हैं 😂😂😂😂

Mashallah love you qaiser bhai..mai ek aalim aap ke lecture sunte rehta huu allah aapko mazeed trqqi ata farmaye

Engineer is, unfortunately, blinded by his fame and following! His arrogance has made him think he is infallible...

Iqbal is a great philosopher.

Bilkul sahi kaha qaisar bhai aap ne

ALLAH PAK APKO STRENGTH DEN, SIR AMEEN SUCH AN INTELLECTUAL ANSWER, WITH ALL RESPECT😍😍😍

Qaiser ahmed raja sb ❤❤

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉ماشااللہ صحیح باند کرنا قیصر بھائی 🎉

دنیا کے پہلے قاتلانا حملے دیکھیں ہیں۔ جس میں کوئی سوئی سے حملہ کرتا ہے کوئی پیاز کاٹنے والی چھری لا رہا ہے۔ اور وہ بھی دور دور سے۔ 😂😂😂

Qaisar bhai ap boht acha❤ kaam kar rahe hain Allah SWT apko Jaza e khair ata kare Aameen Ya Rabbul Alamin

Love u qaiser bhai,❤

Masha Allah well explained brother Allah save you for every evil eye

According to qaiser sir if you are praising someone on a particular act it means you are endorsing him in all his aspects. Kis ketab mei lekha hai ye?? If you closely follow the poetry Sir Iqbal is praising Karl Marx in that one particular aspect, nothing wrong about it

انجینئر صاحب علم و عقل سے پیدل ہیں ۔۔۔اللّه سمجھنے کا حوصلہ دے ۔۔۔۔۔۔۔

Salam, Mash'Allah a very positive way of putting forth your criticism. I'm looking forward to your series on socialism and communism to better understand this issue. As far as Iqbal sb goes it doesn't really matter if you are or Ali Bhai is right about him. My source of religious knowledge is based solely on the Quran and Sunnah alhamdulillah. JazakAllah kher

It's really disappointing to see someone go to another person's home as a guest, ask for a podcast, and then come back to laugh at him (Phaka). If you had questions or concerns during the podcast, why not engaged at that time instead of resorting to ridicule ? Aur rahi baat iqbal ki tw If he was that competent the nobel prize would have been given to him instead of rabindranath tagore. Even his own late son Javed Iqbal denounced the mighty claims that you connect to his father but you are insisting to hold him as a noblest of Muslims that ever lived.

قیصر بھائی مرزا اساب اس مٹی کے بنے ہیں کہ جو کچھ انکے منہ مبارک سے نکل گیا وہ حرف آخر ہے چاہے مرزا ساب کو کتنے اچھے الفاظ سے کوئی سمجھا لے یا سخت الفاظ میں ان پر رد کرے، کبھی اپنی غلطی پر رجوع نہیں کر تے بلکہ اس پر جہالت کے ساتھ ڈٹ جاتے ہیں، بھلے ان سے اپنی اس بات کا دفاع ہو یا نہ ہو، اور مرزا ساب کے بھکتوں کا یہ حال ہیکہ جو کچھ مرزا ساب نے بک دیا وہ انکے لئے قرآن و حدیث ہے، اس لئے آپ اس مرزا کی جان چھوڑیں دو آدمیوں نے مرزا کی دکان پوری طرح بند کردی ہے ایک مفتی طارق مسعود دوسرے قیصر بھائی آپ نے وہ پوڈکاسٹ کرکے ❤❤❤❤

Engineer is just exposing his grave ignorance

Muhammadu rasoolallah jesa hai hi koi nai Ashraf ali rasoolallah ta shai hi koi nai

مرزا اور علم میں بہت فرق ہے

Qaiser sahab❤😍

11:40 Sir baat ye hai key un ka ye point tha key For Example Aik banda Hitler sey mutasir hai aap kahey key Nahi Wo Genghis Khan Sey mutasir they Tu Maqsad Wahin Ka Wahin Hai dono ney galat kiya dono galat hai asal main baat ye hai key mutasir hi galat bandey sey they

Looking for "MashaAllah, well needed clip" 🤣

Ak podcast mufti Rashid Mahmood Sy krlein regarding firqa wariat

راجہ صاحب Thanks for the great and sweet response. مگر جس طرح آپ نے یہ کہا کہ یہ آپ کی فیلڈ نہیں ہے اسی طرح سارے مسالک کے علما بھی کہہ رہے ہیں وہ اسکی فیلڈ نہیں ہے. اگر ہوتا تو ضرور اسے کوئی گروہ ضرور گلے لگاتا. جس طرح آپنے اس کی باریکی کو سمجھ لیا، اسی طرح دین کی باریکی ہے،

Allah apko salamat rkhe

Overall Great Qaiser Raja bhai..

Much appreciated brother 🎉

Sir qaiser ahmad sahb before you mein engineer muhammad ali mirza ko sunta tha i was like k har waqt onke hi videos deikhna theek hei k onhoin ne kkafi ache kaam kiye but mujhe yei feel hone lga k wo thore over ho rahe hein like insert karna molivoin ki am still defend him on the field of firqa but mujhei yehi feel hota tha k wo thore zyada qareeb hein seculrism k but apki podcast mein mujhe sun kr boht afsos hoowa k onhein seculirsm ka matlab bhi ni pta tha sorry to say but yei mere dill ki baat thee or i think yei bettre hoga k hum madrisoin mein nuqs nikalne ki bjayei apne islam ki hifazat krein khas tor par Indian Muslims ki awaz othayein

Phala ma music or movies dakh k sota tha Aj kl EMAM k videos or podcasts sun k sota hu❤❤❤❤ Ekhtalaf apni gajha ,EMAM one man army to Han bahi..... Chota mota opinion k difference to hota he ha , duniya ma har ek Banda ko khush thoda he keya ja skata ha❤❤❤

Sir I think aap apna point sahi sey nahi bta paa rahey aap kehtey hai key "Karl Marx" Human Rights key khilaf tha aur dosari jga jahan "Iqbal" ney "Karl Marx" ki Tareef ki wahan aap Iqbal ko Defend kar rahey hai I Mean Main Samjhney sey Qasir hon aap ki baat ko

Bohut khoob Qaiser bhai!

اقبال جیسا ہے کوئی نہیں۔ مرزا تے شے ئی کوئی نہیں۔

JAZAK-ALLAH KHAIR BHAI

Raja sahab you seems knowledgeable person, i like your way explaining thing. I just want to say you respectfully that you are on wrong track. Suggest you a book and reconsider your opinions again " A Refined Explanation of The Sanusi Creed - The Foundational Proofs by Shaykh Said Foudah"

Engineer Md. Ali Mirza has half of a knowledge about mazhab. He is totally ignorant about poetry, philosophy, communism, socialism and other idealogies. You are giving him undue importance about Iqbal and his philosophy.

Thank u sir wanted u to respond to this video :)

I wish Engineer sb never surrender to your school of thought. You need to learn to accept and acknowledge the difference and focus on your tazkiya e nafs. Danda le kr hr aik k pechay pr janay se phlay apna mohasba bht zruri hai. Bht se log apni apni capacity me den ki khidmat kr rahay hai. Sb ko apna kaam krnay dein. Ap apna kaam krein. Ironically you are making people rebel and revolt against conservative thought. It feels like a matter of ego and not ideology. Baqi dilo k haal Allah bhtr janta hai.

Have you wrote any book on these ism's?? If Yes then plz tell their names.