"this movie could have been dialogue free and still made the same amount of money" Funny enough, Wall-E, the first time I saw that was in french, couldn't understand a word of it but could understand the entire run of it and what was going on, it basically was dialogue free for me and my eyes were glued for hours and I paid for the experience I rewatchd it in English and still got the same experience

I know this movie is trash and all, but the *biggest* sin it has is forcing the fact that the Major is "beautiful". In the original, the Major uses the cheapest and most common body you can find on the market, it's described as borderline ugly and usually used by the lower class. This leads to some pretty trippy scenes where you can see other people using the same body in the background, specially in scenes when they're in the slums. This not only trimmed the production cost a little, but was also way more deep and meaningful.

When you said: "something that has never been explored before in the terminator, the matrix, ex machina..." actually Ghost in the Shell 1995 was actually the first one to come up with that concept and from there the matrix took inspiration even the director of the matrix when he was making the matrix showed his producer the ghost in the shell 1995 anime and said he wanted something like that

This movie did everything bad that I expected Hollywood to do to the source material. So bravo to Hollywood I suppose for at least being completely consistent.

"It's like this movie put Blade Runner, The Fifth Element, and Attack of the Clones in a blender, added Pop Rocks and Diet Coke, smashed it with a baseball bat, then f*cked it." I have never heard a more accurate description of something in my life.

It feels like this movie wanted to be be two or three different movies and it all got mixed together.

I'll tell you what I couldn't stop paying attention to during this film: ScarJo's weird ass posture/walk.

"My programmer Liam Neeson told me so"... Deaad😂😂

LMAO!! "The ads are all for cybernetic enhancements, how are people going to be reminded to drink a coke??"

When u do the emoji movie: 1) 1000 sins bcuz it exists 2) Bonus round sin *1000 every time an emoji appears

The moment that "i will find him" line came out of major. i knew there was going to be a taken reference. lol

"To officially become a sentient human, you must ingest a massive dose of LSD" You know, that's pretty accurate

Everything Wrong With Ghost in the Shell (2017): It is a raw cash grab riding the fame of a classic movie.

This movie looks like shit as compared to the Anime but looks pure gold as compared to other Anime movie Adaptations 😅😅

As a friend of mine said it as we were leaving the cinema. "It was a reminder of a better movie." I should rewatch the originals.

6:15 I agree. The original was much more interesting. Seeing the different versions of The Major's model and how built up everything was made you think about a few things like identity, etc.

The thing I hate the most about this movie is its divergence from the original philosophy of the movie. Things like asking if what makes us human holds us back, and if that is a bad thing or not, being replaced for a movie that is mostly about "EVIL" coporations like every other dystopian piece of fiction is just not right.

This movie was quite disappointing. It took everything from the original that was good, threw it out, and tried to be original and failed in the process. Check out Nerdwriter1's video about how to not make a remake. Its fucking awesome.

I liked this video just for the line "Do fish even need advertising?" I hope there are more sins like that in the future.

"you were not autorized to deep dive the geisha" - "yes I was ! I paid a 100 bucks" xD nice one

An HOUR AND 15 MIN -- I mean ONE MINUTE AND 15 SECONDS OF LOGOS made me laugh my butt off

I can't thank you enough for bringing out the major differences between the original and the live action remake. Makes so much sense to why the remake felt so weird when watching it

Yea-aww

I just hate how they beat you over the head with the plot OVER and over , hand holding you. Telling you who is who, what's going on , who's the bad guy, why this is important . OVER Explaining lines or metaphors. The original never did this , it knew it's viewers were functioning conscious adults lmfao

Next video: Everything wrong with sharknado, in hopefully less than 50 years!

Every thing wrong with cinema wins

Forgot one sin - where was no Tachikoma. I was waiting all movie to see it

Ghost in the Shell is my all-time favorite anime and this MOVIE JUST UGH GODDAMNIT ALL

Why is the lie detector connected to the internet? Hey, we live in a world TODAY where they're trying to force you to hook up your juicier to the internet or it won't run.

This movie was dumbed down for the American Audience, and that's a fact. FUCK I was in the theater and someone actually thought this was a Marvel movie..smh.

"Discount Tropic Thunder Jack Black." I died.

5:13 "You know, for a story that's supposedly set in Japan, there's VERY little Japanning happening" Hong Kong: Am I a joke to you?

i saw the original 1995 version when i was very little with my dad, the part where she ripped off her arms fuck me up man.

so the company trying to fill Majors head with fake memories and erase her actual identity are supposed to make her robot body look exactly like her original one? Doesn't it make more sense that they would change as much as possible to distance her from her true self?

"this movie suppose to locate in Japan" *Internationale Commerce center locate in Hong Kong appear in the background* lol, k

if they'd just followed the anime movie to the teeth, would've been perfect

If you feel like you sin movies in the theaters imagine how this guy feels when hes just trying to watch a movie.

Please do the Netflix live action "Death Note".

I really don’t understand why people complained so much about “white washing”. She literally looks EXACTLY like the anime character this was based on. And the Japanese loved the movie. Being as Ghost In The Shell CAME from there, I think their opinion of it holds a hell of a lot more weight then we do 🤷🏻‍♂️

Ok you can dislike the story and characters as much as you want but the aesthetics and general visuals were absolutely phenomenal.

When are they gonna roast the Sir Patrick Stewart out of The Emoji Movie?

Don't mind me. I'm just using my magic to find the legendary Clorox bleach. Still no sign of him on youtube for the last few weeks.

It's so weird how they got rid of cyberizing, was such a cool creepy concept in the anime. And how do they explain thought comms and Major uploading her consciousness if they aren't cyberized? Just technology I guess lol

Seeing this hurt me a lot more than I thought it would, and here I thought I might one day give this remake a chance. This makes me realize this remake is much worse than I imagined even after having had a lot of the changes described to me prior. I'm going to go rewatch the original again and pretend this never happened.

12;44 If we can say one thing about this movie, it's that they made Aramaki a kick-a gunslinger. XD I think they should have based the movie on the animated series and got it as close to the show as possible. They can't touch a classic like the movie, but they could have possibly pulled off that cyber-punk Law and Order: SVU vibe.

MY PROGRAMMER LIAM NEESON SAID SO IM GAGGING

I loved the fact that originally you didn't know if the major was truly Male or Female as she was under classified information due to the nature of the department she was asigned to plus the experiment of full cybernetic augmentation. I felt the reason why the Major preferred the female body was no would suspect a woman to do the things she does, lighter and more agile than any male form and finally the creator was nothing but a naughty person who loved the female form.

Her strength didn't really come out of nowhere, in the water fight scene she kicked him several feet and she's built to be a soldier, is super strength _that_ unexpected?

Hey, Jeremy, is the director Kong: Skull Island still having a hissy fit.

The Major keeps referring to being "designed" and "built". I'll admit it's been a while and I committed the cardinal sin of watching the english dub, but I'm pretty sure she was still a human consciousness in a full prosthetic body. Why is she talking like an AI? *sin ping*

I dont understand why people dont like this movie Its one of the best live action adaptations I've seen. Some just like to complain I guess

Went to the cinema to see this with a friend. It's the only movie I have ever walked out of before. There were 16 people in the cinema at the beginning. I left after just over an hour (inc. adverts and trailers) and there were 7 people left when I went.

You need to do an EWW Kings of Summer. Jordan Vogt-Roberts is pretty much asking for it at this point...

Pretty much expected this film to take a dump on the original. Thank you for confirming so I don't have to waste 2 hours of my life to watch it. Cinemasins providing an important public service :)

I searched "Ghost In The Shell ANIME", and the most of the videos are about this film. That shows how much you love this film. Digit tells.

The worst line in the movie: "My name is Major."

Last time I was this early the floor was still the goddamn floor

Kuze's voice is so fucking cool

Another version of "Martha."; " Why did you say that name"

All the CGI in the world can't save a dull story line.

I like how he gives it a sin for being like the matrix when the matrix was inspired by the ghost in the Shell lol

*THIS MOVIE SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN MADE !!!* Maybe studios might finally learn not to fuck around with classics ............ probably not.

Seeing the utter greatness that is Takeshi Kitano here is like a stab through the heart.

This, Attack on Titan, Fullmetal Alchemist and Death Note are all testaments to why anime doesn't work in Live action. Dragonball Evolution too

Seriously? Not one reference to the Black Widow hallway scene from Iron Man 2?

I was in this film as a featured extra. I played three different characters and you can spot me in a scene (yay). Thing is 2 of the three scenes I was in were cut from this film and I think that is the problem with this film is the studio cut the shit out of it as Jeremy rightly said to dumb it down. This could have been soooo much cooler and having met Rupert Sanders the guy was really cool, not arrogant and very approachable (bear in mind I was just a lowly extra though he still took the time to chat with me about a shot I was in which I found rare, his willingness to talk to a pleb like myself, I mean the conversation did start with me telling him that the shot was f&*king amazing, but still we chatted for a few minutes, very rare for big shot directors). Anyway, my point it, like David Arye on Suicide Squad, I feel for Mr Sanders as I could see the love he had for what he was making, I saw some of his vision, then I saw this pile of shit and I knew the the studio would have cut the f*&k out of it. I wouldn't judge the director on this, I would however tell the studio to fuck the fuck off, stop dumbing down movies and allow the audience to think for themselves, movies aren't tv where we a constantly reminded of shit, movie are there to challenge and make people think, studios don't like people thinking. Anyway, thats my little rant, cue the haters and people to flame me for whatever reason.

"Thanks, Batman" Ahahahhaha I knew it

15:31 that was the point. She threw the consent lie back into Cutter’s face.

Was it a dumb movie? Yes. But Major wasn't white-washed good dammit. In the anime she was deliberately generic, fitting no race. She was using a cheap common body model, and it played into the whole question of individuality and soul that was the whole driving theme of the anime

Seriously, what killed this movie for me, was the change from the original plot-line. I literally walked out of the theater after the first 10 minutes of trying to swallow this garbage.

MAJOR IS NEVER MEANT TO LOSE HER COOL LIKE EVER

After watching the anime version just a few hours ago... Watching this finally... Boy the live action is painful.

also all the movies you reference as it being derivative of are derivative of the original anime this movie is based on

people should stop trying to adapt anime, its always shit

Biggest issue for me: This movie is "meant" to be a prequel, but still copy/pastes scenes from the original. That and it was made in first place. I hold this film in the light as Wolverine: Origins. Holy shit, is that Takeshi Kitano? minus 10 sins. He is a legend!

11:00 I was so happy to see this scene, cause i really thougt there will be the epic dialogue/monologue like in the original....but then....well...chit-chat :( It was such an important scene in the original.

Did you know that Sony Pictures now have ownership of Funimation studios so we have alot more of subpar adaptations of anime for the cinema going public

6:30 It‘s pretty common to understand a language without being able to speak it fluently (for me with Italian and Dutch), so not a sin. Also both may be wearing Star Trek style translator devices that translate into their language whatever the other guy says.

People bitching about the whitewashing obviously know nothing about the original writer of the manga. She's supposed to be americanized... ffs. Still going on 2 years later.

Alright, I hate the dialogue I hear in this movie of a series I fucking love. I need to watch this movie now to confirm that my hate isn't just being shaped by Jeremy's Cynicism. I will be back.

Now it's time to wait for Rupert Sanders to have a meltdown on twitter.

The fact you didnt make a Max Headroom reference is a sin in itself.

I enjoyed this movie. The major is a trained soldier... That's why she walks the way she did. Also, if you watched the original anime, it was about the philosophy of the self, which in a different way, so was this movie. The matching scenes from the movie and the original are gifts for actual fans.

BTW any of you thinking "why didn't they get an Asian actress to play Major to be more culturally accurate?" Even in the original manga and anime, the android her consciousness is in is supposed to resemble a more European person. Dunno if anyone asked that but thought I'd just share that

Michael Pitt was in a wayyy better existential flick back in 2001: Hedwig and the Angry Inch. Y'all go watch that instead, aiight?

> Complains about unnecessary use of stealth camo >> Complains about character becoming visible again exactly one sin later >>> What do you want from us? Signed, the league of invisible people

I mean the thing with Major is she is a mass production android body (this is true in all GitS media), of course she won't look like herself. It's a rough movie and very shallow but they did at least consider some of these things

When they only concentrate on the visuals and completely forget what the movie was about...Sure just slap on a generic plot.

"Thanks batman!" 😂😂

This is the best anime adaption I ever seen

"American movie has white characters, Indian movie has Indian characters, water is wet and the sky is blue. The world is outraged at such a blatant injustice. More at 12."

I notice that your thumbnail has rounded corners. Nice.

Let's see how much Controversy this one manages to create and how whiny this director is

The Rupert Sanders joke is brilliant!!

One thing I always loved about Ghost In The Shell, is there was no love story. Everyone always wants to turn shit into a giant love interest, I get so sick of having awesome expositions, amazing fights, funny banter, and everything else being replaced with sex scenes and people being lovey or even like lame pointless wifey hubby nonsense. It’s nice to give the sex and romance a break. And that’s one things that Americans always do. They make everything revolve around an edgy love story.

Where is rogue one?

15:49 is that doge in the background?!!?!

"Also, maybe next time you could design me a little more culturally appropriate." Dude, in both the original anime and SAC The Major is said have a Caucasian appearance, even the original creator of GITS said that Scarlett Johansson would've been perfect for a live-action Major.

Everything wrong with Ghost in the Shell: Everything

"Y'know, for a story that's supposedly set in Japan, there's VERY little Japanning happening..." Exactly how is Japan supposed to look in a technological future? I guess you're right, the cities in this movie look so much more like Rock Island, Illinois than they do Tokyo...