here's my weird perception: everything perceived as major and cheerful creeps me out - while everything in minor, sad, and anguish... I find it soothing, genuine and peaceful

Wonderful!!! Chopin and you!!!❤❤❤, thank you

Incredible video man - loved listening to this. My teacher just handed me this nocturne so I’m doing some research on it to fuel my interpretation. Loved this video - Thankyou :)

Thank you so much. I started playing the piano one year ago and after watching your analysis I already learned op. 9 no. 1, so now i can’t wait to lern this emotional piece. thank you so much for introducing us to this deep emotion behind the piece

Thank you very much for this Grzegorz!

earlier this week i started going to a clinic for my depression and i had to learn this specific song, or at least part a, for a movie i played a part in. i didnt understand at that time but this peace has always stuck with me. i like the way you said "to feel understood". and i think i now understand better why this piece hits me so hard. i havent cried for over 10 years, but now i am starting to be able to acknowledge my emotions. i have hope, and i want my life to end in a major key.

Lovely nocturne played by a tremendous pianist and an incredible analysis. Thank you so much.

SO WONDERFUL AS ALWAYS AND IMPORTANT!!!!! Thank you for one of my favourite Chopin's Nocturnes in an excellent rendition and for this analysis/tutorial, your great video will be helpful for many pianists, again my best regards, have a nice happy weekend. Joanna

Learning this piece at the moment and keep coming back to your video. It truly is medicine for the soul.

I am learning this masterpiece. Thanks for the insight

Sublime!. Thanks a million!

Hello Grzegorz, I am learning this magnificence Chopin Nocturne. I love hearing you perform it. Watching your video helps me understantd the deep meaning of this nocturne. I am so deeply touched by this music that tears isntantly come to my eyes. I hope one day to have enough sensitivity to interpret this nocturne as movingly as you do. Thank you for this great moment.

I love this piece, it'd help me a lot! Thanks!

Thank you so much❤❤

This was a lovely analysis to watch, thanks for uploading 😁

Thank you soo much for this video!! I just started learning this nocturne but everytime I played it I felt that something was missing. When watching your video i realized that you can't play if you don't know what you're playing. This gave a twist to all I think about this piece and I'm very gratefull. After all, Chopin has always been one of my biggest ambitiuos and, thouht I'm a little new at this, I hope I can be better and your video has been very helpfull. Thank you so much again and please keep it going ❤

i heard this 2 days ago during the program of ice skater Ksenia Snitsya and i loved it, and i have began to study.

What a fantastic analysis. As a beginner I am considering starting to learn this piece and your backstory and interpretation will give me a lot to think about while learning it. As someone who has struggled with depression and anxiety for a lot of my life, part B to me definitely feels like a panic attack, which is complete chaos and not knowing what to do - all you can think about is that you want this to stop, you want to escape the attack. And then the panic attack ends and you feel relieved to go back to part A. But having felt the worst feelings in your life during the panic attack, afterwards you feel a deep appreciation and inspiration and motivation to be outside of it. Without having experienced the dark and negative, you cannot appreciate the light and positive as much. This is what the piece feels like to me.

Thank you! I have been wondering what events were happening to Chopin when he wrote this piece. It is so beautiful and touching, especially bar 77 .. the molto legato e stretto ... so heart rending and anguished. Thank you again for giving us this life perspective of the one and only Chopin

Wonderful!Very deep and emotional!!! At the same time very professional!!! Thank you a lot!!!

Thanks. I never thought trying to play this piece this way you explained. JM

Incredible lecture. I've loved this piece for many years, and learning to play it was my project at the beginning of Covid, but I feel that I've never fully understood it until now.

thank you very much

Thank you for this wonderful video, it's incredible. I cry every time I listen to it because it touches my soul so deeply.

I returned to your wonderful video because it is unique for the feeling and imagination! This is so important! Without imagining the music you never be real musician,creator,not just a student! Thank you again!!!

awesome man thanks for the emotion!

Your channel is a treasure. I am a big fan of Chopin and I play lots of works from him too. Unfortunatelly I have a small pair of hand, that makes the understanding of the music is extremely important. I am so happy that I found your channel. Thank you so much!❤

very good thoughts on feeling the sadness before you play ....i first heard this piece played by Horowitz and I believe he had the sensitivity you are talking about..I would like to add , that your articulation verbally is absolutely spot on and right in line with what comes to my mind and heart

Fantastic explanation, thank you! Pure delight to watch and listen!!!

Very moving lecture - the major final chord makes It even sadder

Maestro Niemczuk, I wish i had earlier the chance to enter the Chopin universe in the magic way you suggest to us !!! Your detailed approach reveals not only a solid conception of facts associated with Chopin's life, but also a thorough grasp of the most refined scents emerging from controversies concluded by blurred and ambiguous hope to come true, only through religious Faith ... Pure romanticism at its peak !!! Thank you so much !!!

Incredibly helpful

Thank you again, And also thank chopin for the happy endings 😅 , they never get old.

Un aporte tan importante Maestro, para Bach el Fa Mayor tiene una importancia muy relevante y eso lo sabia muy bien Chopin al concluir, cuando los intervalos de segunda en fa menor significaban dolor en el Fa Mayor es como redimirse de los pecados usando el intervalo de segunda mayor y menor para crear ese simbolo de lo eterno y divino que necesitaba oir Nuestro amado Chopin.

Hello sir. I am currently trying to learn and finish this piece and I'm currently working on the last section ( part D) . I have to tell you that this analysis and these words you use to describe the whole poetic sense are absolutely wonderfully amazing (eventhough sometimes interpreted feelings might be different). Also, I have to add that this vide helped me TREMENDOUSLY. So I want to thank you for your time and your work and your love to spread the knowledge, specially since you are Polish yourself and you can also express the cultural matters and history. Thank you very much.

I love listening to Chopin's Nocturnes, Etudes, Ballades, Preludes and Waltzes. He was a musical genius. Music is subject to personal interpretation. When I play this particular Nocturne in F minor Op. 55, No. 1, I do so slightly faster, accelerando, which unfortunately increases the level of difficulty, particularly for my exceptionally short fingers. I had the audacity to make a youtube video of myself playing this nocturne, check it out. Nigel Willson - Nocturne No. 15 in F minor Op. 55, No 1 by F. Chopin. I confess, it gets a little messy at times, ( but is certainly not sad nor depressing ) probably because I am a cabinet maker, not a professional musician. As such, I don't have the opportunity to play the piano as often as I'd like. However, I agree that a slower tempo would have improved the performance, in so doing, eliminating the "messy" parts.

One of my favourites, just learned 2 months ago.

Thanks ❤

Most people when they feel sad try to run away from this feeling. Chopin however must have turned and faced his sadness, experiencing it directly. How can one draw upon the inspiration to compose such sad music if one tries to run from the sadness? By putting this sad emotion to music, he is transforming it into understanding. I am most attracted to sad music, and yet I don't feel at all bad when listening to it. I feel that I'm connecting to something real.

Vladimir Horowitz usually included this piece. I learned it in 1959, still play it. Very emotional piece for sure. I think romantic music has a melancholy aspect, especially Chopin. Thanks for the lecture.

Beside being Minor it's really brings peace loved your performance as always!

Dear Greg, thank you for this inspirational lesson and explanation of this piece which ive been working on for some time now. Even when the terrible news of the russian madness in the Ukraine is unfolding i force myself to try to find inspiration in playing the piano and your passion is infectious, no pun intended ;-). Im having trouble with the last part, the "almost like going to heaven" part because it really is a bit beyond my skills at the moment. I wonder though if for the right hand the rotation method is best to use t get the soft touch and also, im using edition Peters for this, the pedalling looks hard as well as the stachiatto left hand notes, how should it approach these? Thanks again

I have a question. But first. Thank you so much for the analysis! It is really interesting to here your thoughts and interpretation. You play beautifully. Now the question. In the bar where the base note melody starts eith the G flat or sol bmol, the sheet music says to omit the pedal. Is it permitted? I find it loses the flow and beauty without the pedal. The nexy part after has pedal which I find disrupts the flow.

Consider to do an analysis of op 55 no 2 too :P

Почему-то именно этот ноктюрн никогда не казался мне грустным. Задумчивым, меланхоличным, но нифига не трагичным.

it's famous nocturne but I can't have sympathize. Like the funeral march, the present feeling just does it. Thank you for wonderful analysis.

Będę 😊

Guys pls help. I watched the best performance of Chopin"s 55 1 in youtube by a young lady. I added it to favorites and ... now it's gone. Can someone tell me her name, please!

Melodia "Rozkwitały pąki białych róż", którą słychać w tym Nokturnie, powstała w roku 1918, więc to autor tej melodii być może inspirował się Chopinem!

Very approachable analysis and beautiful demonstrations. Too bad that the auto-subtitles don't do justice to your words, giving "theme in bass" as "team in base", "opus" as "oppose", etc.

Hello, dear colleague. It would be great if you had Persian subtitles in your videos

hysterical performance. what kind of depression are we talking about? this is a rather bright work, it is a search, with a bright solution at the end!!!

Bravissimo