Amy Lee didn‘t like the male part in the song, but the record label obviously insisted. I personally believe that the two voices make song more interesting!

Amy Lee’s voice is still a voice to be reckoned with! This video will forever remain immortal!! Love you guys!!

That's PAUL MCCOY of 12 stones ( the male singer ) Amy has such a fabulous voice.

I always love how Amy's beautiful angelic voice is backed by the bands' hard and grungie backing. It's a match made in heaven and it's been that way ever since they produced this particular track back in the early 2000's. So many other excellent Evanescence tracks to knock your spots off. Fantastic band, headed up by the amazig Amy Lee. God bless them. 🙋‍♂ 🙋‍♂ and God bless you both for another excellent reaction.

Hope you listen too 'Call Me When You're Sober' next, Amy Lee's vocals really shine there 🙂

video still gives me chills ... seen it over 50 times ... never gets old

A couple more of their songs are " Going Under" "Call Me When You're Sober" and a collaboration with Korn of " Freak On A Leash"

Amy reminds me of a couple of my favorite female singers from the seventies. Ann Wilson of Heart and Annie Haslam of Renaissance, similar type of vocals. There's so much more to dive into, Call Me When You're Sober, What You Want and a great cover of Korn's "Thoughtless" toname a few.

Amy Lee is still a legend. Evanescence released a new album in 2020 title track Wasted On You. She also did a song with Lindsey Stirling for Lindsey’s Album Artemis. It’s called Love goes on and on and it’s just Amazing. Amy’s voice is god tier ❤ And Lindsey did a song with Evanescence called Hi-Lo.

This is one of those iconic songs to last forever nothing but legendary still listen to it to this day, I remember I 1st heard it during the daredevil movie

Halestorm with Amy Lee break in is awesome react to it please.

The reason for the male vocals in this song was because the record company wanted a rapper in one of their songs. At the time, a female frontend band didn't sell albums so this was Evanescence's compromise. Amy Lee hated the idea at first but, she made peace with it. Check out Evanescence - Call Me When You're Sober. That video has a little red riding hood theme to it.. and the song rocks!

I’m just glad I got to listen to Amy Lee at local establishments before Evanescence became a global interest!!! Little Rock establishments pay tribute to AmyLee, thank you and all the best for your career, hope we contribute to your success!!! 🎉🎉🎉🎉

This song always spoke to me

This song keeps reminding of an exceptional girl I once knew. Her melancholy led to her death by overdose at a young age, leaving a hole in my soul.

Great reaction Sam and Phil! Amy has such a beautiful and powerful voice. If you want to watch another version of this song, Amy sang this song with the Wagakki Band at one of their live shows. The Wagakki Band is Japanese and uses traditional instruments.

A standout of its era. It will always hold up. Great songwriting. A true classic. Amy Lee became an icon with this song! Ty! 😊

What a classic!!! Going under is my fave from that album. Just epic 👌👌👌

This was the theme song to the movie “Daredevil” starring Ben Affleck. Hence the look/feel/imagery of the clip. Absolute classic ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

Great reaction guys you should really do going under her voice so angelic

Looooove Amy😍😍 early 00’s rock miss it!!

Another good choice guys! 🤘🤘 For your next Evanescence's song I would suggest "Lithium".

I've had the opportunity to see Evanescence live in first Monday, November 03, 2003 Venue: Wolverhampton Civic Hall Location: Wolverhampton, England, United Kingdom first uk tours at was in the front row and was unbale to breath to see the bands see Amy Lee will blow you away. it from in the soundtrack of the film Daredevil. starring Ben Affleck.

I just watched Amy a few weeks ago in Vagas at the Sick World Tour. She is still amazing

i love them! saw Amy Lee in concert. her vocals are amazing!

Always nice to see father and daughter making videos together.

LP & Evanescence for me are the G.O.A.Ts of this genre of 2000s rock. So damn good.

🇨🇦 There are two videos of these two songs that are Amy singing them live in concert, with her at the Piano !

This is from an era that yielded a lot of throw away tracks but this one hit me hard with the vibe. The “Alternative” music from the 60’s, 70’s and early 80’s was music that I could put my headphones on, sit in a recliner, close my eyes and take a musical journey, high on life, not chemicals. This song had that for me which is why I had to find out who it came from the first time I heard it. #hangovergang forever 🤙🏽

I saw them last year. Course she did my immortal. Her vocals are so good 🔥

My man Phil was really digging this one..watching him jamming was so funny. 😄

Listen to Never Go Back, from their self-titled album... It's amazing (it's my favorite Evanescence song)

my childhood song!!! this was my favorite song when I was 8

"Going Under" A real banger!

Really nice reaction!! My I suggest "Evanescence - Lithium" it's a really beautiful song. 👌🏻

Very good choice for a song to make a reaction to, and thank you for it. Maybe you also would make a reaction to the song "Whisper", though I don't remember if I ever saw it's music video clip

The interesting part of this song,is that Amy Lee fought to not have the "famous rap version" as a part of this song. However,knowing that i still prefered thoose 2 going back and fourth,Amy Lee and Paul McCoy from the band 12 Stones. (I found it strange at the time that he was presented under Evanescence like he was a part of the band,while in reality he simply was a guest artist/a featuring artist. I would have loved at the time to have him presented in the video title as i watched it on MTV all the time. This song means something special to Amy Lee,as she wrote it as only 19 years old,so i get why she fought her producer over having rap parts. Ironicly,this is the version that blew up,so Dave Fortman (producer) obviously knew what he wanted and was talking about. This is around the time that Linkin Park started skyrocketing alongside the other Nu-Metal bands as people so eagerly wanted to classify it as. Evanescence mixed both Nu-Metal with Goth-Metal,wich you can clearly see in this video,and in My Immortal where Amy Lees makeup and setting is very Goth. But yeah,i love your take on the video and the lyrics. It was written by Amy after an exchange with an acquaintance during a time she was in relationship turmoil; the song is about having been desensitized and realizing all the things she had been missing in life. And i feel like this comes through the most with both her cleans,and Pauls "growls/screams" and rap parts. Is Going Under gonna be theese 2`s follow up? Still my favourite song by Evanescence. Always wondered how My Immortal would have sounded if i had more UMPH? I feel like the answer lies in Evanescence - My Heart Is Broken. I think that is my 2 favourite songs by them, Going Under and My Heart Is Broken. Amy Lee has had numberous vocalists trying to cover this last song mentioned. Then there is always a wonderful duet that happened back in the day too: Seether - Broken ft. Amy Lee. It has abit of Evanescence feel meets Seether vibe over it. Seether is considered one of thoose many Grunge Rock bands that came out of the blue back in the 90s,early 2000s.

This was their first song to hit the radio in like ... what? ... 2003 maybe. The first time I heard it was on my alarm clock radio! Do people even know what the eff that IS now? LOL! It made an impression even though I was half asleep!

I love Amy Lee she is magic. awesome reaction.

I Remember in the 06/2007 on 2009, They were in Fashion the Videos of Dragon Balls Goku vs Broly ah... Old Times 😅with this Song and Bon Jovi with It' s my life, with a many Video montages

The guy is a band member from 12 Stones

Was part of the soundtrack for the Daredevil film.

Next, "Call Me When You're Sober". Paul McCoy of 12 Stones was asked to sing with the group. At that time the label didn't think a female only voice would catch peoples attention....they of course were SOOOOOOOOO wrong as Amy Lee has become one of the best. Their contrast in this song is awesome however. Loved that you 2!

They have a Great song titled " What You Want" It ROCKS!

Though this isn't the genre of music I normally listen to, but I was into Evanescence pretty heavy because of Amy Lee's voice. "Lithium" is a dope record as well.

The male vocalist if i'm not mistaken, is the frontman to a group called 12 Stones.

A BRILLIANT SONG WRITER

this song was used in Daredevil

Love the song, but I was distracted by the gun show. Dayummm. 😍

I heard this song for 10years amy lee have amazing sound

Jr the one that was on my list is called you ❤❤

People mostly forget that the male vocal in this song actually is a feature. I have no idea what happen to him (i forget his name) but last i know he was lead singer for 12 stones

Excelente reacción ❤ también reaccionen a Tarja Turunen ex vocalista femenina y cofundadora de la banda Nightwish con la misma banda con la música Ghost Love Score en el final de una era 2005 y como solista Tarja Turunen con la música INNOCENSE desde el Live Circus Life 2022 y Victima del Ritual desde woodstock del 2016❤ desde Paraguay🇵🇾 apoyo este canal 🤘🏻

Both my immortal and Bring me to life were on the Ben Affleck Daredevil movie soundtrack

Cool song. Thanks! Try Britain's Got Talent audition performance by Aliki doing Bring Me to Life. I wouldn't say it's better than the original, but it's a bit different, and really good, with an interesting story to go with it! Thanks again for a great video and reaction!

CALL ME WHEN YOU'RE SOBER is probably my favorite song 🎵 by Amy Lee, yall should definitely check that one out! 😊

Amy Lee was unhappily married and she met a guy that changed her world. Thus this song!!!

quick cool note she was trained in classical singing initially which is probably why it has that ballad feel

“Call me when your sober” favorite Amy lee song.

gotta do call me when your sober

Ben Moody was here still in Evanescence.

Well now you guys gotta dive into Dan Vasc covering this song. Amazing male cover of Amy Lee...

The "male singer", Paul McCoy is making a guest appearance.

They were forced by the record company to add that rapper to the song cuz nu metal was all the craze at the time and the producers of the movie daredevil wanted a nu metal song for their soundtrack.

Every bodies fool and lies are also crazy to hear as well as huanted warning its a bit of a trip

I recommend “End of the Dream” and “Bring me to Life” on their Synthesis album, if only to listen to

So unfair!! Amy Lee has the beauty.of an angel and the voice of one.

Fire 🔥 this song stands the test of time.

The man singing isn’t part of evanescence This was her first song and the record company wouldn’t release song with just her singing and said they only would with the added male vocals She was hesitant to begin with as she wanted to be out there as herself but eventually she agreed

I don’t know if you do cover bands but, check out Halocene version of this song. Also check out Halocene with NOAPOLOGY (formerly Sershen and Zaritskaya)

That's Paul, awesome singer,listen song Broken from 12 stones,it's awesome song,and Amy Lee, probably best female vocalist in the world ❤️❤️❤️

Amy lee is my dads crush and i remember he said he saw her at the airport. he asked for a pic and he was so starstruck he fainted😂

12 Stones guest appearance on this track!

Having seen and heard AmyLee before Evenescence was created says Little Rock Arkansasneeds a little respect!!!

I'm trans so when he said im living a lie there's nothing inside spoke to me living female which was a lie because that wasn't my true authentic self and i finally did something about it 2020 and now has transitioned to male now and no more depression

The male singer isn't in the band. He's Paul McCoy, lead singer of the band 12 Stones. The record label forced his addition to the song, on the grounds that a female-led rock band would not be "marketable." During an interview, Amy Lee stated: "It was presented to me as, 'You're a girl singing in a rock band, there's nothing else like that out there, nobody's going to listen to you. You need a guy to come in and sing back-up for it to be successful.'" In fact, several radio stations' programmers wouldn't even listen to the whole song, and wouldn't schedule it for airplay until the song was featured on the Daredevil soundtrack and people started calling radio stations to request it. in 2017, the band re-recorded the song without the male vocal part for their 4th studio album.

Hey, I am just now finding your channel so I haven’t been here long enough to know the process of requesting songs. Can you please tell me so I’ll know for future reference? Thanks guys. Love your Evanescence reactions, and want to add a couple more of their songs that are top tier in my opinion anyway. So, yeah just let me know what I need to do please. Thank you so much, Keep shining✨

So the story goes The Record Company wanted them to be accompanied with a male singer so Amy lee in the band pack up their shit and went back to. I think it was Oklahoma where they lived and then they ended up coming to an agreement to just do one song with the male singer and that was this one. But if you want to hear a Heartbreaker when they will definitely touch a sad nerve, my immortal, very good song very deep meaning, very sad.

If you enjoy this song you might want to check out RocknMob version done in Moscow with 450+ musicians. :)

She sounds the same live. Peace

You should rly check out their live performances

Uno de los mejores temas de la historia del metal

My understanding is there’s a spiritual tone to all of her stuff.

Fun fact amy lee hates that she had to work with the male lead singer, the song was just her and the band but because she was not famous the stuido said work with the male lead singer or the stuido said they will not be making her music.

The studio added the guy into the video because they said it needed it for marketing purposes. Boloney!!!. Amy stands alone with her powerful voice!!!

This song was released in 2003. The Matrix had a massive influence on everything, and I suspect it leaked into this song a little.

U look so in love sometimes...❤

If ya'll haven't reacted to or heard Broken-Seether ft. Amy Lee. It's a good song.

The record company was afraid of releasing this as it originally was without the male singer. They didn’t think it would be a hit if it was just Amy because they thought her voice wasn’t powerful enough.

The guy keep saying that its not what he expected but both of those songs are from the second studio album the first one it’s more rockier like you said

You need to react to Evanecence newer stuff. Better than ever. Just got off a tour with Muse.

In order to keep their contract they were told that they have to add a male voice in at least 1 song.

They guy looks like the guy with long hair and the tiny hand stuffing the chicken on not another scary movie 😂

The band helping her for this song is a Christian band 12 STONES.

The male singer is not part of the band. This was forced on them because it was a movie soundtrack

👍

I don't think Amy Lee ever accepted how much she was loved

Early 2000's? I would have been about 37.

May I suggest . Sia chandelier and Alanis Morissette hand in pocket .

listen to amy lee and lzzy hale perform "Break In"