,내가 걔다 그래 저도 동의합니다.

남자이지만 방탄이랑 엑소,세븐틴은 좋아함. 방탄은 세이브미랑돕을 보고 대단하다는걸 느꼇고 엑소는 콜미베이비랑 몬스터보고 아티스트라는걸 느꼇고 세븐틴은 그냥 그 밝은 분위기이런게 되게좋음. ㅋㅋ 뉴질랜드사는데 방탄때문에 제작년에 대학교에 kpop동아리생겨서 가입함 ㅋㅋ 한국은모르겟지만 외국에서 한국인이 케이팝들으면 애국심 넘치고 자랑스럽습니다. 그리고 여기 아미들 많고 저번에 b.a.p 왔다갔는데 반응최고였습니다. 필소굿 ~~

죄송한데 엑소는 아티스트아님 ㅋㅋ

방탄보는건 엄마의 품으로 보는거랍니다😊... (51세 남자)

K S 그러게요 넘 의미없는 영상 흠.....

ya

Ameni ikr? Their makeup is nothing comparing to other kpop idols😂

Sowi Wang EXACTLY!

+Natalie BTS Do you really understand what they said or did you even see the video til end? I think there's only one who don't follow KPop between them. Be calm, girl. Please respect people for saying their honest opinion. They didn't even say anything bad about your lovely idols tho. -_-"

there artists every artist whers make up so

and get 10M views

the truth has been spoken!!

lmao so true😂💞

JiSuHope NaMinTaeJung true 😂

Sayuri Iwakami I love this comment, you said everything I wanted to say. It seemed like their review in the end was just about K-pop in general but I felt that non of those things apply to BTS, that's what makes them unique and stand out

u've said it all

sammmeee

Sayuri Iwakami couldn't agree more.. the least they could've done was inform them of WINGS' awards, etc.. i cringe every time ppl compare BTS with EXO or BIG BANG like they are much lower 😤

agree with ur comment.

Totally true.we can't help it people who only know like 1kpop group who have those issues. But Big Bang and BTS are on another label.

they are still A LITTLE bit manufactured though (they were formed by bighit and were trained in the same ways as other idols) but compared other groups, they were definitely blessed with more artistic freedom even during predebut. Same as Bigbang. Had a whole documentary about their training process but it still showed how independent they were with their music. I love both groups and I definitely believe that they are definitely two of the most authentic groups out there (include seventeen because they're self producing idols as well)

Chimney Chim true! I used to be an us-uk music fan but before that i was a first generation kpop fan (2007-2008) and i know how these idols have to train and the idols are mostly just sing and dance follow the order of the company. I didnt like kpop anymore cuz i felt like kpop is slowly turn out to be like 188283 different groups typical concept and even they tried to make their music kinda sounds like edm etc which is trendy but they just like put a bunch of pre-made sounds and turn it to a song. But what i like ab BTS is they make their own music without the afraid of breaking border or smt like that, they dare to criticize the corruption in social and even mentioned about the korean taboo which we dont have much in kpop. And now when thay bcome famous and have the trendy music style too but they put it out so well and make their own color, they dont bring up the simple sound that sound like is made lazily.

exactly. No disrespect to the other groups but when I tried to distance myself for awhile from bts and decided to explore the more underrated groups (I was hoping to find another blooming gem that might someday reach the top like BTS) I was honestly underwhelmed. The music I heard was very edm but it didn't feel like it was properly arranged by the producers (there were some groupsthat were good of course but I wasnt a fan of their flower boy type songs). Some of the other older songs even used auto tune which can be VERY off putting (Lotto was an exception though because it was catchy enough for me to ignore the autotune). And majority of what I've heard sounded way too similar and lacked individuality. Really disappointing even though I know these groups worked just as hard as bts and deserves to be recognized. I'm also a big fan of rap and idol rappers who came from the underground (Gtop in bigbang, NamYoonSeok in BTS, and the rap line in Block B as well are my faves) and I was also hoping that I could find a rap line in a group that could connect to me with their flow and lyrics but none impressed me. Sometimes the rap didn't match with the songs and felt out of the place, while in other cases the rappers felt like they were trying too hard for it to be endearing. Maybe I'm just being too hard on them. idk. This made me realize though how special BTS really are because even if they chose the mainstream route now, their music is still not something you would hear from other groups. They have individuality in that sense. They also write their music and their lyrics are so beautiful and personal; not like those generic love songs you'd here from other groups. Their discography is diverse and the fact that they like to experiment with different genres is already an a plus for me. I love them and their music so much and I wish more people outside the fandom appreciated their artistry.

Why do you guys keep saying BTS make their own music? hello they have in house producers too. not every songs is under their name. give the producers credit too.

love u hoseok

love u jimin haha

true :/ It wasn't them reacting to the mv it was just them talking about the differences which were mainly negative.

That was the purpose. LOL we were asked to look for specific things to compare western idols and korean idols. Not necessarily react to the actual video.

okay but then the video should be called foreigners talk about kpop or something, cause if you put react TO BTS and kpop, people like me could think youre going to react to bts and later general kpop. Cause for me i only watch this things bc of bts

ChAiLa Same i just want to say"shut up he is talking un english!!"😂😂😂

ChAiLa IKR!!!!!!

ChAiLa same lol

same

ACTUALLY

minibear85 일본 뿐만아니라 서양인중에도 “여자처럼 메이크업 했네.” 이러는 거 보면 진짜 찾아가서 물어보고싶음. 그럼 카메라에 나오는데 세수하고 쌩얼로 나오니..

문화차이 때문이라 그런 것 같아요 우리가 그런 사람들을 이해 못하는 것 처럼 말이져?

근데 일본남자 도 아이라인 ㅈㄴ 그리고 화장하더만 꼭 어떻게든 까낼려고 함 일본 애들은

일본인들 열폭잼

일본 제이락쪽은 한국보다 더함..아에 대놓고 여자 치마도 입고 나오는데 저사람은 자기 나라 문화를 잘 모르는듯함

I would to but I don't understand WHY she's on a *reaction/opinion video* ...😂 Like why did she even agree to "react" just to be not honest to herself 🤔👏

BTSoul Bingu 😂😂

she didn't even watch the video she was looking at the cam and keep talking she didn't want to react at the video that's what i see here also yes her comments wasn't right at all didn't like her comments

^^^^ a prime example of a salty fan

BTSoul Bingu Lmao

lol..do they look like any other idol group WTF?

But BTS isn't number 1 lol maybe in your eyes but not everyones

How old of a fan were you? What fandom are you in?

Yuri Chittaphon well, me as an "old fan" since 2011 i can care less about new fans, this war btw old and new is stupid, all of us started at one point and before us were other people too. I just want new kpops fans to educate themselfs, and respect others. And i know kpop is such and adicting world but do be that next koreaboo calling people oppa and unnie and using konglish for everything. That's the only think we ask.

I am also old , and the old kpop was much m much more similar

well said. I understand that the idea of men in general wearing makeup is weird but that doesn't mean you have to judge them. It should be acceptable because gender should not define what you want to do with your life. The fact that Korean idols even use make up in the first place (not just performances but also in real life, although subtle) amazes me because it means they're not afraid of dressing up and looking good. They also seem to care a lot about their personal hygiene which is something that I don't usually see from boys in my own country, so this attitude is refreshing. I also agree with the point that although a lot of the western artists are handsome, they look more haggard and aged than the Korean ones PROBABLY because they don't use as much bb cream or anything. That's just my observation tho so don't deem it as a fact.

preach

Chim Chiminie coconut hair styles. Lol. I am dead

That's what we were asked to do. Just following instructions. Sorry it didn't meet your expectations.

Claudia Choi but there was hardly any. They kept going off topic

김혜정 와 멋있네요

김혜정 맞아요.. 자기들은 그런거 한 적 없다는 식으로 투 머치 투 머치....

Right? I totally agree. They said some really good points. I actually liked this reaction coming from people living in Korea. It's nice.

I AGREEE. Some of the comments that are left are just from salty and butthurt fans who are upset coz the reactors were "not paying enough attention to the mv". Oh well, if they dont like the fact that bts is not 'constantly praised' in this vid, then these salty fans didnt even realize that they're the ones who didnt pay enough attention coz the reactors actually mentioned some positive things about bts and kpop in general -_- pssh im rambling

Miki imnida Thanks for watching!^^

they are men but wear makeup , and who gives a fuck , they look sexy , and that's what i care about most (i mean even without make up i'd still see them as sexy and u find men complaining about ugly women , why don't they look at their selves in the mirror and then talk about ugly women )

If you look at the history of pop in general. 80's western pop had many male artists who wore a ton of make-up.

yep. could've showed them dope instead. Not as confusing as BST but still just as beautiful.

***** ik xD

Minji Park yh i found that really annoying

Minji Park Except that if she does say shit she will get hate... It's not her fault she's scared, fans can be vicious.

true, but at the same time some fans attack people for their opinion

Minji Park We savage ass fans

Yah sadly the fans looking for honesty are the minority. Just look at the comment section here & on some other reactors. If a person says negative stuff or doesn't give desired reactions the immature fans go straight on the attack. I say this as a BTS fan. I've introduced BS&T to friends from other fandoms. They love it, they like the song but refuse to get more into BTS since they've been attacked by Armys while supporting their bias groups. This is recent & has happened to multiple people. The fandom isn't all bad but the immature ones love to be the loudest when they're acting out.

they cant even finish watching the video til the end coz the butthurt is too strong lol. but anw yeah i agree with you.

jigglypuff 7012 same

Fairuz Su'da not really butt hurt its because they were talking so much and I feel the only one who actually tried to get it was the Asian girl. The others should've reacted separately in my opinion.

Irene Wan Just a teeny tiny detail, which is usually the case for a lot of American music videos as well, they don't usually buy the clothes. They get samples which they use and then return. So albeit an interesting calculation, the assumption that they buy the clothes is simply wrong.

Jenny Park Oh yeah that's absolutely true. I wouldn't be surprised if they got paid to wear some of the pieces as a sponsorship

Irene Wan lmao

Where do they sell jeans for $200 😂👌🏼 but true

misuka same,she annoys me..

Mr Worldwide Handsome same

ㅎ ㅎ ㅇㅈ

엄밀히 말하면 특히 해외는 남녀구분을 아시아보다 훨신더 뚜렷히 하구요 남자들이 핑크색 노랑색옷을입는것도 매우매우매우매우 드물고 찐따취급당하는데 문화차이는 인정해야죠. -,-ㅋㅋㅋ 남자가 구두신으면 그거도 인정해주실건가요? ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ남자가 립스틱이랑 아이라이너는 사실좀 .....ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

las vegas ㅋㅋㅋ그게 성차별임 배우고 오셈..ㅇㅅㅇ

las vegas 자신을 꾸미는 행위가 언제부터 다른사람 시선을 의식해야하는거였냐..ㄷㄷ그래서 못나게 꾸몄어요? 잘생기고 멋지기만 하고만ㅋㅋ 본판이 되니깐 화장도 되는거임ㅎㅎ

죄인 그니까 화장이 여성들만의 전유물이 아닌데 '여자'처럼 메이크업 한다는 말은 남녀가 평등해야 한다는 현대사회에선 좀 없어져야하지 않을까해요. 솔직히 말하자면 저도 남자가 화장을 진하게 하는건 별로인데 그냥 개인의 취향 차이라고 생각해야죠 물론 남자 연예인들은 방송 때문에 하는거지만

량인 맞아요.. 다른분들은 의견이 딱 확실한게 좋았는데 일본분만 약간.. 좀 빙빙돌려서 기분나쁘게 한달까.. 좀 듣기엔 그랬던거 같아요

비꼬는거 같아서 보는내내 기분나빴음 ㅋㅋ 그냥 저일본인은 k팝 자체를 싫어하는 느낌? 이듬

일본인의 특성이 돌려말하기입니다 :> 문화적인건데 설명하기가 그렇네욧.. 그래서 일본인들 약간, 좋지 않다고 표현하는건 우회적으로 돌려말하기를 많이합니다

화장 때문에 별로라고 하는 건 진짜 말이 안 되는 게, 일본 아이돌은 진짜 화장 떡칠하고 나오는데 ㅋㅋㅋ 걔네는 눈썹까지 다 얇게 밀어서 다 그리고 나옴. 우리나라 아이돌은 거기 가면 완전 상남자 마초남 됨. 다 빼빼 마르고 멸치고 어좁이들이라...... 아마 일본에 섹시존이라는 남돌 보면 뒤집어질 듯. 거기는 입에 장미 물고 꼬꼬마 애들이 호스트처럼 분장하고 나오던데 ㅋㅋㅋ 변성기도 안 지나서 완전 목소리는 초 하이톤에 옷은 재롱잔치 수준으로 허접하게 입혀 나오는데 진짜 샤이니 데뷔 때보다 후짐.

화장때문에 별로라고 한게아니라 영상에서 질문이 케이팝남자아이돌들이 여자같이 보이냐고 물어봤잖아요. 그래서 그에 맞게 일본인분이 말하신거고.. 영상 좀 잘 보고말하세요

홍지수다행히 방탄을 좋게 보는것같아요!

parkhyunuuoo 오 저도 그렇게 생각했는데 좋을거같아용

Mina Choi ㅎㅎㅎㅎ 외국에서도 화장을 하는건 알고 있겠지만 (저도 외국인이라 답장함) 자연스럽게 해서, 뮤비에 나오는거는 좀 티난다고 생각한다는 말인거같애요 ㅎㅎ 또는 일반 외국인남자가 비비크림도 안쓰고 다녀서 좀 상상하기 힘든거예요 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

Mina Choi 미국이나 서양권에서는 연예인이라도 저렇게 남자가 눈썹 칠하고 입술 칠하고 진하게 화장하는 경우가 거의 없습니다. 그래서 저러고 다니면 자동으로 "게이냐?" 라는 소릴 듣죠 (물론 이런걸 게이리고 욕하는건 성소수자를 경멸하는 잘못된 행동이죠) 미국 남자 연예인들도 기본 메이크업 정도는 하겠지만 그래봤자 피부 좀 밝게 보이려고 로션바르거나 기본적인거? 거의 화장안하죠. 그래서 미국애들은 동양권 남자연예인들이 막 스모크하게 화장하고 방송나오는거 보면 좀 기겁을 하더리구오.

ᄋᄉᄋ 맞아요ㅜㅜ 단순한 사랑노래가 아닌데

나도 네 말에 동의해!!

TheJaneReads Ph no 😡😡😡

i don't think she was being particularly judgmental though... it seemed more like she was just pointing out things she'd noticed. and she's Japanese, so she's probably pretty used to KPop/'strange' culture lmao

yup me too XD

I totally understand K-pop idols seen as these "robots" and BTS are idols too but getting to know them, I realized that they are a bit different than your usual idols? Yes, they follow the K-pop system but they are very much involved in their music (with the production, writing, composing) and they always share the stories that they want through their songs and you can see that when you look at the meanings of each one. So, I hope people also look at these idols in a different light and maybe see that some groups are more than the "robots" that their company produce.

Shymoon I agree with you, I hope they will get more freedom. It's actually sad that some idols have to perform songs they don't like :( Where are you from?

sonyia S I am fro Brazil

Mexican pop used to be this way, manufactured and VERY successful.

Kpop is not just limited to so-called idol groups. It's quite sad to me that many foreigners recognize kpop as idol group industry. always makes me frustrated..

stupidsminkle I used to love RBD

지금 달고 잘게요 ㅎㅎ 주무시고 내일 CC 자막 켜서 보시면 됩니다^^ Good night!

Heechulism 허얼 감사합니다😍 안녕히 주무세요 ㅎㅎ

김민지 미안

+김민지 한국어자막CC로 올렸어요:)

영알못이라ㅋㅋㅋ ㅜㅜ 좋은 영상 감사합니다 잘 봤어요💕