This is the first debate ever on the question: Is Islam True? Please share your thoughts and comments! Timestamps: 00:00:00 Apostate Prophet Opening Statement 00:12:50 Dr Abdul Majid Opening Statement 00:25:30 Apostate Prophet Rebuttal 00:31:46 Dr Abdul Majid Rebuttal 00:38:00 Open Discussion: Arabic Necessary? Who is Qualified? 00:49:55 Predestination vs. Free Will 01:21:00 Muhammad's Failed Prophecy Questions & Answers 01:25:05 Majid: Does Allah Know Human Experience? 01:26:23 AP: Is Safe Incest Wrong? 01:28:10 Majid: Are your Arguments Circular Reasoning? 01:29:35 AP: Is Slavery Historically Justifiable? 01:30:50 Majid: Why Argue for General Theism? 01:32:35 AP: Are Christianity & Judaism Beautiful? 01:33:44 Majid: Quran Contradiction? 01:37:35 Majid: What Should Happen to Apostates? 01:41:46 Majid: Is Hell Literal or Metaphorical? 01:42:22 Majid: Muhammad Marrying Adopted Son's Wife 01:43:47 AP: Why do Christians Support an Atheist? 01:44:55 Majid: Is the Quran Necessary? 01:47:17 Majid: Should Hijab be Compulsory? 01:49:32 Majid: Did You Answer AP's Questions? 01:51:35 Majid: Why Do We Need Arabic? 01:54:12 Majid: Muhammad's Child Marriage? 01:57:25 Majid: Your Education 01:58:56 Majid: Did You Address Arguments? 01:59:38 Majid: Explanations to the Big Bang 02:00:40 Majid: Why Do You Greet an Apostate? 02:02:08 AP & Majid: Child Marriage Justified? 02:04:22 Majid: Why Are Animals Killed? 02:06:22 AP & Majid: Virgins in Heaven 02:08:15 Majid: Does Morality Change? 02:10:10 Majid: Forbidding Churches & Synagogues 02:11:55 Majid: Where is Sperm Located? 02:12:39 Majid: Predestination & Free Will? 02:13:49 AP: Are You Open Minded? 02:14:30 Majid: Is Child Marriage a Problem? 02:15:55 Majid: Husband-Beating 02:19:50 Majid: 1. Child Marriage 2. Jinns in Hell 02:22:35 AP: How Do You Explain Muhammad's Miracles? 02:25:26 Majid: Disbelief + My Cat 02:27:04 Majid: Is Allah a Deceiver? + Ex-Muslim Stereotype 02:30:00 Majid: Muhammad Tongue-Kissing Grandson 02:31:10 Majid: Does Islam Allow Lying?

I find it very funny that when a Muslim wants to convert you to Islam, speaking and understanding Arabic isn’t really necessary but if you start to question Islam, you cannot because you do not speak or understand the Arabic language.🤣🤣🤣

I want to thank Dr. Abdul Majid for helping muslims leave islam for good. You are a hero

"You don't understand it, I don't understand it, nobody can understand it." - Islam according to Abdul Majid

I'm an ex muslim anti theist atheist from Afghanistan. Hundreds of thousands of young generation left islam in Afghanistan....that is happening in many muslim countries. Keep it up.

Dr Abduls argument in short: "I am right because I am right" "Allah is Allah" "Quran is Quran" "You are wrong because you are wrong"

So, here's the problem, if AP wasn't 'qualified' then why has Abdul Majid agreed to the debate in the first place?

I will never understand why they will continually speak and recite quotes in Arabic when their goal here is to adress a western audience.

I think Dr Majid is one of those unfortunate people who have found themselves in a religion and have never bothered to examine it's claims or understand it enough to debate it. He looks like a good,honest, well meaning muslim. AP thanks for coming out and pointing out things that people desperately want to explain away. Its time to face the ugly truth.

This debate is another proof that having a PhD does not necessary mean having intelligence nor intellect.

Dr. Abdul Majid is INCREDIBLY resistant to understanding points. I have seen this in SO MANY Muslims. No ideology numbs the mind like Islam.

"Aisha was 6 years old" "How do you know if she was a small child or a woman?" What 😂

Dr. Abdul is honestly a shining star. If he continues like this he will be listed 1st influential man out of 100 who led people out of Islam. 😃😃😃😃😃

Islam is true because Muhammad said so and Muhammad was a prophet because Muhammad said so

That doctor has some of the worst arguments AP has ever heard, its like talking to an 8 year old

Dear AP, please continue the work you're doing. Millions of Hindus have your back and support you. You have lots of love and respect coming your way. Stay strong. Stay blessed.

His basic argument is that Islam is true because it is. Genius I tell you,

“Debating a smart person is hard, Debating a Dumb person is Impossible” -Someone said it I forgot who.

My friend said that he left Islam when he read "Kill the infidels." He said that a True God would NEVER tell him to kill anyone.

Dr Majid literally went two hours of saying: „ALLAH GAVE YOU CHOICE ALLAH GAVE YOU CHOICE“ and thought he killed it

This guy dodges all questions like a pro 😂😂😂

I am an Ex-Muslim antitheist from Pakistan. I left this evil 7th century cult in 2016. One of the best decisions of my life ..

This is what happened when an Abdul gets a Dr certification from Madrasa.

First logical fallacy at 17:08 - Appeal to Ignorance: How were we created? We don't know. Therefore Allah. Second logical fallacy at 18:20 - False/Faulty analogy or false eqivalence: Can a mother create herself? No. Hence the Universe can't create itself. Therefore Allah. Third logical fallacy at 19:04 - Non sequitur or Causal Reductionism: You cannot have two creators because if you did you would have chaos (there was no chaos in Olympus). Fourth logical fallacy at 21:46 - Poisoning the Well: All the books are inferior to the Quran therefore the Quran is correct. Fifth logical fallacy at 22:35 - Argumentum ad populum or Red Herring: Even the non believers accept Mohammed's greatness hence Mohammed was great (which deflects from the relevant question of whether he was a prophet of the truth). Sixth logical fallacy at 32.26 - Argument to Authority or Appeal to Accomplishment or Poisoning the Well: AP is not qualified to argue therefore his questions are invalid. Seventh logical fallacy at 33:17 - False dichotomy: If Islam doesn't hold the truth then what does? If nothing else holds the truth then Islam must be the truth. I also find it quite ridiculous that Dr Majid states that you must know Arabic to understand the Quran. Hence if you don't know Arabic you better forget about converting to Islam as you have no chance of understanding the book of truth. It also begs the question - if the Quran can't be translated, why translate it? From around 40:00 it starts to descend into disorder and it becomes personal. At 60:00 Dr Majid states that we don't have free will (Allah decrees everything) but because you don't know what that decree is you bear the responsibility of your choices. This is an absurd argument. You either have free will and can choose or everything has been decreed (predestined) before your birth. If I do not have the ability to choose why do a bear responsibility of my choices? Dr Majid either doesn't understand the question, has misinterpreted the word "decree" or he is quibbling. Eighth logical fallacy at 1:17:15 (I've skipped many in between but this one is a pearler which all theists use) - ad baculum and appeal to fear: if you don't believe me you will perish in hell. At 1:28:15 Question: "Dr Majid do you think your arguments are circular?" "I'm not here to convince anybody... [but let me answer the previous question on incest which was directed at AP]". Hilarious. By the way, I think AP could have done better with the question on incest (which is an appeal to emotion fallacy - the Romans for example didn't have any problem with it) by asking whether pedophilia is equally reprehensible. Don't throw stones if you live in glass houses. At 1:30:54: Question to Dr Majid - Answer: Christians believe in one God, Hindus, Jews believe in one God etc but what about the 2 billion (a quarter of the wold's population) East Asians, Indigenous peoples of North and South America & Australia & Africa? Let's just sweep them under the carpet. Next time a Muslim asks a Christian about a contradiction in the Bible the Christian should say, you can't understand because you're not a Christian scholar and you don't speak Koine Greek, Hebrew or Aramaic. This argument, which was extensively used by Dr Majid, contradicts his argument. Dr Majid claims that the Bible and Torah are inferior books to the Quran. How would he know if he hasn't read these books in their original language?

If islam were true, why do they use a sword to prove it? Would a math teacher do the same?

It’s amazing how when Muslims make an argument they always bring Christianity into it

The final “stay away from Islam” is gold!! Lol

Finally, people began to speak the truth. No more fear but facts, verses and great bebts, Greatful for internet🙏

Respect to all these individuals who have taking the time to have this discussion.

The more i listen to that doc, the more im convinced that he has no answers. He simply cannot defend his book and religion.

Without lies, Islam dies.

Why do so many Muslims wear the same clothes everyday? Is it because that they are required to wash only their face, hands & feet? They must save a lot on laundry...

I'm leaving islam since 2017, and the sad part is I starting learn the truth on Islamic University

Well, the Dr was superb at circular arguments and obfuscation. At least he was polite, unlike the majority of his peers.

AP won the debate by his opening statement on the mistakes in the Quran.

This was such a good debate video. There are too many good things to point out in one message but thanks for posting AP

I really thought Dr Majid was gonna be up for this and I was excited to see a good debate. But after that opening I’m finding it difficult to carry on watching.

Is Islam true? Dr. Abdul Majid: Yes, because Muhammad said so.

Even sunflower has more knowledge than Muhammad about the sun.

Loved watching this, even if I did not learn much. Dr. Abdul has a great sense of humor, I am glad AP took it like a champ. The second half had me laughing!

Allah wanted the “truth” to be revealed to humanity so much that he revealed it only in Arabic. And that “truth” is only “true” in Arabic. If it gets translated, it’s not true anymore.

As a mathematician it feels so bad to see someone using a statement to prove the same statement: Islam is true because the quran is true and the quran says islam is true. The quran is true because it is the speech of Allah as stated in the quran I'm sorry to say but one must be straight stupid to not see the logical fallacy in this.

That "doctor" is proof that a formal education means nothing about how intelligent you are.

My brain cells just died listening to Abdul.

Dr. Abdul has made himself more than qualified for a lifelong meme in this video. Thanks to Apostate Prophet

Well done AP, I’ve never watched such a one sided debate in my entire life, keep in mind Dr Abdul Majid is an authority and well learned man in Islamic studies and Arabic language who have so much qualifications. If Dr Abdul is the best islam can offer, then islam will die sooner then later.

This idea that a layman is qualified to accept Islam, but only a scholar is qualified to criticize it is, in itself, a layup of a refutation of Islam. The fact that even these “learned” Muslims don’t see that is incredible.

"...so, here are my arguments, now you can respond" "Yeah, you are not qualified to do that, I have a PhD btw"

This was very enjoyable

Abdul just answer questions not asked! - a typical tactic when you don’t want to or can’t answer the question, this is also often seen in the political environment.

'You got destroyed, BOY!!!!!' said an ignorant Muslim who thinks that dogs drive away the Angels

No matter what this Abdul guy says, millions follow Islam without knowing why they are following it and millions don’t even read Arabic so how do they know what’s in the Quran 😂😂😂😂

Can you prove that a 9 year old is not a woman? INCREDIBLE

AP you're getting better at debate man....good luck...

I feel really bad for Abdul. He seems like a good guy, brainwashed with a horrible philosophy.

*Dr. Abdul's arguments in the beginning about islam being true:* Islam is true because Allah is only one god and if there were many gods they would fight each other, it would be chaos... It's just like in boxing: you can have only one winner, therefore Allah is only god and islam is true. - This is even insulting for a brain of a 14 year old.

Has Majid done customer phone support for AT&T…I swear it was him who just kept telling me to reboot my iPhone …tru dat !!!

Dr Abdul’s answer is not convincing he has failed to answer many of the points raised by Ridwan

"A 9 year old girl IS NOT a woman."

Good stream bro

Your patience is unbelievable, Ridvan. Impressive!

Dr. Abdul Majid should have a conversation with Christian Prince seeing CP Arabic speaking Christian.

Dr Abdul Majid is the single weakest debater I've ever heard in a formal debate.

Thansk Abdul majid may Allah give u more tawfeeq to fight against these ignorant people

U get ‘em brother

As an agnostic, I am kinda disappointed about this debate. I was expecting that Dr. Abdul Majid would give some reasonable answers and straight to the point, instead of telling children stories.

I am half way through. Respect to Dr. Abdul Majid for at least being willing to engage in a public arena. Regrettably all that is shown here is that he is functioning in a different paradigm of intellectual investigation. AP is openly and repeatedly inviting a response to his atheism and how he perceives the unintelligibility of Islam. Dr. Majid is assembling a catalogue of Quranic references that that he feels are relevant that justify his own convictions without actually engaging with the subject.

Dr Majid seems like a great guy but he did circle every question ALOT. Otherall. this etiquette of debate is what I like to see

"Maybe Turkish girls are not ready at that age, but Arab girls are. Come on man, I know how Arab girls are, heheheh" brb, throwing up.

So basically Dr Majid's "argument" is Allah is true The Quran is true Muhammad is true I'm a Muslim you're not I'm educated in Islam you're not I speak Arabic and it only works in Arabic So there !

He never addressed or answered anything you brought up, and he acted like a nice guy to convince viewers that Muslims are friendly :)

Dr. Majid seems like a happy man in his faith. As a Christian, the Dr. did a very good job showing that a person can be Muslim and NOT BE A screaming mean spirited person. Because of this, I actually enjoyed listening to his responses and was not put off. Thank You.

I dont think a lot of religious people understand what ‘evidence’ means. They go to their book, read a verse and say thats the evidence 😅

Thank you doctor Majid for letting me know that Islam is false

Dr Abdul is good for preaching to the less educated. Clearly Abdul cannot handle criticism well.

Thank u Dr. Abdul Majid you have done a great job ...

That boxing example was funny😂😂

This "debate", simply confirms the futility of doing so with muslims with indoctinated closed minds. Great job done A.P.

I do not possess a degree in geology, so that means (according to mr. Majid) I am not qualified to say the earth isn't flat?

Very respectful debate. I have seen Dr Majid before. He is very respectful.

@Apostate Prophet, Your points are very clear and precise. Kudos. 👍🙏

Since Dr Abdul Majid is so proud about his Arabic, I suggest he debate Christian Prince in Arabic and let us laugh together.

Allah is true because the Quran says so. I didn't expect this kind'a argument from an educated person. Aisha was a woman playing with dolls. The debate didn't materialize simply because one of them is arguing and the other one preaching.

This is the best islamic debater in the whole world of history. period.

Our new David wood. How are you?

Is Islam true? No.

My brain hurts when this bearded guy speaks! He just cannot answer one single question and makes no sence.

How different is the 'meaning' of the text in Arabic, compared to English? It sounds to me as if Dr Majid is saying that a Muslim will not understand the true meaning of the Quran unless it is read and understood in Arabic.

Dr came to conquer but he forgot It can only spread with Sword 🗡….. by discussion even other will leave if they get to know the reality

Credentials are meaningless. Take Christian Prince, an Arab with a masters in sharia law, complete understanding of the Quran and hadith and can debunk Islam with one opening sentence .

Dr Abdool Majid says he's got Six cats, Five daughters, Four wives. ...and a partridge in a pear tree. Taqiya at its best. The Wisdom of Islam belongs in a slapstick comedy. This could be funny if it wasn't so true.

“Can mother create mother?” Well my grandmother gave birth to my mother so…. Yes

This how you debate when your whole life is wasted studying one book

How did he get his doctorate if he is missing a common sense/logic?

As an ex muslin I’m familiar to his reasoning their main saying to order Muslim if they question them is you have to believe in your heart and don’t let this questions entering your mind because it shows that the sheitan (devil) is trying to mislead you

Bro is calling himself nice and generous and giving random lectures instead of directly answering the arguments

Watching this takes minutes off my life I’ll never get back.

I got the feeling that “dr” Abdoul Majid isn’t alone there and he is getting help of one or two people sitting beside him.

Dr. Abdul Majid must have received his doctorate degree from the University of Al Phoenix...

Ap was just laughing sarcastically🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 He knows he ended him