Excactly what I was looking for, perfect review. Helped me a lot, thx! Greatings from germany

Thank you so much for this in-depth review and for this bs-free channel. Your video review of the 2 watches is the best comparison out there in terms of functionality. I can't thank you enough! You are definitely in my top 3 wearables reviewer from only seeing this one video. Keep up the good work.

Great in-depth review! With your pinpointing each systems weaknesses, they should hire you as their adviser!

I have used Garmin 945 for a year and I can say they have excellent support services. I have had problems with pool swimming with the watch not detecting reversal at the wall. I usually lose 50 yds on an 1800 yd swim in a pool due to not detecting turns. Great watch for cycling and running too. I do use the polar strap and Elite app for HRV. Over all I am very happy with my Garmin 945.

The best part about polar is that they haven't been hacked twice in two months.

Great video. Thank you from Italy

I've owned a F5+ before my current Vantage V. I do agree that the high end Garmins have more features, but I don't agree that Garmin is the undisputed better choice. I've found the integrated advice (based on recovery pro or nightly recharge and training load) very valuable. The HRV score on Garmin (which is. the basis for the body battery) was inaccurate for me, it always said I had lots of resources left which was often not the case. I don't mind that Polar shows less. data than Garmin, as I didn't use most of. the data presented by Garmin. Obviously neither are bad, but most reviews seem to be skewed towards number of features in stead of how they are made.

Amazing review! thx a lot!

Et bien même entendu en France ces informations débitées à une vitesse de ouf sont très précieuses car l'utilisation des fonctionnalités montrent clairement les différences pour les pratiquants passionnés Thousands of great thanks !!!

Very good review, thank you very much. At the moment with the Ignite, but after all it looks that the next system will be Garmin :)

In the After-Workout Summary, you did not show any Cycling or at least Running Summaries for Polar V2.

Great Video TY

Agree about the brightness of the Polar! Disappointed on that and the notifications you mentioned. Garmin also has Garmin Pay, right? Pay from the watch?

Thanks for this great video. I would like to ask a quick question. I have an arrhythmia and have been on beta blockers for twenty years. According to the advice of my cardiologist, I practice running regularly, it helped me a lot and I was able to reduce my medication always according to my doctor's advice. For a complete follow-up of the shape and the heart, you recommend which watch? A Vantage V2 or a 745 for example? Hello from Germany ^^

Thank u!!! Finally good reviews not focusing on the damn running bla bla bla stuff. Great job

i feel like polar has the best designs for their watches , they do look amazing but garmin ones are way more functional , with better metrics and information

Which do you recommend overall to track output from crossfit and weightlifting and your strain/recovery levels? Also do either have specific options to track a martial arts session and if so which had better stats?

Thanks for a great review. Having owned both polar vantage and Garmin fenix 6 one (suprising) deciding factor for my is to get garmin training status. However to use this on a continous basis you need to run or bike 1-2 time a week with GPS data. For me this is a problem especially during winter where most of my training is indoor. Do you know why this is the case?

My biggest issue with the aPolar daily activity is that it counts driving and sitting in the car as low or medium intensity activity. It makes the whole thing worthless on days when I’m commuting

Hello from spain !! In your opinion What is the best, Vantage v2 or Garmin fr945 ??? Thank you very much.

Which ones are better at monitoring sleep and giving more sleep analysis? P.S. Cool dumbbells in the background.

ive had polar vv2 for 2 weeks. I find it not accurate in pace during running when I check my watch? it either becomes very slow pace 2min difference for a km or extremly fast 1min/km faster than my normal speed. and even when I wear the polar h10 strap, I find the heartrate varies a lot during different day even for the same routes same distance. one day it tells me the avg hr around 120 and the other day almost 140. currently im running 70-80km/week.　also, it gives me the heart rate of 60bpm after I deadlifting 60kg for 10 reps, which I really doubt since that's 1.2 times my bodyweight, heart rate could not be that low. wonder if any one has the same issue?

This is very detailed review and very good comparison, I have Garmin 245 and thought I would upgrade to the new 745 but not sure the additional features is good enough for more than double the price?

Hi! Would you please help me to do the right choice? I am doing a sport almost every day. Mostly combining runnuning and swimming or outdoor exercising. Is it possible to do run a kind of multisport with V2 or 945/745 and have an overall training status from all kind of sports ? I mean to go from one kind of sport to another without stopping the previous activity?

what stats are available on garmin forerunner 945 related to strength training compared with polar ? Vo2 max should be calculated when doing activities related to running. Also i know that most of other features are based on vo2 max. Does this parameter takes into consideration also strength training ? thanks

I have Garmin Fenix 6 PRO with STRYD 🦶 pod and Polar H10 ❤️ strap and it’s amazing 🤩

I'm a Triathlon athlete, between this two what one should I get? Great video, comment from Brazil!

Great vid! After watching a few of your superb review videos I decided on getting the 945. I think it's the best all round watch. One thing that's different on mine compared to yours is the user interface. How can I get the user interface like the one you show in the video? Thanks

Hi, Thanks! Do you know which of these watch response faster in the 24h continuous heart rate when one walk up stairs to second floor? Thanks!

Time for a video on the 945 LTE!

After the activities with the polar, is there a place where you can show the indicated recovery time?

1st...btw...how many watches do you a Have? I have a f6x sap...would like a second device but feel like the new garmin recovery features using a different watch screws the metrics...

The Polar's Run power and hill rep splits are 2 great functions garmin don't have.

Hi, another question, in your video you mentioned that garmin body battery and their new sleep metrics is more encompassing for recovery tracking because they take in the full days stress to come up with the score where as polar doesnt. So I was looking into the white paper of polar recovery and from what i understood the ANS metric, which is weighted primarily on the HRV impact relative to your historical, would be actually directly measuring your previous days stress impact just in a different methodology, as you would expect the HRV fluctuation to be directly impacted by the stresses of the day. And even though it is just a 4 hour window, the white paper claims that based on their research this is the most critical window to determine the impact to the metrics. did you ever notice much difference in the metrics Polar vs Garmin assigned for you the next day and how much load can be handled?

Nice review. Do you have any plans to review the Ticwatch Pro 3?

If you could do a review on the TicWatch Pro 3 that would be awesome to see what you think

So v2 vs f6 (since it has the sleep) ...is a v2 worth it?

don't you think the titanium version of the v it's more durable than the aluminum?

I am waiting to see if Garmin will release the 955 before Christmas. What do you think about the odds of a release before Christmas? I would really like the bezel to get smaller and screen to get larger as I don’t like the weight of the f6.

Which one feels less bulkier wearing and sleeping in 🤔

I am asking polar for this . Otherwise it is not enough for day to day use. I hope Polar adds in a 4hours average heart rate In the watch display. This way I can checked my “ energy” from my 4 hours average heart rate. If it is average at the 70% range of my max heart rate , I need to take rest. currently I am eyes Average my hr from the polar flow Hr graph. It is very clumsy. As we know Garmin has 4 hours hr graph on the watch display and the body battery. Other watches has the 4 hour Hr graph too.

Hi what is the best watch for doing crossfit and mountain bike.

Too bad you couldn't show all of the features polar offers . Little bit of a biased review there . With polar there is cardio load muscle load and perceived load along with orthostatic test. Owning a garmin myself I agree with alot of what you say but its not fair to omit some or polars features just because garmin doesn't offer them. For running polar is my choice their adaptive plans are amazing . For fitness fitspark its handy for casual fitness. Garmin no question is the more versatile watch tho and if I was only in the gym would be my choice too

The one thing which polar does better is the heart rate is more stable then Garmin.

polar is wow

Honestly, all those fitness and lifestyle data is so useless for me. It frustrates me a bit that I have to pay for all that bloat and a super advanced wrist HR I won't ever use just to get the battery life, GPS accuracy and build quality that I want. I don't have plenty money, but I run alot and need professional gear for that as my 235 really can't holt its battery together for a single Longrun of mine, and GPS accuracy is super floppy :/ well, I guess at least the polar one looks good even for its price, so that's what I tell myself to calm my nerves over those 500€...

Okropny stan paznokci zabija wszystko...