Nice meeting you all!

I got second hand embarrassment from how uncomfortable you guys made him in the beginning. Matt would’ve never

This guy legit looks like if Matt and Mike had a baby

Not me thinking that was just Mike’s brother 😂

here after matt said on unfiltered that he was so upset about this guest being brought on without him😭

Matt not being here feels like a crime lol feel like he would’ve gotten along perfectly and brought more to the table

Bro Matt was absolutely crushed over this! He was so beyond upset 😢

Jack Antonoff, Rick Glassman and Mike Sheffer all look like long lost brothers

I genuinely feel so bad for Matt

this was a hard watch 😭 it was a waste of a guest that Matt would’ve loved and Carly was being cringe for some reason , seems malicious but ik Erin is gonna laugh it off next episode and dismiss that it’s mean af lol

yeah weird decision and missed opportunity not having Matt there, he would have helped it flow so naturally.

Is this the episode everyone realized they only watch this podcast bc of Matt?

To do this to Matt and also make such a waste of good guest with whatever this episode was is incredible sad. Matt would have MADE this episode.

Y’all did Matt dirty with this one!!!

I feel soo bad that yall decided to bring this person when Matt wasn’t here knowing it’s one of his fav people… Mike literally only knows him cause Matt😂

HAHA Mike is so flustered

damn they shouldve at least had a topic. he seemed excited about weird crimes🙃 also carly was on one lmao

Even rick glassman was like why tf is Matt not here and hes not even his friend lol.. so mean

The worst part is this episode would’ve been 100x better with Matt there. Weird ass choice

Carly does not click with this guy and it is hilarious to me 😂

rick made this podcast very funny to watch but idk it felt weird - carly seemed off idk how to explain it, I definitely wish matt was here for this, I feel like he could’ve added a lot to this episode!!

The fact that they told Rick that Matt is sexist and a misogynist.. he's going to be so upset. Its just disrespectful.

I lost it at Rick asking Mike if he’s str8 😂😂😂

lmao Matt is not wrong by saying they’re always talking over each other. Let the guest finish his sentence 😅😅😅 hard watch tbh

never thought id say this in my life but please let the man speak.......

Carly was so nervous, she fucked this up. She was being too much with the reactions. There was no flow. Ughh I had high hopes.

I think bringing someone BOTH guys wanted to meet but only one got to is a little messed up 🥴

It’s always “Matt is a grown man he’s fine” but never “Erin is a grown woman she can take accountability for her fucked up actions” :-D

I wanted to like this podcast sooooo bad 😩 I feel like y’all need to get on the same page regarding podcast etiquette (talking over each other, not being prepared, arguing about etiquette ON the podcast). I understand this may not be the case, but episodes like this feel like you’re just winging it and thinking that will be enough. Like take some interest in your guest, prepare, don’t leave them in the dark when surprising someone with them. And the constant dog-piling on Matt even when he isn’t there is so hard to watch. I get you have a relationship outside of the show that we don’t know, but you should understand that because we don’t know that and y’all don’t explain it, it comes across like bickering and annoyance for him. I love all your content individually but this podcast is bare minimum and you guys have the potential to be so much better than this.

So now you know why true fans see Matt happier on unfiltered cause they consider his feelings lol

Once he started guessing your weights out of boredom, I was out. Why wasn’t there anything prepared for this “dream guest?”

Feeling a little sad for Matt. It would similar to if Erin was off one day and the guys surprised Carly with Taylor Swift. I know it’s on a bigger scale it same idea

This would have gone so much better if Carly and Erin told Mike, and Matt was there. Kinda feel bad there wasn’t a structure for the episode. I miss those days

respectfully this episode is bad on so many levels. why bring him when matt isnt here? can this man finish a sentence? idk if carly is so scared of not being funny or of being the butt of a joke that she has to overdo it this much, its giving „insecure dude“. could you guys at least prepare a few questions to respect the guests time, and frankly also the viewers time.

Just thinking about how much better this could’ve been with Matt… 😭 I feel for him

oh man, i thought it was me too

i hate to say it but this episode was a flop :( i feel like carly and erin kept cutting him off, bringing up topics that just weren’t interesting. idk it seemed like mike was embarrassed at what they were asking him. definitely wish matt was there to ask better questions!

I feel really bad for Matt he would’ve loved to have been on this episode :(

Rick literally describing debilitating mental illness that controls his life. Carly “that’s so cute!”

Mad for Matt. Friends shouldn’t do that. That’s a tad far to bring in someone he loves.

Carley needs to read the room, stop talkingggggg😭😭

Really cruel and weird of you guys to bring him on as Matt’s replacement knowing how big of a fan Matt is

STOP CALLING ME CRINGE I WAS NERVOUS ASF LOL

Big fan of the pod but I think Rick would’ve been better on hoot and a half because he could actually get a word in. This felt messy and disorganized and the girls just talked over him the whole time.

Why would you guys bring him when Matt isn’t there :/

Poor Matt. This highkey made me sad that they did this without him.

a hard watch ngl. esp when mike kept bringing religion into it

'You're not 5'9" or you wouldn't have started with 5' 8" and a half' Oh damn Mike, he pinned you to the wall with that one hahaha

also they better not come at Matt for the comments cus they knew wat they were doing having Rick on when he wasn’t here 😂 I can also see them making him feel like crap when he has a right to be upset , should’ve seen this coming

tougher watch than usual (rick was great tho)

I'm sorry but Carly is doing too much this ep 😅 idk if I can continue watching

Im sorry but carly and erin should never have guests on. This was kinda crazy

so unbelievably iconic I was praying it was gonna be Rick when they were teasing on onlyfriendss but also was like no wayyyy they would do this to Matt

Poor dude couldnt even get a full sentence out?

I am absolutely the biggest rick glassman fan now, he had me dying. His fast wit is iconic and you all fit in so perfect together especially for just meeting!! Great episode. Also mike’s heart eyes the whole time were so adorable

the way my brain was malfunctioning during this episode

Honestly thought about not watching in support of Matt lmao but I needed to see Mikes reaction 😂

love carly sm but she’s being a bit of a pick me this episode

"you're straight, right?" absolutely sent me especially because mike is so aggressively hetero

I always thought Erin secretly hates Matt. This confirmed it.

Fair enough for Matt to be pissed, and he’s so good at asking questions and interviewing. Mike is only worried about Jewish stuff which I’m sorry no one is really here to watch for

we don't have a topic?? guess our age & weight?? what's your morning routine?????? Good grief, that was awkward.. i just know Matt would never. just saying.

Not watching in support of Matt

I feel so bad for Matt :(

Matt being there would have made this ep way more structured and fun! Although Matt wouldn’t be mad or anything, he so deserved to be here for this! He’s great at keeping the convo going and being personable 🤗

Yall did matt so so so dirty. You really had to have someone on that he loved, instead of just doing you 3 for one single episode? I would be seriously annoyed and upset if I were Matt what sort of “friends” would do that SMH

this was actually a really shitty thing to do to Matt, but we all know Erin is just gonna brush off his feelings and laugh it off like she always does

I didn’t know Rick before this but i’m now a fan. He was cracking me up the whole time. Poor Matt missed out 😂

Lmao carlyyyy stop

why was carly so cringe this ep :(

the edited bleep tried yet failed LMAOO

Matt truely is King and without him these jesters fall flat. Poor Rick - he handled these kiddies as best he could. #cringetowatch

Mean girl behavior strikes again! It’s honestly baffling how little Matt is considered by his friends.

Omg! I'm so happy for Mike, he looked so excited!! A bit bummed that Matt missed it, but hopefully they can get him on Hoot & a Half. 🤗

i really hope y'all bring him back as a surprise for matt one day D:

Damn I wonder if Matt will talk about how upset he was over this on this podcast :( I feel like they owe him an apology

Should have just had Joe on to replace Matt for this one and waited for Matt to get back once Rick accepted and you found out Matt was a fan of his. It would have made for better content. This was awkward at best, mean at worst and it's going to cause a rift in the group, said or unsaid. Erin should do an AITA and see what Reddit thinks about the situation. Sad she doesn't care if she is seen as the A. Friends care.

why did you guys wait for matt to be GONE to have him?!???

Rick is ACTUALLY funny and you can so tell the difference between someone who is actually funny and someone who thinks they need to fill up every second of silence with bad jokes 😭 (Carly….). Rick knows when to take a beat, good timing, complex jokes

loved getting an intro to Rick and his sense of humor! would love to see Matt and him on a pod in the future!!

I had no idea who Rick was but I’m a fan now, this was freaking hilarious!

Rick doesn't always shine on other podcasts. He did today. There are over 90 episodes of this podcast, and this was definitely one of them.

I was crying 🤣😂 this whole ep. I've never seen or heard of Rick Glassman. He is hilarious! I'm a fan now! Everyone is upset for Matt and trying to create drama. I found the clip of Matt talking about this on Unfiltered. It seemed like he was just angry at first bc he was shocked they got Rick as a guest (of course when he wasn't there) but Matt even said "I'm not angry. It's fine. I was so like WTF.".. But I was thinking this whole ep Matt would've been going crazy. They all kept talking over each other and got lost on so many side conversations 😂 some stories weren't finished. Well hopefully they can get Rick on again with Matt.

This should have been a Matt episode, I think Mike kinda made it blah for me personally.

Mike seems so smitten I love it. This was such a fun episode!! Poor Matt, he was definitely missed!!

i had no idea who this guy was before this episode and now i love him, this is my favorite episode so far

So funny to see Rick slowly become more comfortable as the episode goes on

Actually really sad for Matt

This episode was so cringey. Carly was acting so weird and Mike seemed embarrassed by the way they were acting. It would’ve been 100% better if Matt was there

me thinking they brought mikes brother on until they said his name

Justice for Matt! We need Rick back for a redemption episode with Matt.

I wish i could hear the debrief that happened with Mike after Rick left lol.... not often we see Mike flustered. I feel like Rick fit right in 😂

I have no idea who this is but I love that he loves him!

Uhhhhhhh 😅😅😅 this is painful to watch

This is one of the best episodes ever! Had me “ lol”ing 😂

Matt would’ve done amazing 😢

Damn. This was hard to watch.

It’s better to just leave the seat empty

I'm like legit trippin out in the best way possible. Glassman is one of my all time faves I've watched TYSO since the beginning! watched everything he's acted in and now he's on one of my favorite pods.THANK YOU! THANK YOU🎉

I thought I was just me being a hater and thinking this episode was awkward and a waste of time. Reading the comments glad to know it wasn't just me!!