I never tire of watching hiking/camping stove videos. Thanks for showing the difference. I too like the versatility of being able to use wood, pellets, & alcohol. I like that in an emergency I can cook indoors with alcohol.

Another great informative video . I have the Goshawk 206 Atomic and it's a great little stove. Used it many times and found that for me it works better as a bottom lit stove. I find that you have much more control over heat. Stacking to just below the gasification ports is ok for a quick boil but I still prefer lighting from the bottom and adding as I need. Also works great with a trangia with only using the top section as you showed.

Another great review, thanks Mark.

I bought the atomic 206 the first week it came out and have used it like you have. I’m very very happy with it. I also got the same results you did. I will say I didn’t like using wood pellets in it though. I had trouble getting the fire going when I used just wood pellets. I believe that’s because the air flow is cut off unlike when I used trigs and small chunks of wood. Overall, I’m glad I made the purchase and I have cooked steaks, eggs, bacon etc on it with great results. The gasification system on the atomic 206 is impressive.

I love your pyro vids! Thank you Mark!

Great review, Mark, as always. Kind of back to your roots as I subscribed a few years ago when you were doing a lot of wood stove reviews. Happy with my Lixada tower stove but always have an eye out for the next one 🙂

Neat looking stoves. I'm addicted to cooking stoves so one day may have to add them to my collection I'm starting to form😁 Thanks for the demo. It looks like they perform reasonably well.

Thank you for your very through review. I will keep those 2 products in mind when deciding on my next wood stove.

Really Like How These Nest Together, Great Demo, Mark ! ATB T God Bless

Very comprehensive. Thank you

All I want is for Solo Stove to make titanium versions of their stoves, especially the Titan size. Maybe even Ranger. But yeah, I need it all enclosed 🙈 cheers for the video Mark!

Thanks Mark, always interesting. I think I will stick with my large Toaks titainum tower stove for it works about the same and no rivets to pop off. Both these Gosshawks look like nice stoves though and do have a cool name.

I really like the pot handle. Cool stoves!

I was looking at those was 2 models a few months back and wondering how they compared. Once again, you have put out another impressive review. Cheers from New Brunswick 👍

I was trying to figure out how to pack my Kelly Kettle Trekker for my upcoming northbound Appalachian Trail thruhike, beginning March 30th. I finally gave up, as I will be carrying a bear canister on this trip (2+ pounds, and bulky). In playing around with the titanium wood stoves I have on hand, I realized that the top of my large Toaks tower stove will burn long enough to boil 2 cups of water with one load of sticks. I also found a holiday candy tin which has a top that fits the bottom of the top section of the Toaks stove perfectly. The combination weighs 2-7/8 oz. Cut down pot supports from my Kelly Kettle weigh an additional 2-3/8 oz. and seem to be worth carrying. I plan on riveting the candy tin top in place and sticking it into the side pocket of my pack, placing my stainless 40 oz. Klean Kanteen inside of it. I will carry my 1.3 liter Evernew titanium pot, a Snow Peak cup, my Supercat alcohol stove, and my titanium foil windscreen from Backpacking Light (with paper clips to hold it together) in the pot, inside the bear canister, with my food. I still have to do a "real world" test with damp twigs in the wind, with the windscreen made of a section of my Seek Outside Hot tent stove. Gasification is overrated, imo, especially for a hiker on the move. Fwiw: using the fire starter on top of the wood fails to utilize a very useful aspect of a fire starter: drying out slightly damp tinder above it. Thanks again, for another excellent comparison video. 👍

Good review Mark , thanks for sharing , God bless !

Unless there’s a possibility of snuffing out the fire, as soon as I get a flame going, I put the pot/pan on. By the time it starts gasification, I’ve cut my cooking time in half. Both of the stoves are cool. ✌️🇺🇸🇨🇦✌️

I also have the Pioneer and like it for both wood and alcohol. It does require a lot of feed of twigs which can get troublesome but that’s a limitation of all small volume stoves.

I went with the pioneer pro. I like that the top is open as opposed to the criss cross stand blocking the top for feeding. Also not having the feed port on the side makes for a better wind shield, especially for alcohol stoves. This thing is a pellet champ. Also, it nests perfectly in a Toaks 750 ml if you don’t want the goshawk pot.

They just introduced 2.0 versions of these Mark! Let’s see the NEW VERSION reviews! (I just ordered the new Atomic/Wood version with the BBQ GRILL attachment since I already have the older Pioneer/alcohol version) 👍🏽

Being that i'm never in a hurry, speed to boil is unimportant.. a lower temp and burn rate is, as i do more cooking then boiling. Though i am a " pocked rocket 2 " man i am leaning more towards the 206.. the ability to add sticks when i need them and control the burn is convenient and more important to me. nice informative video thanks

Very Cool Mark ! I like the look of these and also the look of the Goshawk Folding Pad .....cheers my friend !,;;; Spook

I do wish they had a bottom like the Bushbuddy that would protect surfaces under them. I found that the top for the cup that I store my 205 in will work as such but then I'm left without a cup lid. Otherwise, the Goshawk is a great little stove.

Nice Review my Friend

Great video! I'm totally new to that kind of stove and don't have one yet. I was using a Jetboil for years and I'm now looking something as compact, but to use with wood or pellets. I first heard of popular Solo Stove (Lite or Titan) and while I was looking for reviews of cheap alternatives from Amazon, I found your channel and I can't stop watching videos from many many more similar stoves. I'm curious to hear your opinion about a good option to start. I like both compact options from Solo obviously but also find interesting the Eddy 206, the Arnaud Kombuis and a cheap TOMSHOO... I can't decide.

Looks great! But same "problem" as many other wood stoves - they need a bottom like Solo Stove. Of course you can bring an extra titanium cup lid or similar to put under just a shame it's not integrated.

To many companies trying to reinvent the wheel. So many others have set the bar high.

Nice stoves. Great comparison video. The Atomic is 162g or 5.7oz. you have 7.7oz in the description.

I have so many stoves now 😂… I don’t know why but I can’t stop… I think the gasification of wood stoves is key. I have the uberlieben stove but takes forever.

Perhaps you could do a comparison of some of the top options in multifuel stoves? I like your practical and comprehensive review style and I think there are a lot of people like me with a canister stove who are curious to try alcohol and twig stoves. Personally I'm looking at picking up the Goshawk multifuel from this video, FireBox freestyle or nano, or the Trail Designs Sidewinder, as well as the alcohol stove that comes optional or best fits each of them. A side by side would be super helpful. I'm most curious about 1) packability with flatpack style vs pack-in-pot, 2) keeping your pot and pack clean from the soot, 3) efficiency and 4) ease of use with pot & skillet. With a stove like the Goshawk or Sidewinder that packs inside your pot, how do you recommend keeping it clean on a multiday trip? Any insight you can give here in the comments also greatly appreciated!

Apparently the pro version is now taller. I wonder how well it would do against the atomic. I really don't understand why they don't just blend the best of the two into a single stove. The pro only needs to be taller with a window.

Another great informative video, Mark. Thanks 👍 I've been waiting for it after you said Goshawk sent u these 2 to review. But isn't their siphon stove made out of aluminum? That may account for that weight difference you felt? I have an addiction to titanium that must be continuously fed LoLz 😝 so I, too opted for the Lixada siphon

Saw the eddy 205 in paleo hiker’s channel a while ago and apparently they improved the design. Same happened with their Steampunk alcohol stove, for which they made another pot stand. This company listens and improves upon their products! Five stars. Thanks for another top notch in-depth review Mark!

Thanks for the review Mark. Have you cooked food with either stove? How did they do? I am patient for boiling water as I want to cook without torching my food. Thanks!

First many thanks for sharing. You mention burnout times but no conditions, please clarify. Just removing a boiled pot and allowing it to burnout is heating up space, wasting of fuel and time. Hopefully burnout times are in use / under working conditions, ie cooking something. Could the Pioneer be adapted, a removable drawing chimney added (AliExpress 100mm 0.01thick? Titanium foil made into a tube). Or make an addable interim collar to improve gasification and incorporate a feed port. Thanks again Take care

Could you use Esbit tablets on the Eddy 205 as well? Thank you for the video.

Love your vedios I have the original l multi stove love it would it be worth adding and upgrading with the pioneer or is there. O difference between them ?

Great Review Mark,,, My understanding of Gasification is,,, other gas’s from the burning of wood, drop down to the bottom of the stove and then come back Up in between the burn chamber and outter wall . Then igniting as they come out the hole’s just below top of the burn chamber. Not having the bottom of the stove Closed/ Sealed,, doesn’t that Greatly reduce/ distract the gas’s from traveling back up to the upper burn ports,,??? Compared to the Solo or Bushbuddy gasification stoves,,, Thanks Mark,,,,, Joshua

Can you use this stove with propane or butane?

I like the look of these stoves, but the pot support on both have something to be desired...

Would that pin on your jacket be a Coleman lantern pin ?

I am looking at the eddy 200 stove only . I have a toaks 750 pot already . I like stoves the don’t have to many extra pieces liane the pack stove xl the eddy 200 would be right for me

What is SMOKE? Unburnt fuel... try to increase AIR to burn the smoke fuel...balance the combustion equation HEAT-OXYGEN_FUEL. Remember AIR only 20% O2 hence 5X required. If a store-bought stove cannot perform better than a tin-can with a few vent holes... pay? Go figure. Good luck!

Hello from British Columbia Canada 🇨🇦🖐👍♥️🚐🛣🚐🌲🌳🚴‍♀️🥳🤴🦝🏒❄🚍🍲