國外聲樂老師點評黃霄雲《左手指月》Vocal Coach Reaction to Ghost Huang「左手指月」

Рет қаралды 519,767

6 ай бұрын

Join this channel to get access to perks｜加入會員提前解鎖完整版影片:
/ @clubzeromedia
*Performance videos and instrumentals may have been censored due to copyright concerns. Please visit our Bilibili for full-versions of the reaction: space.bilibili.com/7295246
Stayed tuned for more professional vocal coach reaction videos!
Follow Rozette on KZfaq: @RozetteSaaangs
Follow Rozette on TikTok: / rozettesaaangs
Artist Booking: clubzeromedia.com/rozette
#reaction #vocalcoach #reactionvideo #thevoiceofchina #黄霄云 #萨顶顶 #梦想的声音

Пікірлер: 591

@garykao5084 6 ай бұрын

周深直接變成形容詞😂

@adeleanne9433 24 күн бұрын

周深的歌喉已經是國寶等級的了因為達拉崩吧把老師震驚到了😂

@BADthing1995 21 күн бұрын

甚至變成了古風的代名詞 😂

@bennychu3260 16 күн бұрын

非常周深😂

@zachwang6485 14 күн бұрын

It's very 周深~

@WenyuMelodyMoves 4 күн бұрын

Very 周深

@khaisiang1806 6 ай бұрын

黄霄雲的选择太多了她几乎是没限制，多亏她同时拥有了暗和亮音色可以适合唱很多风格而且还是非常好听，这缺不了自己天赋和努力挖掘自己的声音。又因为她天生的机能和努力练的技术技巧还有基本功，让她有能力连续挑战高难度的歌而且消耗很小最多累而已。明明是大嗓却有小嗓的音色和细腻能力，也保留了自己大嗓该有的声压和腔体共鸣并且能随意控制。她无所不能，也就是老师所说的😁

@user-ib3nk5zl7p Ай бұрын

我每次都是来学英语的 😂 配上中英双字幕加上老师的清晰的发音不错

@kamlam782 27 күн бұрын

老師發音好易聽

@crystalliu0608 26 күн бұрын

我也有同感，常常單純只帶著耳機聽，之後再看有字幕的。

@user-ib3nk5zl7p 25 күн бұрын

@@kamlam782 对听着很清晰我正腔圆 🫡

@haohanzhang5065 24 күн бұрын

还真的是 😂 我现在就是双字幕

@yurawei 24 күн бұрын

嘿😂我也是

@darcy8857 6 ай бұрын

我最喜愛的年輕歌手黃霄雲，無暈置疑的是真的因為太厲害導致被太多人黑，在聽過薩頂頂唱左手指月無數遍之後沒想到還有人能把這首歌演繹得如此美妙，相信黃霄雲將來一定會大放異彩的

@user-qf3ml8fq5s Ай бұрын

當時還不是專業歌手，唱到這樣超級強了，也喜愛這版本

@VincentSun-sf1zk 21 күн бұрын

在我心中的新生代最强，没有之一。

@shouyelang9575 20 күн бұрын

@@VincentSun-sf1zk 不是會飆高音就是是會唱歌，新聲代單依純如果排第二，那沒人能排第一。音樂的詮釋，表達和演唱上，單依純才是最強的那個。

@VincentSun-sf1zk 20 күн бұрын

@@shouyelang9575 我没怎么听过单依纯唱歌，肃然我听黄霄云的歌也不多。但我想说机能强的人同样能唱小歌，而机能弱的人是唱不了大歌的。

@QWQ485 18 күн бұрын

黄和周深吧

@user-yl7fc6dy5p 6 ай бұрын

❤黃霄雲就是一級棒的歌手

@sheyokoso 6 ай бұрын

終於輪到黃霄雲的這一首了眾所期待…太經典了神級演唱看林俊傑的表情就會知道了還讓他叫出聲音😹

@weijiaCAI 6 ай бұрын

毕竟是中央音乐学院年级专业第一啊

@317greenleaf 6 ай бұрын

她的“你的答案”、“我們的愛”跟“天下無雙”也務必reaction😍😍😍❣️❣️❣️ 我反而很愛黃霄雲的這個版本第一次先仙氣地用比較像假音的聲音輕盈地唱上去像是穿梭在雲霧繚繞山林間的仙女第二次用紮實聽起來像真音的聲音飆上去像是降下凡間後對世俗的吶喊層次變化很豐富堆疊成最後的高潮對表演編排的理解非常透徹曉得觀眾喜歡什麼樣的呈現就像老師說的敬業的藝人不單單只是沉浸在自己的世界而是也服務到每個觀眾因為她聲帶閉合夠好有用對喉嚨與聲帶的控制才能不變音色不斷層地由低而高唱上去她才年紀輕輕就有這樣的技巧相信在人生歷練更加豐富後情感表現會更加純熟完全是一顆指日可待的閃耀鑽石

@lijanejane 23 күн бұрын

我也愛這個版本❤️❤️❤️

@panpeter2969 9 сағат бұрын

我可能不對但是我甚至覺得她的版本好過薩頂頂的

@tang0122 6 ай бұрын

黃霄雲的技術無庸置疑,剩下就經驗加詮釋! 隨著時間加上繼續在這行會慢慢更好的

@gikyoko4885 2 ай бұрын

17岁的黄霄云参加中国好声音的时候我就非常欣赏她，她是当之无愧的的中国顶级音乐天才少女。

@aremyday 25 күн бұрын

真的應該辦演唱會的

@redarrow1076 7 күн бұрын

黄确实是个歌唱的杰出人才❤❤❤

@user-xiangjianhao 6 ай бұрын

2020年的中秋晚会周深和萨顶顶合唱这首歌排练的时候隔了几条街都能听到周深在飙高音

@ForeverHappy 6 ай бұрын

这里有些评论曲解Rezette 老师的意思，老师说的是黄霄雲有很好的taste，而且她在另外一期 re (All By Myself) 里说了黄霄雲：1. She is phenomenal（她是现象级的）。2. Her ear is extremely accurate（她的耳朵听音极为准确）。3. She is one of the best female singers in China I've seen（她是我见过的中国最佳女歌手之一）。

@user-qe6xc3yp5e 6 ай бұрын

感謝老師和字幕翻譯君😂這一切很有意義，讓我明白唱歌不只是唱歌還有其他很多的東西，比如技巧之類的，非常感謝❤

@cwhkg 6 ай бұрын

黄霄云對我來說, 就是武術奇才還沒有遇到對的師傅, 或是找到真正厲害的武功秘笈。所有的武功對她來說都是輕而易舉就能學會的,但就是還沒真正的耍出來。跟龔琳娜、譚晶這些大魔王比技巧一點不輸, 但論歌曲演繹的說服力, 大魔王過去歷練的修為就在這。

@ptolemylin914 2 ай бұрын

龔琳娜、譚晶這些大魔王比技巧還差的遠。就那幾招。

@JJ-3721 2 ай бұрын

@@ptolemylin914 还大魔王。没人听

@corner10 17 күн бұрын

我也同意黃宵雲無庸置疑唱功很好很有潛力但在如何演繹歌曲的部分還是不比其他唱將沒有那麼唱入人心的感覺但他還很年輕再多幾年的閱歷一定會更厲害

@cwhkg 17 күн бұрын

@@JJ-3721 曲高和寡!! 很多真正好的音樂, 只是不通俗不是不好。人多聽不一定就是好! 因為真正好的是內行的行家才有見識修為可以分辨。

@cwhkg 17 күн бұрын

@@corner10 是的, 好歌手唱出意境, 聽的人像是進到歌手跟詞曲創作人所描繪的故事中, 所謂的"演繹"就是這麼一回事! 宵雲音域音準都很好, 就差扣人心弦這一步了, 值得期待!

@user-xk9nj5hc9q Ай бұрын

😂😂老師好好笑，好高。

@Heng0001 6 ай бұрын

You are so right about “that’s so Zhou Shen” because Zhou Shen sang this song live in a big stage with the original singer and it was amazing.

@tianyuxing3096 6 ай бұрын

黄霄云真的很努力，而且很热爱音乐，小时候每天都走几里还是十几里的山路去上音乐课

@davidbruce184 6 ай бұрын

我不懂音乐，第一次知道声乐这个词。但是很享受老师的分析过程。听老师分析发现，原来声乐才是音乐灵魂沟通的语言啊！且沟通的本质就是真诚与真实。就好比小情侣一方背叛了另一方，但是就是要听一方ta真实真诚的声音一样，就算很难听，但是就是要这个东西，甚至就是要这个来让自己死心。这可能就是艺术的本质吧！也是人性的本质。谢谢老师带给我的体会！也祝福节目帮到更多的人越做越好。

@user-lw7ht5cu5c 13 күн бұрын

写得真好

@MrGary9370 6 ай бұрын

這首終於出現在老師點評影片裡了！👍👏

@penciltip8853 6 ай бұрын

Very thoughtful points! Now I know why I always enjoy watching your reactions. You do have great taste too Rozette.

@kuirenjou7246 6 ай бұрын

這老師真是太厲害了

@user-ms2gh4nn8p 6 ай бұрын

周深的確唱過！！！還是跟原唱合唱！！！拜託老師做一集 >

@hungkeungwong2915 23 күн бұрын

相信頂頂有後期修音，所以難評。

@mariobevilacqua3445 6 ай бұрын

这首歌的原唱是萨顶顶！！！并且萨顶顶和周深有现场live！！这首歌的三个版本很难对比，都是神级

@user-kg2zk7bu7e 6 ай бұрын

感觉黄霄云唱的有点吃力，高音有点尖锐，缺少自己的特色

@mariobevilacqua3445 6 ай бұрын

@@user-kg2zk7bu7e 听听她的《人鱼之歌》，你就不会说她的高音吃力和尖锐了

@user-gz5tr4vk8j 6 ай бұрын

高音吃力尖銳？！沒有一樣像黃😂

@user-id9km2eg6b 6 ай бұрын

@@user-kg2zk7bu7e 真的是很没taste🤣黄是故意在第二遍副歌选择用“听起来比较吃力”的真声去唱那两个音的，这样听起来会更有人味，更有代入感，也更流行化

@user-kg2zk7bu7e 6 ай бұрын

@@mariobevilacqua3445我知道她是学美声的，有功底，也许故意那么唱吧！

@user-qc1bc4lu7e 6 ай бұрын

完蛋了，老師徹底中了周深毒，連"周深式"的形容詞都出現了 🤣

@beab8738 6 ай бұрын

Alot of Chinese classically trained sings like that by transitioning between mixed and head voice, even the original signer of this song. Zhou Shen does it particularly well though and became his signature.

@user-mp5cl4yi9i 4 ай бұрын

我認為周深更仙氣空靈, 聽起來沒壓力.

@aremyday 27 күн бұрын

Very 周深，哈哈哈，周深霄雲流派，深雲流

@lwhsimon6984 22 күн бұрын

星辰大海，霄雲好聽炸

@Leonananado 6 ай бұрын

早期的黃宵雲可能表演高超技巧為趣，比較單調，但後面她進步超快速，學會把技巧更多用在表達歌曲上，令觀眾可更沉浸在歌曲的情感意境裏。

@wamushaku 20 күн бұрын

這位老師好棒！專業又謙遜👍

@po91283 27 күн бұрын

我真的快笑死，老師好幽默

@cool007zqw Ай бұрын

Your taste is what really makes you amazing. I couldn't agree more!

@user-gv6ij7re9i 6 ай бұрын

我個人還是比較喜歡薩頂頂個人及跟周深合唱的版本，比較仙比較美，黃霄雲的技巧很好，在年輕一輩算很傑出，但唱得有點太美聲了，也許是薩頂頂給人的印象太深了。

@cecewang70 Ай бұрын

同感

@ubcTech 29 күн бұрын

我反而比較喜歡黃的版本，低音部分有種強而有力的感覺，高音也有高音的繚繞，薩頂頂的感覺低音高音都是細柔路線

@michellemichelle775 27 күн бұрын

认同

@yiwen717 20 күн бұрын

我也是薩頂頂派

@dizupo8441 18 күн бұрын

这首歌更喜欢萨顶顶版，她的音色相对更空灵、清澈，演绎的更轻松，高音部分唱出了慈悲感。。。

@leannefranson1198 6 ай бұрын

Thanks for reacting to this. I have only heard the songwriter, Sa Ding Ding, sing this together with Zhou Shen, whom she chose to sing with. Good ear you have!

@andrewpheng2936 21 күн бұрын

我太喜欢黄霄云了❤

@user-hf3os8sp3l 12 күн бұрын

好好笑，老師的競爭心直接飆起來XDDD老師也超棒 You're awesoem lady

@victorgoldfish 6 ай бұрын

學霸果然技巧與天賦並重

@jewelstella 6 ай бұрын

zhoushen has sang together with the orginaly singer, and perfect stage with perfect voice.

@user-hl4ff2im2t 6 ай бұрын

这才是霄云的王炸曲目

@MrGegao 6 ай бұрын

老師太可愛~~~♥♥♥

@Hannahloves70smusic 22 күн бұрын

声音真棒❤

@user-cu3ng1kk1j 6 ай бұрын

看到老師的正能量😘

@wacod33 6 ай бұрын

Really enjoy Rozette comments, very professional, and yet fun and easy to understand, and Roze has got very good taste!! ❤ bravo to you Roze

@ching1295 22 күн бұрын

老師好專業又好可愛😂

@leiyang25 6 ай бұрын

Upward to the Moon, composed and originally sung by Sa Dingding. There’s a duet version of her and ZS with epic production. Rozette you should check that out as a comparison.

@purityhanhan 27 күн бұрын

我超喜歡黃霄雲唱這首歌❤❤❤

@user-nv4kx1cj8y 6 ай бұрын

真的喜歡老師對霄雲的評價!! 可憐霄雲一直被黑像老師說的聽霄雲唱高音!! 看起來唱得很輕鬆這一定需要很多的努力才能有這樣的技巧~~ 人家有技炫也是努力練來的

@sianico2435 6 ай бұрын

說她炫技其實是因為，技巧壓過感情時，一首歌會變得很機械式，就像一堆高級的音符飄過，卻留不下什麼訊息。但我覺得，黃後來除了技巧，也增添了很多情感、越來越好，是個很有實力的歌手！

@jeffganlk 5 ай бұрын

一开始没几秒, 老师不就听出问题了吗? 她的抖音不稳也不准。只是老师不想招恨, 说得有点隐晦。

@lorylan2988 Ай бұрын

@@jeffganlk你在开什么玩笑，她可是国家队选手😂

@CK-gd3lb 29 күн бұрын

@@jeffganlk 老師只是說她選擇用大顫音，然後開始和JK討論中英文歌曲，你是如何腦補出來的？

@jeffganlk 17 күн бұрын

@@CK-gd3lb 你开心就好。

@daoma7735 2 ай бұрын

黃霄雲的最耐聽最有感情

@susanhughes1800 6 ай бұрын

She is an amazing singer. Sa Ding Ding and Zhou Shen sing this and it’s so incredible!!!

@junemck.5531 2 ай бұрын

周深唱过了！是我最喜欢的他的一首歌。

@kenwong888 Күн бұрын

我 ❤ 黃霄雲 😇

@C929_Lily 6 ай бұрын

老师，这首一定要看周深的，而且是快乐大本营那一版，因为是很多米子入坑的歌曲！！

@cheungh4064 6 ай бұрын

說得好👍👍

@bluem3zs 6 ай бұрын

對對

@allylo9163 6 ай бұрын

我之前就有聽過周深和薩頂頂的中秋版，看到你的建議去看大本營這版..... 真的太~好~聽~了!! 聽完熱淚盈眶.... 每一個音的呈現完全扣人心弦呀!! 我還是覺得黃唱得很棒，只是聽完周深的大本營版..... 腦海又只剩下周深了!!

@user-vb9oq5or4q 2 ай бұрын

這集好好笑阿~~

@quincyuraam7807 23 күн бұрын

I love her mouse so much!

@soul369 6 ай бұрын

黃霄雲確實蠻可惜的被黑的太嚴重了以她的實力該跟周深一起發光發熱的

@neal710609 6 ай бұрын

沒給錢

@yxuen3051 6 ай бұрын

黃霄雲少了一些勾人的東西

@hollandbankchq 6 ай бұрын

黃霄雲是商品，周深是藝術品，不同類別。

@328sad7 6 ай бұрын

周深人品真的很好很討人喜歡。黃霄雲本來我聽左手指月的時候也覺得她挺不錯，結果在歌手看到她挑毛不易打好感度一下子就掉光了。基本上挑戰者都是挑曲風差不多的歌手挑戰，她就挑毛不易的慢歌打。雖然比賽上這樣的策略不能說她有錯，但給我的感覺就是為了贏沒有風度，讓我對她的好感一下子轉負了。利申：不是毛不易粉絲，最多算路人粉。毛不易的歌就聽過4首

@haoxianglyu7929 6 ай бұрын

@@328sad7 少来这一套啦，就挑毛不易咋滴啦？你毛不易水平差就不要上歌手！

@user-fx7yl9fi5l 6 ай бұрын

希望老師觀看2008年，薩頂頂在英國皇家歌劇院的表演。😊😊

@Whats-DanT-Up-To 6 ай бұрын

Love your comments. I really wish you would comment on the original version by Sa Ding Ding and compare it with Huang and Zhou's version

@solitudepanda5300 6 ай бұрын

Although this song was written in the recent years, it is actually a soundtrack for a period drama 古装. It’s specially written for that show, so the song will have more traditional elements than modern ones.

@LanJun520 6 ай бұрын

If I remember correctly, when Huang Xiaoyun sang this song, Zhou Shen and Sa Dingding had not yet sung together.

@user-bo8cj5zb4s 6 ай бұрын

技巧到了一定級數，再想進一步評估更深層的好與壞，我想就是技巧的用法／表現方式了。記得一個老歌手（忘了是誰）說過，他用了10年時間學習和精進技巧，但用了之後的大半生去忘記技巧。當時有幸在他老去時聽他唱過歌，那種充滿技巧但一點不感覺他有用技巧在唱，和那種豐富但不做作的情感融入真的利害。至今幾十年過去也忘不了。

@CK-gd3lb 29 күн бұрын

但你連他是誰都忘了😅

@user-bo8cj5zb4s 29 күн бұрын

@@CK-gd3lb 只是忘了名字，但這個人本身是經過了30年以上我還是記得，甚至當時的情景也印象清晰。只是聽他唱過一次就記了30年。

@leonardsimmers9158 6 ай бұрын

Hi Roxette, I forgot to say you stopped Ghosts video a little too soon, as after a bit of talking the panel asked Ghost to do some whistles. And she sang a bit of Vitas's Opera 2 that Dimash performed on 2017 Singer.

@MrAndy22782000 6 ай бұрын

可以講有能力唱到左手指月,每一個都是能力者

@wfx-1997 6 ай бұрын

日常一推周深的光亮和Monster

@naej3721 25 күн бұрын

Once I heard she sang this I tried to search her other videos on KZfaq, and found some classical music opera singing. She has great talent and trained voice, she expertly uses chest and coloratura in this song

@cl1lighter 6 ай бұрын

老師應該很喜歡周深版。中秋煙花特別版👍👍

@lwhsimon6984 22 күн бұрын

霄雲依純是新生代最強女歌手。

@ycL-yt7yd 6 ай бұрын

老师的点评真的很专业，直击要害，能道出一些常人难以发现的关键问题👍。我也很喜欢黄霄云，正如老师所说，她的出现是现象级的。同时也十分认同这期老师的非常客观评价🙌，她还需要提升自己的审美，打磨自己的演绎方式。

@bigchief1210 6 ай бұрын

謝謝你的評論讓我懂了，老師的意思是黃技巧都有了，但是缺乏一點藝術家應有的個人特質，所以沒那麼吸引人

@ForeverHappy 6 ай бұрын

不要曲解Rezette 老师的意思，老师说的是黄霄雲有很好的taste，而且她在另外一期里说了黄霄雲是中国最好的女歌手之一。@@bigchief1210

@ForeverHappy 3 ай бұрын

you misunderstood Ms Rosette's comments - she actually means Huang Xiaoyun's great taste that built her skills!

@ycL-yt7yd 3 ай бұрын

unable to disagree @@ForeverHappy

@CK-gd3lb 29 күн бұрын

“It’s about her taste that built her skill.” - 絕對不是你以為的意思

@noitelin 23 күн бұрын

我很喜歡也很享受黃霄雲的表演，聽到老師的形容，再配上打了碼的畫面，真的很周深

@lemonadenbird 6 ай бұрын

Zhou Shen was the only person who does not cause my blood pressure going up when sing high notes.

@cheungh4064 6 ай бұрын

Yes, cannot afford singer always with noisy and shouting tone !

@rolandzhang9077 6 ай бұрын

这是我认为黄霄云唱的最好的一首歌

@ptolemylin914 2 ай бұрын

我個人認為，只有這一首還有點意思，結合了歌詞歌曲特有意思。其它千百首沒意思。就常常沒意義地..阿阿阿阿阿

@lilychoucrounchoucroun3466 6 ай бұрын

赶紧做一期深深和萨顶顶的《左手指月》，还有《自由行走的花》！！！

@yuhj1259 6 ай бұрын

@@bernardklein8669 can't agree more

@NLayla875 25 күн бұрын

真的要去聽一下薩頂頂的我真的是聽到開眼界！

@user-ty9et1pc7n 22 күн бұрын

每次听到都感觉人类进化不带上我的感觉

@cindy431 6 ай бұрын

Teacher u so funny, I can't stop laughing... Lol

@user-sr7op8ip6p 6 ай бұрын

建议老师可听萨顶顶和周深唱的“自由行走的花”。

@tuesdae666 6 ай бұрын

喜欢老师的积极态度。希望有机会跟老师学习。 And I do agree the Asian (Chinese) cultural songs do have more vibrato. And I would find the more traditional songs weird without that vibrato。老师说到 coco 时我哭了。即便只看过一次。 ❤

@fiona104 25 күн бұрын

以前的中文歌喜歡很多大顫音。黃的音域確實讓觀眾聽了很爽。

@contactanthony 4 ай бұрын

說得真好從來都是審美達至高度

@user-yi5jj2vz1f 6 ай бұрын

繼續敲碗起風了三種版本

@user-mz2sd9uj8n 6 ай бұрын

因為近年來古裝戲的風潮，導致中國樂壇的古風跟流行歌曲是并進的。

@lou-lu2644 6 ай бұрын

Huang Xiaoyun (Ghost) it's among my favourites singers

@cheekeonggan8441 6 ай бұрын

对呀，她也是來自貴州的女周深。什麼歌都可以唱，老師太历害了。

@tao888 24 күн бұрын

说的真中肯，黄霄云技术是一流的，但个人不太认可，一首歌是用来表达感情的是用来叙事的，而她就是缺少这一部分，很多人没这天赋唱不出这些技巧，但黄霄云是反过来的，唱得出技巧，但很多时候不能真真切切的表达和体现到歌的感动和内容

@123BLueBee 6 ай бұрын

左手指月是古典風的, 所以她選擇大顫音啊 :'D 這是她為這首歌而做的選擇和設計吧她唱Chinese pop也是很淺的顫音

@kenong28 6 ай бұрын

it's written more like a traditional chinese song, and fyi... your fav zhou shen sang this song with sa ding ding in 1 of those festive concert. it was all over the news that when zhou shen was practicing before the actual performance.. it was heard blocks away while he was practicing. you should check out zhou shen & sa ding ding version.. original song by sa ding ding

@KuanYuzhe-vb3pc 6 ай бұрын

Another Bravo performance 天下无双by ghost hwang!!!!!!!!!!!

@io520wei 2 ай бұрын

想聽聽看怎麼評論華語界顫音蜂鳥張韶涵❤

@Mikobaby1220 6 ай бұрын

這首周深也有唱過哦！廢話不多說給老師傳送門 kzfaq.info/get/bejne/ra1im8Wl3JfNlps.htmlsi=XoL72C3FFIjBiA8C

@wongtingyun 6 ай бұрын

這首殺頂頂才唱得出那種味道，黃霄雲和周深在技巧或是高音方面比得上殺頂頂，甚至可能更厲害，但兩人的高音都是輕靈舒服的類型，但殺頂頂不同，她的高音像暗藏刀鋒，十分適合左手指月那種月下舞劍，提劍指月的意境。

@dwmobusa 6 ай бұрын

hmmmm，萨顶顶，纠正一下错别字，一个平舌音一个翘舌音

@leonom7827 18 күн бұрын

也是...意境不同

@Lucky20053 24 күн бұрын

hxy我第一次听她唱歌我就感觉很惊艳而且那次艾伦沃克帮她伴奏了一首歌我当时觉得她好厉害但是好像她没有那么火在我心里她应该火起来很快的

@ingemarsong 19 күн бұрын

黄霄云会成为顶级歌手

@Bowiejai 6 ай бұрын

什麼時候出周深版本 :)

@user-tb6vg1bm1j 6 ай бұрын

希望听到周深萨顶顶版的！

@BaeLasso 14 күн бұрын

They sound similar because both Zhou and this girl were classically trained, they went to music institutes

@longgr0321 6 ай бұрын

建議可以做一個薩頂頂、周深版，讓老師聽聽、評論~

@leonardsimmers9158 6 ай бұрын

.Hi Rozette, I new you would do more Ghost Huang (Huang Xiaoyun), as you liked her as much as we do. Like you, my first introduction to her was also her audition on The Voice of China. I've seen all of her performances on it. As well as the one you just reacted to. Ghost also was in The Singer 2021. Where she was up against JJ, Zhou Shen and a few others. I especially like a song she sang loosely translated to Your Answer. Would you also like to check out Zhang Bi Chen her audition for the voice. She sings one of JJ's songs. This was back in 2014 onAlphaMV, and it's got over 10M views. And I especially like the Semifinal where she sang My Destiny (Which is from a successful kdrama). Before taking part in the voice, she was in a kpop group. But left after a year to pursue her solo career.

@user-xv6lv2nm5h 6 ай бұрын

當然這個版本也是很棒但你聽原唱你會覺得是妖魔在唱歌，黃霄雲跟周深唱的像在說一個很美的故事，而薩丁丁像是故事的主宰一樣有上帝視角述說的更驚心動魄更有穿透力更有帶入感，他們訴說這故事而薩丁丁就是故事裡的所有一草一木他就是故事本身的樣子，都很棒看個人喜好，沒辦法總有心理的比較，對我來說薩丁丁的演唱就是那個世界原本的樣子，更具張力更具戲劇性她的歌聲裡面你可以清楚看得到顏色，不可思議！

@Isdoleia 25 күн бұрын

original Singer - 薩頂頂 Sa Dingding . 希望可以讓老師也review 一原唱真的好聽很多

@lamlamlam2825 16 күн бұрын

黃霄雲-左手指月单依純-永不失聯的愛都是出道即巔峰作品比原唱有一個更昇華的演繹外老實說她們再唱一次也未必能唱回一次的感覺就是藝術品！！

@user-ig9ii3yt8l 4 ай бұрын

电视剧mv的左手指月完美！！

@dianecoolcool 16 күн бұрын

黄霄云和周深都是美声科班出身，应该有很多共同点，加上他们都是属于天赋与努力并存的青年一代，他俩是我最喜爱的新生代歌手，前途无量。

@user-de2xi7wq4y 13 күн бұрын

veryveryvery周深😂😂😂

@stevenchou7415 6 ай бұрын

期待老师评价下周深和萨顶顶的左手指月

@TSENG666 6 ай бұрын

簽到影片下方給你們點個讚👍 遇廣告看完看🈵

@tyinyu8426 23 күн бұрын

4:30 the style that Chou Shen usually uses and the singing skills that the girl used in this video, is some kind of the things that often found in Chinese traditional music drama called 京劇, while this song is also added some characteristics of traditional Chinese music. it just like a western style pop song mixed with some Chinese style features. so that's why the singer chose to use this kind of style to perform. she wanted to emphasize the Chinese style in this song and by the way, the original singer also performed like this