Despite all the "stuff" this family goes through, it is great to see the human condition forgive, continue to love, and celebrate each other. Those babies are so cute and I honestly love the way they are being raised. It's not our job to judge. Happy Birthday Gunner!!! The resilience of some of these family members is amazing to me. In a good way. 🎉❤

Happy 1st Birthday Gunner! Evie was cracking up at that stuffed toy talking. It was so good to see your Mom and Dad!

My goodness, time does fly. It's hard to believe he's already a year old. He is such a happy baby. Always smiling. Happy birthday, sweet boy!🥰🎉🎂

I love hearing Michelle talk. Her voice is so calming. So good to see your parents Joy! Happy 1st Birthday Gunner! Precious family. God bless 🙏🏼

If truth be told, I tune in to see what Evie is up to and what words of wisdom she will be sharing with us each week!!😂😂 Seriously, she is just the cutest. Happy Birthday to Gunner. Many blessings to you all!❤

Happy 1st Birthday, Gunner! Evie was laughing so much at that talking stuffed toy. It was wonderful to see your Mom and Dad! 💓😊💕🌈

Joy you are turned into such a beautiful woman. You are a kind and gentle Mom and a loving and giving Wife. Austin and the children are so lucky to have you. Your children are a reflection of the great love between you and Austin. I knew from the moment I saw him, he loved you so much. You've been through so much and you've weathered everything together.

Gunner could just swallow his world whole with his big beautiful smiles!! Happy Birthday little guy!!

Gunner is such a happy baby! I love his smiles! ❤️❤️❤️

Happy 1st Birthday Gunner! Keep on smiling 🥳🎉🎈🎂💙😊

Small bday parties with just grandparents are the best for 1 year olds❤. I love your dress joy!

Gunner is so cute he is definitely Joy’s twin that smile is everything 😊

The once adorably cute kids that I used the watch on youtube years ago have grown up and are now having adorably cute kids of their own!!! Boy, how time flies.

I love watching little ones. Good to see your parents too. God bless!

What a cutie pie!! Gideon and Evie are being such sweet brother and sister!! Beautiful family!!! Happy 1st birthday Gunner!!!

Happy Birthday Gunner to the smiley baby boy that puts joy in my heart everytime i see him.😊❤🎉

Gunner smiles at everything. I love his chubby cheeks.. He is one cute little man..🙏❤️🎂🎈🎁

Happy birthday Gunner…It was so good to see your mom and dad!

It seems like you just had little sweet Gunner. All 3 of the Children are growing fast and they are little Dolls. Happy Late Birthday Gunner🎂❤️

HAPPY BIRTHDAY GUNNER!!🥳🥳🥳🥳🎊🎉🎊🎉🎊🎈🎈🎈🎈 wow Joy it's just like you just had him and he's already one years old he is just adorable cutest little sweet little happy baby !! God Bless You and your Family!!😇🙏🏾🥰❤️❤️❤️❤️💙💙💙💙

Happy 1st Birthday Gunner!🥳 You guys have the cutest kiddos!!! Love how Gideon is working hard not to suck his thumb! You can do it big guy! Evie cracks me up😂 Gunner’s grin🥰 Love your videos!

Loved seeing your parents!. Everyone is humans and has their own skeletons. It's good to get along. so glad family got to celebrate gunner!. Happy birthday little man!

What a angel gunner is. I do think he looks just like ma ma. You make life so special and so easy. Your older boy and evil are getting so big. Oh what beautiful balloons. Oh he loves his cake. I am so happy all of you are together your mother your seiblings. Joy you have that touch motherly touch. Great for your father too I sorta wrote it backwards,. Gunner sure got a lot of presents. Everyone loved that talking animal. Evie laughing so hard. God bless all of you your mom and has raised Christian children’s.

Happy 1st birthday to Gunner. Children are growing up so fast.

Man o Man Evie just cracks me up every video, she is just go go go. She is so much fun. Joy all your kiddos are just. A delight to watch, makes me miss my kids now they are all grown up and are now a bit more subdued. ❤🇦🇺🙏

Hi Joy and Austin! Such beautiful children, sending big hugs your way! Joy, you are so pretty, just like your Momma! 🩷

Happy Birthday Gunner! So good to see your Mom and Dad.

Happy birthday Gunner! I can't believe he is a year old already. Evie melted my heart when she looked into the camera and said "it's ok thunder is so cool."

❤Happy 1st Birthday, Gunner!! Gunner has to be the happiest baby I’ve ever seen and his personality began to develop at birth….at least it seemed that way to me., each of your children have a unique specialness about them. I’m curious to see how their little lives unfold. Love n prayers to all of you! 🙏🏻🙏🏻💜💜🍰🍰🎈🎊🎉

Raining cats and dogs comes from the Middle Ages in England when a roof was made of thatch ( thick grass). Cats and dogs would climb up into the roof to keep warm. When it rained, the thatch would become slippery and the animals would fall into the house. Hence raining cats and dogs.

What a sweet moment as the children hugged papa as he went to work. You guys are super adorable!!! Happy Birthday little man!!🎉🥳

Evie is so funny! “That’s nuts”😂

Happy Birthday Gunner! Such a beautiful boy. I love his smile and happiness every time. Thank you for sharing eith us. You have such a wonderful beautiful family. Enjoy your videos always.

🎉happy birthday baby boy, joy thanks for sharing your real life with all. Love your family❤

Regardless of what some people may think it was good to see Jim Bob and Michelle again!! The kids thinking that cats and dogs were literally going to fall out of the sky with the rain was so cute!! Gideon is trying so hard to break the thumbsucking habit!! HAPPY 1ST BIRTHDAY GUNNER 🎂🎁🎈💙💙

Sweet Gunner is growing so fast, happy birthday to the little guy! I love when we get to see your parents, I miss them so much! They aren't perfect, none of us are, but they are still wonderful people who raised a wonderful family. Much love to you all from Wilsonville Oregon

I love watching your sweet babies learning and doing things. Evie is such a sweetheart, soothing her baby brother so he won’t be scared. I love it!

Happy Birthday Gunner! I love watching Gunner smile, he can light up any room. 🎂🎊🎁🎉

Gunner reminds me of my cousin's son when he was a baby. Always smiling and sweet. Didn't cry and was very calm. Now he is a hyper pre-teen..... lol

Lovely practical family 1st birthday celebration without all the showing off features… just like taking them to Disneyland, too young, they don’t remember keep it simple and happy is the best I think…just like every day life!

Happy birthday to your baby boy. I love the innocence of children. It rains cats and dogs.😉 I'm french Canadian and we say you can stand and drink. I miss this period with small kids around. Enjoy this beautiful time for tomorrow they will be all grown up.

Happy Birthday Gunner! You have the cutest kids! 💗

Oh nooooo! Say it isn’t so! Gunner is already a year old! That just does not seem possible! Happy Birthday sweetness! 🎂🥞🎁🎉🎈🧸❤️

Happy 1st Birthday Gunner! It was so nice seeing your Mom and Dad. Peace and Blessings everyone ✝️

Beautiful birthday celebration for Gunner!🎂all your babies are adorable but he’s the image of you joy!

Happy 1st birthday 🎂 Gunner . Many blessings to you and your family ❤

Thank you for sharing your beautiful family with us! It is truly such a blessing to have watched you grow up and now watching your beautiful children and your family grow. God bless you and your beautiful family!

I always love seeing your precious mom and dad! Thanks for sharing family time with us

Wonderful to see a loving, intact family ❤ thanks for sharing your life

Bless his beautiful heart❤️ he clearly loves the cake, happy birthday to gunner!

Your mom is the sweetest woman with the most comforting demeanor. You're all very lucky to have such a great family...Despite any negativity from people who will never truly understand certain things. Happy birthday to your cute little nugget. Those cheeks are so squeezable! 😂🤍🤍

I love seeing kids like that excited and being happy and gunner is soooo cute 😍

Happy birthday Gunner 🎉it was so sweet to see your Mom and Dad there. Evoke is always the life of the party she is little miss personality.❤❤

Do very nice to see your mom and dad joy. They look good. And it’s been a while it’s so nice to see how excited all the kids gets with gift opening always wanting to help the little one to open their gifts. So cute. Goes on in every family

Happy Birthday Gunner!!! It's so good to see your family together! I'm so glad to see Jim Bob and Michelle! Happy Times for your family!

Happy birthday Gunner! I can't believe he's one year old already, that's year flew by so fast! I enjoyed Gideon and Evelyn were big brother and big sister helping Gunner eat his birthday cake and then helped Gunner opened his birthday presents! It's so nice to see both sets of grandparents!

Love the steps in front of house, and the deck looks so nice. Awesome you two!! Happy 1st Birthday Gunner!!

Good to see grandma and grandpa duggar!!❤

Happy birthday, Gunner! Blessings to all!!❤️

So many sweet moments! Happy Birthday Gunner! Thank you for sharing.

Happy Birthday Gunner. I can’t believe it’s been a year already. ❤❤❤❤❤

Happy 1st Birthday Gunner!!! So sweet. The kids are always so adorable.

Happy Birthday, Big Boy! Good to see the family!

I always look forward to your Friday video. The children are precious. Love the teamwork of you and your husband. I enjoy seeing the work he is doing on homes. Have a great weekend!

Love your family and loved seeing your mom and dad!!! God Bless you all.

Happy Birthday Gunner!🎁 Loved watching the vblog. Thanks for sharing!

Happy Birthday Gunner! I was happy to see your mom and dad there. Have a Blessed weekend .

I just love that smile of his! He's adorable, you guys! Happy Birthday little guy!

HAPPY 1st BIRTHDAY, Gunner!!! I love the colors of the balloons!!

My heart. It was so nice to see your dad...I'll never understand the world we live in when people who preach forgiveness don't practice it. I send y'all love and prayers and hope for healing. Gunner is precious, happy birthday!!!

Happy birthday handsome gunner 🎉🎁🎂🎈🥳❤️❤️

Such a beautiful family y'all!! ❤

Happy 1st birthday Gunner! He has the sweetest smile 💙🎂🎁

Thank you for sharing Evie! Beautiful t❤️❤️❤️! May God bless you all!!❤️🙏🏻❤️Happy birthday Gunner!🎉🥳🎂😊

Happy birthday bud!!! 🎂 so glad to see your parents are doing well ❤

Happy birthday Gunner 🎂🎉. Blessings to the entire family🙏

What a wholesome birthday celebration! Good family time! Thanks for sharing!

Precious baby❤❤Loved seeing your mom and dad too

Your very welcome Evy! Thank you for sharing with us.

Happy Happy First birthday 🎂 Gunner.. Soo precious.. Hugs sent from me to y'all...

Happy 1st Birthday Gunner, where did that year go. He is such a smiley little boy so cute. You have a lovely family. 🙏🏻🫶 God Bless You. xx

So fun Joy love watching your blogs with the children you can tell how much you love them because you never yell at them unless you are out side and then if you did not yell the children would not hear you I love you all so much and God bless you and all your families ❤️ ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

HAPPY birthday Gunner your such a bundle of joy to watch!!!

Aww poor kids were really worried about those ‘cats & dogs’ out in the rain,😂 so sweet! Evy didn’t want the dogs to sink! 🥺😬

Joy your a natural on camera! Your videos are a lot of fun and inspiring. Thank you Joy!

Can't wait to see the new vlog and hope you guys have a great Friday afternoon and evening with the kids and a wonderful weekend ahead and happy belated birthday Gunner is so cute and adorable and can't believe he is already 1 year old and hope he likes his first birthday celebration.

Happy Birthday precious boy. Your 1 today. Time needs to slow down. Your littles are growing up….. they are all so precious❤️❤️❤️🍰🎂🎈🧸🧁🥳🎶🎼🎵

Happiest birthday sweet Gunner! Blessings 🎉❤

Yes Indeed…It’s really hard to believe it’s been a whole year. WOW!!! I love the balloon colors you picked. I’ve never seen the green color before. 👍😊 HAPPY BIRTHDAY GUNNER‼️🎼🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶 🎂🥳🙋🏻‍♀️💖

Such happy, loving little ones. ❤

Happy 1st birthday, Gunner! God bless you! 🙏❤

Beautiful party!! Happy birthday Gunner!!

Happy 1st Birthday sweet Gunner! You are such a blessing! 🎂🎶🎈🥳💕🙏

Sweet video. Love seeing your family.

Happy first birthday to the smiliest baby!!🎉🎈

Happy birthday, Gunner🎉❤

Happy birthday, that cake looks yummy. Many blessings to you all. Blessings 🙏

What a cute video! That dress looks so pretty on you Joy!

Happy Birthday Gunner!! Can't believe he's already one!! He's so cute!! ❤

Happy birthday, Gunner! 🎉