The part where Harry loses his temper in Dumbledore's office in the book,should've been in the movie. It was so intense.

This was the the strongest scene in the book but movie ruined it

Book Dumbledore: Dumbledore asked calmly Movie Dumbledore: HARRY DID YA PUT CHA NAME IN DA GOBLET OF FIA!!!!!!! Book Harry: Shouting at Dumbledore while breaking everything in the room Movie Harry: Harry asked calmly

'I know how you feel, Harry' 'No, you don't'. Actually, Dumbledore knew. He lost his sister and taught it was his fault for his whole life. Harry will do the same for Sirius

"Do carry on breaking my possessions, I daresay I have far too many." I always cry when Dumbledore talks about "another old man's mistake." (I'm going to cry just typing this, thinking about it...)

Order of the Phoenix should have made two movies. This movie was absolutely not up to scratch (especially this intense, brilliantly written scene from the books)

Just finished reading this scene from the book. Wanted to watch how it would play out in a movie. Sorely disappointed.

I like how when Harry says that dumbeldore doesn’t understand him it really shows that Harry is only a teenager

I feel like they bonded more in the book, Harry lost his temper, at the end he calmed down

This scene could have been so much better. Especially for people who've never read the books and are only fans of the movies. They still never explained exactly WHY Harry was part of the prophecy and why Voldemort was truly so desperate to kill Harry as a baby. That part was very frustrating. Surely they could have added just a few short minutes of this scene to have Dumbledore explain to Harry the history of the prophecy and why he was chosen.

I love the movies, but I love the books even more, and they totally missed the mark on this scene. It should have stayed true to the book. I would argue this was the most important scene in the entire series. A complete and total end of innocence, that moved the series from being the kid-friendly story, to being an epic finish and story of growth. This marked the beginning of Harry's journey as a hero, and wrapped up things happening by unexplained things. most importanly, this scene in the book was a recap of the first 5 books, and explained what was going to happen in the final two.

I understand why they cut a lot out of the movie, but reading this after watching the movies (yes, I'm one of those people) I couldn't help but have an ugly cry moment. Now I'm pretty disappointed they cut so much out of this scene.

"HARRY DID YOU PUT YER NAME IN DAH GOBLET OF FIYAH!!!!" Dumbledore asked calmly. " *softly* It's my fault..." Harry screamed, so loudly that he felt his throat might tear but also the lighting in this scene is beautiful...Dumbledores kind of in a slightly warmer light while harrys still in greens. But at the very last second when Dumbledore says his final words of comfort, the lighting on Harry turns warm too!!!

Awhhh, I really feel bad for Harry. Nearly everyone he loved, died. Lily, James, Sirius, Dobby, Hedwig, etc..

Harry’s outburst was heartbreaking in the books because he has suicidal thoughts at 15 YEARS OLD! But no one can blame him for why he wanted out, the drama he had to go through was too much.

"Harry, did you put you name in the goblet of fire?" Book: Dumbledore asks calmly Movie: DUMBLEDORE GOES ON A RAMPAGE Harry and Dumbledore talk in The Order of the Phoenix: Book: HARRY GOES ON A RAMPAGE Moive: Harry talks calmly

this is my favorite scene in the books, it is so intense and sad, and it is the moment when we see the weight that Harry has of the wizarding world on his back. I don't accept that the movie ruined my favorite scene.

I'm feel sorry for Harry Potter for losing his godfather. It reminds me of when I lost my grandmother. I think and feel it in my heart that their are times were I blame myself for never being their for her. But something tells me to never blame myself. I continue to understand that death is a natural part of life and that even if we lose our loved ones physically they are never truly gone because they are in here ❤. Remember the good times we've have had with our family members even our elders and if we remember those times well than they are never truly gone. I miss you grandma so much and I love you with all my heart. God knows I love you so much. I hope to see you and grandpa and my family again. Thank you for being their in my life for all our lives.

This should have been a two part movie

Scene aside, I just love the music here. It's so close in style and sound to the soundtrack of Half-blood Prince movie and this makes me feel like there is this slight connection between the two movies, as if the production wanted you to feel like the movies are not just separated things in a franchise but they are all connected like a stream of happenings of the same story. Of course there wasn't such an intention but this is what I feel when I hear this music piece and I think it's beautiful.

Why couldn't someone have just said to Harry, "Voldemort might try to lure you to the DOM, don't go"? How is that hard?

This scene was so sad in the books. Harry expressed suicidal thoughts

In the book, when it got to this scene, at the end of the chapter, it said, “Harry looked up at him and saw a tear trickling down Dumbledore’s face and into his long silver beard.”

Never mind me. I am just writing a letter to the *BOOK* Dumbledore. Dear professor, You say that Sirius was old enough to not take Snape's comment about him being a coward seriously and that he should have just listened to you and stayed inside instead of coming to the ministry. I agree with all these, but when are you ever going to tell Snape that he is waaaaay to old to keep grudges against gryffindors, treat slytherins like heroes even if they don't deserve it, call a man a coward for following orders, hate Harry for looking like his father, bully Neville for he could have been the chosen one meaning lily wouldn't have died, taunt Hermione for being smart and mistreat other kids cause his childhood was bad? Also, you are almost indirectly saying that Sirius kind of deserved what he got, for he mistreated Kreacher being the reason why Kreacher sold him to Bellatrix (well, personally I hated how Sirius treated Kreacher, but right now?). You know what, it's 40% your fault that Sirius mistreated Kreacher, for you locked him up alone in a place he did not even want to see. And, you are saying all this to Harry. HARRY, who lost his only fatherly figure, his godfather just less than an hour ago. How are you doing this? You totally know how it feels like, don't you? Your friendship with Grindelwald being the reason Ariana died. And still, how can you tell all these to Harry? Maybe you wanted Harry to feel better and understand it wasn't his fault Sirius died but is this how you say it? By blaming Sirius and making it look like he deserved what he got? THIS IS SO UNFAIR! Yours sincerely, Nobody Ahh, that feels good. So good to finally write it down somewhere.

This scene is sooo important and very long in the book. It really frustrates me that they made it like that. People who don't know the books are missing central aspects of the whole harry potter saga

This was my favourite scene in the book.I was so much disappointed when they didn't show Harry screaming and thrashing everything.It was so intense and emotional.

Book Harry: destroys dumbledores freaking office while shouting things like “I DONT CARE!” And planning on hitting dumbledore and running away Movie Harry: calm

Why have they shown harry so calm... In the book he was shouting at Dumbledore and this scene was so intense

0:07 Albus Dumbledore: entiendo cómo te sientes, Harry Harry Potter: no lo sabe, es mi culpa Albus Dumbledore: No es mi culpa, sabía que era cuestión de tiempo antes que Voldemort, supiera la conexión entre ustedes, ¿creí a distanciado de ti? cómo lo hecho todo el año, el tendría menos interés, y por lo tanto tú estarías más protegido Harry Potter: la profecía decía: "ninguno de los dos vivirá si el otro sobrevive" significa ¿que uno de los dos ahí que matar al otro al final? Albus Dumbledore: Si Harry Potter: ¿por qué no me lo dijo? Albus Dumbledore: por lo misma razón, que intentaste de salvar a Sirius, la misma razón en la que tus amigos te salvaron, por qué después de tantos años seré todo lo que has sufrido, no quería causarte más dolor, tú me importas mucho

The movies never explained why Voldemort wanted to kill Harry in the first place. I didn’t read the book before the movie and I had no idea what was the point of the prophecy or why Voldemort wanted and or knew about it. I don’t understand, why would they cut out one the most important of the series were we finally find out why Harry’s parents died. I was let wondering for years.

The book explains so much better than this scene. 2 minutes can never do justice to the book.

1:34 Hello, Mr. Director!

I wanted to see Harry destroy Dumbledore's office so badly! Ugh!

RIP Dumbledore :(

Book dumbledor:he asked calmly Movie dumbledor:DIDYAPUTYANAMEINTHEGOBLETOFFIRE

Am I the only one who remembers this scene looking different? I remember there being a really great shot that pans over to Harry when Dumbledore says he cares about him too much

Funny thing is Dumbledore does care about Harry but only his role in his plans. That’s why he’s such an interesting complex character

The one with the power to vanquish the Dark Lord approaches....

i just..really wanted the scene where harry loses his temper to be in the movie....

Overall I thought the movie was pretty good but for me 2 things were sorely missing: The lack of Occlumency and the effect the memory had on Harry and the scene where Hrry rages at dumbledore :/ 2 of my fave scenes as well

I kinda understand why Harry doesn’t destroy Dumbledores office in the movie. From the filmmakers point of view, it would’ve probably felt very awkward, especially after the final battle. But it’s such a good scene in the book, and it makes reading the Half Blood Prince even sadder. Because you know that while Harry is destroying Dumbledores stuff and being an asshole to him, Dumbledore only has 1 year left to live

The moment I read the scene is Dumbledore’s office at 11 y.o. I believe my childhood was over)

The death of sirius was like losing his parents all over again for Harry. The scene where Harry yells at dumbledore, saying he wants to give up, is one of the best chapters in the books. I cried so hard reading that like I screamed into my pillow. Its one of those scenes where you forget that you are reading a book. And afterwards when I thought everything was over, He asked Nick if Sirius will be back as a ghost which made me cry all over again. Oh and I forgot to mention that when Sirius died, Harry was waiting for Sirius to come from the other side of the veil... Also in the movies we dont see how much harry dreads to say his godfather's name. I think all this is because we dont have that narrative voice in the movies so we dont see how harry feels in all of this.

Somehow I always idolized Dumbledore, he was my favourite character(well he's still pretty cool tho) because he was so calm and collected in times of crisis. Little did I know how manipulative he actually was. He orchestrated everything so well. And at the end of the Deathly Hallows my affection went to Snape(like it could've been any different). I know that literally everybody had mentioned it already but I really liked the way how in the book Harry went emotional and started shouting and breaking Dumbledore's stuff, this scene was much more powerful in the book

*I CAN'T EVEN TYPE* the words from the book where Harry rage at his office and destroying all of his items, it was so painfully sad to even read it

This scene in the books was madness. Harry was shouting and smashing everything he could find in Dumbledore’s office, some of them prized possessions. I think this scene is better though because I can’t really imagine Daniel Radcliffes calm, easy going portrayal of Harry doing that.

In the book, Harry was so angry and disrespectful to Dumbledore he kept yelling and shouting at him. Here, they're talking 'calmly'

0:40 not protected enough and you could have told him or the others before.

1:17 i care too much about you....

Shoutout to anyone to recognized this was music from Half-Blood Prince.

I love how in the book Dumbledore refers to this prophecy, which might not even have come true if Voldemort ignored it, as the greatest burden in Harry's life and then goes like "oh and btw Harry, a part of Voldemort's soul is living inside you and you will have to sacrifice yourself for him to become mortal"

Dumbledor: I know how you feel Me: have you been possessed by a serial killer and seen your family right in front of you I think not

In the book, we know now why Harry has to stay his aunt’s & uncle’s home even though both Vernon & petunia had no love for their nephew Harry.

Movies books all of them are awesome nothing is ruined

A little bit of heroism theme in this melancholy score at 0:51-54

I still don't understand why so many people hate dumbledore

Did they ever talk about in the movie that Sybill Trewlawney was making those prophecies? And that is why Dumbledore had to keep her in the castle? I can’t remember...

By far my favorite Order of the Phoenix moment.... In the book, of course! Why didn't David Yates included it?

Man see harry feeling so sad it make me want to put my action together to support harry no matter what even I really want to be in the movie no matter what & harry it not your fault ok it voldemort fault ok & your only 15 year old ok & Sirius is watching over you now in spirit in your heart no matter what 😉

Anyone know what is the named of music in the firt of this scene

Dumbledore put Harry in danger again, he knew that being beside him Voldemort would never touch him but he didn't, he was distanced from Harry during all that year and look at what happened, Umbridge was about to become the owner of Hogwarts and Fudge was about to be the owner of the world of the magic

There must be a mistake! There must be an angry Harry somewhere! Just like in the books!

Remind me again how much money and seconds they saved by eliminating Neville's correspondence to the prophecy?

One of the most emotional, revealing and significant chapters of the entire series, when Harry finally snaps, when Dumbledore finally admits how much he's put Harry through... Cut down to a few half-hearted sentences. Really shows how badly the quality of these adaptations fell off after Prisoner of Azkaban 🤦

Hate how Harry says Albus doesnt know how he is feeling because yes he does. He lost gellert and Ariana and felt just like Harry

One of the few scenes that I would disagree of what Dumbledore did to Harry throughout his 5th school year. Why would he distance himself from Harry thinking that Voldemort would be less tempted, when clearly Harry needs protection from Dumbledore after everything that he had been through? The Ministry boycotting him, the majority of the school turning against him, and he lost his godfather. Dumbledore should know that he’s in the same predicament as Harry.

What if they made him calm because They didn't want Daniel to play Angry Harry that often,like earlier in the film he already lashes out too much.

what is the name of this soundtrack

What is OST ?

I'm still don't get it why Dumbledore try and distances himself from Harry

Maybe Mr maybe it’s so heartbreakingI know it’s just my opinion that I know pain better than any other maybe would have been better but still I don’t know I hope you understand Mr

It took Fudge a whole year to realze that Harry Potter was right. He believed his carrer as Minister went the toilet. Making Umbridge a teacher at Hogwats and sending Dumbledore were a bad idea. He must of Fired Umbridge for pending the witch and wizard community against one boy. Harry lost his godfather Voldemort and his Death Eater goons were out there. The Good news is the Ministry got one of Voldemort's generals.

I feel over all, that this movie is an improvement over the book (the only movie to have that accomplishment imo). But if there was one scene that the book did far better then the movie it was this scene. they could've easily packed in so much more dialogue with only a few minutes more of runtime, but I wouldn't go so far that the movie ruined it.

I first read the video title as "Dumbledore and Harry talk about the pregnancy" 🙄

This movie should have 2 parts, the movie “ Deathly Hollow “ has 2 parts , the books of “ order of Phoenix “ is thicker than Deathly hollow

England is not the only place there is magic I look at it more as cultural magic, and the English magic is like an erased culture, a lost language, so to speak, around the world there are Norse cultures who use the runes, as their type of magic, and the Chinese and Japanese who use Buddhism as a type of spell. Some aspects state Buddhism is not magic while others do state that it is. Creating spells with elemental magic, tattva mudra is my favorite. I know there are real published works of alchemist called Nicolas’s flamel he was a real guy, so maybe it’s not all conspiracy, tattva

0:08

So much better in the books.

What’s the song playing in the background?

I liked it better in the book when Harry lost his temper.

Can't even hear it.

Delete scenes from the mauraders would be great

In books this scene felt just majestic and glorious and etc., Movie kinda didn't gave justice to it

movies botching scenes like these makes me look forward to the TV show.

Why are they all moaning whwn they got hurt like stop my dirty mind cant😩😩😩

I never understood why it was so hard to try and kill someone that literally killed your family

Even it's just a movie I still hate Voldemort....

Is anyone else besides me a little irritated/disappointed that the scene in Dumbledore’s office in the movie wasn’t the same as the book? The part in the book was so intensifying. We see a completely different side of Harry and for the first time in his life he is ANGRY at Dumbledore. Why couldn’t they have stuck to that in the movie? 😠😠

This is unbelievably lame. Not just in comparison to the book, but as a scene itself is completely unremarkable. It's as if they're discussing the weather.

Harry Potter I think you are the red ranger a Power Rangers mystic force

sorry but this scene absolutely SUCKS in comparison to the book scene

I think that Dumbledore had too much influence on Harry's life. Mentoring is one thing but manipulating is a bit too much.

No you don’t You standing there YOU *Throw something* Previous Profesor in picture *really* You can keep throwing i dare say i have too many Movie ruined my favorite scenes in this book we never saw harry lose his temper ,anger and hurt and hate scenes are the scenes stealer you shouldn’t cut it

Weak (in comparison to the book)

COPYRIGHTS!!!