You know that this is playback? Obviously her voice isn't suited for pop rock at all. Girl couldn't sing even if her life depended on it.

Yes, i thought the same, the choruses are a dead give away, really off putting since the verses sound very natural.

They think we dumb 😅

Executives are letting “singers” lip singing a whole concert these days lmao.

Hahahahha I’m glad I wasn’t the only one who noticed it

I love this song too. I love hilary in general. I suffer from anxiety n depression n this song helps alot

Yes!

VERY well said! 👍👌

Omg i just cried for the first time today after listening to this song so many times for so many years. Catharsis

Same т_т

Yes. Their 2000s releases are pop rock and pop punk: Hilary Duff, Lindsay Lohan, Miley Cyrus, Demi Lovato and Selena Gomez. Even Ashley Tisdale's 2nd album "Guilty Pleasure" is pop rock. Maybe it's because of the popularity of Avril Lavigne, Kelly Clarkson, Ashlee Simpson, Michelle Branch and Paramore.

Because Disney is sick of pop stars

@@xavierrose8208 No, it was because the 2000s was ruled by Avril Lavigne

Not Vanessa Hudgens

@@benugobenugo5621 she was so far from that vibe in the mind of execs since she wasn't white. Wouldn't have worked for the demographics.

Rachel's loss

Her Signature Hand Over Mouth Is My Fave

Thought I was the only one that notice that signature move lmao

Luis Enrique Vera Cervantes I accidentally read this as ‘I’m a methhead’ 😂

I've imagined a combination Dream Theater/Hilary Duff tribute band called Ytse McGuire. This song is one of the HD songs in the repertoire.

There's a mashup of this song and Evanescence's "Bring Me to Life".

That same drummer toured with Hannah Montana and is seen in season one

@@CSReed If I'm not mistaken, her name is Alicia Warrington. She used to be the drummer of the Canadian rock band Lillix.

+Brandon Frabel agreed

It was all live

@@watherby29 yeah no.

@@JakobTennisMB Why do you think so? What's the point so singing part of the song live?

@@JakobTennisMB sure yes.

Sadly she didn't sing live back then. Maybe some pre-recorded sections on a couple songs (There are live performances of Fly where her voice soubd live at the verses and playbsck at the chorus but the verses are pre-recorded). She sang love on her comeback with her "Breathe In. Breathe out" album. She performed her single SPARKS singing live over the recorded version but you still can hear her singing and she sang TATTOO live in her backyard3

Search the the Dignity tour, there's a KZfaq vid of the entire concert, she's singing live and you can tell cause you can hear her breathing and such(use headphones if you have em), she sounds almost identical to the studio version of the songs, it's crazy, I never knew she could actually sing that well, live, the entire time I've been a fan(since I was 11, I'm 32 now) until literally today when I stumbled across it, blew my miiiind.

@@AmbyrAllenunfortunately they aren’t live. they add the breathing parts so that you’ll think exactly that. sorry:(

@@gracewilloughby4745 no waaaaaaay really??? Like every single time she performs no matter what?? Cause there's like one or two videos floating around of her performing in like Sao Paulo or somewhere with blonde hair, I think it was her second album tour, she sounds live there too! Ahhh my dreams are crushed hahaha

There is a small Button under her heel that activates the playback with the movement. That's why.

no, this is obviously full playback

@@ToxDuris It's not. I can tell the difference.

@@nicorizzo5402 did covid make you def?

@@ToxDuris I posted this before covid dumbass. But no, I'm a musician so I have a very well trained ear. You just haven't had as much ear training as I have.

@@ToxDuris Right there in the opening couple lines, in the studio recording she breaks her breath whereas here she keeps her breath straight, and on "shoulder" she stays on the same note here whereas in the studio recording she went down a minor second. If you had a well trained ear and had listened to the studio recording this would be obvious to you.

Find a dream you can

nword ortiz well it was 2004

it is a girl, it would be cool if she didn't look like a man though,lol

I think that's Alicia Warrington. She has also worked with Miley Cyrus (as Hannah Montana) and Selena Gomez. She used to be the drummer of Canadian all-girl rock band Lillix.

That's Shauney Baby. Yes, that's what she goes by. She's toured with Sting, Pussycat Dolls, Will.I.am...and Hilary.