Antony might be the worst value for money signing I’ve seen!

Sabitzer was a hit, he played well, he was better than mount was in that midfield, he provided more rigidity, could complement the dm and cm and ETH should have retained him

James and flav - deadly combo I love it

Great pair James and flav, ran into them at fleet services last year. Amazing experience.

Thanks for having me on lads! ❤

The fact he's had to have so many loan players says it all about where Utd are at.

I think reguilon has been incredible when he’s played for united the fact that people talk crap about him is ridiculous he is so much more attacking a positive really hope the sign him in January

How is sabitzer in tbd when he's been and gone 😭

The mason Mount transfer is a miss for me based on all aspects; 1. The fee- he was available for free next summer so at 60mil this is his cut price value? So if he had 4 years left he’d be worth 100mil? Of course not 😂. He wanted out too so united should have hovered around 30-40mil TOPS. . 2. Necessity- ETH doesn’t seem to know how to use him? All that money for the bench? Him and Bruno won’t work together but Bruno doesn’t get dropped even when crap so bench it is then? 3. Player quality- some say he’s underrated some say he’s average, he’s a system player but united don’t have a system, also he’s been on a downward trajectory for Chelsea for a little while too.

Good video. Cant beat the Jaffn duo! Would like to hear Joe's opinion a bit more especially on a Man Utd topic.

The players as an individual being judged as a hit or miss is Utds transfer problems in a nutshell. Sure Casamiro and Erikson are good ideas as individuals. But when you look at them in the team dynamic they don't make much sense. You've already got Fernandes who doesn't defend doesn't have the legs and you bring in an older version of him and an aging Casamiro you can't expect the team to function with energy and defensive accument. Then when you take into consideration they're shielding Evans and Macguire the issues become quite clear.

Get James and Flav on here every week

Shocking defending by Joel Glazer against Newcastle. Should’ve been tracking almirons run for the first goal embarrassing. Glazers out

I appreciate everyone here for genuinely examining the players irregardless of overall club from (this is from a Liverpool fan)

Antony is definitely a miss. 85m for 8 goals. 😂

11:00 Did he really just base his opinion on a player from an overall Sofascore rating for the last 12 months? Go look it up right now - it's exactly 7.06 like he said. Not only is that number wrong in this context because it includes international and German games, but it proves that he has not seen Manchester United play last spring, because Sabitzer didn't pass the eye test.

What makes it worse for Antony is that Ten Hag personally wanted him

Absolutely obsessed with man united.

The only hits should be Martinez and Casemiro , that's a 12% success rate on incoming players and that's abysmal.

I don’t understand the idea of them saying “with a better manager” like Ten Hag massively overachieved last season I don’t see another coach doing that with this squad. They need to stop talking about changing managers and commit to the project or we will be in the same position in a year or 2

How is malacia not a hit 14m is great value and had good impact

we still haven’t seen a game plan from ETH, it seems like last season all they’d do it set up to be solid at the back and hope rashford/bruno do something special and a lot of the time it would work or casemiro would pop up with a goal. If u look back at arteta or klopps first couple seasons they atleast had a way of playing, they didn’t have the players to do it well enough yet but u could say give them time and it’ll work.

Hit or miss describes Antony pretty well tbf

I believe you should show the guest’s club to give a better view of us the audience to understand the arguments made by them.If bias plays a factor when discussing about the team that they support as well as their rivals, because we don’t know all your guest’s football clubs and it might give a better insight imo.

Casemiro?? He was good last season, but thats enough for 70mn, one season??? Ridiculous

Enclusive, keep em coming.

Casemiro was brought much like Varane to bring much needed big game experience as well as a title winning mentality.Think they are brilliant signings. As for the rest, most people commenting on here don't even watch United and know nothing about ETH style. They watch a hightlight reel on MoTD and all if sudden they think they can have a informative conversation. Makes me laugh, but it is clear to see what ETH is trying build. Injuires and the club stupid preseason tour messed everything up. As for Antony being a flop his 22 years of age. I don't care about his price tag thats the clubs fault if they think they paid to much ots on them. Far to early to judge. He has time on his side. He offers far more then previous United wingers, have in our recent past. Including Rashford and Sancho. We have far more balance when his on the right wing. His season last year wasn't terrible it was ok for a young player stepping up into what everyone calls the hardest league in the world. His second season is hindered not only by the obvious off-field issues, but also the team in general hasn't clicked, especially the attack. He tends to get most of the blame, much like Bruno. Whilst a certain other few individuals get support and backing. I hope we stick with ETH and Antony as well, i believe they will come good and make us a genuine threat in this league but its going to take time.

Casemiro and Evans are short-term fixes, not hits.

Bring on james every show!!

Spot-on and a very balanced panel

There were relative hits, but in a vacuum they're all misses.

Johnny Evans a hit at 73! Those legs not gone then?? Him and Macguire were splendid together 🤣🤣

Antony has beaten more women than leftbacks this season.

JAFFN lads are the best as always!

eriksen needs to play he creates crazy he had injury in the second half of the season but i believe he is integral to the team for atleast 2 seasons

4th choice LB from spurs is madness, well it is what happens when your first two choice LB are out injured. It clearly was just a stop gap to cover injuries.

It’s not even the lack of goals from Anthony it’s more his general contribution otherwise (or lack of) he can’t pass, can’t go past a man, can’t cross. No wonder poor Rasmus isn’t getting any goals.

Only Forwards 👈😄👉🐌

Antony was such an obviously terrible signing. At least with Sancho he was putting up genuinely world class numbers at such a young age, still a poor transfer but the logic is there. Antony scored 12 goals in the Dutch league and apparently that justified 85 million quid.

Not saying ETH is faultless, but alot of these points should be levelled at the club rather than him. Had months to start putting work in before he even arrived yet they sat on their hands. From failing to sign his priority targets to paying a premium for club's unwanted players, from failing to move players on or sign efficiently for the future, the club is failing yet another manager. Just look at the fact we paid £72M for a player that moved last year for £15M, when our ST was 37 years old going into the season & that Antony went from being rumoured at £40M in June to £86M when we signed him.

fun fact, Maguire has scored more goals than Anthony this year

6:43 what a fake sip 😂

Kind of poinless rating emergency loans like Sabitzer, Weghorst and Reguillon no? Surely just rate the permanent players he's signed.

James and Flav 🔥🔥🔥🔥

Man, Sky sports doing great getting Quavo on Saturday Social

Sabitzer on TBD?!?! He’s literally not even there anymore. NOTHING more can "be determined" later at this stage!😂

Licha needs to be paired with Casa, he’s got everything for a perfect DM

I'm thinking injuries isn't an excuse. If you buy a car that is prone to being at the workshop all the time you're probably thinking that it's a crappy buy, especially if you payed loads of money on it.

Hojlund has to be a hit for me! I have no doubt he’s going to be class.

Malacia is a hit. You dont spend 14 mill on a starting player at man united. Clearly a back up player and has been very good in a lot of games. Unfair to judge him being a hit or a miss because of 1 injury. Shaw is permanently injured.

Could’ve saved 5 mins by just putting anyone who signed in the summer straight into TBD, but guess that doesn’t make for good viewing, apparently…

The only hit is casemiro and Ten Hag didn't want to sign him

These ratings sections are a waste of time when they're rated on their quality, rather than performance. If so many players are a hit why are Utd in 8th?

Is there any such thing as a Man United supporter from Manchester?

Why didn't Avram Glazer score four bicycle kicks from halfway to save Man united against Newcastle? Disgraceful, Glazer's out

HOW is Sabitzer TBD?! He's not at the club anymore!

Dunno, Dubravka might be a hit just cause it meant Newcastle didn't have him in the cup final and with Pope banned and the backup injured that one might just have won you silverware

James and Flav need to be on every week

i look back at them signing antony for that price and just laugh, they could’ve got gakpo for around 50m a few weeks prior to getting antony who had better numbers and he could play as a striker aswell as a winger, meaning he and rashford could’ve developed a good relationship where they interchange in games based on the opponent. I know this whole sancho situation is crazy but at the start of last season i would’ve signed gakpo and had a front 3 of rashford gakpo and sancho

Spot on 👍

Is there really a hit in any of these??? Hojlund could become a hit. Case has been half decent, but I wouldn’t put a single one in hit.

there we go the media keep on hammering united! let’s start at united being the team most negatively impacted by var! money must be changing hands

Come on lads. Antony has to be a 'hit'

The biggest thing about Anthony is he hasn’t got the pace to beat a player so he rolls his foot over the ball a couple of times to make it look like he’s trying something and then just cuts back inside and plays a simple pass. How can the recruitment not see that?? How are other clubs able to sign quality wingers for half the price? Gordon at Newcastle is a great player, always making runs in behind, Diaby is quality and rapid, Liverpool brought Diaz in for pennies. Meanwhile Utd sign a winger who can’t get to the byline to cross into the box for the centre forward they bought as well 🤣 you couldn’t make it up

you know its a good day when they talk about united and you aren't a united fan

Why have they incljded add ons which haven't been met

only watch jaffn and fcm what a collaboration

The disrespect on ten Haag in this video is disgraceful

Most of them aren't bad players but the club is in a bad place so if you're a 7 or 8 after a month or 2 the club brings you down to a 5 or 6. Then you have clubs like Liverpool a couple years ago and every player that went there a 7 or 8 after a couple months the confidence pushes them on.

"Hojlund hasn't done anything", but... currently top scorer in champions league

Reguilion would be TBD for me

We should have signed sabitzer, he'd have been better than the ones we signed permanently. Look at that europa league game where he bombed forwarda nd got 2, he played out of his skin. That's what we need.

Protecting Johnny evans 😂😂😂

He is the problem, they are clearly judging most of the players for previous club's performances or just an individual talent, instead they should be judging if the player fits the system or not and so many players don't fit.

Johnny evans a good signing. Iv heard it all now 😂

Only forwards

Just put hit for all the united players. Even though 9 losses 17 games Hit hit hit . Brilliant. Keep antony hes a hit!

Slugs n Dat

Find the criticism of Erikson harsh. Compared performances before and after Andy Carroll wrecked his knee - that's the only reason why he isn't considered a hit now Same with Casemiro and Martinez - only reason they aren't outright hits is because of injury. Can't really defend Antony. Just have to hope that given time he adds end product, which I think he will if Ten Haag can get a regular fit first team built around a consistent defensive lineup

Flav sounding like we just woke up 5 mins ago

What is this page without Manchester United

Hojlund, regulion and weghorst were/are hits for me. Bc they have all performed better than the squad. Wout didn’t get goals yet damn he hustled a lot and created the space for Rashford that went unseen/unappreciated

Onana wasn’t the best keeper in Serie A, that was Vicario. He did have a very solid defence though

shocking stuff

Every player ten haag has signed has been underwhelming and should be allowed to oversee another transfer window for the club

Need a fourth section above TBD that says just grand

Joe made it off FootballDaily.

Have they done other teams signings as well ??Or is it just United players under ETH. What about Chelsea??

Obsessed!

SkySports & Talksport really have the Ten Hag obsession. Every day it's always about Ten Hag trying to find any single fault they can.

Little fact for everyone ten hag is the quickest Manchester United manager to reach 50 wins, stats can be manipulated and can write untrue narratives. Stats aren't everything!

Joe seemed a bit fed up towards the end.

Martinez has been injured.. the guy in grey hasn't a scooby man

What shirt is Mayowa wearing?

The amount of hyperbole around United is unreal. Recency bias of United struggling at the start of this season is really affecting this conversation. They've had a massive injury crisis (same reason why Liverpool struggled last year, or Man City losing 3 on the bounce without 1 player, Rodri). I think the hyperbole goes way too far. Also ETH is the fastest United manager to get to 50 wins, can't be as clueless as they all say can he

Really not sure Casemiro is a hit, feels like a tbd. He had a great last season, but it feels like we are already seeing his age catch up with him, he just doesnt seem to have the energy needed for the role he was bought to fill. Extremely poor start to this season with game absences, and Man Utd have already begun looking for a replacement. For 70m I worry about his longevity

Hi guys thanks for the show . I really feel sorry for Antony, he wont improve neither cant adjust on style of play, even Gordon of Newscastle is more of a threat than Antony. Ten Hag would have employed Mohamed Kudus than Antony. The rest will pickup well though injuries.

What's this Flav guy on about Ten Hag needing to go at the start of this season?! I love how every few months, just because one team is in form and another is out of form, these "influencers" start calling their shots, despite all evidence pointing to the fact that this is cyclical and Spurs could be back below United by this time next season.

The bar to be a hit for man utd has reduced so so much, quite lauaghsble tbh Deserved to be the second best team in Manchester rn, mancity is lightyears ahead of them

Martinez - Super hit