I am assuming leafpool and squirrelflight are never born so sandstorm takes on a different mate? Or no?

An added darker depth to the character that all leaders had.

Ye ye you got it right!! I was never really fond of Firestar because he always seemed to be the hero. This AU gives me the excuse that he had personal intentions as to why he did what he did uvu/

Hey i know this is kind of your opinion but firestar did has flaws, he was over used? Yes. But in the first series you van see his true esence

@@thelmainoah im talking about every book past the darkest hour

@@Amichie yes I agree, I think that the first 6 books are overrated. Firestar never really had flaws except that he was a kittypet

Yeah I agree. Firestar was just too perfect in the Canon story.

My goodness

After all he was still depressed after spottedleaf's spirit dying, who wouldn't fall into spiral depression,getting murdered in the process, all because of your 1st crush literally DYING, there was a reason why he was so depressed

Just garbage writing tbh

Firestar seeing Spottedleaf as a motherly figure is a creative way to put it!

I m sorry if i sounded like i hated the map, i like the au i was just saying (also i read the first 9 books translated in another languge and there may have been errors that made it sound that way, idk)

@Rose Skywalker i mean, i remember it being true

@Rose Skywalker my Brain automatically said "Gee firestar, how come starclan lets you have three motherly figures?" In greystripes voice

@@stardustlover8446 whose the 3rd,all i know is bluestar and spottedleaf, thats all

Which book did Spottedleaf want Sandstorm gone? I gotta read it

@@localjb Oh, I can't remember if it's ever explicitly said in any of the books, but it's hinted at between the lines whenever she speaks with him about stuff he doesn't need to hear about, she yearns for his attention constantly, and if I had to guess where it's made clearest, it's probably Firestar's quest. I don't actually know 100% if it is explicitly mentioned, I saw someone on Tumblr talking about it in tags and it kinda sprawled from there, she's not a good cat when she gets to Starclan, because her crush results in her desperately stalking him whilst he's actively married.

@@xxblackdahliaxx6490 I feel like I vaguely know the line your talking about but I also feel like it's been taken to literally. She (Word of God) is a good medicine cat and would never enter a relationship after her failed infatuation with Thistleclaw (I hate that book.) She expressed that she sometimes yearned that she could have a life with Firestar and things could be simple but she's a medicine cat and would never do that to him. (or something along those lines.) Don't get me wrong though I don't really like her character that much either she honestly feels more like a prop but the Erins have really, really tried to make it so she has no flaws and is just perfect.

Didn't she save Sandstorm from Mapleshade at the cost of her life?

@@qwmuffin She did, yes. That's why I wanted to make a point that she never explicitly tried to murder her or anything, she did save Sand, but Warriors characters are notorious for their inconsistency so that may have even been the writers not being able to think of another cat to kill off. In fact, I think they only killed Spottedleaf off because they needed to close the "triangle" between the three of them and have Firestar say one last goodbye to his "lost love"

Take a snickers

You're not you when your *hungry*

Gosh I really gotta get on uploading about those AUs pff. In the AU collection, Tigerstar is more of an anti-villain while Firestar is an anti-hero. So, this MAP focuses on Firestar doing "good deeds" to get into Starclan and not legitimately caring for them or for others. He just wants to be with Spottedleaf, only to later be angry when she's killed. Tigerstar's focuses around from the first time he's introduced. Thistleclaw's hatred towards Bluestar and how he forces it onto Tigerclaw takes a toll on him. During Tiger's exile, he tries to catch Fireheart's attention to let him know that he didn't want to and he was forced to, but Fireheart didn't bother picking up on it, (because Fireheart is only focused on Spottedleaf). In "Tigerclaw's Fury", you see a voice constantly criticizing him and telling him to do better and to get rid of Bluestar. I know some people say Mapleshade and it makes sense, but I'm acting as if it's Thistleclaw because when Tigerclaw mentions Fireheart, the voice quickly criticizes him and brings up Bluestar instead. The AUs in this collection called "A Warrior's Judgement" initially had AUs of the cats: Bluestar, Tigerstar, Scourge, Ashfur, and Darktail. Firestar was recently added as a recommendation by Martletwing. Bluestar, Fire(heart)/star, Tiger(claw)/star, and Scourge's AUs all occur during the same time as the usual canon events occur in the books. No event is changed so that it's different from how it's canon. The only difference with my AUs is that it's a different perspective. I try to focus on an alternate reason as to "why" these cats are acting like this. I recently had done an animatic on Bluestar's: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/jeB4ZaxyqdjUlGw.html and Scourge's: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/b8CXd9Bku7ecfKc.html I plan on doing a proper animatic on Tigerstar and Scourge soon, so keep an eye out for that! I'm also interested in your AU idea. Would the other cats favor Tigerclaw more? 👀

@@Amichie Oooo those are really interesting! And, hm. I’m not entirely sure as this was an idea I came up with nearly 3 years ago, however, I don’t think Tigerstar/claw would’ve been favored more, but maybe framed by some cat and having rumors spread around him that Bluestar eventually believes 🤔 Or Redtail was alive, and maybe Rusty/Firepaw would’ve killed him later in the book as a way to frame Tigerclaw just because he didn’t like him.

Thank

yE YE THANK YOUU

It was mainly intended so that he'd be guaranteed to go to Starclan, but it was also because I never really liked his "heroic" character persona so I wanted it to have a double meaning by making it seem like a front

@@Amichie so you dont like good people i guess

Where did he say that again?

@@jupiter649 Firestar’s Quest, Omen of the Stars (I believe), and the Super Edition. There are of course other books, but I can’t remember every single line from every book.

For deffinition he cant be a Mary sue

Wait are you saying they cant have the same music? I really want to give you the benefit of the doubt here...

@@allandrawstoomuch4146 close to same. Make something fresh.

What a dumb complaint. No one owns a song besides the artist. The concept is completely different

@@xChijouChanx but it's still boring.

@@user-cu9en4ix1v Then stop bitching and don't watch