Is no one gonna talk about *"Who choreographed this? They're rolling down the stairs"* That part had me rolling 😭😭😭

It's like a google translate robotic voice trying to sing 😬

The problem is that, I bet, everybody around Madonna is always saying "Amazing, Wonderful, Great Idea" and she totally belueves it ... but ... it isn't.

You are total class! I just love your channel. Brilliant. You do say 'honest!'

I'll never understand how everyone has a parade bashing Mariah Carey and Madonna gets a pass for performances like this.

She said "wake up" at the end because she sent us all to sleep with this performance...

6:34 Your cat sounds more on key than Madonna.

Kitteh: maow maow maow... Translation: Will you turn that bloody racket off...

Well.... it’s too bad for Madonna but all you said is true. She needs to focus more on her voice.

Did she just sing the same 2 sentences throughout the whole song????

Even Kitty was traumatized by that. "Please mum, no more"

When you hear this being played as elevator music you will be taking the stairs every time xd

They sound like they were in a huge aquarium under water! If that's the future then count me out 😁

You are the gogglebox of music! Great channel

This was an example of a total loss of creativity but you, Honest Vocal Coach, are beautifully honest as usual.

If even the Cats starts to react....its realy bad.

This will hopefully be the last time EBU invites a random superstar to perform at eurovision - Madonna had absolutely nothing to do on that stage and the contest can easily carry itself..

It wasn't a performance. It was a warning.

Spot on review, your comments, disappointment and bewildered reaction, I think, reflect that of most viewers and Madonna fans after Saturday's performance. She was so breathtakingly brilliant at times during her career that watching this is truly sad. It's like she has lost touch with what she, the industry is all about. The whole performance was dark, gloomy, uninspiring, depressing, that Quavo bloke came on looking bored and lost, nothing worked, and that's before we get onto the vocals. Very, very sad. Do you think the people around her are too afraid to give honest feedback? I have no musical experience or experience of the industry, but simply as an observer with a brain, had I seen this performance before it went out I would have seriously urged her to go back to the drawing board and make major changes.

This is horrendous! What the hell Madonna?!!

She’s become too self-referential, relies too much on what worked in the past, chases what’s current. Basically everything that is the opposite of what she did in the past that made her the biggest star in the world. It pains me to say that. I’ve been a huge fan since I was four. Just being honest the way I see it.

Do yo feel the costume was appropriate for this song? I mean.. if you are going to lipsynch at least dance more.... imho. Cheers!

She looked so done after the first 30 seconds. 💀😂

It’s Eurovision, love! Get up and sing Music or Holiday or Hung Up! It’s a party. It’s not a flipping funeral.

The guy looks so out of place on a Eurovision stage. He didn't even know what it was. Well they both look off. They copletely drained the energy and fun out of the night A much better fit would have been Kylie. She would have started a party

When the door behind you opens I got the chills 😂

You are amazing Georgina x

Your facial expressions KILL me🤣🤣🤣 and the cat was pressed

If you will watch Madonnas performence once again today, maybe it will make sense

haha ....love your "whats happening here" reaction at 6:08. Big fan of you by the way. Enjoy your brutally honest reactions which comes with a sense of respect other reactions deviate from :) Love from Vietnam

I like how the words "WAKE UP" appear on the big screen after the song. As if Madonna is saying: "Ok, I know this was boring."

What is she doing on the Eurovision? Getting paid 1.5M $ for this single performance. She didn't compete, she was a performer guest. And actually there where some really great performances and songs this year. You should have a look.

Lol, I think your cat sounded better. 😂🤣

"What's going on" lmbo that's what I'm trying to figure out 😂😂😂🤦🏾‍♀️

Great analyzes, we didn't have a clue then. Now everyone is in quarantine. The storm isn't in "the air", is inside of us.

First song when she talks is called Dark ballet . Then Future ;) Horrific performance :( And i am i HUGE M fan !!!!!!!

I just remember how incredible the half time performance was in 2012. That was utterly amazing. This is abysmal

let's hope she just had a bad day. she is human after all. I love the Queen

Just found you and love your channel... thanks for your honest, refreshing take on life! XXX

Georgina, please explain auto-tune to us in as much detail as possible. Can you always hear it on the finished product? Is Madonnna using auto-tune + vocoder? It seems like the last decade of pop music (at least in America) has featured heavily electronic voices... Is this always auto-tune or some effect they are putting on the voice to make it sound electronic? I thought auto-tune was something used strictly in the studio and wouldn't be evident on the final recording.

Please make a comparison of the original recording of Madonna Eurovision and video from her channel! There is a completely different singing. (like a prayer) / - / / /

Hahaha! I Love Madonna and I LOOVE THIS CHANNEL! This is my reactions!!!!! ❤️❤️❤️😂👏🏻

When I saw this live on Eurovision I muted the TV until she got off the stage

Honestly, Madonna, I am buying long black boots and sing and dance your new awesome song FUTURE. Madonna, 12 #1 hits, over 300 albums sold worldwide, you look beautiful QUEEN MADONNA👸♥️

Lol Love your reactions of shock to this rubbish!😅🤣😂

The way georgina looks back at us 😂😂

People are dissing the queen but she was not the only artist that sounded like this this sound is popular the vocoder is a tool that's being use with many raggae artists just because her voice is different doesn't mean it's bad.

you are so cute and honest. i love your videos. you dont insult anyone, you are so polite, honest and funny.

Totally agree with you. By the way, the initial part is a political message against Israel on the Palestine situation. That's pure Madonna, political as always.

Omg you crack me up

just love your channel very refreshing

1:08 I love your WTF face and then at 1:40 WTreF. She even managed to upset the poor cat at the end.

This was a big message of Peace, Madonna is one of the most famous Singers, and she just wanted to set a big statement before ending her career. See the Israeli Flag walking hand in hand with Palästinense Flag upstairs. And she is Madame X, bringing this Problem into the Public.

The cat was more in tune.

Nobody should have the balls to criticize my Donna she's the queen recognize

Your channel is so great!!! Could you react to the performances of Katy Perry from the America Idol 2019 finals?

It was the worst interval act in Eurovision in like forever!

You are honest and I love it. I feel exactly the same. It's not great. It's not even good. It's just a farce. I would not pay for that at all

I´m a new fan of your channel! Thanks a lot!

This songs has a whole different meaning to it now after corona 👀

In spite of Madonna’s poor vocals on the night I have to say that I have a lot of respect for her inclusion of the Palestinian and Israeli flags which stood united whilst walking up the stairs together. Peace for the Middle East 🙏💛

Okay. Let's start. Madonna vibrates on a very high spiritual level. It's always been like that-nothing new! Back then, during her First Album/Virgin phase, she had those crucifix earrings, all those rosaries, crosses, the Star of David. In 'Desperately Seeking Susan/Into The Groove', she had that New World Order/Pyramid jacket (and there was the number 1313 on that door). In 'La Isla Bonita', there was again that number 1313 above an entrance. In 'Like A Virgin', Madonna appears as a virginal bride dressed in white. There is lion symbolism. And at the end of the video, she appears dressed in black holding a mask in her hand (like she had been to some 'Wide Eyes Shut' mansion party). That's the good girl gone bad symbolism (later explored in her song 'Girl Gone Wild'). In the 'Who's That Girl' music video, Madonna goes to a fortune teller, there's Ancien Egyptian symbolism all around, and Madonna picks the High Priestess card (featuring a cartoon version of her WTG character, Nikki Finn). And then came 'Like A Prayer', and then 'Express Yourself' inspired by the cult movie 'Metropolis' (one-eye symbolism). And then there was that big crucifix in 'Justify My Love', and that cross/cemetary/death/resurrection scene in 'Erotica', the occult symbolism in 'Deeper and Deeper' (the three balloons, the big pillar candles, the tarot cards, the séance, etc.), all the religious symbolism and Catholic angst of 'Blond Ambition', 'The Beast Within' number of 'The Girlie Show', the baptism/Catholic imagery of 'Secret', the thumb pricking/blood-sucking/Catholic imagery of 'Take A Bow', the whole 'Bedtime Story' video, the 'Human Nature' pentagram, and I could go on and on. As you can see, it's nothing new! This Eurovision performance is filled w/ religious/spiritual symbolism. Georgina says it's weird, she doesn't understand, she doesn't get it, but that's Madonna! She was never your usual/simple pop singer. She was always very avant-garde and highly mystical, a true reflection of her own name, Madonna. As for the vocals, they've been revised on her official KZfaq channel.

Now Georgina, this song is a total grower, I promise!

I really enjoy your comments. It’s really good watching a video of an expert giving their honest opinion. So my suggestion is to focus commenting on this area and not in others like choreography itself, which I believe in the particular one was amazing given the fact what message M tried to convey. Also the first part is, as you might know, from Overture (The Nutcracker) by Tchaikovsky. It’s really great on focusing the words and also consider what Madonna did that night in Tel Aviv.

With this one, I get the symbolism behind the performance, but the vocoder is just horrible. HORRIBLE.

Your reaction is soooo cool. I am a Madonna fan to, but I was after her performance speechless. The Queen has lost her crown. Yes, the cat has right

Great channel thank you x Totally agree with everything you said x

I'm loving your channel cuz you say the right things. I mean , the truth!

Your cat is a great critic:-)

I don't know. She clearly hasn't been singing for a while. I know she has put out a new album and it is good but yeah she has kind of lost her spark.

Big fan of Madonna since I was a child- growing up with Ray of Light was an amazing time! But her recent music is not something that I find enjoyable 😭. She used to be so innovative, but I feel like she is trying to fit in with current trends and music. I remember she rarely collaborated with other singers in the 80s and 90s and did her own thing... now it’s like she wants to sing with rappers and sound like everyone else 😓

Your face is a picture! Had me in stitches.

Oh! Your facial expressions are just divine. I really feel for Madonna. I am one of her biggest fans and I would love to see her live. But this performance was hard to watch.

I love Madonna since the early 80's..the very beginning I've heard her go from an okay singer technically to a really good singer in the 90's with a vocal peak ability from 1996 after training for Evita through to the Re-invention Tour in 2004...ever since then her vocals have slowly declined as if she gave up treating her voice as an instrument requiring care and maintenance which is exactly what you called out with Like a Prayer & here during Eurovision. It's disappointing for so many of us that love her and want to see her have a real win again.

So many people saying her career is over, so many people dragging her. In her own words, decades ago, Madonna has said she knows she does not have the vocals, but she has the voice, she has something to say. Her fans want her stuck in the 80's, when she fails everyone rejoices, she's too old, she looks terrible, she should retire. Madonna has been about spectacle, visuals, and when standing still and focused, in her own concerts, she can sing. The said thing is that people will keep dragging her as Michael was, but will quickly cry and mourn when she dies, declaring her a genius, saying her hate was unwarranted. Those same haters will come and pretend they loved her all along. All the hate she is getting, for daring to refuse to settle, to retire, to grow old gracefully, for daring to try other sounds, all this hate shows she still has power to change, and that change is necessary.

And you're absolutely right on every count!

The truth is haters are gonna hate. Must be tough realizing that a 60 year old singing legend is still adored by everyone, more sexy, more good looking than you behind your computer. Even in your 20's you wouldn't come close to Madonna at 60.

it's a political comment on the palestine/israeli conflict.

I love how towards the final minute of the song she just gives up on commenting haha

wait what do you have against the performance??? it's cool

What's going on, I hav no idea what's going on hahhahahhahahaha I lov your channel!!!

I think the kitty threw some shade😂 I kinda get the song for my first listen. However, that performance was very cringing to my eyes.

I don't even think it's madonna's voice that sounds bad, it's the autotune😱

Well, the meaning of the song is actually pretty simple. Only the people who are willing to learn from the past can come into the future. She speaks directly to the audience and explains how that could work when she's singing "Open your mind," "Open your eyes," "Just free your mind," "We can lighten the darkness, Everyone has a spark." The performance itself is actually the problem. It is so complicated that even I as a historian can only guess what she wanted to say at the beginning with this dialogue, with the gas masks, the pillars, the pictures, the flags: Israel/Near East → birthplace of the three big world religions, region is related to so many conflicts of the past as well as of today around the world Eye Patch → Moshe Dayan, Israel's Minister of Defense during the Six-Day War the dance of the sugar plum fairy → massive contrast to war/violence gas masks → death and destruction through chemical weapons, WWI, Holocaust/Gas chambers, Syria Stairs → top: future; bottom: past Wind → change Water → flushes the dancers down the stairs so they can not come into the future Pictures of priests saying "You are so naive. They think we are unaware of their crime "→ Child sexual abuse by Catholic priests wildfires / devastating fire along with the pillars and the smoke → destruction of nature, chimneys from crematoria, bombed buildings destroyed statue of liberty → freedom in danger the pair holding hands with flags on their backs (Palestine/Israel) → peace A performance that is incomprehensible to the majority of people limits its own power. So even the best message will be lost in translation. Oh, and that the music/singing isn't the best, doesn't help either.

For me Madonna's performance looks like an occultist cerimony more than a Music concert. So dark so heavy so hopeless... My feelings is that the entity she is devoted to have left her behind and carried with him her light. People don't buy her anymore. May God bless her! Love you channel Georgina.

Can you react more to the vocals and talk us through the problems they have and what the solutions would be, i feel im just watching you pull faces in this one.love your chanel

You made my day thanks

Thank you for the good laugh session :))

Madonna 😍

The Eurovision set is the worst performance she has ever done , horrible singing , boring performance, I like a lot of her music but this is awful .

No one has commented that Madonna uses some music from peter tschaikowsky in the first segment.

I love you 💕 you’re fair and honest ! And boy that was baaaad

Just as confused as you were. Trust me

When cats start complaining about your performance, it's time for some self-evaluation.

"What's going on?, I haven't a clue!", exactly what I was thinking!. I was like just watching it with a facial expression of disbelief!

The song sounded really good at the end... when the cat took over the vocals. 💅

Georgina I see you a bit 'sconvolta' (upset in italian) xD and cat too LOL 😀

How did you not understand it? It's a political statement that you seemed to miss the whole entire point of

Seriously don't understand what happened! I am a huge Madonna fan. Since the beginning. But the whole sound was off. Not just her vocals. She can slay when needs too. I bet some heads rolled that night. Come on queen your better than this!! 👑👑👑

I love your expressions!