Thank you for sharing this conversation. I too am on my journey to understanding historic Catholicism. Please pray for me.

Me too. I was a prosperity preacher faith healer Pentecostal for years. Then I went to my first Mass and experienced God on a new level!!!!!! I’m Catholic now!!!

Former Pentecostal here becoming Catholic after 5 years of cautious discernment. Join our family of saints and angels and pray for me please.

As a Catholic revert who suffered alone (seemingly) with severe scruples once I truly begin to know and understand my faith, I cannot begin to convey how incredibly helpful this has been ~ Glory to our God ~ ❤️🙏🏻🌹

I loved how you handled that first prayer asking for Mary's help. I had a similar experience, with the same reticence, probably because I had started listening to Christian radio programs while driving in the car. I'm a convert from Judaism. I was converted by a dream. I fell madly in love with Jesus. Even though it was Mary in the dream, I understood instantly that Jesus is real, He's alive, and He has all the power and all the love. I was bowled over. I went around all day like I was filled with helium gas -- just floating. That night I got down on my knees and said to the Lord, "I'm yours body and soul, do whatever You want with me." My second prayer was asking Him to find me my church before Easter. That was on March 12, 1990. After an exciting adventure of about a month, going to any church where I was invited, I was led to the Catholic church in my neighborhood, on Good Friday. I knew right away, that was where I was meant to be. I was so crazy about Jesus, I told Him, "I love Your Mother, but I'm sorry, I really don't want my Mother-in-law along on my honeymoon. Not long after that, I had a really important prayer request. There was someone I wanted to talk to and share my testimony with, but I hadn't seen him in months. On my way home one evening, I got up the courage to say, "Lord, I hope it's okay and it doesn't offend You in any way if I ask your Mother to pray for this intention." Then I asked Mary to pray, describing exactly what I wanted to happen, the conversation and every detail. Less than two minutes later, I saw the person I wanted to talk to. I found a parking spot, and we had an excellent talk. It was an amazing answer to prayer. I feel that Mary is my friend, that she's happy I love her Son. I can imagine myself helping her fix dinner and do the dishes. I picture her in the kitchen baking cookies for all the kids on the block. She's that sort of Mom.

Weeped many times watching this video. Mary is real, her love for her children is real, her powerful intercession is real.

“I desired the freedom of Authority.” Dr Ian Murphy Catholic Convert

Excellent guys - from a 65 yr old cradle Catholic, you refresh my faith 🙏✝️🦘

Thanks so much for having me, Eddie! I look forward to part 2. God bless, brother!

I'm former Pentecostal (Assemblies of God). Some of my Pentecostal family who can't wrap their heads around my becoming Catholic have reconciled it by thinking that I will "shake things up" and help Catholics become "born again" and stop doing Catholic things. Reformed theology made me prideful. I was chosen, I was saved, I was better than those idiots who couldn't figure it out. I had royalty, I was morally superior, I was going to heaven. I said the sinner's prayer, I could sit back, relax, and wait for death or the rapture. Catholicism not only levels the playing field but reveals that our lives as Christians is a lifetime act of the will, a choice we make every moment of every day. And for that reason none of us is better than the other. In Pentecostalism, my sins were "forgotten" by me. I was aware of them, but hey, God already forgave me. I was good! I put little to no effort into stopping. I justified sins. I even ignored sins thinking they weren't sins or weren't big enough to matter. But, becoming Catholic all of my sins are revealed, laid out in the open, I see my struggles and have to confess them and do penance for them. And that has helped me grow in virtue and in love if Christ and others in ways that I couldn't as a "saved and done" evangelical.

The connection between the teaching of mortal sin and maintaining purity really hit me. I wasn't able to fight my flesh at all before becoming Catholic. I was all on my own before, and now I have so many people in heaven helping me pursue purity

i like so many people had to stop watching Taylor Marshall because he was also leading us astray. great interview - welcome home.

What a beautiful testimony ❤. My faith gets stronger and stronger with these beautiful people being touched by God to come home ❤. We Catholics take our faith for granted sometimes

This is great! I suffered from scruples for months after I reverted. Thankfully Mary rescued me multiple times. I guess I should prepare for another attach. I have to be really carefull who I listen too!!

I really enjoyed that. I'm so happy he found his way to the Catholic church.

I do struggle with scruples and likewise had to stop listening to Taylor Marshall. I try to guard who I’m listening to. Is because I realize it is so unhealthy for me. I really enjoyed your story.

Oh my...I have personally been to that basement. I am a convert and I was deeply scandalized by the first church I went to and tried to attend RCIA. The "priest" was from India and he was chanting Hindu prayers in the homily and telling us to learn about Jesus from the Bhagavada-gita. It was a nightmare. I enjoyed the interview. Very thought-provoking and lively. God bless!

Welcome home brother!

As Filipino - Canadian, I enjoyed listening to this great testimony including part 2. Thank you for sharing your story. You abd your wife are amazing couple.

if you struggle with pron try and make a shrine honoring Mary. i did that and i haven't tojched the stuff since. the temptations are still there, but the strength to overcome the temptations is attributed to Our Lady.

Convert from Baptist here. Best 24 years of my life so far! Early Church, Acts, and Pentateuch pretty much sealed the deal for me.

Please know that this precious man that his testimony was POWERFUL. Bless you Jesus! You are so good!

I'm loving this conversation! I'm right next door in Mississauga. Fascinating, especially about the scruples, which are a huge temptation. My measuring stick for listening to anyone for guidance is if they undermine my faith in the authority of the church, it's a bad fruit, and I stop listening to them. Thank God for your wife :)

Us too! So blessed to become Catholic. Nothing compares!!!

Dave Armstrong has some of THE BEST apologetics out there - he needs to be re-discovered.

This is great testimony and as a Catholic myself in Canada it is great to hear.

I was raised Catholic and went to catholic school til I was in 7th grade. Then I went to a Baptist school that turned me away from Catholicism. I had a rough young adulthood and fell away hard. I tried to go back in my late 20s but was pushed away by a priest. Got really angry and turned away from God completely. The devil convinced me that I was going to hell so I should just reject God and find something else. I went down a dark path for years, a dark path. One day, I was online and saw a picture of Jesus with the sacred heart. I felt something, this tremendous outpouring of love and some kind of light and this beautiful energy. I broke down crying. I was so confused, was he real, did he want me? It took me a while but I could never forget that. I had a wild angel encounter that saved my life in my twenties and that stuck with me too. So I'm back in the Catholic church now and watching and learning all the biblical reasons behind our beliefs but all these prodestant issues are still rattling around in my head and I have such fear of fully embracing my faith. I pray the rosary everyday but I'm terrified that I'm displeasing God so my heart isn't in it. Any advice? I'm scared to go to my priest because of the experience I had when I went back before. I don't want to be turned away again. The worst thing I ever did was to walk away from my faith the first time.

Blue Collar Catholic podcast really helped me. I'm at peace about our church.

I totally agree about Marshall's ego-based scruples. He has brought a touch of protestant attitude into Catholicism.

"and then, my wife is not brains.." Hahaha! Man! I was laughing, and fell at the edge of my seat! As a Filipino, I Hope you still can sleep at home after this comment.. 😂🤣😂

Worth listening while doing household chores. Thank you for sharing your beautiful convertion. May God bless you always.

I've been spending a lot time with a lot of protestants recently, and many aren't open to a conversation like you were, which is too bad. Your story is so great, your openness to learn and stop judging, and then suddenly seeing where this will draw you closer...how beautiful! We have so much in common, but the constant arguments tamp down real conversation. Your story provides great ideas on how to get past the arguments!

All praise to God! ❤ Welcome Home brother. I love hearing conversion stories.

I loved this episode. Thank you so much.

Don’t criticize your priest ( it says in the bible) Sometimes the mass is boring for you but for other is a blessing. We catholics don’t comment the mass. Remember is the sacrifice of Jesus and it doesn’t have to be fun. It was fun only for Romans and Jews in the time he was condemned to death. But most important remember Jesus died for your sins. Pay more attention to the word of God and the gospel.

What an interview!! 😲 Outstanding! Love the Ricky and Bullwinkle mention. Lol

This was a very enjoyable conversion story. I love the joy he exudes when speaking about the faith. God bless you both!

The scrupules part is sooo helpful in this vid. The whole vid is really good. But the scrupules part is sooo good. Wish more content on this was available

Fascinating. I had to look up what you meant by 'scruples' as I'd never heard it spoken about in the way you were using it. It seems it's even called that in psychology, a recognised disorder, distinct from but often intermingled with OCD. My head hurts. I've been called back to Christ after being into 'new age' mystical mumbo jumbo for decades, and am searching for my spiritual home where I can be with others who know and love Him, and will support my faith, not destroy it. I see problems with every denomination, and am not going to any church as a result. I have a tendency towards needing to be across something intellectually before I will trust it, and relate to your guest in this regard. Can't wait to see Part 2 of this. Many thanks for sharing, and I'm fascinated to explore your channel more.

Great interview. Thank you! 🎉

Great one this week! Liked your comments on Luther. You should do an explanatory video on that.

For all former Protestants anytime you have temptations just ask Virgen Mary…. She takes care of us because she wants us clean to get to Jesus.

Wow! This is so powerful. Thanks for sharing this wonderful interview.

Part 2!!!!!! Loooove this man

Excellent discussion and story.

This is one of the best stories I have ever heard! God bless you both!💙🙏🏼

Fantastic discussion. Thank you!!!

Thank you for this amazing content. Your commentary on RCIA "volunteers" leading people astray is so true. I met a guy through a friend of a friend, who was an RCIA teacher at The Catholic Church I now attend. This ex RCIA teacher, said he no longer goes to church or teaches RCIA because he's homosexual, and felt judged. This guy is a full on card carrying Lgbtqxyz, unrepentant rainbow flag waving gay and proud, women should be priests type guy. I couldn't believe it! This is who they have (had) indoctrinating would be new Catholics? Someone who opposes many core Catholic teachings and traditions? Thank God we now have very devoted, traditional Catholics teaching our RCIA classes. But it does make me wonder how many did he lead astray? And how many other churches are experiencing heretical people teaching our incoming members? There should be more thorough vetting procedures in my humble opinion. God help and bless Holy Mother Church.

Waiting for part 2 🎉🎉

This interview is so real, loved it. I love the Blessed Virgin Mary, Jesus loves her so much. Love this interview Tyler, one of the best. I have moments of scrupulously, now I understand it, now I can control it, thank you Tyler. Give my regards to your wife.

Loved this!!

Eddie, WELL DONE ON ALL YOUR VIDEOS ! I have now watched several of your interviews including this one + part 2...I have to say Thank you for this wonderful gift you are giving us all ! Wonderful testimonials...very diverse.....very encouraging knowing people are still converting to Catholicism....now with all the inner problems/clergy abuse discoveries et al...not to mention controversies surrounding this current pope! God bless you for your work/ministry !

Beautiful testimony ❤. Welcome home

The movie The Passion is based on Blessed Ann Catherine Emmerich’s visions of Christ’s Passion.

Thanks for sharing. Thanks.

I am a convert from Pentecostalism. I have been really researching the hate of Catholicism and trying to find the root. You mentioned it being worse in the states and this totally goes along w what I think I’m uncovering. In 1500s king Henry VIII creates Church of England and breaks from Catholicism, mostly a break from the pope. Calvinism was spreading throughout England at the same time. The Puritans were a form of Calvinism in the Church of England, that was trying to completely get away from anything Catholic. The Church of England still resembling Catholicism, the Puritans literally fled to America to completely divorce themselves from all of it. Enter Dispensationalism in 1850s….Scofield put Dispensationalism in the footnotes of his Schofield study Bible….and the rest is history as they say.

Welcome home brother 👏

Lol the beginning 😂 sincere prayer and then chatterbox on

Pretty good interview 👌 ❤

Mr Eddie i like your altar at the back, very catholic loved it, thank you for the vdeos it inspires others who are non catholics. Godbless!

28:37 It’s interesting he saw that as a mockery of Mary and Jesus after he became Catholic, because I had always seen that moment in the movie in that way.

Wow. Didn't realise it was a 2 hour 8 minute interview. Not heard of scruples in this context. Will look up Robert Sungenis V James White and will watch the next part of the interview too. Amazing.

I have never heard of scruples in this context. I will go look it up.

Would be so great if these vids had chapters so it's easier to reference and share 🙏🏼

Part 2!!!!!!

I enjoyed this one! Same experiences I have encountered. I just prayed. Hear mass, communion and confession and rosary everyday just like what he experienced… poofff! All the vices gone! Good hearted guy! 🙏🙏🙏

Gotta love the Supertones. As a Catholic, Spirit West Coast was my happy place for many years.

Isn’t this interesting… the focus of the Pentecostal church that hires this man was to bring in a young musician to attract young people… so there is a focus on “feel good” music to prop up the young…

Welcome home 🙏

Hey, I would like to share my message I received while sleeping. I'm thinking it was St Joseph or my guardian angel who spoke to me. I was raised Catholic, and I love my church. I never wandered to other religions because I remember when I was in high school, I heard the teacher say that the Catholic church was the true church of Christ. I think that is why I received this message, because I can't understand why others aren't Catholic. Now with the internet it's a way to learn and this message is important. St Joseph said to me," that all Jewish Kings choose their Mother to be Queen."1 kings 2,20 says that King Soloman (a Jewish king) gave His Mother, Bathsheba the throne to His right. Because the Kings have so many wives, but they had one Mother, to be Queen. Our Lords spouses are Sisters or Nuns who give up their livers for Jesus. The Convent has a wedding for each one, and they wear a gold band on the right hand, Jesus is their spouse. They are His hands and feet to teach people to love Jesus. Protestants can't see this. Is Jesus a Jewish King? Mary is His Mother; she is your Queen. Statues of Mary have cried tears. I wonder if she cries for your love, She is your loving Mother given to us at the foot of the cross from Jesus. Love her. God bless you

Great video,I’m impressed with it.I just hope that Catholic’s realize that salvation was never meant to be easy even though our Lord God and Savior Jesus Christ is All Love Mercy and Compassionate.The sole problem with people is our fallen nature and Freewill which Catholic’s don’t know much about,this is something mysterious to us humans that Lucifer and his countless evil spirits take a lot of advantages over a lot of Catholic’s everyday along with the shepherd’s of the Catholic Church.For the human saying is true,corrupt the head of a person and his body will follow.Oooh Wee what are we Catholic’s UP AGAINST DAILY.May the All Powerful Holy Trinity everyday Bless Protect Guide And Inscribe in us Catholic’s the understanding of True Love Truth Good Grace And Virtues Amen Amen Amen 🙏 🐑🕊️✨🌈

Iam a catholic too Ilearnn now always ask the help of the Holy Spirit when you are in trouble

Amen!

Amen

Love how he explained that we Catholics have no issue with Divine misteries. And tes, Catholics we are being badly cathicatize since decades a go. Great for the voluntaries, sad there are not enough priests, but still.

What a funny "coincidence"!!! I was just watching a video of Eddie Trask that randomly appeared on my feed. It was from 3 years ago: "How a Megachurch Protestant Returned to the Catholic Church". In the main time my wife just passed me a link for a video that a friend of her suggested (she used to be a Protestant and become a Catholic after much studies). Lo and behold, it is this video :)

Omg Taylor

Wow that Protestant German efficiency hit home. Why have beautiful tradition of the Catholic Church? Just pray and worship with two other people and you are all set-great talk gentlemen

Re 3:40...Not only...once saved always saved, but protestants do not even have to think about the suffering of Purgatory....

👍🙏

Calling out Tyler's Jordan Peterson-esque accent and intonation.

Thanks be to God for this explanatuof scruples and the big difference between the false "reformed" belief, once saved always saved - which is really an unformed belief - and the true faith that is based on scrutiny of one's soul. Well, how DOES it happen that Jesus could say "I never knew you". Only if we do not spend a fair amount in self-examination of our motives for doing things or not doing things? My mum's side of the family are Protestant and I feel their scruples are all around death - they are so afraid of death. No wonder. On the other side, my father is so protestant in his thinking. I don't even know if he ever goes to confession. So he has no scruples whatsoever but many of his actions are such that no protestant would ever convert, even my mum. 😢

I don’t leave comments often but I feel a scared and anxious going through this conversion. I’m going through the process of converting from Methodist , Pentecostal, Baptist , Presbyterian / Reformed theology to Catholic and I too have been feeling anxious and attacked at night. I really don’t like dealing with that terror stuff and sometimes it doesn’t make sense that God would allow this to happen to me if I’m trying to get closer to him by learning about Catholicism. I never felt attacked like that as a Protestant. Coming from Protestantism (still am technically, but my heart is wanting to convert to Catholicism) when I read my Bible and did my own Protestant daily devotions I always felt extremely close to God and had immense levels of peace and security and a strong presence of the Holy Spirit guiding me, it was always me and Jesus with the help of the Holy Ghost leading me. But I did always had issues internally about Protestant churches , the way they worshiped and did service always felt uncomfortable to me. I always thought to myself “should that be allowed in church? Is that holy? Should we be having all these lights and entertainment going on?” When I discovered that the Catholic Church and started attending the mass , I saw how it addressed all these issues and this was how church was supposed be since the beginning I immediately was convinced. However, even though I do feel convinced and happy to learn that Catholicism is the original and one true church , I don’t know why I feel so anxious and nervous to pray to Mary or the Saints . I’m so scared to do that because me and Jesus have had such a peaceful relationship and it was just me , God , and the Holy Spirit. Now that I’m learning about the rosary , Mary, and the saints I feel really scared . I start getting these night terrors. It feels like my safety and security has been shaken. This doesn’t seem like it should be happening. I’ve always had peace when I read my Bible and prayed to Jesus alone. Why do I need to pray to Mary and the saints? And it can even get confusing who I’m supposed to pray to and for what? If anyone could try to help me I would greatly appreciate it. God bless you all and I’m trying to my best.

3-4am is the Devils hour! 😂 I also got an attack which felt like a heart attack but wasn’t!

Kingdom Bound?! Dude Daren Lake is like 40 minutes from where I grew up!

Welcome home……

They were ALL like that where I grew up. You have no idea what some of us have gone through or are still going through decades after conversion

The german mindset analysis. Blew my mind. I think it’s true

Im suffering scriples and anxiety for some time having left the rad trad groups ...how can i find a wise and balance spiritual director? Im in western Canada

With us but not among us

Robert Sungenis is great! What path do you think he went down erroneously? Geocentrism?

Contemporary worship is important to many non-Catholic Christian’s. Is contemporary worship allowed when you’re a Catholic christian? Could you advise me how to find more information online?

you never have control.

Yep. There are very well meaning Catholics but they’re off the track Especially Taylor Marshall and Michael Voris. God bless them .

👍

In what they call the Lord’s prayer, it says lead us not into temptation, but Matthew four verse one says that Christ was led by the spirit into the wilderness to be tempted. I noticed this about a year ago. Seems odd.

The accounts of the Passion of Christ were actually taken from the mystic experiences of a Catholic Saint Anne Catherine Emmerich

Sungenis is still great

And the list keeps growing while my former sect, the SBC, is dying. The internet is a vile place, but it also provides a medium to hear the best of both sides of an argument. It sounds like a lot of people who are taking a step back to reevaluate their theology are going Catholic or some other form of Orthodoxy.

I can relate tho about his Filipina wife not wanting to bring up his ex-girlfriend. It's like a taboo name for them or something. 😂