For the last scene, Filoni said in the new download episode that it was set a few years into the empire

Actually, Revenge of the Sith was supposed to last roughly 9-ish days from the Battle of Coruscant to the Duel on Mustafar. That would mean the Siege of Mandalore lasted over a week

I watched revenge of the sith using this, and it totally hits different

Ships travel through hyperspace at the speed of plot.

I can assume that Ahsoka felt an aftershock in the Force as Order 66 was issued and that's why it was delayed

I am almost entirely sure that Vader visits the crash site after the "the apprentice lives" scene in Rebels to confirm his suspicion. When he discovers the discarded lightsabers and the helmets, he would be completely convinced that Ahsoka did indeed survive, and be prepared for her by the time they fight on Malachor.

1 - I think the music in the airstrike on Mandalore implies the Battle of Coruscant starts as Rex and Ahsoka leave the gunship 2 - Ahsoka and Maul don't sense Anakin's turn as it happens, but shortly after. The visions they have actually skil dialog from the film. This also explains the Order 66 problem

Great points, wow, you’ve done your homework!

Drinking game: Take a drink everytime he says “Return of The Sith” instead of “Revenge of The Sith”.

"Return of the Sith"😂 That aside, great video. This will help me a lot to mix my own cut together👍

To be honest, I don't think what Ahsoka senses what's happened between Anakin, Mace and Palpatine at the same time. Like you said, the timing makes no sense. First off, we have to take the Force in consideration. My assumption is that the events were already taking place and happened already. What already transpired, I get the feeling the Force was warning Ahsoka about the danger that occurred. When Yoda sensed it, I'm betting he was feeling what Ahsoka was feeling and the Force warned him, which gave him an advantage and the vision he had on Dagobah made him well prepared if the troops ever did turn their weapons on him.

I remember the clone wars.... I was young didn’t understand I now think and smile because It was beautiful

U forgot that Bo-Katan and Ahsoka met on Coruscant, so it’s entirely likely that she met with Anakin and Obi Wan on their way back to Coruscant, maybe halfway between. We don’t have an indicator of how much time passes between Ahsoka’s message and their actual meeting.

I think Ahsoka sensed Anakin's fall a few minutes after it actually happened. This makes sense to me because if you pay attention, what she heard was also a highly compressed version of what happened in the movie. I feel like she sensed it just as Sidious was contacting Cody and Anakin was storming the Jedi Temple.

6:45 Yes, the Force lags because they are moving in hyperspace. And Master Yoda can sense the deaths of the other Jedi before almost being killed himself, because he's Yoda.

I think (and correct me if I'm wrong) but when Anakin turned to the dark side and order 66 was given, Ahsoka, Rex and Maul were all in hyperspace at that moment, so time probably doesn't work the same way as if they were just chilling on another planet, Ahsoka also might have sensed it late because she may not have been reaching out into the force when it happened, sorta like seeing a message you missed on your phone a few minutes after you get it (if that makes sense) Big chance I'm wrong but eh lol

The Commitment torwards this video is amazing. I love how you even studied the day and night rotations for both planets and lined both of them together. A well deserved Like. The Problem is that the full events of Revenge Of The Sith conclude over a six day gap but it actually takes place over 10 days. One of the writers said this but may just of been a random guess. Fantastic Video

Everything looks good except for the timing of the final scene. It most likely takes many years later. Ahsoka's lightsaber is rusted.

This makes it feel more eventful than what happened in the film

Actually, in terms of when Rex gets the command to execute Order 66, it was probably a coincidence that another message came through before Sidious came on the holy. He doesn't specifically say he's going to talk to the Chancellor. Just getting a briefing. Probably after Anakin left, Palpatine told his communications section to give a "warning order" to expect a message.

The Epilogue of "Victory and Death" would have to have _at least_ taken place a couple months afterwards, because Vader has his red Lightsaber hung on his belt. We know from the comics that it was quite a while before he even got the crystal to make that saber, so a few weeks extremely unlikely.

Man this "Return of the Sith" sounds like a good movie I should go watch it

7:33 here you are wrong, the vader surgery lasted several days

Someone already made a supercut of the Mandalore episodes mixed in with ROTS. It's pretty epic.

This is very similar to how agents of shield attempts to crossover with the winter soilder. Feels that way. This of course was a 1000 times better

I always thought that ROTS took place over several months, since Padmé barely looks pregnant in the beginning of the movie. I think this version is awesome and it makes a lot of sense, but it also makes Anakin’s turn to the dark side a little less logical (he went from being a good hearted Jedi knight to a fully fledged dark side user with yellow eyes in one week)

You could justify the "within the hour" part as their making use of the Nexus Route.

1:22 Mandalore days are 19 hours long

I appreciate this guide, thank you for taking time to do it. May the force be with you, good man

From watching Mace, Kit Fisto, the other Jedi Masters die, all the way til the End Credits, I had tears in my eyes The real tears started during Anakin's and Obi-Wan's duel on Mustafar It hurt watching all of this, and watching those two fight, it just hurts.. after all these years of the Clone Wars and Movies, this list to watch was the best Star Wars decision I've ever made, thank you for providing this amazing guiding list on how to watch these together!

Really great job with this; incredibly thorough! Only note I would make is that the Battle of Coruscant and the first incursion onto Mandalore probably are meant to take place at the same time. They used the music from ROTS almost like a time stamp. They later did the same with Ahsoka bringing Maul up to the cruiser lining it up with the music as Padme looks out to the Jedi temple.

When anakin's getting his new limbs after mustafar that took about a few days of surgery. Theres no way he had the suit on in a days time

Ah yes favorite star wars movie return of the sith.

6:31 Ahsoka only sensed it after it all happened. Makes perfect sense to me

I'm actually glad someone took the time to map out the timeline of events between Revenge of the Sith and the Seige of Mandalore! From the comments below I see there are still some debates, but this video helps me get a sense of when things are happening.

There's a 4.5 hour cut of Revenge of the SIth that actually edits parts of the OG Tartakovski Clone Wars [the parts that don't conflict with current canon], The Clone Wars Siege of Mandalore episodes, and the movie with a few deleted scenes edited back in that covers it all in chronological order. You'll have to rely on a search engine to find it for yourself, but it's out there and really well done.

Pamde was only a few months pregnant at the Start of RotS, because she's rather flat stomached. So I thought the film was suppose to take place over a series of months, not days. I could be wrong though so

My estimate is a few years have passed when Vader visits the downed cruiser. The lightsaber looks rusty. The grave markers would have stood for a while under normal conditions and I don’t believe the clones were fitted out with Stormtrooper gear so soon, or that gunships would be replaced by Lambda class shuttles in that time either.

Ahsokas feeling of the events was probably just after the fact, not during

It would be years for a few scenes, Tarkin meets Vader a few week/months after he becomes Vader so the scene looking at the death star is during that and it would be a few years until the clones change over to Stormtrooper armor

i really appreciate the work you put into this

I planned on doing this when I entered the arc, lol, but thought I'll just mess things up. Ended up heading directly to ROTS after 7x9, then watching the three remaining episodes. Will definitely try using your instruction next time

The Vader scene at the end of sith is a few months in the future, I believe. One reason for my belief in this because in the comics Vader goes straight from being put in the suit to his very first mission, which then expands into a chain of missions, plus it’d make more sense for the time taken to construct the Death Star, matching up with Galen Erso’s story from rogue one.

I merged all the episodes together in one film. You did a good job

Placing Ashoka's fight for her life and Anakin's attack on the Jedi temple together, fits musically as well, since in both instances, the song heard is "Anakin's Dark Deeds".

The more i think about the proposed time-zones these planets have makes me wonder how much jet-lag everyone must experience.

That’s so cool, I would love to see and edited version of everything together, but I know that will probably never happen. Thanks for sharing!

Great video! You deserve way more subs than 60. That’s why I’m subbing. I also noticed you kept saying “Return or the Sith” but that’s fine

About the confluence between Anakin's turn and Order 66: I'm reminded KOTOR 2 and its emphasis of "echoes" in the force. Because an echo is a sound, you hear it sometime after you've made the original sound. In my opinion, that's why Ahsoka felt the disturbance just as Sidious was speaking to Rex, because what she felt was an echo in the force.

There's a line from the 1950s War of the Worlds when a character estimates that the Martians will destroy the Earth in 6 days. Another character realizes a connection stating "That's exactly how long it tool to create it (the Earth)" All that happened in six days.

I think the outerim sieges issue makes more sense when you remember that the outer rim extends along the outside of the entire galaxy, even in the North. So thats where Anakin and Obi-Wan's battle could have been taking place, and it is much closer to Coruscant.

That scene where the Republic Sorry I mean Empire making a landing on Mandalore looked badass

Vids like this, make me happy

I can’t be the only person who’s been looking for this!!!!

Thanks! I've downloaded the sheets and am going to watch it this way!

The scene looking over the deathstar is actually a timeskip originally. You dont see it but he has his new lightsaber clipped to his belt as is discovered in the behind the scenes, and we learn from the comics it took him months to a year before he finally crafted it after bleeding a crystal from a fallen jedis saber. This matches up with the enslavment of the geonocians following the war to build the deathstar.

Thanks for this I’m planning on making an edit and this helped so much

I love this! Thank you!

I've got nothing for the "within the hour" line. Maybe Obi-Wan was exaggerating and he just meant we can be there quicker than others can? But for the delay in Ahsoka sensing the conversation in Palpatine's office, maybe the explanation is that Ahsoka isn't actually sensing those events, and she's actually sensing Order 66 (just like Yoda in the movie and Jaro Tapal in Fallen Order), NOT Anakin's fall. And they just put in that dialogue because it was the most recognizable dialogue from that scene so that we know it's about to happen. That way there's no actual delay because she's sensing Order 66 instead of the actual conversation we hear in the episode. Maybe she can sense Anakin has something to do with it which is why she whispers "Anakin," but she's not actually sensing his fall. Plus if she sensed it there's no reason Obi-Wan wouldn't have as well. Other than that there's no explanation I can think of that makes sense. And it'd also explain why Maul senses it. Maul hasn't met Anakin so unless Anakin falling creates that big of a shockwave in the Force (which I don't think it does or all the Jedi would've sensed it), Maul has no reason to sense it, yet he does. If it's Order 66, however, Maul could definitely sense that.

This is useful thank you for making this

Personally I figured that Ahsoka felt Anakin’s turn at the same time as Yoda, and they just used the dialogue to make clear when we are in the timeline. But this is a great breakdown and I might try this on May the 4th!

Anyone here used to watch Micahv6v8? He actually predicted how the show would end. Even saying the final season should overlap with the Revenge Of The Sith. And guess what? It did😆 that was one hay of a prediction! I really miss him☹

I always thought Revenge of the Sith took place over the course of a couple weeks, at least. Palpatine gradually working Anakin as Padme's pregnancy, and Anakin's fears, progressed seemed more realistic. But I guess I can believe the tighter time frame since Anakin has had the whole Clone Wars series to slip closer to the dark side now. As for Ahsoka sensing Anakin's fall: spacetime is weird and the dark side, which is stronger than ever, is clouding the precognition of the Jedi. Not to mention that it was likely an ECHO of the events that had transpired, not a direct line to them. Ahsoka's personal connection to Anakin is probably the in-universe reason for it being so vivid, but it's a stroke of luck she sensed anything was amiss to begin with. Even Yoda didn't sense anything was wrong until the Jedi were already dying.

I'll use this guide next time I watch *_Revenge of the Sith_* !

I would say the meeting near courascant/core worlds was both convenience, but also necessity for Obiwan/Anakin. They just finished their fight on Yerbana, so they need to restock on munitions, artillery/air support lost, supplies, etc. We would assume courascant would be the main area for restocking, or a planet within the core worlds.

Hey bro, not sure if you’re still reading comments, but I had a thought about Obi’s holo meeting w/ Ahsoka. He had his hood on, which leads me to believe he may have already been on Utapau or at least that may be what was implied by the writers since he has his hood on until he drops down to fight Grievous. Also, for the Anakin vs Mace “vision” that Ahsoka has, and the fact that Order 66 came immediately after... I chalked that up to Ahsoka being finally able to decompress after the siege and everything horrible that happened hitting her at once with the order coming right after as sort of a lucky “coincidence” since it put Ahsoka on her guard that something was horribly wrong. “But as one trained in the force knows, true coincidences are rare,” and may just have been the Force working to alert Ahsoka. :) Great vid bro, wish I would have seen this the other night I watched the Siege of Mandalore arc then ROTS after and thought, man I wish there was one complete edit of these together.

Just look up the Siege of Mandalore cut by Sheev Senate. It’s a 4 hour cut of the film combining deleted scenes, the ‘03 Battle of Coruscant, and the Siege of Mandalore alongside the film.

All this make sense. Very impressive.

Great video! Thank you :)

Galaxy brain analysis, good job.

Very good video, I love that! I also think of a timeline and we mostly agree with the exceptions of two points. I will try to explain them, please excuse me for the long comment. First point: the Battle of Kashyyyk/Battle of Utapau. The Battle of Kashyyyk starts right after the Council meeting when Obi-Wan is sent to Utapau. The Battle is still ongoing during Order 66. With your timeline, that means that they fought on this same beach for more that 36 hours! And nothing happens on day 3 (Coruscant time) neither on Coruscant nor Mandalore! Here is my proposition. I think that Obi-Wan leaves for Utapau in the morning of day 3 (Coruscant time), and the Battle of Utapau starts on the afternoon of day 3. Order 66 would then takes place on the evening/night of day 3. Hence, day 3 and 4 are merged. Second point: Almec's assassination. With your timeline, two days took place between Maul talking about Sidious to Ahsoka, and Maul sending Saxon to kill Almec. Why Maul would have waited two days during which Almec was held in custody and can reveal Maul's plan to kill Anakin? And why did Ahsoka wait two days to question Almec? Here is my solution. The attack on Sundari takes place on the morning of day 1 (Mandalore time) as in your timeline. The Siege lasts approximately 30 hours. In the afternoon of day 2, Almec is captured while Ahsoka meets Maul for the first time. Then, Obi-Wan contacts Ahsoka (it is the morning of day 3 on Coruscant). I know that we see sunlight on Mandalore. This could be explained if we supposed that the Council meeting takes place very early (around 7am) and Obi-Wan contacts Ahsoka right after (around 8am on Coruscant), and we extend the Coruscant/Mandalore difference to 10 or even 12 hours, so that it is only evening on Mandalore. Then, everything happen as you proposed. The only differences is that day 3 and 4 (Coruscant time) are merged and Almec's capture/Maul-Ahsoka meeting are separted with the attack on Sundari. In this modified timeline, ROTS only happens in 5 days. This might looks short, but I have a "justification" for that. I think about the timeline of the other episodes and I find that Episodes III, IV and VI could happen in 5 days, while Episodes I, II and V could happen in 8 days (for ESB it could be longer because of the Hoth-Bespin journey, but 8 days is still possible). So, this means that there is some kind of a balance in these storylines, with 3 episodes of 5 days and 3 episodes of 8 days. From a classical/theatrical storytelling perspective, this looks very balanced for me, with very short timelines (with the same length) during which many events happen. Well, this last "justification" may be a little far-fetched! Thank you if you read me and please excuse me for my poor english, I am not a native speaker. May the Force be with you.

the last scene is a few years into the imperial era as lambda classshuttles, which we see in the clip were not manufactured until this time

This video deserves a lot more attetion!

Listen man, as a Star Wars fan to another I love the vid. However it is so wrong that I had to make a comment. The clone armor was still used for while after so that’s more than a couple weeks plus Ashoka getting the visions is so normal for Jedi of power that it’s not even new. Everything lines up perfectly man and it’s a masterpiece

Thanks 4 the description

On the last scene, you can tell that time had already past, not only the Stormtrooper armor but you can notice Vader's suit. In ROTS, Vader's suit has his pauldron over the robe whereas in CW, he has donned the classic robe over the pauldron and the red lenses of his mask. To reinforce this, Filoni said that this took place within the golden age of the Empire. And top it off, Obi-Wan's "within the hour" line might be an exaggeration. Not to mention, remember that The Force dwells within every living being, surrounding, connecting and binds them. The reason Ahsoka felt the disturbance too late within the timeline is because The Force (the light side) is already weakened but just in time to warn her or experience the same thing as Yoda did as many Jedi are killed during Order 66

Great work!

Yeah, the second issue had me thinking when I watched the episode about the time difference and I though no one else would care but apparently they do!

One also has to keep in mind that this is a mapping of the Galaxy within the Star Wars Legends, 'Galactic Atlas'. The Old Canon and Expanded Universe has different locations for some Star Systems, planets, sectors and regions of the Galaxy, compared to the rebooted New Canon. In Canon it seems that the Unknown Regions and Wild Space are switched around, relative to the Old EU Galaxy Maps. Even then, Hyperspace is and can be faster than the speed of light, it seems that a vessel can be in Hyperspace as long as the plot demands it, so I don't think there is a discrepancy, considering Yerbana could be near the north-west tip/area of the Unknown Regions and Mandalore is located Galactic Eastern side.

6:30 I too initially had issues with this continuity error. I concluded that, due to how close Anakin and Ahsoka were, they must have developed a Force Bond, which would allow them to feel one another when they are either A.) nearby or B.) in great pain. In this case, both are triggered, as Ahsoka is on her way to Coruscant, so she would become increasingly close to her master as the ship got closer and closer to the planet, and Anakin's turn to the Dark Side would have been a painful moment emotionally for her master. I don't think she was feeling the moment as it happened, but rather felt the echo of that moment through the Force. Anakin's turn to the Dark Side is a pivotal moment in the galaxy. It's the moment where the entire galaxy at large changes forever. The moment the Dark Side gains control of the Chosen One. We know that Yoda was able to feel this echo all the way on Kashyyyk, so it stands to reason that Ahsoka would feel it, given how much closer she was to Anakin than Yoda.

this was really good it seems that you lined up things pretty well the only thing that I think may be off is ROTS took about 3-4 days and you made it took 5 or 6. I’m not sure tho but yea

I think assuming that the final scene in the final Clone Wars episode, takes place a few weeks or months after the crash is a bit underestimating. All the stormtroopers are wearing armor that resembles the well integrated and finalized armor we see in Rebels, the orignal movies and the Solo movie. Adding to that, they even have established the exact same snowtrooper outfit that we see in Empire Strikes Back. In the Bad Batch series we see the new "stormtrooper armor" that they are integrating which is different from the originals stormtroopers. I know this was made before The Bad Batch series, but we can only assume that these outfits took probably on the good side at least a year before integration, possibly a few years. I think the last scene in Clone Wars also wants to represent that Vader has spent years hunting down the remaining Jedis, while doing so he stumbles upon an old memory. At that moment he remebers exactly how his last ineraction with Ahsoka was and that the lightsabers he gave her was a gift she never would've left behind. He assumed her dead in the crash or atleast exiled. And then he leaves the area in the constant pain he resides in. (Most likely he assumes her dead, as he can be heard in Rebels saying "The apprentice lives", when he feels Ahsoka is alive.)

For the issue of "Being at Coruscant within the hour" or whatever he said, it's resonable that Yerbana is close to a Major hyperspace lane, which goes straight into the Core in once continuous journey, wheras a trip to Mandalore from Yerbana would take several pit stops, and be more awkward to get to. Remember, Hyperspace doesn't work in a straight line. They need to follow Hyperlanes just like cars need to follow roads. As for the Ahsoka sensing Anakin's turn to the dark side, if i remember correctly the force does kind of travel in ripples, of sorts. I remember that being implied somewhere, but I could be totally wrong about that. But I digress. Either way, fantastic video :)

The Bad Batch arc takes place after The Martez Sisters arc so months are in between when Ahsoka leaves Coruscant and when they have that hologram meeting on Yerbana. Might I add Tarkin was on Kamino for a long amount of time during The Bad Batch. Yet we see Tarkin on the star destroyer near The Death Star. So that scene where Vader and Palpatine look upon the Death Star wouldn’t have been during the movie, weeks or months after is more accurate

I think the fight sent ripples through the force but wasn't felt until after the four minutes of dialogue with Anakin and Palpatine. That means that echoes in the force would have been felt minutes after it happened meaning Ahsoka's connection to Anakin would have been felt as a result of the occurrence rather than as it happens.

Love the idea, but one important thing is the concept of days. Not every day in the galaxy is the same length, which is why they are usually referred to as "rotations". I think its important to remember that eventhough at the meeting it might be morning there and afternoon here, there might be a time where both locations experience sunrise at the same time just due to the faster/slower rotation times

6:45, the most likely explanation I can think of is the fact that Ahsoka got that force... vision (?) probably 30 minutes to an hour after the scene actually happened, as a warning from the force that something was about to happen. My guess is, Palpatine waited for Anakin’s arrival at the temple assuming that they had to get the clones there, debrief the plan, then march in. Right as Anakin and the 501st started marching in, or when the clones arrived at the temple even, Palpatine issued the order.

I have to say this is pretty accurate👍

Or you can find and download fused together ROTS and CW season 7. It's 4 hours long but it totally worth it

I never would have thought that Revenge of the Sith took place over such a short timeframe. Padme's pregnancy is not apparent when Anakin comes home to her, but then she is showing considerably on the night that Anakin wakes up from his nightmare. I always assumed some months had passed there.

How the fleet can be there within the hour? It's hyperspace, it doesn't really follow any physics, or rules, it's a HUGE plot device, laways has been and always will be. Like what is the probability that when Maul pulls the destroyer out of HS that it appears EXACTLY near a habitable moon? Hyperspace cannot be made sense of. and it probably shouldn't. In my headcanon it is an aspect of the force, like it's implied in rebels. Therefore it's basically magic.

I love this jobe! i love you XD

Its years after, they had clones in clone armor for about 3-5 YEARS after the end of the war not a few months

You did a really good job. #CloneWarsSaved

I always assumed that the scenes with Vader being suited took place a few days after the battle on Mustafar and Palpatine and Vader watching the death star being built took weeks (possibly months) after Mustafar just based off how much was completed. (Who knows they could have gotten that much done in a few days, this is a world with space wizards and magic light up swords that can travel at light speed with a flip of a switch).

Taking into account the comics. The order 66 scene in the Kanan comics obviously has to happen at the same time as The two main scenes from ROTS and TCW as well as Jaro Tapals death in Fallen Order. As for Cere and Trilla getting captured by the empire they say that it happens sometime after the Order 66 and the Purge. So assuming ROTS order 66 scene happens over the course of 1 day then I'd say Cere and Trillas capture happens at around the time Anakin is speaking to Padme on Mustafar, if not that then maybe when he's killing the Separatist leaders. As for the ending scene of "Victory and Death" I'd say that takes place around 5 years maybe just before the beginning of Fallen Order. I say that because in that scene Vader already has his signature red lightsaber. So that scene has to take place at least after the events of Darth Vader:DLOTS Vol 2. But that's just a rough placement of where I'd say these events happened obviously.

6:25 remember sidious contacted each clone commander one by one cause those holo plates or whatever they are called were not able to hold big meetings like the ones at round tables which explains why Ashoka felt everything happen in what LOOKS like four minutes when in actuality it was literally happened a good few minutes prior and the fact that they are traveling at light speed also justifies that as well

The ending scene in the final episode of the clone wars was years after revenge of the sith, my guest is during the time of the inquisitors hunting Jedi... And mostly it was also shown prove in the bad batch season 1

this is pretty awesome

The scene where Vader stands with Palpatine watching the Death Star being constructed takes place months or years after Anakin first wore Vader suit. I know because that younger Tarkin recognize Vader as the Emperor's enforcers when standing at his side. In the new comics Tarkin didn't recognize Vader at first, only recognizing him after the Emperor introduced Vader to Tarkin and then the whole Imperial high command/officers corps.