Hope you guys enjoyed watching the video as much as I did making it! Be sure to go and vote for your favourite design here: bit.ly/3RF1myt 😊 How I can help you ⬇ 👉 Wow your clients with easy-to-customize templates www.abiconnick.co.uk/templates 👉 Transform into a highly-skilled, confident logo designer www.abiconnick.co.uk/pencil-tool-course 👉 Elevate your biz with these FREE resources www.abiconnick.co.uk/free-resources 👉 Where I get all my mock-ups & fonts: 1.envato.market/abidesign 👉Free weekly tips, advice & exclusive videos: www.abiconnick.co.uk/newsletter ---------------------------------------------------------------------- After more content from me? ⬇ Instagram: instagram.com/itsabiconnick TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@abiconnick Disclaimer: some links in the descriptions of my videos may be affiliate links which means I receive a small commission. it is no cost to you to use the links, it is totally free.

Please, if possible, more videos like this one! It's so interesting to see the different solutions. The observations you made were totally coherent. The learning potential from this is huge. Thank you so much!!!!

Matt's design is so freaking cool and clever. The use of letters and the colors used are just amazing. I love it.

Cool to see how different designers interpret a brief! You see this a lot in the design community for those who do passion projects. But they always use different mockups. Seeing the same mockup, just different design, in your video really makes it easier to compare. Loved it!

Jorge's design is my favourite. Love the minimalism and elegance of the package design, the different colours for each does the work, enough to imagine an extension for a potential range. The others feel too busy imo, Matt's a good second. Though I'd place Joanne's as third, hers would be the most visually appealing on a shelf, relative to what the product is (the one I'd imagine grabbing the most people's attention). Pedro's design's use of right aligned text on the packaging bothered me, but al-in-all each are strong contenders!

I love Jorge’s design! I would totally buy that if I walked past it on the shelf. Very aesthetically pleasing

All great designs! For me, Joanne's definitely has the most premium and tropical feel. Also ticking the "modern" checkbox. But for shelf appeal, I'd say the winner is Abi. Those designs will really pop as you're walking down the aisle. Matt certainly has some pop to his design, but it's almost too busy. All around, sweet designs though!

I don't understand why Pedro is being underrated here. That looks the best and I would really consider buying if I see such a lively packaging.

I said wow out loud for Pedro's ❤️ It's just so well done, and unlike anything I've seen before.

If I were at a store and had to pick among all these designs, Id definitely be drawn to your design or Matt's. Although Matt's is quite busy, it screams tropical which I noticed right away. But everyone had awesome designs. Great work.

I like your Orange & White colours. It makes it feel premium and stand out from the shelve. Second one is the Joannes green one that feels clean.

This was a fun video Abi. And out of all I definitely was drawn more to your design. However all the designs were so good! Loved seeing the different styles from each designer. It’s crazy to see how different designers interpret the same brief .

What I like about your video's is the way you breakdown & explain the design process in a fun & engaging way. And all those designs look amazing....😍

Abi, I love your design, especially your logotype solution. The one-color design makes it more economical than the others to produce. That said, after comparing it to the others, I would have liked to see your design in tropical colors.

The Shrek scene tho 🤣😂 You slayed it Abi! I love how you designed the packaging and chose the colours. I love watching you create patterns and has to be one of the best and iconic moments of brand designing. Have a great week ahead ❤️🔥🤩 (I'm so tempted to participate in a coming session too if my final evaluations weren't so dangerously close 😖🤐)

I love Jorge's font, it feels clean and premium 👌But Abi you absolutely smashed it out the park with that design 😍

Matt’s wordmark reads iNmerscent, with an n followed by an m, quite confusing. The rest of his design is stellar!

I loooove theses videos! I hope you still read the comments on these not so recent ones because it would be sooo great if you brought this series back!

Matts stands out the most to me, it's funky bright and very much eye catching, it says pick me up and take me home.

Matt’s was the best and the one I’d buy passing it on shelf vs others. It’s fresh and funky and playful! Jorge seemed monotone with the color. Joanne seems too much flamingo going on and hard to read. Pedro I really liked the design on paper but too busy on the box? Abi is good but missing something I can’t place, more colors maybe.

This video is really special the idea of it was so unexpectable and so exciting . I think Joanne worked with the riskiest direction and still managed to make it look very good and when we put the four designs together Joanne's design just stands out and grabbs the most attention at least my attention that why I will vote for her the only question i got is why she used a flamingo ? maybe that's in the vid but im too lazy to read lol . Anyway abi your channel is really killing it your videos are getting better and better i keep getting amazed by the quality of the videos. you have come a long way I saw your very first videos and I was like WOW you have upgraded a lot like A LOT . KEEP IT UP .

Although I love each of these designs, I find myself being drawn to Jorge's simple design. Matt's design was a favourite too.

This wonderful, amazing and gorgeous woman deserves more subscribers 🫶You could tell that she puts time and effort in her videos ❤️ Your filmography skills have transformed since the beginning of your channel in an unimaginable way! You really inspire me!

Matt's design is for me the best. But all of them did a great job ! It's amazing. ❤️

Matt - but Daym gurl, you were right about the stiff competition! Your critiquing on all entries was On POINT!!!! Honestly, your work is outstanding and I totally vibe with your entry. If I can't choose you, I choose Matt!!!! Thanks, Abi... great content as always!

Matt killed it imo. The incorporation of the letters in the illustration/pattern was a WOW factor. I don't think the logo in black did it any disservice, on the contrary seeing that the whole package is colorful, it brought the attention to the logo and info more.

Artistically speaking Matt or Joanne are the winners here but for the shelf appeal abi is honestly the best. Beautifully simplistic. Idk which direction to vote!

Love it when every end of your videos there's a strong CTA of watching the next content. It's my first time seeing that execution here in YT! Great job btw :)

It's really nice to see a creative sponsored video, great idea and execution. It was really hard to choose a favorite design, I can see the appeal of DesignGuru, hoping to able to join it in the near future.

All great, I think your one is the best. Your logo is great and I feel like the packaging says diffuser more than the others. Great all around though!

Your take on comparison is so insightful. I love that POV.

I LOVE YOUR DESIGNS AND YOUR CHANNEL MISS ABI but I gotta say those three designers NAILED IT LIKE DAAYYYYYYMMMMM

I'm sold already to all the designs 😍😍😍

I enjoyed watching this video Abi, great job as always! I'm late to the party but I would definitely purchase Matt's package. It gives me topical rhythm vibes and the added abstract letters in the back is a dope move. They only thing I would do different is change the text color to a navy blue or the teal color on the barcode for a more cohesive feel. All designers did an amazing job! Yours is exceptional as always also. Keep creating Queen!😊

1. Matt 2. Jorge Really just love your design the most though!

I love Matt's with your logo and the navy font like you said! That would look amazing

Abi! I really love competition videos like these! Coincidentally, Ben Marriott just posted a motion design competition video where he competed against another well known KZfaqr, Jake Bartlett, and it was so entertaining! It is really interesting to see how other designers interpret the same brief. I would love to see more videos like these, and I think it would also be cool if you competed another designer/KZfaq educator like yourself--that way we could watch both of your go through the process

I really liked the idea of this video! All the designs are great, but I have to say that Matt's by far my favourite. Very much would like to see more videos like this from you!

You were all great. Now it's up the client to choose what he prefers for his brand. Great job!

I like the last one but I loved yours the most!

Abi, your design is so much fun! I'm curious-do you freestyle your patterns, such as the one on your design? Or do you sketch your ideas out beforehand? They're amazing!

Abi at it again 🔥. Your work was great, as always. I tried to come up with an idea from the brief, no matter how vague it is, before you start to show yours but you really took this to another level.

I think a video where you design an album or a podcast cover, I think it would be interesting. Have you ever did something like that? (Your videos are really entertaining)

matt's dsgn luv it

This is so cool! I love seeing all these different interpretations of the same brief. They're all really beautiful! And you're very brave to take on such a competition and put yourself out there. I love the 'S' in your logo and that sound bar is subtle but really clever and clean! I feel like as long as every designer thought well about the concept and made conscious decisions, then it eventually comes down to what you (the viewer or the client) value most. I find myself weighing the pros and cons of every design and of course personal taste plays a big role. I take inspiration from all five of them, but my winner would be... (drum roll) ...the flamingo design! The scenery just takes me there and the dark green and orange tones give it that premium feel for me. Great video. Love it. ❤️ I'm gonna vote now. 🙃

Thankyou so much Aby, I really appreciate your help through this videos 🥰

Absolutely love your design!!!

So hard to choose a winner, they were all incredible! ❤️

I love to see your videos. I always improve my vision about design with your help. Thankssssss

Great stuff Abi!! thank you for sharing

Thank you for being so inspiring ✨❤️

Abi’s design was by far the best

Love this kind of video Abi! Learned a lot ❤

You’re videos have seriously improved in quality and design since I last watched!

awesome video abi...I have really learnt alot

absolutey in love with your whole concept and design! well done ((:

I think you still should have added your design to the final image so we could visually see it next to the others - even if we aren't able to vote for you. The name is clunky "immerscent" so that's starting off awkward and the concept of mixing scent and sound is a bit obscure - how exactly did they describe how they were going to do this??? Do you get an exclusive music playlist with every scent? Otherwise - it makes scents, but doesn't make sense. Pun intended. In any case - no matter what design you get you will always see things that work and things that don't - even in your design, I found the little music bar thing to be superfluous - I didn't get it. Maybe if it had a recognizable play icon like an arrow it would have been a stronger music symbol, but if I were to see that on the shelf I would just think it's a line with a dot - just another design element to fill some space. I do, however, love the way you customized the logo - your interpretation of that weird named looked the best of the lot. And while the design was interesting - very bold and stark against the white background, it just seems a little - plain. I don't know - it WORKS though, but it just kinds reminds me of a random tile pattern. Simple and super clean. I found the blobs of color around the name on the package and on the scent bottle to be kind of - I dunno... I feel some type of way about it, but can't articulate it. the design is almost so "no frills" that you would think it's something a designer would present to a client who is on a VERY tight budget. As for the designs you want votes on, if I was forced to choose one, I would choose Matt. Matt (Winner) - The design looks bold and bright and summery. The scent sticks look thin and light and airy - like the scent just wafts through the air. The colors almost match the actual bottle (wish they had). The dark blue and light blue kind of look clunky and out of place - the light blue is too light/bright and the navy blue is too dark/bold. I wish the colors would have stayed in the golden oranges, yellow, and maybe a little red to mirror the scent bottle. And maybe tone down some of the extra elements - beating me over the head with the summer icons (palm trees, volley balls, musical instruments, fruit, tropical animals, etc). And in the middle of all of this - that stark, almost medicinal label that looks like it should be more on a face cream. Other than that - it gives me the most consistent idea of summer, scents, and sounds because it has ALL three. Jorge (Runner Up) - It's basic, but that doesn't mean it's not appropriate. If the client wants something more "familiar" then this def fits the bill. The use of the reeds in the design in the shape of the rising sun (the apropo symbol for summer) is literally the best thing about this design. Otherwise - this doesn't tell me anything else. It actually looks like a standard cosmetic line - you might pass this on the aisle and think it was lotion. I think the dark pink background and the heavy drop shadows weigh this design down giving it the opposite feel of light, summer vibes and fun. This looks like it could actually be a Clinique brand product or packaging for Tan Towels. The reeds also look very heavy and oily and thick in this mockup - making it seem like the scent will linger and be overpowering like an old grandma with thick, floral perfume on. The heavy feeling is also reinforced by the boxes laid flat - it's like they're too heavy to even sit upright. Joanne and Pedro (Tied #3) - Both designs look incongruous for the brand. Pedro edges slightly ahead of Joanne because at least his reeds come in multiple colors and I think that would add nicely to the room decor. His design though - is a bit too abstract and the colors a bit too muted - nothing about it says summer, sounds, or scents. The box design is playful and whimsical, but the product design is very sedate - went form curves and odd shapes on the box to lines on the actual scent bottle. Joanne's is visually (and easily) hands down the most elegant, luxe, sophisticated of all the designs, but I think that's the problem. The design is too dense - almost overwhelming for scent sticks. You don't want to feel like you're being smothered with scent. And the palm trees and flamingos are just too dang regional and specific - summer in Florida or the tropics, maybe, but certainly not summer in the mid-west or mild climates. The pink and green together - not really stretching the color combo muscle there - that's a no-brainer. I wonder what this would've looked like if the flamingo was a bright yellow instead of pink. I actually like her logo as well, the wavy letters in "immerse" do give the feel of water or movement - which is great. She should have gone all the way and made the "i" wavy, too - it looks weird standing there at attention while the rest of its letters are exaggerated. I love how she made knowing how to pronounce the name easy by making both words visually different - "immers" and "cent." This is fun to watch. I love seeing how different designers interpret something. If I had to choose one element from each design to use to come up with a different design I would choose your logo (simple, but cool), matt's mockup (love the standing boxes), jorge's colors (light, bright, versatile palette that fits the product), joanne's layout (I like where she placed the elements on her design), and pedro's multicolored sticks.

Wow. Great video. I liked them all alot. Never thought anyone would be at your level, but theyre all great.

Hello Abi, i love watching your videos, and i can say the last one is super cool and very useful for any designer. Your competation made me to work more creative than what i did before. i really want you to be winner, but i really love Joannes design, thanks you attention

Keep giving us videos like this. 🤲🏾🤲🏾🤲🏾

As always you did an excellent job. One of the things that I most like about your videos is the humility that you transmit in them when you share content and experiences of your life as a professional designer, I also like the color palettes with which you work, because they are very nice, funny and I think they really describe you as a designer, they totally fit with your personality.☺

Matt did very good !

This was an awesome idea! All 4 designs are really great, wow!

More videos like this one please!! ❤️❤️

To true we would have your back 😏 I feel like your logotype was definitely best! But some of their packaging was really solid as well.

Really amazing explaining, keep creating this content 👏

This Creative Doesn't miss man. In the heat of battle she doesn't miss. in the heat of challenge she doesn't miss.

Thanks a great book behind you Atomic Habits

I love your videos , it is so helpful

I wowed at Pedro's! 😅

Matt's design is my favorite, but if I was actually purchasing the product I would choose Jorge's.

Abi you are incredible ✨✨ thanks for your amazing videos it's happening me so much 🙏❤️

Love this! I’m only 18 but am passionate about design and am so excited to have a go at designbros (even if I don’t win it’s SUCH good experience and addition to my portfolio!)

Overall design: 1. Joanne 2. Jorge 3. Matt 4. Abi 5. Pedro Best color usage: Joanne and Abi tied for 1st

.... by the way, this video is fun to watch and your design is awesome!

I love your design process. also i wish i have patient to be more organized like you haha ❤

All 5 designs are absolutely fantastic. How do I hire these designers for graphic design projects?

could you please provide other designers social media link or KZfaq channels so I could follow them, could learn or take some inspiration from them. The challenge was so good 💖

Hard to choose between joanne and pedro !! Good job guys ❤

This video is amazing!

My favorite is Jorge and Joana 😍

I think Matt had a great concept

I love the way u editing ur videos

This is so interesting to see! I have a question tho: do you have any tips on developing one’s style. I dont feel like I have a style myself and this makes designing hard

That apple logo climbed up high in the thumbnail

Abi, Where can I also download that text effect from the beginning of the video?

I had this question Abi. First is why chose Shrek characters than normal people but I like your thinking of that? And two which relates to this like should I be a seasoned pro or full time. I got confused so I wanted your opinion

Wow, I can't even decide who to vote 😍✨🤯 Very well done 👏

I like your editing sister

Wow, they are all so beautiful 😍 but Matt's my favorite

This is so impressive!

Joanne's design is definitely my top pick! It fit so well wit the client's brief and her choice of colors for the packaging feels really premium and lux. I gotta agree with Abi though, it is quite difficult to read her logo in a first glance (one is positioned vertically and the others are prone to misread). Honorable mention : I think Jorge's logo design is the most different and unique out of them all! But the use of single color on the packaging might feel too cliche (cue Abi's research on diffuser packaging in the beginning) and I think it'll be difficult to stand out from the crowd as per the client's request in the brief.

Thank you so much for your content!!! 🫶🏼🫶🏼🫶🏼🫶🏼 i really really appreciate it!!! Lots of love from Mexico 🇲🇽!!

I used to compare myself to others, because i tought their skills / draw, whatever...was better then mine. Finally, i changed my perspective :D

.I ❤ the 4th design. It's bold, vibrant and visible. Can I ask you a Favour. Cold you suggest any Design Competition site on which we can submit and check, what lever of skills we are at, by receiving natural ratings. That Will Be a Great Help. I try not to miss any of your Tutorial they are all very informative & to the point.

I honestly look at your thumbnails and ask myself the same questions 😅

Amazing!! Tbh my ranking would be: 1. Abi (totally not biased) 2. Pedro (I think it would improve the design to do more fruity shapes like you did!) 3. Matt, he got the vibe and loved the creativity on the i-m-m-e-r-s-c-e-n-t 4. Jorge 5. Joanne

Hello Abi, I kinda like the logotype and illustration. Could it be possible I get list of skillshare courses to help me with that?

I trust you're a good designer cuz all good designers wear glasses like that

Can you do a video on how you edit KZfaq videos x