This is my favorite song from the show, too. Stephanie Block's voice is so wonderful, and, of course, Hugh Jackman is perfect!

One of my favorite shows. Hugh was awesome and Stephanie was great. They should have released the show on DVD so more people could enjoy it.

Love Stephanie. Her voice is absolutely amazing.

I like how she isn't making Liza into a over done character, but taking a hint of Liza and making it her own. Brilliant. I got to see a show, I don't want to see the perfect impersonation.

this is my favorite from the show! I'dnever hear the song before and it just slays me every time. Thanks so much.

I love you, Stephanie J. Block.

I CAN NOT listen to any version of that song without devolving into a puddle of tears..this one, Rita Coolidge, Thelma Jones..😭

After seeing these clips, Hugh Jackman walked into my life. Now I'm a fan!

Am I the only one who can't get enough of Hugh???

My crush and one of my all-time favorite actors being so versatile for he sing, dance and, most of all, act.

SO PERFECTLY DONE HUGH! WITH SUCH REVERENCE.

Just simply need to say the Great Hugh Jackman.. so authentic and full of emotion in his singing and acting.

Saw this show three times. Would have gone again if it hadn't ended.

Oh My goodness, this is pretty much my favourite tune from both the Australian and Broadway Cast recordings and I can't believe I've only just now thought to look it up on KZfaq! Just gorgeous. Would've loved to have seen SJB and Hugh perform this live so thanks for posting and allowing us to get a glimpse of this beautiful song and scene.

I belive he loved her for her gifts yes but not love as in partner love.. It could not have been easy to leave her but he had to do it for him self.. I am lesbian and this whole played touched me in so many ways in fact it helped one of my friends come out and this year at my courch on pride we are going play Love Dont Need A Reason it was my idea ..

Absolutely beautiful amazing

Beautifully acted.gr8.charisma from both...Hope there'll be a revival as when we saw it on Broadway,it was a limited run..Peter & Liza loved each other more as siblings than romantic partners. Her dad & granddad were gay,so was looking to replace them.

Even though I haven't seen the whole thing and I'm not entirely sure exactly what's going on, this song just about makes me cry. I feel so bad for both of them! Two amazing actors.

Hugh: Somebody's heart gets broken, usually it's mine Me: I'll never break your heart Hugh!!!!

It's amazing how some things run in the family - Judy Garland's mother married a gay man and had Judy, then Judy married Vincente Minnelli and had Liza, and then Liza married Peter Allen. Still, out of those marriages, Liza and Peter's was probably the least agonizing.

WOW!

Well, I'm thinking she captured the essence of 'Liza' without doing a caricature. Maybe that's a better word.

SJB does early LIZA... Besides LIZA actually hand picked SJB.

Quiet Please, There's A Lady On Stage

If you all watch interviews, peter was deffinatly in love with liza and then he realised Their was a different comnection between him and men

Jesus Christ I do not get the Broadway stuff.

is this performance available on DVD?

Horshit. She does Liza as well as anyone can without doing an impersonation, which was not the point of the number.

@gmarcarr thx

which song was before this please?

They really screwed this show up when it wnet to New York. Biggest mistake, Hugh Jackman,

I have just witnessed the murder of one of my favourite songs. Listen to the Julie Andrews version and you'll see how bad this one is.

Whatever ya recon mate.

And then she did it again. She would have been better off to stay with Peter. Does anybody remember the name of that grotesque person Liza Minelli married a few years ago? If I'm not wrong, he sued her for divorce on the grounds that she beat him up....

Now this is crap and I'll tell you why...... when she sings "You And I...... Can't Say Goodbye", she just talks it rather than SINGS it. You have to sing those particular words because the inherent chord changes behind them are fundamental to the melody..... the main "hook" of the song, in fact. Once again, actors spoil songs by talking phrases instead of singing them. They overdo it, thinking they're being all dramatic. She's got a great voice, I hasten to add, it but needs to respect the GODDAMN TUNE!

She sounds NOTHING like Liza