I’m sure many of you will disagree, so let me know why! (Politely please, or I’ll set Altair on you 🗡️)

Just my 2 cents but not every AC game needs a great story, if it’s a cheesy or uninspired story but has great gameplay I’ll be a happy man, which is why I love AC Syndicate

I played every AC so far and for me Odyssey and Black Flag were the most fun and memorable for sure.

Generally agree but Odyssey once again mischaracterised as not being good for stealth. Apart from the boss fights and the arena, you can literally stealth the entire game with the assassin skill tree by far the strongest and most powerful. The only thing is missing regarding stealth is the blending.

rogue has been called underrated so much that it’s now overrated

Man my favorite part of Odyssey was all the mythological fights like Medusa… that was so fun

I’m just happy Valhalla isn’t ranked last like most other rankings

Odyssey is by far my favourite AC game. When you look at the game as a rpg instead of an ac game, Odyssey is pretty much fantastic

AC Origin is my #1 favorite and I also love AC 3 Connor

Call me crazy but AC Odyssey is the first game that I have platinumed on PS4. 😅

I'm surprised Odyssey was so low

This was so agreeing showing all your thoughts on what game and having a fair rank for each game 👏👏

Unity was about using the gadgets, you had to pick your gear carefully too (sprinting full on towards the target isn't going to work) when its also buffed with the PC mod to allow for more control (using the phantom blade when hanging off walls) its one of my favourite AC games.

The best and most reasonable analysis about assassins creed games

I still for the life of me don’t understand why so many people hate Valhalla, longer story and bigger map= more fun, fighting was decent and story wasn’t bad, wouldn’t put it top tier but I think it’s a solid middle of the pack.

AC oddessey is my first Ac game and I’m loving it,I know the games “assassin” aspect is very rough but I love Ancient Greece and it will probably be one of my favorites

One thing I wish the other games allowed just for the giggles was that in AC1 you could run into people with brooms and knock it out of there hands if you did so you could then pick it up and proceed to kill guards with it when I would get bored I would just grab that and see the string of death a man and a broom could bring

I loved Odyssey, it’s my first AC platinum.

Based on reading tons of comments, I would say odyssey might be the best one as it is in the majority of everyone’s top 3 if not number 1.

Of all these AC rankings list, I definitely resonate with your placings most! I have an identical top 3

I’d say this list is pretty spot on. I haven’t played origins or mirage though so can’t comment on those. But the brotherhood, AC2 and black flag placements are right in my opinion. That’s number wang

I started with Odyssey, and I’m glad I did. Because if the OGs ruined it for you, you didn’t want to like it. I love it

You forgot a game from the list “assassins creed: nexus VR” a great get weird feeling assassins creed game, parkour entirely depends on if you, it can either be smooth if you’re used to VR or terrible of not, yet it’s a fun game overall, if you have VR you should totally check it out

Origins is my favourite asassins creed, then ac2 then black flag. Honourable mention to mirage because i actually really enjoyed that

Good to see people here in comment section are supporting Odyssey and giving it the respect it deserved.

I agree with most of what you say about Rogue’s plot being a very simple exploration of the Templar side. One thing I do give the story props for is Achilles isn’t wildly evil in this game. He doesn’t want to use the artifacts for his own power. He’s just recovering the Pieces of Eden to keep them out of Templar hands like every other Assassin we have ever played as does. At the end of the day, we really don’t understand any of these items at first. He was just unlucky enough to discover the wrong POE. That’s at least a little grey area in a mostly black and white story.

Honestly one of the best lists I’ve seen. I would probably have the same top 5, however a few may be in a different order. Hard to find a perfect list but this one is close!

I think they should make a ww1-ww2 based ac where you take part in famous battles and focus on stealth alot more, you could kill generals and eventually world leaders I think it would be easy and fun to tie in with the ac chronicles russia story with the russian revalution The part before the title scree could be the guy who assassinated franz ferninand < - (who would be a templar) be an undercover assassin who was a ‘luckily at the cafe’ to asassinate him not knowing it would cause a world war This would be risky but how in ac freedom cry you have plantations they could add that but make them concentration camps instead or just military camps instead It would be good if you could also fight for rebels in guerilla warfare which would use stealth and be quite fun

Odyssey is in my top 3 favorite games of all time. Mostly due to the amazing Greek/Sparta setting and mythology. The combination of naval and foot combat, participating in land battle and exploring all the islands. An absolute masterpiece!

I get where people come from about stealth in Odyssey but I’ve legit never had a stealth problem in that game. It lacks social stealth which is a bummer, but otherwise it’s a perfectly fine stealth game. You just gotta spec for assassin.

I love every ac game! My favourite is AC II. I would like you to include the psvita ac game! Thanks for your video, I enjoyed it

Brotherhood is my favourite! I got so addicted to that one. Think my least favourite AC was the first one. One the 2nd came out, I loved the series

Never let this bro cook again *in Irish*: saying rogue map is small💀(bro you got a atlantic area a forest area and New York and calling that small)

i loved rogue i just got the remastered version and play all the time.. i do wish it was much longer and bigger though. i love it

Great list. For me though I would definitely have to put mirage a little higher. It’s my absolute favourite AC. Everything from the environment, the soundtrack, the stealth and the historical accuracy it’s all mind blowing. Whenever I play it I feel like I am genuinely in 9th century Baghdad. The NPCs add so much life to the world. Also, the musicians in the city are such a nice touch and the music they play is amazing. But I do agree with the criticisms stated in the video, not much variation in open combat and the multi kill thing. But neither of those things stopped me from platinuming the game. Thanks for the video!

From a True assassin to another I like your list was even better than mine! great job brother!

Odyssey was a great game

Origins is my favorite due to it being first assassins creed game and it's setting being beautiful.

Valhalla for me ❤ love it! Then ac 2, odyssey and origins 😎

I highly disagree with some of the entries in this video, but we can agree to disagree. It was an amazing video, regardless. Keep up the great work, man!

At first I wasn't agree with you but then it suddenly changed my opinion and I agreed with you

Love the entire series, but it does have flaws for sure, like all things do. Personally, my favorite game of the series is Odyssey. It may not be a generic "assassins creed," but the gameplay, story, world, history, combat, outfits, weapons, rpg style, and overall game is just pure bliss. I love that game so, so, so much

Merry Xmas George! Have a great Christmas mate! I was done with Valhalla abt a month ago... I have now started playing Mirage. Hoping to see u with more videos onMiragr gameplay, strategies and weapons. Have a great year ahead mate!

Great review!! I feel the same playing the AC series. The unity bug on Arno face really gets me!! Origin is irresistible in terms of Egyptian setup but the side quests and material-hunting annoys me and lead to a give-up on the game

As Ubisoft sticks with the RPG style, I feel that they need to strip some of it back and return to basics like Origins. That game had the best balance between classic AC and RPG AC

As far as Ive read theres nothing from Ubisoft or other officials saying they provided their Notre-Dame render to aid in restoration. The only confirmed things from ubisoft is that they donated €500,000 euros. Ubisoft did say they would provide other help if they could, and that would likely mean giving their render of the building, but a French monument organization had more recently laser mapped the building before the fire. So Unisofts render was not used at all. Still a good gesture by Ubisoft tho.

I always think it is a good thing have fans with many different rankings because truthfully there isn’t a game offensively bad there are games I would rather play like odyssey and black flag for me there is a a quality in each of them which it does better than the rest. But my ranking personally Rouge: there is a lot imported and also you switch side I think in sequence 2 of 6 even then sequence 3 is a tutorial sequence as well but the game does have one of the most challenging mission the storm fortress but it is a side mission 1: fine for the time horrible to replay now. the flag collecting annoying, stealth is none existent and it is repetitive but it is a starting block and but movement still holds up and setting is still great and was something never seen before so can’t bash it too bad Brotherhood: it did fix a lot from 2 but it just aggravates me in a lot of cases with the annoying 100% sync requirements which some are just unfair and the map is not that fun to traverse ezio and the time period is built for building parkour it is not a rpg game so the map being 2/3 fields doesn’t fit the ezio trilogy style I know 2 had horse riding and wide open space but you were mainly in the cities of Venice and Florence Unity: Snipers just Snipers. Ok story tried to be more complicated it did alright but I just got annoyed at the assassin council and I think that is why In the games character you play are either leading or not affiliated with the brotherhood because no like being told what to do only mirage and 1 have you a part but unity find just jank and an alright story could’ve been longer iii: unity and iii could be either place iii horrible pacing almost kills the game you get 3/4 or the sequences with Conner and one is a tutorial so 2/3 as an actual assassin I think it is also a game that relies on the setting too much for mission it every event oh look it is Conner which for some is fine but basically carried the revolution which is hilarious but does make Washington look weak but iii get a plus for just having haytham Valhalla: I don’t really have a problem with this game yeah it is on the long side and i would’ve cut some of arcs and made them side quest the arc system I think was a direct fix for the problem odyssey had where people would play then have break come back and couldn’t remember what happened and Ubisoft wanted people to play an arc a day but that not how we work. But I do think it got combat numbers right for a rpg they were not easy but they weren’t damage sponge. Valhalla had good moments Mirage: this is a game ranked with expectation I think we needed a simple stealth focus game and that what we got there wasn’t going to be massive character driven stuff because Basim was working for the hidden ones which I expected but there was some could’ve been more stuff for Basim maybe in more side quest it was just a nice quick game in the end and I enjoyed it I hope next time they will stuff with the masked group it give the villains nothing until the end Revaluation: same as mirage a nice quick game with more emotional weight love seeing more Altair and him having a personality enjoy parkour with hook blade and it was nice seeing ezio happy do wish there was more to do but I think it simplicity work in it favour and one of the only game where you are not actively hunting the Templar they are more in ezio way Origins: new era was a really good start to the rpg style good story some of the villains were stand out like the scarab but there gameplay issue like lack of mission variety mainly just kill this or place here but it is working out the kinks for the next game. Bayek is awesome and aya was someone who should’ve had more but a least we played as her for a bit 2: this had quite a chill tone to it with memorable mission like Grimaldi assassination with the flying machine ezio is a amazing protagonist and the cities of Florence and Venice are amazing. Rodrigo is a poster boy of ac villain even though his boss fight sucked and most people forget ezio isn’t even an assassin till sequence 10 I’m pretty sure it just a pretty setting and a rare setting to have in a game Odyssey: has the best side quest ever there are stories to make you laugh, cry and think I will say people may say that assassins creed protagonist should be an assassin but it can lead for the same story being told again this is the first story about something different the revenge and killing it about getting family back together it did the choice and order better than Valhalla by having integrated into the story better and I can odyssey for hours Black flag: this was the new era of ac after Desmond and it was the first to have a protagonist skirt around the assassin but did most of their work for them even though he messed there hold in the West Indies up it had great ship combat even though the cities were smaller they did well showing colonial architecture and the story being very character driven with great side characters and love Bartholomew Robert even though I’m iffy on sages in general Syndicate: oh this bias it was my first ac but syndicate is mechanically unity if it was stable I like the tone of syndicate it making good on a bad situation like brits always do as well as the aloofness of Jacob mainly the story though his perspective and he is a very skill assassin so he doesn’t have to worry much it also has a simple story of breaking Starrick control over London taking out his lieutenants by finding who they are because they lead an industry starrick controls and Evie is looking for a piece of Eden against Lucy Thorne it just a good time that plays well for me I will say this assassins creed hasn’t got better or worst it is just different some you’re gonna like some you’re not but don’t bash other people for liking what they like

The tower defense game isn't really used outside of tge tutorial. It only happens if you don't assign master assassins to a section and not get max notoriety.

agreed on your ranking, btw i would love to see a game with the setting graphics and parkour of unity with a different and better story

I think that assassin‘s Creed two assassin’s Creed brotherhood and black flag were the absolute best ones out of the whole entire assassin’s Creed! Reason being is because they had the best storylines and when you played it, you actually felt like you were playing the character. The problem with the new games is it feels like I’m playing an arcade instead of the character. There’s no counter attacks and it takes a decade just to take somebody out! And when they did that, the game felt less realistic!

Great video thanks for doing it,as much as i wanted black flag to be #1 i cant disagree about the tailing missions plus i was terrible at them!.

I still play on a PS4PRO and I find Odyssey to run the smoothest!

Although personally my favorite is still syndicate, but I also haven't played it in a long time but I had so much fun with that game.

my favourites AC: origins odyssey black flag and everyone else

The thing is with odyssey even tho the story is not that long either the dlcs and side quests I’ve got well over 100hrs

I'm planning on getting most of these or well the old ones since I played Odyssey a lot and just beaten Valhalla I suppose, I haven't killed Aelfred yet but the whole prophecy story and wedding is done so I'm guessing I beat it. Anyway as I was saying I'm planning on trying out the old ones since I started on ac 3 and that was back when it first came out so I missed out. Idk if I should get them on pc though or keep them on ps5 I mean I'm playing ac4 now and it looks ok other than the weird brightness and insane motion blur but I started immediately after Valhalla so that could be it. I can't wait to play Mirage now because the whole ending with Valhalla is very confusing.

ac black flag had some fun multiplayer

Assassins Creed 3 is honestly my favorite 😂🫠

Man, I guess I've never disagreed more than I do with your take about AC Rogue 😂😂😂 but hey, to each their own. Good video

It's assassins creed 2 at number 1 for me, although I haven't played all the assassins creed games. I think the often overlooked aspect of the game is it was only the second in the series and such a massive improvement on the flawed first game.

Does anyone wanna help me get the multiplayer lab technician trophy on AC4? The player base is dead so I can’t find a game. I’m stuck at 99% trophy completion. Or does anyone know where I can find help?

Great list. Biggest positive is the placing of Rogue at the very bottom, as it should be. A bit disappointed that my favorite game of the franchise, Valhalla, is placed so low. But great job anyway. I've played every AC game at their release ever since the very first game, but I still love the RPG games a lot. Not everyone who loved the first games hates the new ones.

Odyssey is my favorite but valhalla graphic combat should have been used in it.

I am glad you didn't put Valhalla and Odyssey at the bottom of this list and I think they are both really underrated. Like you I love vikings and if Valhalla was not an AC game, then it could have been one of the best Viking games of all time, same with Odyssey if it was not an AC game also and both of them should of been based more in mythology and not another Assassin's Creed game.

Played them all, valhalla is my fav, i was hooked from start to finish, alot of the others felt grindy

Mirage looks gorgeous but the dialogue and voice lines alone make it sound like a highscool play

I have the ezio collection (ac 2, brotherhood and revelations) and out of those my personal favorite is ac 2

I really keep trying to play and like black flag but I just don’t care about the setting or characters

19:35 if u paid closed attention to the story, its clear that Arno even tho suffering from the lost of his dad, knows that are greater and more important battles to figth then killing a pathethic "king wannabe"

Nice vid

So, Rogue is just better Black Flag? 10 hours sounds great to me. I don't want to spend my whole life playing a game.

mirage is the only one of the new ones that feels like a stealth game

Might be a little controversial, but I think AC Syndicate is the most fun. I enjoy the hand to hand combat more than the stealth assassinations so it’s fun for me.

Rogue // very good arguments. I’d beg to differ on the story being awful though. I think it has some insanely good moments throughout the story. But I get your point, it did a really poor job on switching to a Templar view which also is my biggest complaint for Rogue. It was also a bit too short sadly, I didn’t feel it was that rushed however. Apart from the Templar/Assassin aspect which you said very well. The overall story could’ve been bigger tho imo. AC1 // 100% agreed with your opinion. AC1 gave us this amazing franchise, but even looking through my good old nostalgia goggles I notice the flaws a lot now. I am praying for an AC1 remake, which would hopefully take most of its issues away, but the tedious mission design sadly is unable to be fixed. Mirage // Didn’t watch because I have yet to finish it Syndicate // Valid arguments. On one hand, I really liked Jacob, on another, he didn’t feel like an Assassin to me, as he wasn’t taking it serious at all. Imo they should’ve made him responsible for his actions, like how Arno was kicked from the brotherhood and Altaïr who lost everything when he failed the mission due to poor behavior. Valhalla // Can’t say much about this one, you mainly covered my opinion for this game. I agree its combat is actually very enjoyable, probably my second favorite behind AC3’s. Odyssey // I actually think Odyssey’s stealth is pretty good. It’s terribly oversimplified but it works really well actually. I must admit I had an insane stealth build though. However, the game really should’ve allowed instant assassinations. Revelations // Valid points you make. This game really had its moments but it was too damn short for sure. Still those moments really made me fall in love with this game. AC3 // I believe something popped up in my mind while watching the video but I really can’t remember what. Valid arguments. Unity // Definitely agreed with the Shay point. It really makes no sense that he never tracked him down. I personally have always hoped that Ubisoft would ever make another Assassin’s Creed game in which we have to kill Shay (even though I really liked Shay a lot lol) which could also justify the reason that Arno never did. Maybe ever… Origins // 100% agreed. Abubakar Salim IS the game. He made it the game the best experience ever no doubt. Same as you, only thing that is keeping me from giving it a 10 is the leveling scale. I wasn’t too bothered by it, but I agree that it doesn’t really make much sense. AC2 // I guess almost everyone can agree that this game was so good lol. Valid points given, don’t have much to say about this one. Black Flag // Sadly this game wasn’t for me. Still, you make some really valid points. Only thing I disagree with is the combat, it felt like a dumbed down version of AC3’s to me. What made AC3 truly shine was the double counter kills, which were heavily reduced in Black Flag sadly. Brotherhood // As usual, really good points. I would argue the combat improved a LOT from AC2 but I really agree with the rest Conclusions // overall really solid ranking mate! Mine is entirely different but I understand and agree with the points you made. Considering it’s 1am I didn’t add my own arguments regarding the AC games, just dove deeper into the ones you presented but maybe another time. Still, the arguments you have given are really strong and make sense imo. I do not agree but it is a valid ranking.

I love Origins. Really enjoyed the RPG aspects - it motivated me to explore and fight, as if the amazing world and revenge story weren’t enough. Bayek was great as you mentioned. For me it’s the best. But yes the Ezio games were great too. I just think the modern feel of origins puts it over the top as the other ones as a little more dated. Back in the day AC2/BH was amazing though. I wouldn’t complain if they did a remake one day lol great video

Personally I'd have AC 3 lower on the list. It was quite a disippointment after the ezio trilogy. Odyssey is the one I'd raise much higher. Enjoyed it quite a bit!

My first assasins creed was a very old one. And i hate it. After maybe 10 years or more .. i bought Odessey and holy fk. I played 70h in 1 Week and love every second. Today i bought Origins and after that i will play Vahalla. I will only play these big RPG style of games. Are are insane

Syndicate I always forget about that game. Never played

I’ve only played one - Odyssey. Still making my way through it actually. Im really enjoying it but that type of RPG is my thing. I came to Odyssey on the back of finishing The Ghost of Tsushima which was a remarkable game. Odyssey feels similar, although not quite as flash. Saying that, once Ive completed it I can’t see me checking out any of the others. This feels like a one and done game for me.

For me it’s the first ever assassins creed game that came out. Being a kid and hearing there’s a game like this being released got everyone excited. You wouldn’t understand.

I mostly agree but I have seemed to really enjoy Mirage and that’s probably because the reason I started playing assasins creed was for a good stealth game. And I like the teleport feature.

honestly the reason odyssey is probably my second favorite game is because of the insane combat and the overpowered abilities and the fact you CAN FIGHT IN WHOLE WARS IS FREAKIN AMAZING and valhalla has to be my number 1 favorite because the reason its norse is because: it was focused for combat like why else did they allow you to go "OFF WITH THEIR HEADS" during finishers and i also love the weapons since the axe can be really fun but in my opinion great swords are much cooler due to the carolingian sword literally making u trip enemies making them idle in the air and slowly fall [ not really slow ] and then u SLICE OFF THEIR HEAD MIDAIR LIKE WHAT DA HAIL and the game is honestly huge which is the best thing the bigger the game the greater the experience but number 3 is pretty much origins and i know you will hate for putting it at 3 but it is just not as big as valhalla or odyssey but it becomes waaaaaaaaay better with the curse of the pharaohs DLC but the main storyline isn't too big but i really appreciate the fact they based it in my country egypt and didn't forget the pyramids or sinai or the name of the ancient egyptian gods but the game is probably one of the first assassin creed games i ever played

U can replay missions in AC2, u go in DNA and there u have the sequences

Okay I appreciate the one spoiler warning but why the heck didn’t you put a spoiler warning before saying Lucy was a Templar. I just started playing brotherhood for the first time and now I’m super disappointed that such a big plot point is spoiled for me now

I just started Origins yesterday, and so far, I love everything about it: the graphics are stunning, I really like Bayek, I find the story super interesting and the combats are pretty cool. Only thing I don't love are the voice acting.

My Ranking 1. AC 4 Black Flag 2. AC Origins 3. AC 2 4. AC Brotherhood 5. AC Revelations 6. AC Unity 7. AC Odyssey 8. AC Valhalla 9. AC 3 10. AC Mirage 11. AC Rogue 12. AC 1 13. AC Syndicate

AC3 Footage of the towns has been used in some museum aswell

I have a question, what is better? Syndicate or black flag

while i would agree that the story of mirage was quite weak, it was the first assassins creed game in awhile that i thoroughly enjoyed with and had a ton of fun with, something i hadn't experienced to the same degree since origins. There were moments of odyssey and valhalla that felt so dull, and five hours of odyssey felt like years as compared to the campaign of mirage flying by. It felt like assassins creed again, and the combat fulfilled the purpose it was meant to fulfill; motivation to use stealth and be an assassin. while simple, it was could still be quite satisfying, and you never had to use combat if you didn't have to. It felt like Ubisoft Bordeaux understood what we wanted, made the best of the situation, and output a product that sufficiently satisfied a group of fans that was crying out for an experience like this. I could keep going on like this, but overall i'm just very excited to see what ubisoft bordeaux might do in the future.

I would like to know what is considered the best length of a game? Some people would complain about a game for being too short, while others would complain about it being too long. So where's the middle ground? I personally love when a game is long with a lot of content. I feel like you get more bang for your buck in that aspect.

Ranking the vision damage: No.1: Black Flag, all white. No.2.: AC2, white flash.

do you think i should play black flag or brotherhood i have only played odyssey?

Bayek is in my top 3 favorite characters of any game.

Mirage not being the last one when it's a buggy mess with shitty story and repeatable missions is truly marvelous

Yes, the “formula” is different fr the new RPG AC games, but so many people are gatekeeping the “good ol’ days”. should the games had not been NAMED assassin’s creed, theyd get so much less backlash.

Odyssey and Black flag are my favourites by far!

Hopefully, when BF gets remastered, they will dial the follow missions back. Capcom did well with taking things out of the RE remakes that players hated so Ubisoft could if they wanted, and the game does deserve it. If they refined and remastered BF it could be a master piece and really elevate it among others games like RDR2 but they won't. They could, but they won't. Sad really with what it could be now. Looking at you S&B.

Haha you started with my 2 most favorite but I still agree

I think odyssey is one of my favorites behind black flag and brotherhood

I'm gana be honest with you I clicked the video the second you said "I don't think there are eny bad ac games"