The carcano is way too good, I’ve never not had it one shot and it’s great even when hip firing at so many ranges, I used it for weeks and it costed me 10 CENTS to clean it for the first time since getting it, it’s perfect

Duel weilding the semi-auto pistol (c-93) is the equivalent of bringing an Uzi to the old west. Using headshots i wiped out what seemed like 20 (it was probably 12) armed men within 30 seconds without reloading. I couldn't live without it after that.

ofc the sawed off shotgun is great, it's what o'charles uses for his sidearm

Don’t underestimate the varmint rifle, I did the whole Saint Denis shootout and the one with Sheriff Gray where you massacre the Lemoyne Raiders all with the varmint rifle

I no joke used my cattlemen revolver from the start of the game up to right now, after I’ve beaten the epilogue, because I just love using it

I think the Cattleman has the quickest fanning. Just like real life, a semi auto gun is the gun you want to use in any setting, even for hip fire, but the one thing the revolver has over the semi auto pistols is that it has simple parts so you can manually slap it as fast as you want (Though it's less accurate hence the slapping the guns hammer instead of just pulling the trigger).

I feel like you should have paid more attention to accuracy especially with the revolvers. For example the double action has really bad accuracy unless you're staying still, also I noticed the cattleman and scotchfield are kinda the same it's just the scotch has better accuracy and the cattle is faster.

Such a good video Duke. Red Dead is still crazy in terms of content 5 years later.

I dual wield Schofield Revolvers and a pump shotgun on my back and Lancaster repeater on shoulder

cattleman, with a short barrel has a higher rpm when you fan it than dual wielding double action. The double action has a heavy trigger, and the cattleman has a hair trigger

Thanks just got rdr2 and I’ve been fishing through your vids since they’re in depth so this helps a lot!

Algernon's revolver, High roller revolver, Flaco's revolver, Granger's revolver, John's revolver, Otis Miller's schofield revolver, Calloway's Schofield revolver and the Rare Golden Double Action revolver which looks a lot like Otis Miller's Schofield revolver.

Love American venom in the background

Yo duke I’ve been enjoying these series keep it up! Ur a great KZfaqr

The varmint rifle is actually insanely good because it has pinpoint accuracy and damage doesnt matter because everything one hits anyway if you get headshots its my favorite rifle in the game now

I prefer using m1899. Cause it's beatiful, really fast on shooting and recharging, also, i like hitting on the head, so the precision is really good.

Volcanic pistol with high volicity ammo is definitely underrated. I know that in real life the gun was ass and technically by the games year its an anachronistic weapon but bro is it satisfying hearing that reloading click noise follow by that kickback/ vibration feeling from the controller while the kill cam perfectly captures arthur accuracy/ precision with the gun while the intense music play in the back ground. It truly makes you feel like a badd-ass with every place shot!!!

I watched these when they came out this is so good to see them again

I almost exclusively use the semi-auto pistol and I’ve never had any issues with it. I’m a little biased because I think it looks cool and I prefer the smooth fire rate and reload of it when compared to other sidearms. Though, in my experience, the guns in this game are pretty well balanced and fill their respective roles perfectly. Each gun will work perfectly for whatever you use it for and so long as it suits your play style. Well done reviews!

Love your content man

I just recently went through the raid on Shady Bell from the O'Driscolls and the only "long arm" and pistols that spawned on me was the Varmint Rifle and the cattle mans....they were all upgraded and i was mowing down the O'driscolls with ease. With head shots and just using dead eye for a few seconds to get good shots. Both are actually really good for combat.

Ironically the Mauser used by Brontë in the mission “Revenge Is A Dish Best Served Cold” and some irl trivia I think it was used by H!tler

Love your vids mr, keep up the good work ;)

Awesome video, also i would loke to say you sound a lot like the youtuber HighBoi. Ngl i almost thought yall was the same person

I Love my sawn off shotty it's probably the side arm I use the most and takes great screen shots of Arthur/John using them I love that pump action & double barrel shotties as well as for the others cattleman and lemat are my fav revolvers till I get the mauser pistol it's just a beautiful weapon glad to see the bolt action get love it's usually my main long gun it's not easy going for the high honor when I got all these toys haha I got that ending twice that's good enough it's more fun making noise and creating chaos with these cannons.

ty man i love your videos

You thought you could get rid of me? Outfit name: The man with no name Stalker hat: dirty brown Everyday shirt: baby blue Huntsman vest Everyday pants: black Quickdraw boots: tan ( the 2nd option) Western rider spurs: light brown Weapon equipment: Horseman gunbelt, arthur's holsters Modification:Roll down sleves, pants over boots, ooen collar You can also use john nekerchif but the outfit looks better with arthur. No coats, bandoliers or gloves

I used to use Schofield but now I’m using cattlemans again, they suit Arthur so well, and they are helping me get the most of the game without John

@12:06 - Regarding the Volcanic, think of it the other way around -- the Henry and Winchesters are Volcanic Pistols, in Rifle form. The Volcanic was developed by the OG Smith, and Wesson dudes. The "Volcanic Rocket-Ball" ammunition was... terrible. Firing at a velocity not much more than a good Paintball gun today. However, the *lever repeater design* was worth keeping around, and was upscaled to rifle ammunition. First in the form of the Henry rifle, and later the Winchester - the "gun the won the west." Anyway, there's some history on the Volcanic. (I could blather on about ALL these Red Dead guns for hours.)

22:00 but its my favorite rifle to use in combat because of its fast fire rate lack of recoil, high range, and low sound.

My personal favorites are Cattleman revolver, Sawn off shotgun, and Lancaster repeater. My lancaster has blue and bronze steel to fit my Arthur outfit with blue everyday shirt and buckskin king vest.

Varmint rifle is really good for run and gun hipfire from my own personal experience Plus, since it's so accurate, it's really easy to hit that one tap headshot Easily my first pick for a combat weapon

Thanks bro

What I find unbelievable is that in real life, the Revolver Schofiel reloads at half the speed of the Colt Single Actiin Army, which is the reason for having the top break with automatic ejection of cartridges and in the game the CSAA is faster, these two Revolvers 45 caliber should have the power of a rifle, even Colt started to manufacture the 44 Winchester, to be compatible with carbines, so a single ammunition could be used in the rifle and revolver, it was supposed to kill with one shot, the only realistic revolver is the Colt Double Action, which, being 38 caliber, was not efficient in neutralizing enemies in combat

My favourite revolver is LeMat, bc it has 9 bullets and a additional 1 shotgun bullet. Its basically for a good last stand if you go out of ammo for your rifles.

The second I got enough money in online I got two Schofields and use them over my navy revolver (the serial killer thing I got for free) and they are amazing

Always thought that the mauser should have a legendary called a Wauser it could do less damage and would get dirtier because it's a knock off

The Carcano is based on the 1891 M91 Carcano rifle, not the 1938 one.

Whyem DLC, RDO and Smokes Combo it's what you're visible using as mods, besides the rampage trainer. Great video reviewing the weapons. very pleasant to watch and my stats are not far from the ones you got - just one thing we "don't agree": the 1899 is less underpowered than the semiauto and it seems like a machine guns being shot, imo faster and more reliable than the semiauto. Handguns, I surely agree with you, Schofield and Navy are the best, but I would had the LeMat - although unrealistic, very few were produced and had a lot of issues, at least first versions - just like the "springfield", in some ways, is overpowered and the reloading system works well for a rifle but not for a hand handled well single handed. Shotguns, don't like them, their just spammable weapons, but I would go with the most spammable of them all, the semiauto. Rifles, the 22 varmint can really kill a ped with just one shot, but it's good for rabbits and nothing else. I found the Springfield pretty dope, but the trap door makes it very slow, nonetheless It's a great backup sniper rifle when one shot is enough and the gun is pretty high powered. Carcano is my favourite as it is superior to the bolt action (both are bolt action, but well...) mainly when you can use with and without scope option view with one mounted on the top (don't use glitches where you would lose the scope, but mods that allow you to use iron sights or the scope as of your preference). also those long range scopes are crazy, only beaten by the firepower of the rolling block rifle, but as the springfield is too damn slow. Repeaters I only use the lancaster for historical reasons, the Lietchfield as the most powerful of the repeaters and meh, sometimes, the evans repeater just for the fun. I'm not a great fan of bows, even with the wide array of them with smoaks mod mainly. Pro: when you really need, for immersion sake, to be really stealthy. Kudos for the melee review,. It was a "bonus" I wasn't waiting for and very nice to watch your narrative. I only use express or high velocity on my guns (one of each in the handguns if I'm duel wielding) due to more firepower and for better ranged shots; explosive ammo to some crazy legendary animals, as we all no the pelt will never be damaged. Great video. Will see what more your channel have. 👍

Always ran a sawed off in my primary holster and a Mauser/Navy Revolver in my secondary simply because the Mauser in the primary holster looks like it dosent fit and you only really have the barrel stuffed in there

My loadout in both Online and story is 2 Cattleman (maxed out), A pump action shotgun (maxed out) and a maxed out Lancaster, they work perfectly for me, feels very cowboy

Mauser pistol is my favorite sidearm ❤️

My usual in-game loadout is: Primary sidearm: lemat Off-hand sidearm: Schofield or Mauser Shoulder: Lancaster or carcano Back: semi-auto shotgun

Leeeeeeeezzz gooooo please now start a gtav weapon review series im begging 🙏

i love the cattleman solely because of the R.W.A.O (realistic weapon audio overhaul) mod, it tickles my brain in a good way lmao

For gun nerds like me the "Semi-auto shotgun" is the Browning auto-5 and a mistake DukeMeiser made is that he said it uses a gas system, that is incorrect as it uses long recoil for its self-loading mechanism and Ian McCollum did a good video explaining how it works at Forgotten Weapons. Edit: He cleared that mistake but he didn't specify that it uses long recoil. Another edit: With the word Jørgensen in Krag-Jørgensen the initial two letters are pronounced similar to "yo" and not pronounced with a English J, another mistake is that he said internal clip instead of magazine.

4 videos in a minute for christmas, i cant relate because i hate my fans🙅‍♂️

Sawed off shotgun tip for people undeserving of life like Micah shoot two bullets activate deadeye before you reload then shoot other two it’s basically 4 bullets probably works with other guns but sawed off shotguns it works best

Fun fact i got ultimate edition when it was discounted so much that its price was lower than standard rdr2 lol

I actually dropped $25 for twin navy’s and the customization to make them look more like dragoons in online

Removing the scope on a carcano makes it one of the best possible weapons. 6 rounds high damage and a fast reload. The only downside is you lose aim assist on console which you can use dead eye or just git gud.

All the comments, and nobody mentioned the LeMat 😔 I love the LeMat. It’s my favorite! I run the LeMat on my hip and the Volcanic Pistol as a backup. Then if I use the Bow to stealth all my missions, and the Evans Repeater for any survival missions. I only play freeaim, and the LeMat is the best fanning pistol. The Volcanic pistol is the best horseback weapon when being chased because of the damage and range it has. Makes me feel more like a true cowboy when I only rely on my gun belt. Ohh, and the LeMat’s shotgun comes in clutch during missions.

I only use the cattleman revolver because it’s pretty

13:01 The volcanic was so weak that when the creator tried to kill himself with it, he couldn't do it. He tried, several times.

Not sure if anybody else noticed myself but he did miss the high rollers Revolver

One thing about the hammer is that it does not have the same animations as the hatchet in online. It must have been the mod you used because in online, it is blunt and swift with the attacks

Guys you should look up captain balrick's arsenal if you want to see some weapons data and numbers on a spreadsheet

i absolutely love bolt action so the bolt action rifle was basically my only long range weapon

Schofields 🔛🔝🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥

Me who uses a mod that makes all the guns into flintlock guns

Do you have all the holsters or none of the holsters? It only seems fair if you have one of those, as it changes the time it takes for these guns to get dirty. Also, long barrels make a draw from holster slower. That's why with each variant I have one with a short barrel and one with a long barrel.

The only thing that makes me not use the Scofield is that the way it breaks in half to reload and something about the gun just dosent look right to me also praise luna she is god

little fun fact: the small game arrows are just arrows with a (rifle?) round on it.

You should break down peoples outfits next

39:18 I’m a legend XD

Nahhhhhjhh 1 second in the vid and he called us goooofy 0:00

The only guns you have to consider is the Schofield, the like m19 something pistol (I forgor the name) the Lancaster repeater, bolt action or rolling back rifle, and the pump or semi shotgun. All the other guns kinda suck.

You make me want to buy weapons in red dead 2

Best youtuber

Buddy forgot Half the revolvers in the game

What about Jim calloways gun

killed a legendary bear in online mode with dynamite it ruined the pelt

A moment of silence for all the honor he lost making this video

I havent tried getting the m1899 yet but is there a requirement before buying it or no?

What mod do you use that has some of the extra customization on firearms? Like the shell holder on the double barrel, the wrapping around the sawed off, and some others.

W video

I mean this is all humor and no offense. It always makes me laugh when people who know absolutely nothing about firearms talk about firearms. Great video though! Loved it. Just read up on terminology of the parts of the guns, as well as how calibers work.

You forgot the lasso man....

After so long, you've finished 😢

Don't know if you've ever been told this, but you remind me of mittensquad. R.I.P

Which weapons are most effective for fatal shots?

11:53 I thought the real heroes were the teachers

mauser and navy for me agree duke sir?

Yeah

Are you going the review rdr1 exclusive weapons

Say what you want about cattleman revolvers, but I will never turn down a dual wield with my good and evil pieces

What mod do you use to get all the guns in singleplayer?

schofield 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

Hey Mr.duke im new to rdr2 im in chapter 2 and im asking (NO SPOILERS) when can u buy the mauser and the bolt action rifle i know i have midnights pistol but i want to Custimize The pistol .

The size of the video when you adapted the shorts into a full video is quite terrible, but great video

the thumbnail is.... interesting......

I don’t wanna be that guy but surely they could’ve expanded the landscape gameplay to full screen rather than it taking up like 20% of the screen

You didnt mention the pirate sword ⚔️🗡️

Is copper a modded metal foe funs or???

saying double action is bad just lets me know you aim for center mass, like the game gives you deadeye bro you can hit those far range headshots with it 😂 also the varmint rifle op cause it resets super quick after each shot so you can hit the headshot fairly easily compared to any other weapon in the game (not counting shotgun) + you can move and shoot it and it stays pretty accurate

am i the only one who doesn't have the m1899, i literally cant get it, its not in the saint denis gun shop at all i have seen it one time, also cant get the lemat, is it because its not updated???

Duke is good at gun

Wait isn’t the volcanic revolver a revolver?

I HATE the double action