IDOLS that are criticized for being TOO SKINNY (Is it justified?) Web Page: notsosuperficial.com Mail: notsosuperficial@gmail.com ============================ #kpop #notsosuperficial
Пікірлер: 104
@MrsThursJay2 жыл бұрын
Sunmi was always going to be hated for her body because she is apple shaped and gains most of her weight in her midsection. If she would gain weight in her hips and thighs instead, fans would have been praising her weight gain and telling her how much healthier she looks. But because it is not in the "desired" areas, she received a crazy amount of hate. Society has never been kind to women who are not hourglass or pear shaped, and she is just another example of that.
@Nicolesid12 жыл бұрын
So true. Chaeyeon from Dia is the same. She loses 1 too many lbs and netizens lose their mind saying she is too thin, gains a lb and she is not the right proportions. Being in the public eye is such a hard and often thankless job.
@binitakhatowal16922 жыл бұрын
Why people like hourglass but not pear shape?
@lea53082 жыл бұрын
@@binitakhatowal1692 those are the body types society prefers, what people tend to dislike are Apple, rectangle and oval body shapes.
@binitakhatowal16922 жыл бұрын
@@lea5308 why ? What's wrong with those body types 🙂?
@lea53082 жыл бұрын
@@binitakhatowal1692 absolutely nothing. Many people think they’re “ugly” cause they don’t have the desired proportions (small waist, wide hips, big chest etc.).
@evieb81872 жыл бұрын
Yuna honestly hasn’t changed much, and with young idols it’s normal that their body may change weather they gain or lose so the way she’s maintained her weight lessens my worry.
@mimid.2272 жыл бұрын
Ikr, Yuna's figure hasn't changed much since debut in my opinion
@hellooo211 Жыл бұрын
Yea I think Yuna is fine but Wony honestly I’ve seen photos of the back of her neck from the after like era and her spine is sticking out and also her rib too
@JiaPia32 жыл бұрын
I just don’t think we have the right to comment on other people’s bodies in the first place. Just like how fat people get upset when they are recommended a diet, skinny girls should not be recommended a cheeseburger. People have said I’m anorexic (including my parents) all my life when I eat like a normal person. Just because I’m thin doesn’t mean I’m unhealthy.
@VideosForYou902 жыл бұрын
Ironic how only a few months ago kpop stans were obsessed with Yuna's figure and kept praising and calling it body goals. Now a few unflattering pictures during dancing later and everyone acts like she's the sickest person in the world wtf. When nothing changed at all, her body doesn't even look like that when she stands up straight and normally. Stop talking about other people's bodies, stop assuming things you can't surely know, it's none of your business! Believe it or not, there are people who actually struggle with gaining or maintaining their weight, just like there are people who struggle with losing it. It's sick what kind of entitlement kpop stans have to constantly judge an idol's body and act like they know everything about their actual health. Just listen to their music and support them if you love them but don't cross the line & stop acting like you are allowed to control them, their body, life choices or whatever.
@a.n.d.r.e.w22 жыл бұрын
You dropped this👑
@Babiemelo2 жыл бұрын
Yuna has even stated herself she doesn’t restrict herself from eating her favourite foods and actually eats a lot she just had a fast metabolism 🤷🏻♀️
@eb.37642 жыл бұрын
we never see what happens behind the scenes. What is she doing when the cameras are off? Is she vomiting? Is she skipping meals?
@Babiemelo2 жыл бұрын
@@eb.3764 All we can do is trust her Jesus y’all are so quick to judge
@Blackpill149 Жыл бұрын
Yeah.Idols will say any BS and we are supposed to believe it.Great
@FanfictionWoes Жыл бұрын
Yes because the KPOP industry doesn’t make their idols lie.
@MrsThursJay2 жыл бұрын
There's definitely a lot of factors that go into it, but the weight itself is not the concern, it's all about the context. For example, a very rapid weight loss, especially if the idol was bigger (by idol standard, e.g. an average weight) can be worrisome. If the idol was very publicly fatshamed, expressed being unhappy with their body, or the company having a history of starving idols, it's a concern. If the idol is less energetic on stage or in interviews, it's a also a concern. On the other hand, an idol that is still very energetic is probably in good health.
@chuuu46102 жыл бұрын
I feel like some people are rather selective about the idols they defend “aren’t too skinny” when I looked at what happened to Wendy back in Red Flavour era. Her pictures looked just like the recent issue pictures where ribs show in certain poses, but instead of showing concern or talking about how posing impacts it, people called her a skeleton and complained that she made them uncomfortable.
@boombayuna5362 жыл бұрын
can people finally leave yuna alone? there have been way too many videos about her lately, she doesn't even post anymore at the moment because it probably got to her. using pictures where someone bends back and with harsh lightning is extremely manipulative. it depends on your bone structure and how big your rib cage is whether it shows or not while you're moving - and not on your weight only. yuna always has been skinny and her rib cage has been showing since debut while performing. i would be concerned about idols who acually lost quite amount of weight - and not about the idols who always looked skinny + never ever lose energy like yuna, rosé or lisa for example. not every skinny person is automatically unhealthy, i get the concern in this industry but labeling someone whose diet and life you don't know personally is unnecessary and disrespectful. and you're not helping anyone but probably making them feel insecure about their own body type.
@saltyriz77342 жыл бұрын
Ikr people always want to talk about idols bodies its weird
@yourjuliet80132 жыл бұрын
YES
@Nicolesid12 жыл бұрын
For Gdragon, keeping his muscles means CONSTANT working out and if it's not natural for him CONSTANT special dieting. So his look change, could be due to him not following those specific workouts and diet. Those photos are just showing what he looks like naturally. For all of the idols, the TV camera adds weight where photo don't add as much. This means, on TV they may look one way, while in person or in photos will look different. Additionally, we are not THEIR doctors and have no real insight into their lives outside what they want to show. Lastly, netizens needs to start taking on the 5 minute rule. If a change takes more than 5 minutes to "correct" or change it's not your place to comment on it, especially with anyone you are not around 24/7.
@TheBilayer2 жыл бұрын
Stress cause weigh loss/gain
@dgds242 жыл бұрын
At the end of the day everyone has different body types and we should respect it.
@haileymitchell81652 жыл бұрын
I suffered from anorexia and bulimia for years to the point of hospitalization. I’ve always been Underweight and I honestly still don’t have a great relationship with food but I’m trying. I’m still in therapy for it and still have to go to a gastroenterologist for my stomach problems it caused and dietitian for checkups. I just think we definitely need to talk about the diet culture and body image that Kpop promotes on the regular. Because it’s not good for the idols. But we also got to face it that most Kpop fans would rather their favs to be too skinny rather than them be too fat. A lot of Kpop fans are fat-phobic without even realizing it. A big reason I still find it so hard for me to want to gain weight is I know everyday people would rather me to more skinny than fat. And we all know how Kpop stand would act on Twitter if someone like Wonyoung one day got on screen and didn’t have a thigh gasp. They would start calling her fat. It’s something we all need to talk about but it’s hard too.
@k1pepeo2 жыл бұрын
i absolutely love your commentary, hope you continue to make more.
@lily-wg9zv2 жыл бұрын
The way I can relate to them because people that don't know me call me anorexic and say i need to eat an hamburger and stuff like that, the people that really knows me don't say stuff like that because they see how much I eat
@angelichobi__182 жыл бұрын
There’s a huge difference between idols who are a healthy skinny/naturally skinny and those who are alarmingly skinny. What really infuriates me the most is that Knets will never be satisfied with how an idol looks especially with female idols, forcing them to fit the old fashioned beauty standards when beauty is more so how the person expresses it and shows it through their fashion, makeup, personality, or confidence. It’s the 21st century, it’s not the 1400s, it’s not the early 1900s anymore, yes it’s okay to be concerned about an idols weight but DO NOT constantly shove it in their face that they’re too “skinny” or too “fat”, and don’t believe pictures from articles that clearly look edited, how an idol decides to show off their natural beauty be it, curves, monolids, thicker thighs, more circular face, shouldn’t be such a huge issue now days, it’s THEIR body and THEIR life. It’s not your choice how they should look. Sorry for the slight rant, this topic really pisses me off especially when it comes to the thicker idols, I myself have rather thick thighs, face, and stomach so it makes me incredibly insecure about my body because people point it out so much. When seeing netizens and companies criticizing idols because they gained 2lbs makes me really angry, your career shouldn’t rely on how skinny or pretty you are, what should matter are your talents. But sadly in an industry where everything relies on beauty more than talent, an idol’s real talent is overshadowed because of their looks.
@neleshabroderick26742 жыл бұрын
*WTF ,since when have fans/people forgot that K-Pop Idols are just as much Human as we are, not everyone can gain weight that's just the way it is, of course it depends on the situation but come on Enough is Enough!!!!!
@nut6572 жыл бұрын
I hope companies understand that idol's health is more important than a good looking body
@mckinleykingbird64422 жыл бұрын
If you don’t follow itzy at all you’ll know that Yuna said she’s okay and for midzy not to worry, so if you’re still stressing about this you’re just not a midzy
@woosyy2 жыл бұрын
just bc someone says they're okay doesn't mean they are lmao
@peachxtaehyung2 жыл бұрын
True she's always looked the same way!!!
@peachxtaehyung2 жыл бұрын
@@woosyy what they're saying is that this is nothing new for Yuna to look like this. She looks no different than she ever has so I don't get why everyone is having a fit over it when there was never concern for her before. Yuna has always eaten very well and she still does.
@woosyy2 жыл бұрын
@@peachxtaehyung i agree that she's probably not unhealthy, i just don't think it's an argument bc people can lie.
@mckinleykingbird64422 жыл бұрын
@@woosyy I don’t think Yuna would lie
@lily-wg9zv2 жыл бұрын
About Yuna and wonyoung they have always looked very skinny from debut
@meguaanaa48652 жыл бұрын
yuna, yes. wonyoung was skinny when she was in iz*one but not as skinny as she is now.
@lily-wg9zv2 жыл бұрын
@@meguaanaa4865 wonyoung was still very skinny back then and got criticized since the start, her weight difference isn't big
@meguaanaa48652 жыл бұрын
@@lily-wg9zv i'd disagree, i implore you to look at the pictures again because the weight difference is very obvious. im not trying to imply that wonyoung has an eating disorder of any kind, all im saying is that the weight difference is imminent and i really dont see how people are in denial of this
@lily-wg9zv2 жыл бұрын
@@meguaanaa4865 I've been watching her since produce 48 the weight difference isn't big at all
@Rosieposie032 жыл бұрын
@@lily-wg9zv I disagree there's a big difference compare her legs when she was a member of iz*one and now.
@rvsluck26062 жыл бұрын
Rather than criticizing the idols, people should criticize the industry that promotes these types of bodies as the standard. Even those who are underweight get shamed for not being skinny enough.
@musaxcoco2833 Жыл бұрын
There is definitely no damn way that you can tell me wonyoung is "healthy". I’m not a food/diet expert but i know that shes a underweight for her hight of 170+. Yujin is the same height as her but do you see the difference in body type? She's definitely severely underweight. (A insider from there company had leaked that wonyoung only eats 1 cucumber a day that’s so dangerous and unhealthy) There's no way she's having her period. This is so sad. She needs help, quick.(sorry to all the people that think I’m skinny shaming, I’m not, I’m just concerned for her health)
@andinkify2 жыл бұрын
it could be that these idols are naturally very thin, but also loose weight because of overwork and/or stress
@angel127_ Жыл бұрын
this is what i believe is true. ofc if someone who is naturally super skinny loses weight it might look concerning to people. we can’t do anything ab it
@Ryhuga56982 жыл бұрын
Blackpink Queens🖤💖👑👑👑👑
@alysiusgabrielmosquito67792 жыл бұрын
Yoona and Sooyoung has always been skinny even before debut, they are the most eater in the group labeled as the shikshin of the group, they have no diets (all snsd members) they've already said it before that due to their schedules they can't do any exercises nor diet but they always eat on their sets, no it's not concerning people have different body types and people should chill. These idol mentioned are healthy the only unhealthy about them is their mental health, they've struggling with people shits that made them look like that let people live their own lives
@jihosz2 жыл бұрын
My idol said they saw a real unicorn in their backyard. If my idol said it then it means it's true 😁😛🤪😜😽👻
@pandachimxchim41972 жыл бұрын
People need to not judge or say “eat well” like it’s not gonna help the idol even if they do have a eating disorder! Lots of people who have EDs said it really is gonna just help them want to lose weight more! So please please don’t……..just…. Talk about it you can just support and give love! Like “we love you :)” please just please don’t judge or even talk much about it if they have an eating disorder!
@nekocat80832 жыл бұрын
If you're naturally skinny, it's fine, but when alll female idols starts concentrating on being as skinny as possible, that will become scary. Cuz common people will start copying it and hence "trend" skinny trend is kinda coming back too.
@lavienrosewon88112 жыл бұрын
Wonyoung is overworked and lost easy weight with pilate exercice than she love done much adding she revelead than she take vitamin for stay energic with her busy schedules. Ive members said wonyoung is optimist and love eat much Wonyoung get much pressure from company with her life as ambassadors of brands and highschool girl. She is natural slim person since izone.
@NoctLightCloud2 жыл бұрын
can you really lose weight at that stage from Pilates alone? cause it's rather difficult to go from low weight to even lower weight without actually starving/reducing your meal intake. By exercice alone, you can't reall become that skinny due to how human bodies work.
@Aphrodites_son5552 жыл бұрын
@@NoctLightCloud she’s a very busy girl now some people lose a lot of weight under stress
@3rdelement102 жыл бұрын
@@NoctLightCloud We're talking about the same girl who always encourages her fans to never skip a meal. Stop talking about how skinny she is, worry about yourself. She's doing fine and she, herself, knows this.
@jihosz2 жыл бұрын
@@Aphrodites_son555 The only way people can lose weight is by cutting or/and burning calories . there's NO WAY ANYONE EVER becomes dangerously underweight by eating normally and doing pilates. a lot of people have busy schedules, some even more than her, are they that underweight? doubt.
@jihosz2 жыл бұрын
@@3rdelement10 My idol said they saw a real unicorn in their backyard. If my idol said it then it means it's true 😁😛🤪😜😽👻
@souptown84902 жыл бұрын
The fact that many (especially) female idols are underweight is concerning for me. But that is what's expected from them. This is not just a thing in Korea. The cast of the show 'friends' is an example, too. The women were all underweight while being on the show and the actress who played Phoebe later revealed it was the weight, that was expected from them, while the male cast members had weight changes over the course of the show without any consequences. The thing is people who say being skinny has something to do with being healthy are hypocrites. Being that skinny is the beauty standard, it doesn't matter if it comes naturally to an idol or not. So I think it's pretty obvious that many of them lose weight in an unhealthy way because it has to be fast and effective. The important thing for me is, to know, that this isn't a normal standard, a normal weight for normal people out there. But since many Kpop fans are young or teenage girls, I sometimes think it is a bit concerning. I absolutely don't think the idols are at any fault, it's the constant pressure from their company and the public that often gives them the feeling that they have to be skinny, no matter what it takes. But considering that many idols themselves are teenagers, I think it's really sad and it can have a bad influence on their overall health, especially later on. Of course, that doesn't mean any idol out there is underweight or has a concerning diet. And of course, for some, it's just the body they have because of their constant training and schedule and their natural metabolism or just eating healthy. It is just a common thing, which means there are more than just a few idols out there who had to go through unhealthy diets or have to keep a weight that is in the very low spectrum.
@profscarlett2 жыл бұрын
Yuna is extremely skinny. You can count her ribs.
@user-zj5lx5yf7h2 жыл бұрын
Rose is my bias She is our queen
@delixcious2 жыл бұрын
my problem with wonyoung is not that she is skinny but that she is said to have such great proportions and is praised for being so skinny. if she really has a fast metabolism and things like that or even if she just likes to be skinny, its her choice. yes she should be healthy but in the end people have to decide on their own…however she is an idol with a role model function and portraying this really unhealthy looking body type as body goals is so toxic. i felt finally kpop became more open to different body types, seeing that girl from twice (sorry idk her name) and one in nmixx or something…there are idols with bigger bodies and they seem to be accepted which i find refreshing as it makes the viewers develop a better feeling towards their body since they‘re shown that not only skinny is a beauty standard but also other body shapes and sizes are considered beautiful. idols like wonyoung and especially koreans pointing out her „great proportions“ is a huge step back imo…i don‘t say shes not beautiful, just please don‘t make her the beauty standard because her body is not average…
@gigi9623 Жыл бұрын
Your comment is extremely ignorant. So is Wonyoung just supposed to never show her body? Wonyoung has no control over what the public says about her. People choose to comment on her body but she has never actively encouraged or endorsed her body type. People’s reaction to her body is not her responsibility. Calling her body an “unhealthy body” is extremely rude because you don’t know the status of her health. Who are you to make assumptions about her diet and lifestyle? Please leave Wonyoung and her body alone. You by calling Wonyoung’s body “unhealthy and toxic” is toxic in itself. Skinny bodies, fat bodies, and all bodies are beautiful. Let’s stop shaming people for what they look like.
@angel127_ Жыл бұрын
@@gigi9623 yeah i’d rather criticise the people calling her body goals than criticise her body itself. we dunno wat she’s going through anyway
@Blank_xX2 жыл бұрын
Honestly , people are hypocrites in yuna's case. As someone who has a prominent rib cage bones like her they just show like that when I move or bend even though I am at a perfectly healthy weight, in our case to hide these bones we will have to gain a whole lot of weight, an amount of weight that if she gain they will be targeting her for being too fat. Female bodies are the easy target and you can't win with them. For me she seems like in a good weight and her rib cage showing is just how her bone structure is.
@katr_i_na2 жыл бұрын
Yuna's obviously underweight - likely severely underweight. Definitely not a healthy weight for her height though, since 97% of female idols are underweight. So, she's definitely not a good weight.
@Tarikkb2 жыл бұрын
G dragon does look concerning tho , even his facial features look too big for his face
@kelv57542 жыл бұрын
personally I think Yuna is rather FN
@kmalulan12 жыл бұрын
who else got rosé’s tiffany & co. ad on this video
@klopkerna35622 жыл бұрын
It looks like beboss TV video
@FanfictionWoes Жыл бұрын
The super skinny body trend of the 2000s is coming back, and KPOP is definitely influencing that. Not good for impressionable children/teens
@kpopsushi48232 жыл бұрын
Yuna is ok she said that she ate a whole pizza those photos was Photoshopped👇
@AL-pi4du2 жыл бұрын
I think it may be wise to change the thumbnail and add a trigger warning for ED sufferers/those in recovery. The images in this may encourage unhealthy idealisation and can cause viewers to engage in unhealthy weight loss behaviours.
@Dina-zb2cv2 жыл бұрын
It's for catching the attention of the viewer to instantly click the video you know...
@lea53082 жыл бұрын
@@Dina-zb2cv it’s still not okay
@Dina-zb2cv2 жыл бұрын
@@lea5308 well welcome to KZfaq 🤷♀️
@skillbopster Жыл бұрын
Trigger warning? Grow up!
@m.a28492 жыл бұрын
well, as far as i know rose always ate well so i think is genetic
@greentea-dg7ht2 жыл бұрын
When i was 10s-20s i was 170cm and 47kg. But i ate all the long.
@kimirish9532 жыл бұрын
Early this time
@saltyriz77342 жыл бұрын
Who are y'all to talk about peoples weight...
@sofia.a12 жыл бұрын
I’m Latina and I’m a skinny person since always and when I turned 17/18 I started losing baby fat so now I look even skinnier (plus I’m flat chested) so I had to deal with people calling me anorexic, to eat more, you don’t look Latina, ugly, no one will want you cause it’s not attractive, etc. Eventually, I tried so hard to gain weight but my body is just naturally like this so I realized I will just stay healthy and don’t worry about stupid comments when I know that I’m totally healthy (tbh I still feel insecure). Anyways, sometimes we can’t know what eating disorders other people may have only by their looks so I think the best thing we could do is appreciative different body types and asking the companies to watch all the idols health, not only one just because they look “skinny” or “fat” cause they might be so stressed over this.
@viktoria8189 Жыл бұрын
What I am trying to unerstand....they are really underweight, but their faces are kinda full. Is this the effect of the injections or what?
@mbc2642 жыл бұрын
A lot of the girls, like Wonyoung, she's growing. She's not 18 yet. Women don't fill out until mid 20's.
@fgjy3093 Жыл бұрын
It's their life and fans should know their place not to blame their insecurities on idols lol
@monikarozalianam15992 жыл бұрын
Non siete mai contenti dei vostri idol,dovete trovare il pelo nell'uovo,ridicoli.Gli idol alti,hanno un corpo,se di natura sono magri,in certe posizioni si vedono le osa. L'unico è Gdragon,e veramente magro,e il taglio dei capelli non gli stanno bene,troppo magro,troppo
@bangpink27712 жыл бұрын
First
@shiningstarmultistan54892 жыл бұрын
4th
@edxxeno23682 жыл бұрын
Let’s be real they’re just starving to death
@y.a.44642 жыл бұрын
no way in hell does anyone call rosé too skinny lol. completely normal size 5:37 her large head is probably why her body might appear smaller to some people
@lea53082 жыл бұрын
Rosé? Completely normal size? Are you joking? She is a 25 year old woman, stands at a height of 169 cm and weighs around 41 kg, that’s the weight of a 12 year old. She currently has a bmi of 14.36, which is severe underweight and usually causes health problems, such as organ failure. She’s also lost weight ever since that pic was taken.
@SladkiyStream2 жыл бұрын
Wonyoung trying so hard to gain attention and fit in beauty standarts so she went to the point where even safety short are too big