Insurgency, ambush, fresh violence, ‘self-rule’ ultimatum: dangers in forgetting Manipur crisis

  Рет қаралды 52,821

ThePrint

ThePrint

8 ай бұрын

#CutTheClutter #manipurvoilance
Over six months after Manipur first erupted in ethnic violence, the conflict has far from disappeared. In Ep 1348 of Cut The Clutter, Editor-in-Chief Shekhar Gupta rounds up some of the latest developments from the state to explain why the situation there remains a grievous threat to India’s national security.
#PaulJohnVisitorCentre
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our KZfaq Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8

Пікірлер: 392
@ThePrintIndia
@ThePrintIndia 8 ай бұрын
Exclusive content, privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
@kangleisintha7554
@kangleisintha7554 8 ай бұрын
1What kuki demand in the first place for against ST is now chnage to 6 schedule, separate administration,union territory and now state.... 2 Kuki started by forcing out meitei from kuki dominated area like CCPUR,morey and kangpokpi..... 3 now they are claiming people are seperated and separation is completed and now they asked for separate administration...what a plan sirji...long time plan of kuki for more than 30 yrs....your preplan is already exposed 4 why no others tribal community didn't back your demand even saying is for tribal..total 35 tribal community in whole manipur 5 why kuki people are so active in social media...from may 3 itself....even the propaganda was spread even from middle east and some others country....is they already paid the media and other youtube influencer, fb,twitter influencer.. 6 why kuki dont want NRC at the first place....all the 33 community of Manipur accepted but kuki dont want NRC 7 why they are using militant and myanmari pdf lunggi clad terrorist..to accived their demands....if you want to demand than demand in a proper channel as india is a democratic country's...why killing innocent meitei people like you do in myanmar... 8 the longer your kuki drama the more the clearer people will understand the root cause and your tactics....only Karan thappar of wire and east mojo is left 😅😅 9 why you people are angry when home minister Amit shah change DGP doungel and for that you people even compromised the integrity of army by exposing the name of the meitei army officer who posted in Manipur..
@user-qi7vy7yk8v
@user-qi7vy7yk8v 8 ай бұрын
It’s good you have made an effort to bring it back to the attention of people but you are not helping anyone by passing comments like Metei people are fully armed and better armed! Ask the kukis coming from Myanmar how well armed they are. As long as the centre and the media keep ignoring the reality of what’s happening in Myanmar and the destabilising effects it’s having on Manipur, nothing will change. Trying to keep up with tribal appeasement is not going to help in bringing peace.
@tapemaj
@tapemaj 8 ай бұрын
What is equally baffling is the stony silence of the central government about Manipur . For some reason NSA Ajit Doval seems suddenly missing from action and out of sight . Forthcoming winter session of parliament after state elections could possibly witness more rowdy scenes and walkouts thus keeping Manipur away from the radar . Extremely scary scenario with China lurking in the shadows.
@rayhqq9635
@rayhqq9635 8 ай бұрын
Media and Twitter made Ajit Doval as some super cop or super spy or something. whereas in reality he is a Buffon and spokesperson of chaddi gang.. he ran away many times
@ligithanghal4042
@ligithanghal4042 8 ай бұрын
4 people were not going to imphal airport they were going to kangpokpi to give information that the eloped women is with them base on oir tradition but they happen to lost their way and runs into a meitei dominated area and the rest goes on as described by sekhar
@peace_manipur
@peace_manipur 8 ай бұрын
2 meitei Teens who had gone into kangpokpi district on a bike, a kuki dominated district, have gone missing since the past week and their phones were dropped in a plastic bag in senapati district. Judging from past experiences, they have most likely been tortured and killed. Something shekhar Gupta missed to point out. It had happened just days before 4 people went missing.
@Lonesome1997
@Lonesome1997 8 ай бұрын
Ajit doval need to hide as well because they are the one who make proxy militants also know as Kuki militants by the indian government and train by Assam rifle now this militant is strong and not afraid of the india government 😅😂
@johnmathew379
@johnmathew379 8 ай бұрын
​@@Lonesome1997true
@tejesheconomics4072
@tejesheconomics4072 8 ай бұрын
I don’t know why Modi is not imposing President rule and take complete administrative control over Manipur for the time being
@Corgi_Manu
@Corgi_Manu 8 ай бұрын
Because our President is just a mascot for BJP.
@rajx7120
@rajx7120 8 ай бұрын
Because the majority population i.e. Meitei are actually very angry with BJP. They are even stopping Indian Army from entering.
@pratham3507
@pratham3507 8 ай бұрын
Because he wants to come back as the Supreme leader of India and thus doesn't want to lose votes for such petty issues...
@tamobiswas6083
@tamobiswas6083 8 ай бұрын
​@@rajx7120they are not angry with bjp. If that was the case, biren Singh would have long gone. But if govt puts president rule then they surely would become anti government and thus anti india.
@anasmanalath
@anasmanalath 8 ай бұрын
That will showcase the failure of double engine sarkar which Modi never agrees even if people die.
@shashamnk2525
@shashamnk2525 8 ай бұрын
I pray for Manipur everyday, it is the most important state of India in my opinion because it's people are one of the most hard working and talented, it breaks my heart to see the state of Manipur in turmoil, the govt has failed the people of Manipur.
@shashamnk2525
@shashamnk2525 8 ай бұрын
@@AmalTan if you have any decency then you will show your appreciation for the people of Manipur, I never said that people from other states are not hardworking or talented, Manipur being one of the smallest states of India with little to no Industry has managed to produce great sports women and men, the football team , the hockey team, from boxing to weightlifting, they have produced world class athletes , while many other Indian states have not, this is because of their talent and hardwork, the least we can do is pray for the people of Manipur and if you have any decency then expose the incompetence of government there.
@BenjaminRosh
@BenjaminRosh 8 ай бұрын
What you want the government to do? shooting on civilian mobs fighting each other?
@shashamnk2525
@shashamnk2525 8 ай бұрын
@@AmalTan No it's not, don't try to malign a whole society for being open, the problem is not what you're trying to portray here and put an end to this toxicity.
@Daraxxi898
@Daraxxi898 8 ай бұрын
​@@AmalTanare you saying hinduism is the problem as meitei follow hinduism and Naga and kuki are Christian? Think properly before typing 😡😡😡
@rajx7120
@rajx7120 8 ай бұрын
​@@Daraxxi898The same logic can be used for saying Christianity is the problem. Reservations, land restrictions and illegal migration, are the problems. When 53% of the population is allowed to live on just 9%, and others who have whole of the state, but keep coming into the valley, and bring relatives from Myanmar, then that is unfair to Meiteis. The Meiteis were a princely state, that joined the Indian Union. And what do they get? Losing control of their own land. Meitei anger is justified.
@BharatThatIsIndia
@BharatThatIsIndia 8 ай бұрын
I will ask Amit Shah to request Modi ji to call someone in Manipur so that this could stop. If he can stop war in Ukraine, I think he should be able to do that jn his own country. By the way, as per my info, Modi ji did not even go to Mizoram for Election Rally too. So brave PM and what a leader we have.
@AmalTan
@AmalTan 8 ай бұрын
Yes Modi and BJP can be blamed for not able to bring situation under control. But is there any solution when both groups don't want to compromise? Go beyond schadenfreude!
@karansingh70151
@karansingh70151 8 ай бұрын
Feku credit lene aur photo op plus train ribbon katne aajata he, but when it comes to our state he is maun Modi.
@BharatThatIsIndia
@BharatThatIsIndia 8 ай бұрын
@@AmalTan 😂😂😂 That's the Job of government or any controlling authority. That is der basic duty. Thats why political parties exist. That's the main job of a politician. Matlab Chamchagirii ke liye kuchh v bol dena hai. limit hoti hai kisi cheej ki.
@AmalTan
@AmalTan 8 ай бұрын
@@BharatThatIsIndia Men incharge are responsible for good and bad, it is their fate. But sometime there is so no solution to certain problems. Only time will heal things. And haters have a field day! So enjoy!
@Maimom7
@Maimom7 8 ай бұрын
I too followed Manipur crisis since May 3. You aptly summed up my observations in just 22 minutes. But I want to add that sentiment of the Meiteis are spurred up by the narratives of Meitei Leepun & Arambai Tenggol, organisations which are sponsored by CM Biren & Rajya Sabha MP Leisemba Sanajaoba. Had the two organisations not been there, the crisis in Manipur would have been over within the month of May itself. CM Biren is the elephant in the room for peace in Manipur. Now, that the divide between the two communities is too deep, I don't know if peaceful coexistence would ever be possible in Manipur again. I am afraid the Nagas will soon scaled up their demand for Nagalim. If this happens, say by the 1st half of next year, peace will be the rarest commodity in Manipur for the remaining half or a century.
@shokugekichef3019
@shokugekichef3019 8 ай бұрын
Don't blatantly twist the facts to blame the Meiteis. The SoO kuki militants have collaborated with myanmarese CDF and PDF and narco terror groups to cause upheaval in the state of Manipur holding peace and normalcy as hostage for their demand of separate administration for a new autonomous golden triangle. There has been arrest of CDF and PDF militants in Manipur following police crackdown after the deadly sniper ambush attack on DSP/SDPO at Moreh by Kuki Militants. Arms been looted both in the hills and the valley but when there is an active par legalised terrorist SoO Kuki militants committing atrocities and incessant attacks to civilians the Meiteis have the right to self defense. Though veiled , it is a well known fact by now that SoO pact with the Kuki Militants have been weaponized to fuel the crisis which left the 70k police companies and army personnel powerless and as mere mute spectators to the Kuki Militants' violence. There should no longer be any delay in the abrogation of SoO pact and conducting surgical strike. Had this crisis ever occured in China, they would have extinguish the situation on May 3rd itself.
@yengkartangva
@yengkartangva 8 ай бұрын
agreed
@davidyum
@davidyum 7 ай бұрын
you are someone who would blame hamas for being there in gaza. try learning the facts and comment
@jaganms62
@jaganms62 8 ай бұрын
My subscription to The Print is worth every Penny. Keep up the good work!
@ThePrintIndia
@ThePrintIndia 8 ай бұрын
That is very kind of you, Jagan. Thank you so much for appreciating and supporting our journalism...best wishes, Shekhar
@karandharni6299
@karandharni6299 8 ай бұрын
Thank you for doing this episode and picking up this topic Shekhar. More power to you!
@awadheshkalia
@awadheshkalia 8 ай бұрын
Dear SG, Thank you for bringing spotlight on Manipur. What you have called an opinionated episode of CTC, I see it as an attempt to conscience keeping for the nation. One hopes the govt and the opposition are stirred into some action to bring normalcy to Manipur as also begin disarming the local population.
@shyambajekal8084
@shyambajekal8084 8 ай бұрын
The opposition instead of stridently and loudly 'cursing' the government on this issue should seriously engage it and work in a genuine and sincere manner. If one constantly just shouts at the other it shows that you are actually not sincere about the issue, therefore you only end up antagonising it which then plays tricks on you like last time. Engage seriously please.
@ThePrintIndia
@ThePrintIndia 8 ай бұрын
Thank you, Awadhesh. I am glad to know that you enjoyed this episode. Thank you for your support...best wishes, Shekhar
@user-nz2ql9zj3g
@user-nz2ql9zj3g 8 ай бұрын
Manipur episode is a classic case of how inefficient central government is in tackling national security issues. Central govt. has failed miserably in Manipur under MoSha leaderships.
@rishabhsinghal6120
@rishabhsinghal6120 8 ай бұрын
Now we understand that much of the Manipur voilance has been due to Instability in the region, typically in Myanmar. China had a big hand in increasing the conflict. The opposition had been a total failure in understanding the situation and tried to make it an communal issue. The government had been slow to understand the situation and should have acted stricter. The center should now be more careful in dealing with external factors like China and Myanmar in the picture.
@shyambajekal8084
@shyambajekal8084 8 ай бұрын
Absolutely right you are, Sir. This is exactly the situation. And the opposition, instead of shouting themselves hoarse should have sincerely engaged with the government and in fact helped it in the country's interest. After all they have much more experience handling this issue in the past!!
@sujithkumar2041
@sujithkumar2041 8 ай бұрын
Let us blame China and left liberals 😂
@rishabhsinghal6120
@rishabhsinghal6120 8 ай бұрын
@@shyambajekal8084 well only if you call bad experience as experience...
@nimbusroy3468
@nimbusroy3468 8 ай бұрын
Thanking you for your concern for my State of Manipur
@wayenbamsunil5036
@wayenbamsunil5036 8 ай бұрын
this is very much of a one sided story...thanks for bringing it on this platform but the narratives could be improved in many ways....no one wants violence and taken arms but the situation here is something else....life comes first...we cannot compromise our lives with the failure in governance and security .....if you guys have any concern with what is happening in Manipur please go and check how it started....please stop criticising one particular group
@somdutta7322
@somdutta7322 8 ай бұрын
Shekhar ji, stop blaming liberals for not talking about Manipur. The only people who talked about Manipur are the liberals. The Government and it’s stooge main-stream media is quite since day one. Like everything, Modi and Shah has failed here too. 😢
@shreyassharma3194
@shreyassharma3194 8 ай бұрын
Are he is not blaming.......this is a reminder for those who claim to be liberal that there's a situation that needs more attention than is being given to it. Ofc Political parties are busy in State Elections but The Newsrooms and truly independent columnists must have a regular highlight about Manipur. Once it becomes popular narrative by media.......Politics will take care of itself.......Lekin Janta jaagruk ho....Voter jaagruk ho......Vo kaam toh unhi se kahenge na jo kar sakte hain.......Liberals will atleast act when they'll trhink objectively......unlike Zee News Conspiracy Theories about George Soros and China being the reason for something happening in a state of INDIA
@rishabhsinghal6120
@rishabhsinghal6120 8 ай бұрын
Liberals are only noise, no action. What have they actually done to help the government in tackling the situation? Did any liberal gang actual did anything apart from inciting more voilance? The problem with liberals is that they see every such issue as an opportunity for political vendetta. You should be equally, if not less ashamed of yourselves.
@shyambajekal8084
@shyambajekal8084 8 ай бұрын
Wonder what the actual problem there is. I heard that it's basically an issue with migrants (from Myanmar) and drugs. We Indians have always believed in 'Atithi Devo Bhavo' and allow all and sundry to take refuge in our country and these very same people then create problems.
@sujithkumar2041
@sujithkumar2041 8 ай бұрын
Hahaha.. He couldn’t even take the name of Modi and co. But he was sure who to blame after beating around the bush all along.
@s_solo
@s_solo 8 ай бұрын
Well said Sir!....Thank you for your continuing coverage of our often forgotten Northeast...
@user-jl7xx2mu1b
@user-jl7xx2mu1b 8 ай бұрын
Shekhar ji you have the heart of a lion, bravo and hats off to you, our country is blessed to have a son of the soil like you.
@shauryaO1
@shauryaO1 8 ай бұрын
Internal security issues have been India's achilles heel since time immemorial & seems to have exacerbated even under a "percieved" strongmen government. All that machoism can work against unarmed student leaders , political opponents , environmental activists & likes but not when it comes to a critically important crisis like these? It's not just the government of the day, It is the people of the country that have also failed Manipur. Imagine the uproar if this level of violence precipitated closer to home, say Delhi. People have stopped holding government accountable & provide intellectual defense to the state. What's worse? Common man is colluding with the government to silence, troll, maim it's critics & political opponents in ways unlikely seen & it's manifestation is that anarchy in a state has reached levels not seen since Independence yet the stoney silence & obliviousness in the masses to this grave threat to a part of the country is in itself an example of why the idea of India is incomplete in our hearts and minds . Ambedkar once argued that Hero worshipping is one of the worst habits of the people of India (Subcontinent,I'd say) & it is almost catastrophic when it comes to politics. If the government had any spine & shame left then they would have imposed President's rule by now but power politics seems to have taken precedence over people & that is the lesson I derive from this whole fiasco. For politicians nothing matters but power & the idea of India is just to drive their own agenda nothing to do with it's people.
@himanshu54365
@himanshu54365 8 ай бұрын
Thank you shekhar sir for speaking about Manipur I feel disheartened to see total lack of empathy and disinterest of my fellow countryman for the suffering of one of our own state. I hope peace will get restored in Manipur soon.
@Sunil13593
@Sunil13593 8 ай бұрын
The situation of Manipur is worst than Gaza still no one is talking about it.
@thehumancondition111
@thehumancondition111 8 ай бұрын
Thank you for the episode, and sharing your opinion, sir.
@_M_D_M_
@_M_D_M_ 8 ай бұрын
On one side we have Acche Din. On the other side we have Mandal. What a beautiful political setup we have in India.
@sujithkumar2041
@sujithkumar2041 8 ай бұрын
Only difference is ache din wallahs rule the country for that last 9 years.
@255438101
@255438101 8 ай бұрын
Congratulations on the award. I hope I see the print going strong for years to come. Keep up the good work.
@LeoDas688
@LeoDas688 8 ай бұрын
Andbhakts who call Nehru incompetent for no reason is silent about bjp government's inability to take action in Manipur
@manjulashanmugasundaram706
@manjulashanmugasundaram706 8 ай бұрын
Congratulations to Ananya and ThePrint.
@AnilYadav-nt9mf
@AnilYadav-nt9mf 8 ай бұрын
I am a bit amazed at Shekhar's rant against left liberal side, when they were most vocal for several months into Manipur crisis. He didn't say a word against PM who took 4 months to put even a tweet. Interestingly he took only a few hours to tweet on Israel issue. That's probably more ironic situation. Yes everyone is tragically forgetting about Manipur but one shall not forget who has more responsibilities on the matter i e. Government and who kept quite and shied away from taking the most obvious decisions.
@sunil2548
@sunil2548 8 ай бұрын
waah Shekhar ji…. you said opposition/liberals did not raise manipur issue enough…but you did not say that our PM who do tweets in favour of Israil never says anything on manipur…you did not talk about failure of bjp govt in center n state to stop the violence…and then you say your journalism is unbiased and fair !! Great !
@chanahyingchan5070
@chanahyingchan5070 8 ай бұрын
Just give Manipur the Independence it deserve. The Indian Government cannot be trusted
@soumajitmukherjee6291
@soumajitmukherjee6291 8 ай бұрын
Who the hell are you 😂
@Savi3_1
@Savi3_1 8 ай бұрын
Moirangthem Thamba of KYKL had ambusged and executed 21 Jawans of 6 DOGRA in 2015. He was released from Army captivity by Meera Paibi and a BJP MLA
@Corgi_Manu
@Corgi_Manu 8 ай бұрын
That’s what the tribals mean when they keep saying the government is biased.
@Daraxxi898
@Daraxxi898 8 ай бұрын
Recently SDPO Anand was shot dead by kuki ex army man in moreh, killing of state force by retired army is abit too much
@Savi3_1
@Savi3_1 8 ай бұрын
@@Daraxxi898 I don't know how mind processes such things. This is is how I am biased. Retired army man's wife was paraded naked. I have no pony in this race but as a woman I always take sides against the rapists. So I'm biased for the Kuki position.
@Daraxxi898
@Daraxxi898 8 ай бұрын
@@Savi3_1 its up to you nobody ask u to take meitei sides,just letting you know that both sides are suffering and people of Manipur needs peace
@Savi3_1
@Savi3_1 8 ай бұрын
@@Daraxxi898 I'm just saying I am biased.
@user-jl7xx2mu1b
@user-jl7xx2mu1b 8 ай бұрын
Wow Shekhar ji, hats off to you for this brilliant analysis.
@ayushpathak9474
@ayushpathak9474 8 ай бұрын
Much needed CTC,atleast someone is talking about Manipur...Thanx Print and SG
@jaykumar_khot
@jaykumar_khot 8 ай бұрын
thank you for covering story that most people avoid. I would like for a government representative to explain their side in an interview and let people know, what is it exactly that they are doing? however inadequate or wrong government steps might be, government should inform citizens about their efforts.
@shyambajekal8084
@shyambajekal8084 8 ай бұрын
I agree with you here. The government should actually come out and show everyone the true picture. But it is always busy fighting elections somewhere or the other. But that's politics!
@anuragrajasingh
@anuragrajasingh 8 ай бұрын
You mean a press conference sort of? By this Government? Lol!
@jaykumar_khot
@jaykumar_khot 8 ай бұрын
@@anuragrajasingh government should put a detailed version of its story in front of people. That is always a good idea. Whether you choose to believe or laugh it off is personal choice. But a detailed one on one interview by a minister or senior official on this one particular topic will help in solving the situation. Right now government is letting the problem die in silence. If they answer the question publicly they will have to stick to what they have said
@jonathanfanai827
@jonathanfanai827 8 ай бұрын
Thank you @theprint for being the voice of India's Hinterlands.
@subhasishhalder6045
@subhasishhalder6045 8 ай бұрын
Manipur High court, Personally CM of Manipur and Amit Shah is responsible for this kind of crisis.
@anindyabagchi6119
@anindyabagchi6119 8 ай бұрын
ThePrint is a relatively new, small, and not-so-well-to-do organization. The sheer commitment, persistence, and tenacity of thePrint now specifically towards Manipur and in general to North East India is unbelievable. I feel lucky to be able to support Journalists who have a good head and a lot of heart. In contrast, the Central (and State) Government's action - or rather the lack of it leaves me disgusted even though it has clearly done so much for North East. I am wondering if Mr. Modi has forgotten the lessons on Raj Dharma that Mr. Vajpayee gave him after the Godhra riots.
@ThePrintIndia
@ThePrintIndia 8 ай бұрын
Thank you so much for your words of appreciation and support, Anindya. It means a lot. Do keep watching and writing in...best wishes, Shekhar
@amitabhabhattacharyya658
@amitabhabhattacharyya658 8 ай бұрын
Thank you Sekhar Gupta sir for this episode. Clearly the two weaponised groups are vying for blood of each other. This widespread hatred is so terrible. The people from mountains have no safe passage. It is impossible to imagine how they are bearing with the circumstances. It must be nerve wrecking for the people. There is no answer to this crisis it appears, unless HEAVY ENFORCEMENT is done. But nothing is happening and the atrocities list is ever increasing in Manipur. Unthinkable situation.
@surajgurav
@surajgurav 8 ай бұрын
Congratulations Ananya! Shekhar sir, thank you for keeping us focused on the issues that matter.
@jayeshpathade8320
@jayeshpathade8320 8 ай бұрын
Thank you
@nickycruz8671
@nickycruz8671 8 ай бұрын
This great nation of Bharat needs a central government that respects federalism, diversity, tribals, dalits and minorities.
@anupchaudhari4298
@anupchaudhari4298 8 ай бұрын
Are you forgetting something? Rights of Hindu community also important same as above list. One sided concession not acceptable to hindu anymore. Hindu are getting aware of their rights now
@DeletedAccountForSure
@DeletedAccountForSure 8 ай бұрын
Most of the tribals and almost all Dalits are hindus
@ParminderSingh-ft3cc
@ParminderSingh-ft3cc 8 ай бұрын
@@anupchaudhari4298 Which right of Hindu's have been infringed upon? Come back to senses else this cake will be cut into further pieces.
@hindurashtra63
@hindurashtra63 8 ай бұрын
@@ParminderSingh-ft3cc Hindus are denied these Rights : Right to manage their own Temples Right to Equal and Fair Opportunities at Education and Work Right to Celebrating Hindu Festivals wthout Fear or Attacks or Mockery Right to be proud of Hindu Heroes from Freedfom Struggle like Veer Saavarkar Right to their Former Territories from which they are Ousted or Exiled Right to retain their Demographics Right to recieve benefits from Govt, Just like Minorities Right to stand for Political Positions in regions where they are Minority Right to Truth and Liberation from Fraud Commmie written Garbage History RIght to have their own Cultural Code of Laws like Muslims Right to demand Temples not to be taxed / looted by Government Right to preserving their Culture, History and Civilization Right to Self Defense by carrying weapons like Sikhs Right to Preach, Convert and spread their Faith in all Regions of India Right to Live in Dignity without being shamed for Religious Social Evils of Past Right to get Subsidiary from Govt for Hindu Pilgrimage, Just like Haj Fundin Right to demand Societal changes based on Collective Opinion Right to propse enacting of Laws which favour preservation of Hindu Lifestyle Right to Ban Food or Cultural Habits that are not Indian and are of Foreign origin Right to Humanitarian assistane by Govt where they are suffering Right to recognition of Genocide against them by other Communities in Past Right to Propose Common Language that unites us across the Nation - Hindi Right to be recognized as Oldest Natives of this Homeland we call Bhaarat
@gabbar51ngh
@gabbar51ngh 8 ай бұрын
Central government already does. All these conflicts are result of that only. Giving special rights to minorities and specific communities, then wonder why other people feel they're being discriminated.
@balrajseth6310
@balrajseth6310 8 ай бұрын
I was expecting, you would close the episode with a set of possible solutions
@mayukhbagchi5629
@mayukhbagchi5629 8 ай бұрын
Very good balanced coverage, Shekhar Ji! Congrats to Ananya as well ...! Keep it Up ✅
@shravansodesetti
@shravansodesetti 8 ай бұрын
Congratulations Ananyaji and The Print team
@hanumanmalghosal7742
@hanumanmalghosal7742 8 ай бұрын
Sir, what you explained in this episode is the incidences happening in Manipur. Please inform us the reasons of both State and Central authorities inaction on this issue. Also politicians dormancy on this burning issue
@shyambajekal8084
@shyambajekal8084 8 ай бұрын
Exactly. The other media might be quiet but atleast _you_ can find out the _real_ causes of this trouble and tell us. Because right now nobody knows the truth, only hearsay which is another reason for the silence on everyone's part. Or maybe it is too sensitive which is why the government also is not telling everything.
@sujithkumar2041
@sujithkumar2041 8 ай бұрын
That’s out of SGs ‘journalistic syllabus’
@subhrangsudhar3757
@subhrangsudhar3757 8 ай бұрын
Aptly said Sir
@Drkp23
@Drkp23 8 ай бұрын
Unfortunately MODI JI and Co including opposition are busy with 5 state elections and completely forgot Manipur…. Modi shah who have reputation for taking tough decisions not doing anything regarding Manipur is very surprising
@gazalmohd
@gazalmohd 8 ай бұрын
True
@tamobiswas6083
@tamobiswas6083 8 ай бұрын
What do you suggest they do without antagonizing any of the 2 groups and not invoking secession.
@tabrezhussaini3241
@tabrezhussaini3241 8 ай бұрын
Very relevant episode of CTC and I hope the government takes notice!! Well done SG sir!!
@naveenkumarv5690
@naveenkumarv5690 8 ай бұрын
You also reminded after a long long time 😅😅
@sarweshwardayal9687
@sarweshwardayal9687 8 ай бұрын
Shekhar Your cut the clutter clips are always reflect your personal opinion. The choice of word, tone, delivery makes your opinion clear. This episode You have spent enough time in NE and you do have knowledge about it. You have right to keep yourself in limelight/ relevant by talking this issue repeatedly. One thing which no one’s including you talks about 1. Why Meitis raised issue for reservation? Did they feel that in today’s popular tic political environment ( classical example RG, Nitish Kumar), they are at disadvantage? 2. Is state Govt responsible for HC decision? 3. Why the state or central Govt should oppose immediately /appeal against this decision. See how whole opposition is acting about OBC, Caste reservation. Once reservation ids given it never ends because of vote bank politics. 3. Who started the first attack in Manipur No one taps about it. 4. Even if this is not separatist movement from India, it takes help from other nation. It is equally dangerous if not less than separatist movement. However I agree that Central Govt has to play important role in making things normal quickly. Ethan’s all parties are busy for 2024 election and the amount of impact Manipur situation can have on it will decide this response. Have a good day
@pardeepshori3355
@pardeepshori3355 8 ай бұрын
TY Shekhar Ji for regrouping on what is the Manipur status.
@user-hu1mf2mk9t
@user-hu1mf2mk9t 8 ай бұрын
Shekhar ji please share your views on recent war in Myanmar. If possible do a CTC on conflict between Junta and Chinese army.
@abhiku4358
@abhiku4358 8 ай бұрын
Don't worry sir it is on top of our mind. No new content was coming on Manipur. Thank you for making this episode.
@Seevawonderloaf
@Seevawonderloaf 8 ай бұрын
Manipur being ignored is a symptom of a greater ignorance of the north east generally. Places outside of the Hindi belt or where the Hindu-Muslim rivalry cannot be stoked, is immediately ignored. I initially heard about how meitis were Hindus and kuki Christians were being killed by them - just a silly communal angle from the west to create divisions that don’t exist like that.
@Godfavourite01
@Godfavourite01 8 ай бұрын
Meiteis are mixed religion.Sanamahism,Hindu (beef Eater Hindu) ,Pangals (Meitei Muslims) & some are Christians. Muslims are not involved in the war , infact they save hundreds of Kukis lives.
@Vijay-ot6bq
@Vijay-ot6bq 8 ай бұрын
Excellent coverage in depth study of current scenario of Manipur crisis. Next time prepare clip on the topic how the state will come out from problem with solutions.
@shreyashdeshmukh1470
@shreyashdeshmukh1470 8 ай бұрын
Several aspects of Manipur issue which no-one daring to question is reservation and religion. 1951 act is quoted and twisted as per will, and the asymmetric population distribution in Manipur
@Corgi_Manu
@Corgi_Manu 8 ай бұрын
In reality, reservation, land issue, none of this will be problem if only state government ensures ONE SIMPLE THING. Meities want to go to kuki hills and buy land, but since their lands are protected by ST, they legally cannot buy land (But ofc, kukis can sell them land if they WANT TO, that has never been issue). So to tackle this apparent lack of land, meiteis demand ST quota. In reality, the main problem is that if even 20-30% of meitei population settle inside kuki hills, then demographics will change, and kuki constituencies will become meitei constituencies. NO SANE DEMOGRAPHIC WILL WANT THIS, whether they are Hindu or Christian or buddhist or any religion or ANY ETHNICITY. So, to fix the issue, the only thing state government has to do is create a protection which will keep kuki constituencies as permanently kuki, despite any demographics change. Do that and nobody will have issue with meitei st demand. SIMPLE solution but no implementation. This is the ACTUAL THING NOBODY IS TALKING ABOUT, not what you have written.
@rajx7120
@rajx7120 8 ай бұрын
​@@Corgi_ManuGood solution. Give rights to Meitei, but protect Kuki. But one problem. Kuki society is expansionist. In their society, except eldest son, others sons of a society are asked to spread out and start new villages, by clearing the land and practicing jhum cultivation. They should stop this behaviour.
@Corgi_Manu
@Corgi_Manu 8 ай бұрын
@@rajx7120 I assure you that’s not in their fundamentals. Even now in the kuki dominated areas of Manipur, there are many tanghkhuls villages that recently popped up, just 5-6 years ago. No kuki has cleared them out or even had an issue. Similarly, kukis never have issue with meiteis forming villages either, everyone is welcome to stay. The main issue arises when other demographics say they have a 'right' to that land. Leme give you example. In Nagaland, kukis are a recognised tribe. they have many villages living amongst Nagas. HOWEVER, they have to pay tax to Nagas once every 5 years, and all had to sign some documents stating that kukis are living here but they dont have RIGHTS to the land as it belongs to Nagas. This same thing can be done in Manipur by the kuki demographics in their areas. But they have not done it. Even if they have to expand, they will choose an empty spot. But problem will arise if another demographic tells them they cannot open village on their own areas.
@woman178
@woman178 8 ай бұрын
Sad part of this story is that this kind of conflicts hampers the development of both the communities and unfortunately lag behind every body should have equal rights in their ansistor homeland with discussion now arms in the civilian hand this issue is related to law of the land hope that both the community of the Manipur will be most developed state with communities coexist peacefully which will be an example for other northeastern states
@shashankmorey4707
@shashankmorey4707 8 ай бұрын
Only " The Print " is talking about Manipur issue frm starting. No other media & people are taking it seriously. We forgot our manipuri people.
@parthoprotimsharma1647
@parthoprotimsharma1647 8 ай бұрын
Thank you SG sir
@saiajay9858
@saiajay9858 8 ай бұрын
At least someone is talking now 😂
@mn1k4114
@mn1k4114 8 ай бұрын
Good move CTC.
@GinzaGeorge
@GinzaGeorge 7 ай бұрын
Thanks for bringing this to us. As you mentioned NE states are quite ignored in mainstream media and imagination.
@Siddharth_Rao
@Siddharth_Rao 8 ай бұрын
Shekhar has hit it out of the park with this episode, very informative, very emotional. This is one reason why The Print stands out in the field of journalism, they follow stories of national interst that the other mainstream media usually forget. One thing I do not understand though is why Shelhar is pleading with the Left "liberal" crowd for this Manipur issue? We all know that Left "liberal" is just another phrase for blatant hypocrisy, a bunch of people who enjoy high life, sipping champagne or a crowd of permanently outraged people who would rather just protest than to get some work done the hard way, holding the country hostage to their utopian fantasy. Perhaps one CTC on why the Left is relevant and how they have achieved what they allegedly stand for, in any country in the world anytime in history.
@shyambajekal8084
@shyambajekal8084 8 ай бұрын
But I hate the way he treats us like school children, repeating words and sentences, beating around the bush (nay, bushes, to be more precise) and finally when he comes to the point it's a damp squib. His National Interest is much better, more coherent and to the point.😊
@ckush928
@ckush928 8 ай бұрын
@@shyambajekal8084 You are watching free "content". Content generates money based on watch time. If you want succint information you have to spend from your pocket.
@anuragrajasingh
@anuragrajasingh 8 ай бұрын
@@shyambajekal8084 Hate is a strong word and even stronger emotion bro. Just stop watching if you feel so strongly about it or start paying upfront and ask him to change.
@ThePrintIndia
@ThePrintIndia 8 ай бұрын
Thank you for the kind words, Siddharth. I'm glad you enjoyed this episode. A CTC on the larger Left relevance and impact could make for a good episode, thank you. Do keep watching...best wishes, Shekhar
@Siddharth_Rao
@Siddharth_Rao 8 ай бұрын
Thank you for replying@@ThePrintIndia
@dangmeipunshi
@dangmeipunshi 8 ай бұрын
Shekherji.. thanks for reminding about Manipur again.. I am from Manipur, I am neither meitei nor Kuki.. I don’t know is it ignorant or deliberate you seem to be biased and guided by Kuki let me explain how.. you narrated the story about meitei passionately but you deliberately didn’t mention how Kuki came to Manipur.. how their numbers increased manifold in few decades.. how they broke off Naga district to curve out Kuki majority area.. you say autonomous administration.. but why would.. meitei concede that to people who were given refuge by meitei just 200 years back.. please refer Sir Johnstone the British military commander during 19th century for reference.. shekherji you say read our comments.. I hope you talk about this sometime soon..
@shyambajekal8084
@shyambajekal8084 8 ай бұрын
Wonderful Sir. You have pointed out the real issue here. This is exactly what I have heard too as the root cause. In addition, it is the lucrative business of drugs.
@msketchart4179
@msketchart4179 8 ай бұрын
I mean, the way this guy, Shekhar Gupta deciphers the situation in Manipur is really crazy in the sense that, ThePrint and he have a massive number of people following, mostly people with rather good cognitive sense; and yet his irresponsible way of speaking highlighting only some things (which are important) but leaving out other crucial points (which are also equally, or even more important) is just-disappointing. I mean, how wouldn't information among the capable thinkers be completely muddled then, right?
@conflictvideo3014
@conflictvideo3014 8 ай бұрын
Bro, this is an update not a history lesson on the Manipur history, chill down.
@sachinsiib
@sachinsiib 8 ай бұрын
Thanks!
@ThePrintIndia
@ThePrintIndia 8 ай бұрын
Dear Sachin, Thank you for contributing to our journalism.
@laishramherojit2984
@laishramherojit2984 8 ай бұрын
PM can reach the venue of cricket world cup in a matter of minutes but not showing interest in ending the violence in Manipur. So this is going to continue.
@vijay15kumar15
@vijay15kumar15 8 ай бұрын
Looking forward to more opinionated videos from you! Great work! ❤
@sujithkumar2041
@sujithkumar2041 8 ай бұрын
End of all this rant, SG told us who’s responsible for failure to stop violence in Manipur- hold your breath - it’s ’left liberals’. That is Indian journalism in a nutshell. Now you know why Modi and dispensation can get away with any thing. Now count yourself how many times he held gvt and its leadership responsible for what’s happening in Manipur.
@alchemist.3
@alchemist.3 8 ай бұрын
The way media made us believe that banging thali and vessels will ward off Corona, similar conviction is required for Manipur and other similar issues.
@alexhangminlian2097
@alexhangminlian2097 8 ай бұрын
Shamelessly looting my aunt blanket 😂
@Rv2023CeO
@Rv2023CeO 8 ай бұрын
Just shows shear incompetence of Modi and BJP leaders😢
@siddhubabaji
@siddhubabaji 8 ай бұрын
A horribly managed situation which is conveniently forgotten,but we all should remember and brand it in our thick heads that if we still keep ignoring this situation then it's not like that it will vanish by itself, rather it will bite back and it will bite back hard,scarring us all pretty badly &:then all the sarkari and non sarkari drama will start when all the good and some not so good people will start shedding fake tears for poor people of Manipur, until then it's all about Israel-HAMAS or whatever the current fashionable issue to be dealt with at the present.
@maxbizpaojel601
@maxbizpaojel601 8 ай бұрын
There is no good or bad terrorists. But we should be more careful with the terrorist whose population are well distributed between the neibouring countries with bangldesh and myanmar. See how they are behaving
@azingo2313
@azingo2313 8 ай бұрын
Rich states in India like Andhra Pradesh or Karnataka police doesn't have rocket launchers 😂😂😂😂
@conflictvideo3014
@conflictvideo3014 8 ай бұрын
Even yesterday an Assam rifles convoy way ambush on patrolling. But you wouldn't hear anything about this because the county don't give a f.
@thor3932
@thor3932 8 ай бұрын
I don't know why prachar jivi is not going to Manipur
@anindaguharoy3165
@anindaguharoy3165 8 ай бұрын
This situation will get attention if a China factor is thrown in.
@conflictvideo3014
@conflictvideo3014 8 ай бұрын
😂😂😂 true just add " China is flaming the violence" and all media will shout at the top of their voice. Whether it's true or not
@pronoydutta614
@pronoydutta614 8 ай бұрын
The leadership in Delhi are a bunch of apathetic and opportunistic racists. It goes a long way in explaining their refusal to address the matter.
@BenjaminRosh
@BenjaminRosh 8 ай бұрын
Bong commie idiot spotted 🤡
@kshmobisingh4531
@kshmobisingh4531 8 ай бұрын
​@@BenjaminRoshand u
@shyambajekal8084
@shyambajekal8084 8 ай бұрын
How can you say they are not addressing the issue? Maybe the real reasons are too sensitive to be made public. There _is_ something called 'National Security,' isn't it? Even the so called most free of countries like the USA also keeps many secrets 'classified' as they call it from the general public!!
@disanKh
@disanKh 8 ай бұрын
You're missing a big point the role of Manipur police, during previous government the Congress government all meitei valley based insurgencies were outs from valley and went to Myanmar. But the problem is both Kuki and Naga insurgencies are still inside the territory of Manipur.
@zgeorgem
@zgeorgem 8 ай бұрын
Yeh abhi bhi chal raha hai? Sorry, we were too busy taking about israel. /S
@fuzzyfaisalgmail
@fuzzyfaisalgmail 8 ай бұрын
About the Gaza-Manipur analogy: It is not the fault of the people of India if we are receiving much more information about what's happening in Gaza than in Manipur. It is this govt's media and social-media blackout of Manipur which is causing the illusion of people's apathy towards Manipur. Slowly but steadily, India will see the rot that these Hindutva fanatics have caused to India. Hopefully, it won't be too late.
@nv9991
@nv9991 8 ай бұрын
Would SG be as soft-sympathetic if Kokani Marathi demanded autonomy and started supporting armed violence and kicking out all non-Kokani from Mumbai and the rest of Konkan? Remember Raj Thakare and his "Marathi language's first" demands and how anti was Delhi's old deep state ecosystem?. Replace Konkani Marathi with Tulu or any other Marathi or Kannada, Gujrath-based Hindu group asserting autonomy, and the Delhi deep state reaction will be predictable. So why does the old deep state Delhi ecosystem have such deep sympathy and tolerance for the autonomy violence by special Indians?
@jeremiahduomai
@jeremiahduomai 8 ай бұрын
Is anyone in New Delhi listening?
@nickycruz8671
@nickycruz8671 8 ай бұрын
BJP has allowed this arming the Meitis. This is very dangerous for the country. Will this happen in other parts of the country.
@mangangpoirei6924
@mangangpoirei6924 8 ай бұрын
Mention recent developments in Myanmar and its implication Mr knowall.
@rushi9154
@rushi9154 8 ай бұрын
Festering wounds are extremely dangerous.
@munchiesimphal
@munchiesimphal 8 ай бұрын
Shekharji, why the arms were looted from the police Armoury? What makes such drastic decision? Anybody we will do the same when the Central paramilitary has different treatment to the valley people. And pls highlight the main threat by the foreign influx plus Narco terrorist
@fuzzyfaisalgmail
@fuzzyfaisalgmail 8 ай бұрын
Manipur is the final nail the in the coffin of the Modi's image as a strongman on national security. Also, Shekhar Gupta is slowly but steadily coming into his own.
@Seevawonderloaf
@Seevawonderloaf 8 ай бұрын
So sad considering kukis were brought to protect the meitis from myanmar. This is what happens when you don’t create a United identity
@sagolsemchamanganlakpa3254
@sagolsemchamanganlakpa3254 8 ай бұрын
One can easily see the way Indian State treated us so far. I would not be surprise if Meitei start calling for total independence from India again. Wonder the where the failures is - the intelligence or the politics.
@tapaskhanda
@tapaskhanda 8 ай бұрын
Your "integrity" is defined by the lack of apathy towards people who are dissatisfied by the current regime and your solution to it is force them to remain in the system. Its like old Indian system of forcing the members of the family to stay within the family. Get real man, world has grown. Please face the reality. Everyone has his right to stay or depart. Each individual has to take a call and face the eventuality
@vickssag88
@vickssag88 8 ай бұрын
I think there is some misinformation regarding killing of some kuki while coming to airport. It is impossible for kuki to come to airport. And moreover kuki consider Imphal international airport as another state's airport they don't come there.
@Godfavourite01
@Godfavourite01 8 ай бұрын
Dumbo!Kukis are all over NOrth eastern states!Assam, Nagaland, Mizoram, Arunachal, Tripura
@mangangpoirei6924
@mangangpoirei6924 8 ай бұрын
As always print kuki media spitting half cooked knowledge.
@Thoughtflux
@Thoughtflux 8 ай бұрын
Gujarat model catapulted Modi's career. This inspires other CMs too.
@puneet1977
@puneet1977 8 ай бұрын
Congratulations on the award to the entire The print team.🎉 well-deserved.
@user-ni2ny5xp5r
@user-ni2ny5xp5r 8 ай бұрын
The award committe had Saleem Yogendra yadav and irfan habib as juries. So that says it all. LOL
@lphaokip5056
@lphaokip5056 7 ай бұрын
In my analysis the recent peace deal with valley base insurgent is the result of work behind the scence.To be accurate prolonging the conflict to the extent of violence spreading to bordering area of Burma driving out militants from their cocoons by Kuki arm group living there n PDF. All these at the expenses of Kuki Zo people in Manipur. Now having achieved its goal of disarming meitei militants, Govt of India should compensate the Kuki Zo by granting them UT with legislation or state.
@bikashlaishram114
@bikashlaishram114 8 ай бұрын
Have u watch video of itlf if not then i will send it to u they openly said that they will formed seperated land from india its clearly mention that
@cinefile0075
@cinefile0075 8 ай бұрын
They can't live each other that's for sure. Make two states than violence.
@mangangpoirei6924
@mangangpoirei6924 8 ай бұрын
Mr half cooked knowledge is dangerous. Also mention the recent development in Myanmar.
@rajendranathanmnair4122
@rajendranathanmnair4122 8 ай бұрын
Manipur is off national media now as Rahul gandhi is busy with election season. So sekharji have to remind Rahul and co about this. This is needed to wean public attention from islamic terror thats gaining traction even in west as refugees have started showing their true colour. Well done Sekharji for this service to islamists who I am sure will be pleased. This in no way diminishes importance of Manipuri issue and I believe the state must be under Central rule immediately as kid gloves wont solve tribal enimity among themselves which is causing this issue whatever their justifications are
@Rags1982
@Rags1982 8 ай бұрын
Congrats Ananya🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
@VarchalUchiha
@VarchalUchiha 8 ай бұрын
Forget what’s being said but I can’t help but laugh at the video clip which shows the looting of Tribal properties by the meitei people especially the mothers who had Steel vessels wich they had looted! Those are the so called Meira paibis of Manipur 😂😂😂
@Corgi_Manu
@Corgi_Manu 8 ай бұрын
Average radicalised meitei behaviour.
@kshmobisingh4531
@kshmobisingh4531 8 ай бұрын
It's vice-versa
@Knk-ph5ds
@Knk-ph5ds 8 ай бұрын
Arms were looted.. as a meitei I say.. the reason.. we can’t fight kukis automatic guns with swords. As a scholar, you know how well armed they are. That’s it.. 🙏🙏🙏
@Godfavourite01
@Godfavourite01 8 ай бұрын
😂😂😂😂😂😂
HAPPY BIRTHDAY @mozabrick 🎉 #cat #funny
00:36
SOFIADELMONSTRO
Рет қаралды 18 МЛН
Опасность фирменной зарядки Apple
00:57
SuperCrastan
Рет қаралды 5 МЛН
This should be a country…But it’s not
16:50
Johnny Harris
Рет қаралды 787 М.
Dictator's Dilemma (Full Episode) | North Korea: Inside the Mind of a Dictator
44:24
Soldier Explains REASON Behind North East Insurgency
10:47
TRS Clips
Рет қаралды 162 М.
HAPPY BIRTHDAY @mozabrick 🎉 #cat #funny
00:36
SOFIADELMONSTRO
Рет қаралды 18 МЛН